Article Title: "Florida. Message to the President. Amelia was in the hands of 'sea rovers' and a 'system of coercion' was needed to force them to respect the laws of the sea and the rights of property.
Published in: National Intelligencer
Place of Publication: Washington, DC
Publication Date: 1/13/1818
AMELIA ISLANDThe situation of this island being at present the subject of much speculation, we have been at some pains to obtain for early publication a Report made on Saturday last, in the House of Representatives, which throws much light on the motives of the occupation of that position by our government. This report furnishes an allsufficient answer to most of the far-fetched arguments used to justify the opponents of that measure. It is really amusing to find, in some of our newspapers, piracy and smuggling, by a metonymical process, converted into heroism and enterprize, and held up to the admiration of the world, in contrast with the imputed treachery of our government in desiring to remove from its borders those meritorious patriots engaged in it There is but one step from the sublime to the ridiculous, said Napoleon in the nadir of his military career. Those writers have certainly discovered that step, who can find any analogy between our Revolutionary principles and their supporters, and the motives and merits of the soi-disant Republicans, who flit along our borders in search of the most convenient receptacle for the plunder of the ocean. It is a subject of painful regret to the best friends of the republican cause in South America, that so much labor is bestowed to identify the Amelia island party with the real friends of South-American Independence.
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES.
SATURDAY, JAN. 10.
The Speaker laid before the House a letter directed to the Congress of the United States from a certain Carl Theodore Mohr, residing in Wallendorf, in Germany, offering to come to America upon certain conditions, and to establish a manufactory of Porcelain, which was read and ordered to lie on the table.
On motion of Mr. Sergeant, the committee of Ways and Means were instructed to enquire into the expediency of allowing a drawback upon refined sugar exported from the United States.
Mr. Middleton, from the committee on so much of the Message of the President of the United States as relates to the illicit introduction of slaves from Amelia Island into the United States, made the following report :
The committee to whom was referred so much of the President's Message as relates to the illicit introduction of Slaves from Amelia Island, having carefully taken the matter committed to them into consideration, respectfully report:
That having applied to the Department of State for information respecting the illicit introduction of slaves into the United States, they were referred by the Secretrary of State to the documents transmitted to this House by the President's Message of the 15th December last, consisting of various extracts of papers on the files of the Departments of State, of the Treasury, and of the Navy, relative to the proceedings of certain persons who took possession of Amelia Island in the summer of the past year, and also relative to a similar establishment previously made at Galveston near the mouth of the river Trinity.
Upon a full investigation of these papers, with a view to the subject committed to them, your committee are of opinion, that it is but too notorious, that numerous infractions of the law prohibiting the importation of Slaves into the United States have been perpetrated with impunity upon our southern frontier ; and they are further of opinion, that similar infractions would have been repeated with increasing activity, without the timely interposition of the naval force under direction of the Executive of our government. In the course of the investigation, your committee have found it difficult to keep separate the special matter given into their charge, from topics of a more general nature, which are necessarily interwoven therewith : they therefore crave the indulgence of the Hourse, while they present some general views, connected with the subject, which have developed themelves in the prosecution of their enquiry.
It would appear from what had been collected from these papers, that numerous violations of our laws have been latterly committed by a comination of freebooters and smugglers of various nations, who located themselves in the first instance upon an uninhabited spot near the mouth of the river Trinity, whithin the jurisdictional limits of the United States, as claimed in virtue of the treaty of cession of Louisiana by France. This assocciation of persons organized a system of plunder upon the high seas, directed chiefly against Spanish property, which consisted frequently of slaves from the coast of Africa ; but their conduct appears not always to have been regulated by a strict regard to the national character of vessels falling into their hands, when specie or other very valuable articles formed part of the cargo. Their vesels generally sailed under a pretended Mexican flag, although it does not appear that the establishment of Galveston was sanctioned by or connected with any government. The presumption, too, of any authority ever having been given for such an etablishment, is strongly repelled as well by its piratial character, as by its itinerant nature ; for the first position, at Galveston, was abandoned on or about the 5th of April last, for one near Matagorda, upon the Spanish territory ; and at a later period this last was abandoned and a transfer made to Amelia Island, in East Florida ; a post which had been previously seized by persons, who appear to have been equally unauthorised, and who were, at the time of the said transfer, upon the point, it is believed, of abandoning their enterprise, from the failure of resources, which they expected to have drawn from within our limits, in defiance of our laws. There exists, on the part of these sea rovers, an organised system of daring enterprise, supported by force of arms, and it is only by a correspondent system of coercion that they can be met and constrained to respect the rights of property and the laws of nations. It is deeply to be regretted that practies of such a character, within our immediate neighborhood, and even within our jurisditional limits, should have prevailed unchecked for so long a time ; more especially, as one of their immediate consequences was to give occasion to the illicit introduction of slaves from the coast of Africa into these United States, and thus to revive a traffic repugnant to humanity and to all sound principles of policy, as well as severley punishable by the laws of the land.
By the 7th section of the act prohibiting the importation of slaves, possessed in 1807, the President is fully authorized to employ the naval force to cruise on any part of the coast of the United States, or territories thereof, where he may judge attempts will be made to violate the provisions of that act, in order to seize and bring in for condemnation all vessels contavening its provisions, to be proceeded against according to law.
By the joint resolution of the Senate and House of Representatives of 15th January, 1811, and the act of the same date, the President is fully empowered to occupy any part of the whole of the territory lying east of the river Perdido, and south of the state of Georgia, in the event of an attempt to occupy the said territory, or any part thereof by any foreign government of power ; and, by the same resolution and act, he may employ any part of the army and navy of the United States, which he may deem necessary, for the purpose of taking possession and occupying the territory aforesaid, and in order to maintain therein the authority of the United States.
Among the avowed projects of the persons who have occupied Amelia Island, was that of making the conquest of East and West Florida, professedly for the purpose of establishing there an independent government ; and the vacant lands on those provinces have been, from the origin of this undertaking down to the latest period, held out as lures to the cupidity of adventurers, and as reources for defraying the expenses of the expedition. The greater part of West Florida, being in the actual possession of the United States, this project involved in it designs of direct hostility against them ; and as the express object of the resolution and act of 15th January, 1811, was to authorize the President to prevent the province of East Florida from passing into the hands of any foreign power, it became the obvious duty of the President to exercise the authority vessed in him by that law. It does not appear that among these itinerant establishers of republics, and distributors of Florida lands, there is a single individual inhabitant of the country where the republic was to be constitued, and whose lands were to be thus bestowed : the project was therefore an attempt to occupy that territory by a foreign power. Where the profession is in such direct opposition to the fact ; where the venerable forms, by which a free people constitute a frame of government for themselves, are prostituted by a horde of foreign freebooters for purposes of plunder ; if, under color of authority from any of the provinces contending for their independence, the Floridas, or either of them, had been permitted to pass into the hands of such a power, the committee are persuaded it is quite unneccessary to point out to the discernment of the House the pernicious influence which such a destiny of the territories in question must have had upon the security, tranquility, and commmerce of this union.
It is a matter of public notoriety, that two of the persons who have successively held the command at Amelia Island, whether authorized themselves by any government or not, ha issued commissions for privateers, as in the name of the Venezuelian and Mexican governments, to vessels fitted out in the prorts of the United States, and chiefly manned and officered by ourown countrymen, for the purpose of capturing the property of nations with which the United States are at peace. One of the objects of the occupation of Amelia Island, it appears, was to possess a convenient resort for privateers of this description, equally reprobated by the laws of nations, whcih recognize them only under the denomination of pirates, and by several of the treaties of the United States with different European powers, which expressly denominate them as such.*(*See the treaty of peace with France, 1778, art. 21st. U. S. Laws, vol. 1, p. 88; with the Netherlands, 1782, art. 19, v. 1, p. 162 ; with Sweden, 1783, art. 23, vol 1., p. 190 ; with Great Britain, 1794, art. 21, v. 1, p. 218 ; with Prussia, 1785, art. 20, v. 1. p. 238, and 1797, art. 20, p. 256 ; with Spain, 1795, art. 14, v. 1, p. 270.) It was against the subjects of Spain, one of the powers with whcih the United States have entered into stipulations prohibiting their citizens from taking any commission from any power with which she may be at war for arming any ships to act as privateers, that these vessels have been commissioned to cruise ; though, as the committee have observed, no flag, not even that of our own country, has proved a protection from them. The immediate tendency of suffering such armaments, in defiance of our laws, would have been to embroil the United States with all the nations whose commerce with our countrty was suffering under these depredations ; and, if not checked by all the means in the power of the government, would have authorized claims from the subjects of foriegn governments for indemnities, at the expence of this nation, for captures by our people, in vessels fitted out in our ports, and, as could not fail of being alledged, countenanced by the very neglect of the necessary means for suppressing them. The possession of Amelia Island as a port of refuge for such privateers, of illicit traffic in the United States of their prizes, which were frequently, as before stated, slave ships rom Africa, was a powerful encouragement and temptation to multiply these violations of our laws, and made it the duty of the government to use all the means in its power to restore the security of our own commerce, of that of friendly nations upon our coasts, which could in no ther way more effectually be done than by taking from this piratical and smuggling combination their place of refuge.
In order, therefore, to give full effect to the intentions of the Legislature, and in pursuance of the provisions of the above recited resolution and acts, it became necessary (as it appears to your committee) to suppress all establishments of the hostile nature of those above described, made in our vicinity, the objects of which appear to have been the occupation of the Floridas, the spoliation of peaceful commerce upon and near our coasts by piratical privateers, the clandestine importation of goods, and the illicit introduction of slaves within our limits. Such establishments, if suffered to subsist and strengthen, would probably have rendered nugatory all provisions made by law for the exclusion of prohibited persons. The course pursued on this occasion, will strongly mark the feelings and intentions of our government upon the great question of the slave trade, which is so justly considered by most civilized nations as repugnant to justice and humanity, and which, in our particular case, is not less so to all the dictates of a sound policy.
Your committee anticipate beneficial results from the adoption of these measures by the Executive, in the promotion of the security of our Southern frontier and its neighboring seas ; and in the diminution of the evasions, bitterly so frequent, of our revenue and prohibitory law.The experience of ten years has however evinced the necessity of some new regulations being adopted in order effectually to put a stop to the farther introduction of slaves into the United States. In the act of Congress prohibiting this importation, the policy of giving the whole forfeiture of vessel and goods to the United States, an no part thereof to the informer, may justly be doubted. This is an oversight which should be remedied. The act doers indeed give a part of the personal penalties to the informer, but these penalties are generally only nominal. As the persons engaged in such traffic are usually poor, the omission of the states to pass acts to meet the act of Congress, and to establish regulations in and of the same, can only be remedied by Congresss legislating directly on the subject themselves as it is clearly within the scope of their constitutional powers to do.
For these purposes your committee beg leave respectfully herewith to report a bill.
Mr. Middleton also reported a bill in addition to the former acts prohibiting the introduction of slaves into the United States ; and the bill was twice read and committed.
The report was not read, but ordered to be printed.