Preservation conversation : exploring historic preservation processes in Florida

Presentation to Evaluators.pdf

presentation.pptx

presentation.pdf

Austin Bell

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^Renee Kiefer^^^^^^^^^







0 0
1 listoric
0 0
preservation differs
le
among sites,,








Historic Preservation


Mision Son Luis de Apalachee
Tallhassee, FL


M


Govamment
House
St. Augustine.
FL


Gamble Mansion
Efenton, FL


























mhw Prosm Oonwrveri
nprufbtk~rdf
Frgu kfladd











H 10 0
istoric Preservation Worlespace













U ''.1
1 1 4 1 lilm i I i 1
will,
i4i
UL P 1; ,
T1
;I:
411 11 i: I I I .1 -10 !

j It,
"141T ',;y
11 41

'Ij;jflpj- fill
ji

IT
Architectural drafting table Pencil, protractor, line level
Rolled blueprints Book
Photographs Herschel Shepard photo and bio






























,* +*.*









'L'I
-- Nip.~'A~*huin

- FfQ~U I1C8 U
U F .










Mission San Luis de Apalachee


Reconstruction
KGC out RAiluou


Onm f e kmgest iaMIc
Indian dnKdhmu hn
Suthmawd, i1 Apalachw
Councl Howv ws o-m
bnpofun community crde
tor bolths Ipolnuh and
NSotv Amtfcm inhaobalmb
fl MIanllS n SmL In iOs M
Ceuriy. MA e Mluln slan R
wa tkuavsn y burn down hI
no*iW MI for fie biv dlb
Oltie ftond For hiunmaLe of
yaW. lh onPy e lence of ts
etuice Wy hdden unwr
Ihe rM g hM cd what we now
kinw ai Ta hnoie.
In IIS. archaeeIsoim as
Mha r Sa Luk begw
urmWarrng tie clmand
ure"iPLtfl m ched
"ftcqlprit" l oh Councm
Houe. IdMWCifl uKoh
Iwolures pmuthumos nmudg.
pfh and a canIdl hiarft
tiadki pml.armlo s used
m anrclhawm n cl dcuk
comblad with hiodca
*Ilmmu h oid cionpmdul
imilyi ol ezftg dsuchwL
b ll t Sauimad mand I
ContDbear, Io raeHuM Whe
bmmal HOus Es a wMold
have appenud owS 300
Im1 i.


d mpal a p a past wern by
pledng togetw evidence or lacie
what ffgt hwe taen pla-


The Apalachee
Council Huma


S


Constuadon


W O ,o ncprtl.lapb
;',. ^ ---












n Sns


:4












iweK/- CLWC/L A*L~




-- "--*1--~-


. .- -_
I.;


vilorrl
'~'~'~. r-~~T.-~ilL
'
I- -.I
---.-..~-.I,
~~ 7?1 ------
iui


7-LDCk I COUAC.IL iHOOJ
















........4 ..


M 0
issionSan LulYs d e Apa~lache





0//// IM


tnIII
























































- -r

Pho to Cluter

















I, r










































aU









Government House


Adaptive Use
W limgA wpg


asiigns a new use to a historic
propwy wNhe prsenrvng oginal
potonm or features lhat convey t
structure hilolfcaL cuwluil, or
arct*eclural values


,Gcewir thaewg(,'
Throughout its isory, Governmnt House has served many
purposes. In the 19lOs, the drecison wca made to again
repurpose the de. Many rooms were conp ltely s~rpped and
given new uses. or example, the ftomer mdboom, which had
more recently served as an aum ortunm, was turnd into a space
that would become a museum in 1991.


In 2007, FlMada's Sale Le&ilalure transferred management of
Govenment House to hse Unhwlery af FPloda.














w


r I- *wl.I.
~C~L ly.. ""*2;;:i~"S


4.;rr;;


SW'~;; .~F Eili 1C
4 a~~i ~EI.~ .


V IU


.I
. L v


-A ......

~Y~;~;- and4


.rr ;;.
-US*vw


:i ,


tw


















28


tE


Governmnt Hous





















































































-- -Cl-r -- q -


4 .. ~in I


~


......


I.


















28


tE


Governmnt Hous











Swate Owned Buldngs
ag sw o Ownmd POpens


FUcM- PlmnMg & Consrucown
UJF nciiuAo, ....








u^i1P %P Bi
6fc v5o M
VKs~il kk^C







Iw^^ sllVs -- -"


















28


tE


Governmnt Hous

































Mw Promr ilr*d Conv
iwkrfthtm
UW













Restoration
uRpovnnoftr0


Gamble Mansion


relurmn a buldlng to ttt condlon at a
spectlc tme pedod


Ln tha 1A4o Ma
lobrt Gamble, Jr.
edueswhd a wgm
piantld on the
GamMb MalAitn Os.
AtXcsW I was onc
pwoducesn ct tugr mn
FRrda. the pnlanlaon
was abdandoKd and
mglected by e *arly
19M1.


Afmr Hwas acquired
by twe Slate of Frdda
Ih Ihe 1920. he
Man on undm wnt a
ubtmanld redBralrl
procus I reurn ihe
btiHc g l th
cmndlan and
appearance during Is
haydayln the 184
and 1850N


ril



















a


S


Th Gmbe anio
Retoato





























I--


-s fl~I



1


Cr-r"--

1~ r
11' I- Ir





























*. 1 I I M



- .*La '--. .,| .1 -1 o ..1. I


*~~ -*.. ,


*L -, -. .L j' '~ L


CI I. .


-- I -..
















a


S


Th Gmbe anio
Retoato








Which Place, Which Process?
RCrt'- 'a. J.. Ires.Di"s.'i.1 K lion nd idJ ay.iv. yse1 dFr Itf'' U o the Tia; cQ-'n.I ni .yp.I. 0 .i ar .
.eRstcz id!.Lir rie,' !v ior :j .ney f re *id. P'iu ; l.Qe isiv L M E. T' [r e iV At& LIU --OsLtiJ ;1- poL' M I
T,'ie UP sers.j. n L- .r*- ` jf r.V i WA'L VX' to LL e.e Ihe ..Jr i t LdaL-ei L t I '. re
resr tL I* pI.'U tM i ver a I'i harr. ie L'.' ''& -d r oe y'ea "d WOreOp JcU V a. e Lu
Ci"eist di' .iU J'Jn' "ex tl o da Qw ow -cng in I Ce Ctld Y itnlFR c iTL. i'ot'dd. L '1- 1 i-
w* i prC e:' iu'- us i z i w L lin er ? A'eu r v eNir C l Ie eTi' LJt dY E-e '. 'rcI- -L "k .a 1 7
te"dI 'Dr il and L.Ca'Mpl e lite d iV L t Uw.





Exhi^ I lo Mterias Prvide
^^^" Introductory panel^^^^^
^^^"NuObject checklist^^^^
^^^" Object labels^^^
^^" Key images^^^^^^^^^^
^^*^^" Layout^^^^^^^^^
^^l" Press release^^^^^^
^^" Brochure^^^^^

































+ .I r c.
.-, ~in~u

PAGE 1

Austin Bell Renee Kiefer Kim Tinnell April 18, 2011

PAGE 2

Historic preservation differs among sites.

PAGE 5

engages the past in a conversation with the present William Murtagh first Keeper of the National Register for Historic Places What does historic preservation do? How does the Importance of the Herschel Shepard Collection Introduction to the exhibition

PAGE 6

Architectural drafting table Pencil, protractor, line level Rolled blueprints Book Photographs Herschel Shepard photo and bio

PAGE 7

The Apalachee Council House

PAGE 10

Council House: 8Le4 Excavation Block 1, Spring Feature Profiles Archaeological profile of Council House post molds Author unknown Facsimile of handwritten drawing Circa 1985 8 x 11 inches Computer rendering of proposed Council House layout Author unknown Date unknown 5 x 7 inches Archaeological site plan for Council House Author unknown Facsimile of computer printout with handwritten notes Circa 1985 11 x 8 inches Case 1 Grouping

PAGE 12

Interior view of application of palm frond thatched roof to Council House Photographer unknown Photographic print, reproduction from Date unknown 6 x 4 inches Exterior view (from ground) of construction of Council House with scaffolding Photographer unknown Photographic print, reproduction from Date unknown 6 x 4 inches Council House under construction, view from interior before installation of benches Photographer unknown Photographic print Date unknown 6 x 4 inches Council House under construction, view from interior of two men in cherry picker Photographer unknown Photographic print Date unknown 6 x 4 inches Exterior view of Council House during application of roof thatching Photographer unknown Date unknown 5 x 7 inches Case 2 Photo Cluster 1

PAGE 13

Fire alarm and exit sign on interior of entrance to Council House Austin Bell Photographic print February 2011 4 x 6 inche s Lighting and sprinkler systems along interior roof of Council House Austin Bell Photographic print February 2011 4 x 6 inches Concrete support anchors at the base of the peripheral post holes of Council House Austin Bell Photographic print February 2011 4 x 6 inches Crossbeam support along interior roof of Council House Austin Bell Photographic print February 2011 4 x 6 inches Panoramic view of Council House interior Austin Bell Photographic print February 2011 5 x 7 inches Case 2 Photo Cluster 2

PAGE 16

Artist unknown Photographic reproduction Reproduced in 2002 with permission from Elsbeth Gordon 9 x 13 inches

PAGE 18

Renovations to Government House, Interior Elevations Shepard and Associates, Inc. Architectural drawing June 27, 1988 Sheet A5 24 x 36 inches

PAGE 20

St. Augustine Historic District State Properties and Structures University of Florida Poster 2008 16 x 11.8 inches

PAGE 24

Gamble Mansion west side elevation Historic American Buildings Survey Blueprint June 22, 1935 Sheet 3 of 10 18 x 24 inches

PAGE 26

prepared for the Florida Department of State, Division of Archives, History and Records Management Herschel Shepard Fisher & Shepard Architects & Planners, Inc. Thirty three page typeset report June 21, 1974 11 x 18 inches

PAGE 27

Letter to Herschel Shepard from Florida Department of Natural Resources Two page typeset letter November 17, 1977 11 x 18 inches

PAGE 30

Introductory panel Object checklist Object labels Key images Layout Press release Brochure CD



PAGE 1

Austin Bell Renee Kiefer Kim Tinnell April 18, 2011

PAGE 2

Historic preservation differs among sites.

PAGE 5

“It has been said that, at its best, preservation engages the past in a conversation with the present over a mutual concern for the future.” William Murtagh, first Keeper of the National Register for Historic PlacesWhat does historic preservation do? How does the “conversation”change from site to site?Importance of the Herschel Shepard CollectionIntroduction to the exhibition

PAGE 6

Architectural drafting tablePencil, protractor, line level Rolled blueprintsBook PhotographsHerschel Shepard photo and bio

PAGE 7

The Apalachee Council House

PAGE 10

“Block 1 –Council House: 8Le4 Excavation Block 1, Spring ’85 Post & Feature Profiles” Archaeological profile of Council House post molds Author unknown Facsimile of handwritten drawing Circa 1985 8 x 11 inches Computer rendering of proposed Council House layout Author unknown Photographic print, reproduction from slide (2x2”) Date unknown 5 x 7 inches“Block 1 –Council House” Archaeological site plan for Council House Author unknown Facsimile of computer printout with handwritten notes Circa 1985 11 x 8 inchesCase 1 Grouping

PAGE 12

Interior view of application of palm frond thatched roof to Council House Photographer unknown Photographic print, reproduction from slide (2x2”) Date unknown 6 x 4 inches Exterior view (from ground) of construction of Council House with scaffolding Photographer unknown Photographic print, reproduction from slide (2x2”) Date unknown 6 x 4 inches Council House under construction, view from interior before installation of benches Photographer unknown Photographic print Date unknown 6 x 4 inches Council House under construction, view from interior of two men in cherry picker Photographer unknown Photographic print Date unknown 6 x 4 inches Exterior view of Council House during application of roof thatching Photographer unknown Photographic print, reproduction from slide (2x2”) Date unknown 5 x 7 inches

PAGE 13

Fire alarm and exit sign on interior of entrance to Council House Austin Bell Photographic print February 2011 4 x 6 inche s Lighting and sprinkler systems along interior roof of Council House Austin Bell Photographic print February 2011 4 x 6 inches Concrete support anchors at the base of the peripheral post holes of Council House Austin Bell Photographic print February 2011 4 x 6 inches Crossbeam support along interior roof of Council House Austin Bell Photographic print February 2011 4 x 6 inches Panoramic view of Council House interior Austin Bell Photographic print February 2011 5 x 7 inchesCase 2 Photo Cluster 2

PAGE 16

View of the GovernorÂ’s House at St. Augustine, in E. Florida, November 1764 Artist unknown Photographic reproduction Reproduced in 2002 with permission from Elsbeth Gordon 9 x 13 inches

PAGE 18

Renovations to Government House, Interior Elevations Shepard and Associates, Inc. Architectural drawing June 27, 1988 Sheet A5 24 x 36 inches

PAGE 20

St. Augustine Historic District State Properties and Structures University of Florida Poster 2008 16 x 11.8 inches

PAGE 24

Gamble Mansion west side elevation Historic American Buildings Survey Blueprint June 22, 1935 Sheet 3 of 10 18 x 24 inches

PAGE 26

“The Gamble Mansion: A Report”, prepared for the Florida Department of State, Division of Archives, History and Records Management Herschel Shepard, Fisher & Shepard, Architects & Planners, Inc. Thirty three page typeset report June 21, 1974 11 x 18 inches

PAGE 27

Letter to Herschel Shepard, from Florida Department of Natural Resources Two page typeset letter November 17, 1977 11 x 18 inches

PAGE 30

Introductory panelObject checklistObject labelsKey imagesLayoutPress releaseBrochureCD