Citation
Heritage Florida Jewish News

Material Information

Title:
Heritage Florida Jewish News
Place of Publication:
Fern Park, FL
Publisher:
Heritage Central Florida Jewish News, Inc.
Publication Date:
Language:
English

Subjects

Genre:
newspaper ( sobekcm )

Record Information

Source Institution:
University of Florida
Holding Location:
University of Florida
Rights Management:
Copyright, Heritage Central Florida Jewish News, Inc.Permission granted to University of Florida to digitize and display this item for non-profit research and educational purposes. Any reuse of this item in excess of fair use or other copyright exemptions requires permission of the copyright holder.

Downloads

This item is only available as the following downloads:


Full Text

PAGE 1

WWW.HERITAGEFL.COM YEAR 42, NO. 16 DECEMBER 22, 2017 4 TEVET, 5778 ORLANDO, FLORIDA SINGLE COPY 75 Editorials ..................................... 4A Op-Ed .......................................... 5A Calendar ...................................... 6A Scene Around ............................. 9A Synagogue Directory ................ 11A JTA News Briefs ........................ 13A Its a world record for largest human menorah! (JTA)Students at a Jewish school in New Jersey broke the world record for the worlds largest human menorah. Over 500 students from Ben Porat Yosef, a private school in Paramus, stood in the shape of a Chanukah cande labra on Wednesday morning, the first day of the Jewish holiday, Paramus Patch reported. A representative from Guinness World Records certified that the formation was indeed the largest one in the world. Students dressed in colors to make the menorah come to life, with the younger pupils wearing red or orange to sym bolize the flame and the older ones in white to represent the candles and dark colors to represent the menorah itself. Union for Reform Judaism President Rabbi Rick Jacobs speaks at the organizations biennial convention in Boston. By Deborah Fineblum JNS BOSTONRabbi Rick Ja cobs used his pulpit to com pare the difficulties between Israel and Reform Jews to those of Joseph and his brothers in last weeks Torah portion of Vayeshev. It was a huge congregation Jacobs was addressing: the record-breaking 6,000 Re form Jews gathered in Boston for the Union for Reform Juda isms 74th North American Biennial General Assembly. But it was President Donald Trumps announcement that the U.S. has recognized Jeru salem as Israels capital and will be moving its embassy there from Tel Aviv that was the subject of much of the conversation at the Dec. 6-10 convention of Ameri can Jewrys largest religious denominationin formal Jerusalem takes center stage as movement opposes US policy shift speeches and workshops, in the hallways between ses sions, and over sandwiches at lunch. Jacobs, the URJs president, had stated last week that Trumps announcement as ill-timed, breaking with the relatively broad Jewish communal support of the Jerusalem recognition. While we share the presi dents belief that the U.S. embassy should, at the right time, be moved from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, we cannot support his decision to begin preparing that move now, ab sent a comprehensive plan for a peace process, said Jacobs, whose position was echoed by Sen. Elizabeth Warren (DMass.) when she addressed the URJ conference Dec. 8. In an interview with Is rael Radio this week, Natan Sharansky, chairman of The Jewish Agency for Israel, said the Reform response to Trumps Jerusalem recogni tion was terrible. Everything that comes out of Trump is bad, from [the Reform movements] perspec tive, Sharansky said. When the leader of a superpower recognizes Jerusalem, first you have to welcome it, then offer disagreement. Here it was the opposite. At odds with Israeli policies Many of Reform Jews con cerns about Israeli politics including growth of what they consider settlements, and the states religious policies such on conversion and Western Wall prayerwere aired at Israel at 70: Ensuring a Jew ish and Democratic State, a workshop featuring Rabbi Gilad Kariv, president of the Is rael Movement for Reform and Progressive Judaism (IMPJ). We need to understand that 70 years ago Reform Judaism was not around the communal table when the state of Israel was conceived of, Kariv told a standingroom-only crowd. Kariv covered what he called the ideological debate over non-Orthodox Jews push to conduct egalitarian prayer at the Western Wall, a site long separated by gender, as well as the fact that Reform rabbis are not recognized by the Israeli Chief Rabbinate. He noted that all Reform rabbis spend a year of their training in Israel and that each year, 500 young Israelis spend time in Reform camps in North America to teach and also to learn from us. If Israel is the nation-state of the Jewish people, then all Jews wherever they are have respon sibilities and rights too, Kariv told JNS after the workshop. Certainly not in a decisionmaking role, but the right to be heard and respected. When David Grossman took the stage Dec. 7 to accept the Maurice N. Eisendrath Bearer of Light Award, the Reform movements highest honor, the award-winning Israeli novelistwhom the left-wing J Street lobby lists as one of its strongest Israeli support erswas openly critical of Israels political and religious policies. He urged the audi ence, which gave him several standing ovations, to make your presence known more than ever before. Though he said he cant understand values like those of the Palestinian mother who celebrates her childs attacks on Israelis and hopes her other children follow suit, Gross man leveled his most intense criticism at Israels leaders, blaming them for alienating Reform youths. Grossman described him self as a secular person and an atheist, but he did allow his children to celebrate their bar mitzvahs in a Reform temple in Israel. Sami Kuperberg and Rayna Exelbierd. By Christine DeSouza It only takes one person to strive to make a difference. Sami Kuperberg is such a person. She had endured antiSemitism since her freshman year at Oviedo High School. Students would tease her because she is Jewish. One student wouldnt let her raise her hand in class to answer questions and grabbed her arm and drew a swastika on it. She was even punched and kicked just because she is Jewish. Kuperberg heard of a pro gram called Jewish Student Union, and reached out to Rabbi Gabi Gittleson of JOIN Orlando to start the club at her school. A light in the face of darkness JSU is an after-school club that provides any high school student a Jewish ex perience through programs that strengthen their Jewish identity. Kuperberg planned a pro gram titled One Day Starts Today with the support of JOIN Orlando and StandWi thUs, a non-profit pro-Israel education and advocacy or ganization that believes that education is the road to peace. I have been fighting every single day for this event and fi nally in less than a week it will all come together, Kuperberg stated on her Facebook page before the event. My goal is to fill 600/600 seats there and Democrat Doug Jones wins the Alabama Senate seat. be the first Democrat elected to the Senate from Alabama since 1992. Moore said he would not concede until absentee ballots are counted. Moore, a former state chief justice twice removed for ignoring U.S. Supreme Court rulings on churchstate separation and on gay marriage, had been beset by allegations that when he was in his 30s he wooed teenage girls. Two women accused him of sexual assault. Moore drew criticism from some Jewish quarters in the last week for suggest ing that billionaire liberal philanthropist George Soros was headed to hell and that his agenda was not our America culture. That was compounded by his wife, Kayla Moore, at his final rally on Monday night, when in defending the couples In stunning upset, Jones trumps Moore WASHINGTON (JTA)In a stunning upset, Roy Moore, the controversial Republican nominee backed by President Donald Trump in a Senate race in Alabama, was pro jected to lose against his Democratic challenger. Networks called the race late Tuesday night for Doug Jones, a former prosecutor. The counting closed with Jones 1.5 percent points ahead of Moore. Jones would Light on page 14A Jones on page 15A Jerusalem on page 15A

PAGE 2

PAGE 2A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 Shown here (l-r): Emily Bradley and Jenna Mathis, of Nemours Childrens Hospital, and PJ Library Families Committee members Oshrat Molayem and Fiona Anavi show off some of the stuffed animals that were delivered to the Lake Nona hospital by the Federa tion earlier this month. Smiles and bear hugs were in abundance on a recent Sunday afternoon as the Jewish Federation of Greater Orlando held its third annual PJ Library Family Mitzvah Day at Build-A-Bear in Al tamonte Springs. More than 70 moms, dads, babies, kids and grandpar ents took part in this increas ingly popular Federation holiday tradition, creating nearly 40 stuffed animals and cards to donate to the young patients at Nemours Chil drens Hospital in Orlando. Federation volunteers, along with PJ Library Coordinator Jennifer Cohen, delivered the bears to Nemours in early December. We are extremely grate ful and appreciative of the partnership with the Jew ish Federation of Greater Orlando and look forward to the Build-A-Bear delivery each year, wrote Samantha G. Klaff, a certified child life specialist at Nemours. Fiona Anavi, PJ Library Families Committee cochair, who has attended the event since its inception in 2015, said, One of my favorite programs is our annual Mitzvah Day! To see so many little children lov ingly give away an adorable bearbecause they truly understand they are doing a mitzvahis priceless. PJ Library engagement programs like Family Mitz vah Day help me teach my children why we should be so proud to be Jewish. Since 2015, Federation has delivered nearly 100 bears and cardsand count less bear hugs and special wishesto the hospital. Joining the families again this year was Rabbi Rick Sherwin, a chaplain at Nemours. Rabbi Rick helps make Family Mitzvah Day even more meaningful be cause he is able to explain to the children that they are part of the healing journey for the children and families at the hospital. Even Build-A-Bear de scribed Federations Family Mitzvah Day as an ...incred ible project! We applaud the great work you are doing thats inspiring children in the community to give back and make a difference in another childs life, wrote Ellie Tymorek, associate cause marketing specialist at the Build-A-Bear corporate office. A program of the Harold Grinspoon Foundation, PJ Library provides free Jew ish childrens literature and music to more than 140,000 children around the world, including more than 600 families in Central Florida. The program is administered and underwritten locally by the Jewish Federation of Greater Orlando. Federations PJ Library Families, formerly known as Shalom Families, regularly puts on engagement events that are inspired by or rein force the Jewish values pro moted in PJ Library stories. Rabbi Rick Sherwin entertains the children and explains how they are helping the chil dren in the hospital. Federation has created a bear-y special mitzvah There is an organiza tion that provides last dol lar, interest-free loans for higher education to Jewish students in need. The Jew ish Educational Loan Fund has been helping the Jewish community since 1889 when the doors of the Hebrew Orphans Home first opened in Atlanta, Georgia. Over the last 120-plus years, the or ganization has transformed twice: first, in 1931, when it began providing adoption and foster care services under the name Jewish Chil drens Services and then, in 1961, began granting inter est-free loans for college and formally changed its name to JELF in 1989. Since 1961 JELF has awarded nearly $12 million in interest-free loans to Jewish students in need across its five-state region of Florida, Georgia, North Carolina, South Caro lina and Virginia (excluding metro-DC). JELFs last-dollar lending policy is designed to serve students in need who would otherwise have to take out even more high-interest loans, incur high credit card balances or simply put off their education. When compared with the Stafford loan (a typical student loan), a $5,000 interest-free loan from JELF saves over $2,600 in interest. While JELF sometimes serves students who have faced major tragedy in their lives, many of its thousands of recipients simply come from middle class families struggling to find the resources to pay for the increased cost of higher education. JELFs 99 percent repay ment rate reflects how aware our students are that every dollar repaid is a dollar that helps another Jewish stu dent. The organization is made of a 40-person Board of Directors who are grate ful for JELFs growth both amongst applicants as well as donors from the communi ties it serves. JELF has a long-standing goal that has never wavered since 1889: to provide Jewish youth in need the knowledge and skills to step into their futures with confidence and lead successful lives. To day, JELFs mission remains rooted in its twin objectives of helping ensure the higher education for our Jewish com munitys next generation. As Bea Feiman, past president of JELF, poignantly stated: You can lose many things, but an education once gained can never be lost. Today, JELFs mission is more relevant than ever. Ac cording to the National Center for Education Statistics, over the last 10 years the cost of a public university rose 33 percent and rose 26 percent for a private institutionfaster than the rate of inflation. By comparison, JELF granted loans to 121 students in 2007 for a total of $604,709 and in 2017, awarded $1,000,046 to 273 students. This figure rep resents more money to more students than ever before. As the Torah portion Mishpatim guides us, interest-free lend ing is actually the highest form of tzedakah. After all, we all know that teaching a man to fish is more empowering than just giving him a fish. JELF has two applica tion periods each year: March 1April 30 for the full upcoming school year (fall, spring & summer); and Sept. 130 for the following spring and/or summer terms. For more information about either becoming involved in JELF or applying for aid, visit jelf.org or email info@jelf.org. Need help to pay for college? JELF can help Abraham Cohen When, in 1967, Israel dismantled Syrian guns on the Golan Heights as part of a preemptive strike, it was a mystery to most how they knew those weapons secret location. Few knew it was the work of Eli Cohen, a 41-year-old married father of two daugh ters and a son, and Israels most famous spy, who had successfully penetrated the upper echelons of the Syrian government as an undercover Mossad agent. The secrets he obtained proved crucial to Israels victory in the Six-Day War. He had infiltrated the regime with such brilliance that he was being considered for the position of Syrian min ister of defense, said Rabbi Yanky Majesky of Chabad North Orlando. He was eventually discov ered, captured, tortured and publicly executed, leaving behind a widow, three daugh ters and a son. His remains still have not been returned to Israel, despite many dip lomatic attempts to ensure a proper resting place for our man in Damascus. Avraham Cohen said that even if his presentation inspires someone to try and apply pressure on Syria to return the remains, he holds little hope of such a development, since in recent years, there really has been no Syria; no one to talk to over there, and few with a sympathetic ear. In the days between Jan. 8 11, 2018, Avraham Cohen will tour Central Florida and visit five Chabad centers to retell the amazing story of his brother Israels great est spy. Cohen will reveal behind the scenes insight into Eli Cohens story, said Majesky. He will share his familys experience as well as the ongoing struggle to have his brothers remains returned to Israel. Before retiring in 2009, Avraham Cohen was the senior economist for the in dustrial development bank of Israel, in charge of feasibility studies for the electronics, high-tech and defense indus tries. He now volunteers with the Weizmann Historical Ar chive and is active in the As sociation for the Preservation of the Legacy of Eli Cohen. The tour schedule is as follows: South OrlandoMon day, Jan. 8, 7 p.m. www. JewishOrlando.com or 800765-7905 LongwoodTuesday, Jan. 9, 7:30 p.m. www. JewishNorthOrlando.com/ EliCohen or 407-636-5994 The VillagesWednes day, Jan. 10, 12:30 p.m. www.OurChabad.org or 352-330-4466 Palm CoastWednes day, Jan. 10, 7:30 p.m. Brother of Israels greatest spy touring Central Florida www.ChabadPalmCoast. com or 386-225-4941 LakelandThurs day, Jan. 11, 7 p.m. www.ChabadLakeland. org or 863-937-5565 To reserve seats and pur chase tickets or for more information please contact the location nearest you. By Rachel Raskin-Zrihen Vallejo Times-Herald It could be argued that Israel might not exist today were it not for Eliahu Eli Cohen, who was executed as a spy in Syria in 1965but not before passing on information that likely saved his country. Over 50 years later, Avra ham Cohen, is still trying to get his brothers remains returned. Avraham Cohen, Eli Cohens last surviving sibling, will be speaking at Nates Shul as part of a larger presentation on the historical and ongoing issue. Its something hes been doing in Israel for many years, but abroad for only five, he said. I feel I have a mission and a duty to honor Elis memory, he said. Its painful to talk about, but I also feel its a great honor to be his brother, and I feel a sense of warmth when I share his story. 205 North Street Longwood, FL 32750 www.elegantprinting.net Bring in this ad and receive 18% DiscountInvitations & AnnouncementsBrochures & Booklets Forms & Letterheads Business Cards C ustom Pri nting Direct Mail Services Envelopes 407-767-7110

PAGE 3

HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 PAGE 3A Mark Wilson/Getty Images Sen. Al Franken at a Capitol Hill committee hearing on hurricane recovery efforts in Puerto Rico, Nov. 14, 2017. By Ben Sales (JTA)Its a shame Al Franken has to go, Minnesota Jews say. But he has to go. Thats the feeling Minne sota Jewish leaders expressed a day after the Democratic senator announced he would resign his seat in the coming weeks following a string of sexual harassment allegations against him. Eight women have accused Franken of inap propriate conduct, and many of his Democratic colleagues called on him to step down. Franken denies some of the allegations. Minnesotans deserve a senator who can focus with all her energy on addressing the issues they face every day, Franken, who is Jewish, said in a speech on the Senate floor Thursday. I know in my heart that nothing I have done as a senator, nothing, has brought dishonor on this institution. Jewish political activists in Minnesota and beyond told JTA that they have fond memories of the senator, whom they described as an advocate for their agenda and a patron of the local Jewish community. But several said he was making the right choice by resigning. I think Senator Franken has been a really effective senator, said Carin Mrotz, executive director of Jewish Community Action, a lib eral Jewish Minnesota activist group. It was hard to lose him from the Senate, and its also what needed to happen. I think that in resigning he has an opportunity to say this is a culture thats toxic, and he wants to be part of that change rather than part of the problem. Franken was elected to the Senate in 2008 following a ca reer as a comedian, actor and liberal political author and activist. He won re-election comfortably in 2014 and rose in national prominence this year for his aggressive ques tioning of President Donald Trumps executive appointees. As a senator, Franken was a friend to Jewish communal priorities, his Jewish con stituents said. He supported parochial Jewish issues like safeguarding Israels security, as well as domestic policies favored by communal institu tions, like expanding access to health care and social services. At times he disagreed with legacy Jewish groups, notably in his support for the agree ment curbing Irans nuclear program that most large Jew ish groups opposed. But Steve Hunegs, executive director of the local Jewish Community Relations Council, said Fran ken remained friendly despite that conflict. He always made time for the Jewish community when we would go and visit him in D.C., Hunegs said. When he was in town, if there was a visiting Israeli diplomat, he would receive the visiting Israeli diplomat. If we had human services concerns, he was always open to discussing the issue In his personal life, Fran ken was not just Jewish but Jewythat is, highly identi fied if not personally religious. He grew up in St. Louis Park, a Minneapolis suburb with a large Jewish population that served as the setting for the Coen Brothers film A Serious Man. In his recent memoir, Al Franken: Giant of the Senate, Franken recalls learning moral lessons from his childhood rabbi at the Reform Temple Israel. We had the Holocaust pounded into our heads, he told JTA in June. That was our first lesson in justice. Our rabbi, Rabbi [Max] Shapiro, would say, Its not enough to be for justice. You have to do justice. I think he was quot ing Hillel. Franken also brought out his Jewishness in his comedy. As one of the original writers on Saturday Night Live, he co-wrote, with his writing partner Tom Davis, a skit in which a mohel performs a circumcision in the backseat of a car in order to test its suspension. And his signa ture character, the feckless, unlicensed therapist Stuart Smalley, channeled stereo typical Jewish neuroses. As a lawmaker, Franken re mained Jewishly affiliated, at tending Temple Israel for High Holidays services and speaking there at a 2011 dinner to honor former Vice President Walter Mondale, a fellow Minnesota Democrat. He also sits on the council of the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum. There was a great pride in having another Jewish sena tor in that seat, said Marcia Zimmerman, Temple Israels current senior rabbi, referring to the Jewish senators who preceded Franken in his posi tion. We were quite proud of his position and what he has done as a senator. Not everyone was happy with Frankens performance. Mark Miller, who chairs the local chapter of the Republican Jewish Coali tion, portrayed Franken as an ineffective senator and moral disgrace. Miller disliked Frankens support for abor tion rights and opposition to conservative judges. He was a complete hypo crite, Miller told JTA, stress ing that he was speaking only for himself and not for the Republican Jewish Coalition. When the Weinstein allega Al Frankens resignation pains his Jewish fans in Minnesota The Jerusalem Central Bus Station. the scene, the terrorist was quickly apprehended, while the security guard was evacu ated to Jerusalems Shaarei Tzedek Hospital in serious condition. Doctors were able to sta bilize the condition of El maliach. According to the hospital, had he come in two minutes later there would have been nothing we could do. Thats all that separated life from death. Hours before the attack, the terrorist wrote on Face book, Please let our blood be spilledfor it is of little matter to spill ones blood for our homeland, for Jerusalem, and for the Al Aqsa Mosque. The attack came after the Gaza-ruling Palestinian ter ror group Hamas last week called for a violent uprising in response to President Donald Trumps recognition of Jeru salem as Israels capital. Al-Qura is reportedly the son of a retired Palestin ian Authority (PA) general, Yousef al-Qura. Several alQura family members hold high-level positions in the PA security forces. Palestinian terrorist stabs security guard in Jerusalem (JNS) An Israeli security guard is in serious condition after a Palestinian terrorist stabbed him in the heart on Sunday at the entrance to the Jerusalem Central Bus Station. Graphic security foot age of the incident shows the 24-year-old terrorist, Yassin Abu al-Qura, removing his coat at the stations entrance and then suddenly drawing a large knife and plunging it directly into 46-year-old security guard Asher Elma liachs heart. After attempting to flee tions came out, I remember Franken saying how terrible it is, and then these allegations came out and he had to resign. The guy was a disaster. Good riddance. Revelations about the Hol lywood mogul Harvey Wein steins treatment of women set in motion a series of accusa tion of sexual harassment and assault by high-powered men. Weinstein is under investiga tion in New York, Los Angeles and the United Kingdom after 80 women came forward with allegations of harassment, abuse, unwanted advances, retaliation and rape. Some of Frankens liberal Jewish supporters agree with Miller on one point: Franken was right to resign. Even though they appreciated his work in the Senate, they said that by facing the conse quences of his actions, he set a good example for the wave of men accused of sexual assault in politics and beyond. Theres a loss of his voice, but the resignation is an ex pression that no one is above that accountability, said Rabbi Rick Jacobs, president of the Union for Reform Judaism We will miss that voice, but we understand and affirm his courage to resign and set an example for all others. AP/Manish Swarup Indian Foreign Minister Sushma Swaraj (C) with Chinese and Russian counterparts Wang Yi, (R) and Sergey Lavrov. By: Ben Cohen The Algemeiner Foreign ministers from In dia, Russia and China notably refrained from recognizing East Jerusalem as the capital of Palestine at their annual meeting in New Delhi this weekseven days after the US recognized the holy city as the capital of Israel. The decision not to re state the position on Jeru salem long-held by all three countries was in marked contrast to their joint call at last years meeting in Moscow for a sovereign, independent, viable and united State of Pal estine, with East Jerusalem as its capital. At this years 15th annual meeting, their statement on the IsraeliPalestinian conflict stressed support for an independent, viable, territorially contigu ous Palestinian State living side by side in peace and security with Israel within India, China and Russian refrain from recognizing East Jerusalem as capital of Palestine mutually agreed and interna tionally recognized borders, without mentioning the issue of Jerusalem. The absence of Jerusalem from Tuesdays statement is particularly striking given the strident opposition to the US move in the Arab and Mus lim worlds. Turkey and Iran, both of whom retain close diplomatic and security ties with all three countries, have led the denunciation of the US announcement on Jerusalem. India in particular stands out for not having even taken a position on the US decision. Asked for clarification of In dias position on December 7, a spokesperson for the External Affairs Ministry said simply, Indias position on Palestine is independent and consistent. It is shaped by our views and interests, and not determined by any third country. Bilat eral relations between Israel and India were handed an unprecedented boost by Prime Minister Narendra Modis high-profile visit to the Jewish state in July of this year. Russias individual position is also under scrutiny, follow ing the announcement by its foreign ministry last April that Moscow was recognizing West Jerusalem as Israels capital. At the time, the Russians stated their reaffirmation of their commitment to the UN-approved principles for a Palestinian-Israeli settle ment, which include the status of East Jerusalem as the capital of the future Palestinian state. At the same time, we must state that in this context we view West Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. That statement went onto declare support for the two-state solution as an optimal option that meets the national interests of the Palestinian and Israeli people, both of whom have friendly relations with Russia. Meanwhile, Chinas official statement in response to Trumps decision expressed strong concern at the security implications of the move but stopped short of full-throated condemnation. A spokesper son for the foreign ministry even implied that historic claims of exclusive Arab ownership of the city are not as clear-cut as Palestinian leaders might believe. The question over the status of Jerusalem is com plicated and sensitive, for eign ministry spokesperson Geng Shuang said, following Trumps recognition an nouncement. All parties should be cautious in order to maintain peace. All parties should avoid shaking the longterm foundations of solving the Palestinian issues, and avoid creating new divisions in the region.

PAGE 4

PAGE 4A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 THE VIEWS EXPRESSED ON THIS PAGE ARE NOT NECESSARILY THE VIEWS OF HERITAGE MANAGEMENT. CENTRAL FLORIDAS INDEPENDENT JEWISH VOICE ISSN 0199-0721 Winner of 46 Press Awards HERITAGE Florida Jewish News (ISN 0199-0721) is published weekly for $37.95 per year to Florida ad dresses ($46.95 for the rest of the U.S.) by HERITAGE Central Florida Jewish News, Inc., 207 OBrien Road, Suite 101, Fern Park, FL 32730. Periodicals postage paid at Fern Park and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes and other correspondence to: HERITAGE, P.O. Box 300742, Fern Park, FL 32730. PHONE NUMBER (407) 834-8787 FAX (407) 831-0507 MAILING ADDRESS P.O. Box 300742 Fern Park, FL 32730 email: news@orlandoheritage.com Editor/Publisher Jeffrey Gaeser Editor Emeritus Associate Editor News Editor Gene Starn Kim Fischer Christine DeSouza Account Executives Kim Fischer Marci Gaeser Contributing Columnists Jim Shipley Ira Sharkansky David Bornstein Ed Ziegler Production Department David Lehman Gil Dombrosky Joyce Gore Society Editor Gloria Yousha Office Manager Paulette Alfonso By Stephen M. Flatow JNS The P is for Palestine childrens book that is causing so much controversy presents anti-Israel propaganda and deeply disturbing justifications for intifada violence. But it also contains one very important truth. Golbarg Bashi, the Iranian-born author, decided to use the device of an alphabet book to indoctrinate children with anti-Israel mes sages. The most incendiary part, which has been at the center of much of the public debate about the book, declares, I is for Intifada, Arabic for rising up for what is right, if you are a kid or grownup! The accompanying illustration shows a father and child, wearing keffiyahs, standing near barbed wire (symbol of Israeli oppres sion) and flashing the V-for-victory sign. Victory over Israel, that is. Not surprisingly, many Jews are troubled by Bashis attempt to justify and glorify the waves of Palestinian intifada violence, in which more than 1,300 Israeli Jews were murdered. Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch of Manhattans Ste phen Wise Free Synagogue, a leading critic of the book, correctly described it as the glori fication of the Palestinian intifadaa cruel, murderous, and terroristic campaign that purposely targeted innocent Israelis, includ ing children, in restaurants, buses, hospitals, schools and shopping malls...The intifada was not a rising up for what is right. It was a mass descent into immorality. In a Facebook post, Bashi blamed criticism of her book on what she called self-proclaimed powerful neighborhoods of New York City. Thats pretty obvious code language for the Jews. But its also important to pay close atten tion to the explanations that Bashi and her supporters have presented in several recent interviews. Intifada is part of Palestinian life, to resist occupation, she told JTA. In an interview with Haaretz, Bashi elaborated, Intifada is an aspect of Palestinian life just as Bethlehem is the birthplace of Jesus Christ. An Israeli Arab educator named Areej Masarwa added, Its part of Palestin ian identity. Exactly right. Mass violence against Jews is indeed a central part of Palestinian identity. And that tells us a lot about Palestinian identity. Palestinian Arab nationalism did not arise because of any major historical, linguistic, religious or cultural differences between Palestinian Arabs and, say, Jordanian Arabs or Syrian Arabs. Thats because there arent any. Palestinian nationalism arose as antinationalism. Its raison dtre is to murder Jews and destroy the state of Israel. Other nations express their distinctive identity through positive cultural expressions. The Palestinians express their identity by bombing, shooting, hijacking, stabbing and stoning Jews. Witness Sundays stabbing attack at Jerusalems Central Bus Station. Why does the character of Palestinian Arab identity matter? Because the fight for Israels survival is not just a military conflict. Its also a war of ideas. Understanding the legitimacy of Jewish nationalism, and the falseness of Palestinian nationalism, is vital. We must understand why our side is rightand why their side is wrong. So, thank you, Golbarg Bashi, for helping to remind us of the true nature of Palestinian nationalism. Stephen M. Flatow, a vice president of the Religious Zionists of America, is an attorney in New Jersey. He is the father of Alisa Flatow, who was murdered in an Iranian-sponsored Palestinian terrorist attack in 1995. He may be reached at smflatow@gmail.com. P is for Palestine author got one thing right By Caroline Glick Monday, Dec. 4, The New York Times pub lished the Palestinian response to an alleged Saudi peace plan. Saudi Crown Prince Moham med bin Salman reportedly presented it to PLO chief and Palestinian Authority chairman Mahmoud Abbas last month. According to the Times report, Mohammed told Abbas he has two months to either accept the Saudi proposal or leave office to make way for a new Palestinian leader who will accept it. The Palestinians and their European sup porters are up in arms about the content of Mohammeds plan. It reportedly proposes the establishment of limited Palestinian sovereign ty over small portions of Judea and Samaria. The Gaza Strip, over which the Palestinians have had full sovereignty since Israel pulled its military forces and civilians out in 2005, would be expanded into the northern Sinai, thus providing economic and territorial viability to the envisioned Palestinian state. While the Palestinians would not receive sovereignty over Jerusalem, they would be able to establish their capital in the Jerusalem suburb of Abu Dis. There are several aspects of the alleged Saudi peace plan that are notable. First, the Palestinians and their many allies insist that it is a nonstarter. No Palestinian leader could ever accept the offer and survive in power, they told the Times. The same Palestinian leaders from Hamas and Fatah, and their allies, also noted that the Saudi plan as reported strongly resembles past Israeli proposals. Another aspect of the report that is notable is that the Saudis did not acknowledge that Mohammed presented the plan to Abbas. Unlike the situation in 2002 when Times columnist Thomas Friedman presented what he claimed was then Saudi king Abdullahs peace plan, the Saudi regime has not admitted that the characterization of their peace plan by the Times reflects their thinking. It makes sense that the Palestinians and their Lebanese and European allies are upset at the alleged contents of the new Saudi plan. It is also reasonable that the Saudis are not willing today to publicly present the plan laid out in the Times. The fact is that the alleged Saudi peace plan represents a radical break with the all the peace plans presented by the Arabs, the Europeans and the US for the past 40 years. Unlike all of the previous plans, the contours of the plan reported by the Times guarantee that Israel will remain a strong, viable state in an era of peace with the Palestinians. All the previous plans required Israel to accept indefensible borders that would have invited aggression both from the Palestinians and from its Arab neighbors east of the Jordan River. The purported Saudi plan is the first peace plan that foresees two viable states living in peace. All the other plans were based on trans forming Israel into a non-viable state with a non-viable Palestinian state in its heartland. While the Times report cites Western sources claiming that Egypt has rejected the prospect of merging Gaza with the northern Sinai under Palestinian sovereignty, there is no reason to assume that the option is dead. To the contrary, in the aftermath of last weeks massacre of 305 Muslim worshipers in a mosque in the northern Sinai, it is arguably more relevant now than at any previous time. The mosque massacre makes clear that the Egyptian regime is incapable of defeating the Islamic State (ISIS) insurgency in Sinai on its own. Egypts incapacity is as much a function of economic priorities as military capabilities. With Egypt constantly on the brink of economic collapse and in need of constant support from the World Bank, the US and the Gulf States, it is hard to make the argument for preferring economic investment in Sinai to economic investment west of the Suez Canal. And in the absence of significant economic support for developing the Sinai, it is hard to see an end to the ISIS insurgency. If the Europeans, Americans and Arab League member states chose to develop the northern Sinai for a Palestinian state with half the enthusiasm they have devoted to building a non-viable Palestinian state in Jerusalem and Judea and Samaria that would render Israel indefensible and enfeebled, the A credible peace plan, finally By Andrew Tobin JERUSALEM (JTA)Amid the global con troversy over President Donald Trumps recog nition last week of Jerusalem as the capital of the Jewish state, Israeli and Palestinian leaders actually found rare consensus: They agreed that the development was a win for Israel and a loss for the Palestinians. To be sure, Trumps concession was not a major one. Israel was always expected to get a recognized capital in Jerusalem under any Middle East peace deal, and the president did not reject Palestinian claims to have their capital in the city, too. However, the change in two decades of American policy on Jerusalem cemented the impression on both sides that the United States was tilting toward Israel. With Trumps team working on a peace deal, Israeli and Palestin ian leaders debated how his decision would affect the effort. The Israelis said their country still wants peace and Trump was only recognizing the ob vious: Israel already controls all of Jerusalem, has treated it as its capital for 69 years and was never going to settle for anything less than an acknowledgement that Jerusalem is its capi tal. Whether the Palestinians can also claim parts of Jerusalem as their capital remains an open question, but that was always one of the so-called final-status issues at the heart of negotiations. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Sunday during a visit with French Presi dent Emanuel Macron that Jerusalem was as much Israels capital as Paris was Frances, and that recognition of this fact was neces sary for peace. I think that what peace requires is to be built on the foundation of truth, on the facts of the past and on the present, Netanyahu said. This is the only way that you can build a pluralistic and successful future. More important, Israeli leaders contended, Trump gave the Palestinians a long overdue reality check. They said the president showed that he would not indulge the Palestinians attempts to deny Israels existence. Netanyahu made that equation explicit in a meeting Monday with European foreign ministers in Brussels. He likened the Palestin ians opposition to recognizing Jerusalem as Israels capital with their refusal to accept the existence of a Jewish state, which he has long maintained was the primary obstacle to peace. I think we should give peace a chance. I think we should see what is presented and see if we can advance this peace. But if we have to begin it, I would say its one place: Recognize the Jewish state, he said Monday morning in Brussels. Its always been about the Jewish What Israel and the Palestinians make of Trumps recognition of Jerusalem state. And its time that the Palestinians rec ognize the Jewish state and also recognize the fact that it has a capital. Its called Jerusalem. Palestinian leaders, meanwhile, accused Israel of having no interest in making peace on terms they could ever accept. By giving Israel something it wants for free, they suggested, Trump signaled that he would not even try to oppose its continued settlement of eastern Jerusalem and the West Bank, which they said has made nearly impossible the creation of the state the Palestinians demand as part of a peace deal. In an op-ed Thursday in The New York Times, Hanan Ashrawi, a Palestinian lawmaker and a member of the Palestine Liberation Or ganizations executive committee, said Trump may have finally put to rest the dream of a two-state solution, which has been on life support for years already. By rewarding its claim on Jerusalem with official recognition, Mr. Trump is giving Israel a free hand to accelerate its policies of creeping annexation of the occupied Palestinian terri tories and its deliberate attempts to erase the Palestinians historical, political, cultural and demographic presence in historic Palestine, she wrote. Saeb Erekat, the Palestinian Authoritys chief peace negotiator, on Thursday for the first time endorsed giving up on a separate Palestinian state and instead pushing for a binational state shared by Jews and Arabsan outcome unthinkable to most Israelis. Now is the time to transform the struggle for one state with equal rights for everyone living in historic Palestine, Erekat told Israels Haaretz newspaper. At the same time, Palestinian leaders said Trumps recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel showed once and for all that the United States was not an honest broker for peace. Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas said in a statement Friday that the United States was no longer fit to oversee the peace process. The next day, Ab bas diplomatic affairs adviser confirmed that the president canceled plans to meet with Vice President Mike Pence this month in Ramallah, the Palestinian Authoritys de facto capital in the West Bank, because of the announcement on Jerusalem. There will not be a meeting with Pence. The matter is bigger than a mere meeting because the United States, in its decisions on Jerusalem, crossed redlines, Majdi al-Khalidi told the P.A. radio station. Palestinian leaders warned that with the two-state solution no longer viable, their people would turn to violence. The Palestinian Authority urged protests, and the Palestinian terrorist group Hamas called for a new inti fada, or uprisinggranted, a call they make habitually. A series of rockets was launched at southern Israel from Gaza, where Hamas governs. However, by Tuesday, the status quo seemed to remain in effect. To ease pressure on Trump over his Jerusalem announcement, Netanyahu quietly delayed the final votes, slated for this week, on a bill that would make it harder for Israel to hand over any part of the city under a future peace deal, Israels Hadashot TV news reported Saturday. Pleased but not ecstatic over Trumps decision, Israelis continued their daily routines. In eastern Jerusalem, Gaza and the West Bank, a wave of Palestinian demonstrations petered out and schools and businesses that had closed reopened. Abbas foreign affairs adviser on Sunday clarified to The Times of Israel that the Palestinians had no plans to cut ties with the United States. We are not cutting our relationship with America. We are protesting the move of Mr. Trump, Nabil Shaath said. We think Mr. Trump has acted in a way that makes it impos sible for the United States to act as an honest broker. We are just expressing that. Meanwhile, the world awaits Trumps plan for what he branded as the ultimate deal between Israel and the Palestinians. Glick on page 15A

PAGE 5

HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 PAGE 5A Reality on page 15A By Sarah N. Stern JNS Dec. 6, 2017, will be forever remembered as a day when a historic wrong had been righted. His long-awaited speech drew praise from both sides of the aisle from our Florida Congressional representa tives Congressman Brian Mast (R-Fla.) called it a day of celebration and warned that for groups like Hamas, this is just another excuse to cause violence and destruc tion that proves they are not ready to negotiate peace. His sentiment was echoed by fel low Republican Ron DeSantis (R-Fla.), who lauded President Trump for is decision, after the Obama administration worked furiously [last De cember] to engineer a U.N. resolution so anti-Israel that it characterized the Western Wall as occupied territory. Meanwhile, Congressman Ted Deutch (D-Fla.) issued a joint statement with Repub lican Ileana Ros-Lehtinen (R-Fla.), highlighting again the profoundly bipartisan nature of the decision. The two Floridians stated that the announcement is a recogni tion of existing U.S. law that Jerusalem is the capital of Is rael and that the U.S. embassy should ultimately be located in the capital. The pair added: There is no debate that the Jewish people have a deeprooted religious, cultural and historic tie to Jerusalem, and todays decision reaffirms that connection. Senator Marco Rubio (RFla.) also threw his support behind the move. I commend President Trump for following U.S. law and recognizing Je rusalem as the eternal capital of the Jewish state of Israel, he noted. The Jerusalem Embassy Act of 1995, which Congress passed during the Clinton administration, he continued, requires the United States not only to recognize Jerusalem as the capital of Israel, but also to eventually move the American embassy to Jerusalem. With his landmark speech, the president accomplished something remarkablehe brought some sorely needed reality therapy to the Pales tinians. Trump honored a biparti san commitment made over 20 years agoa policy reaf firmed by the Senate in June of this year, when lawmakers de clared that Jerusalem should remain the undivided capital of Israel by a 90-0 vote. Zionism is the national liberation movement of the Jewish people, and finally, af ter 2,000 years, we have come home to our ancient home land, where we are no longer passive agents in history, but free and active participants in determining our history. Yet Israel has been the one nation in the world that, up until Dec. 6, had been denied the freedom to choose its own capital and have it recognized by the international commu nity, and to have the nations of the world respect and honor that decision. Of the 190 nations with which the U.S. has diplomatic relations, up until this week, Israel had been the only one whose capital had lacked rec ognition from America. Contrary to what some of the State Department types have argued, this is not a concession to Israel. This is American law, and has been so since 1995. Yes, prior presi dents have taken advantage of a presidential waiver in the law, arguing that it is not the right time. According to these stale State Department types, it is never the right time. They argue that it will destroy the peace process. One might ask, What peace process? The truth is that there has not been any peace process to speak of for at least a year. The latest round of official Israeli-Palestinian talks, held from 2013-2014, broke down under Secretary of State John Kerry because the Palestinian Authority (PA) refused to rec ognize Israel as a Jewish state. PA President Mahmoud Ab bass foreign minister, Riyad al-Maliki, stated in December 2016 that recognizing Israel for what it is, a Jewish state, was unacceptable. If Trumps statement is going to cause mass violence, it is not the fault of the U.S. nor of Israel. It is the fault of the Palestinians, who have not even recognized pre-1967 Israel in their textbooks, who teach that all of pre-1967 Israel will one day become Pales tine, and who have television programs indoctrinating Trump delivers a sorely needed dose of reality therapy By Andrew Silow-Carroll (JTA)E.B. White famous ly wrote that there are rough ly three New Yorks: the one of the native New Yorker, the one of the commuter, and the New York of the person who was born somewhere else and came to New York in quest of something. To which a resident of Jeru salem might respond, Only three? Lucky you. Jerusalem is messy, in the best and worst sense of the word. Its a city of secular intellectuals and insular haredim. Its the seat of Israels government and flypaper for the dreamers, fanatics, seek ers and tourists from three major religion and dozens of cults, sects, denominations and movements. And of course its a city of Jews and Arabs, roughly and unmistakably divided into west and east, with the Old City as a sort of (forgive the imagery) bathtub drain into which both sides swirl, mix and boil. Anyone who likes to talk about Jerusalem as undivid ed is either being delusional or hopelessly optimistic. And thats not just because the city is diverse, or incoherent, or less a typical city than a sprawl of boroughs or villages that somehow share a city hall. You could say the same thing about New York. Undivided is little more than a slogan because no one, least of all the Israelis who run the place, can agree what Jerusalem is. From the 1948-49 War of Independence until the Six-Day War in 1967, Jerusalem was indeed divided: Jordan occupied the Old City and areas to the north and south, and Israel made its capital in the western and southern parts of the city, with a narrow road acting like an umbilical cord between the Israeli side and the Jewish enclave on Mount Scopus. The wall dividing east and west was torn down after the Six-Day War, and Israel celebrated the citys reunifi cation by annexing the Old City and eastern Jerusalem and taking responsibility for the 66,000 or so Arabs living there. The new boundaries added some 40 square miles to the municipality, including familiar Jerusalem neighbor hoods like Pisgat Zeev, Gilo and Ramat Alon. Much of the international commu nity consideredand still considersthese as illegal settlements, although the Israelis insist their claims to Jerusalem and its environs are longstanding and you cant occupy territory that wasnt under the legitimate sovereignty of any state in the first place. By 1993, Jerusalems mu nicipal limits had been ex panded to nearly as far south as Bethlehem, west to include majority Arab neighborhoods like Abu Dis and as far north as the Atarot, or Qalandia, airport, now an army base. The Jerusalem municipality, now 77 square miles, has a Palestinian population of 293,000, or 37 percent of the citys total. The vast majority of this population does not vote in municipal and national elections because they never accepted Israeli citizenship. In October, the Knesset set aside a billreportedly under pressure from the United Statesthat would have redrawn the borders to make the Jerusalem municipality ever larger, absorbing the Jewish communities of Maale Adumim, Beitar Illit and Efrat along with the Etzion bloc of settlements. Declarations that Jeru salem should remain the undivided capital of Israel, like a unanimous Senate resolution passed earlier this year marking the 50th an niversary of the reunification of Jerusalem, rarely specify what they mean by Jerusalem In his announcement last week recognizing Jerusalem as Israels capital, President Donald Trump did not use the phrase undivided Jeru salem, and indeed insisted What we talk about when we talk about Jerusalem that the United States is not taking a position of any final status issues, including the specific boundaries of the Is raeli sovereignty in Jerusalem or the resolution of contested borders. That makes sense because Israels sovereignty and the borders of any future Pal estinians state are what the peace process is supposed to be about. Arguments for keeping Jerusalem undivided are both emotional and practical. The idea of a city cleaved in two is both aesthetically and pragmatically troubling. Without fail, divided cities suffer either intense economic stagnation or general atro phy, Nathan Diament, execu tive director for the Orthodox By Hara Person NEW YORK (JTA)In a recent talk at Temple Emanuel here, former first lady Michelle Obama spoke about how women live with tiny cuts that build up over time, cuts that we endure without noticing, even as we bleed. That is what it is to be a girl and a woman in this world, she said, urging women to own our scars, and to find power and healing in doing so. The last weeks have been a sobering reminder that sexual misconduct is rampant in every profession, not just in the entertainment industry or in politics. It is a reminder, as if we needed a reminder, that to grow up a girl is to expect, if not accept, unwanted com ments, remarks, touching and assault. As women, in our personal lives and profes sional careers, we all have our stories, our workarounds and our scars. The conversation about sexual harassment and sexual assault in our society comes at a time when the Central Con ference of American Rabbis, the professional organization of Reform rabbis, stands ready to launch the Task Force on the Experience of Women in the Rabbinate. This need be came evident in the aftermath of the 2016 presidential elec tion, the publication of The Sacred Calling: Four Decades of Women in the Rabbinate and a study we undertook on rabbinic professional satisfac tion. Although women have been Reform rabbis for 45 years, it is painfully obvious that these issues are still a fact of everyday life. The rabbinate is no excep tion to the conversations going on in the wider world about womens experiences. It is the rare female rabbi who, if married to a man, has not been asked if her husband is also a rabbi. Or the joke we all hear: If the wife of a rabbi is a rebbetzin, what do you call the husband of a rabbi? (Lucky.) While seemingly harmless, such comments nonetheless undermine the credibility and authority of women as rabbis. And the comments dont stop there. There are these lines, uttered at board meet ings or during the oneg or even at a funeral, like Ive always wanted to kiss a rabbi, or If rabbis looked like you when I was a kid, I would have come to synagogue more. Theres a kind of sliding scale to the comments, from bad to worse. Rabbi, please cross your legs when seated on the bimah, otherwise its too distracting. Rabbi, are you pregnant? Your breasts look bigger. And so on, and so on. Women rabbis are coun seled to wear lipstick or told not to wear lipstick. We are told that our clothing choices are too revealing or too dowdy. Our shoes are too sexy or too old fashioned. Our voices are too soft or too strident. Were too emotional or were too cold. Were called by our first names while the male rabbi is called Rabbi LastName. Were called kiddo, babe, sugar, sexy, honey. Were advised to get home quickly from a board meeting so that we can make our husbands happy. And it isnt just laypeople. There are stories as well of rabbis in positions of power preying on younger, more vulnerable rabbis, inappropri ate touching or comments during supervisory sessions, and jokes that are not in the least bit funny. In only four short decades since the first ordination, there are now nearly 700 wom en members of the CCAR, the first rabbinic organization in history to admit women as full members. In this time, women rabbis have made profound progress. The adoption in the 1980s of egalitarian liturgical language and gender-neutral God language in our prayer books and Haggadot opened up prayer and Jewish practice in important new ways. The development of new lifecycle rituals allowed for the sanctification of experiences previously outside traditional Jewish practice. The publica tion of the groundbreaking and award-winning The To When women rabbis say #MeToo, communities must pay attention rah: A Womens Commentary highlighted and canonized feminist Torah scholarship. However, women rabbis still experience substantial obstacles: gender-based bias, inappropriate comments, sexual harassment, sexual assault, lack of proper institu tional support, undermining behavior, and issues related to contracts, pay equity and parental leave. Intertwined with these challenges are is sues of sexuality and gender nonconformity. The CCAR already has in place a robust ethics code and rigorous ethics process to address instances of rab binic misconduct. Whether these experiences happen in congregations, in communal or institutional settings, in rabbinic school or student placements; whether they happen with colleagues or with laypeople, when com Talk on page 15A #MeToo on page 15A

PAGE 6

PAGE 6A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 LIGHT SHABBAT CANDLES AT A COMPREHENSIVE COMMUNITY CALENDAR Whats Happening For inclusion in the Whats Happening Calendar, copy must be sent on sepa rate sheet and clearly marked for Calendar. Submit copy via: e-mail (news@ orlandoheritage.com); mail (P.O. Box 300742, Fern Park, FL 32730-0742); fax (407-831-0507); or drop it by the office (207 OBrien Rd., Ste. 101, Fern Park) Deadline is Wednesday noon, 10 days prior to publication. DEC. 22 5:16 p.m. DEC. 29 5:20 p.m. MAIL SUBSCRIPTION TO: Name ___________________________________________________ Address _________________________________________________ City/State/Zip _____________________________________________ Phone _________________________________ # ____________________________________________ expiration date __________________________________ Name _______________________________ Address _____________________________ ________________________ Phone _______________________________ YES! I want to be informed. Start my subscription at once. Please: enter extend my subscription for: 1 year at $37.95 52 issues 2 years at $69.95 104 issues 1 year out-of-state at $46.95 or 2 years out-of-state at $87.95 P.O. Box 300742 (407) 834-8787 Its inexcusable! My week is not complete without it! Im lost without it! I cant live without it! How in the world am I supposed to know whats going on? What are you missing out on?... Subscribe today! These are some of the comments we receive from readers when they miss an issue of Heritage Florida Jewish News Quote of the Week I come to Jerusalem. There, the sky is blue and memory becomes clear. Menachem Begin 63. Looks 64. Meas. for Jamie Geller or Susie Fishbein 65. 2017, e.g. Down 1. Star Wars, e.g. 2. Israeli hero Ramon 3. Copacabana girl 4. HEBREW 5. Make like the Jewish people 6. Potential beau 7. Like a shabby Shabbat shirt 8. Brother, in Israel 9. Attachment for closeups 10. Stella ___ 11. Brownish horses 12. Hello. My name is ___ Montoya. You killed my father. Prepare to die. 13. Brother of Miriam 18. Month with a megillah reading 22. Blood poisoning 24. Ray Donovan actor Schreiber 25. Legal claim on a property 26. Need aspirin, maybe 27. Kill like Samson 28. What a sacrifice must be 31. Admits 32. Stan celebrating his 95th on December 28th 33. Genesis creator? 34. Actor Jonah 35. Bills in America, but not Israel 37. Fingerprints or DNA 38. Chatter: Slang 39. Many a summer option from BBYO and NCSY 43. Close again, as a Ziploc bag 44. Release a chin strap 45. Ooze like honey 46. The most famous Jew of all time 47. ___ you a little short for a stormtrooper? (Carrie Fisher) 48. Exchange between Sela and Nadal 49. Shoe like a clog 50. Sophs and Jrs. 53. Lois created by Jerry Siegel 54. James of jazz 55. Mix (the chicken soup) 57. Two-time loser to D.D.E. 59. Not ordained See answers on page 14. Across 1. Cocoon covering 5. United hub, briefly 8. The Simpsons voice man Hank 14. Soothing ointment 15. Daughter of Zelophehad in the Bible 16. Mexican competitor of 10-Down 17. Breakout movie star of 2017 19. Kind of big balloon 20. The NHL Ducks, on scoreboards 21. Rapper Nissim often does them, essentially 23. Large Blazing Saddles character 24. In 2017 Mark Zuckerberg replaced him as the worlds richest Jew 26. Harbor high hopes 29. Dominos or Big Apple output 30. This might be a frustrat ing one 31. Elizabeth who plays an Avenger (Scarlet Witch) 33. Home of Homeland, for short 36. Jew that made the most headlines in 2017, unfortu nately 40. Visual palindrome 41. Blades of a windmill 42. Synonym for 40-Across 43. Wrestler Flair and musi cian Ocasek 44. Same old bar orders 46. Jew given a truly monu mental task by his father-inlaw in 2017 51. Clean, as a flash drive 52. Like MySpace 53. ___ Misrables, film with Sacha Baron Cohen 56. Gomez sarcastically called a college grad by Joan Rivers 58. Broadways breakout star of 2017 60. Take off hockey skates 61. Light moshav located outside Jerusalem 62. Establishment start? Challenging puzzle Jews in the News by Yoni Glatt koshercrosswords@gmail.com MORNING AND EVENING MINYANS (Call synagogue to confirm time.) Chabad of South OrlandoMonday Friday, 8 a.m. and 10 minutes before sunset; Saturday, 9:30 a.m.; Sunday, 8:15 a.m., 407-354-3660. Congregation Ahavas YisraelMonday Friday, 7:30 a.m.; Saturday, 9:30 a.m.; Sunday, 9 a.m., 407-644-2500. Congregation Chabad Lubavitch of Greater DaytonaMonday, 8 a.m.; Thursday, 8 a.m., 904672-9300. Congregation Ohev ShalomSunday, 9 a.m., 407-298-4650. GOBOR Community Minyan at Jewish Academy of OrlandoMondayFriday, 7:45 a.m.8:30 a.m. Temple IsraelSunday, 9 a.m., 407-647-3055. FRIDAY, DECEMBER 22 Ahavas YisraelKabbalat, 30 minutes before sundown. SUNDAY, DECEMBER 24 Kehillah: A History of Jewish Life in Greater OrlandoOngoing exhibit at the Orange County Regional History Center, 65 E. Central Blvd., Orlando, and will continue through Feb. 20, 2018. JOIN OrlandoKids in the Kitchen, 1 p.m.-3 p.m. Children ages 5-12 can create crafts and make food. 109 Water Oak Lane, Altamonte Springs, Fla. Register at joinkik.eventbrite.com MONDAY, DECEMBER 25 Israeli Folk Dancing7:30-8:15 p.m. instruction, 8:15-10 p.m., requests. Cost: Free for JCC members, $5 nonmembers. Info: 407-645-5933. TUESDAY, DECEMBER 26 JOIN OrlandoMens Whiskey and Wisdom, 8:30 p.m. at The JOIN House, 109 Water Oak Lane, Altamonte Springs. Free of charge WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 27 Temple IsraelLunch & Learn with Rabbi Neely, noon1 p.m. A parashat discussion class. Open to the public, no RSVP needed. Info: 407-647-3055. THURSDAY DECEMBER 28 SPARKDessert and Discussion, 7:30-8:30 p.m. Join Sarah Gittleson and other Orlando Jewish women to discuss different Jewish values and concepts in a meaningful and interactive way. Free of charge, held at JOIN House, 109 Water Oak Lane, Altamonte Springs. FRIDAY, DECEMBER 29 Ahavas YisraelKabbalat, 30 minutes before sundown. Kehillah continues to amaze its viewers Kostya Kimlat and his niece Kira Murga are entertained by Fatz, one of the animatronic characters created by Aaron Fechter, founder of Creative Engineering. Kehillah: A History of the Jews of Orlando continues at the Orange County Regional History Center through Feb. 20, 2018. For information about hours of operation and cost, please call 407-836-8500. The History Center is located at 65 E. Central Blvd., Orlando.

PAGE 7

HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 PAGE 7A HEALTHY EYES WEAR SUNGLASSESEvery day that youre outside, youre exposed to dangerous, but invisible, ultraviolet (UV) sunlight. Left unprotected, prolonged exposure to UV radiation can seriously damage the eye, leading to cataracts, skin cancer around the eyelid and other eye disorders. Protecting your eyes is important to maintaining eye health now and in the future. Shield your eyes (and your familys eyes) from harmful UV rays. Wear sunglasses with maximum UV protection. For more information, visit www.thevisioncouncil.org/consumers/sunglasses. A public service message from The Vision Council. rf rntbn rrrn rfrntbr r By Marilyn Shapiro On Dec. 23, Larry and I traveled 400 miles to spend time with our friends, Chris and Bernie Grossman, in their new home in Tallahassee. And on Dec. 25, the Shapiros and Grossmans upheld a tradition as steeped in Jewish culinary ritual as eating brisket on Rosh Hashanah, potato latkes on Chanukah, and matzo ball soup on Passover. We ate Chi nese food on Christmas Day. Growing up in a small town in Upstate New York, my fam ily didnt eat Chinese food on Christmas Day, or most other days of the year. If there was a Chinese restaurant in Platts burg, the big town near us, I dont remember ever going there. Once or twice a year, my father would pile my mother and the four children into the station wagon and drive the 90 minutes to Montreal. We would weave our way into Chinatown and head to the Nanking Cafe. We would climb a set of steep stairs and crowd around a table in a booth. (Family lore tells of the time that my brother Jay drank the water in the finger bowl.) The wonton soup and noodles would be followed by chow mein (much better than the stuff we ate out of cans that we got at the local Grand Union). We would finish up with fortune cookies and vanilla ice cream and head back home. The Chinese food at Christ mas tradition started for me after Larry and I married and bought a home in Saratoga County in 1976. Lings, near the corner of Routes 146 and 9 in Clifton Park, was the only restaurant open on Dec. 25th. (It was also the only Chinese restaurant in a 10mile radius; there are now at least 10!) Larry and I met half the Jewish population of our community there. By the next year, we were going to Lings with a group of friends. And by the time our children left home, we had a standing date for a Dec. 25th dinner with the Grossmans and several other couples in various Chinese restaurants throughout the Capital Dis trict. Wherever we chose to go, we could count on sharing the evening with tables of fellow Jewsincluding many rabbis and their families. The tradition continued when we moved to Florida in 2015, when the Grossmans and another of our regulars, Joyce and Mel Toub, joined us in Kissimmee for three days. Of course, we had reservations at the local Chinese restau rant on Christmas Day. Last year, Chanukah start ed on Dec. 24. Congregation Shalom Aleichem in Kissim mee held a community din ner. I was hoping we would be dining on huge metal pans filled with vegetarian or kosher-style dishes from one of the two Chinese res taurants close to our shul. To my disappointment, the committee planning the event opted for Italian. The next day, we joined my brother Jay, his wife Leslie, and their family for a traditional Chanukah meal in Sarasota. This year, however, we were back on track for wonton and moo shu, heading to Tallahassee to maintain the ritual of eating Chinese food on Dec. 25. According to Mathew Good man, author of Jewish Food: The World at Table, the Jews love for Chinese food dates back over 100 years ago. The Lower East Side of Manhat tan was populated by Eastern European Jews, Italian, and Chinese. Italian cuisine and especially Italian restaurants, with their Christian iconog raphy, held little appeal for Jews, Mark Tracy wrote in a 2011 Atlantic article. But the Chinese restaurants had no Virgin Marys. And they prepared their food in the Cantonese culinary style, which utilized a sweet-andsour flavor profile, overcooked vegetables, and heaps of garlic and onionall similar to Eastern European cuisine. Another theory was in cluded in a 1992 academic (seriously!) paper by Gayle Tuchman and Harry G. Levine in which they supported the idea that Chinese food was Safe Treyf. True the dishes featured un-kosher foods in cluding shellfish and pork. But it was chopped and minced and mixed with so many vegetables, it was disguised. As stated in a 2007 blog post Feed the Spirit, If pork was in wontons (which looked very much like Jewish kreplach) or in tiny pieces in chop suey, it didnt seem as bad as chowing down on a ham sandwich. And the Chinese typically dont cook with dairy products, so no one had to worry about mixing milk and meat. The concept has made it to the highest court in our country. According to the Judaism 101 website, Justice Elana Kagen brought up the Jewish/ Chinese food connection up at her 2010 Supreme Court confirmation hearing. When a senator asked her where she was on Christmas, she said, You know, like all Jews, I was probably at a Chinese restaurant. In 2009, Brandon Miller even penned a song: I eat Chi nese food on Christmas/Go to the movie theater, too/Cause there just aint much else to do on Christmas/When youre a Jew. As you can tell by her un decidedly non-Jewish name, Chris was not born Jewish. She converted after she met Bernie at Grinnell. Chris, whose Hebrew name is Chava, keeps kosher. So on Dec. 25, in a Chinese restaurant in Tallahassee, she ordered the egg drop soup and flounder filet with yu shang sauce. The rest of us, however, ate Safe Treyf. Larry ordered crispy jumbo scallops with black bean sauce. Bernie got egg rolls and black pepper beef tenderloin tips (Bernie always eats something with beef, no matter what ethnic variety food we have, quipped Chris). And I ordered my favoritechicken moo shu chicken with pancakes and plum sauce. After the main meal, we popped open our fortune cookies and shared the Chi nese predictions for the up coming year. Then we went Fried rice, friendship and fortune cookies on Dec. 25 back to the Grossmans and dined on my world famous chocolate chip cookies, another long-standing holi day tradition for us friends. We raised a glass of wine, shouted LChaim (To Life!) or ganbei (gon bay) the tra ditional Chinese toast which literally means dry cup. The Hebrew year is 5778 and the Chinese year is 4715. That must mean, the old joke goes, that against all odds the Jews went without Chinese food for 1,064 years. Fortu nately, for us, we were able to share fried rice, friendship and fortune cookies with the Grossmans.

PAGE 8

PAGE 8A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 that keeps the issue in the public eye as a means of getting through to governments that have influence on Hamas, such as Qatar and Turkey. We need the Jewish com munity and the American government if were going to release him, Fenta said. Ilan Mengistu said they have been heartened by their recep tion here on a visit arranged by the Israeli government and the Jewish Agency for Israel. It in cluded meetings at the Jewish Federations of North America General Assembly last week in Los Angeles, and meetings in Washington and Los Angeles with congregational rabbis. They have also spoken with StandWithUs and J Street about advocacy campaigns. The two groups are usually on opposite sides of the pro-Israel spectruman indication of the breadth of the causes appeal. Advocating for Mengistus return is an issue we hope will bring people and organizations from across a broad swath of the Jewish community to gether, J Street spokeswoman Jessica Rosenblum told JTA. Jason Greenblatt, Presi dent Donald Trumps envoy to Middle East peace, met with the family and posted a photo on his Twitter pagean important signal from the Trump administration figure who is closest to the Palestin ian Authority and has worked to ease economic strife in the Gaza Strip. Today I welcomed the family of Avera Mengistu to the White House, Greenblatt wrote. Avera has been held by Hamas in Gaza for over 1,000 days since he disappeared in September, 2014. It is outra geous that Hamas will not let him return home or commu nicate with his family.They have also met with lawmakers, including Reps. Brad Sher man, D-Calif., Ted Deutch, D-Fla., and Ed Royce, R-Calif., the chairman of the U.S. House of Representatives Foreign Affairs Committee, as well as with staff from the office of Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas. Its not easy repeating this story again and again, Ilan Mengistu said. It requires emotional strength. We get love, and it gives us strength. Jewish Pavilion Program Director Walter Goldstein performed familiar holiday and classic tunes at Brook dale Island Lake. Volunteers Terri Fine-Stenzler and Debbie Meitin led blessings, songs, and told the Chanu kah story to a room filled with friends and neighbors. Vitas Health Care and Cornerstone Hospice provided cookies and calendar gifts for the residents in senior living communities. These photos are from Brookdale Island Lake in Longwood. Berny Raff, who usually organizes the entertainment for COS Seniors, got to sit back and enjoy the day. Jewish Pavilion Chanukah celebrations are in full spin Brookdale Island Lake residents Al and May. Brookdale Island Lake residents Pearl and Ruth enjoyed the festivities. The following is a recipe from the Inbal Jerusalem Hotels executive chef, Chef Nir Elkayam. The Inbals Orange Vegetable Soup is one of the many soups offered during the hotels annual Soup Festival taking place through the winter in Jerusalem. The Inbals Orange Vegetable Soup Ingredients (Yields 8 servings) 2 large onions 4 garlic cloves 2 tablespoons olive oil 2 cups of pumpkin cut into cubes 2 large sweet potatoes cut into cubes 3 large carrots cut into cubes Black pepper 3 fresh thyme leaves Salt Water as needed Directions Heat the olive oil in a large pot and add the chopped onion. Cook until golden brown and add the garlic. Add the thyme and cook for a few seconds. Add the vegetables and water. Then add water to cover the vegetables and bring to a boil. Season lightly and cook until the vegetables are soft. Season to taste. Enjoy! The Orange Vegetable Soup is one of the many soup offerings at the Inbal Jerusalem Hotels Soup Festival. The rich, all youcan-eat soup buffet, runs from November through April at the hotels Sophia Cafe. The Soup Festival is open to hotel guests and the general-public, Sunday-Thursday from noon-10 pm. The Inbal Jerusalem Hotel is an award-winning, deluxe hotel situated in the heart of Jerusalem overlooking the Old City walls, and minutes away from all the major cultural and historical sites. With its Jerusalem stone exterior, the 283-room hotel is known for its intimate authentic Jerusalem character and impeccable world-class service. The hotel was recently awarded the 2016 TripAdvisors Certificate of Excellence award. An Israeli soup that warms the soul and body Previously the property was voted the most luxurious hotel in the TripAdvisor Travelers Choice Awards, as well as the best hotel in Israel and fourth best hotel in the entire Middle East by readers of the influential Cond Nast Traveler magazine. For more information, please visit www.inbalhotel.com. By Ron Kampeas WASHINGTON (JTA)Ilan Mengistu knows his pitch to rescue his brother, Avera, should be a no-brainer to Jewspidyon shvuyim, the redemption of the hostage, is among the greatest of com mandments. But Mengistu also knows that the story he has to tell is not the straightforward nar rative longed for by those who would do good: Avera was not a soldier, nor was he captured exactly. He crossed into the Gaza Strip of his own volition. Mengistu came to Los An geles and Washington, D.C., last week with his mother to raise awareness of the plight of his brother, who has been held captive, presumably by Hamas, since September 2014. Meeting with Jewish organiza tions and lawmakers, they are hoping for the kind of activist and diplomatic pressure that rescued the Mengistus from a repressive regime in Ethiopia and brought them to Israel on Operation Solomon in the early 1990s. For that to happen, Men gistu knows he must start at the beginning of a difficult tale: The birth 31 years ago in Ethiopia of a brother so beloved his mother named him after an Amharic word for light. They say a name shapes an identity, Mengistu said, meet ing a JTA reporter last week in a hotel lobby here. Avera was ebullient and loving, his Ron Kampeas Agamesh Mengistu, with her son Ilan, in Washington, D.C., Nov. 17, 2017. Their troubled brother wandered into Gazanow his Ethiopian-Israeli family wants US help to get him back brother recalled. He was the light in our house, we would feel him around the Shabbat table and on holidays. Light nourishes but also fades: Avera Mengistu, suffer ing from a mental disorder, managed to keep it under control as long as his older brother, Michael, was around. He, his five other brothers and three sisters idolized Michael, who Mengistu says served in Israels esteemed Golani unit and imposed army-like disci pline at home. In 2012, Michael, deep into an ascetic journey, starved himself; he was hospitalized and died. Thats when Avera began to fade. He was institutionalized twice over the subsequent two years, but each time released within less than two weeks. And then, on Sept. 7, 2014, Avera left the familys Ashkelon home and walked into the Gaza Strip. He was imprisoned by Hamas, the terrorist orga nization controlling Gaza. Mengistu had indications from Averas Hamas captors that his brother was alive, but since then, nothing. The family heeded Israeli government pleas to keep quiet for 10 months: The less pub licity, Israeli authorities told them, the likelier his release. After 10 months, despairing, the family asked to go public. They reached out to an array of human rights organiza tions and the International Red Cross. They received as surances, but not sustained exposure of Averas plight. Human Rights Watch put out a report, Mengistu said, and smiled, unable to add much more. The Red Cross also has said it is dedicated to securing the release of Av era Mengistu and Juba Abu Ganima, another Israeli taken captive after entering Gaza. Mengistu skates close to expressions of disappointment throughout the interview: with the Red Cross; with the Israeli government; with his brothers caregivers, who kept releasing him back to the family; with the soldiers who witnessed his brothers crossing into the Gaza Strip (its on video) and did not stop him; even with Avera. But then he backs away. The day the Shabak [Is raels internal security service] came to me, I thought, Gaza, really? Avera, you could have gone anywhere, Mengistu said. But when someone is undergoing a breakdown, their ability to think clearly is clouded. You cant judge. Whats important, he said, is what happens next. The Mengistus want what happens next to be along the lines of the dedicated cam paign that brought about the familys aliyah to Israel in 1991, with the Operation Solomon airlift. It dawned on the family that a driving factor in the Ethio pian aliyah was the American Jewish community, which in the 1970s and 80s argued to a sometimes reluctant Israeli government that the com munity was indeed Jewish and in need of rescue from the repressive regime in power at the time. There is a deep connection between the Jewish commu nity here and the Ethiopian Jewish community, he said. Yonit Fenta, a relative and an activist helping the family, translated the conversation into Amharic for Agamesh Mengistu, the mother of Ilan and Avera. Among American Jews, I can sense mercy, said Agamesh Mengistu, who lis tened quietly through most of the interview, which was conducted in Hebrew. The family hopes for the kind of sustained campaign

PAGE 9

HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 PAGE 9A can be purchased at the following locations: Scene Around Scene Around By Gloria YoushaCall 407-657-9405 or gloriayousha@gmail.com ORANGE COUNTY JCC 851 N. Maitland Ave., Maitland JCC South 11184 South Apopka-Vineland Rd., Orlando Kinneret 515 South Delaney Ave., Orlando SOJC 11200 S. Apopka Vineland Rd., Orlando Browns New York Deli 156 Lake Ave., Maitland Most Publix Supermarkets All Winn Dixie Supermarkets SEMINOLE COUNTY Heritage News 207 OBrien Rd., Fern Park Barnes and Noble Booksellers 451 E. Altamonte Dr. Suite 2317, Altamonte Springs & 1260 Oviedo Marketplace Blvd., Oviedo Bagel King 1472 Semoran Blvd., Casselberry Kosher Kats 744 W. S.R. 434, Longwood Central Florida Hillel 4250 Alafaya Trail, Ste. 212-363, Oviedo Most Publix Supermarkets All Winn Dixie Supermarkets VOLUSIA COUNTY Federation of Volusia/Flagler 470 Andalusia Ave., Ormond Beach Most Publix Supermarkets All Winn Dixie Supermar kets Barnes & Noble 1900 W. International Speedway Blvd., Daytona Beach Perrys Ocean Edge Resort 2209 South Atlantic Ave. Daytona Beach Debary City Hall Debary Library Vienna Coffee House 275 Charles Richard Beall Bl Starbucks 2575 Enterprise Rd Orange City City Hall Orange City Library Dunkin Donuts 1296 S Woodland Stetson University Carlton Union Deland Chamber of Commerce Sterling House 1210 Stone St Temple Israel 1001 E New York Ave Beth Shalom 1310 Maximillan St Deltona City Hall Deltona Library Temple Shalom 1785 Elkam Dr. Temple Israel 1001 E New York Ave, Deland College Arms Apt 101 Amelia Ave, Deland Boston Gourmet Coffee House 109 E. New York Ave, Deland Stetson University Carlton Union 421 N Woodland Ave, Deland Family Bookstore 1301 N Woodland Ave, Deland Deland Chamber of Commerce 336 Woodland Ave, Deland Deland City Hall 120 S Florida Ave, Deland Beth Shalom 206 S. Sprng Garden Ave, Deland Orange City Library 148 Albertus Way, Orange City Boston Gourmet Coffee House 1105 Saxon Blvd, Deltona Deltona Library 2150 Eustace Ave, Deltona Temple Shalom 1785 Elkam Dr., Deltona Deltona Community Center, 980 Lakeshore Dr, Deltona Debary City Hall 16 Colomba Rd, Debary Debary Library 200 Florence K. Little, Debary OSCEOLA COUNTY Cindy M. Rothfield, P.A. 822 W. Bryan St., Kissimmee Most Publix Supermarkets Verandah Place Realty 504 Celebration Ave., Celebration All Winn Dixie Supermarkets St. Cloud City Hall 1300 9th St, St. Cloud St. Cloud Library 810 13th St, St. Cloud Southern Oaks 3865 Old Canoe Creek Rd, St. Cloud Plantation Bay 4641 Old Canoe Creek Rd, St. Cloud Osceola Chamber of Commerce 1425 Hwy 192, St. Cloud Valencia College 1800 Denn John Ln, Kissimmee Kissimmee City Hall 101 Church St, Kissimmee Kissimmee Library 211 E. Dakin, Kissimmee Robinsons Coffee Shop 114 Broadway, Kissimmee Osceola County Courthouse 2 Courthouse Sq, Kissimmee Barnies 3236 John Young Pwy, Kissimmee Reilys Gourmet Coffee 3831 Vine St, Kissimmee Shalom Aleichem 3501 Oak Pointe Blvd, Kissimmee Books-A-Million 2605 W. Osceola Pwy (522), Kissimmee Lower East Side Deli 8548 Palm Parkway, Lake Buena Sudoku (see page 14 for solution) Israel ahead in research... Once again, when it comes to science, medicine... everything, I am proud to say, Israel seems to be leading the pack. I read the following in Impact, the magazine of the American Associates of Ben Gurion University of the Negev. I pass it along to you: In the United States today, one in 68 children is diagnosed with autism, a disorder symptomized by social interaction problems, restricted interests and repetitive behaviors. Autism is currently the most prevalent childhood disorder in this country and the cost is high: an estimated $265 billion in 2015. Despite the high priority of understanding autism and treating it globally, autism continues to puzzle researchers. To address this challenge, Ben Gurion University (BGU) scientists and medical professionals created the Negev Autism Center in 2015. A team of top researchers and medical profes sionals conceived an ambitious project to create the first com prehensive database of children with autism and their families in Israel. The database promises to become a critical tool for finding new answers to this complex development disorder. The scientists began with the view that there is no single answer to autism... a fact most scientists agree with after 15 years of serious research. Its a family of distinctly different disorders that probably have multiple different causes and require a variety of different treatments, according to one of the team. While all diagnosed children exhibit common symptoms, such as social communication problems, their underlying biol ogy varies greatly. There seems to be many paths to autism, another scientists says. In some cases it may be caused by a genetic problem, while in other cases it might be environmental exposure. We need to distinguish between different autistic disorders, he continued. Their goal is not to cure autism, they agree, but to find new tools and techniques that help diagnose children during the first year of their lives and identify their subtype. Then they can recommend optimal interventions to ameliorate as many of the symptoms as possible. (I have great confidence in everything the Israeli scientists do puzzling out the causes of Autism.) And speaking of confidence... I have great confidence in SAMANTHA TAYLOR, publisher of J Life, Orlandos Jewish Lifestyle Magazine. I just received my second edition, Winter 2017, with RUTH ABELS, 100, and four members of her family on the cover marking four generations. What a beautiful lady, what a beautiful family, what a beauti ful magazine... and what a beautiful publisher! This magazine stays on my coffee table for sure. (I have more wrinkles than the lovely Ruth. I recently went to the hospital and asked for a face-lift. They gave me a heart valve instead!) A smart and steady voice... I encourage you all to reach out, discuss the issues and get involved with our Jewish Community Rela tions Council. Through open dialogue, we can all do our part to achieve that timeless American objective: A more perfect union. These are the words of BEN FRIEDMAN, director of Community Relations for the Jewish Federation of Greater Orlando. He brings his background in law and public policy, as well as his passion for advocacy and civil discourse, to his role with Federation. You can reach Ben at bfriedman@jfgo.org or by phone at 407-645-5933 ext. 233 to give him your feedback about moving the embassy to Jerusalem. (I, for one, have mixed feelings about it. Although I agree that Jerusalem is the capital of Israel, I fear for another war. I got caught in the Yom Kipper war when I was there. I repeat, I have mixed feelings.) A holiday feast... SCOT MYERS, president of the Eastbrook Home Owners Association, hosted a holiday party as he does every year and all are invited! The food was delicious and plentiful (and NO CALORIES!) The guests were lively and interesting... and I found the cook ies that I love! (What more could I ask??) On the subject of calories... A dear friend I attend Grief Counseling with each week, gave me a terrific gift for Chanukah! Its a lovely book with great photos. Its title is The Book Of Schmaltz. Its labeled as a love song to a forgotten fat. The book is filled with fabulous recipes (many my mother cooked) and I am tempted to try them. My friend is RICHARD ANDERSON, and I guess I should cook something for him... but I wont (because I like him too much!) Back to music, my favor ite subject... Our own talented CAROL STEIN will be appearing at Blue Bamboo, 1905 Kentucky Avenue, Winter Park, on Jan. 5th 2018, along with a super star singer, JENNY EVENS. Carol and Jenny present: A Night of Moonlight Melodies. Jenny Evans is a Britishborn, naturalized German jazz singer. She was also known as owner of Jennys Place, a jazz club in Munichs Schwabing district. With a sultry, crystalline voice, impeccable diction and a sense of pitch-perfect intonation that would make Ella Fitzgerald proud, Jenny Evans is the leading female singer in Germany, according to Michael Walsh, in Time Magazine. Ben Friedman Carol Stein Jenny Evans One for the road... A man goes to a lawyer and asks, How much do you charge for legal advice? The lawyer replies, A thousand dollars for three questions. The man responds, Wow! Isnt that kind of expensive? Yes it is, says the lawyer. What is your third question? (Is that the definition of chutzpah or what?) The Rosen JCC celebrated the 100th birthday of Ethel Siegel, a dedicated and active member of the Jew ish community center. A ceremony honoring Ethel was held on Dec. 21 at the Rosen JCC. Ethel is a senior member of the Chai Steppers social group that meets at the Rosen JCC. Originally born in Brooklyn, N.Y. in 1917, Ethel married Matthew Siegel in 1941 and is the mother of two chil dren. The family resided for many years in Roslyn, N.Y. on Long Island before retiring to Florida. Ethel is an accomplished artist who has specialized in painting and sculpture. In 2009, Ethel was honored at Orlandos City Hall with a showing of her clay work and a story in the Jewish Heritage newspaper. Ethel has been an inte gral part of our senior adult community and a vivacious participant of many of the programs we have, said Jen nifer Jacobson, adult program coordinator at the Rosen JCC. Ethel Siegel at the Rosen JCCs Great Latke Cook-Off. Happy 100th birthday to Ethel Siegel

PAGE 10

PAGE 10A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 signed in July by the govern ment with the Jewish com munity, according to Slagerij Marcus lawyer, Herman Loonstein. The measure lim its the production of kosher meat to local consumption, a stipulation that Loonstein says amounts to an export ban that may render the business nonprofitable. Community representa tives say they reached an oral agreement with the government that will head off the export restrictions, but a government spokes man declined to confirm the claim. The spokesman told JTA only that special circumstances may be taken into account when it comes to export. Either way, The leash keeps getting tighter and tighter, and there are ques tions on what kind of future there is for the industry, said Luuk Koole, the longtime manager of Slagerij Marcus. Iris Jonah is among the hundreds of Dutch Jews who depend on the meat shop and deli; she says its her only dependable source for fresh kosher meat. Kosher ground beef is on offer at several Dutch supermarkets, but only at Marcus can she find steaks, veal and corned beef for her family of six. If they close shop, I dont know what Ill do, well be in a big problem, Jonah told JTA last month. Its already tough to lead an observant Jewish lifestyle here as it is without this added complication. Jews in the Netherlands could still import kosher meat from France even if Marcus closes. But the quality wont be the same, according to Nis sim Guedj, the France-born store manager at Slagerij Marcus meat shop. Theres no comparing the far superior quality you get here, he said of Dutch meat. A closure could also mean the end for one of Dutch Jewrys fabled delicacies, a fatty kind of corned beef known as pekelvlees that is produced commercially only at Slagerij Marcus and sold at the iconic Sal Meijer Jewish sandwich shop in Amsterdam. In Belgium, meanwhile, legislation was passed this year in two of the federal king doms three regionsinclud ing Antwerps Flemish region, with its predominantly haredi Orthodox Jewish community of 18,000that starting in 2019 bans all slaughter per formed without first stunning the animal. Jewish and Muslim reli gious laws require animals be conscious at the time of their slaughter, a custom that animal welfare activists call cruel and anti-Muslim activ ists say is barbaric. Rabbi Pinchas Kornfeld, a communal leader from Antwerp, told JTA on Mon day that his congregation is considering an appeal of the legislation in court. Unlike the Dutch community, Ant werps predominantly haredi community is so strict that French kashrut certification may not suffice for its leaders, placing the community and its congregants in a potential bind when the bans go into effect. The current wave of legisla tion in Belgium and the Neth erlands follows an earlier drive to ban ritual slaughter. In the latter, opposition led by the far-right Party for Freedom and animal welfare activists spurred a ban on kosher and halal practices in 2010, but it was overturned by the Dutch Senate in 2012. In 2013, the Polish parlia ment also banned the prac tices, though the prohibition has since been partially overturned. Slaughter without stun ning is now illegal in five European Union member statesSweden, Denmark, Finland, Lithuania and Slo veniaas well as three other non-EU countries in Western Europe: Norway, Switzerland and Iceland. EU members Aus tria and Estonia enforce strict supervision of the custom that some Jews there say make it nearly impossible. Attempts to promote such legislation in France, how ever, have failed. Back in Paris, Levy says his immediate concern is with the departure of Jews and not the introduction of laws against their food. Since 2014, at least 25,000 French Jews have immigrated to Israel alonea 260 percent increase from the 9,537 who left France for the Jewish state in the previous five years. Levys father also left, as did other family members. And although their depar ture has made only a small dent in Frances Jewish com munity overall, their absence has had a disproportional effect on Levys business, he said. Those who left are exactly Cnaan Liphshiz Nissim Guedj unpacking merchandise at a kosher meat shop in Amsterdam, Oct. 26, 2017. Why kosher butchers in Western Europe are preparing to close By Cnaan Liphshiz PARIS (JTA)When Jerry Levys family opened one of the first gourmet kosher meat shops in France, they had some of the countrys best-laid business plans. Hailing from a long line of Jewish butchers in their native Algeria, they had the exper tise and diligence in 1977 to cater to the changing needs of their growing community, where tens of thousands of Jewish immigrants from North Africa like them were developing both the appetite for qualityand the means to pay for it. Four decades on, the fam ilys gambit certainly has paid off: Levys meat shop and deli in this citys 17th district is a communal institution. With a kiss on the cheek, Levy and his teenage son, Maurice, welcome dozens of regulars daily to Boucherie Jerry Levy who swear by the signature foie gras, artisanal charcute rie and assortment of North African salads But like other producers of kosher meat in Western Eu rope, the Levys are no longer certain of the viability of their business. In recent years they have been suffering both from declining revenues due to emi gration from France by Jews fearful of jihadist violence and anti-Muslim measures targeting the ritual slaughter of animals. I want Maurice to learn a trade because with the meat industry, who knows what tomorrow will bring, Levy told JTA about his 17-year-old son. All kosher delis, they will be a thing of the past within one generation either because theyre made illegal, suffocated by anti-kosher regulations or defeated by supermarkets. Not all kosher meat produc ers in France, a country with 500,000 Jews, share Levys pessimism. But several of his counterparts in the Nether lands and Belgium do follow ing a fresh wave of restrictive regulations and legislation in those countries, where a total of 90,000 Jews live. In Holland, the viability of the countrys only kosher slaughterhouse, Slagerij Mar cus, and its meat shop are under threat from a new deal my clientele, Levy said at his meat shop. Across the street from his meat shops blue facade, two French soldiers toting ma chine guns stood guard as part of their deployment around Jewish shops and neighbor hoods in Paris following the 2015 slaying of four Jews at a kosher supermarket by an Islamist. As Levy sees it, the French Jews who are leaving are ob servant individuals with the means to forego the French states generous welfare, and who fear for their security fol lowing multiple anti-Semitic attacks since 2012 on Jewish schools, supermarkets and other institutions serving mainly affiliated community members. The assimilated Jew who eats pork and whose son at tends a public school, theyre not likely to leave, Levy said. Neither is the poor Jew in social housing. But neither is likely to come to my meat shop anyway. French immigration to Israel, which in 2015 peaked at approximately 8,000 new comers, has subsided, with less than half that number immigrating in the first 10 months of this year. But Levy said that growing initiatives in France targeting kosher meat and the Muslim variant, halal, are compounding his losses and threatening the viability of his businesses. The problem, he says, are campaigns headed by the Na tional Front party, which op poses what its leader, Marine Le Pen, describes as Islamist globalization. Le Pen won 34 percent of the national vote in the first round of the 2016 presidential elections. She ultimately lost to Emmanuel Macron, but it was her bestever showing. In recent years, opposition to halal and kosher meat has grown significantly amid awareness-raising efforts by National Front and animal welfare activists who believe that the Jewish and Mus lim custom of slaughtering animals without stunning are cruel. Since 2011, hundreds of butchers in France have ad opted a label declaring that their meat only comes from animals that were stunned. Reaching approximately 10 percent of all French meat shops, it was a stunning suc Butchers on page 15A Maitland 9001 N. Orlando Avenue Maitland, FL 32751 Jewish Graveside Package: Service of Funeral Director and Staff Sacred Burial Shroud Filing all Necessary Paperwork $200.00 to Chevra Kaddish Society donation for washing Traditional Jewish Flat Top Pine Casket Staff Supervison of Service at Graveside Transportation to Cemetery $4595.00 407-695-CARE (2273) www. DeGusipeFuneralHome.com Sanford 905 Laurel Avenue Sanford, FL 32771 West Orange 1400 Matthew Paris Blvd Ocoee, FL 34761 Call us to receive your free Final Wishes Organizer!

PAGE 11

HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 PAGE 11A HEALTHY EYES WEAR SUNGLASSESEvery day that youre outside, youre exposed to dangerous, but invisible, ultraviolet (UV) sunlight. Left unprotected, prolonged exposure to UV radiation can seriously damage the eye, leading to cataracts, skin cancer around the eyelid and other eye disorders. Protecting your eyes is important to maintaining eye health now and in the future. Shield your eyes (and your familys eyes) from harmful UV rays. Wear sunglasses with maximum UV protection. For more information, visit www.thevisioncouncil.org/consumers/sunglasses. A public service message from The Vision Council. Orlando Weekday Morning Minyan (Conservative/Egalitarian ), services MondayFriday 7:45 a.m. (9 a.m.national holidays); 2nd floor ChapelJewish Academy of Orlando; 851 N. Maitland Ave., Maitland. For information call 407-298-4650. Celebration Jewish Congregation (R) services and holiday schedules shown at www. JewishCelebration.org ; 407-566-9792. Chabad Lubavitch of North Orlando (O) 1701 Markham Woods Road, Longwood, 407-636-5994, www.jewishorlando.com; services: Friday 7:00 p.m.; Saturday at 9:30 a.m. Chabad of Altamonte Springs (O) 414 Spring Valley Lane, Altamonte Springs, 407280-0535; www.jewishaltamonte.com Chabad of South Orlando (O) 7347 Sand Lake Road, Orlando, 407-354-3660; www. jewishorlando.com ; Shabbat services: Monday-Friday, 8 a.m. and 10 minutes before sunset; Saturday, 9:30 a.m.; Sunday, 8:15 a.m. Chabad of the Space & Treasure Coasts (O) 1190 Highway A1A, Satellite Beach, 321-777-2770. Congregation Ahavas Yisrael/Chabad (O) 708 Lake Howell Rd., Maitland, 407-6442500; www.chabadorlando.org ; services: Sunday, 9 a.m.; Monday-Friday, 7:30 a.m.; Shabbat services: Friday, 6:30 p.m.; Saturday, 9:30 a.m.; Family service, 4th Friday of the month. Congregation Bet Chaim (R) 181 E. Mitchell Hammock, Oviedo, 407-830-7211; www. betchaim.org ; Shabbat services: Friday, 8 p.m. Congregation Beth Am (C) 3899 Sand Lake Road, Longwood, 407-862-3505; www. congbetham.org ; Shabbat services: Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, 9:30 a.m. Congregation Beth El (C) 2185 Meadowlane Ave., West Melbourne, 321-779-0740; Shabbat services, 1st & 3rd Friday, 8 p.m.; 2nd & 4th Saturdays, 9:30 a.m. Congregation Beth Emeth (R) 2205 Blue Sapphire Circle, Orlando, 407-222-6393; Shabbat service: monthly, 8 p.m. Congregation Beth Israel (Rec) Collins Resource Center, Suite 303, 9401 S.R. 200, Ocala, 352-237-8277; bethisraelocala.org; Shabbat service, second Friday of the month, 8 p.m. Congregation Beth Sholom (R-C) 315 North 13th St., Leesburg, 352-326-3692; www. bethsholomflorida.org ; schedule of services on website. Congregation Beth Shalom (Progressive Conservative) Orange City congregation holds services at 1308 E. Normandy Blvd., Deltona; 386-804-8283; www.mybethshalom. com ; Shabbat services: Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, 10 a.m. Congregation Bnai Torah (C) 403 N. Nova Rd., Ormond Beach, 32174, 386-672-1174; www.mybnaitorah.com ; Shabbat services: Friday, 8 p.m.; Saturday, 10 a.m. Congregation Chabad Lubavitch of Greater Daytona (O) 1079 W. Granada Blvd., Ormond Beach, 386-672-9300; Shabbat services Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, 10 a.m. Congregation of Reform Judaism (R) 928 Malone Dr., Orlando, 407-645-0444; www.crjorlando.org : Shabbat services, 7 p.m. 1st, 2nd and 3rd Fridays; 6 p.m., 4th and 5th Fridays; Saturday: 10 a.m. Congregation Mateh Chaim (R) P.O. Box 060847, Palm Bay, 32906, 321-768-6722. Congregation Ohev Shalom (C) 613 Concourse Parkway South, Maitland, 407-2984650; www.ohevshalom.org ; Shabbat service, Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, 9:30 a.m. Congregation Or Chayim (Rec) Leesburg, 352-326-8745; egrae@hotmail.com; services 2nd and 4th Fridays of each month at Providence Independence of Wildwood. Congregation Shalom Aleichem (R) 3501 Oak Pointe Blvd., Kissimmee, 407-9350064; www.shalomaleichem.com ; Shabbat service, 1st and 3rd Fridays of the month, 8 p.m. Congregation Shomer Ysrael (C) 5382 Hoffner Ave., Orlando, 407-227-1258, call for services and holiday schedules. Congregation Sinai (C/R) 303A N. S.R. 27, Minneola; 352-243-5353; congregationsinai.org; services: every Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Shabbat Service evert Saturday, 10 a.m. Orlando Torah Center (O) 8591 Banyan Blvd., Orlando; 347-456-6485; ShacharisShabbos 9 a.m.; Mon.Thurs. 6:45 a.m.; Sun. and Legal Holidays 8 a.m.; Mincha/Maariv Please call for times. Southwest Orlando Jewish Congregation/Ohalei Rivka (C) 11200 S. ApopkaVineland Rd., Orlando, 407-239-5444; Shabbat service, Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, 9:30 a.m. Temple Beth El (R) 579 N. Nova Rd., Ormond Beach, 386-677-2484. Temple Beth Shalom (R), P.O. Box 031233, Winter Haven, 813-324-2882. Temple Beth Shalom (C) 40 Wellington Drive, Palm Coast, 386-445-3006; Shabbat service, Friday, 8 p.m.; Saturday, 9 a.m. Temple Beth Sholom (C) 5995 N. Wickham Rd. Melbourne, 321-254-6333; www. mytbs.org ; Shabbat services: Friday, 7 p.m.; Saturday: 9:30 a.m. Minyan, Tuesday, 7:30 p.m.; Thursday, 10:00 a.m. Temple Beth Shalom (R) 1109 N.E. 8th Ave., Ocala, 352-629-3587; Shabbat services: Friday, 8 p.m.; Torah study: Saturday, 10:00 a.m. Temple Bnai Darom (R), 49 Banyan Course, Ocala, 352-624-0380; Friday Services 8 p.m. Temple Israel (C) 50 S. Moss Rd., Winter Springs, 407-647-3055; www.tiflorida.org ; Shabbat services: Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, 9:30 a.m.; Sunday 9:00 a.m. Temple Israel (R), 7350 Lake Andrew Drive, Melbourne, 321-631-9494. Temple Israel (C) 579 N. Nova Road, Ormond Beach, 386-252-3097; Shabbat service, Friday, 7 p.m.; Saturday: 10:30 a.m. Temple Israel of DeLand (R) 1001 E. New York Ave., DeLand, 386-736-1646; www. templeisraelofdeland.org; Friday Shabbat service, 7 p.m.; Saturday, 10:00 a.m. followed by Torah study. Temple Shalom (formerly New Jewish Congregation) (R) 13563 Country Road 101, Oxford, 352-748-1800; www.templeshalomcentralfl.org ; Shabbat services: Friday, 7 p.m.; last Saturday of the month, 9:30 a.m. Temple Shalom of Deltona (R/C) 1785 Elkcam Blvd., Deltona, 386-789-2202; www. shalomdeltona.org; Shabbat service; Saturday: 10 a.m. Temple Shir Shalom (R) Services held at Temple Israel, 50 S. Moss Rd., Winter Springs, 407-366-3556, www.templeshirshalom.org ; Shabbat services: three Fridays each month, 7:30 p.m. Traditional Congregation of Mount Dora (T) Mount Dora, 352-735-4774; www. tcomd.org; Shabbat services: Saturday, 9:30 a.m. sharp. (R) Reform (C) Conservative (O) Orthodox (Rec) Reconstructionist (T) Mehitsa Ellen Braunstein An exhibit at the Jewish baseball museum at Milts Extra Innings in Chicago. At left is deli worker Zahava Auerbach. Eig saying that in baseball, like Judaism, members of a tribe... pass along a collective sense of identitywhere we come from and who we are. Were telling the story of Jews in America through baseball, Aeder said. Extra Innings branches away from the barbecue fare next door by offering fresh meat sandwiches, prepared salads and side dishes. The deli, offering catering and takeout, is small, seating only 14 The deli fare ranges from soups to schnitzel to whitefish salad and sweet potato salad. The workers cure their own meats and sell them in vacuum-sealed pouches. A Shabbat menu offers traditional fare like cholent and chicken. Extra Innings was a re sponse to customers, general manager Stephen Kriesler said. Our customers appreci ated a kosher restaurant but wanted more than barbecue, he said. For almost four years we thought about what other foods we could do. Then the restaurant next door left and the space became available. Most of the deli workers at Extra Innings are associated with Keshet and its GADOL programGiving Adults Daily Opportunities for Liv ing. They have an intellectual disability but are high func tioning, Kriesler said. Overseen by a job coach, They can hold a job, learn tasks, be able to communicate with people, and help prepare and serve the food, he said. Deli worker Shmuel Eman uel, 24, describes his work as fun. I like making the sand wiches and working with my co-workers, he said. Debbie Harris, Keshets di rector of adult programming, said, We are excited to bring together people of all abilities to work side by side and create a new community. Most of all, we are grateful to Jeff for his incredible vision and are so pleased to be his partner in this new endeavor. Aeder views the deli as a partnership between the com munity and the restaurants. Hiring primarily special needs adults to work in the restaurant, weve given them an opportunity to live a fulfill ing life, he said. The neighboring koshercertified restaurants are not in an Orthodox Jewish neighborhood, so the clientele is diverse, Aeder said. We created something for all of us to be proud of. The success of it is dependent on the community viewing it as their own, he said. And I think that the patrons gain something from the experi ence of interacting with each other. Redevelopment around Wrigley Field includes a new five-story headquarters for the Cubs, a seven-story hotel, a new residential and retail complex, and an annex to the famed park that will include retail and restaurant space. It doesnt hurt that the Cubs won the World Series in 2016ending a historic 107-season droughtand made it to the National League Championship Series this year. Im a huge Cubs fan, Aeder said, and being able to throw that into the equation was great. In the shadow of Wrigley Chicagos newest kosher deli By Ellen Braunstein CHICAGO (JTA)Baseball gloves and caricatures of famous ballplayers adorn the walls of Milts Extra Innings no surprise for a deli thats a short drive from Wrigley Field, the fabled home of the Chicago Cubs. But look closely and the picture becomes a little more unexpected: The memorabilia on the walls celebrate Jewish greats and not-so-greats like Sandy Koufax, Philadelphia Athletics first baseman Lou Limmer, and the catcher and sometimes spy Moe Berg. And there among the collection of bobbleheads, right next to former catcher Brad Ausmus, is Mosesthat Mosesgrip ping a set of tablets. The latest addition to the redevelopment of the neigh borhoods around Wrigley is a kosher deli that is a celebra tion of Jews and Americas pastimeas well as a place where Jewish adults with intellectual disabilities can find meaningful work ex perience. Restaurateur and real es tate investor Jeff Aeder recent ly opened Milts Extra Innings next door to his kosher Milts Barbecue for the Perplexed, which for five years has do nated all profits to Jewish causes. Milts Extra Innings will follow suit, donating all profits to Keshet, a Jewish agency serving children and adults with intellectual chal lenges in the Chicago area. The owner of a 5,000-piece collection of Jewish base ball memorabilia, Aeder is showcasing a small fraction of artifacts that celebrate 170 Jews who have played in the major leagues. A mural timeline on a wall tracks the history of Jews in the sport from 1860 until today. Among the framed collectibles near the deli counter are a jersey worn by Koufax from 1963, his best year, Detroit slugger Hank Greenbergs game-used bat and a mitt used by Berg. Baseball is a great meta phor for the Jewish experi ence in America, Aeder said of his niche Jewish Baseball Museum, where his entire col lection lives, for the moment, online. The website includes a quote from author Jonathan

PAGE 12

PAGE 12A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 Protesters of the New School panel on anti-Semitism demonstrate outside the event. eliciting loud applause from the crowd. Panelist Lina Morales, a member of the Jews of Color and Mizrahi/Sephardi Caucus of JFREJ, called Zionism a mistake that has led us down a dangerous and hor rible road, while Rebecca Vilkomerson, executive di rector of the pro-BDS Jewish Voice for Peace, described the Israeli treatment of Palestin ians as apartheid. Sarsour said she was con fused as to why some in the Jewish community saw her as an existential threat. But she appeared to take a slightly more moderate stance after making two remarks earlier this year that had drawn the ire of many in the Jewish community. Asked by an audience mem ber about an interview in which she seemed to have said Zionism and feminism were mutually exclusive, Sarsour said there was room for those with different opinions in the feminist movement. If you believe that you have to be part of a movement where you show up and agree with everybody, then this definitely aint the movement for you, because I dont agree with half the people in the movement either, she said. Sarsour, however, also chastised pro-Israel activists who have demanded that progressives welcome them uncritically into their coali tions. If you are going to come to the movement with the condition, with the imposi tion that people need to know that you are a Zionist and a feminist and only under this idea, [and] that we have to accept you as a Zionist and a feminist because you want to impose that on everybody else in the movement, Im just letting you know thats just not how it works in the movement. No one else does that, she said. Sarsour also clarified a comment in which she said anti-Semitism, unlike dis crimination against AfricanAmericans and Islamophobia, is not systemic. She said she had meant that anti-Semitism is not encoded in the U.S. legal and criminal justice system today, unlike discrimination against other groups. All the panelists spoke of the dangers of anti-Semitism and said they were commit ted to fighting it, but they focused on its manifestation on the right. Some in the audience believed that emphasis was unfair. There was a lot of focus on white supremacism and Trump, which is totally valid, but I was hoping for a little bit more introspection and critique of some people in their own circles that are antiSemitic, said Uri Westrich, a 32-year-old filmmaker. Asher Lovy, a 25-year-old working in online sales, said the panel had failed to address the types of anti-Semitism he had experienced on the left. Id also like to see ideo logical purity tests on the left addressed as well, the idea that if youre Jewish you have to affirmatively prove your anti-Zionist bona fides before youre let into any leftist space regardless of the causes, he said. Meanwhile, Andrew Weitzner said Sarsour had adequately expressed con cerns from critics, including the comment about antiSemitism. It was the protest ers outside, said the 33-year old paralegal, who were not participating in constructive dialogue. Theyre screaming Am Yisrael Chai outside and sing ing Hatikvahhow is that a level of debate? he asked, not ing the words for the people of Israel live and the Israeli national anthem, respectively. How is that an argument on both sides? One of the demonstrators said he was there to protest Sarsours views, which he saw as anti-Semitic, anti-Israel, anti-America. She knows how to get the crowd going on her side, but shes not promoting peace and unity at all and coexistences between the Israelis and the so-called Palestinians, or Jews and Muslims, or even fellow Americans, said Ariel Kohane, 46, a kosher food supervisor sporting a kippah with a picture of President Donald Trump. Shes actually brainwashing these college kids. Inside the auditorium, au dience members cheered and clapped many times through out the speeches. Despite the enthusiasm in the room, many audience members did not want to be interviewed or would not agree to use their full names. When asked why, one man simply pointed to his shirt, which featured the name of an Orthodox rabbinical school. Its too risky, he said. Linda Sarsour gets warm welcome at controversial panel on anti-Semitism By Josefin Dolsten NEW YORK (JTA)Au dience members greeted Palestinian-American activ ist Linda Sarsour with loud applause at an event here that in recent weeks became a rallying cry for both critics and defenders of Israel. Sarsour, a leading feminist as well as pro-Palestinian advocate, was the best-known speaker on a panel on antiSemitism held Tuesday at the New School for Social Research. Billed as a discus sion of anti-Semitism on the right and left, the panel was denounced by pro-Israel critics who have accused Sarsour and other panelists of anti-Semitism and charged that the event was meant to obscure the anti-Semitism they see lurking among farleft critics of Israel. A crowd of 400 attended the panel, whose organizers included the New Schools journalism program, Jewish Voice for Peace, Haymarket Books, Jacobin Magazine and Jews for Racial & Economic Justice, or JFREJ. Outside the auditorium in Lower Manhattan, 50 protesters gathered behind metal barricades waving Israeli flags. Among them were members of the far-right Jewish Defense League, once deemed a terrorist organiza tion by the FBI. Larger Jewish groups also weighed in as the event neared. These panelists know the issue, but unfortunately, from the perspective of fomenting it rather than fighting it, the Anti-Defamation Leagues national director, Jonathan Greenblatt, wrote earlier this month. The Zionist Organization of America called Sarsour an Israel-bashing, Jew-hater in a statement denouncing the event. Sarsour, who helped or ganize the Womens March on Washington in January, has harshly criticized Israel, once tweeting that Nothing is creepier than Zionism. That led various Jewish groups on the center and right to label her anti-Semitic, and worry that she represents the mainstreaming of anti-Israel rhetoric on the left. Tuesdays panelists of fered plenty of attacks on Israel while insisting that such views are being labeled anti-Semitic in order to si lence criticism of the country and its policies. Just in case its not clear, I am unapologetically Palestin ian American and will always be unapologetically Palestin ian American and always be unapologetically Muslim American. And guess what, Im also a very staunch sup porter of the Boycott, Divest ment and Sanctions move ment, Sarsour proclaimed, Josefin Dolsten Rose Holm at her apartment holding a photo of her late husband, Joe, Oct. 31, 2017. By Josefin Dolsten NEW YORK (JTA)Nazis came for Rose Holms fam ily in the afternoon. By the evening, the 16-year-old was lying among corpses in the underground bunker where she and her family had been hiding. I was between those dead ones, and I didnt know if Im alive or Im dead, Holm, now 92, recalled. Among those shot and killed were Holms parents, brother and one of her sisters, as well as some 85 other Jews hiding in the bunker outside Parczew, a town in the eastern part of Poland. Only one fam ily member other than Holm survived: a sister who had left the bunker with her husband and young daughter before the Nazis came. That unimaginable inci dent would go on to motivate Holm to fight back against the Nazis. A few months later, she met a childhood friend who recruited her to join a group of Jewish partisans. Members of the fighting unit, which was under the command of Chiel Grynszpan, lived in the forest by day and fought the Nazis at night. I was thinking I have to take revenge, whatevers go ing to be, I dont care, Holm told JTA last month at her Upper East Side apartment. I never [used to] think Im going to be alive, and thats the way I survived with the partisans. Today, Holm is elegantly dressed and soft-spoken. She wears a pearl necklace and offers home-baked cookies. As a partisan, it was a whole different story, she said. I was like a wild one, she said. I didnt know what I was doing. Whatever Id been told, thats what I was doing. Holm is among a shrinking group of living partisans. Each year there are fewer Jewish partisans who are able to share their experiences, Sheri Pearl Rosenblum, direc tor of development and out reach for the Jewish Partisan Educational Foundation, told JTA in an email. On its website, the group features the testimonies of Jewish partisans, including Holm and her late husband, Joe. It collected testimonies from 51 Jewish partisans from 2002 to 2015; only 16 are still alive. Holm was one of just five women in her unit, which started with 25 people but grew to around 250 by the end of World War II. Partisan fighter units were reluctant to have women and children as members, but the friend who recruited herher future husbandtold the other fighters that the two were a package deal. As part of the unit, Holm and the other women car ried supplies and helped detonate hand grenades. The group focused on destroying bridges and roads that Nazis were using. A train used to come, so we used to throw the hand grenades, she recounted. The hand grenades were very scary because if you pulled the ring [incorrectly], it could kill you. Partisans would sleep in the forest with little to no protection from the elements The first winter was a very, very bad winter. We used to sleep in the woods under the snow, Holm said. They would make do with whatever food they got from non-Jewish Poles, who had been threatened that they would be killed if they did not aid the fighters. For survival you do every thing, you dont think youre a human being, she said. Sometimes the partisans would get a pig to grill in the forest. The first time was very hard, but when youre hun gry you dont ask questions, Holm, whose religious family had observed Jewish dietary laws, said of eating pork. Many times she came close to dying. In one incident, Holm entered the house of a non-Jewish Pole to get food and supplies. A German sol dier discovered her and she ran, holding on to a sweater the Pole had given her. Later she found bullet holes dotting the side of the sweater, where the soldier had shot at her and narrowly missed. During her time as a parti san, Holm didnt think about life after the war. I didnt think I was going to be alive, she said. She became close with the friend who recruited her, and the two went on to marry shortly after the war surrounded by the friends they made as partisans. In 1945, the couple moved to a displaced persons camp in Germany before leaving for New York in 1949, where she found a job in a dressmaking factory and he in a cardboard box factory. Joe Holm later opened his own butcher shop before the couple founded a factory producing womens sweaters about 10 years after moving to the United States. They had two children. Joe died in 2009. Today, After Nazis killed her family, this woman joined the partisans to fight back Holm lives in their home surrounded by photos of her husband, children, four grandchildren and three great-grandchildren. Holm once would not speak about their wartime experiences; talking about them makes her sad. In 2013, however, she told her story in a video for the Jewish Partisan Educational Foundation. The group also honored Holm and her husband at galas in 2010 and 2011. Earlier this year her son, Steven, emceed an event by the foundation honoring surviving partisans and their descendants. Theres also another emo tion that comes with telling her story: incredulousness that she went through what she did and survived. My whole life, Im just laying sometimes in bed and thinking is this true? she said. I was thinking that I was reading [the story in] a book, that its not from my life.

PAGE 13

HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 PAGE 13A Weekly roundup of world briefs from JTA Mother, 3 children killed in Hanukkah house fire flown to Israel for burial NEW YORK (JTA)The bodies of a woman and her three children killed in a house fire were flown to Israel after a crowd of mourners proved too large and distraught for a memorial ceremony to be held in Brooklyn. The New York Post reported Tuesday that hundreds of bereaved members of the Or thodox community gathered outside Congregation Sheves Achim in East Flatbush on Monday evening to mourn Aliza Azan, 39, and her chil dren. Unable to enter the syna gogue, the Post reported, the hearses then headed straight to JFK airport where a flight was preparing to fly them to Israel. City fire and police officials confirmed that a Hanukkah menorah on the first floor of the 2 1/2-story house sparked the blaze at around 2:20 am. Monday. The victims included Azans sons Moshe, 11, and Yitzah, 7, and daughter Hen rietta, 3. The father, Yosi, three chil dren and their cousin survived the fire, but were injured in the fast-moving blaze, Fire Commissioner Daniel Nigro said at a news conference. Yosi Azan and his daughter Shalit, 16, and son Daniel, 15were in critical condition at Staten Island University Hospital. Two younger boys were treated for minor injuries. Fire Department officials said the house had a working smoke detector, which may have alerted the boys on the first floor to the fire. Hundreds of mourners at tended a funeral in Brooklyn for the mother and her 3 children killed in a house fire this morning https://t. co/9R9odme8gX pic.twitter. com/H7Nf501ydE amNewYork (@am NewYork) December 19, 2017 Trump thanks Israeli mayor for naming new park after him JERUSALEM (JTA)Presi dent Donald Trump thanked the mayor of an Israeli city who named a new park after him. In a letter dated Dec. 13, Trump expressed gratitude for the gesture and satisfaction that Israelis welcomed his recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of their country which apparently earned him the honor. A week earlier, David Even Tzur, the mayor of the Haifa suburb Kiryat Yam, in north ern Israel, said he would es tablish Donald Trump Park in appreciation of the presidents Jerusalem announcement the day before. Thank you for this great honor, Trump wrote in his letter. It was a distinct pleasure to visit Israel during my first international trip as President of the United States... I am thankful for your gesture and am moved to know that the people of Israel are encouraged by my decision to recognize Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. Trump also called Israel one of our most steadfast allies and an oasis of hope, democracy, and prosperity in the Middle East. Tzur said Trump took a brave and unprecedented step that none of his prede cessors were willing to take and we must honor him for it. Jerusalem is a dream that is present in every Jews heart, the mayor said, and Trumps decision gives this dream clear international recognition. Tzur added that he is looking into the possibility of inviting Trump to the opening of the facility, which is slated for April. U.S. recognition of Je rusalem was welcomed in Israel and much of the Jewish community but rejected by much of the world. Palestin ians have rioted against the decision, leading to numer ous deaths and injuries, and throwing Trumps Middle East peace initiative into question. Obama undermined probe of Hezbollah drug empire in pursuit of Iran nuclear deal, ex-US officials allege WASHINGTON (JTA) Several Obama adminis tration-era security offi cials are claiming that the administration frustrated their pursuit of Hezbollahs drug-dealing empire in part to avoid jeopardizing the Iran nuclear deal. Politico quoted on the record three officials who ran Operation Cassandra, a task force principally run by the Drug Enforcement Agency, as saying their ef forts to bring down the Leb anon-based terror groups drug-running network was derailed in part out of the administrations desire for a negotiated settlement to curb the nuclear ambitions of Iran, a benefactor of He zbollah. This was a policy decision, it was a systematic decision, David Asher, who was a Pen tagon illicit finance analyst and is now an adviser to the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, told Politico. They serially ripped apart this entire effort that was very well supported and resourced, and it was done from the top down. The Hezbollah network, the officials said, was par ticularly expansive in Latin America, and financed Hez bollahs arms purchases and terror operations. The officials told Politico that the Justice Department refused to investigate and prosecute a Hezbollah figure considered the linchpin of Hezbollahs criminal net work, among other figures, and that the administration rejected repeated efforts by the investigators to charge Hezbollahs military wing under a federal Mafia-style racketeering statute. Obama administration of ficials quoted in the article denied that the Iran deal drove the obstructions faced by the former Cassandra offi cials, saying that interagency spats and broader concerns about U.S. interests caused the problems. An unnamed former Obama administration, Po litico wrote, offered several reasons for letting Hezbollah off the hook, including the fear of reprisals by Hezbollah against the United States and Israel, and the need to maintain peace and stabil ity in the Middle East. At least one of the incidents, a derailed anti-drug mission in Colombia, predated the Obama administration. The assessments by the three officials are based on their recall of interactions with other unnamed officials during Obamas two terms and their impressions. The officials are Jack Kelly, the DEA supervisory agent who led the Cassandra task force and is now retired; Derek Maltz, who headed DEAs Special Operations Division until 2014 and now directs a security consul tancy; and Asher. They will believe until death that we were shut down because of the Iran deal, Maltz said of his colleagues. My gut feeling? My instinct as a guy doing this for 28 years is that it certainly contributed to why we got pushed aside and picked apart. There is no doubt in my mind. There were a number of arrests and prosecutions during the period the article covers, but the agents said their requests for broader racketeering prosecutions which would have allowed them to piece together disparate alleged crimes into a conspiracywere consistently turned down and that diplomatic support was lacking. The former Cassandra officials cited among oth ers the case of Ali Fayad, a Ukraine-based arms mer chant detained in 2014 by Czech authorities. Czech authorities released Fayad in 2016, reportedly under pres sure from Russia, and he was allowed to return to Lebanon. Fayad was indicted in the United States for plotting the murders of U.S. officials, pro viding support to a terrorist organization and attempting to smuggle anti-aircraft mis siles. The Obama administra tion protested the release after the fact, but the agents said it did little to pressure to the Czechs to extradite him to the United States. The Iran nuclear deal traded sanctions relief for Irans rollback of its nuclear program. Israels govern ment and a number of proIsrael groupsamong them the Foundation for Defense of Democraciesvehemently criticized the deal. Hezbollah, which launched a war with Israel in 2006, is a U.S.-designated terrorist group with deep ties inside Lebanons government. It is allied with Iran and has joined that country in prop ping up the Assad regime in Syria during the civil war that has raged there since 2011. Critics of Obama and the nuclear deal seized on the Politico report. Morton Klein, president of the Zionist Organization of America, sent a news release with a summary of the article. Instead of drawing the conclusion that Iran was up to its neck in terrorism and drug-trafficking, President Obama ploughed forward de spite to empower Iran via the nuclear agreement he foisted on America, Klein said. It is an extraordinary dereliction of duty for a president. Donald Trump Jr., the presidents son, forwarded the article with a tweet read ing, The secret backstory of how Obama let Hezbollah off the hook. The real collusion story no one will cover. Nazi hunters recom mend nine for pros ecution in Germany, Austria BERLIN (JTA)Germa nys Central Office for In vestigation of Nazi Crimes has handed nine potential new cases against former concentration camp guards to prosecutors in Germany and Austria. If tried, the nine men and womenwho variously live in both countrieswould be charged as accessories to murder in several camps. The cases, already investi gated by the Central Office in Ludwigsburg, were handed to local prosecutors for poten tial indictment, according to news reports in the Berlinbased daily Taz newspaper and elsewhere. Jean Rommel, who heads the Central Office in Lud wigsburg, Germany, con firmed to the German news media that the nine men and women, most of them in their 90s, were stationed at the Ravensbrueck and Buchen wald concentration camps in Germany, at Mauthausen in Austria, and at the Auschwitz death camp in Nazi-occupied Poland. The 2011 conviction in Mu nich of former concentration camp guard John Demjanjuk as an accomplice in the mur ders of nearly 30,000 Jews in the Sobibor death camp in Poland set a precedent in that being a guard at a death camp was sufficient to prove complicity in murder. Since then, the Simon Wiesenthal Centers chief Nazi hunter, Efraim Zuroff, has encouraged the public to provide tips on possible perpetrators, an effort titled Operation Last Chance. In related news, an 88-year-old Holocaust sur vivor in Minnesota recently provided testimony that led to the indictments in Ger many of two former guards at the Stutthof concentra tion camp in Nazi-occupied Poland as accomplices to murder. It remains to be seen whether they will be deemed fit to stand trial. If so, then Judith Meisel is ready to bear witness against them, she told the NEWSER online publication in November. Sinking Sea of Galilee to get infusion of de salinated water JERUSALEM (JTA)Is rael is preparing to pump desalinated water into the Sea of Galilee. The states Water Author ity recently started work on the $300 million project, which will take about two years to complete, Israels Hadashot TV news reported Monday. With Israel apparently ap proaching a fifth consecutive dry year, the Sea of Galilee has dropped to danger ously low levels. This has increased the lakes salinity and harmed the quality of the water, which constitutes a quarter of Israels potable supply. The Water Authority is also overseeing projects to pump out saltwater from the lake in order to maintain its potability. The authority says it is extracting about 17,000 tons of salt each year. In October, the Water Au thority warned that the Sea of Galilee was at a danger ously low Omri Casspi lights me norah on Golden State Warriors court (JTA)Omri Casspi, the first Israeli to play in the NBA, helped lead the Golden State Warriors to their eighth straight win, then celebrated by lighting a giant Hanukkah menorah as part of the teams Jewish Heritage Night. Casspi scored 17 points and had 11 rebounds in the Warriors victory over the Dallas Mavericks on Thursday, the third night of Hanukkah, J. The Jewish News of Northern California reported. It was among the top performances of his nineyear NBA career. After the game, Casspi helped light a menorah al most as tall as the 6-foot-9 forward. He chanted the Ha nukkah prayers with Rabbi Yosef Langer, executive di rector of Chabad of San Fran cisco, as hundreds of Jewish fanssome attending their first Warriors gamelooked on at Oracle Arena. Casspi told the newspaper that lighting the menorah on the Warriors court was a privilege, it just means the world to me. Danny Grossman, CEO of the San Francisco-based Jewish Community Federa tion, was at the game along with other community and spiritual leaders, and said it was appropriate that Casspi had his best night since join ing the Warriors in July on a one-year deal. It cant be coincidental, it had to be a Hanukkah miracle, Grossman told J. The crowd attending the menorah lighting ranged from those wearing yar mulkes and black hats to bare-headed Jews in War riors garb, according to the newspaper. Casspi, 29, has played for six NBA teams, including five seasons in two stints with the Sacramento Kings. He was signed in March as a free agent by the Minne sota Timberwolves nearly a month after being waived by the New Orleans Pelicans his second stint with the teamafter breaking his thumb in his debut with the club. He has also played for the Cleveland Cavaliers and Houston Rockets. He was a member of the championship Maccabi Tel Aviv team in Israel before making himself available for the NBA Draft. Canada synagogues get hate mail saying Jewry must perish MONTREAL (JTA)At least three synagogues in Canada received hate mail warning that Jewry must perish. Police are investigating the envelopes delivered Mon day to two synagogues in Montreal and one in Toronto. Each featured a drawing of a bleeding Star of David enclos ing a Nazi swastika with the slogan Jewry must perish. Bnai Brith Canada de scribed the threats as being an eight on the frighten scale. Sadly, weve seen the swastika make something of a comeback this year, said Michael Mostyn, CEO of Bnai Brith Canada. Last month, Statistics Canada reported 221 hate crimes against Jews in Can ada in 2016, up from 178 the previous year. In response, Bnai Brith is calling on Canadians to stand in solidarity with Montreals #Jewish community. Hanukkah menorahs lit at sites of terrorist attacks (JTA)Young Jews in sev eral countries lit Hanukkah menorahs at sites targeted by terrorist attacks to signal their solidarity with victims and celebrate resilience. The ceremonies, organized by members of the World Bnei Akiva youth movement, included one lighting at the HaCarmel kosher restaurant in Amsterdam, where earlier this month a 29-year-old Palestinian smashed the es tablishments windows while holding a Palestinian flag. The assault happened one day after President Donald Trump announced that the United States considers Je rusalem Israels capital. Im here to light a candle for the security and safety of the Jewish community of Amsterdam, Avichai Meyer, the movements emissary to the Netherlands, said at the event earlier this week. David Rogovoy, the em issary to Germany, lit his menorah outside the Christ mas market where a truck deliberately drove into a crowd last year on Dec. 19, killing 12 and injuring 56. One of the casualties was an Israeli woman named Dalia Elyakim. Rogovoy said he was light ing the candles In honor of those who are not with us, and those people who were wounded and injured in ter ror attacks all over the world. The activists filmed the lightings and posted them on the World Bnei Akiva Facebook page under the hashtag #LightUpTheDar kness. Thousands have watched the videos. In Israel, Bnei Akiva mem bers filmed a menorah light ing outside Jerusalems Central Bus Station, where a security guard, Asher Al mialach, was severely injured in a stabbing incident this month. In England, Benaya Cohen lit candles at the entrance to the Manchester Arena, where in May a suicide bomber mur dered 23 people and injured over 500 at a concert in one of the countrys bloodiest terrorist attacks ever. Meanwhile, in the United States, Bnei Akiva members filmed a candle lighting at the Houston home of a member, Maya Wadler, whose home was ravaged by flooding during Hurricane Harvey. We hope and daven [pray] that this year will bring us pleasant weather and rains of blessing, Wadler said. Bnei Akiva is the largest Zionist youth movement in the world, with tens of thou sands of members in dozens of countries.

PAGE 14

PAGE 14A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 S1I2L3K4 E5W6R7 A8Z9A10R11I12A13A14L O E N15O A C16O R O N A G17A L G A18D O T H19O T A I R A20N A D21U E T S22 M23O N G O L24A R R Y E L25L I S O N A26S27P28I R E P29I E S C30L U E O31L32S E N S33H34O35H36A R V E37Y38W E I N S T39E I N E40Y E V41A N E S O42G L E R43I C S U44S45U A L S J46A47R48E D K U S49H50N E R E51R A S E P52A S S E L53E54S55S56E L E N A57 B58E N P L59A T T U60N L A C E O61R A A62N T I S63T Y L E S T64S P Y65E A R Light From page 1A show that hate really will not win and that this is something the people want to hear. Her hard work and deter mination paid off. More than 600 people filled the Oviedo auditorium and heard two Holocaust survivors, Genia Kutner and Gerald Biegel, speak about their experiences. Rayna Rose Exelbierd, Southeast high school coordi nator with StandWithUs and a third generation survivor who also spoke, told the Heritage that the majority of those who attended the event are not Jewish. She asked for a raise of hands of those who had never heard a Holocaust survivor speak and 90 percent raised their hands. Exelbierd is a motivational speaker for teenagers and mentor to teens who want to organize a program like this one. She has helped or ganize 105 programs in the Southeast, reaching more than 8,000 people who may never have heard a Holocaust survivors story. The Oviedo audience was silent as Biegel shared about his ordeal in five concentra tion camps. Then, Kutner provided details about who Hitler and the Nazis were, and what a swastika really stands for before sharing her own harrowing story. Kutner concluded that we must accept each other and what hatred leads to. Also speaking to the group that evening was Daniel Naba tian, director of JSU Orlando. This was more than I could have dreamed of, he told the Heritage. So many lives were impacted for the better. It was a powerful event. The program was enlighten ing to many people, not just Jewish students who had expe rienced anti-Semitism. After hearing Exelbierd share that her grandparents, who were survivors, fought for the rights of black people after seeing segregation in the South when they came to the States, sever al African-American students said they didnt know that Jews helped blacks during the civil rights era. The response was so amaz ing, Exelbierd said. The message was for everyone. At the conclusion of the program, students lined up to have photos taken with the Holocaust survivors, and shared their own stories of being bullied. One year fighting for this night all to spread the word to stop the hate, Kuperberg shared in her Facebook post. I cannot describe how thank ful I am for all the people who fought with meGabi Gittleson, Rayna Rose Exel bierd, Daniel Nabatian, Nicole Feldman Kuperberg, Justin Kuperberg, and so many more. I am also so thankful for all of you who supported me, even when I was losing the battles. You guys showed me that in the end hate will lose and love will win. This is what JSU is here forto education others, be there for them, stated Nabatian. To learn more about JSU or to request having the club open at a high school, visit www.jsu.org or contact Dan iel Nabatian at dnabatian@ joinorlando.org. But Immanuel is the only hospice in Europe for guests like Goudeketting who keep kosher, although there are other hospitals with palliative programs that offer kosher food. They include the North London Hospice Group, which defines itself as Britains first multifaith hospice. Its also the only hospice where the staff and volunteers already know the special is sues connected to caring for the generation of Holocaust survivors, said Sasja Martel, the institutions founding di rector. Thats crucial, she said, because at the last stage of life, its often too late to start explaining what those special issues are. A case in point: At Im manuel, the staff encourages guests to resist the urge to finish their plates, Martel said, and only eat when they are hungry. Traumatized by the Ho locaust, survivors and their children tend to associate eating with staying alive, she explained. And thats true, but at the terminal stage eat ing can hasten death. Rabbinical or other spiri tual counseling is available to guests, as is counseling on accepting death, mostly by volunteers. Thats an issue for many survivors who are conditioned to fight death at all costs, Martel said. The hospice, which has an annual budget of approxi mately $500,000, is subtly adorned with Jewish symbols ranging from mezuzahs, me norahs and, atop one piece of furniture in the main hall, a small pile of stones of the kind that Jews place on cemetery headstones. But even though they are understated, the symbols can have a profound effect on some guests. The significance of little things is amplified near the end, Martel said. Many guests feel a need to touch their identity, reconnect with it, even if only through the symbols. Or the typical Ash kenazi Jewish chicken soup we serve, that they remember from their grandmother, or the white tablecloth on Shab bat and the candle lighting. Or just a Jewish joke. The importance of a Jewish setting increases for many people facing end-of-life ques tions, according to Jewish health care professionals. Jewish teachings and values can provide comfort to them, according to a 2013 study by four American research ers, including a rabbi and a physician. Jewish liturgy, traditions and even a common language also ease some difficulties, according to a 2009 interview that Rabbi Sara Gilbert, a chaplain at Shalom Cares Hospice in Aurora, Colorado, gave the Intermountain Jew ish News. At Immanuel, staff are trained to accommodate the special needs of survivors like Goudeketting, who have no family, added Martel. We need to be conscious that for many of our guests we are all that they have, which is not necessarily the case in other hospices, she said. There are other sensitiv ity issues. For example, the hospice decided not to hire a nurse who had a German accent, Martel said last week at a symposium on hospice care in Judaism in honor of Immanuels 10th anniversary. If it was discrimination, it was a positive one for our guests, she said. One former patient, Bram Koopmans, said in a filmed interview before his death in 2010 that the hospice was his first contact with a Jewish community institution since staying at an orphanage for child Holocaust survivors in the 1940s. On his deathbed, Koopmans said that after decades of avoiding his Jewish identity, staying at Immanuel made him remember the Jewish blessing over bread, or hamotzi, which he was taught at the orphanage. Holding back tears, Koopmans recited the blessing during the interview while holding one hand over his head. Its been waiting in me for years and years, he said. Its as though I never left. Koopmans asked volun teers at Immanuel to go to his home and fetch a kippah and menorah that he had hidden away, Martel recalled. He also asked a rabbi to give him a bar mitzvah at the hospice. Koopmans had a Jewish burial, which he didnt plan to do when he first arrived at Immanuel. Only about half of the hospices guests are Jewish, however. Anyone diagnosed as being terminally ill can ask to be referred here. And though capacity is limited because of Immanuels small size, the high turnoverthe average stay is 11 daysmeans fre quent openings. When we set up this home, we decided as a matter of policy that it wouldnt be a place for Jews only, Martel said. We didnt want to send anyone away. Subsequently, Immanuel has a second non-kosher kitchen so as not to limit the nutrition of non-Jews. But one thing not on offer at Immanuel is assisted suicide, which is readily available in the Netherlands for the ter minally ill. The countrys parliament is now debating a controversial draft bill that would allow even healthy people to receive assisted suicide. But ending ones life is diametrically op posed to the Jewish values that sanctify life, said Martel, who added that Immanuel advises patients not to give up their homes in case they wish to end their life after being admitted to the institution. Anne van de Geest is a nonJewish guest in her 90s who is unable to walk because of cancer that has metastasized throughout her body. I like the atmosphere here, which is quiet but lively, she said. Van de Geest, who used to make jewelry and fashion accessories, said she chose to stay at Immanuel after hearing good things about it from friends. Word of mouth was also how Chazia Mourali, a wellknown television host and writer in the Netherlands, heard of Immanuel, where her mother, Elise van den Brink, stayed before her death in 2015. Were Catholic and people at church told us the Jewish hospice was the best choice, Mourali, whose father was born in Tunisia, told JTA at the symposium. We liked the sound of that and she felt right at home. People with our Middle Eastern mentalitya Calvin ist Dutch hospice is the last thing we needed. Cnaan Liphshiz Henny Goudeketing, left, and Anne van de Geest at the main hall of the Immanuel Jewish hospice in Amsterdam, Nov. 1, 2017. Europes only Jewish hospice gives Holocaust survivors a dignified farewell By Cnaan Liphshiz AMSTERDAM (JTA)Hen ny Goudeketting, a 95-yearold Holocaust survivor, is ailing and preparing to leave the world. Goudeketting, who was sterilized in Nazi medical experiments at Auschwitz, has neither children nor other relatives to care for her. Now, after multiple infections and recurrent falls, shes readying to say goodbye. Its kind of strange, Goudeketting told JTA. I know I have no future and Im ready to die, but Im still afraid of actually dying. The Amsterdam native re turned to the city at 23 after surviving Auschwitz. My biggest sorrow is not being able to have children, said Goudeketting, who had worked for decades as a seamstress. Last month she was admit ted to Immanuel, a small but upscale eight-room facility for the terminally ill. It is Europes only Jewish hos pice, according to Tel Aviv Universitys Kantor Center for the Study of Contemporary European Jewry. While such facilities are common in the U.S.the National Institute for Jew ish Hospice, which was es tablished in 1985 in New York, lists no fewer than 225 accredited Jewish hospice programsthey remain rare on the continent, where the Jewish community was deci mated by the Holocaust. Funded through private donations, as well as patient fees and some subsidies, the hospice was built by the Dutch Jewish community for survivors like Goudeketting to receive top end-of-life care. Im not sure whether this is real, the luxurious treat ment Im getting here, she said. Ive never experienced anything like this in my whole life. Take the on-demand room service. If I want a fried egg, or anything else, all I have to do is buzz, said Goudeketting, whose stay at Immanuel is covered by her insurance. They come round in seconds to terribly spoil me. The Netherlands, which last year was No. 1 on Europes index of public health systems, has 146 hospices nationwide with an average guest satis faction rating of 9.1 out of 10. And whereas Immanuels on-demand room service is a standout amenity, patients at other hospices receive similar conditionsall for a daily rate of less than $70 covered by the government or basic insurance policies.

PAGE 15

HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 PAGE 15A Butchers From page 10A cess of a campaign launched that year by the Vigilance Halal association founded by an anti-halal veterinarian and promoted by National Front. This has lowered the de mand for meat left over from animals that were used for ritual slaughter, Levy said, explaining that kosher rules allow Jews t0 use only 15-20 percent of the cow. Once a shochet, or certified slaughterer, has taken the ko sher bits, the slaughterhouse where he performed the work Glick From page 4A Palestinians would have a viable, developed state in short order. And the Egyptians in turn would have the international support they need both eco nomically and militarily to defeat ISIS completely and to rebuild their national econ omy. Indeed, as advocates of the plan note, by yielding control over the northern Sinai to the Palestinians, and so enabling a viable Palestinian state to form, Egypt would become again the indisputable leader of the Reality From page 5A Talk From page 5A #MeToo From page 5A plaints are reported, they are responded to with the seriousness that they deserve. WRN, the Womens Rabbinic Network, has been tackling these issues for decades and is currently spearheading Union Advocacy Center, has written. Critics of the term undi vided Jerusalem say it is a slogan that hides ugly truths about occupation and disen franchisement. Fifty years on, Jerusalem is more binational, more con tested and more divided that at any point since 1967, says attorney Daniel Seidemann, children that Haifa, Tel Aviv, and west Jerusalem will all someday be theirs. On Nov. 29, 1947, prior to President Harry Truman recognizing Israel at the United Nations, people had told Truman that the recogni tion would only lead to mass rioting. What would have hap pened if Truman had listened? Jones From page 1A Jerusalem From page 1A record on Jews, she told the crowd, One of our attorneys is a Jew. In an acceptance speech at 11 p.m, Jones acknowledged his Jewish supporters. To all my Jewish friends, Happy Chanukah, he said. Trump had endorsed Moores primary challenger, Luther Strange, but pivoted to Moore after he soundly defeated Strange in the September primary. The president went all in for A recent study commis sioned by the IMPJ found that a small but increasing number of Israelis, 7 percent, identify with Reform Judaism. At the same time, a 2016 Pew Re search Center study reported that 2 percent of Israelis identify as Conservative and 3 percent as Reform, while 50 percent identify as Orthodox and 41 percent eschew any denominational identity. Distinguishing between religion and politics buys the leftover meat from him. But with demand falling for that product, slaughter houses dont view us as the ideal customers anymore, Levy said. They are paying less than 10 years ago, he said. Meanwhile, politicians in France are pressing for the obligatory labeling of meat that does come from animals that were slaughtered without stunning. In 2013, an advisory com mittee of the French Senate on the meat industry for the first time made a nonbinding recommendation for such la beling, prompting passionate condemnations by Jewish and Muslim faith leaders. But even without obliga tory labeling, the awarenessraising campaign means that a non-Jew today wants to buy neither the meat of the cruel Jews nor the terrorist Muslims, Levy said sarcasti cally. As pressure mounts, it will become more and more difficult in the kosher and halal industries. Albert Elbaz, a kosher meat shop owner from Aix-enProvence, near the southern city of Marseille, calls this vi sion alarmist. Jews, he said, will always eat kosher, and, thank God, we have enough Jews in France. But Jews make up less than 1 percent of Frances population of nearly 67 million, meaning that in reality, the only thing protecting kosher slaughter is the electoral power of the farlarger Muslim population of 5.7 million, said Levy. Yet even that protection may be temporary due to the growing acceptance among French Muslims of post-cut stunninga method in which animals are stunned as their throats are cut. Post-cut stunning is shunned by most Orthodox certifiers of kosher meat, with the exception of a handful in Austria and the United States. But its acceptability is grow ing among Muslims, whose rules on ritual slaughter are not as strict as those of Orthodox Judaism. The Jewish community seems united in opposing preslaughter stunning, while the Muslim community is divided on the question whether stun ning should be allowed before halal slaughter, noted a team of researchers who in 2013 published a report on post-cut stunning. Technical advances and the Muslim communities relative openness mean room for adapting halal slaughter without compromising its deep and essential meaning, they added. Thats bad news for Levy and others in the kosher meat industry, he said. The minute the Muslims accept post-cut stunning, Levy said, the kosher meat industry is done for. an important project on pay equity with Women of Reform Judaism. But we must do even more to create safe and sacred com munities for both those who are participants in those com munities and those who serve them The time has arrived to open a communitywide con versation beyond the ethics process about these experi ences, and examine the way that women in the rabbinate face systemic and ongoing challenges. The responsibility to strengthen the Jewish com munity and enhance the professional and personal lives of Reform rabbis is central to the mission of the CCARit is our ethical and professional mandate to ad dress these deeply troubling challenges. The Task Force on the Experience of Women in the Rabbinate will study the realities facing women in order to identify their root causes and potential solutions. It will engage our membership, laypeople and partner Reform insti tutions. Ultimately it will create change for the good and bring healing, hope and greater strength to our rab binates and the communities we serve. Rabbi Hara Person is the chief strategy officer for the Central Conference of Ameri can Rabbis and the publisher of CCAR Press. who heads the the Israeli advocacy group Terrestrial Jerusalem. There are two national collectives in Je rusalem, one endowed with political rights and the other permanently disenfranchised and disempowered. And certainly some ideo logues use it that way, drawing their own lines in the sand (and borders on a map) and daring anyone to cross them. Is it possible to imagine an undivided Jerusalem that also accommodates Palestinian aspirations for a state and capital of their own? It is, but it will take an honest discussion of what Jerusalem is and isnt. Like Trump, no Israeli and no Jew elsewhere wants to go back to the pre-1967 reality, when Jordan blocked Jews from the Western Wall and limited Christian and even Muslim access to holy sites. And no one expects Israel to unilaterally give back all that it won and consoli dated in war and built in peacenot just the current government, which pro motes a Greater Jerusalem and is indulgent of plans to build housing units in areas that Palestinians and their international backers consider disputed, and not any government one could foresee. Thats why credible peace plans have called for a consolidation of surround ing Jewish neighborhoods within Israel, with various land swaps to accommodate the Palestinians. Meanwhile, as long as the Palestinians insist that no part of Jerusalem is Israeli, peace is impossible. If the Palestinians are to achieve their own state, they, too, will have to accept the reality of what Jerusalem is and isnt. But even short of a com prehensive peace plan, it is worth asking what is meant by Jerusalem. In the bibli cal and rabbinic imagination, the city has always been as much an idea as a real ityan earthly Jerusalem (Yerushalayim shel matah) and a heavenly Jerusalem (Yerushalayim shel maalah). Hopes for peace rest on wise leaders who understand the difference. The Arabs and Palestinians have always used the threat of violence as a negotiating tool. The longer we cower to the threat of violence, the more we reinforce that as a legitimate tool of negotiations. Either we have a policy and a law, or we do not. We should not change our policies to appease the most violent participants on the world stage. It simply does not work, but rather begets more violence. By using appeasement, we do not gain the respect of the international community, nor of the Muslim and Arab world. As Osama bin Laden had said, When someone sees a weak horse, and a strong horse, it is natural to bet on the strong horse. Those who argue otherwise are engaging in what the late Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan called the soft bigotry of low expectations. They are simply being patronizing to the Palestinians. What message does that send to the Palestinian leader ship when there are govern ment spokesmen around the globe saying that we expect the Palestinians to engage in violence? We are giving them a pretense for violence and bloodshed, which eventu ally becomes a self-fulfilling prophesy. The Palestinians need to learn that no matter what dangerous illusions of con quest they are teaching their children, Israel will never cede its capital of Jerusalemnot after 3,000 years of history. And they need to learn, once and for all, that Israel is here to stay. In this way, Trumps Dec. 6 speech was a sorely needed dose of reality therapy for the Palestinians. Sarah N. Stern is the founder and president of the Endowment for Middle East Truth (EMET), which de scribes itself as an un abashedly pro-Israel and pro-American think tank and policy institute in Washing ton, D.C. Arab world. With the good will of the Europeans and Americans, Sisi would secure Egypts position indefinitely. This then brings us to the third notable aspect of the purported Saudi plan. The backlash against the plan, like the backlash against Mohammed, has been furious. Abbas has reportedly been calling every international leader he can think of to op pose the deal. The Europeans reportedly also oppose it. French President Emmanuel Macrons adviser reportedly contacted the Americans to make clear that the French are not on board with the proposal. And whereas the opposition to Mohammeds purported proposal has been largely behind the scenes, since Mo hammed did not make it pub lic, the Palestinians and their international supporters have been grabbing every available microphone to condemn US President Donald Trumps recognition of Jerusalem as Israels capital. With or without a public announcement of his alleged peace plan, Mohammed has become a hated figure in wide circles of the foreign policy establishment in the West due to his trenchant opposition to Irans rise as a hegemonic power in the region. Its a hard sell though. Mohammeds peace plan is the first peace plan that has ever offered the Palestinians a chance at a real state. Its the first plan that ever envi sioned a situation where the Palestinians have a state that doesnt imperil Israel. People who actually care about the Palestinians and Israel should welcome and support his position. People who oppose it have to explain why they insist on remaining faithful to a peace paradigm that has brought only war and instability. Why do they prefer to retain Abbass authoritarian regime over a non-sovereign kleptoc racy in Judea and Samaria with a Hamas terrorist state in Gaza to an alternative without either? Why doesnt Abbas support it if his chief aspiration is the establish ment of a viable Palestinian state and actually wants peace with Israel? The New York Times article may or may not be an accurate portrayal of a real plan presented by the actual crown prince of Saudi Arabia. But if it isnt his plan, it should be. Or it should be Trumps plan. Because it is the first peace plan anyone has ever put forward that makes sense. Not only does it secure the future of both Israel and the Palestinians, it enables Arab states like Saudi Arabia to work openly with Israel to de feat their joint Iranian enemy, while ensuring that Israel can survive and remain a credible ally to its Arab neighbors for decades to come. Originally published in The Jerusalem Post. Convention attendee Rabbi Jonathan Aaron of Temple Emanuel in Beverly Hills, Calif., told JNS that he makes a distinction between the religious and the political when it comes to Israel. Yes, Im frustrated that I cant perform weddings over there, but as far as political decisions go, its not our blood on the line, he said. The bot tom line is, even when there is criticism, the Reform leader ship knows how important Israel is to the future of the world and of Judaism. We will always support it. The Reform movement emphasized at the conference that it is working on initiatives to bring more Israeli Jews to the U.S. to witness American Jewish life through a Reform lens as well as to double the funding for increasing the Reform presence across Israel. Rabbi Jacobs encouraged attendees to increase their activism on Israeli policies. We should never shirk our obligation to raise objections to policies that weaken Israels Jewish democratic core and undermine prospects for Israeli-Palestinian peace, said Rabbi Jacobs. But we must simultaneously help our people fall in love with Israel, with her diverse and remarkable people, her found ing vision, her creativity in its scientific, business and cultural achievements, and so much more. Frank Ponder, a biennial attendee from Los Angeles, similarly said, We have every right to be critical, but I feel like its our job to make sure Israel continues to exist. Its neces sary for the future of the Jewish people and the world. I can disagree with the internal poli cies and their attitude toward Reform Jews, but it will never stop me from supporting her. Moore in the campaigns final days, recording a ro bocall endorsement for the candidate and turning a rally he headlined in Pensacola, Florida, near the Alabama border, into a Moore elec tion event. Establishment Republi can leaders had distanced themselves from Moore, but Trump heeded Moores most prominent backer, Steve Bannon, the CEO of Breit bart News. Bannon, who was a top White House adviser to Trump until August, had urged the president to back Moore.

PAGE 16

PAGE 16A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 22, 2017 Every day that youre outside, youre exposed to dangerous, but invisible, ultraviolet (UV) sunlight. Left unprotected, prolonged exposure to UV radiation can seriously damage the eye, leading to cataracts, skin cancer around the eyelid and other eye disorders. Protecting your eyes is important to maintaining eye health now and in the future. Shield your eyes (and your familys eyes) from harmful UV rays. Wear sunglasses with maximum UV protection.For more information, visit www.thevisioncouncil.org/consumers/sunglasses. A public service message from The Vision Council. HEALTHY EYES WEAR SUNGLASSES Josefin Dolsten Matzohgram is printing patterns on matzah. By Josefin Dolsten SECAUCUS, N.J. (JTA) Caution: Meat and dairy sampling on show floor, read a sign at the entrance to Mead owlands Exposition Center. That may seem like an unusual warning outside a convention center, but to the crowd attending the food expo there on Tuesday, it made sense: Kosherfest is the worlds largest kosher food trade show, where the vast ma jority of those attending follow the Jewish prohibition against mixing meat and dairy. More than 4,000 food in dustry professionals gathered for the annual two-day event, which featured more than 325 vendors showcasing an array of products, from candy to wine. Naturally, there were lots of samples. Reporting can be a tough job, but somebody had to taste everything. Amid the offer ings of many obvious treats (lox varieties and bagel fla vors, for example), there were some surprises. These are the five most unexpected foods and beverages JTA sampled at this years Kosherfest. Patterned matzah Matzohgram, which was crowned by Kosherfest the best Kosher for Passover prod uct, is matzah printed with Jewish-themed patterns, such as Stars of David and Passover greetings. The manufacturer, Independent Ink, uses color ful, edible ink that is kosher for Passover. Customers placing large orders can also customize matzahs with any image they desire. It gives you the ability to be creative for your seder plate, said NK Ranganathan, Independent Inks chief oper ating officer. You can have a variety of designs, and it becomes very interesting for the kids. Customers can buy Mat zohgram online beginning Nov. 20: Its $10 for a box of mini-matzahs and $16 for the regular size. Oxygen-infused water If Oxigens claims about its waterthat it improves both post-workout and or post-hangover recovery time and mental clarityare true, then Gatorade may have some serious competition. A bottle of the oxygeninfused beverage contains 1,000 parts per million of stabilized oxygen, compared to 5 to 40 parts per million in regular water, according to its manufacturer. Those in need of even more Os can take an Oxigen shot, which contains 5,000 parts per million. When you drink the water, the oxygen gets into your bloodstream and goes to work immediately to aid in focus, recovery, endurance and stamina, Max Lewis, direc tor of sales for Formula Four Beverages, told JTA. The oxygen is not in gas form, meaning it wont escape the bottle when its opened, Lewis added. Oxigen bottles retail at stores nationwide for $1.69 to $1.99, while the shots sell for $2.79 to $2.99. Salted caramel frozen pizza Its a pizza, its a frozen dessertits a Frizza! The Salted Caramel Frizza from Elegant Desserts won the trade shows award for best dessert. The dairy-free treat consists of a cookie bottom, salted caramel ice cream and caramel sauce. Everybody, when they come over, they go crazy about it because its entertaining, its fun, its different, said Benjamin Weisz, president of Elegant Desserts based in Brooklyn. At Kosherfest, the friz zas were cut into bite-sized squares, but they are meant to be served by the slice, like a pizza. Each pie contains eight to 16 servings, depending on how its sliced. Elegant Desserts, which sells frizzas online for $36.50 each, also sells the pies in flavors such as cookies and cream and strawberry. The five weirdest kosher foods for 2018 Josefin Dolsten Elegant Desserts sells frozen pizzas in sweet flavors such as salted caramel, peanut butter, and cookies and cream. Josefin Dolsten Cooks need only add eggs to this sauce to make shakshuka. Ready-made shakshuka Craving shakshuka but short on time? This sauce is perfect for any busy person who loves this Israeli breakfast food, which consists of eggs cooked with spices in tomato sauce. To make this version of the hearty dish, one only needs to open a jar, crack a few eggs and cook the delicious mess on the stovetop or in the oven. It makes it very quick, said Tami Bezborodko, vice presi dent of marketing for Iron Chef. In seven minutes you can have a nice, hot breakfast. The sauce contains toma toes and spices and comes in mild and medium spicy variet ies. A 24-ounce jar retails in stores nationwide for around $4.50. Rabbi-approved BBQ sauce Want a barbecue with a rabbinic seal of approval? Look no further. Rabbi Men del Segal, who founded the Kansas City Kosher BBQ Festival, now offers three va rieties of his RaBBi-Q sauce. Since launching in 2015, Segal has expanded his line of sauces to include flavors that draw on both his Jewish and Southern rootsthe pomegranate honey barbecue sauce, which Segal came up with when making brisket for Rosh Hashanah, is a favorite. It sells really well in the non-Jewish market, too, be cause nobody has a barbecue sauce that flavor yet, he told JTA. But Jews catch onto it right away. An 18-ounce jar of sauce re tails at select kosher markets nationwide for $4.99. Roasted Winter Squash with Tahini Recipe to the dish and makes it feel a little extra special, especially for a Friday-night dinner or Thanksgiving celebration. You might also add some pomegranate molasses for sweetness and tang, or some pomegranate seeds or chopped fresh herbs for color and brightness, or nothing at all. Note: You will want to go easy on the olive oil, so that the squash develops a nice caramelized texture and isnt too oily. Ingredients: 2 honey squash (or 1 medium butternut squash) 1 tablespoon olive oil Salt and pepper 3 tablespoons good quality tahini, at room temperature Pomegranate molasses, pomegranate seeds, chopped fresh herbs (optional) Directions: 1. Preheat oven to 425 F. 2. Peel the honey squash, cut off the ends and cut into 1/2inch thick rings. 3. Spread squash out in a single layer on a baking sheet. Sprinkle with salt, pepper and olive oil, and using your hands, make sure squash is evenly coated. 4. Cook on first side for 10-15 minutes. Turn over the rings and cook another 10-15 minutes, until just caramelized. 5. Drizzle with tahini. Top with additional pomegranate molasses, pomegranate seeds or fresh herbs if desired. Serves 6. Shannon Sarna is the editor of The Nosher. The Nosher food blog offers a dazzling array of new and classic Jewish recipes and food news, from Europe to Yemen, from challah to shakshuka and beyond. Check it out at ww wTheNosher.com. By Shannon Sarna (The Nosher via JTA)I recently fell in love with honey squash, a new variety of hearty winter squash bred specifically to be concentrated in flavor and adorable in appearance. OK, maybe it wasnt specifically grown to be adorable, but the result nevertheless is the same. I found honey squash at several New Yorkand New Jerseyarea farms and farmers markets, and I know that Whole Foods has also been selling them. But even if you cannot find this super sweet squash, you can substitute regular old (delicious) butternut squash, acorn squash or delicata squash. Drizzling tahini over roasted vegetables just adds a richness