!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 0 $ ART AS A MIRROR FOR SOCIAL CHANGE: AN EXPLORATION OF ART'S REFLECTIVE POWERS TO RAISE AWARENESS OF HUMAN TRAFFICKING By JENNIFER L. RAPP A CAPSTONE PROJECT PRESENTED TO THE COLL EGE OF FINE ARTS OF THE UNIVERS I T Y OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2014
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 1 $ 2014 Jennifer Rapp
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 2 $ Acknowledgements I would like to thank my Capstone Committee; Jodi Kushins and Patrick Grigsby for their support and creative direction of this project. I would also like to thank my instructors; Craig Roland for his encouragement to take "the leap," and Bob Mueller who taught me not to be afraid. Thank you to my children ; Ben, Lindsay and Oliver for their patience and tech support throug hout the duration And, thank you to Bob for your support, encouragement and enduring belief that I am, "always 10 minutes away from the next great idea." Thanks to my mom and th e Korolys for their unending cheerleading. And, finally, thank you to the Office of the Kansas Attorney General for the opportunity to work on the frontline s of anti human trafficking efforts in the great state of Kansas. There is a certain grace and omni science gained from coming home the ability to truly see yourself and who and why you are. The intersection of all of the paths of my journey is right here, right now. Who says you can't go home? I am truly blessed.
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 3 $ ABSTRACT OF CAPSTONE PROJECT PRE SENTED TO THE COLLEGE OF FINE ARTS OF THE UNIVERSTIY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS ART AS A MIRROR FOR SOCIAL CHANGE: AN EXPLORATION OF ART'S REFLECTIVE POWERS TO RAISE AWARENESS OF HUMAN TRAFFICKING By Jennifer L. Rapp May 2014 Chair: Jodi Kushins Committee Member: Patrick Grigsby Major: Art Education Abstract This study address es ways in which art can transmit meaning and increase awareness of complex social issues. Authentic qualitative research methods such as Arts Based Educational Research, A/r/tography an d Ethnography, were used to explore the role visual art and culture can play in anti human trafficking ef forts. The au thor use s performative social science (artmaki ng) as a means to establish connection between personal passion and humanity and demonstrate s their contribution to an active tran sformative process. She argues that engagement with artwork and visual imagery is a powerful way to extrapolate meaning from h uman suffering by looking inward and carefully examining factors that trigger individual passion, connection and ultimately the impetus to act for social change.
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 4 $ Table of Contents Title Page. 1 UF Copyright page ... 2 Acknowledgements. 3 Abstract 4 Table of Contents Page 5 Introduction. 7 Statement of the P roblem 7 Purpose of the Study 9 Assumptions of the Study ..10 Rationale and Significance of the Study10 Definition of T erms11 Literature Revie w ..12 Methodology . 18 Subject Selection, Site, and Description 18 Data Collection Procedures 19 Data Analysis .20 Research Methodology. .14 Findings. 20 Finding 1 20 Finding 2 21
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 5 $ Finding ...24 Summary across all Findings .27 Discussion and Conclusion 27 Discussion and Interpretation of Findings. 27 Implications and Recommendations . 29 Conclusion. 30 References .32 Appendix A 36 Appendix B 40 List of Figures and Figure Captions..43 Auth or Biography .44
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 6 $ Art is the lie that enables us to realize the truth Pablo Picasso Art offers a reflection of society but the image in the mirror is often complex. While some art holds a mirror up to social reality so it can see itself exactly as it is, other times it depicts a view that cannot be seen without such a mirror. Such a rt presents a picture of the way reality is not (Kelly, 2003). Accordingly, there is a long tradition of artists concerned with social justice; Thomas Hart Benton, Diane Arbus, Pablo Picasso, Francisco Goya, William Blake, and Kara Walker just to name a few. In fact, many artist s have looked at the theme of justi ce in society which is not surprising given that the use and abuse of power is so prominent a part of the human condition. It is not a question of whether art and social justice are connected, but rather, the forms and intensity that connection takes (Cocke, 2013 ) Since the beginning of modern times there existed an innate tropism toward suffering. As observed by Edmund Burke in "A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origins of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful (1757), "we have a degree of delightin the real mi s fortunes and pains of others" (Burke as reported in Sontag, 2003). Similarly, William Hazlitt, in his essay on Shakespeare's Iago underscores this point by examining the attraction of villainy ( Hazlitt as reported by Sontag, 2003). Human trafficking rep resents one of the greatest social issues and human rights abuses of our time. Demand f or sex trafficking can be traced to a visual culture that supports objectification of women, "wherein women's bodies and sexual capability are seen as commodities" (My ers, 2011, p. 3). My research explores ways in which art can transmit meaning and increase awar eness of complex social issues like human trafficking.
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 7 $ Statement of the Problem According to Sidford (2010) : C ulture and the arts are essential means by which all people explain their experience, shape their identity and imagine the future. In their constancy and their variety, culture and the arts allow us to explore our individual humanity, and to see our society whole. People need the art s to make sen se of their lives and to know who they are. They increase our compassion for others by providing creative ways for use to underst and and deal with differences (p. 8) However, c ompassion as noted by Sontag, is an unstable emotion. It needs to be translated into action or it withers (Sontag, 2003). Social movements often suffer fr om a level of apathy that mirrors something known as the "bystander effect." Bibb Latane and John Darley (1964) attributed this term to the diffusion of responsibility and social influence (as cited in www.psychologytoday.com/basics/bystander effect ). Variations of the bystander effect have been pervasive t hro ughout history and responsible for some of its greatest atrocities slavery, human trafficking and genocide to name a few. Wherever people feel safe they will be complacent. How do we use art to un numb the oversaturation of current day causes to provide real and meaningful connection to incite action? Significant e vidence shows that exposure to art changes a person's ph ysiology and attitude (Samuels, 2013) however details of this transformative process remain somewhat of an enigma. I argue in this study that a rt can be used as a vehicle for transmission of meaning and greater understand ing of pe rsonal connection with complex societal issues. My investigative research seeks to provide greater insight into the role of art and visual culture in personal reflection, identity and connection that can lead to social action. It is my hope that results of this
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 8 $ research will foster a reexamination of modern thought paradigms associated with accepted practices (visual culture) that lead to the objectification and commodification of women. Study results are relevant t o the fields of behavioral health, political science, sociology, psychology, public relations and marketing, and art education. Purpose of the Study In this study, I investigate d the linkages between art, visual culture, and identity and their subseque nt role in the transformative journey to action. The goal of this study was to repre sent the process of identification w ith human suffering that can result in personal connection and action This was done through examining the issue of h uman trafficking : Human trafficking is a sensitive and complex issue. Human trafficking is impacting millions of people around the world. Trafficking occurs within and across the border. It is a local, national and international issue. Trafficking is happening not just b ecause of poverty, but also due to many other social, political and cultural factors. A multi dimensional and integrated approach is needed to eradicate human trafficking from the face of the earth. Many lack understanding of the complexities of this issu e thus necessitating a new model of integrated trafficking prevention activities (Gulzar, 2010.) Research Questions The following research questions guided my investigation and were explored using empirical, phenomenological and creative methods:
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 09 $ 1) Ho w can observation of visual arts create a connection with viewers and tap into personal journeys? 2) How can engagement with the arts aid personal connection with emotions and passion that can give voice to individual action? 3) How can exploration of p ersonal connection through the visual arts foster greater understanding and awareness of self, others and society as a whole? 4) How can art give voice to victims to create a powerful connection with viewer s ? Rational e and Significance of the Study Data about human trafficking, while horrifying, can't do justice to the concept of captivity and enslavement. "Visual images with the capacity to draw us into another human being's existence have a vital role to play as powerful storytelling vehicles. Abs ent this personal connection, peopl e remain detached" (Hamman, 2010, p. 4 ). Investigation through using various supporting qualitative research methods can make for a transformative process for researchers, participants and viewers alike and can be a co nvincing and impactful contribution to social science and the field of art education (Glass, 2008 ) Assumptions Arts Based Educational Research (ABER) 1 methodology can produce outcomes not anticipated by the researcher at the onset of the study. This can be positive in that it can acknowledge, "the value of the less definable and often holistic kinds of knowing that may result through the use of art tool s and aesthestic analysis" (Greewood, 2012, p. 1). However, the nature of the data collected and the types of analysis required by this kind of study create potential for bias as well potential risks associated with the level of personal disclosure that m ight arise Due $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $ 0 $ !:;< = >?<@A$/ABC?;DEF?G$"@<@?:CH$D<$A@IDF@A$JK$;H@$L:@<@FC@$EI$C@:;?DF$?@<;H@;DC$MB?GD;D@<$E:$ !"#$%&'"(")"&*# $ ;H?;$ DFIB<@$;H@$DFMBD:K$L:EC@<<$?FA$;H@$:@<@?:CH$N;@O;P$Q>?:EF@$R$/D
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 00 $ to the flexible and less "controlled" nature of the case study method, observer bias is frequently considered to be the main prob lem in observation (Fidel, 1984). Along these same lines, the background and personal experiences of the obs erver may also intr oduce bias. These areas were paid sp ecial attention in an attempt to preserve objectivity of data and outcomes. Limitations The breadth of the subject of human trafficking and its multidisciplinary reach make it difficult to capture in its entirety and that is not the goal of this study. Additionally, t his is not a comp rehensive analysis of the issue of human trafficking, debat e on the definition of human trafficking or discussion on strategies necessary to emplo y to eradicate the scourge of human trafficking on a global level Although art can be used effectively for therapeutic practices with trauma victims, that is not the focus of this study either Rather this is a limited study and examination of the role visual arts and culture can play in forming ideas and values to create connection to and increase the possibility for action against social issues such as human traff icking and other human rights atrocities. The chosen methods of qualitative research for this study are meant to inspire further investigation of these complex topics through invitation to dig deeper into our own life stories and personal journeys. Defini tion of Terms Art. The word "art" conjures up images that are so diverse and inherently subjective that a mental corralling of the term is elusive at best. For the purposes of defining art in the broad context of human community, we look at the definition suggested by John Dewey and Albert Murray in which both thinkers described art as, "the medium through which the possibilities of life are both discovered and realized which is another way of saying that art is fundamentally a (perhaps the ) means of education (hence, grow th) f or humankind" (Hill, 2001, p. 1 ) Taking this
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 01 $ further from a cultural standpoint, art serves as, "an imaginative report of how certain folks get along in the precariousness of the human predicament" (Hill, 2001, p 7 ) Human Trafficking This stud y focus es on sexual exploitation primarily but the global definition of human trafficking includes both the buying and selling of humans for sex ual and labor exploitation through force, fraud or coercion Objectification For the purposes of this study, o bjectification of women is understood through examination of women's bodies and sexual capability as commodities within the context of sex trafficking (Myers, 2011 ). Commodifica tion. The term, comm o dification is examined in the context of women's bodies as, "objects of desire and objects to be desired, limiting a woman's full humanity and laying claim to her body as a form of property" (Nelson, 2013, p. 1). Visual Rhetoric Visual Rhetoric is marked by the pres ence of 3 characteristics; the image must be symbolic, involve human intervention, and be presented to an audience for the purpose of communicating wit h that audience (Smith, 2005). Simply stated, visual rhetoric is a form of communication that uses image s to create meaning or construct an argument to move an audience ( www.stanford.edu/~steener/f03/PWR1/whatisvisrhet.htm ). Performati ve Social S cience Performative Social Science is a term that reflects the, efforts of social science researchers who are exploring the use of tools from the arts in research itself and/or using them to enhance, or move beyondt hose engaging in this new performative social science' are often shifting existing boundaries or transforming them through relational processes (Yallop Vallejo & Wright, 2008, p. 1 ) This term is used to describe the arts based activities employed within the other chosen methodologies for this study.
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 02 $ Literature Review From the earliest records of history, there has been evidence that visual art and imagery play a significant role in both recording historical atrocities as well as serving as a catalyst for change through alteration of the conversation or societal debate on human rights issues. This literature review examine s the intrinsic interrel ationships between art and social justice by taking a close look at specific relational factors as w ell as the role of visual imagery and creative e ngag ement in the ar eas of human suffering and social justice. Art as a Vehicle for Truth Telling Within the field of aesthetics, the relationship between truth and works of art is of considerable interest. Philosophers such as Danto and Adorno skillfully debate the role of art in communicating universal meaning and truth. According to Adorno, "art is critical of reality (whether empirical or social) just by being there, just by existing" ( As reported in Kelly, 2003, p. 68). Michael Kelly elaborates this in his book, I conoclasm in Aesthetics by pointing out that, "art's autonomy is a precondition of its critical stance toward societyby emphatically severing all ties with the empirical world, art in an unconscious way expresses its desire to change the world" ( p. 68). The nuanced complexities inherent in this discussion can be better understood through consideration of Leon Trotsky's reflection that, "artis not a mirror, but a hammer: it does not reflect it shapes" (Trotsky, 1991 p. 129 ). Role of Visual Rhetoric in Public Discourse and Social Justice Movements Visual rhetoric has a long history of serving as a powerful voice and catalyst for change. Kansas painter, John Steuart Curry's famous mural, "Tragic Prelude," completed in the state capitol building in Topeka depicts Curry's interpretation of John Brown and the anti slavery
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 03 $ movement in pre Civil War Kansas Territory. Rich in symbolism, the painting illustrates a fierce John Brown holding a Bible in one hand and a rifle in the other ( See Figure 1). Curry's mural incited much controversy and conversation when completed in 1940 due to its' graphic representational nature and ominous foreshadowing Curry refused to sign the murals and left Topeka in anger due to public backlash. As a result, t he murals were not on the walls of the statehouse when he died in 1942. Today, "Tragic Prelude" hangs in the Kansas statehouse and is an important aspect of Kansas history and recognized as the most signifi cant piece John Stew art Curry completed during his artistic career (Kendall, 1986) Figure 1 +'' "Tragic Prelude," by John Steuart Curry.
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 04 $ National Geographic's 1985 cover of an Afghan girl served as a symbol of what has come to be known as, "representational politics of pity" (He s ford & Kozol, 2005 ). (See Figure 2) N ational Geographic has served as a powerful voice for over one hundred years in the visual representation of the non Western world for American audiences. This visual rhetoric of rescue relies on the, "narrative dualism of tradition and modernity to champion human rights within the framework of Western li beration" (Hesford & Kozol, 2005 p. 1). Similarly, Susan Sontag suggests that" pity can entail a moral judgment if, as Aristotle maintains, pity is considered to be the emotion that we owe only to those enduring underserved misfortune" (Sontag, 2003, p. 75). Figure 2. 1985 National Geographic cover of an Afghan girl. By Steve McCurry.
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 05 $ The powerful role of photographs to illustrate as well as corroborat e atrocities, "lay down routes of reference and serve as totems of causes" (Sontag, 2003, p. 85). This trumps verbal slogans time and time again. Sontag also suggests that, "making suffering loom larger, by globalizing it, may spur people to feel they ought to care' more" (Sontag, 2003, p. 79). Present day advertising often uses images to communicate horror and mobilize action in public awareness and advocacy campaigns. # StopTheNightmare is series of compelling Public Service Announcemen t s that depart from traditional models that focus on the power of voiceover to arouse and call viewers to action. Instead, they rely solely on nightmarish imagery to implicate the horrors of human traf ficking and sex slavery. It has been identified as particula rly innovative and powerful because of its reliance on imagery to both depict and communicate message (Oster, 2014) Visual Culture and Imagery in Feminist Disco urse Many theo ris ts such as Andrea Dworkin and Catharine MacKinnon have studied the role of po rnography in objectification, s pecifically the implications on visual culture, on violence against women, domestic violence, sex trafficking and other feminist issues. Our current culture of objectification has been created and nurtured through visual im agery ranging from historical depictions of women in subversive circumstances through artistic renderings, media and advertising's sexualization of women and girls and cultural acceptanc e and tolerance for pornography. Adam Myers (2011) in his paper The Objectification of Women as a Facilitator of Sex Trafficking Demand, concludes that objectification through repeated viewing of sexualized or pornographic imagery of women leads directly to depersonalization and its accompanying denial of human consid erations or concern towards women in the mind of the viewe r, whether the viewer is male or female.
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 06 $ Sontag compares and contrasts the role of the camera in objectification by pointing out that "beautifying" tends to bleach out a moral response to what is shown while the process of "uglifying" a subject invites an active re s ponse (Sontag, 2003). This is an area that begs additional study and consideration In final analysis of the literature reviewed on objectification and commodification of women, it be comes apparent that the process of transformation of women and girls into an acceptably traded commodity both by themselves and by the user or trafficker is important in defining and understanding human trafficking and the role of visual imagery and cultur e. This is especially pertinent to our present day obsession with "selfies" and the issue of over exposure. Does the urge to compulsively express oneself via social media actually contribute to a culture of misplaced attribution and value? Psychological Aspects of Observation of Human Suffering Susan Sontag (2003) explores the mysteries of vicarious pain and its purpose in her book, "Regarding the Pain of Others." Sontag d iscusses the complexities involved through examination of the role s hocking photographic visual imagery plays in capturing empathy and compassion of the masses. "photographs are a means of making real' (or "more real') matters that the privileged and the merely safe might prefer to ignore" (Sontag, 2003, p. 7). She pu r ports that the shock of images of human suffering cannot fail to unite people of good will through the shared experience of witnessing such atrocities of war and other human rights violations. The resulting outrage often gives rise to opposing responses s uch as a global call for action or sometimes, "a bemused awarenessthat terrible things happen" (Sontag, 2003, p.13). The role of human memory is explored in Sontag's book with the power of visual imagery taking
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 07 $ center stage in the process of remembering "To remember is, more and more, not to recall a story but to be able to call up a picture" (Sontag, 2003, p. 89). Methodology Three forms of quali tative research were engage d for this project: Arts Based Educational Research, A/r/tography and Ethnogra phy. Art processes were used for collecting data, for analyzing it, and for presenting findings. The artworks were developed while collecting d ata and during data analysis. The images form a body of work that will be available for public exhibition at s elected academic institutions with an active anti human trafficking presence ( see Appendix B) I choose to represent m y data as both artwork and written text in order to bring together multiple viewing positions (Glass 2008 ) and attribute appropriate dept h to participant experiences. As both r esearcher and subject I participate d in an "ongoing process of artmakingand writing not separate or illustrative of each other but interconnected and woven through each other to create additional and/or enhance d meanings" (Knowles & Cole, 2008, p. 8). Subjects I was the primar y subject of this study using art processes to collect, process and re present data. Additionally, critical conversations were undertaken with professionals in key fields to augment a n d support my personal research ( s ee Appendix A) Research Site My research site consist ed primarily of my personal art studio Conversations with experts in the field of the arts, advocacy, non profit, law and psychology took place in person in Topeka and Lawrence, Kansas, and by telephone
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 08 $ Data Collection Procedures and Instrumentation In this study, active analysis o f visual processes was done using both created images and written text/results of critical conversations and interviews with survivors and experts in the field of anti hu man trafficking. Outcomes include increased understanding of the contributing factors that foster personal transformation that can inspire social change First, I explore d the history of visual rhetoric in social justice movements through visual ethnographic methods using both written text as well as visual images. The arts can be a powerful pathelevating and amplifying the voices of those most affected by injustice (LaMarche, 2010.) Second, I examine d the role of visual art and culture in ancillary issues affecting sex trafficking and other atrocities. Applicability of these tactics to the "bystander effect" and other psycho social processes were considered. Do not underestimate the power of art to transmute minds and souls. We have n ever before had a platform as large nor connective as the world wide web that can pass insight so efficiently (Stanfield, 2013.) According to Beit Hallahmi (1983), "the major function of art has been considered, since the days of Aristotle, that of catharsis, i.e. the production of a (vicarious) emotional experience, through the arousal and ventilation of strong emotion" (p. 238). Humans are constantly searching for cathartic experiences. Third, I create d a body of a rtwork consisting of sketches, collage and paintings that reflect reaction to human trafficking and its' ancillary issues such as freedom, oppression, repression, villainy, power, fear and safety through personal reflection and expressive art te chniques. A/r/tography was used to explore questions that, "engage emotional, intuitive, personal, spiritual, and embodied ways of knowing" (Springgay et al, p. 902.)
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 19 $ Fourth, I augment ed my personal research with "views from the field" about the potential role of the visual arts and culture in anti human trafficking prevention efforts through a series of interviews with experts. Data Analysis Procedures Data was examined using many interpr etations to find linkages between the subject and outcome with reference to the original research questions (Soy, 1997). Using the arts and aesthetic experiences both in the research and presentation of data is an important part of discovering and understanding multiple perspective s (Given, 2008.) Exploration of the issue of human trafficking occur r ed through analysis of visual and textual means using A/r/tography focusing on reflective inquiry to closely examine aspects of meaning. Thorough investigation of how arts and visual images can catal yze processes of change were con sidered and have been represented both in written and visual form. The process of analysis was congruent with the process of data collection. Findings The goal of my research was to uncover linkages between art, visual culture, and identity and examine their potential role in the transforma tive journey to action. T here are many opportunities to witness human suffering on a daily basis in our society But I wonder, w hat elements need to be present to forge a meaningful personal conne ction and inspire s ome sort of action or advocacy? The Psychology of Oppression Objectification and commodification are he avy words that imply entitlement, control and oppression. I explored these outcomes with experts in the mental health and social services field to fully understand the pathological roots of how they are manifested and frequently acted upon
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 10 $ to impose suffering on others I also queried the potential role of visual culture in this cycle of dysfunction. Steve Halley, a social worker who works wit h male domestic batter ers in group therapy suggested that objectification and the commo dification of women are symptom s of deeper is sues men hold. Vi sual culture through the proliferation of sexualized imagery and disem powerment skillfully reinforce this on a regular basis These issues are typically the result of cruelty or childhood trauma that remains unprocessed or unresolved leading men to "give it away" in the form of violence or cruelty upon another (S. Halley, interview, March 14 2014) He underscored this by explaining that this p henomenon often leads to "stolen empathy" which as a result leads men to see women as objects or means of another's pleasure depersonalized and dehumanized. This breakdown can result in many forms of dysfunction including domestic violence, intimate partner violence and behaviors involved in human trafficking. When the conversation shifted to preventive efforts, art and visual imagery were suggested as powerful tools in the education and treatment of perpetrator s of this kind of v ictimization St eve's wife and colleague, Dorthy Stucky Halley, LMSW, added that the key to affecting social change is at the experiential level According to Halley, this involves vis ual memories and associations which can be very powerful and help with both message deliver y and message impact when working with perpetrators (D. Halley, interview, March 14 2014) Art as a Mirror The role of art as a mirror can be explored both on a societal level and on a personal more intimate level. I approached this concept from the standpoint of the two being inherently intertwined. That is, in order for individuals to understand art's role as a reflection and conduit
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 11 $ on a so cietal level one must first use art to re flect and cultivate personal connection to a n issue or topic This can be a revealing and sometimes painful exercise. I used two processes for doing this: One was the compilation of anecdotal information gained from conversations with survivors of human traff icking, legal case reviews, various professional materials and other creative outlets depicting the realities of human trafficking. Th ese were studied and used to inform my creative practice. The second was more complicated and more personal and invo lved a focused word association with themes of human trafficking on paper ( See Figure 2 ) that ultimately led to an in depth personal excavation and exploration of the theme of sexual exploitation through watercolor, ink, and acrylic mediums. I began with a "scratching process" (Tharp 2003 ) where I used experiences gained through my professional work to provide inspiration for sketches that illustrated personal thoughts and feelings about the issues involved in human trafficking. That pa rt of my creative process lasted several weeks. Figure 3 +'' Focused word search.
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 12 $ Various t hemes emerged from this initial process that informed my final work including: danger, fear, vulnerability, exposure, and resilience The se themes evolved from both my professional experience with human trafficking victims and personal issues resurfacing from my own childhood and young adulthood that dealt with identity and objectification. This opportunity to uncover personal feelings and connections to the themes involved with human trafficking allowed me to get closer to the issue and understand the deep complexities involved. While not a survivor of human trafficking, I was able to understand the issues involved and make associations as a woman and as a mother of a teenage daughter. This led to the creation of a s eries of wate rcolor images us ing a bruise as a metaphor to represent t he layers of injur y involved in human trafficking ( s ee Appendix A) The y evolved from my initial scratching period where I weeded out other more obvious and clichÂŽ ideas. The g oal of my work is to be thought provok ing; i nviting viewers to explore p ersonal connections through feelings evoked by the act of viewing the work I hope this helps foster a gr eater understanding and motivation to learn more about the complexities of human trafficking This exercise was a distinctly different process for me as an artist and took me out of my comfort zone for several reasons. Besides the difficult subject matter, the in troduction of unfamiliar media tools and processes such as sket ching and watercolor proved challenging Usually I use oil and acrylic paint on various surfaces so using new mediums forced me to stretch my self and surrender the predictability and control that comes with the familiar and comfortable I chose to use watercolor to illustrate the layers and complexity of human trafficking as well as the loss of control which is common to both being trafficked and t he application of watercolor to surface. Additionally, the conception of ideas was the most radical change for me as an artist. Typically, I begi n a work by engaging in a creative process and the
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 13 $ meaning emerges through this process This project led me to both find meanings first thr ough intentionality and also allow the residue of exploring the emotional subject matter to drive creative output. This transfer of power and control from the process (subconscious) to my own mind (conscious) proved somewhat pressurized and uncomfortable for me. Engagement and Public Awareness The use of v isual imagery as a communications tool can be a powerful way to engage and mobilize for a cause. "The arts have a unique capacity to raise awareness, build bigger constituencies for social justice and meet people where they are. The arts are also participatory, engaging affected communities directly in advocating f or themselves" (LaMarche, 2010, para 4). I interviewed several professionals working in the social justice field and asked what role visual art and imagery plays in the work they do Two women from academia spoke about the power art holds to make a sta tement and reach a broad audience. Sharon Sullivan, a gender studies professor at Washburn University and leader of an anti slavery coalition, observed that all art is political, you're either with the status quo or against it (S Sullivan, interview, M arch 12, 2014). Laura Dean a PhD student studying human trafficking in Eastern European countries noted that art can insert compassion into the examination of human trafficking issues. She also pointed out that art hits a different audience which can expand the reach of social justice issues outside of typical audiences (L. Dean, interview, March 11, 2014) Margeaux Gray a survivor and anti human trafficking advocate pointed out that, "art is a different neural pathwayto see things from a different perspective" (M. Gray, interview, March 9, 2014). She added that v isual learning is another tool we can use to raise awareness and educate children and adults. She cautioned, however, about the dangers of misinformation and
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 14 $ re exploitation of v ictims through inaccurate or sensationalized portrayals Art can give voice to victims. A lot of people can see themselves in th e art it creates a connectio n" (M. Gray, interview, March 12 2014). Nola Theiss runs a program in south Florida for te ens b ased on empowerment, education and awareness of human trafficking. Her program create s peer educators through art. I asked about the nature of the artwork produced and learned that the younger the child, the more representational the artwork was. A s children get older she said the artwork becomes more abstract, more "emblematic ( See Figure 3 ) The key to using art to communicate and empower kids is the abili ty to "meet them where they are (N. Theiss, March 19 2014). The ARTREACH program t each es the power to change through ar t. They focus on children ages 10 18 but she said the target group where the most im pact has been seen is with children between 12 and 15 ye ars old the target age group for recruitment by pimps and traffickers. Figure 4. ARTREACH slide show screen shot. '
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 15 $ Crystal Freed an attorney and social activist explained that a rt can transmit meaning in a unique way that words canno t. She shared the types of exhibits an d opportunities she initiated during a public awareness campaign in Jacksonville, Florida, in January and February of 2014. As the architect of this campaign, she was able to use art and visual imagery on a multitude of levels to create connec tion. These offerings included visual arts display s with accompanying auditory r ecordings of survivor stories an actual simulation of a labor trafficking situation which inc luded l ocal actors serving as catalysts topical lectures from national experts, and theatrical performances at area universities She identified the strategic placement of these offe rings as key in achieving maximum impact. Summary Across All Findings Interview results supp orted my own personal research through my artmaking process for this project ther e is a strong link between self awareness, tapping into personal experiential data, and connection to social justice issues. The theme of self awareness and the importance of personal experience cropped up in almost every interview I conducted with subjects and obviou sly wa s inherent in my own personal research. Throug h a l engthy interview with a Crystal Freed I explored a connection I had made through my own artwork. We discussed the need to make social issues such as human trafficking resonate with people on a personal level in order for them to be i nspired to act. Art can draw people in on this level by tapping into an individual's self awa reness and start a discussion but as she astutely pointed out in order to be effective with such sensitive issues, art has to "meet people where they are on t he awareness spectrum (C. Freed, March 18 2014). This observa tion was also echoed by Nola Th e i ss in her comments about impact and engagement with children on human trafficking related issues.
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 16 $ Discussion and Conclusion Discussion and Interpretation of Findings "The role of art within society is complex, predominately due to the many functions it serves, and through its very existence as a creative process" (Parkes, 2013 ). What is clear is that there is sufficient evidence among current scholarly re search to merit serious consideration of the implications of visual imagery through art making and media dissemination on creating and facilitating the tolerance and demand for sex trafficking. This is not a new phenomena but one that needs special attention and consideration of our digital age and advanced technology that depends on delivery of visual imagery for messaging, personal pleasure, and potentially nefarious purposes. Artists, like William Hogarth in his early depiction of slavery call for the audience to, "find a sense of t heir moral obligation" (Parkes, 2013 ). Sometimes this requires us to tap into our own personal journeys which can be difficult but rewarding. Successful personal excavation can lead to confident compassion and an enhanced ability to deal with other people's pain The b ottom line is that the key to the connection between visual imagery and social causes, action etc. is self awareness. That predicts a person's motivation and a bility to connect and potentially act. Furthermore, s ocial justic e is linked to self reflection as Tyler & Smith (1995) point out, "p eople's actual behavior is (also) strongly linked to views about justice and injustice justice is connected to people's feelings about the status of their group and within that group their social standing, their self worth, and their self concept" ( p. 3). As prev iously noted, t hrough this research my p ersonal artmaking process was challenged and re arranged. This r equired me to push boundaries, move boundar ies and change things around. It also r equired a major leap of faith which has resulted in lingering uncert ainty
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 17 $ about some of the work I created a questioning of a uthentic ity bas ed on the both the vantage point and the process employed. While uncomfortable, it allowed me to grow as an artist. Artists, "not only document social change; they promote, inform, and shape it" (Martinez as reported in David and McCaughan, 2007, p. 1). Significance, Implications, and Recommendations Case studies present data in very publicly accessible ways and ca n lead participants to apply the experience in his or her own real life situation (Soy, 1997). By examining visual art and visual culture's role in some of the underlying issues associated with huma n trafficking, we are able to understand history as well as forge new ground As these types of issues are identified and understood through the chosen lens of visual imagery, what are the next steps? And is there any knowledge gained from this analysis that can be applied directly to anti human trafficking e fforts locally, nationally and internationally? What for m should this take through prevention efforts by addressing the larger societal issues of objectification culture, commodifi cation, prevalence of pornography in our society? This could be done through careful consideration of the, "e ncouragement of social factors and reinforcing media" (Myers, 2011, p. 60). Art can be a powerful vehicle for increasing awareness but there needs to be sensitivity to its capacity to re victimize victims through the urge to pathologize and sensationaliz e via the media and /or creative process As Rachel Lloyd expressed, "there is a level of voyeurism within the antihuman trafficking movement that does a disservice to survivor s and the movement as a whole (Lloyd, pe rsonal communication, March 19, 2014). 2 We need to see k a balance between representation and empowerment and be careful not to use visual art and imagery to $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $ 1 $ V@:
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 18 $ sensationalize by creating "tragedy porn" (Lloyd, 2014). This research has highlighted the need fo r a closer look at the sensitivities and ethical considerations i nvolved in representing others people's stories through creative expression. However shocking visual imagery can be as an invitation to pay attention, to reflect, to learn, to examine the rationalizations for m ass suffering, these images are merely sy mbolic and cannot possibly convey the full reality of what they refer to (Sontag, 2003). On a big picture level "art should not be an escape from daily events, but rather it should make visi ble the violence, chaos and hypocricies of contemporary lifeart is not an end in itselfbut an opportunity for the true perception and cr iticism of the time we livc in" (National Gallery of Art, 2006, p. 1). Conclusion According to Sidford, (2011 ) t he arts can reflect a society's customs and fortify its conventions and ideologies or they can catalyze processes of change and propel social and political movements. These movements can be for greater justice and equality and for the repr ession of human rig hts (p. 3 ). Th is research allowed me to examine the role of visual art and imagery in social justice through the lens of human trafficking as a case study from the perspective of both the r esearcher and the subject. This is valuable t o my professional w ork in p ublic awareness, outreach, and education efforts and the prevention of human trafficking It provided multiple contexts with which to consider the issue and insight and direction for establishing effective practice in the field. This project has sparked my interest in additional study about the larger role art can play in self awareness and self actualization in public awareness campaigns. The more that is learned about human trafficking, the uglier it gets. For any thinking p erson, it is impossible to face the truth of it without undergoing profound change. That's why so
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 29 $ few people are willing to even look at it. We want to believe it is something that can be solved easily and quickly. It can't. While the media treats it as a new problem, it has been around for over two hundred years. Trafficking is a disturbingly accepted part of our culture and it will take generations of understanding and focused effort to stop it. For example, shifting attitudes about men's access to women's bodies could shift the demand for sex trafficked individuals, but this requires an ideological change within society as a whole My personal artwork from this project is meant to be a departure point and strategy or tactic for viewers to look cl oser at the issue of human trafficking. My hope is that it makes awar eness of the issue more accessi ble through visual imagery My complete body of work is a vailable for viewing at: www.artandatrocities.blogspot.com and http://issuu.com/ufarted/docs/rapp_issuu_pglr Selected pieces with an accompanying narrative and description of this research project will be featured in a special exhibit at the Kansas Crime Victim's Rights Conference in May 2014 in Topeka, Kansas You may choose to look the other way but you can never say again that you did not know. William Wilberforce
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 20 $ References Barone, T., & Eisner, E. (1997). Arts based educational research. Complementary methods for research in education, 2, 75 116. Beit Hallahmi, B. (1983). Understanding religion through the psychology of art [Special issue]. Leonardo, Psychology and the Arts, 16(3), 237 240 Bult, L (2014). Ou t of Sight [Exhibit description]. Retrieved from www.leabult.com/section/293629_OUT_OF_SIGHT.html Cocke, D. (2013). Art and political power. [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://roadside.org/news/art and political power Fidel, R. (1984). The case study method: A case study. Library and Information Science Research, 6(3), 273 288. David, E. & McCaughan, E. (2007). Editor's introduction: Art, Identity, and Soci al Justice. Social Justice, 24(1), 1. Given, L.M. (2008). Arts Based Research. The SAGE Encyclopedia of Qualitative Research Methods Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications, Inc. Glass, N. (2008). Interrogating the conventional boundarie s of research methods in social sciences: The role of visual representation in ethnography. Forum: Qualitative Social Research, 9(2), Art.50. Greenwood, J. (2012). Arts based research: Weaving magic and meaning. International Journal of Education and the Arts, 13(Interlude 1). Retrieved from http://www.ijea.org/v13i1/
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 21 $ Gulzar, A. (2010) 10 things you need to know about labor tr afficking in the greater Mekong Sub region. Worldvision Retrieved from www.worldvision.or.th/doownloadfiles/10things ENG.pdf Hamman M. (2010). Visual Stories of Human Trafficking's Victims: An Essay in Words and Photographs. Retrieved from http://www.nieman.harvard.edu/reports/article/102519/Visual Stories of Human Traffickings Victims.aspx Hesford, W., & Kozo l, W. (2005). Just Advocacy. Women's Human Rights, Transnational Feminisms, and the Politics of Representation. New Brunswick, New Jersey: Rutgers Univer si ty Press. Hill, N. (2001). John Dewey, Albert Murray, and aesthetics of the blues idiom. Retri eved fro m http://americanphilosophy.org/archives/past_conference_programs/pc2001/Discussion% paper/nathan_hill.htm Kendall, S. (1986). Rethinking Regionalism, John Ste u art Curry and the Kansas Mural Controversy, The Smithsonian Institution Press. Kelly, M. (2003). Iconoclasm in Aesthetics. Boston, Massachusettes: Cambridge University Press. Knowles, G. & Cole, A. (2008). Handbook of the arts in q ual itative research: Perspectives, methodologies, examples, and i ssues. Sage Pub lications, Inc. 511 523. DOI: 10.4135/9781452226545 LaMarche (2010) Changing the story: Using the arts to advance social j ustice. The Atlantic P hilanthropies [Web site]. Downloaded from www.atlanticphilanthropies.org/currents/changing story using arts advance social justice
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 22 $ Myers, A. (2011). The Objectification of Women as a Facilitator of Sex Trafficking Demand Unpublished paper. Nelson, D. (2013). Now Open: The Re packaging of Sexual Commidification in Advertising. Unpublished paper. National Gallery of Art. (2006, February May). Dada: Zurich, Berlin, Hannover, Cologne, New York, Paris (Exhibition Guide). Washington D.C. Oster, E. (2014). Nightmarish PSAs Depict Horrors of Human Trafficking. Retrieved from http://www.mediabistro.com/agencyspy/nightmarish psas depict horrors of human trafficking_b62440 Parkes, C. (2013). Art as Representation of Re sistance. Retrieved from www.scholar.library.miami.edu/slaves/representations/Individual_art_essays/carolines.h m Samuels, M. ( 2013). Art and h ealing. How art heals [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.artashealing.org/main/?page_id=10 Sidford, H. (2011). Fusing Arts, Cultur e and Social Change. Washington, DC: National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy P. 8. Smith, K. (2005). Handbook of visual communication research: Theory, methods, and media Mahwah, N.J: L. Erlbaum. Sontag, S. (2003). Regarding the Pain of Others New York, New York: Picador. Soy, S. (19 97). The case study as a research method. Unpublished paper. University of Texas at Austin.
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 23 $ Springgay, S., Irwin, R., & Kind, S.W. (2005). A/r/tography as Living Inquiry Through Art and Text. Qualitative Inquiry, 11 (6), 897 912. Stanfield G. (2013) The bystander effect: Challenging racism. [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.gerriravynstanfield.wordpress.com/2013/08/05the bysta nder effect challenging racism/ Tharp, T. (2003). The Creative Habit: Learn It and Use It for Life. New York, New York: Simon and Schuster. Trotsky, L. (1925 ). Literature and Revolution. Haymarket Books. Yallop, J. J., Lopez de Va llejo, I., & Wright, P. (2008). Editorial: Overview of the performative social science special issue. In Forum Qua litative Sozialforschung/Forum: Qualitative Social Research (Vol. 9, No. 2). Tyler, Tom R.; & Smith, Heather J. (1995). Social J ustice and Social Movements. UC Berkeley: Institute for Research on Labor and Employment. Retrieved from: https://www.escholarship.org/uc/item/54d3j035
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 24 $ Appendix A
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 25 $
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 26 $
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 27 $ Appendix B List of Interviewees Laura Dea n is a candidate for a Ph.D. in Political Science at the University of Kansas (2014) and has a Graduate Certificate in Women, Gender, and Sexuality Studies (2013) and a Master of Arts in Political Science (2011) from the University of Kansas, a Master of Arts in International Studies focusing on Russian, East European, and Central Asian Studies (2006) from the University of Washington, and a Bachelor of Arts in World Politics (2003) from the University of Wisconsin Eau Claire. Laura w as also awarded a Fulbright Research Fellowship in 2007 to Latvia where she examined the exploitation of women, focusing on sex tourism and trafficking Crystal Free d is an attorney in Jacksonville, Florida. In 2013, Crystal decided to use the arts as a platform to educate the public on modern day slavery. While serving as the co Chair of the Northeast Florida Human Trafficking Task Force, Crystal organized Jacksonville's first city wide human trafficking awareness campaign She frequently speaks on t he issue of human trafficking and has also planned and organized legal education seminars for attorneys In 2012, Crystal was appointed to the Jacksonville Human Rights Commission where she serves on its Community Relations Committee. She also serves as the co Chair of the Jacksonville Bar Association's Human Rights Section Margeaux Gray is a survivor of child sex trafficking from Louisville, Kentucky She is an independent anti human trafficking activist, policy advocate, public speaker, and artist. Margeaux uses her voice and art to educate, inspire, and empower others. She uses found objects to create tactile works through the restoration of trash and uses this as a metaphor for telling her personal story. Accompanied by her guide dog due to sight loss acquired during her
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 2 8 $ victimization, s he recently provided compelling testi mony at a Congressional briefing on combating modern slavery. Steve Halley is a Licensed Clinical Social Worker and has been in private practice for over ten years. He has developed specialized skills in working with teenagers, troubled relationships, and with those who use violence and abuse in relationships Steve currently leads Batterer Intervention Programs at the YMCA Center for Safety and Empowerment in Topeka, Kansa s, and is an expert in connection theory and has also worked with the court system as a probation officer. Dorthy Stucky Halley LMSW, has been Director of the Victim Services Division of the Office of the Kansa Attorney General sin ce 2007. Halley served as Coordinator of the Attorney General's Human Trafficking Advisory Board, and continues to serve on the Board and chair the Victim Services Committee. Halley was the Practicum Director and Assistant Professor at Pittsburg State University in the S ocial Work Program from 1997 to 2007, before accepting her current position. She is the past president of the Kansas Chapter of the National Association of Social Workers, the Kansas Coalition Against Sexual and Domestic Violence, and the Kansas Organizati on for Victim Assistance. Sharon Sullivan PhD is an associate professor of Theatre at Washburn University in Top eka, Kansas. She is also the founder of STARS, Stop Trafficking and Reject Slavery, an educational group dedicating to bringing awareness to the issue of modern day slavery. Sharon was chosen as a delegate to the 57 th United Nations Commission on the Status of Women in 2013.
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 39 $ Nola Theiss is the Executive Director of Human Trafficking Awareness Partnerships which is an organization located in Lee C ounty, Florida, that has created a model program called ARTREACH ARTREACH is an interactive creative arts program designed to instill a sense of awareness of human trafficking in our community's boys and girls and to empower them to become peer spo kespersons
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 30 $ List of Figures Figure 1 "Tragic Prelude," by John Steuart Curry.14 Figure 2 1985 National Geographic cover of an Afghan girl.15 Figure 3 Focused word search23 Figure 4. ARTREACH slide show screen shot26
!"#$!%$!$&'""("$)("$%(*'!+$*,!-./ $ $ 31 $ Author Biography Jennifer Rapp is currently the Deputy Director of the Anti Human Trafficking Unit in the office of the Kansas Attorney General. In addition, she is a professional artist and previously served as the Arts in Medicine c oordinator for the development, design and implementation of arts programs in 3 hospitals that are pa rt of a large non profit health system in the Florida panhandle Prior to this, she was a Congressional staffer for healthcare and judicial policy in Washington D.C. After living abroad for several years she moved to Jacksonville, Florida, in 2001, and volunteered as an arts educator in the St. John's County public sch ool system. A fourth generation Kansan, Jennifer comes from a family of artists and professional musicians. She earned her B.A. in Communication Studies from the University of Kansas and is currently a Master's Degree candidate at the University of Flor ida. She decided to pursue a Master's Degree in Art Education in order to meld her professional background in the non profit and public policy arena volunteer work as an art educato r and experience as a working and exhibiting artist. She believes her graduate program is a perfect synthesis of her over 20 years of work experience in advocacy and public policy passion for the arts, creative talents, and desire to make the world a more compassionate and beautiful place. More about Jennifer and her artwork can be seen at : www.jenniferrappcontemporaryart.weebly.com $ and www.artand atrocities.blogspot.com