|
![]() |
|
| UFDC Home |
myUFDC Home | Help | RSS
|
|

HIDE
| Front Cover | |
| Preface | |
| Table of Contents | |
| Executive summary | |
| Introduction | |
| Regional overview | |
| Country profiles | |
| Outlook | |
| Tables | |
| Selected sources | |
| Back Cover |
ALL VOLUMES
CITATION
SEARCH
THUMBNAILS
PDF VIEWER
PAGE IMAGE
ZOOMABLE
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Full Citation | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
STANDARD VIEW
MARC VIEW
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Downloads | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Table of Contents | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Front Cover
Front Cover Preface Page 1 Page 2 Table of Contents Page 3 Page 4 Executive summary Page 5 Page 6 Introduction Page 7 Page 8 Page 9 Page 10 Regional overview Page 11 Page 12 Page 13 Page 14 Page 15 Page 16 Page 17 Page 18 Page 19 Country profiles Page 20 Page 21 Page 22 Page 23 Page 24 Page 25 Page 26 Page 27 Page 28 Page 29 Page 30 Page 31 Page 32 Page 33 Page 34 Page 35 Page 36 Page 37 Page 38 Page 39 Page 40 Outlook Page 41 Page 42 Page 43 Page 44 Page 45 Page 46 Page 47 Page 48 Tables Page 49 Page 50 Page 51 Page 52 Page 53 Page 54 Page 55 Page 56 Page 57 Page 58 Page 59 Page 60 Page 61 Page 62 Selected sources Page 63 Back Cover Back Cover |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Full Text | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
2008 LATIN AMERICAN BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT REPORT 'no a Terry L. McCoy UNIVERSITY Of UF I FLORIDA October 2008 I I N: a I October 2008 Preface This is the tenth edition of the Latin American Business Environment Report (LABER). The goal of the report is the same today as it was at its inception in 1999 -- to present in a single document a straightforward, balanced appraisal of the economic, social, and political events in the past year that have shaped the business and investment climate in Latin America as a region and in its most important economies. We delayed releasing the 2008 LABER in order to incorporate preliminary analysis of the regional impact of the global financial crisis that erupted in September and October.* The LABER is a publication of the Latin American Business Environment Program in the Center for Latin American Studies at the University of Florida. The program draws on the expertise and resources of the University to prepare students for careers related to Latin American business with degree programs, courses and study abroad opportunities. It also organizes conferences, promotes the publication of scholarly research and provides professional consulting services for the business community and public. The program will host the fourth University of Florida Latin American Business Symposium and Career Workshop, November 7-8 on campus. This event is open to the public but registration is required (at http://www.latam.ufl.edu/LABE/symposiumreg.html). Additional support for the LABER and related activities is generously provided by the Center for International Business Education and Research (CIBER) in the Warrington College of Business Administration. Alison Boelter and Alan Watson helped me prepare the 2008 report. Charles Wood edited the 2008 LABER. I alone am responsible for the content and analysis. Terry L. McCoy, Director Latin American Business Environment Program tlmccoy(@ilatam.ufl.edu www.latam.ufl.edu/labep.html * Electronic versions of all 10 reports can be accessed at http://www.latam.ufl.edu/labe/publications.stm. The report may be cited without permission, but users are asked to acknowledge the source. 2 CONTENTS Preface................................................................................................. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.......................................................................5 INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................7 I. REGIONAL OVERVIEW............................................................ 11 EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT..................................................11 Global Developments Regional Developments DOMESTIC ENVIRONMENT.......................................................13 Economic and Financial Performance Social Environment Political Environment Policy Environment Legal Environment II. COUNTRYPROFILES......................................................................20 NAFTA REGION...........................................................................20 Mexico DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES...............................................................22 Dominican Republic Costa Rica El Salvador Guatemala Honduras Nicaragua Panama ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA...........................................................28 Bolivia Colombia Ecuador Peru Venezuela MERCOSUR REGION......................................................................34 Brazil Argentina Chile Paraguay Uruguay II. OUTLOOK...............................................................................41 OUTLOOK FOR THE REGION..................................................... 41 External Environment Domestic Environment COUNTRY OUTLOOKS..............................................................43 Attractive Environments Problematic Environments Mixed Environments TABLES................................. ................ ....................................... 49 SELECTED SOURCES.....................................................................63 2008 LATIN AMERICAN BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT REPORT Terry L. McCoy EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Up to mid-2008 the Latin American business environment was encouraging. It looked as though the region would not be seriously affected by the credit crisis and economic slowdown in the United States. But in September and October, when global financial markets collapsed, it was clear that Latin America would not be spared, some countries more than others. The outlook for 2009 turned decidedly negative as shown in the table below. Grouped into three broad categories "Attractive," "Problematic," and "Mixed" - according the overall character of their environments, the arrows indicate improvement (t) or weakening (4-). An "=" sign signifies lack of significant change, while "?" means the trend is unclear. Since 2003 the number of attractive environments increased. In 2008 Brazil was upgraded, but the 2009 forecast is that the business environments in all 18 will weaken or not change significantly. Latin American Business Environments 2007 Environment 2008 Environment Attractive Problematic Mixed Attractive Problematic Mixed 2009 Outlook Mexico = Dom Rep = Costa Rica = = El Salvador - Guatemala = Honduras = Nicaragua Panama 4 -- t Bolivia = Colombia = Ecuador = Peru t Venezuela 4 =4 Argentina , Brazil Chile Paraguay Uruguay = Totals 7 4 7 8 4 6 6 2008 LA TIN AMERICAN BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT REPORT INTRODUCTION In 2008 the environment for business and investment in Latin America, which had grown increasingly attractive over the previous five years, external developments caused a dramatic downturn at the beginning of the fourth quarter. At outset of the year a moderate slowdown was expected because of the problems in the U.S. economy, but there was a growing consensus that Latin America had become immune to the external shocks that had historically triggered economic crises in the region. Analysts argued that wise policies, stable politics and the changing nature of the global economy effectively decoupledd" Latin America from negative external developments, which, in any case, were not predicted to be serious. The optimistic scenario evaporated with the collapse of global financial markets in September, which became a probable global recession in October. Figure 1 Components of the Latin American Business Environment External Environment Economic Domestic Environment Global ----- ------ Financial SPolicy / Political -------------- Legal Regional Social Whether Latin America or the individual economies of the region grow or enter into a recessionary cycle is the result of a complex interplay of factors that operate at the internal and external levels. The analysis here uses the conceptual framework shown in Figure 1 to capture the most salient components of the Latin American business environment. Part I of the 2008 LABER summarizes major regional developments that took place in the last quarter of 2007 and through mid-October 2008. Part II presents thumbnail sketches of the 18 largest markets, grouped by geographic region and/or trading blocs (see Map).1 Part III summarizes the outlook over the next 15 months for the region and for the 18 countries. Following the text, we present tables that contain country-level data, along with regional averages, for key economic, social, political and legal indicators that were used in the analysis. At the end there a list of publicly available sources monitored to compile the 2008 LABER. 1 Venezuela, a founding member of the Andean Community (CAP), has applied for full Mercosur membership. Bolivia is a member of CAP and associate member of Mercosur. Chile rejoined CAP in 2007 and is an associate member of Mercosur. NAFTA Mexico \ Dominican Republic / Honduras ..... C Nicaragua Salvador Costa Rica % Panama TA Colombia Ecuador Peru ANDEAN COMMUNITY MERCOSUR El! DR CAF C-. L.. ., . 10 I. REGIONAL OVERVIEW EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT Three negative external developments affected the Latin American business environment. First was the credit crisis, which began in the United States in 2007 as a sub-prime credit crisis, and later spread to the rest of the world in the latter half of 2008. Second was the economic slowdown that also had U.S. origins, but spread to the other mature economies, most notably the EU and Japan. Third, rising energy and food prices generated inflationary pressures around the globe. In the early stages of these developments, the hope was that Latin America because of macro-economic policies and diversification of trade and capital flows was more decoupledd" from the United States, and therefore less susceptible to the externally induced shocks that had in the past periodically crippled the region. When the global situation took a sharp turn for the worse in September and October, it became clear that Latin America would indeed be affected. Global Developments t Spreading globalfinancial crisis spilled into Latin America While foreign direct investment flows (Figure 3), which surged in 2007, remained strong into 2008 (with considerable country-to-country variation, Table 3), portfolio investments dropped as a result of the global credit crisis. Equally significant were declining commodity prices and overseas remittances due to the economic slowdown in the United State and Spain as well as the U.S. crackdown on illegal immigration. Following a decade that produced double digit growth, the Inter-American Development Bank predicted that remittances would decline in 2008. Global commodity markets weakened Commodity prices, which generated favorable terms of trade for the natural resource exporting economies of Latin America (Figure 2, Table 2), began to soften in the second half of 2008. This was not surprising given that, by late 2 Symbols capture overall trends over the past 12 months: t improving; J, declining; = no significant change. August, four of the world's largest economies were on the verge of recession. The most dramatic reversal in commodity prices was oil, which fell from nearly $150 a barrel in July to under $70 in October. Prices of other primary products also fell in the face of declining demand. Some commodity exporters (Chile) were better equipped to handle it than others (Venezuela). By the same token, declining commodity prices were good news for the countries of Central America and the Caribbean, and they may reduce inflationary pressures for all. Figure 2 Terms of Trade for Latin America, 1998-2007 (Source: ECLAC 2007) 140.0 120.0 115.1 117.9 109.0 103.9 100.0 91.3 94.5 100.0 96.3 96.6 98.6 80.0 - 1160.0 40.0 20.0 - 0.0 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Figure 3 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Net Foreign Direct Investment in Latin America, 1997-2007 (Source: ECLAC 2007) 90,000 79,923 80,000 70,308 70,000 - 60,999 63,659 60,999 _ 60,000 57599 S49,206 c 50,000 45,213 4 9 m 40,000 35,114 30,000 20,000 10,000 0 77,126 *World trade negotiations collapsed In late July 2008, the Doha negotiations of the World Trade Organization reached an impasse over agricultural tariffs, which effectively ended the seven-year round. Barriers to Latin American agricultural exports continued, but existing protection from manufactured imports remained in place. Failure of the Doha round casts a shadow over both the future effectiveness of the WTO and world trade liberalization. Regional Developments = Hemispheric trade liberalization even more uncertain The U.S. strategy of signing bilateral trade agreements with Latin America was in greater jeopardy. While Congress ratified the U.S.-Peru FTA in 2007, it refused to act on the FTA with Colombia. The agreement with Panama was also in doubt. For their part, the South American countries led by Brazil and Venezuela continued to seek integration of their continent, but the two countries were not in full agreement on the path. Venezuela continued to promote the Bolivarian Alternative for the Americas as an anti-U.S bloc. U.S.-Latin American relations on hold While immigration was no longer the flashpoint it once was, the U.S. government implemented measures to tighten its border, cutting down on the flow of migrants from Latin America. Latin America received very little attention in the U.S. presidential campaign, which signaled that the next administration, while promising closer relations, would likely deliver few concrete improvements. DOMESTIC ENVIRONMENT The domestic components of the business environment in Latin America were generally strong at the beginning of 2008, although there were country-to-country variations. Economies continued to grow with moderate inflation. Thanks to economic growth, the social environment also continued to strengthen. Politically it was a reasonably quiet year, in part because there were few national elections to mobilize politics. In the policy arena most but not all governments adhered to prescribed market- friendly macro-economic orthodoxy, and dissident populist voices gained little ground. The turmoil of September and October, however, suggested that by year's end the inter- related domestic components of the Latin American business environment would be significantly realigned. Economic and Financial Performance Economic growth slowed GDP growth in 2007 was again strong (Figure 4), which meant that Latin America had experienced five consecutive years of positive growth for the strongest growth cycle in 25 years. Furthermore, in each of the 18 countries except Ecuador growth exceeded 3.0%. The outlook for 2008 was for slower but nonetheless acceptable increase. Exports continued to be an important component of Latin American growth, but domestic consumption, fueled by easier access to credit, exploded in importance. By the beginning of the fourth quarter, it was clear that GDP growth was slowing throughout the region. Inflation became a concern By mid-year there was growing concern that inflation was the major threat to the economy (Table 2). Countries committed to inflation-targeting like Brazil, Mexico and Chile that were responded by raising key lending rates. On the other hand, Venezuela and Argentina, where price rises were the most acute, opted for heterodox measures such as price controls, subsidies and currency rationing. A positive effect of the predicted slowdown may be reduced inflation. Domestic capital markets deteriorated While 2007 had been good year for Latin American equities, 2008 was a different story: all of the major stock indices were down in terms of prices, volume and listings. For the third quarter, the Dow Jones Global Indices reported the following declines in U.S.-dollar and local-currencies: Peru, -6.2/-6.1; Colombia, -10.9/2.0; Chile, -13.1/-9.1; Mexico, -18.7/-13.3; Argentina, -19.9/-17.1; and Brazil, -38.1/-25.0. For the same quarter which did not include the late September crisis the U.S. stock market index declined 9.1%. Global crises threatened strong external performance FDI nearly tripled from 2006 to 2007 (Figure 3) reaching levels achieved in the 1990s when investors were attracted by privatization of state owned enterprises as opposed to the combination of natural-resource, market-seeking and efficiency- seeking investments of the current period. Brazil received over a third of all FDI in the region, followed by Mexico (Table 4). FDI also increased in Chile, Colombia, Peru, Costa Rica, the Dominican Republic and El Salvador but dropped in Argentina. Venezuela experienced a net outflow for a second year in a row. These flows mirrored improving country risk ratings, topped off by investment grade ratings for Brazil and Peru. Exports grew as did imports, and the region had a current account surplus in 2007 (Table 5). Latin America's external debt, and debt burden, measured in terms of exports-debt ratio declined (Figure 8). The favorable external picture included strong currencies (Table 8), at least until the events of September and October, when Latin American currencies dramatically reversed course. Figure 4 GDP Growth for Latin America, 1998-2008 (Sources: CEPAL 2007 and IMF 2008) Figure 5 Average Annual Inflation Rate for Latin America. 1997-2007 (Sources: CEPAL 2006 and IMF Economic Outlook 2007) 7.4 6.1 6.1 5.2 4.87 18 1 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 1997 1998 1009 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 5.9 5.6 5.6 4.5 4.2 3.9 2.0 0.3 2000 2001 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 -0.8 6.0 4 .0 2.0 0.0 Figure 6 Exports and Imports of Goods and Services in Latin America, 2003-2007 900,000 (Source: ECLAC 2007) 843728 800,000 791,261 700,000 680,123674,521 600,000 560,629 S500,000 466,311 79,391 I 0 Exports C0 405,998 S400,000 378,206 m Imports S333,.513 . 300,000 200,000 100,000 0 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Figure 7 Gross Disbursed External Debt for Latin America, 1998-2007 (Source: ECLAC 2008) 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 S Debt (Billions of US Dollars) Debt (As a % of Eports) Social Environment# Economic prosperity gradually translated into improvements in social wellbeing. In a region of persistent poverty and high inequality, an economic downturn could erase these gains (Table 9). Crime remained a serious social problem throughout the region (see Table 12 for country indices of crime victimization). Social developments with more long-term effects included lower fertility rates, lower population growth rates and a shift from rural-to-urban to urban-to-urban migration. Sustained gains in per capital income reduced unemployment and poverty The UN Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC) estimated that in 2006 for the first time since 1990 the number of Latin Americans living in poverty dropped below 200 million (36.5% of the population of which 13.4% were indigent). A year later it was predicted to fall below 190 million. Social expenditures exhibited pro-cyclical pattern Government spending on social assistance, health and education rose with rising growth and government revenues. This raised concerns about what would happen when both declined, as was expected, on the heels of the global crisis. Political Environment = The economic gains of recent years also helped stabilize the political environments in Latin America, dominated by pragmatic center-left governments. The more radical populist-leftist alternative led by President Chavez in Venezuela did not disappear, however, and its influence may actually grow if the region's economies sink into serious crisis. Elections confirmed center-left trend There were four presidential elections during the last year. As expected, Argentines elected Cristina Kirchner to succeed her husband, but she disappointed expectations that she would take a more moderate path. In neighboring Paraguay, voters ended six decades of one-party dominance by electing an independent left- leaning candidate. Unlike Kirchner, the new Paraguayan chief executive steered a centrist course. Guatemalans also moved to the center left in their presidential choice. In the Dominican Republic the re-election of social democrat, Leonel Fernandez, assured political stability. Constitutional referenda produced mixed results Venezuelans rejected the radical constitutional package proposed by President Chavez, but voters in Ecuador approved a new constitution more moderate in tone. In Bolivia, continuing disagreement between the government and the opposition delayed the constitutional referendum. Policy Environment= In terms of policy, the business environments of Latin America fell into two camps. In the first were the countries led by Chile, Mexico, Brazil, Colombia and Peru that had adopted and continued to implement orthodox macro-economic policies that prioritized fiscal austerity to produce fiscal surpluses (Figure 8) as well as inflation targeting and floating exchange rates. To build up hard currency reserves and reduce external debt burdens these four countries took advantage of terms of trade that favored commodity exports and strong investor confidence. The Central American countries were in this camp. Although not beneficiaries of the global commodity boom, these smaller countries sought to attract increased foreign investment through the DR-CAFTA trade agreement with the United States. In the other policy camp were the leftist populist governments Venezuela, Bolivia and Ecuador that pursued heterodox fiscal and monetary policies and expanded government participation in the economy, discouraging foreign investment. Argentina pursued a mixed agenda, more in the later than the former camp. Financial markets meltdown replaced inflation-fight as priority With the notable exceptions of Argentina and Venezuela, Latin American governments relied on monetary instruments to combat rising inflation. In mid- 2008 Latin America was only region in the world where interest rates exceeded inflation. With the growing likelihood of a major slowdown, they began to implement counter-cyclical stimulus packages. Slippage on structural reforms In mid-October, President Kirchner announced that her government would nationalize private pension funds, which if approved by congress, could set a policy precedent for reversing the privatizations that swept through Latin America in the 1990s. Venezuela, Bolivia and Ecuador continued to re-establish state control of their energy sectors. Figure 8 Central Government Balance for Latin America 2003-2007 (%of GDP. Source: ECLAC 2007) 3 2.4 1 0.6 -0.2 0.1 -0.1 0 - 2003 2004 2W05 2006 2007 -1- -1.1 -3 -2 -2.9 -3 -2.9 -4 Primary Balance 0 Overall Balance Legal Environment = In recent years Latin America made slow incremental progress in strengthening its legal environment, frequently through international commitments made in trade and investment treaties. In terms of rule of law, incidence of corruption, economic freedom, property rights and crime victimization, Table 12 again shows considerable difference among the 18 largest economies. Chile, Uruguay and Costa Rica had relatively strong legal environments, while Venezuela fell near the bottom on most indicators. The pattern was somewhat different regarding the bureaucratic barriers to conducting business (Table 13), although Chile was again at the top and Venezuela at the bottom. II. COUNTRY PROFILES NAFTA REGION When President Bush's took office in 2001, he pledged to give highest priority to U.S.-Mexican relations. The expectation was that NAFTA would flourish and deepen into a North American union. This did not happen. Trade and investment rose at slower rates than under Clinton. More significantly, bilateral relations deteriorated after 9/11. In the 2008 U.S. election, candidate Barak Obama proposed that NAFTA be renegotiated, position that generated some uncertainty about the future of a North American community. In addition, immigration continued to be a debated issue that the next U.S. administration would have to face. The same was true of the war against drugs. In regards to the latter, Mexico and the United States were able to reconcile their differences on the Merida Initiative. The agreement committed Washington to provide Mexico funding for a new era of joint law enforcement action. The objectives were to break the power and impunity of criminal organizations; strengthen border, air, and maritime controls; improve the capacity of justice system; curtail gang activity; and reduce the demand for drugs throughout the region. Even if the new U.S. administration does not renegotiate NAFTA, lingering questions about the agreement on both sides of the border must be addressed as the two nations re-engage. Why has it not reduced poverty, especially in Southern Mexico? On January 1, 2008, as specified in the agreement, all barriers to imports of sugar, corn, beans and milk from the United States were lifted, a step that promises to threaten the continued viability of Mexico's small farmers. The U.S. presidential campaigned revived the fear of "shipping jobs south," and the Democrats' demanded stronger environmental and labor provisions. On a more positive note, rising transportation costs from China refocused attention Mexico as a site for manufacturers exporting to the United States. Mexico=3: Close U.S. ties transmitted global crisis into environment. Slower growth In August inflation reached its highest level (5.57%) in five years. As the year progressed, declining growth became a bigger concern. Improvement in capital markets performance was impressive on the debt side, but equities market continued to be too thin. The limits of the latter became more evident with a regulatory reform allowed pension funds to expand their holding in equities from 15% to 30%. In early October the local stock market was down 40% in dollar terms from the beginning of the year. Vulnerable to deteriorating external environment FDI and exports experienced healthy growth in 2007, but they began to slow down in 2008, a trend that was likely to accelerate in 2009. The same pattern was forecast for remittances. Measures taken to reduce the dollar-denominated debt burden and build reserves should cushion the impact of the credit meltdown. After appreciating to a five-year high in early August, the peso sharply declined in early October, falling to 13.0 to the USD. Rising crime and violence undermined social environment A wave of kidnapping and drug-related executions (in early September there were already over 3,000 executions in 2008) triggered protests demanding that all levels of governments act to improve security. A government official estimated that crime reduces GDP by 1.0% and threatens to discourage international tourism. President Calder6n committed federal forces and resource to combat crime and improve security. The Merida Initiative provides U.S. assistance, but these efforts have yet to deliver concrete improvements. Stable political environment Executive-legislative relations improved. Progress on energy reform In keeping with his commitment to expand private investment and address the worrying decline in oil exploration and production, President Calder6n submitted a bill to Congress that would allow private companies to participate in field service contracts but not in the sale of the oil, which would remain a PEMEX monopoly. The Senate passed the bill in October. Fiscal and monetary policy shifted from keeping inflation under control and to stimulating growth. In mid- 3 The symbols for each country indicate the following trends: +t business environment improved, 4 business environment deteriorated, = no significant change since 2004 report. October, the central bank sold dollars from its reserves to prop up the rapidly depreciating peso *Judicial reform strengthened legal environment Reforms adopted in June were designed to make trials more transparent, improve the rules of evidence and endorse the principle that the accused are presumed innocent. Other features called for universalized counsel and better policing. While these reforms were substantial, their success will depend on the extent to which they are funded and implemented. Weak corporate governance and near- monopoly domination of large closed firms, such as the telecomm giant Telmex, discourage investors. DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES The six DR-CAFTA countries' had sustained growth and low inflation. Their economic performance was encouraging, especially taking into consideration the fact that they did not benefit from the global commodity boom, which favored the natural resource exporters of South America. With the exception of Panama, FDI showed modest increases from 2006 to 2007. Exports were also up, although current account deficits increased due because import growth exceeded export growth. This imbalance could very well be one of the consequences of DR-CAFTA, which reduced barriers to U.S. imports and produced a U.S. trade surplus with all countries in the region. Remittances are another crucial link to the United States, and the growing evidence that they were declining was troublesome. Likewise the economic slowdown in the United States was likely to hurt U.S. tourism to the Dominican Republic and Central America. Drug trafficking and gang violence were an added dimension of U.S.-Central American relationship. The homicide rates in El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras are among the highest in the world. DR-CAFTA, still not full implemented in Costa Rica, has provided the promise of deeper integration within Central America. Financial service providers and companies in retail, real estate and tourism began to develop regional platforms, according to LatinFinance (May 2008). Through the PetroCaribe arrangement to supply petroleum at below-market rates, Venezuela continued to be active in the region. The government of Honduras announced its intention to join Nicaragua as the second Central American, and sixth member of President Chavez's Bolivarian Alternative for the Americas. Central America reported progress in the negotiations with the EU for an FTA. Dominican Republic=: Re-elected president faced softening environment Growth slowed and inflationary pressures increased GDP growth declined in each of the last two years. For 2008 growth was projected to be half of what it was in 2006; 2009 will be lower still. Higher food and energy prices mean higher inflation. A chronic power shortage and periodic blackouts continued to be a drag on the economy and a source of social unrest. External environment presented challenges FDI reached record levels in 2007, but the U.S. slowdown of 2008 meant a drop in Dominican exports, fewer U.S. tourists, and reduced remittances for the large Dominican community in the United States. Although it no longer receives IMF financial support, the Dominican Republic did maintain a monitoring agreement with the Fund. Fernandez won landslide victory and control of Congress Now in his third term, Leonel Fernandez won a first round victory over weak and divided opposition. His victory reflected the persistent importance of personality over institutions in Dominican politics. Belt tightening necessary The Fernandez administration steered the economy through a fast recovery from the bank-failure induced collapse early in this decade. He restored growth, reduced inflation, balanced the budget, and strengthened the peso. He did not succeed in reducing poverty, improving education and health or ending the chronic power shortage and periodic blackouts. In August Fitch warned that the electricity sector was "on the brink of financial distress." The economic slowdown means it will be difficult for the government to maintain its macro- economic policies much less deal with underlying structural problems. Costa Rica=: Strong institutions and solid policies gave stability to environment. Moderate growth and increased inflation Even before September-October global financial crisis spilled over into Latin American, slower GDP growth was expected following three years of strong expansion. Inflation jumped in 2007 but was expected to moderate in 2008. Estimates for the last quarter indicated that inflation would be even higher than earlier forecasts had predicted. External performance still strong Although terms of trade were comparatively weak, exports increased (along with imports and the current account deficit) from 2006 to 2007. FDI also experienced healthy growth, reaching record levels. The economy, nonetheless, began to feel the effects of the slowdown in the United States, which is Costa Rica's major trading partner and source of investment. Costa Rica signed an FTA with the Panama. Arias promised attention to social policy The president promised to give top priority to social policy in the remainder of his term. This will be difficult to achieve given the failure of the long-promised fiscal reforms that would have generated the additional revenue needed to win approval from the National Assembly. Voters narrowly approved DR-CAFTA The October 2007 vote was a victory for the administration, but a year later the agreement was still not fully implemented. Policy focus shifted to containing inflation and stabilizing currency After strengthening against the dollar under the exchange regime adopted in October 2006, the colon began to depreciate in mid-2008. This led the Central Bank to draw on its dollar reserves to prop up the local currency, and to increase the benchmark interest rate in an attempt to curb inflation. DR-CAFTA reforms delayed The opposition in the National Assembly slowed adoption of the required implementing legislation for DR-CAFTA. The delay required two extensions from the other members. Full implementation would open the already investment-friendly Costa Rican economy to U.S. investment, particularly in the previously state-monopolized insurance and telecommunications sectors. El Salvador: Presidential election and deteriorating external situation loomed over improving environment. Satisfactory economic performance Growth (4.5%) in 2007 reached its highest level in over a decade, but it was projected to decline in 2008 and 2009. In August 2008 inflation, which had been effectively contained by dollarization, reached nearly 10%, the highest level in 12 years. Increases in trade and FDI DR-CAFTA membership promoted a big jump in trade (both exports and imports) and record levels of FDI in 2007. Crime and violence constituted serious social problem Presidential election moved to center stage Polls showed Mauricio Funes of the FMLN in the lead for the March 2009 election. Although Funes is from the moderate wing of the leftist party, his victory would be a breakthrough for the former guerrillas, who have won important municipal and congressional contests. It could also bring a policy agenda addressing deep social issues that remained unresolved by the civil war of the 1980s. Guatemala: New administration inherited slowly improving mixed environment Growth moderating and inflation rising After two years of GPD strong growth, economic expansion was expected to slow in 2008 and 2009. The rising cost of food and fuel prices pushed up the cost of living. Impact of DR-CAFTA was mixed FDI and exports jumped in 2007, but imports, the current account deficit, and external debt were also up. For the first time in recent history, Guatemala ran a trade deficit with the United States and faced a decline in remittances. Social environment featured high rates of violence and poverty In 2007 gang and drug-related murders took the lives of 6,000 people. New president lacked legislative majority Although Alvaro Colom became Guatemala's first left-leaning chief executive in 50 years, he promised to pursue a pragmatic, moderate agenda giving priority to social programs and fighting crime. The September discovery of secret surveillance equipment in the president's office underlined the weakness of the presidency and other government institutions. *Policy initiatives required increased revenue To implement his program, Colom inherited a weak fiscal system that chronically under-funded the public sector. Honduras: Another slowly improving environment geared up for presidential election. Strong growth subsided GDP growth, which reached 6.0% in both 2006 and 2007 for the best two-year performance in a long time, was forecast to fall to 4.5% and 4.05 in 2008 and 2009. The rate of inflation nearly doubled from 2006 to 2007. ALBA membership complicated external relations In August the President Zelaya announced that Honduras would join ALBA, the left-leaning trade bloc led by Venezuela. Already benefiting from subsidized Venezuelan oil imports through Petrocaribe, it was not clear what additional benefits would accrue from ALBA membership or if it might conflict with DR- CAFTA membership should the legislature ratify the decision. FDI increased in 2007, but imports grew more than exports, increasing the current account deficit. 2009 presidential election dominatedpolitics Land reform and crime fighting measures adopted Honduran law permits the government to expropriate idle or underproductive agricultural lands. In early 2008, the Honduran legislature approved the expropriation of more than 2,000 hectares of land despite substantial private sector opposition. The government also moved to increase law enforcement and security by passing new laws in June of 2008 designed to strengthen the police and fight corruption. Nicaragua=: Environment continued to be unsettled. Slower GDP growth Tourism, agriculture and trade were leading growth sectors, but economic growth was expected to drop below 3.0% in 2009. The rate of inflation increased in the second half of 2008. Confusing external agenda The Ortega government continued to side with Venezuela while not provoking an all-out confrontation with Washington. The government reached an agreement with its international private creditors in December, which removed overhanging debt and one of the obstacles to foreign investment. FDI increased in 2007. As a sign of the impact of the global crisis on Nicaragua, Venezuela announced in October that it would delay construction of a refinery in Nicaragua. Polarized political environment With collaboration of former president Aleman and his Liberal Constitutional Party, President Ortega began instituting measures the most controversial being creation of Citizens Power Councils that would establish a parallel government and weaken the opposition. Policy agenda lacked coherence Weak legal environment Status of property rights declined (Table 13) in 2007. Panama#: Dynamic environment gearing upfor elections. Signs of overheating GDP grew at almost 10% in 2007 (and 9.5% in the first half of 2008), but inflation reached the highest rate in three decades in August, and was forecast to top 9.0% for the year. Construction, shipping and services were driving growth. Strong inflow of investment funds With a dollarized economy, established financial services and booming real estate market, Panama was an attractive site for foreign investment. LatinFinance (September 2008 issue) reported large increases in net bank deposits from Venezuela, Ecuador and Colombia in recent years. The U.S. Congress had yet to act on the FTA, and its fate was uncertain, even after the November election. Presidential election began to shape political environment Voters go to the polls in May to elect the successor to Martin Torrijos, who presided over the launching of the Canal expansion project and the five-year economic boom. The election underlines the personalistic nature of politics. Strong policy rewarded In February S&P, raised Panama's credit rating to one notch below investment grade, citing the booming economy and improved fiscal indicators. Controversy over security reforms Civic groups and opposition politicians expressed concern over presidential decrees that would create a national intelligence agency to enhance government security powers. Although there was a consensus that something needed to be done to confront rising crime and drug-trafficking, the fact that the measures took the form of executive decrees without open debate harkened back to the military dictatorship. ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Although the five republics that constitute the Andean Community (Chile recently rejoined CAN) prospered from high commodity prices and very favorable terms of trade (Table 2), the region had three of the four least attractive business environments in Latin America. FDI flows (Table 3) indicate that investors were adverse to make long term commitments to Venezuela, Ecuador and Bolivia. In contrast funds poured into Colombia and Peru, both of which had become increasingly attractive to foreign investors in recent years. Disputes among the members of CAN undermined regional integration and further weakened the Community. Most serious was the fallout from Colombia's cross- broader attack in March on a FARC guerrilla camp in Ecuador. In retaliation, Ecuador broke diplomatic relations with Colombia, and Venezuela moved troops to its border with Colombia. Venezuela later backed down from the confrontation because of its heavy dependence on imports from Colombia. In that same vein, President Chavez also put distance between himself and the FARC, the armed guerrilla insurgency that the U.S and Colombian governments charged was supported clandestinely by Venezuela. U.S. relations with Venezuela, Bolivia and Ecuador deteriorated during the year. In September Washington withdrew its ambassadors to La Paz and Caracas after Bolivia - followed by Venezuela in an act of solidarity expelled to U.S. ambassador for interfering in domestic affairs. To add fuel to the fire, the U.S. then declared Bolivia uncooperative in the war against drugs and suspended Bolivia's preferential access to U.S. markets. Until these relationships are mended which will not be easy the business environment in the Andes remains problematic. The U.S. Congress did ratify the free trade agreement with Peru, but the FTA with Colombia remained up in the air. In late September, Congress extended Andean Trade Preference and Drug Eradication Act for another year (with Bolivia suspended from participation). Bolivia #. Environment became even more unsettled. Growth persisted in midst of turmoil GDP growth, averaged over 4.0% for four straight years and seemed likely to exceed this rate in 2008 and 2009, at least until September when serious political unrest threatened to disrupt gas exports, and the uncertainty surrounding international financial markets deepened. Inflation, which more than doubled from 2006 to 2007 declined, although it seems like to finish the year higher than forecast earlier. External position deteriorates The decision to expel the U.S. ambassador (reciprocated by Washington) was a negative signal to investors, while the suspension from the Andean Trade Preference Act hurt export industries that employed thousands of Bolivians. Potential gains from favorable terms of trade were offset by weak investment flows, which were needed in the energy industry. On the positive side, Bolivia continues to reduce its external debt burden. Precarious social environment Regional and ethnic cleavages were raw and deep. The government implemented income transfer and social welfare measures that targeted the poorest segments in South America's poorest (Table 10) country. Struggle between president and governors dominated politics Following a series of provincial votes in favor of autonomy, both President Morales and most of the opposition governors survived the August recall referendum but tension between the central government and eastern provinces seeking greater autonomy remained unresolved and protests increased. The next big test was to come in the December referendum on a new constitution. In early September, the electoral court delayed the referendum. It remained to be seen if the two sides could reach an understanding that would allow the constitutional referendum to take place. Nationalization of hydrocarbon sector completed On May 1 the state oil company YPFB purchased majority ownership of companies still in private hands. At that time President Morales promised to bring all basic services energy, water, and communications under state control. Uncertainty regarding rules of the game in the energy sector discouraged the private investment needed to double natural gas reserves over the next four years under Plan 100. On the macro-economic side, government policies had produced both primary and overall fiscal surpluses and a strong currency, at least until global financial markets collapsed. *No changes in legal environment By most indicators Bolivia continued to have one of the weakest legal environments and one of the least open economies in Latin America. Colombia#: On the way to investment grade? Economic performance softened The economy had made an impressive recovery with GDP growth increasing six years in a row, to reach the highest level in three decades in 2007. Growth began to slow in mid-2008 and was expected to continue dropping in 2009 as both demand for Colombian exports and consumer spending softened. Inflation accelerated in 2008. External performance also softened With the passage of new free trade zone legislation in late 2007 and the subsequent creation of eight new free trade zones, Colombia accelerated already healthy foreign investment inflows. FDI grew to 5.5% of GDP in 2007 up from 1.0% in 2002. In spite of efforts to stem appreciation of the peso, in April the local currency reached its highest level in nine years. However, by early October it had dropped against the dollar. The external debt increased, and the debt burden was among the highest in Latin America. Although the U.S. Free Trade Agreement was still sidetracked, extension the Andean Trade Promotion and Drug Eradication Act maintained Colombia's preferential access to the U.S. market on which it is heavily dependent. Lower violence and higher security strengthened social environment President Urine's effectively reduced violence and extended the government control into the countryside which contributed to strengthening the business environment. Although the guerrilla insurgencies on the left and self-defense forces on the right (both fueled by the drug traffickers as coca and cocaine production increased) remained serious threats, the Democratic Security Policy produced notable results in 2008. In July government forces freed Ingrid Betancourt and other long-time FARC hostages. Earlier in the year they captured or killed key FARC commanders. Uribe's popularity raised prospects of third term Following the Betancourt rescue, the president's popularity surpassed 90%, and 79% of those polled said they supported a third term. It would take another constitutional amendment to allow Uribe to run again. Policy makers must cope with inflation and lower growth The central bank had raised interest rates aggressively in order to contain inflation, but prospects of slower growth may force shift to counter-cyclical stimulus measures. Legal reforms to protect investors To improve protection of investors, the government implemented transparency requirements for transactions between associated companies and electronic tax declarations and simplified accounting rules and double taxation agreements. Ecuador#: Constitutional referendum clarified the environment. Weak economic growth GDP growth the lowest in Latin America economy in 2007 was expected to show little or no increase in 2008 and 2009. Dollarization had kept inflation low, but it showed signs of increasing in 2008. Flat external performance In 2007 FDI was weak; exports did not grow and the external debt increased. Uncertain rules of the game scared off foreign investment. The inefficient state oil company, which was given greater control over the oil industry, could not maintain production to take advantage of the high oil prices that lasted into mid- 2008. The oil price windfall did lead Fitch's and S&P to upgrade the country's credit rating. In October, Ecuador's contract dispute with the Brazilian construction firm Odebrecht over flaws in a hydroelectric project escalated into a confrontation between the two countries. Constitutional referendum gave Correa a big win The majority vote in favor of the new constitution solidified President Correa politically. Standing up to Colombia following the March cross-border raid of a FARC camp earlier had increased his popularity. Unlike his predecessors, Correa seemed likely to serve out his full term, giving Ecuador a degree of political stability that it has not had for a long time. High turn-over in key policy positions Unexpected changes in key ministries, as well as the evolving nature of the new constitution, shaped an uncertain policy agenda. The government resorted to price controls and other unorthodox measures to try and contain inflation. It also continued to expand the government's role in the economy. Legal environment In February the government announced its intention to withdraw from nine bilateral investment accords (including with the United States) that allow investors' recourse to the International Center for Settlement of Investment Disputes. New labor laws were aimed at helping workers stuck in the vast informal economy. It remained to be seen whether the rules yield substantial benefits and whether they will increase or lower foreign investment in Ecuador. Peru#: Contradictory trends hindered march to full investment-grade status Another strong economic performance GDP growth, which exceeded 8.0% in 2007, was declining but still expected to reach 7.0% in 2008. Even as the global crisis spilled over into Latin America, Peru was expected to outperform its neighbors on growth and inflation. FTA and Rating Upgrade enhanced external profile When the U.S. Congress ratified the FTA in December and Fitch's granted investment-grade status in April, Peru strengthened its status as an attractive emerging market. Over the past two years, FDI doubled, and exports more than doubled in three years. These trends allowed Peru to build up its hard currency reserves and dramatically reduce its debt burden. Ratification of the FTA guaranteed permanent preferential trade relationship with the United State, an arrangement enjoyed by no other Andean country. In mid-October, the government announced that it would float a $600m international bond offering, the first Latin American offering since the global credit crisis erupted. Regional inequalities and unrest continued to undermine social environment The economic boom had still not meaningfully trickled down to the very poor southern highlands, although nationally the poverty rate has been cut in half in less than a decade. President governed from position of weakness Much like his predecessor, President Garcia power and popularity (favorable poll ratings around 20%) declined in spite of the economic good news. His government again faced strikes and protests in those regions that had yet to register perceptible benefits. In October, a corruption scandal led to the resignation of the president's cabinet. In an attempt to broaden support, Garcia named an independent leftist politician to be his new prime minister. Proactive fiscal and monetary policies In April the government increased interest rates and the bank reserve requirement to counter rising food prices. It also raised the marginal reserve requirement on short-term investment to slow appreciation of the sol, which reached a nine-year high against the dollar. Legal reforms for agriculture Peru adopted a new legal framework to promote investment in the agro-export sector. It included reorganization of the ministry of agriculture and measures to attract private investment in the highlands and in the Amazon basin. The reform also clarified land tenure issues that remained unresolved since the agrarian reform carried out in the 1960s and 70s by the military government. Venezuela=: Oil prices loomed over risky environment. Deteriorating economic performance By early October, GDP growth, which had slowed considerably from 2006 into 2008, was predicted to drop to below 2.0% in 2009, largely due to the world financial crisis and recession. More bad news came in the form of accelerating inflation, which reached 30% in October. High oil prices fueled aggressive external posture Again in 2007 the oil windfall generated large trade and current account surpluses and hard currency reserves. These gains financed President Chavez's drive to remake Venezuela, allowing Chavez to nationalize foreign firms with compensation, sponsor generous social welfare programs, and pursue soft-power foreign policy initiatives while eschewing private investment. In 2007 there was a net outflow of FDI. Venezuelan flight capital ($19bn according to the central bank) moved to Panama and South Florida, among other places. Before the drop in oil prices, Moody's had indicated that it was considering upgrading Venezuela's credit rating. The sharp drop in prices (combined with stagnant production) would reduce the flow of resources if they persisted and necessitate drawing on reserves. Poverty down but crime and violence up November elections next test for Chdvez Voters gave the administration a serious political defeat when they rejected the December referendum that called for deep constitutional reforms. The president, now in his 10th year in office, puts his government on the line again in November in state and local elections. The Supreme Court issued a ruling in August removing some opposition candidates from the ballot because of pending corruption charges. The government withdrew a proposal to strengthen the intelligence services because of opposition from human rights groups and the Catholic Church, but in September it expelled two human rights observers, provoking international criticism. State's role in the economy expanded In spite of the referendum's defeat, the president resorted to executive degrees to press ahead with his campaign to build 21st Century socialism. The August announcement that the government would nationalize the Banco de Venezuela owned by Santander of Spain meant that the state had taken control of oil, telecommunications, electricity, steel, and cement. Price controls (on some 400 items) and exchange controls (setting the Bolivar-dollar rate at 2.5) implemented to fight inflation and stabilize the currency produced shortages and black marketeering. MERCOSUR REGION Steps to broaden South American integration overshadowed Mercosur developments during the year. In December, seven South American countries formally agreed to create the Bank of the South as a regional development bank. Proponents advanced two reasons for the bank: first, as a way to break dependence on the conditionality of the international lending institutions (especially the IMF) and, second, to deepen South American integration. However, it was not clear whether the bank would have the resources and the resolve to become a major player given the differences between Venezuela and Brazil and their respective influence the bank's mandate and operating structure. A more promising breakthrough came in May when 12 South American countries founded the South American Union of Nations, or Unasur. Its ambitious agenda called for regional parliament, a common currency, and a South American defense council. Under the Unasur banner, Bolivia's neighbors played a constructive role in defusing the conflict in that country and bringing the government and separatist opposition to the table for talks. The new bloc may also prove useful in coordinating South American infrastructural development. Whether it can give the region a greater voice on the world stage remains to be seen, especially given the underlying foreign policy differences between Venezuela and Brazil. President Chavez's Bolivarian Alternative for the Americas (ALBA) did not contribute to South American integration. As for Mercosur, in September Argentina and Brazil agreed to use local currencies instead of the dollar in bilateral trade. Chile and Bolivia made some headway in resolving their longstanding border dispute, and opening Bolivian access to the Pacific. Argentina : New administration presided over deteriorating environment Growth slowing and inflation increasing Argentina had enjoyed five years of impressive growth, but even before the global turmoil of September-October, GPD was decelerating, while inflation was accelerating. Independent analysts put inflation higher approaching 30% in 2008 than what is officially reported. Price controls further clouded the inflation picture. Government took steps to re-enter global credit markets Favorable terms of trade persisted into the second half of 2008, sustaining balance of trade and current account surpluses. But FDI dropped in 2007, and Argentina's external position weakened. In late August the sovereign bond spread against U.S. treasuries reached the widest mark since 2005 (and one of the highest in the world). Doubts grew about longer term ability of the country to service its debt in the face of softening commodity markets and unsettled fiscal policy. S&P downgraded Argentina's credit ratings in August. Largely shut out of international debt markets, Argentina had relied on Venezuela to finance its debt. To reassure creditors, in early September the government announced it would draw on its reserves to pay off the $6.7bn Paris Club debt. Later it revealed that the government was seeking to reach agreement with private bondholders who held out for better terms than were offered in the 2005 default settlement. Economic recovery continued to reduce unemployment and poverty President weakened by decline in public support and legislative defeat Cristina Fernandez's first year in office was difficult. Following her losing standoff with agricultural exporters and subsequent defeat in Congress (thanks to the tie-breaking vote of her vice president) in July, the president's public opinion ratings dropped to around 20%. No longer assured automatic support of her Peronista movement, she had to find new ways of to move forward as a consensus-builder. Government made policy concessions then proposes take-over ofpensions Giving in to the striking farmers, the government revoked the tax increase on grain exports. It also lifted the freeze on residential electricity rates that were in place since 2001. This action recognized the need to revive private investment in the power sector and, second, cut costly utility subsidies to middle and upper class consumers. In late October the president announced that she wanted to nationalize the privatized pension system. *Legal environment The regulation in force since 2002 that required a double indemnity payment for dismissal of workers was eliminated in a step to free up labor markets. Brazil: Investment grade rating conferred full BRIC status. Ratings upgrade strengthened external profile GDP growth, which in 2007 was the highest in more than a decade, began to slow in 2008, even before the October crisis. Inflation grew during the course of 2008 prompting the central bank to progressively raise the benchmark SELIC interest rate. Inflation then it showed signs of diminishing in August and September. Through most of the year higher interest rates did not weaken the consumer boom that had been fueled by expanding credit. The stock market boomed in 2007, but it declined during most of 2008, down 28% in dollar terms in mid-September. By early October the market was off over 50% for the year. Rating agencies rewarded Throughout 2007 and into 2008, Brazil's external performance was very impressive. Thanks to favorable terms of trade, exports boomed, yielding a healthy current account surplus. FDI returned to high levels, the real appreciated, and the debt load declined. For the first time in its history in January the country became a net foreign creditor when its cash reserves exceeded the foreign debt. At mid-year S&P and Fitch's rewarded this performance with investment grade ratings, lowering the cost of credit, and further enhancing investor confidence in Brazil. Improved social environment A recent household survey documented small but encouraging social improvements: growing per capital income; declining inequality; lower illiteracy and declining fertility. According to the Getulio Vargas Foundation, 52% of the population was middle class (versus 44% in 2002 as defined in terms of formal sectorjobs, access to credit and ownership of a car or motorbike). August unemployment (7.6%) was near historic lows. Strong regional variations persisted in all measures of social welfare. Local elections dominated politics The outcome of the October elections was indecisive. Earlier in 2008 Congress did vote down the bill to renew the financial transactions tax (CPMF) forcing the government to find new revenue streams. Policy shiftsfromfighting inflation to stimulating the economy Up to the September-October financial markets crisis, fiscal and monetary policy had focused, respectively, on building a budget surplus and holding down inflation by raising interest rates. With the crisis, the Central Bank moved quickly to protect liquidity in the local market, and opened new credit facilities for key sectors in the economy. It also sold dollars to stem depreciation of the real, which lost 30% of its value in two months. Following the discoveries of large offshore oil deposits, the government announced that it was considering creating a new state-owned enterprise to manage oil resources. This would allow Brazil to capture the promised revenue windfall for social spending. But it would also undermine Petrobras, and fundamentally alter Brazil's mixed public-private energy model. The government also proposed to set aside 15% of international reserves in a sovereign wealth fund that would invest in higher-yielding (and higher risk) securities. Measures strengthened legal environment Brazil strengthened its corporate governance, which enhanced its attractiveness for both portfolio and direct foreign investment. The Brazilian Securities Commission (CVM) issued new accounting and auditing rules based on International Accounting Standards Board standards. The use of market price in valuations, and new requirements in the reporting of capital, tangible and intangible accounts were among the most significant changes. The new rules applied initially directly to all Sociedade Anonimas and larger consortium, but were expected to expand to cover most Sociedade Limitadas. Chile=: Strong environment prepared for political transition and economic downturn. Inflation jumped and growth moderated Early in 2008 rising food and energy costs pushed inflation to its highest rate in over a decade. GDP growth was projected to drop under 4.0% in 2008 and 2009 Falling copper prices threatened to weaken external performance Strong export growth and record FDI flows in 2007 produced a balance of payments surplus and record levels foreign reserves. The result was as appreciation of the peso against the dollar. Falling copper prices and global financial turmoil triggered rapid depreciation of the peso and fall in the dollar value of Chilean equities. Increased spending on education and healthcare Municipal elections were a prelude to 2009 presidential contest Observers looked to the October elections for a clearer sense if divisions within the center-left Concertaci6n coalition that governed since the return to democracy in 1990 would open the door for victory by the candidate of the center-right opposition in the presidential election. The Bachelet presidency, never as strong as its predecessors, was further weakened when her education minister was forced to resign for financial mismanagement, and the opposition parties won control of both house of Congress following desertions from the Concertacion. Policies addressed rising inflation and slowing growth In August the government announced a $1 billion package of tax cuts and spending to reign in inflation and stimulate growth (with an emphasis on encouraging alternative energy development). In September the Central Bank raised the benchmark interest rate to 8.25%, the highest in this decade. The rate was expected to finish the year at 9.5%, as bank authorities sought to bring inflation back under 3.0% in 2009. Earlier in the year, Congress approved significant reforms of the path-breaking privatized pension system and of the education system. Changes in capital market regulations proposed In August the government announced that it would liberalize rules on both equity and fixed-income trading in order to boost trading volumes and make local capital markets more attractive to foreign investors, Paraguay#: New administration confronted high expectations and fluid politics Positive economic performance Although GDP growth slowed in 2008 from the big jump in 2007, it was still well above the ten-year average. Inflation was projected to be lower than 2007, although it could spike up depending food and energy prices. Improved external profile Exports showed strong growth in 2007. Even though imports also increased, the country achieved a current account surplus. Soy exports jumped from $1.9bn in 2006 to $2.7 in 2007 when cultivation expanded to profit from booming global demand. Increasing FDI and international reserves complemented the export boom. These developments, plus the prospect of political stability, made it possible for Paraguay to consider a return to the sovereign bond market. President Lugo worked to balance Paraguay's relations with the United States and Venezuela, and to renegotiate the bilateral energy agreement with Brazil as a means to increase Paraguay's share of profits. Danger of rural violence Landless peasants threatened to escalate farm seizures if the new government did not carry through on its promise to institute agrarian reform. Much of the contested land is occupied by large soy farms owned by Brazilian immigrants. The new government announced that it would restrict soy cultivation in certain regions. April election ended six decades of Colorado rule Although the victory ofFernando Lugo was clearly a call for change, it did not give the leftist former priest a majority in congress. Instead he must govern through the multiparty Patriotic Alliance for Change and the opposition parties, which negotiated leadership positions in Congress in return for their support. In early September rumors of coups shook the political environment. Lugo lays out pragmatic policy agenda In naming a U.S-trained and widely respected economist as finance minister (a post he held for two years under the previous government), the president signaled early on that he would adhere to orthodox monetary and fiscal policies. He also promised to seek more private investment in order to reach a targeted GDP growth of 5-6.0% over the next five years. But he was also committed to implementing agrarian reform and other measures to narrow the gap between rich and poor, and to reduce poverty. Commitment to combat corruption promising for legal environment Like all Presidents, Lugo promised to reduce his country's notorious corruption, but as a political outsider he was more credible than his Colorado predecessors. In June 2008, the government implemented substantial tax reforms in the energy sector to reduce dependence on oil in favor ofbio-fuels. Duties were removed on the importation of used flex-fuel vehicles. In 2009 consumer taxes on ethanol and bio-diesel will be slashed from 10% to just 2%. Uruguay#: Attractive environment preparedfor national elections. Fifth consecutive year of strong growth The controversial pulp plant that began production in November 2007 helped boost industrial growth by 20.5%, and overall GDP growth by 13.1% in the first half of 2008. Internal demand was strong, but inflationary pressures were rising. In July the government announced that the discovery of a large offshore natural gas deposit. If confirmed, the resource would help reduce the country's heavy dependence on imported energy, generate new exports earnings (to Argentina), and attract major new foreign investments. Positive external profile Both exports and FDI continued strong growth, which led to significant appreciation of the peso. Major new foreign investment projects were announced for the pulp industry. In its July upgrade of the sovereign debt rating, S&P expressed concern about the country's high debt burden and the need for fiscal consolidation. Also in July, Moody's reported that the banking system had made a full recovery from the 2002 crisis that wiped out several big banks. October 2009 elections to select successor to popular president During his term, Tabare Vazquez, a left-leaning politician, succeeded in holding a diverse governing party together and guiding it along a moderate path that made the business environment quite attractive. Therefore, there was much interest in who would succeed him. * Solid macro fundamentals and heavy infrastructure investment The Central Bank gradually shifted from an exchange rate anchor to an inflation- targeting regime. * Banking sector reforms The regulatory environment in banking was strengthened by legislation passed in 2008 that enhances the autonomy and powers of the central bank. III. OUTLOOK OUTLOOK FOR THE REGION Throughout much of 2008 it appeared that Latin America would survive the turmoil in global credit markets and the slowdown in the U.S. and European economies. Many observers pointed out that the region was reconfiguring decouplingng") its articulation with the global economy; others that Latin America had put into place economic policies that would protect it from the external shocks of previous decades. With the September-October collapse of credit markets, and the increased probability of that a global recession would affect emerging markets, the outlook for Latin America over the next 15 months became more problematic. Before assessing prospects for the 18 countries in the next section, we examine the outlook for each component of the regional business environment. For each component and each country, we indicate whether it is likely to get better (,), get worse (+), or stay the same (=) through 2008. We use "?" to indicate an uncertain outlook. We further identify key variables to monitor in the coming 12-15 months. External Environment SGlobal When the U.S. sub prime exploded into a full blown global financial meltdown, it became clear that Latin America would not escape unscathed in spite of taking the prescribed and applauded precautionary measures to make its economies less vulnerable to external shocks (building current account surpluses and hard currency reserves, pursuing trade diversification, reducing foreign debt and adopting flexible exchange rates) As the world economy sank into recession in the last quarter of 2008, the commodity bull markets of the last seven years came to at least a temporary end. By mid-October, oil had dropped 44%; corn and wheat more than 40%; and metals more than 33%. These were the very commodities that sustained the economic boom of the South American economies and Mexico. The disappearance of credit also had negative consequences for Latin American equity markets, debt financing, and FDI. Keys: Global recovery; stabilization of commodity and credit markets. *Regional# The new U.S. administration will take office with U.S.-Latin American relations at their lowest level in decades. Added to anger over post-9/11 neglect and unilateralism, Latin Americans blame the 2008 global meltdown on the United States. Although both of the presidential candidates promised to improve relations with the south, their commitments were vague and resources will be increasingly scarce. Regardless of which candidate wins, it will be difficult to revive the free trade agenda, which anchored hemispheric relations through the 1990s and into this decade. Immigration reform that is appealing to Latin America will prove difficult, especially during an economic downturn. Hugo Chavez shows not sign of backing away from his campaign to fashion a new world order that envisions diminished role for the United States. Declining oil prices may reduce the resources available to him, but a serious economic crisis could just as easily help bring to power governments aligned with his cause. It is important that Brazil continue to quietly counter balance Venezuela in South American regional politics. Recognizing that the global financial crisis posed a serious threat, the regional lending agencies led by the Inter-American Development Bank set up emergency lines of credit for countries in the region. Keys: New U.S. administration; South American power politics Domestic Environment Economic and Financial Performance # Instead of expanding at around 4.0% as forecast earlier in the year, Latin American growth in 2009 is now expected to fall below 2.0% with only Peru of the major economies to exceed 2.0% while Mexico may not grow at all. Countries such as Argentina and Ecuador that need to secure debt funding on international markets could be especially hurt by the credit crisis. The predicted slowdown may lessen inflationary pressures. Keys: Commodity prices; fiscal and monetary policy adjustments Social Environment 0 The predicted economic downturn could stop if not reverse the social gains achieved in recent years unless governments are able to act in a counter-cyclical fashion and invest in resources special aid programs. Key: Length and depth of economic downturn; programs to fight unemployment and poverty Political Environment? Latin America's growing economic problems will likely have political consequences. This could mean that voters will be cautious and choose the candidates that promise to stay the course. It is equally possible especially in light of the post-1990s evolution of politics voters would opt for candidates who promise to break with the policies responsible for current problems. The latter course favors the leftist-populist parties and candidates. Keys: Elections in El Salvador, Honduras, Panama, and Uruguay; constitutional referendums in Bolivia and Ecuador Policy Environment? Countries that adhere to prudent macro-economic policies, and limited but effective state intervention in their economies, are better positioned to cope with the deteriorating external environment through the implementing counter-cyclical measures. They are likely to fare better compared to countries that did not set aside some of the commodity windfall in a rainy day fund. In is possible that a prolonged economic downturn will drive countries further from the policy prescriptions of the New Economic Model in favor populist, statist solutions. On two previous occasions, external shocks culminated in major paradigm shifts: the first, in the 1930s and 1940s, led to a shift from an export-led growth model to inward-looking development with import substitution. The second, in the 1980s, promoted the New Economic Model currently in vogue. Keys: Orthodox counter-cyclical measures vs. radical policy options Legal Environment= The financial crisis may convince Latin American governments to tighten regulation of financial markets. Key: Financial market reforms COUNTRY OUTLOOKS This section divides the 18 countries into three categories according to the overall character of their business environments attractive, problematic or mixed in 2008, and then assesses the outlook for each through 2009. As 2008 winds down, the outlook for next year for all 18 countries is not encouraging, but some are better equipped than others to manage the deterioration that is certain to occur. Attractive Environments The number of countries with attractive business environments has increased during the economic cycle that may be ending. With the addition of Brazil there are now eight countries in this category. All eight have achieved high, sustained growth while bringing inflation down and keeping it there. They have adhered to the recommended macro-economic policies, and their external performance has allowed them to build up reserves that will help them defend themselves against the external shocks. Although Costa Rica and Uruguay have a less orthodox policy environment, they share with Chile stable politics, strong institutions, and adherence to rule of law, assets that enhance investor confidence. In contrast, both Panama and Peru have produced high rates of growth but their institutions are not as stable and transparent. Mexico, the Dominican Republic and Brazil fall between the two extremes. Mexico # For this open economy which is tightly linked to the United States, 2009 will be a difficult year. Thanks to measures adopted since 1994, the result will not be a balance of payments crisis leading to the collapse of the peso. Rather the U.S. recession will translate into declining exports, reduced tourism, reduced investment, and a drop in remittances. Revised forecasts in October predicted no GDP growth in 2009. Keys: U.S. recovery Dominican Republic 4 President Fernandez guided the Dominican Republic through a successful recovery during his just completed second term for which he was rewarded with a re-election. But during his third term, it will be difficult for the Dominican Republic to remain as one of Latin America's most dynamic economies. In addition to copying with an unfavorable external environment, the DR must show progress on the perennial problems, such as unreliable electricity and high poverty. Key: U.S. recovery Costa Rica # Costa Rica's conservative monetary policy helped avoid direct damage from the September financial markets crisis, but it cannot escape the secondary effects of the crisis because of its heavy dependence on the U.S. for exports, investment and tourism. Key: U.S. recovery Panama #? The environment will become more unsettled as the presidential campaign heats up. Much will depend on who wins. The nominee of the governing Revolutionary Democratic Party, Balbina Herrera, is running as a populist with ties to the business community. The influential business community may throw it support behind one of two other major candidates. Should Herrera prevail her support of Manuel Noreiga at the time of the 1989 U.S. invasion may become an issue in congressional ratification of the FTA. Key: May election * Peru # Even before the global financial crisis began, the two other rating agencies had failed to follow Fitch's lead in granting Peru investment-grade rating. Social unrest and the declining popularity of the president persisted. With solid macro- economic policies and strong currency reserves, Peru was better positioned to cope with the crisis, but it will be affected in a way the will further delay full investment-grade standing. Growth is unlikely to surpass 4.0% in 2009, and presidential elections are coming up in 2010. Keys; Commodity prices; domestic politics * Brazil= Because of effective macro-economic policies, diversified trading partners, strong FDI flows, and lower debt ratios, Brazil seemed better positioned to avoid or cope with an external shock of the type that threw its economy into crisis in the past, but it became increasingly apparent that as the international credit crisis evolved into a global economic slowdown Brazil would not escape serious consequences. Slower growth is inevitable. The questions are how slow, for how long and at what political cost? Keys: Globalfinance and economics * Chile= While it is undeniable that no economy except Venezuela has benefited more from soaring commodity prices, it is also true that Chile has managed the copper windfall better than the other commodity exporters. Because of strong surpluses, a large rainy day fund, and a strong, proactive central bank, the slowdown will be moderate. Likewise, although the 2009 political environment may become more unsettled because of the presidential election, strong institutions and moderate politics assure that policy will hold steady, even if the conservative opposition win the presidency. Keys: Price of copper; inflation; divisions in governing coalition * Uruguay= As the ruling Frente Amplio and the two traditional parties maneuver to select their presidential nominees, the environment will become more uncertain. President Tabare Vazquez supports his economic minister as the Frente standard bearer who would continue with his program, but neither his nomination nor election is a sure thing. Should neighboring Argentina default and/or enter into recession, the consequences would again be costly for Uruguay. Keys: October 2009 elections; developments in Argentina Problematic Environments The four countries that have the least business-friendly environments in Latin America share several key characteristics. First, they have opted to pursue populist policy agendas that feature heterodox macro-economic policies and an expanded role for government in the economy. Second, their politics are unsettled but tend toward concentrating power in the hands of the president at the expense of the other branches of government and the political opposition. Third, the rule of law is weak, especially in regarding property rights and protection of foreign investment. Fourth, with the exception of Nicaragua, they are all energy exporters. Once a source of strength, the last is quickly becoming a weakness as energy prices plummet. Nicaragua= Like the other Central American economies, Nicaragua is likely to be disproportionately hurt by the global financial crisis and slowdown. Polarized politics makes the Nicaraguan environment more problematic than in neighboring countries. The Ortega government seems determined to consolidate power by creating a hybrid "Citizens Power" version of the 1980s Sandinista and Venezuelan Bolivarian models. While declining global energy prices may reduce inflationary pressures, they may also force Venezuela to reduce its subsidies to Nicaragua Keys: U.S. recovery; domestic politics Venezuela 0 High oil prices have funded President Chavez's activist agendas. Domestically the windfall meant that there were revenues to expand state participation in the economy and finance social projects. On the foreign side, it allowed him to challenge U.S. hegemony in the hemisphere and in world using subsidized oil to recruit allies to his Bolivarian and ALBA causes. What is the future on these projects without the oil windfall? One estimate fixes $95 a barrel as the price necessary for Venezuela to balance its budget. In 2000 it was only $34. In October, oil prices were under $70 per barrel, down 50% from their peak earlier in the year. What will be the political impact of a deteriorating current and fiscal accounts and a stagnant economy? The November elections will give some idea of prospects for the Chavez paradigm in austere times. Keys: Oil prices; November elections Bolivia= The environment in Bolivia deteriorated in the last half of 2008, and it is difficulty to see an easy way out of the current political stalemate. Should the government and opposition find common ground and should the December constitutional referendum take place, we would at least have a more stable environment. U.S.-Bolivian relations also have to be repaired before the outlook can become more promising. Key: Discussions with opposition; constitutional referendum; U.S. relations Ecuador With approval of the new constitution, Ecuador took a step toward bringing order to its volatile politics. It has had eight presidents in the last decade. Correa, who is very popular, could serve two more four-year terms until 2017. Although the new constitution strengthens the executive branch and broadens the economic and social powers of the government, it is less radical than those proposed in Venezuelan and Bolivia. Until elections are held for all levels of government, uncertainty about the rules of game will persist. Continuing decline in oil prices will create serious balance of payments and fiscal problems for Ecuador. Failure to resolve its differences with Brazil over Oderbrecht will increase the investment risk. Keys: Oil prices; Elections mandated by new constitution; relations with Brazil. Mixed Environments The mixed environments have all strengthened in recent years. The improvement in several was so significant that they were upgraded to attractive. However, 2009 will bring an end to the upward trend, both because of external events beyond their control and domestic factors that have left them vulnerable to external shocks. The deterioration of Argentina, which has taken place throughout 2008, could lead its environment becoming seriously problematic in 2009. *El Salvador # In September S&P downgraded the sovereign credit outlook for El Salvador because of political uncertainty and persistent social problems, especially high crime rates. Until a new president is elected, uncertainty will remain. If the candidate of the leftist FMLN prevails and if he pursues the pragmatic leftist agenda, the environment will improve. Keys: March elections and composition of new government; U.S. recovery * Guatemala= Alvaro Colom's election represents progress for a weak environment that has been making marginal improvements in recent years. However, in governing the new president faces the triple reality of the rapidly deteriorating external environment to which is his economy is closely tied by trade and financial flows, daunting social problems, and the need to govern in the context of shifting legislative coalitions. Keys: U.S. recovery; domestic politics * Honduras # One of the poorest countries in the region, Honduras has experienced modest improvements in recent years. Now the weak external environment and the uncertainty of national elections threaten the business environment. Keys: National election; U.S. recovery * Colombia Under the presidency of Alvaro Uribe, Colombia has made impressive strides on both the security and economic front under the presidency of Alvaro Uribe. However, declining oil prices and the global credit meltdown will have significant negative consequences by lowering fiscal revenues and forcing budget cuts and by drying up the international liquidity that funded economic expansion. Reduced domestic demand and lower growth are inevitable. A growing balance of payments deficit will postpone investment grade rating. Keys: Global growth and recovery offinancial markets; U.S. FTA * Argentina # Even before the financial market turmoil of September and October, there were doubts about Argentina's ability to avoid another default. As the global crisis deepened, it assumed the proportions of a classic external shock. First, declining commodity prices and world demand will mean declining exports resulting in current account and fiscal deficits. Second, highly risk adverse credit markets are unlikely, given its past history, to provide Argentina either the investment funds or debt financing it will need to stay out of the red and avoid a serious economic downturn. The October proposal to nationalize the private social security system caused great consternation at home and abroad. Keys: Global growth and recovery offinancial markets; nationalization of social security funds * Paraguay With the election of Fernando Lugo, Paraguay entered a new political era, but the president must now push his ambitious agenda, which includes agrarian reform and negotiating new energy agreements with Brazil, through the tenuous Patriotic Alliance for Change in Congress and a bureaucracy staffed with Colorado party faithful. Keys: Commodity prices; unity of congressional coalition; relations with Brazi TABLES Table 1 GDP GROWTH, 1997-2008 Table 2 ANNUAL INFLATION, 1997-2008 Table 3 TERMS OF TRADE, 1998-2007 Table 4 NET FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT, 1998-2007 Table 5 EXPORTS, IMPORTS AND CURRENT ACCOUNT BALANCE, 2004- 2007 Table 6 GROSS DISBURSED EXTERNAL DEBT, 1998-2007 Table 7 DEBT/EXPORT RATIO, 1998-2007 Table 8 EXCHANGE RATES AND IMF AGREEMENTS, 2008 Table 9 SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT, 2008 Table 10 POLITICAL ENVIRONMENT, 2008 Table 11 CENTRAL GOVERNMENT BALANCE, 2003-2007 Table 12 LEGAL ENVIRONMENT, 2008 Table 13 LEGAL ENVIRONMENT, 2008 Table 1 GDP GROWTH, 1998-2008 (Percentage Change) 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 20071 Average 1998-2007 20082 NAFTA REGION Mexico 5.0 3.8 6.6 0.0 0.8 DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES Dominican Republic Cosia Pica El Salvador Gualemala Honduras Nicaragua Panama ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia Colombia Ecuador Per Li Venezuela MERCOSUR REGION Argentina Brazil Chile Paraguav Uruguay LATIN AMERICA AND CARIBBEAN 8.3 6.1 84 82 3.7 3.4 5 0 3 2.9 -1.9 3.7 7.0 7.4 4.0 5.0 0.4 0I 6 -4 2 2.1 -6.3 0.3 -6.0 3.9 -3.4 0 1 0: 8 3.2 -0.8 406 -15 4.5 -2.8 7.9 2.3 5.0 18 11 29 2.2 1.7 2.3 6 23 22 5.7 2.6 2.7 4.1 3.0 0.8 2.7 0.6 2.2 2.5 1.7 2.5 29 15 19 2.8 5.3 4.2 3 0 02 52 3.7 3.4 -8.9 -0.8 -4.4 -10.9 44 13 1 9 4.5 3.4 2.2 -33 21 0 0 -1.4 -3.4 -11.0 2.5 0.2 3.9 0.3 -0.5 1.4 4.2 3.0 -0.4 2.7 9.2 64 4 1 59 2.3 1.8 2.8 21 27 32 3.5 5.0 4.1 2.5 5.1 4.0 4.2 7.5 6.9 2.9 3.9 4.1 39 49 52 3.6 7.9 4.7 3 52 64 -7.7 17.9 9.3 8.8 9.0 9.2 0 5 4 23 3.9 6.2 6.3 38 41 29 2.2 11.8 6.6 2.1 6.2 4.6 SOURCE: ECLAC Preliminary Overview of the Economies of Latin America and the Caribbean, 2007 1 Preliminary estimates for Year 2007 from ECLAC 2 Preliminary estimates for Year 2008 from IMF Economic Outlook 2008 3 Includes Antigua and Barbuda, Bahamas, Barbados, Belize, Dominica, Grenada, Guyana, Jamaica, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Suriname and Trinidad and Tobago 3.3 2.0 3.1 4.43 Table 2 ANNUAL INFLATION, 1998-2008 (Percentage variation in CPI, December through December) 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 20071 20082 NAFTA REGION Mexico DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES Dominican Republic Costa Pica El Salvador G.ualemala Honduras licaragLua Panama ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia Colombal Ecuador Venezuela MERCOSUR REGION Argentina Brazil Chile Paraguay Uruguay 18.6 12.3 9.0 4.4 5.7 4.0 5.2 3.3 4.1 7.8 5.1 9.0 4.4 10.5 42.7 28.7 7.4 5.0 124 1"0 1 102 11 0 9 7 99 131 14 1 94 4.2 -1.0 4.3 1.4 2.8 2.5 5.4 4.3 4.9 ;5 49 51 89 63 59 92 86 58 15.7 10.9 10.1 8.8 8.1 6.8 9.2 7.7 5.3 185 ;2 99 4 ; 40 66 89 96 102 1.4 1.5 0.7 0.0 1.9 1.5 1.5 3.4 2.2 4.4 3.1 3.4 0.9 2.4 3.9 4.6 4.9 4.7 167 92 88 76 7 65 55 49 45 43.4 60.7 91.0 22.4 9.3 6.1 1.9 3.1 3.1 60 3; 3; -0 1 15 25 35 15 1 1 29.9 20.0 13.4 12.3 31.2 27.1 19.2 14.4 17.0 0.7 -1.8 -0.7 -1.5 41.0 3.7 6.1 12.3 0.0 17 89 60 77 125 93 6 57 31 4.7 2.3 4.5 2.6 2.8 1.1 2.4 3.7 2.6 146 54 86 84 146 93 28 99 125 8.6 4.2 5.1 3.6 25.9 10.2 7.6 4.9 6.4 LATIN AMERICA AND CARIBBEAN 10.0 9.7 9.0 6.1 12.2 8.5 7.4 6.1 5.0 6.1 6.64 SOURCE: ECLAC, Preliminary Overview of the Economies of Latin America and the Caribbean, 2007 1 Preliminary estimates for Year 2007 from ECLAC 2 Preliminary estimates for Year 2008 from IMF Economic Outlook 2008 3 Twelve-month variation up to October 2007 4 Includes Antigua and Barbuda, Bahamas, Barbados, Belize, Dominica, Grenada, Guyana, Jamaica, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Suriname and Trinidad and Tobago 3.9 3.5 3.5 1L] 1 2.7 9 1 9.6 128 5.53 11.9 54 2.7 72 20.7 Table 3 TERMS OF TRADE, 1998-2007 (2000=100) 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 20071 NAFTA REGION Mexico DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES Dominican Republic Cosia Rica El Salvador Guatemala Honduras I icaragIua Panama ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia Colombia Ecuador Peru Venezuela MERCOUSUR REGION Argentina Brazil Chile Paraguay Uruguay LATIN AMERICA AND CARIBBEAN 90.6 99.3 100.0 97.4 97.9 98.8 108.0 105.7 100.0 100.9 101.5 97.9 117 5 106 9 100 0 98 J 969 95 5 95.8 99.6 100.0 102.5 101.6 97.7 115 3 11:119 1001 0I 96 7 95 8 93 0 108.9 107.5 100.0 94.8 92.0 88.0 796 953 1000 884 870 841 104.7 104.6 100.0 102.7 101.6 97.2 102.0 97.1 100.0 95.8 96.2 98.5 81 2 87 2 10 0 94 2 925 95 2 75.8 89.1 100.0 84.6 86.8 89.8 103 4 100 8 100 0 5 6 98 J .102 2 51.2 66.1 100.0 82.2 87.6 98.7 96.6 90.9 100.0 99.3 98.7 107.2 1119 970 1000 996 98 4 97i 91.0 94.2 100.0 93.3 97.2 102.8 108 0 101 7 10 0 1. 2 96 7 101 4 104.4 95.9 100.0 104.0 102.6 103.5 91.3 94.5 100.0 96.3 96.6 98.6 101.6 103.6 104.1 104.6 104.1 108 5a 91.5 1113 118.1 109.2 97 9 124.9 104 3 99.9 111.8 117 7 102.4 119 J 154.4 106.9 99 2 139.8 974 90.7 134.6 1152 109.9 151 1 184.4 113.0 103 8 183.7 95 5 88.7 137.2 121 3 114.1 161 8 200.4 116.2 107 8 194.3 99 2 88.7 103.9 109.0 115.1 117.9 SOURCE: ECLAC, Preliminary Overview of the Economies of Latin America and the Caribbean, 2007 1 Preliminary estimates for Year 2007 from ECLAC Table 4 NET FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT, 1997-2007 (Millions of US dollars) 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 Mexico 12,831 12,409 13,631 17,588 21,800 18,154 14,003 14,509 12,460 DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES Dominican Republic Cosia Rica El Salvador Gualemala Honduras licaragua Panama ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia Colombia Ecuador Peru Venezuela 421 404 59 84 122 203 1,299 728 4 753 724 2 054 5,645 5,507 18608: 3,809 2301 113 MERCOSUR REGION Argentina Brazil Chile Faraguav Uruguay LATIN AMERICA AND CARIBBEAN 700 608 1,103 673 99 218 1,203 947 2 033 870 1 582 3,942 4,965 26 0:102 3,144 336 155 1,338 614 162 155 237 33; 864 1,008 1 392 648 1 812 2,018 22,257 26 888 6,203 89 238 734 2 069 720 81'0: 4,180 9,517 30,i 498 873 98 274 1,079 451 289 456 193 150: 467 703 2 509 1,330 1 070': 3,479 2,005 24715 2,590 78 291 674 1 283 1,275 2 156 -244 2,776 14 108 2,207 12 180 195 820: 1,555 1 275 722 878 9 894 2,701 22 401 57.599 60.999 79.923 70.308 63.659 45.213 35.114 909 430 155 325 250:1 1,004 63 2975 1,160 1 599 864 3,832 8 339 5,646 315 1,023 904 300 2,1,8 272 241 1,027 -280 5, 51 1,646 2 579 1,400 3,579 12 550' 4,764 58 715 13,453 1,183 1 371 254 354 489 282 2,574 237 5365 271 3 467 -2,632 2,721 -9 4201 5,076 166,322 1,322 43.149 49.206 28.657 SOURCE ECLAC, Preliminary Overview of the Economies of Latin America and the Caribbean, 2007 1 Preliminary estimates for Year 2007 from ECLAC NAFTA REGION 2004 2005 2006 20071 16,900 1,393 1 657 1,070 536 494 293 1,000 240 6 739 400 -3,200 1,863 32 000 8,411 181 1,000 77.126 Table 5 EXPORTS, IMPORTS AND CURRENT ACCOUNT BALANCE, 2004-2007 NAFTA REGION Mexico DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES Dominican Republic Costa Rica El Salvador Guatemala Honduras Nicaragua Panama ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia Colombia - Ecuador Peru Venezuela MERCOSUR REGION Argentina Brazil Chile Paraguay Uruguay LATIN AMERICAN AND CARIBBEAN 2004 (Millions of US dollars) 2005 2006 20071 Exports Imports C/Account I Exports Imports C/Account I Exports Imports C/Account I Exports Imports C/Account 187,999 196,810 5,936 6,370 3,337 3,368 2,393 1,365 6,078 2,146 17,224 7,968 12,809 39,668 34,576 96,475 32,215 2,863 3,145 7,888 7,791 5,999 7,189 3,677 2,440 7,617 1,725 15,878 7,684 9,805 17,021 21,311 62,835 23,020 3,108 2,992 466.311 405.998 SOURCE: ECLAC, Preliminary Overview of the Economies of Latin America and the Caribbean, 2007 1 Preliminary estimates for 2007 from ECLAC -6,682 214,233 221,820 1,047 -796 -632 -1,211 -404 -696 -1,061 337 -938 -564 19 15,519 3,446 11,679 1,586 138 43 6,146 7,100 3,432 3,701 2,648 1,552 7,591 2,791 21,729 10,427 17,336 55,473 40,106 118,308 40,574 3,266 3,758 9,876 9,230 6,440 8,070 4,188 2,865 8,907 2,341 20,134 9,698 12,076 23,693 27,302 73,560 30,394 3,758 3,730 20.775 1 560.629 479.391 -5,039 226,218 278,087 -500 -964 -786 -1,387 -67 -800 -782 619 -1,981 204 1,105 25,534 5,789 14,193 703 -22 1 10,664 12,748 11,023 12,427 3,594 8,741 5,070 12,750 3,753 6,206 1,925 3,905 12,416 11,927 4,297 3,436 28,554 30,352 14,204 13,764 26,251 18,266 66,669 37,944 54,150 41,138 157,269 120,466 65,620 44,329 5,646 6,167 5,515 5,708 35.873 1 680.123 674.521 -1,994 287,354 305,676 -786 -1,122 -700 -1,592 -355 -855 -552 1,319 -3,057 1,540 2,589 27,167 8,097 13,621 5,256 -110 -436 11,328 12,533 12,515 13,518 5,410 9,650 8,561 14,425 4,087 7,424 2,567 3,735 14,847 14,686 4,684 3,809 32,503 37,443 14,975 14,912 31,057 24,124 70,003 48,641 63,971 51,973 184,979 156,394 77,263 53,133 7,417 7,384 6,297 1,627 47.515 1 843.728 791.261 -6,975 -1,703 -1,346 -926 -1,678 -727 -914 -743 1,471 -6,703 1,468 1,524 22,611 6,500 4,624 7,985 422 -579 23.844 Table 6 GROSS DISBURSED EXTERNAL DEBT, 1998-2007 (Millions of US dollars) 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 Mexico 160,258 166,381 148,652 144,526 DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES Dominican Republic Cosla Pica El Salvador Guatemala Honduras licaragua Panama ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia Colomibia Ecuador Peru Venezuela MERCOSUR REGION Argentina Brazil Chile Paraguay Uruguay 3,546 3 4102 2,646 2 368 4,369 5,349 5,349 3,661 3641 2,789 2 631 4,691 6 568 5,568 3,679 3748 2,831 2644 4,711 6 6604 5,604 4,176 3,148 2 925 4,757 6 374 6,263 4,659 4,573 4,460 4,497 36 681 36 733 36 130 39 09 16,221 15,902 13,216 14,376 30 142 28 586 27 981 27 195 35,087 37,016 36,437 35,398 147,634 152,563 155,015 166,272 223 792 225 610 216 921 2019 935 32,591 34,758 37,177 38,527 2 368 2 996 3275 30:74 5,467 8,261 8,895 8,937 134,980 132,273 130,925 128,255 116,653 122,938 4,536 5,987 6,380 6,813 7,226 7,242 4 118 4621 4979 4979 4995 IJ/A 3,987 4,917 8,211 8,642 9,305 9,300 3119 3467 3 844 3 23 3 58 4 353 4,922 5,242 5,912 5,103 3,889 2,799 S363 6 596 5391 5348 4 527 3381 6,349 6,504 7,219 7,580 7,788 8,269 4,400 5,142 5,045 4,942 3,248 2,056 37 325 38 :8 39 441 38456 40 162 4304 3 16,236 16,756 17,211 17,237 17,099 17,508 27 872 29 587 31 224 28 657 28 3100 29 637 35.460 40.456 43.679 46.427 44.952 47.256 156,748 210 711 40,504 10,548 10,548 164,645 214 930: 43,067 11,013 11,013 171,205 201 373 43,515 11,593 11,593 113,804 169 450 44,934 31156 11,418 107,886 172 589 47,590 30:28 10,560 116,188 191 358 49,458 11/A 11,910 LATIN AMERICA AND CARIBBEAN 743,457 763,170 738,273 745,702 SOURCE: ECLAC Preliminary Overview of the Economies of Latin America and the Caribbean, 2007 1 Preliminary estimates for Year 2007 are from ECLAC 734,445 763,186 765,825 662,341 647,831 647,696 NAFTA REGION 1998 2006 20071 Table 7 DEBT'IEXPORT RATIO, 1998-2007 (as a percentage of exports of goods and services) 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 20072 NAFTA REGION Mexico 124 112 83 84 78 81 70 60 52 43 DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES Dominican Republic 47 46 41 50 55 67 68 67 67 64 C.sla Rica 42 3; 41 46 46 46 45 37 32 El Salvador 87 88 77 88 105 115 108 109 112 171 Gualemala 68 76 69 75 79 84 85 75 74 51 Honduras 180 210 189 196 196 195 190 148 131 68 Jicaragua 666 680 604 570 557 505 327 287 235 132 Panama 65 78 72 78 84 86 82 71 64 56 ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia 344 349 303 296 283 262 197 151 107 44 ,olontmbia 273 263 229 260", 263 242 21:3 157 137 133 Ecuador 324 298 221 253 264 229 192 150 123 118 PerL 4:00 372 3310 321 3:02 274 210:' 146 1108 95 Venezuela 183 166 105 126 128 141 109 83 61 68 MERCOSUR REGION Argentina 473 546 496 533 538 479 431 245 197 182 Brazil 381 49 336 311 301 257 185 126 99 103 Chile 161 165 160 172 179 162 114 94 70 64 Paraguav 54 95 98 109 121: 1108 83 70 54 Uruguay 132 238 243 274 392 357 270 225 196 189 LATIN AMERICA AND CARIBBEAN 216 211 172 181 178 168 138 101 83 77 SOURCE: ECLAC, Preliminary Overview of the Economies of Latin America and the Caribbean, 2006 1 Gross disbursed external debt includes the public-and-private sector external debt Also includes International Monetary Fund loans 2 Preliminary estimates for Year 2007 from ECLAC Table 8 EXCHANGE RATES AND IMF AGREEMENTS, 2008 US Dollar Exchange Rate Auaust 29. 2008 % change Exchanae Rate Reaime IMF Aareements (Dates) peso peso colon colon/U.S. dollar queLal lempira cordoba oro balboa/U.S. dollar ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia boliviano Colombia peso Ecuador sucre/U.S. dollar Peru nuevo sol Venezuela bolivar MERCOSUR REGION 10.78 32.73 527 8 8.91 7 80 19.22 1873 1.02 8.08 1954 2 1.00 3. 21 2149.0 10.28 34.80 554 95 8.74 7 43 18.90 19 52 6.98 1938 ,00 1.00 2 95 2144.60 4.64% Independent Float -6.32% -5 140o 1.91% 3 70''.:.' 1.66% -4 2200 13.61% 0 83'',: 0.00% 80.20% 0.20% managedd Floal Dollarized Ilanaged Floal Managed Float Ilanaged Floal Dollarized Managed Float Independent Float Dollarized Independent Float Managed and Licensed Stand-bv C 11C-7-2ICci)i Argentina peso 3.08 3.03 1.62% Independent Float Brazil real 1 91 1 6J 1J 13'": Independent Float Chile peso 526.1 512.80 2.53% Independent Float Paraguay guarani 5185 7 39J5 00 23 c93":', Independent Float Stand-bv (5/06-8/08) Uruguay peso 24.16 19.10 22.76% Managed Float SOURCES: New York Times Markets Section Key for IMF Agreements Stand-by is the most common type of credit arrangement designed to provide short-term financial assistance Currency June 19, 2007 NAFTA REGION Mexico DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES Dominican Republic Costa Rica El Salvador Gualemala Honduras Ilicaragua Panama " " Table 9 SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT, 2008 INCOME GROWTH INEQUALITY % GINI index 2 HDI (World rank) 3 2007/2008 POPULATION IN POVERTY 2006 2006 URBAN UNEMPLOYMENT RATE 2006 2006 104.3 NAFTA REGION Mexico DR-CAFTA REGION Dominican Republic Cosla Pica El Salvador GLualemala Honduras I hiCaragLua Panama ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia C) Ccolombia Ecuador Peru Venezuela MERCOSUR REGION Argentina Brazil Chile Paraguay Uruguay 3.3 0.3 3.2 SOURCES: UNDP, Human Development Report2007/2008, CEPAL, Panorama Socialde America Latina 2007 $10,751 $8,217 10 180 $5,255 -4 568 $3,430 I.3674 $7,605 $2,819 1.7 304 $4,341 $6 39 $6,632 44.5 19 0 (2005) 47.5 (2002) 60 2 71.5 (2002) 69 4 30.8 (2005) 63.9 (2005) 46 8 39.9 4 14 5 30.2 21.04 13.7 (2005 60 5 18.54 $14,820 .8 -1402 $12,027 14 642 $9,962 1 GDP per capital (Purchasing Power Parity in $U S ) 1 PPP dollar has the same purchasing power in the domestic economy as 1 U S dollar has in the U S economy 2The Gini index measures inequality over the entire distribution of income or consumption A value of 0 represents perfect equality, and a value of 100 perfect inequality 3 The Human Development Index (HDI) measures a country's achievements in three aspects of human development longevity (life expectancy at birth), knowledge (combination of literacy rate and enrollment ratio), living (GDP per capital PPP in $U S ) 4 Percent of urban population in poverty 5 Data refer to national illiteracy estimates from censuses or surveys conducted between 1995 and 2005, unless otherwise specified and a decent standard of POPULATION (Millions) 2005 AVG. POP. GROWTH 2005-15 2005-15 ILLITERATE POP. (%age 15+) 5 1995-2005 GDP PER CAPITAL (PPP $U.S.)1 2007/2008 1990-2005 ( ( Table 10 POLITICAL ENVIRONMENT, 2008 Level of Democratic Consolidation Election Inaugurating Democracy Unscheduled Head-of-State Changes Political Civil Rights' Liberties2 Current Government President / PM Term NAFTA REGION Mexico DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES Dominican Republic Costa Pica El Salvador Gualemala Honduras I licaragua Panama ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia Colombia Ecuador Peru Venezuela 2000 1963 1949 1984 1985 1982 1984 1994 19803 1958 1978 1980 1958 Calderon Fernandez Arias Saca Colon Zelaya Ortega Torrijos Morales Uribe Correa CGarcia Chavez 2006-2012 2008-2012 2006-2010 2004-2009 2008-12012 2005-2009 200 -2011 2004-2009 2006-2010 2006-20'10 2007-2010 2006-2010 2007-2013 Government Government Opposhon Govt. Coalition Opposlon Opposition Opposition Government Govt. Coalition Government Govt. Coalition Opposition Government MERCOSUR REGION Argentina 19833 4 2 2 C. Kirchner 2007-2011 Government Brazil 1989 2 2 Lula da Silva 2006-2010 Govt Coalition Chile 1989 1 1 Bachelet 2006-2010 Opposition Paraguay 1993 3 3 Lugo 2008-2013 Govt Coallion Uruguay 1985 1 1 Vazquez 2005-2010 Government SOURCE Freedom in the World 2007: Civic Power and Electoral Politics. SFreedom House definition Those rights that enable people to participate freely in the political process On this scale 1 represents the most free and 7 the least free 2 Freedom House definition Freedoms to develop views, institutions and personal autonomy apart from the state On this scale 1 represents the most free and 7 the least free 3 Interrupted democracies Control of Legislature Table 11 CENTRAL GOVERNMENT BALANCE 2003-2007 (Percentages of GDP) Primary balance 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 1 Overall balance 2007 2003 2004 2005 2006 NAFTA REGION Mexico DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES Dominican Republic Costa Rica El Salvador Gualemala Honduras Nicaragua Panama ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia C olombia Ecuador Peru Venezuela MERCOSUR REGION Argentina Brazil Chile Paraguav Uruguay LATIN AMERICA AND CARIBBEAN 2.1 2.5 2.4 2.9 2.6 -0.6 -0.2 -0.1 0.1 0.0 -3.4 -0.6 -1.0 1.0 -27 .2 1 11 1 3 -1.1 -1.0 -0.4 1.0 -1 1 -17 1 9 -2 3 -3.1 -2.6 -1.3 -1.6 -2.2 -1.8 0.0 -0.9 -5.4 -3.9 0.2 -0.5 -5.7 -2.3 3.6 2.1 -54 J J8 1 -3 3 -1.0 -0.5 -0.2 -0.5 -1 3 -07 15 1 8 -1.9 1.6 0.0 0.5 2.0 0.4 1.0 0.7 -12 -32 -3 1 -2 8 2.1 4.5 7.7 8.0 16 01: 0 5 0 0 -2.5 -1.6 -1.0 -1.5 -0.2 0.6 1.5 2.4 2.2 -2.9 -1.9 -1.1 0.1 -0.1 Source Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC), on the basis of official figures 1 Preliminary estimates for the year 2007 from ECLAC Table 12 LEGAL ENVIRONMENT, 2008 NAFTA REGION Mexico DR-CAFTA COUNTRIES Dominican Republic Cosla Pica El Salvador Gualemala Honduras Iilcaragua Panama ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia Colombia Ecuador Peru Venezuela MERCOSUR REGION Argentina Brazil Chile Paraguay Uruguay Rule of Law1 SPercentile Rank Corruption Perception2 i Index Rank | 34.3 37.1 61.9 28.6 11.4 20.5 22.4 50.0 17.6 35.7 14.8 26.7 3.3 39.0 43.3 88.1 16.2 63.3 Economic Freedom3 SScore Rank 66.4 58.5 64.8 79.2 60.5 60.2 60.0 64.7 53.2 61.9 55.4 63.5 45.0 55.1 55.9 79.8 60.5 68.1 Proerty Rights4 Percentile Rank 50 Crime Victimization5 % Yes 75.7 ** 35.7 34.2 41.5 34.2 34.6 28.7 33.8 37.4 40.4 37.8 44.2 47.1 35.6 36 46 27.7 1 As measured by the World Bank's Governance Indicators 1996-2007 the effectiveness and predictability of the judiciary, and the enforceability of contracts The percentages measure the extent to which agents have confidence in and abide by the rules of society, including perceptions of the incidence of crime, 2 As measured by Transparency International, Corruption Perceptions Index 2007 range from 10 (country perceived as virtually corruption-free) to almost 0 (country perceived as almost totally corrupt) The country ranks measure the corruption level in 159 countries as perceived by business people, risk analysts, investigative journalists and the general public 3 As measured by the Heritage Foundation's 20081 ndex of Economic Freedom Scores are based on a 1 to 100 scale, 1 being an economic environment tha is least conducive to economic freedom, 100 being the most conducive Countries are also ranked in order of economic freedom, 1 being the most free 4 As measured by the Heritage Foundation's 20081 ndex of Economic Freedom The percentages measure the degree to which a country's laws protect private property rights and the degree to which its government enforces those laws 100% indicates that private property is guaranteed by the government, 0% indicates that private property is outlawed 5: As measured by Latinobarometro 2002 "Have you, or someone in your family, been assaulted, attacked, or been the victim of a crime in the past 12 months?" Those who response "Don't know" or did not provide an answer were excluded from the results Table 13 LEGAL ENVIRONMENT, 2008 Days Required to' Start a Register Enforce Trade Across Business Propertyb Contractsc Bordersd Paying taxes2 Number of Hours Tax Rate Payments, Requiredb (% Profit), Intellectual Property Estimated Trade Losses due to copyright Piracy in millions USD NAFTA REGION Mexico 27 74 415 17 27 552 51.2 1266 CAFTA-DR Dominican Republic 22 60 460 12 74 286 40.2 12 Cosla Pica ;; 21 877 18 413 402 55 ; 31 5 El Salvador 26 31 786 21 66 224 33.8 17.8 (2001) Gualemala 26 30 1 4539 19 39 344 375 23 8 2002) Honduras 21 24 480 20 47 424 51.4 Nicaragtua 39 124 540 36 64 240 632 " Panama 19 44 686 9 59 482 50.8 ANDEAN SOUTH AMERICA Bolivia 50 92 591 24 41 1,080 78.1 21.8 (2005) Colombia 42 23 1 346 24 69 268 82 4 1165 Ecuador 65 17 498 22 8 600 35.3 51 N) Peru 33 468 24 9 424 415 Venezuela 141 47 510 45 70 864 53.3 174.6 BRAZIL AND SOUTHERN CONE Argentina 31 65 590 16 19 615 112.9 310.7 Brail 152 45 616 18 11 2 600 69 8596 Chile 27 31 480 21 10 316 25.9 127.6 Paraguay 35 46 591 35 35 328 35 3 134 Uruguay 44 66 720 24 53 304 40.7 10.1 (2002) 1 As measured by the World Bank Group's report "Doing Business in 2008 Removing Obstacles to Growth" a) Average time in calendar days spent registering a firm b) Average time in calendar days spent completing the procedures to register property c) Average time in calendar days from the moment a plaintiff files a lawsuit in court until the moment of payment d) Average time in calendar days necessary to comply wth all procedures required to export goods, 2 As measured by the World Bank Group's report "Doing Business in 2008 Removing Obstacles to Growth" a) total number of tax payments per year b) time it takes to prepare, file and pay (or wthhold) the corporate income tax, the value added tax and social security contributions c) total amount of taxes and mandatory contributions payable by the business 3 As measured by the International Intellectual Property Alliance 2008 Country Reports Estimates are based on 2007 losses due to copynght piracy in millions of USD unless year is otherwise noted Industries included in estimates include, sound recordings and musical compositions, business software, entertainment software, motion pictures and books SELECTED SOURCES MONITORED FOR 2008 LABER The Economist Latin America Monitor LatinFinance Wall Street Journal On-line BBC Mundo. com http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/spanish/news/ Brazil Focus: Weekly Report Subscriptions available at fleischer(,aol.com.br Council on Hemispheric Affairs Report http://www.coha.org/ Latin American Newspapers accessible through Latin American Network Information Center at http://wwwl.lanic.utexas.edu/la/region/news/ Latin America Advisor: The Interactive Forum for the Region's Leaders Subscriptions available to mailto:freetrial@,thedialogue.org Manchester Trade Export Performance & Trade Relations www.ManchesterTrade.com Miami Herald www.herald.com New York Times www.nvtimes.com RGE Monitor www.rgemonitor.com Primary Data Sources International Monetary Fund http://www.imf.org/ Organization of American States Foreign Trade Information System http://www.sice.oas.org/ U.N. Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean http://www.cepal.org/default.asp?idioma=IN World Bank: Global Development Finance 2008 http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTGDF2008/Resources/gdf complete web-appended.pdf Latin American Business Environment Program Center for Latin American Studies University of Florida PO Box 115530 University of Florida Gainesville, FL 32611-5530 USA Tel: (352) 392-0375 Fax: (352) 392-7682 www.latam.ufl.edu/labe.html |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| MILLISECOND | CLASS.METHOD | MESSAGE |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | sobekcm_page_globals.constructor | |
| 0 | sobekcm_page_globals.constructor | Application State validated or built |
| 0 | sobekcm_database.verify_item_lookup_object | |
| 0 | sobekcm_page_globals.constructor | Navigation Object created from URI query string |
| 0 | sobekcm_database.verify_item_lookup_object | |
| 0 | sobekcm_page_globals.display_item | Retrieving item or group information |
| 0 | sobekcm_page_globals.get_entire_collection_hierarchy | Retrieving hierarchy information |
| 0 | sobekcm_assistant.get_entire_collection_hierarchy | |
| 0 | cached_data_manager.retrieve_item_aggregation | |
| 0 | cached_data_manager.retrieve_item_aggregation | Found item aggregation on local cache |
| 0 | item_aggregation_builder.get_item_aggregation | Found 'all' item aggregation in cache |
| 0 | system.web.ui.page.page_load (ufdc.page_load) | |
| 0 | sobekcm_page_globals.constructor.on_page_load | |
| 0 | html_echo_mainwriter.add_style_references | Adding style references to HTML |
| 0 | html_echo_mainwriter.add_text_to_page | Reading the text from the file and echoing back to the output stream |
| 40 | html_echo_mainwriter.add_text_to_page | Finished reading and writing the file |