Title: Netfishing Overview – Management Implications for Restrictions on the Use of Gill and Trammel Nets
CITATION PDF VIEWER THUMBNAILS PAGE IMAGE ZOOMABLE
Full Citation
STANDARD VIEW MARC VIEW
Permanent Link: http://ufdc.ufl.edu/CA01300969/00001
 Material Information
Title: Netfishing Overview – Management Implications for Restrictions on the Use of Gill and Trammel Nets
Physical Description: Book
Language: English
Creator: St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands
Publisher: St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands
Place of Publication: St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands
Publication Date: 2004
 Record Information
Bibliographic ID: CA01300969
Volume ID: VID00001
Source Institution: University of the Virgin Islands
Holding Location: University of the Virgin Islands
Rights Management: All rights reserved by the source institution and holding location.

Downloads

This item has the following downloads:

NetfishingOverview2004 ( PDF )


Full Text





NETFISHING OVERVIEW ST. CROIX, U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS:

MANAGEMENT IMPLICATIONS FOR RESTRICTIONS ON THE USE OF
GILL AND TRAMMEL NETS



General Fishery Description
Shallow Water Reef Fish Fishery
The shallow water coral reef fishery is the most important fishery in the U.S. Caribbean,
comprised of some 350 species of reef fish, 180 of these are landed in quantity
throughout the region as part of the commercial fishery (Caribbean Fishery Management
Council, 1985). The fisheries in the U.S. Virgin Islands, as well as in Puerto Rico, are
multi-species, multi-gear and artisanal in nature. There are approximately 380 registered
commercial fishers in the U.S. Virgin Islands (Tobias et al., 2000). The commercial
fishing fleet on St. Croix consists primarily of small-sized, open, wood or fiberglass
fishing boats, which average 20-26 feet in length and are powered by outboard engines.
Because of limited sheltered waters, relatively flat land and good road system on St.
Croix, these vessels represent a mobile fishing fleet, trailered to access sites around the
island, depending on sea conditions and target species. Larger vessels are used for trap-
based fisheries, due to space requirements for traps and machinery (Caribbean Fishery
Management Council, 2003) and are typically maintained in the water. Gear types used
in the fishery include traps, line fishing, nets and diving. Many fishers use multiple gear
types and more than one gear type may be used on a fishing trip.

Recorded Landings
A shallow water reef fish stock assessment of the U.S. Caribbean was conducted in 1991,
focusing on comparing data from the fishing years 1985 and 1990 (Appeldoom et al.,
1992). Data poor conditions were noted for the U.S. Virgin Islands, especially for
historical data sets. Projected reef fish landings appeared reasonably stable between 1975
and 1989 in the U.S. Virgin Islands (1.3 million pounds), averaging 0.9 million pounds
for St. Thomas/St. John and 0.4 million pounds for St. Croix. Fish traps accounted for
approximately 70% of the landings by weight. However, the capture size of numerous
species caught in traps had decreased over time (parrotfish, grunts, surgeonfish, trunkfish
and queen triggerfish). Large grouper species were absent from the fishery. Only two
smaller grouper species were common, red hind and coney. Recorded landings for the
Virgin Islands from 1990 to 2001 also averaged 1.3 million pounds with a range of 1.0-
1.6 million pounds. However, the reported landings from St. Croix during this period
increased from .4 to .8 million pounds (38-53% of total landings).


Gill and Trammel Net Fishery
Origin
Within the 10-year period from 1989 to 1999, numerous hurricanes have impacted the
territory and adversely affected the fisheries, most notably Hurricanes Hugo (1989), Luis
and Marilyn (1995), Bertha and Hortense (1996), Georges (1998) and Lenny (1999).
Unfortunately, St. Croix was in the direct path of all of these systems. Commercial









fishers lost significant amounts of fish traps, the most popular fishing gear in the territory,
during the hurricanes. Unable to obtain loans or federal grants to replace this gear and
reluctant to sustain additional gear losses, many fishers abandoned traditional trap and
handline gear for the higher catch rates and economic returns afforded by net fishing.
Once the net fishing techniques were learned, fishers harvested more fish with gill and
trammel nets in a shorter period of time and did not have to leave the gear in the water to
be subject to storm events. The net gear returned home with the fisher after several hours
of fishing.

The increase in gill and trammel nets in St. Croix also coincided with a net ban that was
passed in Florida state waters in 1994. Sales representatives from Atlantic and Gulf
Fishing Supply Company, a major commercial fishing gear supplier in south Florida,
visited the Virgin Islands to promote entanglement net gear that they were no longer able
to market in Florida.

Net Definitions
Article X, Section 16 of the Florida State Constitution defines gill net as "one or more
walls of netting which capture saltwater finfish by ensnaring or entangling them in the
meshes of the net by the gills" (Andersen, 2002). Gill nets consist of a wall of virtually
invisible monofilament netting, equipped with weights at the bottom and floats at the top.
The fish swim into the netting and become entangled when their gill covers are caught in
the mesh. Gill nets may be fixed to the bottom or set midwater or near the surface for
pelagic species (Barnette, 2001). An entangling net is defined as "a drift net, trammel
net, stab net or any other net which captures saltwater finfish, shellfish or other marine
animals by causing all or part of the head, fins, legs or other body parts to become
entangled or ensnared in the meshes of the net" (Andersen, 2002). A trammel net is
made up of two or more panels suspended from a float line and attached to a single lead
line. The outer panels are of a larger mesh size than the inner panel. Fish swim through
the outer panel and hit the inner panel, which carries it through the other outer panel,
creating a bag and trapping the fish. Smaller and larger fish become wedged, gilled or
tangled (Barnette, 2001).

Net Fishing Methods
Several net fishing methods are used to harvest reef fish species. Some fishers prefer gill
nets; while others prefer multi-mesh trammel nets. Nets may be set by fishers from a
boat and fished indiscriminately or set with the aid of scuba divers for target fish species,
with the divers working the fish into the net. Fishers may scout an area for large
aggregations of adult fish and then use their nets to either surround the whole school or
have scuba divers drive fish into the set nets. Other fishers set nets in areas that are
predictably used by fish during their evening migration between diurnal foraging grounds
and nocturnal reef slope or deep reef resting grounds. The migration routes or "fish
highways" are along spur and grove zones or sand channels through hard bottom
communities. Once the fish migration behavior and "highways" are known, the fish are
particularly vulnerable to harvest by net fishing techniques. The nets are set to form a
wall blocking the migration route of the schooling fishes. This net fishing method is very
effective in capturing large numbers of schooling fishes.









Observations of this net fishing method made by Division staff indicate that as many as
five 300-ft sections of trammel net (1,500 ft in total length), eight feet in height, may be
linked together. Divers deploy the nets from mesh bags underwater and secure the lead
line of the net to the bottom by placing it around or under coral, gorgonids, sponges or
other features on the bottom. Care is taken by the divers to firmly secure the net to the
bottom. If the net is lifted off the bottom by ensnared fish, the remainder of the fish will
escape under the net. Sections of net are stitched together underwater. The terminal
sections of the net (approximately 100 ft in length) are folded back "hairpin-style" to
form pockets on either end. The nets were set parallel to the depth contour (30-45 ft
depth) across several shallow groove areas ("fish highways") on the seafloor, with the
pockets formed on the landward side of the net. The net was fished from 2:00 P.M. until
6:30 P.M. with divers clearing the net of turtles and sharks every hour. Divers were
observed to "rush" the net near the end of the set, chasing a school of confused redtail
parrotfish into the pocket of the net. Most of the target fish, schooling parrotfishes, were
caught during the last 1.5 hours of daylight. Because parrotfishes are social and
gregarious spawners, a disproportionate number of breeding adults are removed by net
fishing, as compared to other fishing methods.

The nets containing the gilled or entangled fish are removed from the water by fishers in
the boat hauling the net in combination with divers freeing the net from bottom
obstructions. The same amount of care in placing the net around coral, gorgonids,
sponges, etc., during the set is not taken during the net haulback procedure, which results
in environmental damage to the benthic community. Once the net has been hauled into
the boat, the fishers return to shore and pick fish from the net at home, where the catch
can be sorted, placed in coolers and iced for sale the next day.

Studies conducted in Puerto Rico indicate that gill nets and trammel nets are size-
selective and capture fish of larger size than other gears (Acosta, 1988; Matos Caraballo,
1991; Valdes Pizzini et al., 1992). The use of fishing gear in coral reef areas is limited to
the nature of the substrate. Typically, the only convenient methods are passive gears,
such as fish traps, hook and line, gill nets and trammel nets (Acosta, 1994). None of the
authors of net fishing studies conducted in Puerto Rico indicated that scuba gear was used
in trammel net fishing. Scuba gear is not commonly used to set trammel nets in Puerto
Rico due to the additional cost of the gear (D. Matos, Puerto Rico Department of Natural
Resources, personal communication). Gobert (1992) reported that trammel nets are
more species selective than fish traps in Martinique and that trammel nets are not fished
with scuba gear. St. Croix fishers have apparently found a more effective way of net
fishing by using divers equipped with scuba gear to actively set and work nets in areas
where they would not be fishable if deployed from a vessel, due to the presence of coral
reefs. The ability to fish in deeper, offshore, shelf edge coral reef/hard bottom habitat
with nets and the knowledge of the daily migratory behavioral patterns and "highways"
used by schooling parrotfishes has enabled gill and trammel net fishers to capture entire
breeding schools of parrotfishes in one set.

A summary of St. Croix gill and trammel net data obtained directly from personal contact
interviews with commercial fishers during a Caribbean Fishery Management Council









fisher census survey in 2003 is shown in Table 1. A total of 43 gill and trammel net
fishers were identified, 34 gill net and 9 trammel net fishers. Gill net fishers owned 78
nets, 69 of which were fished. The nets were made of both monofilament and nylon.
Gill nets were described as 90-1000 ft in length (mean=397 ft) and 3-12 ft in height
(mean=6 ft). Mesh size (square) ranged from 1.3-3.5 in. The gill nets soaked a mean of
3.79 hours and the fishers made a mean of 3.09 trips/week. Trammel net fishers owned
27 nets, 23 of which were fished. The trammel nets were identified as made mostly of
monofilament. Trammel nets ranged from 200-1000 ft in length (mean=4.83 ft) and 4-8
ft in height (mean=6). Mesh size (square) ranged from 1.0-3.0 in. The trammel nets
soaked a mean of 4.13 hours and the fishers made a mean of 3.33 trips/week

Target Species
The Division collects biostatistical data, individual fish lengths and weights, from
complete catches from cooperative fishers through two Department of Commerce,
National Marine Fisheries Service grants, the State/Federal Cooperative Statistics
Program and the Inter-jurisdictional Fisheries Program. This information is entered into
a Trip Interview Program (TIP) database and forwarded to the National Marine Fisheries
Service. Based on the analysis of sixteen personal contact interviews with commercial
net fishers by Division port sampling agents from 1998 to 2002, a total of 4,589 fish were
measured weighing 4,890 pounds (Table 2). The average total number of fish per sample
was 287 and the average total weight of the catch was 306 pounds. On the average, there
were 233 parrotfish, weighing 269 pounds per catch. Parrotfish represented 83% of the
catch by weight and 77% of the catch by number.

Species composition of the net fisher biostatistical catches is shown in Table 3. Six
parrotfish species represented 81% of the catch by number (26.4% stoplight, 24.6%
redtail, 13.8% redfin, 11.3% redband, 3.0% queen and 2.0% princess parrotfish). The
same six parrotfish species represented a total of 88% of the total catch by weight (30.5%
stoplight, 26.9% redtail, 17.9% redfin, 6.1% redband, 4.8% queen and 1.9% princess
parrotfish). All other species combined accounted for 8.4% by number and 6.9% by
weight of the total catch.

By-catch
Observations made during the trammel net fishing trip indicate that non-target species or
by-catch can be significant. Federally endangered and threatened sea turtles (one
hawksbill and three green turtles) were caught in the net (The presence and abundance of
sea turtles may be a function of the fishing location.). Coastal shark species were also
caught. Because the nets are picked at home and not at sea immediately when hauled, it
is not possible to release unwanted species alive. Additional by-catch species included
butterflyfish (foureye, banded and longsnout butterflyfish are protected in federal waters),
filefish, porcupine pufferfish,, scorpionfish, small surgeonfish, small grunts and an
assortment of other species. By-catch also included benthic invertebrates such as stony
corals, fire coral, gorgonids, sponges and algae. Munroe et al. (1987), Ohman et al.
(1993), and Jennings and Polunin (1996) also reported damage to the benchic community
(corals) during net haulback. Based on the fisher's method of sorting his catch, the
observed trammel net trip resulted in approximately 400 pounds of marketable fish, 400









pounds of "give away" fish (to the crew or friends) and 50 pounds of "throw-away" fish.
All consumable fish would presumably be recorded on commercial catch record forms.
"Throw-away" fish represent by-catch that would not reported on commercial catch
record forms.

Fish Spoilage and Wanton Waste
In warm tropical waters, the spoilage of the catch can be great if the trammel nets are left
to fish too long. Gobert (1992) and Acosta (1994) reported greater than 30% spoilage of
fish caught in trammel nets fished for 20 hours. The inability to quickly remove the fish
from the net and ice down and store the catch decreases the quality of the catch and
increases the possibility of fish spoilage. Division personnel have received unconfirmed
reports of large quantities of preferred food fish species (redtail and stoplight parrotfish)
discarded at the public landfill. This wanton waste is believed to be the result of over-
harvesting of the resource by net fishers and their inability to process and market the
resource before spoiling. The "wanton waste" of fish is prohibited in the Virgin Islands
under Title 12, Virgin Islands Code, Sections 302, 304(b) and 321(b).

Fish Dumping
Division staff has responded to a number of incidents involving quantities of fish, coral
and gorgonids and one endangered sea turtle carcass apparently discarded as by-catch
from the net fishery. These incidents include 120 fish (19 species), one poached
hawksbill sea turtle and benthic invertebrates on 10 January 2002 from Estate Castle
Burke, 102 fish (12 species) and benthic invertebrates on 18 July 2002 from the West
Airport Road, 82 fish (12 species) from Half Penny Bay beach on 28 June 2003 and 240
fish (13 species) again from Half Penny Bay beach on 18 December 2003. Twenty-eight
species of fish, representing 17 families, and one poached hawksbill sea turtle were
recorded as by-catch from these four incidents (Table 4).

Derelict Nets
Gill nets or trammel nets set carelessly by fishers in areas of coral reef or left unattended
may become entangled on the bottom. If the fisher is unable to retrieve the net, the whole
net or the section of net entangled in the coral is abandoned. The cost of the gear usually
does not warrant the expenditure of time and effort on the part of the fisher to retrieve it.
This is particularly true if the fisher is not a good swimmer and does not own dive
equipment. Division staff encountered an abandoned monofilament gill net, 94 feet in
length and 10 feet in height (1.5"sq mesh/3.0" stretch mesh), entangled in coral in 20 feet
of water north of Frederiksted on 8 March 2002. The net had been cut and abandoned for
an unknown period of time; however, the net continued to catch fish. One coney, two
scorpionfish, one white grunt, one blue runner, a small coral head, one gorgonian and
eight branching sponges were removed from the net. Monofilament net material is
invisible in the water and does not deteriorate. The discarded, algal-overgrown gill net
continued to catch fish, "ghost fish", long after it was abandoned.









Commercial Landings
Catch Records
Commercial fishers are required by law to submit catch reports on an annual basis to the
Division of Fish and Wildlife, prior to fishing license renewal. The reported reef fish
landings from traps and nets, as recorded from catch reports submitted by commercial
fishers from 1989 to 2003 for St. Croix, are shown in Figure 1. Gaps in the data set exist
at the present time due to on-going data validity checks. In the fishing year 1990-1991, a
total of 297,009 pounds of reef fish were landed, 88.7% (263,527 pounds) of this total
was from traps and 11.3% (33,482 pounds) from nets. Over the next twelve-year period
(1991-2003), the total landings have increased to 346,638 pounds, 42.8% from traps
(148,229 pounds) and 57.2% (198,409 pounds) from nets (Figure 2). Reef fish landings
by fishers using nets have gradually increased since 1990 and currently exceed fish trap
landings. The reported St. Croix reef fish landings for 2002-2003 by species group are
shown in Table 5. Two major species groups, parrotfish and surgeonfish, represented
56.2% (198,586 pounds) and 12.9% (45,759 pounds), respectively, of the total landings
by weight. A total of 75.9% of all parrotfish landed were caught by nets, 23.6% by traps
and 0.6% by other methods. Biostatistical reef fish samples from net fishers catch have
identified six species of parrotfish (by priority of number and weight), stoplight, redtail,
redfin, redband, queen and princess parrotfish. Surgeonfish represented the second most
abundant species group harvested by net (36.5%).

Predicted vs. Recorded Catch Estimates
The accuracy of reported landings on catch report forms is questionable at best. Fishers
reported 198,409 pounds of net fish in 2002/2003. Biostatistical samples (N=16) from
net fishers from 1998-2002 indicate that the average trammel net fishing trip yields 285
fish weighing 306 pounds (maximum 567 pounds). About 80% of the catch is
predominantly stoplight and redtail parrotfish by number, frequency and weight.

A commercial fisher census survey conducted in 2003 identified 43 registered net fishers,
34 reported using gill nets and 9 reported using trammel nets. We can estimate the
annual net landings by the following:

43 fishers x 300 lbs/fisher/trip x 2 trips/week x 52 weeks/yr = 1,341,600 lbs/yr.

The annual landings for net fishing may be in excess of 1.3 million pounds, with a value
of 4 million dollars. Parrotfish would comprise about 1 million pounds annually. This
represents a seven-fold increase over the reported landings from the commercial catch
records. Although errors incorporated in estimating landings may be substantial, it is
believed that commercial fishers may be significantly under-reporting landings on catch
reports.

No data is presently available on the amount of by-catch from the net fishery. Estimates
obtained from the commercial fisher during the one trammel net observer trip indicated
that the harvest was 400 pounds of "marketable" fish, 400 pounds of "give-away" fish
and 50 pounds of "trash" fish. By-catch is considered as non-marketable catch, "trash"
fish. The amount of by-catch can depend on mesh size of the net, the area fished and the









net fishing method employed. If we assumed 50 pounds of by-catch per trip and apply
the same calculations used to determine estimated annual landings, 223,600 pounds of
by-catch would be generated annually from the net fishery. By-catch potentially
represents 63% of the total reported reef fish landings and 111% of the total reported net
landings for St. Croix (Table 5). More by-catch may result from the net fishery than the
present total reported landings from the net fishery. Impacts to benthic invertebrates and
habitat have been identified but have not been quantified at the present time.


User Group Opinion Surveys and Comments
The Division of Fish and Wildlife conducted three public opinion surveys to obtain
information that would be beneficial in the development of a strategic plan for fisheries.
Opinion surveys were conducted with commercial fishers on the impacts of the expansion
of new national monument areas (Uwate et al., 2001). Opinion surveys were also
conducted with commercial fishers and the marine recreational industry (Gordon and
Uwate, 2002) and with members of the Virgin Islands recreational fishing clubs
(Messineo and Uwate, 2003). In each of these surveys, the major issue and problem with
fishing in St. Croix was identified as the excessive catch by fishers with nets (gill and
trammel nets) and the need to regulate their use. The Division also participated in a
commercial fisher census survey for the Caribbean Fishery Management Council in 2004
(in preparation). Of the 215 fishers interviewed on St. Croix, 67.8% of the fishers
responded that fishing was worse now than 10 years ago. The major reasons for the
decline in the St. Croix fishery were given as net fishers taking too many fish (38.9%),
too many fishers (32.9%) and less fish (25.9%).

Fisheries Advisory Committees were established under Title 11, Chapter 27, Section
1404 of the Virgin Islands Code with the responsibility of making management
recommendations for fisheries resources to the Commissioners of Commissioners of
Planning and Natural Resources and Agriculture. Members on this committee include
representatives from the Departments of Agriculture, Planning and Natural Resources
and Law, a marine scientist, a representative from a recreational sport fishing club, the
dive industry and commercial and recreational fishers. On 15 October 2002, the St.
Croix Fisheries Advisory Committee recommended to ban the use of gill and trammel
nets in St. Croix, due to the over-harvesting of parrotfishes and indiscriminate take of by-
catch species.

The St. Croix Fishery Advisory Committee also received a letter from the St. Croix
Charter Dive Operators in support of a ban on gill and trammel nets.


Coral Reef Impacts
Implications on Over-harvesting of Herbivorous Fishes
The St. Croix net fishery selectively targets large herbivorous reef fish, primarily
parrotfishes and surgeonfishes, and their removal may ultimately have a substantial
impact upon the health of our coral reefs. Herbivores play an important ecological role in
maintaining coral reefs. By directly feeding upon algae and plants, these fish enable hard









corals to recruit and grow in areas where they otherwise might be out-competed by faster
growing algal species. When herbivores are absent, due to removal or disease, reefs
deteriorate. A 90% reduction in live coral was reported for reefs near Discovery Bay,
Jamaica. Following the 1983 Pan-Caribbean die-off of Diadema sea urchins, the major
invertebrate grazer on coral reefs, and removal of herbivorous fish, the major vertebrate
grazer, reefs were unable to recover from storm disturbance. Algae replaced live coral.
The heavy harvesting of all herbivores is incompatible with vigorous coral growth
(Pennings, 1996).


Management Alternatives
Net fishers have proposed several alternatives to reduce the gill and trammel net harvest.
These measures include seasonal closures for net fishing, area closures and temporal
closures (i.e., net fishing only two days per week). The proposed alternatives would be
inadequate because they would not sufficiently reduce the fishing effort required for
rebuilding of the fish stocks and they would also be difficult or impractical to enforce.

A complete ban on gill and trammel nets would be the most effective and enforceable
management alternative. However, gill nets are used in different fisheries. Surface gill
nets are also used to harvest baitfish, such as ballyhoo and flyingfish. Bottom gill and
trammel nets are used to harvest parrotfishes and other reef fish. An accurate description
of the gear would be required to permit specific net fisheries to exist.


Fishery Transition Mitigation
Multi-Gear/ Multi-Methods
Data collected during the Caribbean Fishery Management Council commercial fishers
census survey in 2003 indicate that the majority of net fishers also use other methods of
fishing. A summary of gear types used by net fishers is shown in Table 6. Handline
fishing + diving and trap + handline + diving are the most popular methods used by gill
and trammel net fishers. Only two out of thirty-four gill net fishers reported that gill nets
were the only gear fished. No trammel net fishers reported using only trammel nets.
Restrictions on the use of nets will result in a shift of fishers from one fishing gear to
another to maintain their income. That shift will most likely be to a combination of line
fishing, diving and traps.

Net Buy-Back
The Division has received a $75,000 grant from the Department of Commerce, National
Marine Fisheries Service, for the buy-back of gill and trammel nets. Based on the
information received during the commercial fisher survey (Table 1), 43 fishers own a
total of 105 nets; 78 gill nets and 27 trammel nets. The buy-back will be at 80% value of
the net (net + floats + weights), based on current retail price plus shipping ($.80/ft for gill
nets and $1.34/ft for trammel nets). The buy-back of incomplete nets will be for 50% of
the retail value of the net plus shipping. The buy-back of any additional nets not
accounted for in the commercial fisher census survey will be at 50% of the retail value of
the net plus shipping on a funds available basis. If there are funds remaining in the buy-









back program following the cutoff date, the participating net fishers will receive an
additional payment increasing the buy-back value of their reported nets above 80%. The
net buy-back can commence in July, during the registration period for commercial
fishers, with a cut-off date of August 31, 2004.

FADs
The Government of the Virgin Islands receives funding from the Department of Interior,
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Sport Fish Restoration Program, for the deployment of
fish aggregating devices (FADs) in offshore waters. The FADs are surface or underwater
buoys, which attract seasonally abundant pelagic fish species (tuna, dolphin and wahoo)
for harvest. The FADs concentrate pelagic fish species, reduce the travel time and
fishing trip costs and increase fishing trip productivity. The FAD program has been
extremely successful and highly regarded in the fishing community. Additional FADs
have been placed around the Virgin Islands to accommodate increased effort on offshore
species and more are planned.

Increased Enforcement Presence
One of the reasons fishers switched from traps to nets was the reduced cost of not having
to leave gear at sea for long periods of time. While left at sea, traps may be damaged by
storms, traps may be stolen or hauled by other fishers and trap lines may be cut by
passing vessels, resulting in lost traps. Nets are set and hauled daily and the net returns
home with the fisher. With the removal of nets from the fishery, it is anticipated that the
numbers of fish traps in territorial and federal waters will increase. It would be a relief to
fishers who have switched from nets to traps if the at-sea presence of enforcement
officers was increased to ensure that tampering of gear does not occur. This may require
the establishment of routine patrols to monitor compliance with fish trap regulations.
These patrols may be combined with at sea vessel safety inspections.

Fishermen Loan Programs
To support fishers in the transfer from one gear type to another, additional funds will be
required above what is provided through the net-buyback. The Small Business
Development Agency should be encouraged to promote a series of workshops on the
availability of low-interest loans to the fishers. The seminars should include information
on Micro-Loans (unsecured loans to $10,000 at 5% interest), Farmers and Fisherman's
Loans (loans to $17,000 at 4% interest) and Direct Loans (loans to $25,000+ at 9.5%).









Literature Cited

Acosta, Alejandro R. 1988. A preliminary study of gill net, trammel net and beach seine
catches from southwest Puerto Rico with notes on length frequency. Gulf Caribb.
Fish Inst. 41:123-149.

Acosta, Alejandro R. 1994. Soak time and net length effects on catch rate of
entanglement nets in coral reef areas. Fish. Res. 19:105-119.

Andersen, David K. 2002. Understanding the impacts of the Florida net ban (Article X,
Section 16 of the State Constitution). Gulf Caribb. Fish. Inst. 53:378-392.

Appeldoorn, R., J. Beets, J. Bohnsack, S. Bolden, D. Matos, S. Meyers, A. Rosario, Y.
Sadovy and W. Tobias. 1992. Shallow water reef fish stock assessment for the
U.S. Caribbean. NOAA Tech. Memo. NMFS-SEFC-304. 70pp.

Barnette, M.C. 2001. A review of the fishing gear utilized within the Southeast Region
and their potential impacts on essential fish habitat. NOAA Tech. Memo. NMFS-
SEFC-449. 62pp.

Caribbean Fishery Management Council. 1985. Fishery management plan. Final
environmental impact review for the shallow-water reeffish fishery of Puerto Rico
and the U.S. Virgin Islands. 69pp.

Caribbean Fishery Management Council. 2003. Draft environmental impact statement
for the generic essential fish habitat amendment to: spiny lobster fishery
management plan, queen conch fishery management plan, reef fish fishery
management plan, coral fishery management plan for the U.S. Caribbean.

Gobert, Bertrand. 1992. Impact of the use of trammel nets on a tropical reef resource.
Fish. Res. 13:353-367.

Gordon, S. and K.R. Uwate. 2002. 2002 opinion survey of U.S. Virgin Island
commercial fishers and the marine recreational industry. DPNR-Division of Fish
and Wildlife, Bureau of Fisheries, unpublished report. 31pp.

Jennings, S. and N.V.C. Polunin. 1996. Impacts of fishing on tropical reef ecosystems.
Ambio. 25:44-49.

Matos-Caraballo, Daniel. 1991. Comparison of size of capture of parrotfishes
Sparisoma viride and Sparisoma chrysopterum in Puerto Rico using traps and
entanglement nets during 1988-1992. Gulf Caribb. Fish. Inst. 46:299-308.

Messineo, J. and K.R. Uwate. 2002. 2003 opinion survey of U.S. Virgin Island
recreational fishing club members. DPNR, Division of Fish and Wildlife, Bureau
of Fisheries, unpublished report. 13pp.










Munroe, J. L. Parrish, J.D. and F.H. Talbot. 1987. The biological effects of intensive
fishing upon reef fish communities. In Human impacts on coral reefs: facts and
recommendations. Salvat, B. (ed.). Antenne Museum E.P.H.E. French Polynesia.
pp.41-49.

Ohman, M.C., A. Rajasuriya and 0. Linden. 1993. Human disturbance on coral reefs in
Sri Lanka: a case study. Ambio. 22:474-480.

Pennings, S.C. 1996. Indirect interactions on coral reefs. Pp. 249-272 In: (C. Birkeland,
Ed.) Life and Death of Coral Reefs, Chapman and Hall, New York.

Tobias, W., R. Gomez, I. Mateo and B. Kojis. 2000. U.S. Virgin Islands state/federal
cooperative statistics program summary report, 1 April 1997-31 March 1999. 10pp.

Uwate, K.R., W. Tobias, P. Nieves, H. Rivera, W. Ventura and L. Critchley. 2001.
Survey of U.S. Virgin Island commercial fisher opinions and usage of new national
monument areas (Buck Island and south of St. John). DPNR, Division of Fish and
Wildlife, Bureau of Fisheries, unpublished report. 13pp.

Valdez-Pizzini, M., A. Acosta, D.C. Griffith and M. Ruiz-Perez. 1992. Assessment of
the socioeconomic impact of the fishery management options upon gill net an
trammel net fishermen in Puerto Rico: an interdisciplinary approach (anthropology
and fisheries biology) for the evaluation of management alternatives. Final Report
NOAA/NMFS, Grant #NA17FL0100-1.




University of Florida Home Page
© 2004 - 2010 University of Florida George A. Smathers Libraries.
All rights reserved.

Acceptable Use, Copyright, and Disclaimer Statement
Last updated October 10, 2010 - - mvs