Title: Man-Made Wetlands Concern Manasota 88
Full Citation
Permanent Link: http://ufdc.ufl.edu/WL00000788/00001
 Material Information
Title: Man-Made Wetlands Concern Manasota 88
Physical Description: Book
Language: English
Publisher: The Bradenton Herald
Spatial Coverage: North America -- United States of America -- Florida
Abstract: The Bradenton Herald Article October 20, 1986
General Note: Box 7, Folder 2 ( Vail Conference 1987 - 1987 ), Item 64
Funding: Digitized by the Legal Technology Institute in the Levin College of Law at the University of Florida.
 Record Information
Bibliographic ID: WL00000788
Volume ID: VID00001
Source Institution: Levin College of Law, University of Florida
Holding Location: Levin College of Law, University of Florida
Rights Management: All rights reserved by the source institution and holding location.

Full Text

Man-made wetlands

The Bradenton Herald, Monday, October 20, 1986

concern Manasota 88

Herald Staff Writer
Environmentalists are con-
cerned that the state's consider-
ation of developers' plans to
recreate wetlands to compensate
for ones they fill in will lead to
approval of more fill permits for
salt marshes and other wetlands.
A case in point is the Depart-
ment of Environmental Regula-
tion's initial decision to approve a
permit that would have allowed
developer Wilbur Boyd to fill in 17
acres of wetlands for a golf course
at his Riverbay project in North-
west Bradenton.
Manasota 88, an influential en-
vironmental group, appealed the
ruling to a state administrative
hearing officer, who probably
won't issue a ruling on the matter
for several weeks.
DER's initial approval of Boyd's
permit request was due in part to
his promise to create a 1V-acre
artificial salt marsh to replace
some of the wetlands he fills in,
said Anthony Cleveland, a DER
Under the 1984 Henderson Wet-
lands Act, mitigation plans have to
be considered by DER when it
looks at requests to fill in wet-
lands, Cleveland said.
DER's consideration of mitiga-
tion in permit decisions has an-
gered environmentalist who argue
that it doesn't work in most cases.
No one has ever tried to recreate
a salt marsh in Florida, said
Manasota 88 Chairwoman Gloria
By granting fill permits to devel-
opers who have offered to create
some artificial wetlands, DER is
risking the loss of valuable marine
habitats with no guarantee that
they will ever be replaced, Rains
Wetlands are important breed-
ing and feeding grounds for fish
and wading birds.
A study of wetlands in the Tam-
pa Bay region, including the north

part of the county, showed that a
large percentage of wetlands had
been lost. The study was conduct-
ed in 1980 by Robin Lewis, presi-
dent of Mangrove Systems Inc., a
Tampa firm that specializes in
recreating wetlands.
That study showed that 81 per-
cent of seagras lands and 44 per-
cent of the mangroves and salt
marshes were lost between 1940
and 1980, said Barbara Hoffman, a
marine biologist with the state De-
partment of Natural Resources' re-
search laboratory in St. Peters-
burg. She said 11,000 acres of
mangroves and salt marshes were
lost, while 61,965 acres of seagrass
were lost.
"Tampa Bay has really been up-
set as far as marine habitats are
concerned," Hoffman said.
In response to complaints from
environmentalists, DER has at-
tempted to come up with a rule to
govern the application of mitiga-
tion to fill permit cases, said Su-
zanne Walker, chief of the DER's
bureau of permitting.
Under the proposal, developers
would have to create two acres of
artificial wetlands for every acre
they fill in, to allow sufficient time
for the new wetlands to begin to
function, Walker said.
Developers also would have to
assume financial responsibility for
mitigation projects that cost over
$20,000, Walker said. They would
have to post bonds or some other
means of assuring that they build
artificial wetlands, she said.
But environmentalists say the
proposed rule won't prevent
enough developers from filling in
more wetlands.
"What they (DER officials) are
really trying to do is accommodate
the developers, while maintaining
the environmental stance," Rains
But adoption of the rule would
not be an open invitation for devel-
opers to fill in wetlands, Walker
said. That rule would simply give
DER some criteria to use when it
considers mitigation as part of a
fill permit application, she said.
A draft of the mitigation rule
should be finished by the end of
the month, Walker said.

University of Florida Home Page
© 2004 - 2010 University of Florida George A. Smathers Libraries.
All rights reserved.

Acceptable Use, Copyright, and Disclaimer Statement
Last updated October 10, 2010 - - mvs