THE POWER OF PICTURES 1 THE POWER OF PICTURES: THE ROLE OF PICTUREBOOKS IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF YOUNG LEARNER S By Elaine Weeks A CAPSTONE PROJECT PRESENTED TO THE COLLEGE OF FINE ARTS OF THE UN IVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FO R THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2013
THE POWER OF PICTURES 2 2013 Elaine Weeks
THE POWER OF PICTURES 3 Acknowledgements I would like to take this opportunity to thank my mother for her unconditional love and support throughout my education. She is truly my biggest fan. I would also like to thank my capstone committee, Dr. Craig Roland and Dr. Elizabeth Delacruz for encourag ing me to problem find" not "problem solve ." They inspi red me to examine the most basic needs of my young students and develop a successful way to promote literacy and stimulate creativity in my classroom.
THE POWER OF PICTURES 4 ABSTRACT OF CAPSTONE PROJECT PRESENTED TO THE COLLEGE OF FINE ARTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ART THE ROLE PICTUREBOOKS PLAY IN THE DEVELO P MENT OF THE VERY YOUNG LEARNER By Elaine Weeks December 2013 Chair: Dr. Craig Roland Committee Member: Dr. Elizabeth Delacruz Major: Art Education Abstract This capstone project examines how picture books can support the acquisition of language skills in the very young learner. English language learners are those most at risk if they do not embrace the English language early in their academic career. Using pictures and illustrations can benefit a student's literacy skills and promote reading and encourage creativity. Throughout this project I researched picturebooks that contained high quality illustrative narratives that can be used suc c essfully in the art room and Pre K and Kindergarten classroom. I also investigated numerous websit es promoting the use of picturebooks and art to foster literacy skills I compiled these resources on an online Pinterest board at www.pinterest.com/arteacherta lks/childrens picturebooks worth looking at
THE POWER OF PICTURES 5 Using a collaborative participatory action research approach, I examined how my collaboration with a classroom teacher facilitated our students' meaning making, creativity and visual thinking skills through various activities using picturebooks. The research conducted in this caps tone project included documenting young children interacting with picturebooks in both the art room and classroom, facilitated by their Pre K and K indergarten teacher. I created a n online blog journal, chronicling our picturewalks, discussio ns and art activities with our Pre K and K indergarten students. My blog, C.R.E.A.T.e can be found on my website at www.elaineweeks.weebly.com My capstone paper describes my research process, findings, and recommendations. First I discuss the motivation behind this project, an essential need to be able to communicate with my youngest students, the Pre K and K indergarten student s coming to school for the first time. Then, in my literature review I describe the power behind the picturebooks. As part of this project, I also explored ways to provide young children with opportunities to interact with text and illustrat ions in picturebooks and the development of children's emerging literacy skills as they created their own art and verbalized the meaning behind their own illustrations. My recommendations include using picturebooks, like those referenced on my Pinterest board, to entice young children to read and interact with text. I also recommend incorporating the art and illustrations in picturebooks into the classroom and art room curriculums as an effective tool to stimulate and promote children's creativity. I conclude this capstone paper with final insights on the efficacy of pictur ebooks in the development of young learner s
THE POWER OF PICTURES 6 Table of Contents Title Page .1 UF Copyright P age ..................................... .2 Acknowledgement ...3 UF Formatted Abstract 4 Table of Contents Page .6 Introduction ...8 Statement of the Problem, Rationale, and Goals of the Study . .9 Research Questions .10 Definitions of Terms ... 11 Literature Review 11 History of the Picturebooks ... .13 A Picture is Worth a Thousand Words ...14 Pictures Promote Creativity ... .16 Coming Together in the Classroom ... 1 7 Methodology ... 19 Subjects and Research Site 19 Data Collection Procedures and Instrumentation ... 20 Data Analysis . 21 Limitations .. 22 Findi ngs .. 22 Collaboratio n .. 23 What Do You See? ...................................................................... ............................ ........ 24
THE POWER OF PICTURES 7 Making A Splash! ........................ .......................................................... .........................26 Art In Motion .. 29 Assessment Starts With "A" .. ....31 The Writing Is On the Wall 33 Reflections, Conclusions, and Recommendations ..37 Discussion and Interpretations of Findings . 38 Significance, Implications, and Recommendations 42 Conclusion .. 42 References ... 45 Appendix A .49 Appendix B . 52 List of Figures With Figure Captions .55 Author Biography ... 56
THE POWER OF PICTURES 8 A Picture Is Worth A Thousand Words Each year in mid August I welcome a brand new g roup of Pre K and kindergarten students into the a rt room. The majority of these 3, 4 and 5 year olds are coming to sc hool for the first time. Many are fearful of their new surroundings and distressed because they have been separated from th eir families for the fi r st time. It is di fficult for me, as a mother of three children, to watch the tearful e motions of these little people during the f irst few weeks of school. T he r eal challenge for me as an educator however, is that many of my younge st students remain silent, choosing instead to just observe or they do not sp eak English. Despite any encouragement and support I may convey the limited understanding they can express verbally frustrates both the students and me. I know from experience that with in a few weeks of the beginning of school these little people will acclimate to their new surroun dings and love coming to school and ar t class B ut m y concern is th e linguistic challenges facing many of these young learners may follow them thr oughout their academic career. What if I could bridge this language barrier in the art room in a child friendly way in order to ma ke a personal conn ection with these young learners and help them to embrace their new role as student s ? As I contemplated this dilemma, I thought, how could I reach out to these babies, sidestepping the bigger problem of language for the moment, and connect with them on a more experiential level through simple drawings and illustrations? I knew from personal experience that pictures could transcend the language barrier I faced with my youngest students After all, every artist knows that a picture is worth a thousand words In search of possible answers to my dilemma I decided to focus my capstone research project on investigating how to use picturebooks as a teaching a nd learning tool in my classroom In particular, this study searched for meaningful ways of using the art and illustrations in picturebooks as effective resources to
THE POWER OF PICTURES 9 promote the literacy development of t he young learner. In addition, the illustrations served as an effective tool to stimulate and promote children's creativity. Statement of t he Problem Rational e, and Goals of the Study Common Core Stan dards are now in place in Florida for kindergarten age students The expectations in the English Language Arts Standards identify literacy skills involving literature, informational text, foundational skills, wri ting, speaking and listening, and language ( www.corestandards.org/ELA Literacy ) The problem is that emergent readers are struggling to attain the skills needed to meet the rigorous demands set by Common Core Stan dards. Research and study is necessary in order to improve the early reading skills and dispositions of our youngest learners so that they can become co nfident readers. However it is my opinion, they must first make meaning out of visual images that make up their emergi ng literacy strategies. These 3 through 6 year old children are coming to school for the first time in order to build a strong foundation in their early learning to become successful life long learners. I believe the creativ e process emphasized in the art classroom can serve these young students by giving them a way to express themselves visually. Their art making can support meaning making now and continue to support oral and written language skills as they navigate through their early elementary school years. This strategy of integrating prior knowledge and ideas found in imagery is supported by the content of the Common Cor e For the purpose of this study, I refer to the power of pictures in children's picturebooks to signify how images enhance the comprehension of meanings intended by texts. Children intuitively understand the meaning of pictures well before they are taught how to read words on paper (Olshansky 2008). Picturebooks provide a natural platform for text and pictures to come together, intricately weaving meaning into both the art/illustration and the written
THE POWER OF PICTURES 10 language (Martens et al., 2012). I believe that my study is needed to explore creative and dynamic ways to engage emergin g readers through picturebooks. I use visual images routinely in my art room practice to stimulate my students and assist them with strengthening their comprehension, questioning and meaning making skills A ddition ally t he collaborative nature of this pro ject between myself, the classroom teacher and our students has become inherent in how I use picturebooks in the art room to inspire my students to cre ate their own artwork to tell stories. The goals for my research in this capstone project were to first, gain a deeper understanding of the role the classroom teacher plays as a facilitator in our students' comprehension and meaning making through the juxtaposition of the illustrati ons and text. S econd ly to develop learning activities that en courage childre n to create pictures that enhance their own storytelling. The product s of my study include a published resource entitled, A Picture Is Worth A Thousand Words on an e book site called Issuu, a Pinterest page of related books and resources titled Children's Picturebooks Worth Looking At a companion website and personal blog, and this capstone paper that shar e s my research and findings. Research Questions The following research questions guided my exploration of picturebooks and young learn er s using a coll aborative action research investigation with a Pre K and K indergarten classroom teacher: What role do picturebooks play in the development of young emerging readers? How can the art teacher use pi cturebooks to promote children's creativity and meaning maki ng? What are the benefits of using picturebooks in the art room to enhance visual thinking?
THE POWER OF PICTURES 11 Definition of Terms Picturebook. W olfenbarger and Sipe (2007) define a picturebook as a book in which the picture is as important as the te xt. The texts and illustrations are fused together to provide more than either can do alone Picture walk A picture walk is a classroom strategy for previewing the pictures in a picturebook to familiarize the child with the story prior to introducing the text. Walking th rough the picturebook with the teacher prepares the child for reading the story and teaches the use of visual cues as a reading strategy (Milne, 2005). Literacy Patricia Stock, Professor Emerita, Michigan State University (2012) defines literacy as "the ability to use available symbol system s that are fundamental to learning and teaching for the purposes of comprehending and composing for the purposes of making and communicating meaning and knowledge (Literacy in Learning Exchange, para. 1). While there are many types of literacy, in the context of this project literacy refers to the acquisition of language skills in the emerging reader. Visual Thinking Philip Yenawine, Visual Thinking Strategy Co founder defines visual thinking as "the ability to find meaning in imagery. It involves a set of skills ranging from simple identification (naming what one sees) to complex interpretation on contextual, metaphoric and philosophical levels " (Visual Thinking Strategies, para 1). Literature Revi ew From the time we are born, humans strive to communicate with others using various forms of communication. Early literacy researchers agree that young children talk, read, wr ite and draw to create meaning. They have consistently found that children "purposefully and intentionally make, and weave together, marks on paper, movements in space, and comments
THE POWER OF PICTURES 12 to others to communicate their meaning" (Martens, Martens, Hassay Doyle, Loomis, Aghalurov, 2012, p. 2). As y oung children be gin to offer narrative a ccounts explaining their artwork, they provide adults with insight into their awareness that visual forms are related to personal experiences Therefore, creative experiences in the early childhood years should allow children to explore and manipulate many different materials as they respond freely to the possibilities of visual forms (Thompson, 1990). Storytelling is an essential part of childhood and provides young children with access to literature and culture that they may not otherwise experience. Picturebooks provide a natural platform for text and pictures to come together, intricately weaving meaning into both the art/illustration and the written language (Martens et al., 2012). This literature review provides an introduction to the power of illustrations in children's picturebooks. It includes a review of s tudies that investigate how the illustratio ns in children's picturebooks can be an effective tool in the development of the emerging reader. Utilizing picturebooks, educators can entice you ng children to read as well as develop expressive ways to signify meaning, comprehension and visually give a voice to their own story telling The use of picturebooks is not a new idea in art education. Visualizing images play an important role in meaning m aking and comprehension (Marantz, 1998). I personally enjoy using picturebooks to inspire my own students to consider the power behind the illustrations that they create in order to enhance their own story telling. Learning to lis ten, observe, and interpre t my students' actions thoughts, and logic of investigation and construction helps me to understand the processes and choices they make as they acquire knowledge (Thompson, 2005).
THE POWER OF PICTURES 13 History of the Picturebooks Pi ctur e books gained acceptance in 1937 when The Caldecott Medal was created to honor the artist who created the images in the most distinguished picturebook of that year. Maria Popova, (n.d.) a writer at the Atlantic and an MIT Futures of Entertainment Fellow, is the creator/author of the online newsletter Brain Pickings. In her article entitled "A Brief History of Children's Pictures Books and the Art of Visual Storytelling" Popova explains: Though pictorial storytelling dates back to the earliest cave wall paintings the true picturebook harks back to a mere 130 years ago, when artist and illustrator Randolph Caldecott (1846 1886) first began to elevate the image into a storytelling vehicle rather than a mere decoration for text. (n.d., par. 2) Maurice Sendak, auth or of Where the Wild Things Are (1963), wrote about Caldecott's legacy: Caldecott's work heralds the beginning of the modern. He devised an ingenious juxtaposition of picture and word, a counterpoint that never happened before. Words are lef t out but the picture says it. Pictures are left out but the words say it. In short, it is the invention of the picture book. (cited in Popova, n.d., p. 2) P icture book s did not become popular until the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, when new developments in printing technology evolved and changing attitudes toward childhood emerged A new class of exceptional artists also propelled the picture book into modern culture. It was during the first part of the twentieth century that such timeles s classics as Curious George (1941) and Babar (1937) 1 were created. I n the 1950's an 1 The colorful images and animated characters found in these popular picturebooks were designed for early readers. They have become classics among children's picturebook genre.
THE POWER OF PICTURES 14 interesting cultural shift began and the line between artist and author started to blur as a wider appeal in the genre b egan to grow. Author and illustrators emerged on th e scene, w riting and illustrating picture books using vibrant paint and color in combination with book illustration. This new breed of artist/author/illustrator made an impact on educators and scholars, as well as on children (Popova, n.d.). With the term "picturebook now defined, this literature review will explore specific ways in which learning in the pre k and kindergarten classroom may be facilitated through the use of picturebooks. A significant amount of research examines the importance of pict urebooks to learners of all ages, but it would be i mpractical to discuss the vast depth and breadth of this topic within the pages of this review. For the purpose of this paper I focus on how picturebooks entice young children to read and interact with the text and how picturebooks serve as an effective tool to stimulate an d promote children's creativity (Popova, n.d.). A Picture Is Worth A Thousand Words Educators are always searching for effective ways to increase the lite racy levels of their students. T he momentum to engage students in reading activities at the pre k and kindergar ten level is robust, " more and more, the texts that students are being asked to understand and interpret are not simply words; they are words and pictures" (Wachowiak and Clem ents cited in Danko McGee & Slutsky, 2011, p. 174). As Cyndi Giorgis (2012) suggests, "A picturebook is a unique art form, and every aspect of it is meaningful (p. 4) For many young children, their first reading experiences often involve s the use of picture books (Danko McGee & Slutsky, 2011). Children's literature is well suited to the young learner as it encourages reading while allowing the young child to luxuriate in the magic of the picture as the story unfolds. Pictures are a languag e in their own right, not simply an
THE POWER OF PICTURES 15 addition to verbal language. They speak equally to native speakers of English as well as those learning English as a second language. Beth Olshansky author of The Power of Pictures: Creating Pathways to Literacy Through Art (2008), observes, "as a visual language, that runs parallel to our own verbal language, it is possible to teach the very same literary elements through the language of pictures as through the language of words" ( p. xii). In order for educators to deter mine which picturebooks will work best for their young readers, Olshansky encourages teachers to shift their focus from the text to the images in a picturebook. She advises that one should really concentrate on the pictures as opposed to looking at the wr iting for its literary elements. In particular, illustrations that are most informative tell about the setting, who the characters are, what the problem is, what the solution is and what happens at the end of the story (Olshansky, 2008). Fang (1996) disc usses the popular children's book, The Polar Express (1985) as an example of how illustrations can set the mood in a picturebook. Instead of using a bright and cheery palette typically associated with Christmas, Van Allsburg uses dull reds and blues and ev en pallid yellows along with plenty of black and brown to create a mysterious, gloomy and even somewhat scary mood (Fang, 1996). The color choices in the illustrations help support the eerie mood that is carried throughout the story for the reader. Illust rations can be effective in teaching about theme or plot, and they may even provide different viewpoints to explore. Intentional or not, illustrations sometimes tell a slightly different or even contradictory story than the text. For example in Rosie's Wal k (Hutchin, 1968), the text says that Rosie, the hen, takes a peaceful stroll around the farm and gets back in time for dinner (p. 134). However, the illustrations relate another tale; a menacing fox lurks behind Rosie, ready to make the hen its dinner (Fa ng, 1996). Here, Fang describes the
THE POWER OF PICTURES 16 interweaving of the language of pictures and the language of words communicating more than either language could ever convey alone. Pictures Promote Creativity Picturebooks remind us that art is another way to communicate and learn about the world. Galda (1993) explains that as children explore illustrations and develop the ability to read images, they will reach a deeper understanding of literature. Understanding the message of the images, separate f rom the wor ds has great value. As Paula Eubanks, suggests, "Students need to learn how images communicate social value and be able to identify visual stereotypes." (p.39). I agree that through both text and imagery, picturebooks express social messages that teachers need to teach and students need to learn (Eubanks, 1999 ) This will lead to an awareness of how visual images are used in their own creative processes. Research supports the belief that, "picturebooks have the potential to not only secure a set of technica l skills, but also to imagine, to think outside the box of conventions and to move into the powerful area where true meaning and aesthetic creation reside" (Soundy & Qiu, 2006, p. 72 73). Pictures also assist emerging re aders to begin understand ing certa in language nuances, such as metaphor, h umor or emotion. In her picture book Picture This: How Pictures Work (2000), Mo lly Bang explores emotion and how the st ructure of a picture affects emotional response through the telling of the story Little Red Riding H ood (Bang, 2000). Children begin to understand the language of art/illustration through the juxtaposition of basic shapes and limited colors used in this classic tale (Martens et al., 2012). The book exemplifies the process children go through as they ga in the ability to turn information of all types into pictures in order to help communicate information, thus learn ing to navigate back and forth from the visual to the verbal. The illustration s and text in a picturebook is that important dialogue
THE POWER OF PICTURES 17 between t hese two worlds (Olshansky, 2008). Additionally, art/illustrations in picturebooks allow young readers to become aware of the variety of artistic styles and media that artists employ as well as develop a sense of judging artistic quality (Fang, 1996). Com ing Together In The Classroom "What is the use of a book," thought Alice "without pictures or conversation?" ~ From Alice's Adventures in Wonderland (Carroll, 1865) Pre k and kindergarten students can begin a life long love of books and enjoyment of reading by interacting with children's literature as they explore picturebooks. The richly illustrated texts transport young child ren to diverse places and introduce them to characters that expand their own worlds while captivating their imaginations. The story acquaints children with new ways of experiencing and describing what the y see and hear in their world. When young children interact with picturebooks they are experiencing the integral pull between text and image. This could be considered a metaphor for the way in which young emerging readers thoughtfully navigate back and forth, interweaving their comprehension of symbols, text and imagery as they become more aware of how to make meaning of what they are reading This understanding of the importance of both text and illustration allows children to become active critical thinkers and construct meaning in multiple ways. Educators should consider the reading of a picturebook an event. Each event evolves as the readers integrate their responses to each element of the book into a complete experience. Educators can encourage today's emerging readers to use picturebooks as a way to see new forms, images and intersections that are vital spaces for collaborative imagination and inquiry (Wolfengarger & Sipe, 2 007). As Cyndi Giorgis (2012) suggests, "A picturebook is a unique art form, and every aspect of it is meaningful" (p. 4 ). Common C ore princi ples encourage
THE POWER OF PICTURES 18 young students to examine the components of a picturebook, a practice that links directly to individual language art standards (Giorgis, 2012). As this literature suggests, it is apparent that picturebooks play a significant role in the lives of our youngest students today as we ask them to use pictures to solve problems, think through topics and communicate clearly. During art making activities, I encourage my o wn young students to explore picturebooks and interact with the text and the picture s. They love to "discover" and name hidden objects or characters or to predict what is going to happen n ext as the pa ge is turned. This is what Fang (1996) refers to as "the excitement of a good picturebookthe constant tension between the moments isolated by the pictures and the flow of the words th at join these moments" (p 137). The students truly become empowered to lear n as they begin to interact with the story. I have observed my young art students associate illustrations found in picturebooks with their life experiences and construct new meaning based on their prior knowledge. This is evident in the u nique and sometimes wildly creative interpretations the children depict in their original illustrations. Students often combine multiple themes and concepts explored in two or more picturebooks. This shows me that they are using their comprehension skills and exploring a variety of options when they are creating. When children read picturebooks with limited text, they learn to use their active imagination to interpret and recreate a mental representation of the story (Fang, 1996). I encourage the students to really look a t the picture as I ask, W hat do you see with your eyes, not what you think you see?" Many of my young students seem to require the art to understand the so phistication of the text making fostering children's aesthetic appreciation of art another important creative component of the illustrat ions in children's literature. This can be
THE POWER OF PICTURES 19 accomplished in part by exposure to a wide variety of art/illustrations that are coupled with interesting stories in picturebooks. The combination of the two b ecomes a perfect vehicle for opening a child's eyes to the beauty and power of art (Fang, 1 996). Methodology The research methodology I used for this capstone project is referred to as collaborative participatory action research (Berg, 2004). The study took place in fall of 2013 during the first trimester of school. Over a five week peri od, I collaborated with a Pre K and kindergarten Montessori classroom teacher in presenting our students with multiple opportu nities to interact with picture books t o inspire their creat ivity and develop their comprehension and meaning making skills. Prompted and support ed by the classroom teacher or myself a picture walk was conducted as a precursor to these activities. Previewing the illustrations in the picturebook was a way to familiarize the students with the story prior to introducing the text The picture walk also introduced the students to the illustr ative techniques found in the pictures. As these activities unfolded, I observed and photographed childrens' interactions, taking notes about the discussion that ensued and the culminating art lesson. The product of my study includes a self published e boo k entitled, A Picture Is Worth A Thousand Words on Issuu, a Pinterest page containing links to related books and resources at www.pinterest.com/arteachertalks/c hildrens picturebooks worth looking at a companion website and personal blog called, C.R.E.A.T.e at http://elaineweeks.weebly.com and this capstone paper that shares my research and findings. Subjects and Research S ite My study involved Pre K and kindergarten students at a public Montessori elementary school, located in t he southern United States. The students are generally from low socio
THE POWER OF PICTURES 20 economic and culturally diverse families from the i mmediate neighborhood. There were 18 students in this c lass i ncluding 4 three year olds, 5 four year olds, and 9 five year olds. There were 9 males and 9 females. I asked 18 students to participate in my research and received permission from all 18 parents (see Appendix A). A new three year old student will t ypically choose to observe their surroundings and the day to day activities in the Pre K and Kindergarten classroom. At age four, a transition can be expected and they begin to collaboratively within the classroom dynamic. Then at age five, having been part of the class community for the third year, the Kindergartener becomes independent and demonstrates mastery in the classroom environment. This diverse group of students ranges in various abilities including oral, developmental and ELL. The research too k place in my art room and the Pre K and kindergarten homeroom at the public Montessori elementary school where I am currently employed. The homeroom is one of 14 Pre K and kindergarten classes; my art room is the only art room in this elementa ry school. My principal gave her permission to include this Pre K and kindergarten homeroom for this study. Data Collection Procedures And Instrumentation I used the following methods to gather my data : I identified research questions, gathered the infor mation to answer the questions, analyzed and interpreted the informatio n, and shared the results with the participating classroom teacher (Berger, 2004). I collected data from students in their homeroom class and the art room. I collected dat a through info rmal discussion, written evaluations and observations to determine ho w to promote the power of picture books in the Pre K and kindergarten classroom and art room, using the illustrations as the catalyst to encourage literacy development. This included journal writing and field notes
THE POWER OF PICTURES 21 taken by me about each day's observations, discussion and creative exercises, art making, photographs of student work, and photographs of the students wor king and participating in activities As a collaborative participatory action research project I also documented my interactions with t he cooperating teacher, and observed and documented through field notes and photo graphs her interactions with students and the materials they used. Data Analysis M y data analysis of the con versations and artwork by the participants was shaped by my desire t o determine the efficacy of incorporating picturebooks into the art curriculum I used an ethnographic approach as a method of descriptive data analysis for my collaborative action researc h (Spaulding & Voegtle, 2006 ). The classroom teacher and I had conversations with students as we conducted a picturewalk. We asked the students open ended questions about the ill ustrations in the picturebooks Once the students responded, I was able to analy ze from their answer s what they thought the author/illustrator was trying to convey. I was able to evaluate how many students gained a deeper understanding of the story after discussing the illustrations. I then planned art making activities based upon the cen tral theme of the picturebook and the illustrator's technique s and or explored the medium used to convey meaning within the story I observed the students talk about their artwork to each other and with the teacher and describe the choices used to create the artwork. I watched for recurring ideas, referencing, personal knowledge of themes and process es in their art making. I transcribed my journal and f ield note entries (Flick, 2006) I then entered this information into a blo g created for the purpose of this study I reviewed my blog entries to determine if participating in the picture walk followed by a creative activity strengthened the
THE POWER OF PICTURES 22 student's comprehension and meaning making The classroom teacher and I discussed the stu de nts' production work and creative projects looking for developing comprehension skills. The reliability of this study was checked through the triangulation between the researcher's field notes, observations and children's product work (artwork). Limitations Limitations of time required an adjustment on my part in order to conduct my research. I originally planned to meet with the students twice a week, for 30 50 minute s in the art room and in the ir homeroom class. Due to administrative changes made to the school schedule, I met with the st udents 2 3 times per week for 10 to 20 minutes, in either the classroom or art room. These time frame s included student involvement and int eraction with the picturebooks, a picture walk, discussion, studio prod uction and cleanup of materials. Other limitations included the this project was conducted with a small group of children (18) during a short time frame (5 weeks), thus the results m ay not be generalized to other P re K and kindergarten classrooms or emergi ng readers. Finding s The res earch for this capstone project was driven by 3 questions: W hat role do picturebooks play in the developme nt of the young emerging reader? H ow can the art teacher use pi cturebooks to promote children's creativity and meaning making? and W hat are the benefits of using picturebooks to enhance visual thinking? The purpose of this study was to explore the benefits of using picturebooks to promote meaning making in young learners, and to discover how picture books serve as an effective tool to stimulate and encourage children's creativity in the art room and the classroom. The student created art pieces in particular
THE POWER OF PICTURES 23 exemplify the children's internalization of the art techniques and reading strategies learned over the course of the 5 week study. The picture walk was the foundation that initially guided me to find the answers to my research questions. However, over the course of the study, other aspects began to emerge as important influences to consider as I gathered my findings. For example, the benefits of collaborating with a Pre K and kindergarten teacher played an important ong oing role in the dynamic way the classroom teacher, our students and I connected and worked together during the activities The c ollaboration expanded beyond the confines of the classroom and art room to include an art piece created by the young students in a public space at school. This generated conversation about art and the creative process beyond the one Pre K a nd kindergarten classroom. I will discuss these findings in more detail in the following sections of the research paper. Collaboration During my collaboration with the classroom teacher, I learned that drawing go es hand in hand in the pre k and kinderga rten writing curriculum. The students are often asked to draw themselves engaged in an activity with their friends or families. Next, they are asked to write sentence s that describe their picture s This research pushed me to explore ways to enhance the stu dents' drawing and mark making so that they would be encouraged to try to write more descriptive sentences, motivated and supported by their artwork. Prior to c onducting this research, I occasionally use d picturebooks as visual resources, but only to the extent that I thought the book had interesting chara cters or pictures that would promote age appro priate art making geared toward Pre K and Kindergarten student s After reading the picturebook and discussing the images, I conducted a simple guided drawing
THE POWER OF PICTURES 24 activity with the children that would motivate my you ng students to create a drawing, easy enough to avoid frustrating my youngest, but challengin g enough for the more advanced Pre K and K indergarten students. The students were engaged in the art making pr ocess and happy to take their pictures home, but I wondered whether they were taking away any strategies to help them make connections to their learning back in the classroom. How could my art program link up with the classroom expectations using picturebo oks as a rich visual resource ? The answer came shortly after our collaboration began. Pr ior to this research project, I used art prints or my own illustrations as visual aids to introduce various concepts behind the creative art lessons I taught During the research sessions with my co collaborator, it became clear that the visual format would have to change, forcing me to explore other visual options in lieu of art prints to use in my research. U sing picturebooks as our medium to engage our studen ts during the study, we provided rich visual resources in both the art room and the Pre K and kindergarten classroom, as called for in the English Language Arts expectations of Common Core Standards The classroom teacher and I selected picturebooks for th is study that not only i nspire d our studen ts' cre ativity but that as she indicated, allow ed her to embrace a more visual and crea tive approach to introducing our young students to oral language, emergent reading skills and higher order thinking. What Do You See? The question that I ask my students wh en looking at any artwork is, W hat do you see?" When you ask very youn g children this question, their responses vary greatly; some children see the whol e and others see a portion of the whole. Still other ch ildren "see" an entire narra tive. For example, if we are looking at a lush landscape, one child will see leaves, another child will see trees and another will see a jungle where wild animals live As I observed the
THE POWER OF PICTURES 25 classroom teacher conduct a picture walk, it became evident to me that this exercise of asking the children what they see on each page held the key to successfully using pict urebooks as a visual resource. Although the classroom teacher al so requires the children to examine the pages of a book during her picture walk, I discovered that the classroom teacher focuses more on the parts of the book, the author, illustrator and the pictures as they relate to the text. Therefore, I now preface my question and ask the children to tell me what they actually see in the picture not what they think they see. I am asking for a literal description of what is right in front of them. I conduc t a picture walk in the same way (see Figure 1). We discuss the images as ind ividual parts of the whole picture and build on th ose images to address the illustrator's choices and the meaning s behind them. F igure 1 Art teacher c onducting a picture walk of Grumpy Cat T his st udy concentrated on the art and illustration s contained in picturebooks Therefore, we c ho se to focus on the illustrat ive aspects of the picturebooks the illustrations and line work that were used to e nhance the story or characters by showing mood water elements for example, rain and sp lashing and movement I n doing so, it b ecame evident to both of us that the students picked up on the illustra tive techniques that the illustrator used to
THE POWER OF PICTURES 26 c onvey meaning beyond the text as the students described the relationship between the il lustrations and the story. For example, students quickly learn ed that a group of small lines near or behind a character indicated movement by that character. I have included one of the first examples showing a s tudent's grasp of this concept (see Figure 2 ). The students' artwork strongly indicated that the they met the expectations of the Language A rt s requirements set out by Common Core by gain ing meaning from the illustrations ( www.corestandards. org/ELA Literacy ) Figure 2. Original student artwork l ines show figure is "running" (3 year old) Making A Splash! My colleague and I focused the first creative pro ject around two picturebooks that use simple lines and shapes to convey water; Grumpy Cat (Techentrup, 2008) and Our Dog (Oxenbury, 1994 ) Grumpy Cat is a picturebook about a homeless cat who appears to be
THE POWER OF PICTURES 27 grumpy al l the time. Our Dog is a picturebook about a dog who requires a bath on more than one occasion I conducted the picture walk of Grumpy Ca t first I asked the children to look at the picture of the cat sitting outside in the rain and explain why he looked grumpy, and they were able to respond because the cat was getting wet in the rain," and his face looked mad." I then asked them how the y knew it was raining, and they responded, the illustrator drew lines coming down the page, on top of the cat," and because the cat looked wet." After our discussion I demonstrated on the board how to draw t hree types of lines ; straight curved and zig za g, representing the lines used by the illustrator to convey water in both books. Next, I drew a simplified version of grumpy cat' and w e discussed why the cat looked grumpy and they responded because his face looked grumpy. I pushed a little further and asked what on the cat's face looked grumpy and they replied his mouth and eyes. I explained how the illustrator used certain lines to show the cat's grumpy character by showing them the different direction the lines were drawn in a sm iling cat and a frowning cat. I continued to draw adding stra ight and zigzag lines to simulate the effect of rain and lightning coming down over th e cat, referring to the image in the picturebook I gave the students a n opportunity to draw their own version of a grumpy cat in a rainstorm I observed the students furrowing their eyebrows and frowning to imitate the grumpy expression on the cat's face. I assessed the students' success by the lines drawn and their ability to communicate and describe what was going on in their drawings. I thought it was interesting that some of the students stopped their rain lines on top of the cat's head, not realizing the rain would be falling all around the cat. Next, I read Our Dog a nd conducted a brief picture walk. I asked the children ho w a wet dog dries off and they responded by "shaking all over." I asked them where the water on
THE POWER OF PICTURES 28 the dog goes as he shakes, and they told me, "it goes all over the place!" As we looked at the illustr ation of the dog shaking all over the mother and boy I asked them to pay close attention to the lines and shapes on t he page and tell me how did the artist show the water going all over the place T h ey were able to point out that straight lines and tiny circles" were drawn on the page and this showed us the water is flying" and "the water go es a ll over the boy and the mother." The connections the students made to the lines and mark making found in the illustrations in these two books inspired th em to incorporate these drawing techniques i n a variety of ways during the course of this study. The kindergarteners and several of the 3 and 4 year olds now include water features such as rain, splashing and puddles in their dra wings in a more descriptive way visually, orally and in writing. I have included two example s of student work to illustrate this understanding (see F igures 3 & 4 ) Other exam ples can be found on my website at elaineweeks.weebly.com Figure 3 Original student artwork showing Grumpy Cat in the rain (5 year old)
THE POWER OF PICTURES 29 Figure 4 Original s tudent classroom production work incorporating a water element (5 year old) Art in Motion One of my favorite books to introduce the concept of simple movement to my young students is Duck! Rabbit! ( Rosenthal and Lichtenheld, 2009 ) T h is book pushes children to really "see" by creating optical challenges for the reader to decide whether they are looking at the head of a duck or the head of a rabb it While the children are engaged in deciding which of these two animals is depicted on each page it forces them look between the two and decide if they are looking at the ears of a r abbit o r the bill of a duck. The illustrator uses simple curved lines t o support the visual clues for both the rabbit and duck by strategically placing these lines in the appr opriate places to show whether they are seeing the rabbit or the duck moving. During the picture walk discussion, I asked the children if it is a duck, how did the illustrator show us that the duck was flyin g ? T he y responded, "he used round (curved) lines around the
THE POWER OF PICTURES 30 duck's beak." Next I asked them if it is a rabbit, how did the illustrator show us that the rabbit was hopping ? T hey responded, "the rou nd (curved) lines under his ears ." Next I asked the students how could they show themselves moving in their pictures and they responded that they co uld draw "round lines under their feet or arms to show them selves moving. I discovered that this book, throu gh it's captivating concept, e mpowered each of our young artists to use some form of "curved lines" to demonstrate their understanding of motion. I felt that the students needed a little more practice with making curved lines so that they better represente d "motion" in their drawings. However, each student seemed to draw with conviction and was confident that the lines he or she drew to indicate "motion" were in the drawing s for that specific purpose. This new understanding of motion was evident to me ( and the classroom teacher ) by looking at their drawings and was supported by discussion s I had with the students in the art room When they returned to the classroom, w ith prompting and support from the classroom teacher the kindergarten students were able to incorporate motion lines into the drawing component of their writing production work. They were then able to discuss and name the activity in which they were engaged in and talk about why they place d the "motion" lines in an appropriate area in their drawing. Many of the 3 year olds and 4 year olds also incorporated some type of line work to show motion in their drawings. I have included a photo of a student 's art work demonstrating the use of curved l ines under the feet to show "jumping" and the curved lines around the balloons to show "floating" and "lifting" the figure off the ground (See Figure 5 ). Additional examples of artwork documenting "motion" in student drawings can be found on my website at elaineweeks.weebly.com
THE POWER OF PICTURES 31 Figure 5 Original student artwork showing movement (4 year old) Assessment Starts With "A" Even at the kindergarten level, the evaluation and testing of students is r igorous in our district. As students start our P ubic Montessori program at three and four years of age, the younges t ones are given assessments to determine their proficiency levels in all areas of learning. My collaborator shared that she was concerned about the learning deficits that some of the kindergarteners (generally the ELL students) were presenting after the summer hiatus. Specifically, she was looking at the students' beginning reading levels that included letter and sound recognition. Art and the AB C's became the motivation for our next creative project, focusing on reading readiness The classroom teacher suggested a fun rhyming book that motivates children to recognize their letters. Chicka Chicka Boom Boom (Martin, Archambault and Ehlert, 2012) was a good visual resource to integrate oral language and art by pairing it with the "ma gic" of crayon resist and water color. The classroom teacher expressed a concern that this might be an ambitious project for the whole group, because several of the stud ents started the study later
THE POWER OF PICTURES 32 than others, due to the sta ggered start of the Montessori Pre K and Kindergarten program. Some of her concerns revolved around whether three and four year olds would be able to sit on a stool and work at an adult size table? Wo uld the students listen and follow the directions and use the materials in an adequate manner? I rema ined optimistic and together we embrace d an important Montessori philos o phy : process over product! Each student was given the opportunity to trace the alphabet with crayons reinforcing the recognition of the letters and then paint a w atercolor wash over each letter The classroom teacher and I observed the students begi n to "read" the letters out loud and we appreciated the student s' enthusiasm when the group began to sing the ABC song without prompting on our part. The children's singing prompted the classroom teacher to play the music that goes along with the book, prompting the children to sing along with the CD. The classroom teacher was surprised when one child, who is typically a quiet observer in the classroom, began to recite the letter sounds from the Montessori sound baskets, an activity that is an integral part of their daily work. I was surpr ised to see our young students so engaged in the art making process of hand writing the letters, tracing over the letters with different colored crayons and applying a watercolor wash to create a resist M y newest and youngest students remained engaged even though they had very little prior contact with me, and limited exposure to the art room and the materials. The students listened to my directions, observed the example s of the project and sat on the stools at the larg e tables working with the watercolor paints and brushes successfully. This particular project show ed both of us that our 3 and 4 year olds do rise to the technical and creative skill level, with minor modifications, necessary to complete a p roject geared more toward the kindergarten student The students par ticipated with enthusiasm in this multi sensory project, beginning w ith a picture walk, followed by a crea tive project and
THE POWER OF PICTURES 33 unexpectedly incorporating music and singing. The classroom teacher and I felt that this proje ct influenced every one of our students, reaching them at their own level of learning. Figure 6 Original student artwork ABC tracing and water color resist ( 5 year old) The Writing I s On The Wall After our ABC project, the students went back to the classroom and continued the concept of crayon resist in their daily letter tracing. By using the letter and number insets, the children were creating positive and negative shapes of letter s and number s in addition t o tracing the alphabet. One kindergartener took the concept a step farther and traced the word "name" and the n traced her name on the paper (see F igure 6 ) This was significant because the alphabet template is one piece and she not only selected specific letters to trace, but she also had to line them up on the paper to form the words. This concept was embraced by several
THE POWER OF PICTURES 34 other students in the classroom, and name tracing has been incorporated by the classroom teacher as a natural next step in the progressi on of tracing and letter recognition From this tracing exercise, the ABC projec t grew into a much more adventurous art piece and led the students to explore their capacity to take basic prior language acquisition and transcribe it into art. M y collaborat or and I decided to try to push the st udents in a new direction by asking students to create artw ork that would be observe d by other students and teachers but now I was asking my youngest artists to do just that. Would Pre K and kindergarteners work freely and collaboratively on a large mural style project? This translated into an installation that the children worked on as a class out in public view and displayed on the wall outside of their classroom. First, we int roduced our young students to the artis t Jasper Johns, and his paintings Numbers In Color (1959) and 0 9 (1979). W ould they see his work and their alphabet paintings as inspiration to create random letters and numb ers in a bigger art piece? W ould they feel comfort able enough to do it outside of the classroom ? In order to work big and accomplish the goal of this art piece, it would have to take place in the hallway. The wall outside of the classroom was a perfect space and would allow the children to see their work progress. I thought if the s tudents pa ssed by their art piece every day, several times a day, they would have a chance to inspect their work, discuss it with each other and get feedback from other people. I also hoped that they would see something during the development of this creat ive act that would encourage and develop their visual thinking skills. They began by drawi ng the alphabet letters freehand on the 10 feet of brown paper that hung on the wall During each session, the students worked with a different medium : crayons, cha lk pastel, oil pastel and paint. The students drew letters, numbers and their names, building
THE POWER OF PICTURES 35 their marks on top of each other's by working in a different area of the paper each day (see figure 7 ) Figure 7 Layering of m ark s and working together (3, 4 and 5 year olds) As teachers and students walked by, they made comments and asked about the work, but the student s remained focused on their artwork and I fielded any questions. It was interesting to observe the enthus iastic reaction from the students and teachers as they walked
THE POWER OF PICTURES 36 down the hallway They asked what the students were doing and some of the teachers attempted to give a name to the type of art that was being created. I heard the term "graffiti" used several times. Two teachers asked when their students were going to have an opportunity to work with me on a similar project All in all, this project generated a lot of conversation, in the hallway, but also sparked a lot of interest from the other students who asked me about it when they came to art class. This particular project provided our young artists with a unique, creative learning experience where they made art outside the traditional classroom, freely and with experimentatio n. While all of the projects in this capstone research study served to support the important role picturebooks play in the development of the young learner, I think the collaborative nature of students working together on the Jasper Johns inspired wall painting exemplifies the true purpose of this study ; to us e picturebooks in the classroom in order to entice children to read and interact with the text and to allow picturebooks to serve as an effective tool to stimulate and promote children's creativity. It was very exciting t o see how motivated the children we re to explore new concepts and work in an unusual environment This particular class of three, four and five year olds came together to create artwork that required confidence, trust and imagination. It was inspiring to lead them, with the help and suppo rt of their classroom teacher, on this amazing, creative and educational journey. I believe one of the most important benefits of this multi faceted project was its capacity to reach beyond the classroom, and engage the whole school culture. This project, along with the other projects presented in this research study, are all compellin g reasons to consider the power and efficacy of picturebooks in the classroom.
THE POWER OF PICTURES 37 Reflections, Conclusions and Recommendations As I reflect upon the collaboration between the classroom teacher, our students, and myself I am reminded of how significant picturebooks can be to the creative learning process of young children. This study proved to me that students enjoyed participating in the picture walks and that the picturebooks informed them how illustrators us lines and shapes to communicate meaning. This analysis of the picturebook asks the read er to consider "why" the ill ustrator s made the choices they did and "what" the artist s were trying to communicate ( Eubanks, 1999). Our little people embraced the concept of learning through visual images and successfully carried out each project with minimal support and guidance from their teachers. Throughout my research I have also found picturebooks to be very use ful as a starting po int to create and implement various a rt projects. Examples of high quality picturebooks ca n be found on my Pinterest page at www.pinterest.com/arteachertalks/c hildrens picturebooks worth looking at/ Through the use of picturebooks, educat ors and parents can begin to incorporate art and illustratio ns into stimulating and creative reading practice. My daily blog C.R.E.A.T.e. documenting the creative activities accomplished in the art room and classroom can be found on my website at elaineweeks.weebly.com The goals of m y research were to promote literacy and creativity through the use of picturebooks as a tea ching and learning tool i n the Pre K and kindergarten classroom and art room and to create a blog that documented the collaborative journey that transpired between the classroom teacher, our young students, and myself. I have discovered that picturebooks c an promote both oral and visual literacy by enticing the young learner to interact with the images and text within the pages of the book. My research has also taught me that young children, even those who cannot read, can gain meaning from images and apply that new information
THE POWER OF PICTURES 38 into their day to day learning experiences. I now use picture books in conjunction with a picture walk and the students become inspired and their c reative practices are enhanced. The picture walk is an invaluable tool in the classroom and art room, helping the students to really see the visual information on the page in order to build comprehension and meaning making skills. This project has empowere d both the classroom teacher and myself to include building visual thinking skills in our young students through the use of picturebooks. Picturebooks are a resource in virtually every classroom because they are valued as a tool for learning to read that involves interpreting both wo rds and pictures Children can become sophisticated readers and connoisseurs of picturebooks even before they know how to read words. I hope this research will encourage other educators and parents to consider the power of p icturebooks as an effective tool in the development of their young learners. Learning to "read" a visual story is certainly as important as learning to read the words as the images provide scaffolding that helps the reader become engaged in the story (Euba nks, 1999). By taking the students on a picture walk and introducing them to the images in a picturebook students are able to gain meaning from the choices the artist/illustrator made, think about what the artist was trying to communicate and interpret ho w the words and images work together. The world of picturebooks invites interpretation and exploration because the book as an art form is conceived as a total package, a visual verbal entity (Eubanks, 1999). Discussion and Interpreta t ion of Findings In t he course of this study, I have observed my young art students associate illustrative techniques found in picturebooks with their life experiences and construct new meaning based on their prior knowledge. This is evident in the unique and sometimes wildly creative interpretations the children depict in their original artwork. Students often combine multi ple
THE POWER OF PICTURES 39 themes and concepts conveyed or inferred i n two or more picturebooks, showing me that they are using comprehension skills by trying out a variety of strategies to make meaning, for example; visualizing, making connections, inferring and questioning. Reading to children in any capacity is a worthwhile and educational endeavor. By collaborating with the Pre K classroom teacher, our studen ts benefited from the picture walk in a ne w way. Our combined strengths of art and literacy provided our students with a n invigorated a pproach to exploring the components of a picturebook. The benefits of conducting a picture walk with the children and sho wcasing the illustrations in a picturebook became evident in our student s' artwork and classroom production work ( See Figure s 8 & 9 ). Figure 8 The picturebook inspires art and writing
THE POWER OF PICTURES 40 Figure 9. Original student illustration (4 year old) Over the course of the project t he children became confident in their drawing abilities regardless of their naivety or minimal mark making and were eage r to discuss what they had created and writ ten about. The children continue to reference what they learned from the picture walks discussions and creative sessions conducted. Weeks after the project's conclusion, the classroom teacher continu es to update me, and is happy to report that she observ es the students discuss ing elements in their class production work an d qualifying those elements by stating; "Mrs. Weeks taught us that or identifying the name of the picturebook that inspired their illustrative technique The students also continue to use lines, shapes and marks to convey water motion and mood in their artwork in new and inventive ways, creating thematic compositions based on their own experiences or topics discussed in school. Both the classroom teacher and I have observed the students enjoy re reading the picturebooks that were
THE POWER OF PICTURES 41 used in this s tudy and s eem to "look" at illustrations from other picturebooks with a new perspective Through my shared experiences, I discovered that integrating the art and illustrations found in picturebooks into the reading curriculum of a pre k and kindergarten classroom was a challenge given the time constraints place d on the fine arts schedule this year. It takes considerable time to design a worthwhile curriculum and building upon a collaborative project requires an understanding of the respective core subjects. I have embraced collaboration in the past and looking back, I see that the classroom teacher "infused" art into their lessons in order to incorporate a hands on activity for the students. While this is pleasurable for the children, it is not true integration of art. The collaboration between myself, the classroom teacher and our 18 pre k and kindergarten students integrated art into the reading program by aligning ou r instruction to the standards. This collaboration, while not my main focus in this capstone resea rch project, became a driving force and upheld the integrity of the study. I now clearly see the importance of reaching my youngest studen ts right where they are on that first day of school. Images provide countless opportunities for me to encourage commu nication and engage my new students. The illustrations found in picturebooks can be used as an effective motivator to encourage our young learners to communicate and interact throughout their learning experiences. By using picturebooks in the classroom, ar t room and at hom e, we can build up our student s' comprehension and meaning making by encouraging them to interact with the illustrations found on each page as an early reading strategy. Incorporating creative p rojects in this process motivate s students and promote s literacy while stimulating creativity. I believe that the efficacy of the picturebook as a medium transcends beyond elementary school through high school and even into higher learning. The graphic novel, for
THE POWER OF PICTURES 42 example, is an excellent resource for teaching older students through text and visual images (Meyerson, 2006) More research is needed to understand the importance of the power of picturebooks on the development of the older learner. Significance, Implications, and Recommendations The r esearch conducted in this study focused on observing youn g children in the Pre K and kindergarten classroom setting interacting with picturebooks as the classroom teacher takes them on a picture walk. Through my investigati on, I determined how the illustra tion s in children's picturebooks could be an effective tool in the development of meaning making in bo th the classroom and art room. The goals of the study were to provide young children with opportunities to interact with text and illustrations in childre n's picture books and to explore effective ways to use these illustrations as rich resources in both the art room and classroom I hoped to motivate young children to gain meaning from using children's picturebooks by showing them how to begin to comprehend the nuances between the rich visual imagery and limited text. The results established picturebooks as an important tool in the development of the young learner. The illustrations enticed young children to read and interact with the story in a way that allowed picturebooks to serve as an effective tool to stimulate and promote children's creativity. In doing so, the students beg an to use illustrations in their own story telling, while strengthening their comprehension and meaning making skills. Conclusion I have always thought collaboratin g with other teachers is a powerful way to design and implement lessons that engage, motivate, challenge and inspire children to learn. Research supports that Pre school teachers have the power to influence early literacy sk ill development and potentially impact chi ldren's later success in school (Allor & McC athren, 2011). This
THE POWER OF PICTURES 43 collaborative ac tion research project has provided me with the opportunity to expand my art room practices to include literacy strategies By using picturebooks as a critical tool to help young learners to make meaning from visual images, students can learn early reading strategies. My research supports that young learners interact with picturebooks by visualizing, making personal connections, inferring meaning and significance and by asking and answering questions about the illustrations. Studie s s how that when teacher s increase Pre school children's access to books and enhance the quality of how books are read through a rich storytelling narrative, their language and early literacy development increases (Allor & McC athren, 2011). I am not suggesti ng that my art program be replaced by the reading program, but based upon my research, I see the need for my students to receive extra support and I feel that I can infuse reading and meaning making with visual thinking skills and stay true to the National Visual Arts S tandards. In their book Using Art to T each Reading Comprehension Stra tegies Jennifer Klein and Elizabeth Stuart (2013) help to define art integration as objectives in one art form matched with objectives in another subject area and taught to gether in a meaningful w ay, making strong connections. Klein and Stuart confirm my belief that art teachers should be aware of not only the National Visual Arts Standards, but also the Common Core Standards for English and Language Arts, and the National R eading Standards when planning an art curriculum. This project has made me rethink the role I want to have in my school's culture. By incorporating these standards into my art program, I believe I legitimize visual thi nking as it pertains to teaching and l earning As an art educator, I embrace t he power of picturebooks as an essential educational re source found in classroom s from Pre K and kindergarten through higher e ducation. The idea of using these visually rich resource s as tool s in the development of
THE POWER OF PICTURES 44 young learners is just the begi nning of endless possibilities that this genre of storytelling has to offer our students. It is our role as educators to create a learning environment that students find relevant, challenging, and worth y of their attention a nd effort (Landay & Wootton, 2012). It is the role of the art educator to find the connection between the visual and the goal s of the educationa l standards in order to help students think, learn, create, and reflect. Through this stud y, I have successfully learned how to implement picturebooks to achieve those goals in my art program and I hope other art educators will consider doing the same. By doing so, we can create rich, memorable learning opportunities for our young learners.
THE POWER OF PICTURES 45 References Allor, J. H., & McCathren, R. B. (2011). Strategies for supporting early literacy development. Y oung E xceptional Children, 14 (3) 29 40. Bang, M. (2000). P icture t his : H ow pictures w ork New York: SeaStar Books. Berg, B. (2004). Action research. In Bruce L. Berg, Qualitative research methods for the social sciences (pp.195 208). Boston, MA: Pearson Education, Inc. Bosman, J. (2010). Picture books no longer a staple for children [Web site]. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/08/us/08picture.html?_r=3 Brunho ff, Jean de., (1960). The story of Babar, the little elephant New York: Random House Carroll, L. (1865). Alic e' s adventur es in wonderland United Kingdom: MacMillan. Common Core State Standard Initiative. (2012). Retrieved from http://www.corestandards.org/ELA Literacy Cossentino, J., & Whitescarver, K., (2011). [Web site]. Retrieved from http://www.vtshome.org/system/resources/0000/0241/VTS Montessori_International Douglas, N., Schwartz, J., & Taylor, J.B. (1981). The relat ionship of cognitive styles of young children and their modes of responding to paintings. Studies In Art E ducation, 11 (3), 24 31. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org.lp.hscl.u fl.edu/stable/1320069 Eubanks, P. (1999), Learning to be a connoisseur of books: Understanding picturebooks as an art medium. Art Education 52 ( 6 ), 38 44. Evens, K. (2009). Greater g ood: The science of a meaningful life. Arts And S marts Retrieved from: http://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/arts_smarts/# Fang, Z., (1996). Illustrations, text, and the child reader: What are pictures in children's storybooks for? Reading Horiz ons, 37 (2), 130 142.
THE POWER OF PICTURES 46 Fox, J. E., & Berry, S. (2008). Art in early childhood: Curriculum connections. Early Childhood N ews [Web site] Retrieved from http://www.earlychildhoodnews.com/earlychildhood/article_view.aspx?Art icleID =113 Galda, L. (1993). Visual literacy: Exploring art and illustration in children's books. Reading T eacher 46 (6), 506 516. Giorgis, C. (2012). The a rt of p icture b ooks. Bo ok l inks 22 (2), 4 9. Grundmann, U., & Arnheim, R., (2001). The intelligence of vision: An interview with Rudolf Arnheim. Cabinet [Web site]. Retrieved from http://cabinetmagazine.org/issues/2/rudolfarnheim.php Holmes, M., & Meyers, L. (2011). The common core: Clarifying expectations for teachers & students. Ohio: McGraw Hill Education. Marten, P., & Martens, R., & Hassay Doyl, M. & Lo omis, J., & Aghalarov, S. (2012). Learning from picturebooks: Reading and writing multimodally in first grade. The Reading Teacher 66 (4), 285 294. Meyerson, P. (2006). Using children's pictur e books as tools to facilitate undergraduates' learning. College T eachi ng, 45 (3), 259 269. Mulcahey, C. ( 2009). The s tory in the p icture: Inquiry and a rtmaking with y oung c hildren New York: Teachers College Press. Murphy, S. J. (2007). Visual learning in elementary mathematics. Retrieved from http://pearsonschool.com/live/images/custom/envisionmath_ca/pdf/enVision_Murphy monograph
THE POWER OF PICTURES 47 Olshansky, B. (2008). The power of pictures: Creating pathway s to literacy through a rt California: Jossey Bass. Popova, M (n d.). A brief history of children's picture books and the art of visual storytelling. Brain P ickings Newsletter, 1 13. Retrieved from, http://www.brainpickings.org/index.php/2012/02/24/childrens picturebooks/ Ray, H. A., (1941). Curious g eorge Boston: Houghton Mifflin. Soundy C. S., & Drucker, M. F. (2010). Picture partners: Journey into visual l iteracy. Early Childhood Education Journal, 37 447 460. Stewart, M.,G. & Walker, S., R. (2005). Art integration. In M. Stewart and S. Walker, Rethinking curriculum in art (pp.106 117). Davis Publication. Stock, P. (2012) Literacy in learning exchange. Retrieved from http://www.literacyinlearningexchange.org/defining literacy Stokes, S. (2002). Visual literacy in teach ing and learning: A Literature perspective. Electronic Journal For the Integration of Technology in Education 1 (1), 1 8. [Web site]. Retrieved from http://ejite.isu.edu/Volume1No1/Stokes.html Thompson, C., M. (2005). Under construction: Images of the child in art in art teacher education. Art Education 58 (2), 18 22. Thompson, C., M. (1990). "I make a mark": The significance of talk in young children's artistic development. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 5 (2), 5 232. Retrieved from http://www.sciencedirect.com.lp.hscl.ufl.edu/science/article/pii/08852006909004 Whitescarver, K. & Cossentino J. (2011). Visual thinking in Montessori environments. Montessori International [Web site]. Retrieved from http://www.vtshome.org/system/resources/0000/0241/VTS Montessori_International
THE POWER OF PICTURES 48 Wolfenbarger, C. D., & Sipe, L. (2007). A unique visual and literary art form: recent research on picturebooks. Language Arts, 83 (3), 273 280. Ye nawine, P ., (1997 ). Thought s on visual literacy. [Web site]. Retrieved from http://vtshome.org/system/resources/0000/0005/Thoughts_Visual_Literacy.pdf
THE POWER OF PICTURES 49 Appendix A UFIRB 02 Social & Behavioral Research Protocol Submission Form This form must be typed. Send this form and the supporting documents to IRB02, PO Box 112250, Gainesville, FL 32611. Should you have questions about completing this form, call 352 392 0433. Title of Protocol: The Art of Illustration: The Role Picturebooks Play in the Development of the Very Young Learner Principal Investigator: Elaine M. Weeks UFID #:xxxxxx Degree / Title: Master of Art In Art Education Mailing Address: (If on campus include PO Box address): xxxxxxxxxx Email: xxxxxx Department: School of Art and Art History Telephone #:xxxxxx Co Investigator(s): N/A UFID#: Email: Supervisor (If PI is student) : xxxxxxx UFID#: Degree / Title: Director of Online MA Program in Art Education 101 Mailing Address: (If on campus include PO Box address):Fine Arts Building C P.O. Box 115801 Gainsville, Fl 32611 Email : xxxxxxx Department: School of Art and Art History Art Education Telephone #: xxxxxxx Date of Proposed Research: August 26 th 2013 September 27 th 2013 Source of Funding (A copy of the grant proposal must be submitted with this protocol if funding is involved): none Scientific Purpose of the Study: To develop a curriculum and pedagogy promoting visual learning skills in the pre k and kindergarten art classroom through the exploration of picture books.
THE POWER OF PICTURES 50 Describe the Research Methodology in Non Technical Language: ( Explain what will be done with or to the research participant. )While teaching pre k and kindergarten elementary art, I will observe ways in which the students demonstrate comprehension when given picture books as examples of art and literature. I will evaluate what comprehension and meaning making looks like through behavior studies and obser vation. I will observe peer teaching (through Montessori principles, for example) and individual artmaking to determine if comprehension and meaning making are evident. All participants will participate in the development of several art projects that refer back to selected children's literature. Each participant will work through artmaking, discussions, peer teaching, critiques, and evaluations based on the themes and literary nuances of the picture books. Results may vary. Using comprehension as an intrins ic motivator and art as a vehicle, I hope to see students develop stronger visual literacy skills, critical thinking skills, build oral language, and create a deepened sense of community centered around the creative process. As the only teacher in my distr ict who is teaching this content and approach, my own classroom is best served for this research. Participatory Action Research methods will be used for this study. I will observe students as they respond to the picture books, engage in discussion about the themes/story line, create artwork and collaborate in peer to peer teaching activities. I will keep field notes that document these classroom observations. I will take pictures of the artwork produced during the project. I will have informal conversatio ns about these projects with the students and I will take field notes about these conversations. I will be documenting the products produced in this study in a personal blog. No students will be identified. No recognizable photographs of students will be t aken. I will write up my findings in a capstone paper. Some of the photographs of the art projects will appear in this paper. This paper will be deposited in the University of Florida's digital repository in which masters thesis and dissertations are house d. No students will be pressured or coerced to be participants in this study. All students will have the options to withdraw from the study even after the study is over. No student will be identified. Student participation as subjects in this research will be completely voluntary. No students will be pressured to be volunteers in this project and students will be treated the sa me as others not participating. Describe Potential Benefits: Increase visual learning skills, oral language development, inspire intrinsic creative ability and encourage emerging literacy through the use of picture books. Describe Potential Risks: ( If risk of physical, psychological or economic harm may be involved, describe the steps taken to protect participant.) Non e Describe How Participant(s) Will Be Recruited: Students will be currently enrolled in my class. Maximum Number of Participants (to be approached with consent) 18 students Age Range of Participants: 3 6 years of age Amount of Compensation/ course credit: None Describe the Informed Consent Process. (Attach a Copy of the Informed Consent Document. See http://irb.ufl.edu/irb02/samples.html for examples of consent.) Students will be asked to volunteer. Parents w ill be asked to sign a consent form to allow their child t o participate in the study.
THE POWER OF PICTURES 51 (SIGNATURE SECTION) Principal Investigator(s) Signature: Date: Co Investigator(s) Signature(s): Date: Supervisor's Signature (if PI is a student): Date: Department Chair Signature: Date:
THE POWER OF PICTURES 52 Appendix B Informed Consent for Parents and Students Protocol Title : THE ART of ILLUSTRATION: THE ROLE PICTUREBOOKS PLAY in the DEVELOPMENT of the VERY YOUNG LEARNER In order to make an informed decision, please read this consent document carefully before you or your child decides to participate in this study. Purpose of the research study: The purpose of this study is to examine the promotion of visual learning skills using picture books through art education. What your child will be asked to do in the study: All students will be introduced to children's literature in the form of picture books. They will be asked to participate in group discussions and art making proje cts. Students will be given the opportunity to work individually or with a partner to create artwork that corresponds to the theme or story line in the picture book using various types of media. Students will be given the opportunity to provide feedback ab out the books, projects and teaching methodology, thereby helping to improve or develop the curriculum to its fullest potential. This program of study will involve group work, discussions, art making, critiques, strategies to improve visual thinking skills and promote oral language skills. The collection of activities is not any different than what students normally experience in their art class, but could be more personal in nature if the student feels comfortable to share his/her opinion or prior experien ces or knowledge. The desired outcome of the revised art curriculum is for all students to develop a better understanding of picture books and how they can help develop visual learning skills, meaning making and personal growth in the areas of visual and v erbal fluency.
THE POWER OF PICTURES 53 An example of the type of interaction and or exchange between the student and teacher/researcher is as follows: Good morning boys and girls. Welcome to the artroom! Today we are going to take a picturebook walk together. As we look at the pi ctures I am going to ask you so me questions about what you see. We are going to talk about how the author/illustrator made the pictures in the book and why it is important for us to understand what these pictures mean as we take a look at the story. Please raise a quiet hand if you have something you would like to share wit h all of us. I would like you to think about the pictures in the storybook and all of the different things we talked about today. Next, we are going to work together and draw a pict ure t hat represents your favorite part of the story. You may draw and use the crayons, markers and pencils to create your drawing. Time required: One two classes per week for an 4 week period. Risks and Benefits: There are no risks expected with this study. I hope to see your child benefit from this program through the development of visual literacy skills and the formation of life long learning skills. Compensation: No student will be compensated for this study. Confidentiality: Your child's identity will be kept confidential to the extent provided by law. Participant information will be assigned a code number. The list connecting his/her name to this number
THE POWER OF PICTURES 54 will be kept in a locked file in my office. When the study is completed and the data have been analyzed the list will be destroyed. Participant names will not be used in any report. Voluntary participation: Your child's participation in this study is voluntary. There is no penalty for not participating. Right to withdraw from the study: You and your child have the right to withdraw from the study at anytime without consequence. You or your child has the right to withdraw your consent after the study is complete even through the end of the year and after grades are final. Whom to contact if you have question s about the study: Supervisor : Dr. XXXX XXXXX School of Art and Art History University of Florida P.O. Box XXXXX Gainesville, FL 32611 5801 (XXX) 392 XXXX XXXXXX@ufl.edu
THE POWER OF PICTURES 55 List of Figures with Figure Captions Figure 1. Art teacher conducting a picture walk of Grumpy Cat ...25 Figure 2. Lines show figure is "running" ... .... 26 Figure 3 Grumpy cat out in the rain .. 28 Figure 4 Student classroom production work in corporating a water element ...29 Figure 5 Original artwork showing movement 31 Figure 6 ABC tracing and water color resist . 33 Figure 7 Layering of marks and working together 35 Figure 8 The picturebook inspires art and writing 39 Figure 9 Inspired student illustration 40
THE POWER OF PICTURES 56 Author Biography The author of th is paper is an art educator who has been in the field for nine consecutive years. S he returned to school and obtained her degree after successf ully raising three children in S outh Florida. Elaine Weeks has her Bachelor of Fine Arts degree from Florida Atlantic University (2005) and plans to graduate from The University of Florida with a Masters of Art in Art Education in the fall of 2013. She regularly attends professional development conferences around the U.S. and mentors local 5 th grade students who audition each year for the Middle School of the Arts visual arts program in her school district. Mrs.Weeks plans on continuing her teaching career in art education. She lives in Florida and enjoys painting in a variety of mediums, including encaustics, oils, acrylic and mixed media.