Interviewee: Isaac Anderson
Interviewer: Vernon Peeples
Date: July 6, 2000
P: This is an interview with Judge Isaac Anderson in his office in the Justice Center
in Fort Myers on July 6, 2000. Judge, what is your full name?
A: Isaac Anderson, Jr.
P: When and where were you born?
A: I was born July 11, 1946, here in Fort Myers, Florida. I was delivered by a
midwife by the name of Maola Wells.
P: That is amazing that you remember who...?
A: Well, I do not remember her being there at the moment that I was born. However,
I know that she delivered me. She said so, and she still has grandchildren or
great-grandchildren around here. Lovy Wells, who works for the school board,
his father is her son.
P: Was it typical at the time for babies to be delivered by midwives in Fort Myers?
A: I imagine so. It would not be unusual to have midwives deliver babies at about
that time because delivery at the hospital is really a recent things. When I say
recent, I am talking about 1950s and 1960s and 1970s and that sort of thing,
primarily in the 1950s, but I was born before then.
P: Where did your family live at that time?
A: We lived in an area of Fort Myers that was called Johnson Quarters. I
remember growing up on Cuba Street, which is on the eastern edge of the city of
Fort Myers just across the Ford Street Canal, which is a major drainage canal
that runs north and south. Cuba Street is just parallel to Ford but on the east side
of it, on the eastern edge of it. I grew up in that neighborhood.
P: To what degree would that neighborhood at that time have been segregated?
A: We were partially desegregated. Occasionally, a white guy would come by and
pick up industrial insurance policy payments, but other than that, I mean, to the
extent that it was desegregated, that was about it. No, it was a segregated
P: What were the names of your parents?
A: My father's name is Isaac Anderson, obviously, and my mother's name is
Margaret Davis Anderson. Margaret, my mother, is from Dawson, Georgia. She
had several children, Mary Francis, Viola, and then me and Linda. There were
four of us initially. Later on, she married again and she had three other children
who were killed in a house fire. Francis and Viola are still alive. Linda was killed
in a train-car accident out off Hanson and Metro there, near WMR radio station,
where it used to be. I think it is still there. At least, the towers are still there. That
is basically the family there.
P: Where was your father from?
A: My father was from South Carolina in a town called Johnsonville. His mother was
a Barr. Barr was the family name, and she lived to be 104. I think she died in
1984. She had three different families. She outlived three different husbands. Let
us put it that way. My father was in the second group.
P: What did your father do?
A: My father was a truck driver, primarily. He was a labor__ truck driver.
Eventually, he retired up in Webster, Florida, where he lives now. He was
working for a fruit company. I am not sure what the company was, but he lives
there now, he and his wife and three adopted children. In other words, I have a
brother who is seventeen and two little sisters who are fourteen. They are twins.
At any rate, that is where they live now.
P: You have quite an extended family.
P: Was your mother employed?
A: Yes. She did domestic work for a while, quite a bit of her working life. However,
she also was a cook. She cooked at various places. I know there was the lady
that works for Patty. She tells the story, she says that my mom gave her her first
job when she first came to town. My mom was in charge of the kitchen down on
the beach. I have forgotten the name of the place. It was a restaurant hotel there.
W: [Woman] Judy Jefferson.
A: Judy Jefferson, right. Judy saw me one day in Publix there on 41, and she said,
you do not remember? I said no, ma'am, I do not remember you. Of course, she
proceeded to tell me the story. I said, I still do not remember you. I think that was
about 1952 when she came here, and I guess I would have been about six about
that time. But that is what she did.
P: When did your parents move to Florida?
A: Early on. My mother and her family, Mary Cooney Jones-she is my maternal
grandmother, Mary Jones-they moved down here, I think it was, in the early
1940s, or maybe it was in the late 1930s. I am not sure, but it was about that
P: Were your parents married before they came to Fort Myers?
A: No, they got married here in Fort Myers. I do not know the date, but it was in the
1940s. My middle sister would have that information. She has got all the details. I
do not have it. I am sorry.
P: What education did your parents have?
A: High school. My mother went to high school. She did not finish. My father also
did not finish, and my oldest sister. As a matter of fact, I was the only one in my
immediate family to have graduated from high school. That is basically it.
P: What do you attribute the fact that you were the only one in your immediate
family to graduate from high school and then go on to college?
A: Any number of things. Well, not any number of things, but my mother primarily. I
remember growing up in Fort Myers and as a young kid coming home many
evenings. Abe Lincoln had nothing on us with his oil lamps. We had them, too. I
mean, it was a carry over from one century to another. We would sit around, and
she would tell us stories. I mean, a great storyteller, and she would read to us.
That was the most important thing to us, I thought, is that she would read to us all
the time. She always impressed upon us that you do not have to do what I am
doing. She said to me, I remember her telling me distinctly, you will not do
exactly what I am doing because you do not like to do anything I tell you to do. It
was her way of saying that I was kind of incorrigible. That is a nice spin, I
suppose. But I think that was the most important thing that impressed upon me
the necessity of an education. I also remember a man by the name of Talis
Knight. My father was gone when I was kid growing up, and this man, Talis
Knight, we called him Poppa. He was more or less like a fixture part of the family.
He was much older than my mom and the rest of us, but he was there when we
needed him. He could not read. I remember as a youngster that he would get a
letter or so from his daughter up in New Jersey, and he would, come on, boy,
come on down here with me, I want you to read this letter to me. I would go
down, and I would sit in the front yard with him. He would have his little fire set up
on the rocks with a black cast iron skillet with cheese and eggs and onions and
everything just bubbling just right and the fire on the outside. He said, okay, boy,
read to me, I know you can read. I was just as proud as I could be, and I would
read to Poppa. I would read his letters, and I would write his letters. I would help
him compose his letters. That really gave me a sense of accomplishment, and I
became very proud of myself. He was always one, as well. He was proud of me,
too. He would drag me around with his buddies, Old Ben, Joe and Clark and
those other guys. He would tell them, you see my boy, he can read. You jokers
can't read. That sort of thing. It is a lasting thing.
P: Any relationship to Dr. Ann Knight?
A: Talis? No, none whatsoever. Different family. But those are the things. It was a
very competitive little neighborhood. My aunt lived across the street, Stroth Lee
Clark, she and all of her children, and then I had my grandmother, Mary Jones.
She lived next door. Then we had another set of cousins who lived down the way
from us there. We all lived on the end of Cuba Street, and there was a bunch of
us. It was not like three or four or five or six. It was like ten, twelve, fifteen, or
twenty of us. We pretty much made up a block.
P: No one was likely to undertake an assault on the entire family.
A: Usually, they picked on me. The women in the family would pick on me because I
stood out. Of course, the grandmother would come after me because I would win
sometimes. No, I say that tongue in cheek. No, I agree with you, Vernon. That
generally did not happen because it was a mob.
P: How would you describe your life before you were six years old?
A: Happy, just as proud of myself as I could possibly be, and just having a generally
good old time. Growing up down there on Cuba Street in that end of the street, it
bordered on what is now Franklin Park Magnet School, and we were on the
northern side of Franklin Park Magnet School. It would be the northwest corner
where Cuba Street would intersect there, and that is where we grew up. In that
area out there where Franklin Park is, we had a little area out there that was a
farm, more or less. There were pigs, and they grew vegetables. I remember as a
kid, we would grab those big old sows and hogs and just ride them around there.
I mean, they were as big as Shetland ponies. So, as a kid, you would jump them
and ride them. You never messed with those old big boars. Sows, maybe. I
mean, you would do stupid things, dumb things that kids would do. When it would
rain real hard, sometimes the canal behind the house would get high with
drainage water flowing from the south to the north. I mean, that was a great place
to swing with a rope or a vine across into the water, and do all the things that kids
did. It was a good time for me. To say the least, we were not wealthy, but we
were not starving. We were not poor, but we were not middle class either. We
were somewhere in there. I do not know what it was, but it was a time that I have
fond memories of.
P: How would you have differed from your neighbors?
A: Well, I would not have differed any. We all grew up basically the same because
what was happening, Vernon, is that, you know, we talk about the pigs, they
would slaughter a pig or something and they would share it, or a hog or
something. I talk to my wife today about cleaning a hog, how they would take it a
scald the hair or burn the hair off and all this sort of stuff. And she, do what? You
know, it is a question, does not understand that. Or how the fisherman would
come in. I mean, when I say fisherman, these are the guys who worked on the
shrimp boats down on Fort Myers Beach or out where downtown Fort Myers
used to be. You probably remember. There was a big dock area down here in
this area where the Justice Center is, pretty much up here on Monroe Street.
There are fish houses, cleaning houses where they clean fish and __ and
shrimp and what have you. But these men would come back to the
neighborhood, and they would bring back baskets of shrimp and fish and all sorts
of stuff, and it would be shared among the neighborhood. Out there on that little
what I call a farm today, it was basically a very large garden, and people shared
from it. It was a time when people took care of each other because you did not
have a whole lot of government help, as I can remember. The government just
did not have any help. If they did, it was a can of something. That was about it.
You took care of yourself, and people took care of each other. We were all pretty
much the same.
P: How important was the church or religion in your life during those formative
A: Church has always been important in my life, very important at that time, today,
and as I said, always. I was, I guess, raised in a Baptist church. As I grew older, I
became a little more independent, when we moved out of the neighborhood and I
got a little more sophisticated. I studied with the Jehovah's Witnesses, and I
thought I would like to become a Witness, and I was for awhile. I learned and I
benefitted a lot from both. One of the things that I remember most and that
stands out the most and is so clear in my mind from studying as a Witness is that
as a young child, I was given an opportunity to speak at public gatherings, to
read, to exercise those things that I had developed early on and that people were
so proud of me and patting on the back and telling me that I could do this and do
this well. I found that as a Witness, I was given opportunity to do that on a regular
basis, and I got pretty good at it, I thought, and I think it served me well. So,
religion, yes. From that point, it has been very good to me. I think God is very
important in my life and all of our lives, and we need to have somewhere to go
where we can seek a private audience with something that is greater than we are
and feel comfortable in doing it. Religion is very important to me.
P: The churches in many black communities perform a function far greater than just
nourishing the soul. How important was the church to you, other than as a
religious experience, when you were growing up?
A: It was a social thing. You learned so many things. You learned history, you
learned family history, you learned to appreciate family, you learned to
appreciate community through the church. Many times, it was an entertaining
thing. We were not the nicest little boys. I mean, we would sit in the back of the
Baptist church, and every time they would strike up that hymnal, Amazing Grace,
How Sweet the Sound, you know, we used to sit in the back but they moved us
down front because what we would to is we had our own version of that. We
would sing, like, Amazing Grace, how sweet the sound, the bulldog ran my
grandma down. After a while, they picked up on it. They discovered what we
were saying, and they carted us down front, mostly by the cuff of our ear or neck
or something like this. They literally dragged us down front, and we lost out on
that one. But God still loved us notwithstanding that some of the elder members
of the church did not think it was right. From that experience, you learned that
there are sometimes you best keep your thoughts to yourself, or you do not
necessarily have to express them publicly. The church was a place for
entertainment. You learned to sing, you learned to play the piano, you learned to
play instruments. You participated in plays. I do remember at Friendship Baptist
Church, the schools were so tight in terms of places to actually conduct classes. I
believe I was in second or third grade [when] it was being conducted at
Friendship Baptist Church. Our third grade classes were held there. I remember
we had this great play, and, probably, this is why I am a judge today. It probably
has something to do with this. I played the role of a law enforcement officer, the
desk sergeant. They had this huge desk mockup thing that they had built for me
to sit on, and they would bring the scurrilous reprobates and criminals in and they
would tell their story to me. My famous line was, a likely story. I remember that.
But what I found that was even more interesting was the process of getting there.
I had the uniform or whatever it was, for whatever it was worth, but we needed a
hat. We could not find a hat to fit my head. I had the biggest head in the class,
and they called me Tankhead. Carolyn Jo Hill, her father was the Iceman. June
O'Neill has nothing. The Iceman cometh. I mean, he truly came. Mr. Hill would
deliver ice. Do you remember with those big tongs, and they would put the big
hunks of 250-pound blocks on their backs or whatever it was, and they would
literally with the slicker on their shoulder take it where it had to go. Well, it was a
big debate, where are we going to find a hat to fit Anderson's head? And
someone said, I know, Mr. Hill's got a big head. So, one of the kids asked for Mr.
Hill's hat, and Mr. Hill graciously loaned us the hat. It did not quite fit, but it
served its purpose. So, again, the church was a great place to learn and
participate in things.
P: It sounds like in your formative years, you grew up with some order and
A: That is the way you put it today. You may call it order and discipline, but I think
my parents and the people around me probably thought I was one of the most
obstreperous people they had ever seen. I was probably one of the most
disorderly they had ever seen. I was not really a bad kid, but I was always
questioning things, always into things, doing things differently, pushing the
envelope a little bit. I had a lot of folks pushing me, trying to squeeze me back
into the way I should go. If you want to call that order and discipline, okay fine.
P: Where and when did you start to school?
A: Elementary school, I went over here at Waver's Academy for first grade, and
then second and third grade, Dunbar Elementary. From there, we were the first
class to graduate from Franklin Park. I guess it was an elementary school, and
we graduated from there. From there, we went onto Dunbar High School, which
was recently built out on Edison and which is now Dunbar Middle. That was the
new Dunbar High School that was built, and we graduated from there in 1964.
That is basically what happened there. Of course, when I left high school, I went
to a small historically black college, Allen University, in Columbia, South Carolina.
I went there my first year, and in January, I guess would be the second semester
of my first year, my mother died. She was my support, and I had no other
financial means, other than what I got from the school and what have you. I
stayed there and finished off the year, and at the end of the year, I joined the Air
Force. I did it for the very specific reason of continuing my education, being able
to finance it. I figured I could do two things. I could serve my country rather than
being drafted, select the road that I wanted to go rather than someone pushing
again in the right direction. I chose the direction I wanted to go and used the
proceeds from that to pay for my education. I spent three years, three months,
and twenty-seven days in the United States Air Force. I did the Vietnam thing. I
came back. I was stationed up there in Tampa at MacDill Air Force Base and
signed up at Edison and started classes on September 10, 1968. I was
discharged on September 10, 1968. I started classes that night. So, I drove from
Tampa to Fort Myers and went to school at Edison for that year. In the meantime,
I worked for the U. S. Fire Service. A fellow by the name of George Mescaline,
who is a forester, a __ culturist, I worked for George, and George helped me
later on to get a loan to go off, to pay for the rest of my education beyond that. I
was married the following spring to my bride, Audrea. She called me and she
said, I think this is great. I am coming to Florida. I am going to graduate school in
Florida. I said, oh wonderful, where? She said Miami University. I said, no, dear, I
think that is the University of Miami. You read that again. It says Miami
University. Read carefully. It says Oxford, Ohio. You are not coming to Florida.
So, I finished Edison that year, and with the previous year I had spent at Allen, I
had enough to transfer to Miami. I went to Miami for a year a year and a half, and
I finished there while she was doing graduate work. It is an interesting thing, the
river of life that we are sailing. I met that lady in South Carolina at Allen
University. She is from Lee County, South Carolina, and, of course, I am from
Lee County, Florida. When she started to tell me little things about her family, I
said that is nice. I knew that she was something special, or she was really after
me when she told me she had a brother named Anderson. I said okay, right, sure
lady, you are pulling my leg. And she does have a brother named Anderson
Isaac. We were just made for each other, so to speak, and we have been
married ever since. While at Miami, I decided to go to law school. A lot of
experiences go into this decision process, but I interviewed with several young
black lawyers from Ohio State University, and in particularly, a man by the name
of David Wilmont Friedman. We sat and we talked. He had come down to
Miami along with maybe three or four others, and they talked the black student
union, whoever was interested in law school, come on up to Ohio State. I sat and
talked with him, we agreed on a lot of fronts and I decided that was the thing for
me. Well, I had my fill of the "Midwest," so I did not apply to Ohio State. I
probably would have been accepted there. But I was a little, as my kids would
say, ego tripping. I applied to Harvard, Yale, Berkeley and Chicago in that order,
law school. Of course, I was rejected at Harvard, Yale, Berkeley and Chicago in
that order, probably not because of my lack of credentials or anything, probably
because I did not send the application fee in. I was a poor student and arrogant
enough to think that if they wanted me, they would accept my application and I
would pay them later. But they were not interested, so applied to other schools.
The University of Iowa was one, and American University. As a matter of fact,
both of those schools accepted my application without the application fee. We
went out to Iowa City. We drove from Oxford, Ohio, which is in southern Ohio, up
across Indiana and straight up the interstate through Peoria, through wherever it
is, the quad cities and old Iowa City. We got there. It is a beautiful campus, a
neat little town. As a matter of fact, we liked it so much that we got an apartment
and signed up, ready to go to school. I intended to get a law degree and an M. B.
A., because they were offering that program. We drove back, and on the way
back from Iowa City heading toward the quad cities, I did notice, I said, this is still
the Midwest. I noticed corn. I mean, I do not know, I have never seen corn so
high in my life. It was like driving down a tunnel, and this is on the interstate.
Have you ever been on that road? You do not know. It is an experience, when
the man from Oklahoma when corn is high as an elephant's eye, they were
serious. Got back to Oxford and was accepted in American University. I said I do
not know if I want to go back through those cornfields, so we packed up and went
to D. C. instead, to American University. That is where I went to law school.
P: Let us go back a little bit.
A: I will get ahead of you if you let me.
P: No, you are doing great, but let us go back to when you were in high school and
talk about that a little bit. Did you participate in athletics?
A: Yes. I was a pretty fair baseball player. I was a much better football player. I
thought I could play basketball. I do remember after football season going to the
basketball practice, and the coach, Jim Stevens-who died recently, I guess
what, four years ago?-he was my football coach and he was also the basketball
coach. He encouraged us to stay in shape. Of course, I wanted to stay in shape.
I played the season of football. Lo and behold, I went to basketball practice, and I
think I hurt somebody, one of the regulars or something. He said give me my
basketball and get off the court. This is not football. Get away. So, that was my
career in basketball. I was not as good as I thought, but then, I was not too
terribly thin either. But no, I participated in football, baseball, and I used to swim a
lot. We had a swimming team. I did not participate in that competitively, but I
used to swim a lot. But those sports primarily, football and baseball. I still got this
thing about basketball. I should have been a basketball [player]. Michael Jordan
would have nothing on me. You are talking to the shortest Michael Jordan in
P: What other activities did you participate in?
A: I used to be a pretty good little actor, I thought, until Mrs. Jones ran me off. She
was an English teacher, Mrs. Jamie Lee Jones, the greatest English teacher
that ever lived. We participated in several plays, and I did okay until I decided
that I want to work. I had a job part-time, and I could not get to the practices on
time. I would go to work, and I would rush back to the practices. Sometimes, I
would be a little late. I do not know, to a kid, what is five minutes, half an hour.
You know, what is an hour late? So what? I mean, to me, it was not terribly
important but I was there. Well, she could not handle that. She had to go by the
rules, her rules, and was quite strict. I do not blame her. I mean, the fact is ,
so she fired me. She ran me off. I used to also sing a lot, and I still do. I was on
the choir, the Glee Club as they called it. Shirley Robinson Baskin and I did a
couple of duets and all that sort of stuff. I had a baritone and what have you. But I
did that, and I was pretty good. Anything else that I could get into that was
competitive, I did it, yes. Ask me to sing what? No.
P: What type of work did you do?
A: It depended on the time of the season. For example, in the spring, watermelon
season, I would wind up out there at the farmer's market loading box cars. They
would bring in the truck, and you would load them from the truck back to the box
car and stack them and that sort of stuff. Or you would be out in the fields, and
you would load them out to the trucks. I did that. I worked in restaurants as a
busboy, and I worked myself up to a waiter. If I am not mistaken, it was down
near the intersection of College Park near McGregor where the Happy Buddha
is, or used to be. It was called the Hideaway Restaurant and Lounge. It was
tucked way back in there. I started out there bussing dishes and eventually
became a waiter. I worked at the Tasty Freeze. You know, all the things high
school kids do, nothing in particular but anything that would pay.
P: Did you have time for a social life and dating?
A: Of course. Of course I did. You have to work it in somewhere. I did not say I
worked all the time __ I have a great story. I do. This is the best experience
of my life. My wife hears the story, and she will laugh about it again. This young
lady, her name was Devotia Jewitt. A great name, Devotia. I guess I was in
ninth grade, tenth grade, and I was so hot to go to take her to the movies. The
movies were on the corner of Cranford and Anderson Avenue, or MLK as we
know it now, right near the corner. I had asked her and asked her and asked her.
She lived with her grandmother, Mrs. Logan, and I knew from past experience
that every time you went to the movie that was just a show thing. I mean, you just
went with your girlfriend. You walked through all the guys who were hanging out
like a bunch of ne'er-do-wells with nothing else to do but prowl the front of the
movie, see who went in, who came out. Well, Devotia finally said yes. I got my
little money I had saved up and went to buy these tickets. I went over and picked
her up, and we were going to walk down to the movies. Well, we did, but to my
chagrin, Mrs. Logan, her grandmother, was right behind us. She walked us to the
movies and into the movies, and she sat right down. That was an experience,
and that is why I am glad I never had girls. My buddies, I never lived it down. I
think I suffered from that for the next three years in high school. Oh, taking Mrs.
Logan to the movies again, huh, guy? All that sort of stuff. But yes, I had a social
P: Where else did you take a date?
A: Actually, there were not a whole lot of places. You could go to the drive-in, which
is out there in the center of the city's business development center now out by
the Orange Oil place out there off MLK. You could do that, or you could go down
to the beach, Bunts Beach, which is down off whatever the road is there. Those
things, or you could go to the little Lovers' Lane if you had a car. It was kind of
hard walking up there. That was another story.
P: When did you have your first automobile?
A: Did I lead you into that, or did I lead you into that? I think I was a junior in high
school. Some friends of mine, Clarence Hill, Freddy Ross, and I, we bought this
1949 Plymouth. It was battleship gray, and we painted it red and white with
brushes. It was a great car. We knew a little bit about auto mechanics, and we
fixed it up. We painted it. It looked terrible. Everybody hated it, and they laughed.
You know, it was like a gang of flies. We were all packed in there, you know. We
were the only ones who had a car. I remember once we got it just right, and we
decided we were going down to Miami to Joe's Chinese Restaurant along 7th
Avenue. We drove down 41, actually, up to Immokalee, down 29 and over that
way. Of course, when we got down 29 to 41, the old Plymouth was running hot.
We filled it from the canal with coke bottles of water, and somehow or another we
got there. It kept running, and we got to Miami. When we got over there, the little
money we had, we had used it all up and we did not have enough money to get
back home. Adventurous? Yes. Smart? No, but we did it. Somebody
remembered that we had a friend or somebody who lived over there, and we
found them. Their mother sort of laughed at us. She said I ain't gonna to help
you. Get your tails out of here. She was laughing, and we were out there getting
our little heads together trying to figure out how we were going to get this
Plymouth back across the state to Fort Myers. She gave us $5 or $3 or
something, and we had gas. But that was not the end of the adventure. We left
Miami, and we came up through Lauderdale. We came back over through Palm
Beach Boulevard. Of course, I guess the statute of limitations has run out so I
can tell this story. We got along to about where Riverdale High School is, and the
car caught on fire. The wires burn out. Of course, we pulled over and let the
smoke clear, and we got where we trying again, being the mechanics that we
were. We saw this little service station, I guess gas station, you know, with the
one light out front. This was 1:00 in the morning, and there was an old Cadillac
over there. We took the wires off the Cadillac and put them in the Plymouth.
Somehow or another, we got back home. So yes, we were adventurous, and that
was our first car. I think we paid $75 or something, all of us, maybe $100. We put
all our money together. I think we sold it for $125 or something like this, I do not
know. We made money on the deal.
[End of Side Al]
P: During those years that you were growing up in Fort Myers, were either of your
parents active in the community?
A: Not really. No, they were not. My mother was too busy working. She had a little
business. She was the entrepreneur. She sold cosmetics, called Sweet Georgia
Brown Cosmetics, out of a little case like the I remember as a kid, I used to
sell those things for her. She would say, all right, I am going to work. You have to
sell those things. Of course, I would always go around, and all the little ladies in
the neighborhood just thought I was the cutest little thing to see this little boy
coming with a bag to try to sell me cosmetics. Mrs. you look good with this.
Try it. I had quite a few sales.
P: Who would you say during that period of time exerted the greatest influence on
A: I still say it was my mother. Obviously, I am looking back now. You look at the
conditions and the circumstances that she faced, they were not insurmountable.
It was just something that happened. You had to deal with it, and you could
confront it. She confronted a lot of adversity, and she dealt with, and she had all
us little hungry brats running around there. I tell you, that really impressed me. I
am still impressed by it, even today. That is why I have so much difficulty when I
see people today saying, well, I can't, I can't do this or I need that. I take the
attitude that people will offer you a handout to help you. They will help you help
yourself, but if you do not try to help yourself, so what? That is the attitude. My
mom always took the attitude, I do not need your help, I will do it my damn self.
She said y'all listen to me, y'all can do it, too. And we did. So to answer your
question, my mom.
P: Were there other people in the black community who impressed you?
A: Oh yes, there were a number of people who impressed me. Dr. Gilmore, for
example, with the NAACP and the things that he did. Marvin Davies, who was
here at one time. He used to be on Governor [Bob] Graham's [of Florida, 1979-
1987] staff. He now lives in St. Pete, in that area. Marvin did things with young
people, young fourteen-, fifteen-year-old kids like myself. At that time, helped us
get focused and really politicized us to some extent. Showed us that there were
other things in life you could do. You did not have to relegate yourself to
wherever it was that you were at that time. If you had aspirations of moving on,
then certainly it was there, you could do it, but you had to be tough and tenacious
and just do not quit. That is what many of us did. And we listened. I know that
there were people in my class, like Jay Sullivan, he is a doctor or a principal or
something. But we have medical doctors, we have principals, we have lawyers
and judges come out of that little old graduating class of 1964 at Dunbar. We
probably had a total population graduating class of sixty-four in 1964. We had
people around us who would push us, people like Martha Williams. She is a
retired math teacher from the Lee County school system. She had a sense about
her. She could laugh with us, she could joke with us, but we knew that there was
a limit, there was a line. You know when Big Mart drew the line, you did not
cross that line. She knew how hard to push us, and we knew how hard we could
push the envelope that way. But she knew also that there was a lot of potential
there, and she encouraged us. The important thing about her is that what she
would do was pat you on the back. Not literally but, you know, one big atta-boy
to you, son, or daughter. That was more important than being able to winning it
all, to have someone encourage you or to tell you that you can do it, or you are
doing a good job. That meant a lot to many of my classmates. There were small
businesspeople in the community who did well, McCutchin and those folks like
that. They just did what they had to do, and they did very well. There were many
successful businesses on MLK or Anderson Avenue at the time that are no
longer there because of, I think, government intervention, where the government
went through and any number of changes were made. For example, they took
away the on-street parking, and they made it no parking. If your businesses are
right up to the sidewalk and you do not have parking behind you, where are you
going to go? Where are your customers going to park? Are they going to block
away and come back? No. They will go park at the mall where they can walk
right out the door and right in or go to a strip shopping center where they walk
and walk right in. But those folks struggled, and they did well. The myth of the
highway that is coming that has finally gotten here in 2000, I mean, when I was in
high school, they were talking about widening Anderson Avenue. That was in
1964. Good Lord, Vernon, this is forty years ago, thirty-six years ago, whatever it
was. But it is here. So, it was pressures that were there that made those people
who succeeded, I think they were sort of like heroes. They were strong, and they
were adaptive, and they were able to survive some way or another under those
circumstances. People like that, those are the kind of people. We had the
ministers. We had those folks who made a difference in people's lives.
P: I know that you were young, but when Brown versus Board of Education decision
came about, do you have any memory of...?
A: No. I do not have any memory of that as such, but I do remember in terms of
education, I do recall the stories of reality. A guy named John Nightingale who
used to live up in Charlotte County. They used to bus the black kids all the way
from Charlotte County to Fort Myers because Dunbar was the only high school in
this area. Charlotte County got smart. They said to hell with that-excuse my
language-we are going to stop shipping those black kids down here. We are
going to keep them up here and get their fees for them up here in Charlotte
County. That was long before Blalock versus Lee County School Board, which
was in 1968. I think Charlotte County got smart in 1958 or 1960, whatever the
numbers were. But those are the people from Charlotte County, from Punta
Gorda and Folktown and Immokalee and then down in Naples. They would bring
kids up here because of school boards' attitudes about desegregation. Rather
than do what was required, they would pack everybody in here. That is what we
had to deal with. But as far as Brown versus Board of Education, I do not know. I
guess I probably would have been six or seven years old at the time.
P: To what degree were the public schools of Lee County segregated by the time
you graduated from high school?
A: They were thoroughly segregated. The black kids went to Dunbar, Dunbar
Elementary or Dunbar High School or Franklin Park Elementary, and the white
kids went to Fort Myers High, or I guess Cypress High was built then, or North
Fort Myers High. Those were the schools. You know, I am not counting all the
elementary and Sanibel Elementary, those schools. I am talking about the major
schools. But they were segregated, period. We knew that the schools were
segregated and we knew that things were not right. We knew that the law
required something different as students. But I guess in a false sense of bravado,
we sort of patted ourselves on the back and said, hell, we are better than all the
little sorry butts over there at Fort Myers High. We are so much better than those
kids. What do you mean we cannot go there? Notwithstanding the fact that we
got used books or whatever, equipment and all that sort of stuff. But we did that,
and we got it ourselves. We believed it.
P: Certainly, Dunbar did exceedingly well in athletics.
A: Yes. Dunbar did very well athletically. As a matter of fact, academically, we did
very well too. I believe that the year I graduated or my junior year in high school,
we had two or three kids who did exceptionally well on the national merit
scholarship test. This is national, not even talking about the state of Florida, we
had two or three kids from Dunbar who did exceptionally well. Some folks were
even questioning, how did you cheat? How did you get that? But, you know, that
just did not happen. The kids just had that ability. They did very well, and they
knew how to take tests.
P: During that period of time, do you recall any people in the white community who
you particularly respected?
A: There are a couple of families, in particular. When you say respected, it carries a
connotation that I disrespected a lot of others, and I know that is not what you
mean. But the fact of the matter is, Phil and Melva Morse, Phil is probably now
a retired postman. Phil and Melva live down in San Carlos where they used to,
last I knew of them. I have not seen them in years, but they had two boys, Randy
and Ronald. I remember them [from when] they were that tall. Now, they are
grown men. They were called the Aquanuts, but that is a whole different story.
But I respected Phil and Melva. They were very good friends. George and Patty
Nesterman. I consider them to be very good friends. Patty and George are
divorced. They have gone on and live different lives, different families, but I
consider them to be very good friends. I remember when I left here in 1969,
George was at the U. S. Fire Service. George and Patty had me over one day.
They had met Audrea. Patty said, if you were to move in the neighborhood, we
would be the first ones over with a chocolate cake to invite you to the
neighborhood, welcome you to the neighborhood. I said okay, sure. That is not
going to happen. That will never happen in this lifetime. So, when we did move
back here in 1978, we bought a house in Prince Field, which is in south Fort
Myers off College Parkway and Winkler Road. George and Patty lived down off
Winkler Road near where Clancy's is across over the Whiskey Creek Bridge
there as you head up McGregor? Right to the left there, they lived down at
Edgemere, down at the end of the there right on Whiskey Creek. George knew I
was back, and lo and behold, one day, we were messing around in the hot spring
or something or whatever it was, and here comes George and Patty with a
dripping chocolate cake. Those are the kind of people you grow with. Yes, you
know those people, you respect those people. There were other folk coming up
as a child whom I knew, I met. Young white kids, we played together. They would
go on with their life. I went on with my life. We were just kids doing whatever kids
did. But the community was thoroughly segregated. But there were some good
people, a lot of good people. But you got so many people who would go with the
flow. They were afraid to stand up and be counted. I tell my sons this, to do it all
the time. I say I am always getting in trouble, but I am able to sleep at night and I
feel comfortable when I go to bed at night. A couple of examples since I have
been a judge. Most recently, they have this judges' conferences, and at the
judges' conference, they split us into two groups. Actually, we all met in this big
room, and they put a divider in the room. They gave some blue cards and some
red cards. Then they showed a vignette on a television screen over here and one
over here, and this group could not see what this group was doing. Make a
decision, etc. The first vignette was a black guy who was charged with a crime. I
am in the blue group, and of course, that is what I see. People on the red group,
they had a black woman who is charged with a crime, and you had to make a
decision as the judge. Well, we all made decisions, and then we discussed it. I
asked the chairman of the conference, why is it that whenever there is a crime, it
has to have a black face? He said, well, we did not mean that. I said, well, no,
you did not mean it but that is perception that is out there, because I have been
doing criminal work for the last eight years and I know by the sheer numbers that
is just not the case. You know it is not the case, but that is what you are
portraying. You are purveying this attitude out there, and what you are telling 500
judges in here, this is what you are going to see in a criminal circumstance,
whether it be a black male or female. If it is crime, it is going to have a black face,
period. He was very apologetic, and the room got quiet. Everybody kind of
avoided me from that point. I said gee, guys, I shower. I am clean. At any rate,
the point is you just cannot go with the flow for the sake of going. Some folk
would rather not rock the boat. I guess I am used to living in choppy water, ever
since I was a kid when they were trying to get me some direction in my life. But I
do that, and that is what I try to impress upon my children, my young men. If you
believe in something, say it. If you see something wrong, try to do what is right to
make it right. Otherwise, you just feel bad about yourself. When you get up in the
morning, you look in the mirror and you drop your head. I do not like that.
P: Going back to your high school days and earlier, were there any family
celebrations or traditions that have stuck with you?
A: Birthdays. No, I say that [in jest]. We did not do the things like Kwanza. We did
the things like Christmas like everybody else, you know, the holidays of the 4th
and Christmas and that sort of thing. One thing that we did do, and fortunately
my wife has raised these two young men to experience it, and that is we always,
at least once a week, we sat as a family and we ate together as a family. It was a
dinner, and we did it at least once a week, sometimes twice or three times but
she had to work and that sort of thing. But we do the same thing. Audrea grew up
in a family of nine children, and mom and dad were there and they raised them,
and that is what you did. You sat down. My two sons sat down to dinner, and we
did it two and three and four days a week at the house. We sat there and we had
dinner together, and we talked about what is bothering you or what was good
and what was bad or just talked. That is important, because what it does is it
allows a child to get a sense of family. It allows the child to have a sense of
belonging. It even allows them a chance to vent. Sometimes things are bothering
your children, and you never know that something it bothering them unless you
give them an opportunity to say it. Unfortunately, my youngest one, he has a
habit of starting. When we sit down, okay, Justin, it is your turn. He will say, well,
I was born on September 10, and he goes forward. So, by the time we finish the
fourth bottle of wine, he is finishing.
P: When you graduated from high school, you went to college. Was there any
particular reason why you chose the college that you did?
A: Yes. I chose Allen University because of Jim Stevens. Jim Stevens was a
graduate of Allen University. Actually, it was Allen University and another school,
but he knew that he could get me in there and with the financial assistance that I
needed. Academically, I had no problem. I could have gone anywhere. If people
were paying for that, it did not matter. If I went, they would pay my tuition, but I
had to live and all those other things. I just could not afford it, so I went to Allen.
That is why I went there. Jim was very instrumental in that.
P: Was that a pleasant and enjoyable experience?
A: College is always a good experience, especially just getting away from home.
Get your kids away from home if you can. You have some who are on the way.
Send them away, please. They will enjoy it. It was a pleasant experience. It was
a learning experience. You learned how to deal in different circumstances that
growing up at home in an insulated society, I mean, you are dealing with people
from all over the country, all over the world, in a whole different ball game. It is a
whole different ball game, and you just have to learn to adapt. You have to learn
to cope with all sorts of things, and you learn.
P: Did you learn about Columbia?
A: Yes, I learned about Columbia. That was the first place in my life I had ever seen
snow. But of course, I went to Columbia with my Florida overcoat, which was a
windbreaker, and I froze my toches off out there. I learned in a hurry you needed
more than just a windbreaker. Columbia, yes, it is a good town. It was at that time
and still is today. They have Fort Jackson there, and everybody who has ever
been in the Army has gone through Fort Jackson at some point or another in
their life. The city itself, the University of South Carolina is there. You D
College across the street from Allen University. There were so many things you
could do in and around there.
P: How did you meet your wife?
A: Do you want the official story, or do you want the truth?
P: "You could not handle the truth." The first time saw her, we were taking a battery
of exams. They kind of carted you all into this Allen is a church school, a
Methodist school. They have you all in this big old auditorium where you have to
have chapel, and we were given a battery of tests. I saw this tall good-looking
girl. She came down the aisle to my right and sat in front of me, or was it behind
me? I think she sat behind me. That is what it was, because I was always looking
around just trying to see what was going on. That was the first time I saw her. Of
course, I made it a point to get in her way so there I could catch her attention
somehow or another. She sort of ignored me initially. I do recall I was on one of
the benches along the sidewalk that led up to Coppen Hall, which was one of
the girls' dorms, where she lived. Of course, I had staked this area out. I knew full
well that she would come by there eventually, and she came by. I do not
remember what I said, but it was something outrageous, something like I know
you want to talk to me. It was something like that, and she ignored me. But
eventually, we started talking to each other, and one thing led to another and we
are married and we have all these wonderful children.
P: Were you married before either of you graduated?
A: Yes. She was in graduate school, and I had not graduated. See, when I came
back to Edison, I had gotten out of the military and I had basically two years
under my belt. I had to finish. I was a rising junior when we got married, and she
was in graduate school. That is the way it was.
P: Was this a difficult time financially?
A: Not really. As a matter of fact, I thought we were doing quite well. I never realized
how poor we were. I thought we were doing quite well. She had a graduate
assistantship. I had my GI bill benefits. I had a part-time job in a little grocery
store Charles Ruleman Supervalue Grocery Stare in Oxford, Ohio. After
making hamburgers, I decided I would never eat another hamburger in my life. It
was one of those little corner stores in downtown Oxford, Ohio, and all the
college kids went in there. I helped in the butcher area and everything else. I did
it all, but Charlie __ the hamburger.
P: How was Miami of Ohio?
A: It was an experience. It was very difficult for me to sort of make a transition.
Going to school at Edison was fine. I was working during the day. I was going to
classes at night. Most of the people who took night classes were young adults.
They were not the really competitive little cut-throats, little darlings, I saw at
Miami. Then I get to Miami, and I get these little bright-eyed gleaming little kids
right out of high school who are sharp as a tack and gleaming like a saber. I
mean, they are coming at you. It is just going to be tough, man. I really had to
compete with these kids. It was a different type of competition, intense, but I rose
to the challenge. It was just a different experience, but a good experience.
P: How about law school?
A: I found law school to be fun, and I mean it literally. I was older than most of the
kids who were coming into law school. Most of them were coming right out of
college. They were twenty, twenty-one years old. I had been in the military for
three years. In that three year interim, I had been through boot camp, and your
first year in law school is sort of like a boot camp. They grind you and they beat
you. Have you seen that silly movie called the Paper Chase? It is very similar to
that. They grind you, and if you are not up to it, you just will not make it. You will
either wind up falling off by the wayside or committing suicide or doing something
else. I decided that is where I wanted to be. I did not want to commit suicide. I
was too chicken for that. I did not want to do anything else but that, so I stayed. I
made some very good friends there. As a matter of fact, one of my best buddies,
I met him in undergraduate school. He was one of those kids from Powhatan,
Ohio. His name is H. Douglas Spuletch, III. I met him at undergraduate school
at Miami. He and his fiance, Jane, they went to George Washington Law School
in D. C., and I was at American University, Audrea and I. We communicated back
and forth as best you could. Even today, we communicate every now and then. If
we happen to see somebody at an ABA conference, or if he has got a problem
down here and he needs some information or a reference to someone, he calls,
or I will call him. That is a lifelong friendship.
P: Your first job as a lawyer?
A: I think a much more fun question would be my first job out of law school, or in law
school. I worked for the Federal Trade Commission, summer job, and I just knew
I was hot stuff. I was good. That was at the time they were doing the investigation
on eight major oil companies. Remember way back when we had the oil
embargo and cars were lined up and all of that sort of stuff back in the 1970s? I
was there. Not only was I there then, but I was also there at the time that the
Watergate hearings and all that stuff was going on. One of my law school
professors was __ and sued by the Nixon people. Judge Sewicker was
represented by my law school professor, a guy by the name of Professor
Horning. He went over to represent Judge Sewicker and action that the
Nixon people had filed. Anyway, that is another story. It was a great experience.
But my first job, yes, I worked at the Federal Trade Commission, and I just knew I
was God's gift to the legal profession. I was so sharp and erudite and just
prepared and ready to do the things that all lawyers do. My first job, they
assigned me to a secretary, and she gave me a bunch of toting and lifted to do. I
carried a lot of boxes for the longest period of time. It was a humbling
experience, but eventually I got out of that and got into to doing the actual
research and the writing involved in that matter. My first job out of law school, we
moved back to South Carolina and I worked for the South Carolina State
Department of Education. Audrea worked over at Dent Junior High in Columbia,
and I had worked in the legal research and writing department up there for a man
by the name of William Buzby. He was the state superintendent of education.
William may not be right, but his last name, I know, was Buzby. It was primarily
giving the board legal advice and research and writing and doing little books like
Student Rights and Responsibilities. That is a misnomer. Students did not have
any rights. That is what it was called, though. I did that and stayed there for a
year, and that is when I came back home.
P: How did you decide to move back to Fort Myers?
A: Here is that fellow again. Jim Stevens keeps coming up. He was working at the
time for Oscar Corman. Oscar was mayor of the city at the time. His son now,
Tommy, is a circuit judge here in Fort Myers as well. Oscar, they had created this
office called the Office of Community Relations, and it had to do with civil rights
regulations and implementations within the city. They needed a director of that
office, and Jim knew that I was in Columbia and knew that I was eventually going
to come back home. He said look, why don't you come on back down here and
we will give you a job. We can pay you some money, and you can study for your
bar and all that sort of stuff. I said I do not know. I thought about it for a while,
and eventually I am back. I worked over there for a year, and then I moved over
to the county where I worked for less than a year. Then I got my license, and that
is when I opened my practice. So, that was Jim Stevens again. He was
instrumental in my coming back to River City.
P: Let me go back to your family a minute. You mentioned that you have two sons.
What are their names, and what years were they born?
A: Isaac was born in December 4, 1974. He will be twenty-six this year. Justin was
born September 10, 1978, which makes him twenty-two this year.
P: Have they gone to college?
A: Yes. The oldest one is a graduate of Princeton University. He graduated in the
class of 1996. The youngest one would have been in the class of 2000 at
Princeton, but he decided that he wanted to "find himself," and he dropped out for
a while. He went to school at Florida State and took a lot of classes and was
getting within X number of hours of getting a degree and decided that, well, I
cannot live with myself if I do not graduate from Princeton. I have got to go back.
I have got to get my degree from Princeton. He sat down, and he had that
conversation with me and his mother. I told him, I said, son, I am really proud of
you. I mean, that is great. That really shows maturity on your part, but my only
question to you is how are you going to pay for it? So, he is now scurrying. His
mother gave me that look. If you have been married, you know the look. He will
be going back in the fall to finish. I told him he would be the only six-year senior
in the history of Princeton University.
P: You have observed race relations here from a totally segregated society to
whatever degree of integration that we have now. What would be your overall
analysis of how far Fort Myers and Lee County have moved?
A: I think Fort Myers and Lee County have moved long ways, have made
tremendous progress and strides, and I am proud to say that I am from here. I
know there was a time when I was practicing law, there were a lot of young black
lawyers all over the state saying, man, how can you practice in Fort Myers? I said
it is the worst place in the world, you cannot make any money, they treat you like
dirt. It is a rotten place to be. I was lying because I knew I did not want their
competition. Since then, I just look at things around me. I know there are a lot of
instances where bad things happen to people. Some people do bad things to
other people, and their reasons for doing them are just awful. They may be
racially motivated, some are, and they just do it to people because they do not
like them or because they have the power and the authority to do it and they do
it. They misuse and abuse people. Overall, I think Fort Myers has come a long
way, but you got to understand-and I say this to any minority person who wants
to live here-if you have a strong sense of self and you know who you are and
what you are all about, this other stuff does not matter. It is just fluff. I mean, it is
a great place to live. You can raise your family here. You can make some money
here, if that is what you are all about. You can make some good friends here,
and you can have a good time with your friends. You can have a pretty good life.
You may not make a whole lot of money. It all depends on what you are doing,
though. Socially, there are stupid things people do. My wife and I will go to a
place, and people will stand there and stare. I mean, white people stand there
and stare. I say, gee, is my fly open? And I look around. It is rude to stand and
stare at somebody, but that is home training. I cannot stop that. As I said to
Audrea one day, you know, I must be quite an impressive guy if people are
staring. So, it is all about our attitude, but I think we have come a long way. I
know we have got a long way to go, also. About elected officials, I think some of
our elected officials, what they do is, you know the whole expression, they lick
their fingers and see which way the political winds are blowing and they go that
way. But they have got to show leadership. They have got to be strong because
that is what people expect of you. They elect you to lead. If you can show that
and you can rationally explain what you did, people accept that. I say that, and I
look at my career as a judge. I was elected originally back in 1980. I got 78
percent of the vote here in Lee County, right here in Lee County, a little old berg.
I do not think anybody has ever gotten anything close to that since. I had a guy
come tell me, a white fellow, all right, I like you. You are my friend. I have given
to your campaign, I am helping you, but let me tell you something: do not buy any
television. I said why not, Ed? He said, man, you do not want them to know you
are black. I said, Ed, they know I am black. I am telling you, Ed had the best of
intentions, but Ed has been getting some bad reads from some bad people that
he has been around. He was doing it to help me, God bless him. But the fact is
that if I could change everybody's mind and make everybody Miss Goody Two
Shoes, I would do it, but it is not going to happen. Because we are so different,
and that is what makes us strong. But I also believe that you have got to show
strength of leadership. Again, since I have become a judge, I know that over the
years I have made some decisions in some cases that have frosted some
people's toenails, as the expression goes. But I also know that the decisions that
I make, they are well-reasoned. Probably some of the most controversial
decisions I have made are decisions regarding, you know, everybody is in favor
of the "death penalty." I have had cases where people have been charged and
convicted of capital offenses where the jury has recommended the death penalty
and I said no, and the reason I said no was because the law and popular opinion
at the time-the vote, that seven to five majority vote there-were different. Then
you had the executive branch, or the prosecution, saying you got to follow what
the people say. No. Because we always did exactly what the people. Well, I
would not be here. I mean, literally, I would not be here because we would still
have separate but equal facilities under Plessey and all those other cases. So,
you have to show leadership.
P: When you became a circuit judge, it was by appointment?
A: No, it was not by appointment. I was originally appointed as a county judge and
then elected. I had to stand for election. They changed the rules. When I came
along, you had to stand for election at the next available election after your
appointment. But now, apparently, it is my understanding that if you get an
appointment you have to have at least one full year in office before you can stand
for election. Boy, that is a deal. I wish it had been that way for me, but it was not.
At any rate, back to your question, when it came to the circuit judgeship, well,
there were a couple of judges and there were a couple of vacancies, three as a
matter of fact, that had come up. Governor Martinez was the governor at the
time, and he had his committees or his people on his committees, and my name
was submitted to him three times, for three different circuit judgeships. Lo and
behold, he did not see fit to appoint me. So, I said that is fine. I think it was Mr.
Fred Dudley who had the...
[End of Side A2]
A: As I said, I know the sequence of the weather around here. When it rains, it rains
in the afternoon. Well, we had an announcement. We were going to make the
official announcement for the position. We had lined up everybody, and we were
going to do it on the courthouse steps like everybody does. We had about fifty
people out there with placards and signs and had called in all the media and
everything. We set this for, like, 1:30 in the afternoon. We knew it rained at 2:00
everyday in the summer in Fort Myers almost like clockwork. This particular day,
everybody was there at 1:30, and I was supposed to come out and start about
1:25. Boom, downpour, and we all have to rush inside. We are in the lobby of the
county commission building over here. Now, fifty people with placards and with
the TV lights and cameras, it looked like there were 1,000 people when they
showed it on television. I think one of the television stations reported the lead-in
with something like Anderson campaign got off with a bang or something, and
they said with thunder and lightning or whatever. But the fact is there was a
fellow who had indicated that he was going to run as well. I said that is your
problem. You know, I have run before. I do not care, do what you got to do. We
are going to run, etc., etc. He decided he did not want to do it after that, after he
saw that. So when qualifying came, no opposition, I am circuit judge. That was
two terms ago. I am at the end of my second terms. That is the way it happened.
P: When you came back here to practice law, who were the circuit judges at that
A: Jack Schunover from Punta Gorda. John Sheer, my best buddy, old Florida
cracker. He and I fish all the time together. Judge Wally Pack. This was here in
Fort Myers. Who else was here? Judge Gerald was still on the bench. I think
that was it.
P: Did you ever have a case before Judge Gerald?
A: No, I had never had a case before Judge Gerald, but Mrs. Pickering, let me tell
you about her. Greatest lady in the world. She was his secretary. I remember one
day I was up there doing some research, and I made the mistake of coming in
and trying to walk through there at lunchtime to get to the library. Well, in order to
get to the library, you had to go past Mrs. Pickering. [Grunt.] I said, excuse me,
ma'am, I am sorry. I did not mean to come through here. I apologize profusely.
And I got out. I was telling some of the guys, and they said you are crazy, you do
not do that. I mean, who am I? I am a young, dumb, stupid lawyer, right? I just do
not know any better. So what I did was, I went across the street to this little
restaurant at the time called Pate's. The next day, I was over there at lunch, and
everyday on the table, Pate would have a little bottle with a chrysanthemum in it.
Of course, when I finished my lunch that day, I took that mum with me. I went up
to Mrs. Pickering and I said, Mrs. Pickering, this is for you. Thank you, young
man, you are so sweet, or something to that effect. I will tell you, I could go in
that library anytime I wanted to from that point on when nobody else could get in
there. She was a great lady. But no, I never had to practice before Judge Gerald.
P: He had a reputation for being stern.
A: Oh yes, I have heard that. That is one of the things they said about me at some
point or another in my career, but I have had sort of a make over or something. I
have changed a little bit, I think.
P: What type of cases have you generally heard since you have been a circuit
A: I have heard them all. I have done it all. I have heard from capital murder, rape,
robbery, mayhem, I have done for the last eight years, to multimillion dollar civil
claims to injunctions to mortgage foreclosures to landlord/tenant cases to you
name it, to glorified small claims cases. I have heard it all. It has been a varied
P: In your judicial career, have you ever been threatened?
A: A couple of times. Even as a lawyer, I was threatened. You know, you were
talking about a segregated society. I represented a young man, one of four, who
were accused of assaulting and raping three women, and one of them worked in
a prosecutor's office. Needless to say, they were gung ho to get the rascals. I
represented my client, did what I had to do notwithstanding the results, but the
fact is that when it was over, or even before it was over, I got letters. You know,
in Chicago or Philadelphia, we hang your kind. I got that stuff in the mail. So, I
sort of chuckled because I gave it to another lawyer who was representing one of
the other defendants in the case and he said hey man, I am walking on the other
side of the street of you. I do not want to be seen with you. I said, there is no
honor among friends here, among lawyers. You guys hurt my feelings. But that
sort of stuff. Then once I became a judge, I received threats in cases where
security has been beefed up and which we thought were pretty credible threats.
So yes, it has happened, and it is not something that you look forward to. I also
have learned that you cannot let other people define your life, but you do not live
foolishly either. You cannot let them pin you or put you in a box because,
otherwise, you will not be able to live. I live my life considering the quality and the
seriousness of the threats as pretty much the same, and we modify, we do some
things a little differently, but basically it is the same.
P: In the courtroom, do you feel that you have an equal amount of respect as other
judges, even though they may be of another race?
A: Yes. I do not think that is a problem. Some people have attitudes, but that is their
problem. I do not have a problem, see, because I have the gavel. I have the final
say so. I have the ultimate power. I can exercise it, or I do not have to exercise it.
I think a lot of times, not exercising that power of contempt, you know, because it
is awesome, the power that you have as a judge. It is incredible. If a lawyer or
Does something contemptuous, I can lock them up right then and there. Put
them over there with Bubba. I mean, you do not want to go with Bubba in the jail.
You just do not want that. That is awful. By the time it got up to the district court
of appeals for some sort of writ, well, he has been over there or she has been
over there a while. The knowledge that they know that I have that kind of
authority, and I rarely use it, it is just something that just has not happened. I
mean, I have had people go nuts and go crazy. Sometimes they lose it,
sometimes they want to vent. There was one judge, he is on our state supreme
court right now, Major Harvey, he says, you know, once I have sentenced a man
to death, he has five minutes to vent his __ I mean, you could bring _
everyday. Once you have decided against a person and they lose, let them vent.
Let them say what they have to say because, a lot of times, that is what it is.
Then you cut it off because if every time somebody vented you hammered them
or put them away, there just would not be enough room over there. If someone
breathed the wrong way or looked askance, well....
P: How do you feel about the effectiveness and fairness of our judicial system?
A: I think our system is effective. I think the fairness of our system is only limited by
the types and quality of the people who administer it. By that, I mean if you have
got a judge who has some sort of an agenda, he is just not going to be fair, or he
is going to figure out a way how to give the appearance of being fair when in fact
he is not. I think that is a pretty fair way of describing our system. There are
limitations. See, the good thing about being a judge, Vernon, when you make
decisions, if you know....for example, I have got this case right here. I wrote
some stuff up in here, and I am just sitting on it. I am letting it just kind of stew
over here, sort of like making a soup or stew pot, just let it sit there and stew for a
while. Save it a day or two. It gets better. The thing about a judge is this. If you
make a decision and you are wrong, and you know you are wrong, you have to
have the integrity and the personal strength to be able to go back and correct
that, and a judge can do that on his own motion without one of the litigants
having to come forward and say, judge, you made a mistake. You know from
your own experiences, when you have flubbed up, you know it. Instinctively, you
know it. Sometimes you just have to suck it up and go over there and do what
you have to do and take the heat because that is what it is all about. I wish I was
perfect. I mean, I keep telling my wife that, but she does not seem to believe me.
She has convinced me that I am not.
P: Is there anything else I should have asked you that I have not?
A: Gosh, I did not know you had so many questions. You talked me dry. I have gone
through a cup of coffee, and I could use another one right about now.
P: Well, it has certainly been a great pleasure to have the opportunity to interview
A: It has been fun talking to you. I mean, there is so much in there. We will talk
about it later when you do what you have to do. Do your thing, and we will sit and
we will talk.
P: If you had a copy of your family genealogy, that would be great to include. If you
do not, I understand.
A: I do not know. We have a family reunion that is coming up here, up in Lee
County, Georgia. There is that Lee County again. Believe me, I am serious. My
wife is from Lee County, South Carolina, and I am here in Lee County, Florida. I
will tell you what, I will let you have this, I will let you look at it. This is my
grandma. This is her daughter, Stroth Lee, who had a daughter, Ann Evy, who
had all those children. She had her oldest daughter, Charlie Lou, who had all
those children. Anyway, it starts right here.
[End of Interview.]