Heritage Florida Jewish News

Material Information

Heritage Florida Jewish News
Place of Publication:
Fern Park, FL
Heritage Central Florida Jewish News, Inc.
Publication Date:


newspaper ( sobekcm )

Record Information

Source Institution:
University of Florida
Holding Location:
University of Florida
Rights Management:
Copyright, Heritage Central Florida Jewish News, Inc.Permission granted to University of Florida to digitize and display this item for non-profit research and educational purposes. Any reuse of this item in excess of fair use or other copyright exemptions requires permission of the copyright holder.


This item is only available as the following downloads:

Full Text


WWW.HERITAGEFL.COM YEAR 42, NO. 15 DECEMBER 15, 2017 27 KISLEV, 5778 ORLANDO, FLORIDA SINGLE COPY 75 Lior Mizrahi/Getty Images A view of the Western Wall and the golden Dome of the Rock Islamic shrine in Jerusalem, Dec. 6, 2017. By United with Israel Staff Israels leadership and Jews from around the world celebrated President Donald Trumps statement that the US officially recognizes Jerusalem as Israels capital, and that plans to move the US embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem are in motion. The US finally acknowledge[s] the obvious: that Jerusalem is Israels capi tal. This is nothing more, or less, than a recognition of reality. It is also the right thing to do. Its something that has to be done, Trump stated at the White House on Wednesday. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stated that the statement was historic, remarking that Jerusalem has been the capital of Israel for nearly 70 years. Netanyahu added, Jerusalem has been the focus of our hopes, our dreams, our prayers for three millennia. Jerusalem has been the capital of the Jewish people for 3,000 years. Israel is profoundly grateful for the President, for his courageous and just decision to recognize Jerusalem as the capital of Israel and to prepare for the opening of the US embassy here. This decision reflects the Presidents commit ment to an ancient but enduring truth, to fulfilling his promises and to advancing peace, Netanyahu said. Netanyahu also underscored that Jewish world celebrates US recognition of Jerusalem as Israels capital Trumps decision is an important step towards peace, for there is no peace that doesnt include Jerusalem as the capital of the State of Israel. Netanyahu reiterated Israels commit ment to advancing peace and to main taining the status quo at the holy sites. Israel will always ensure freedom of worship for Jews, Christians, and Muslims alike, the Israeli premier underscored. I call on all countries that seek peace to join the United States in recognizing Jerusalem as Israels capital and to move their embassies here, Netanyahu stated. President Reuven Rivlin stated that By Michael J. Koplow (JTA)President Donald Trumps recognition of Jerusa lem as the capital of Israel and his announcement that he will move the embassy there from Tel Aviv will have a number of consequences for Israelis, Pal estinians and the wider region. Yonatan Sindel/Flash90 A patron at a Jerusalem pub watches as President Donald Trump recognizes the city as Israels capital, Dec. 6, 2017. Winners and losers as the US recognizes Jerusalem as Israels capital For Israel, it has finally received from an American president what it has long craved, which is righting the historic wrong of it being the only state whose self-declared capital is not recognized by the rest of the world. Israels government institu tions are primarily in West Jerusalem in undisputed territory, and by formally recognizing this fact, Trump acknowledged what has been obvious to Israelis since the founding of the state 70 years ago. In using language that was not qualified and declaring Jerusalem to be the capital, some Israelis may interpret this to constitute an endorsement of Israeli claims to the entirety of the city, even though Trump explicitly ruled out this announcement as pre judging final status issues or the specific borders of Israeli sovereignty in the city. Nevertheless, even a more appropriate interpretation that the U.S. has recognized only the undisputed sections of Jerusalem as Israels capital is an enormously positive development for the Israeli government, and it will have cause to celebrate. For the Palestinians, Trumps qualifier that his announcement does not prejudice final status issues and the presidents extolling of the importance of peace will not eliminate the bitterness of this pill. Trumps lack of an ex plicit endorsement of an equal Palestinian claim to part of the city will be seen as a reversal of longstanding American policy and make it far more difficult for Palestinian Au thority President Mahmoud Abbas to continue to engage with Trumps emerging peace initiative. It will adversely af fect Palestinian cooperation with the U.S. and Israel going forward, and is likely to lead to protests and violence. While nothing that Trump said Wednesday has actually changed the situation on the ground, for the Palestinians Cantor Jillian Marini By Christine DeSouza Congregation Beth Chaim is back, but actually, it never really left. The small Reform congregation, which was located on 434 in Winter Springs, was struggling a few months ago. Funds were tight and its location was in a re mote area. Rumors abounded that the congregation had closed its doors for good. It had closed its doorsthat is, the doors of the building in Winter Springs. Right after the High Holidays the group of faithful congregants opened a new door in Oviedo, thanks to its cantorial soloist and spiritual leader Jillian Marini. I did a lot of research for an area that was growing more, she said. She found that location in Oviedo where Marini and her fianc had just opened a new business, Songbirds Music, Art and Dance Center. Marini donated space in the building for Friday evening for services. The real reason we chose Oviedo was because it is a family-friendly area, and thats what we arefamilyfriendly! said Marini, who grew up at Bet Chaim. We wanted to return to our roots, with lay-led services. The seven-member board with co-presidents, Diane Langer and Mel Berger, also chose a donation-only struc ture rather than membership dues. With no monthly rent and no required dues, this Bet Chaims new Oviedo location eased a financial burden for the congregants. The services, led by Marini, are very interactive. She even created a new word to describe themvoluntold, mean ing that everyone actively participates. Marini confessed though that she isnt sure if its the interactive services or the best Challah ever that draws the more than 20 congregants to the synagogue. We have two of the best challah makers! Both challahs are different, and both taste wonderful! she exclaimed with laughter. Bet Chaims new location is 181 E. Mitchell Ham mock, Oviedo. Services are at 8 p.m. every Friday, and tonight, there will be a special Chanukah service and party. Marini stated that everyone is welcome, and bring latkes. JERUSALEM (JTA)Hours after ordering preparations for a U.S. embassy in Jerusalem, President Donald Trump de layed moving the diplomatic mission to the city by another six months. Trump signed a procla mation at the White House Wednesday saying the United States sees Jerusalem as Israels capital and directing the State Department to start planning an embassy in the city. Soon thereafter, he signed another presidential waiver of a 1995 law requiring the embassy to be moved from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem. Under U.S. President Bill Clinton, Congress passed the Jerusalem Embassy Act recognizing Jerusalem as Is raels capital and stating that the embassy should be moved here. However, presidents ever sincefrom Clinton to George W. Bush to Barack Obama have invoked a waiver written into the law that allows them to postpone the move for rea sons of national security. As a result, the law has never gone into effect. Trump referred to this his Trump delays moving embassy tory in his speech announcing the historic shift in U.S. policy on Jerusalem on Wednesday. Presidents issued these waivers under the belief that delaying the recognition of Jerusalem would advance the cause of peace, he said. Some say they lacked courage, but they made their best judg ments based on facts as they understood them at the time. While previous presidents have made this a major cam paign promise, they failed to deliver, Trump said. Today, I am delivering. According to the Guardian, White House officials said Trump signed the waiver to avoid a legally stipulated cut in State Department fund ing until the new embassy is actually opened. They told the newspaper that previous presi dents used the waiver to avoid moving the embassy, whereas Trump instructed the start of practical work on the mission. Winners on page 15A Jerusalem on page 15A Roth JCC Spring Program Guide Inside...


PAGE 2A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 On Tuesday, Dec. 5, fifthgrade Jewish students from the Jewish Academy of Or lando got together with Muslim students from Lead ership Preparatory School and Christian students from Geneva School for a morn ing of learning and sharing. The Multi-Faith Education Program began 14 years ago when its founder, Louise Franklin Sheehy, worked to foster a climate of peace among the children of the different Abrahamic faiths. This was the first meeting be tween the three schools that will take place this year. At each meeting, students and faculty will learn about each others different faith tradi tions. At the Jewish Academy of Orlando, Head of School Alan Rusonik talked about the central role of Torah in Judaism and opened up the Sefer Torah (Torah scroll) for all the students to witness and behold. Additionally, the students learned a song of peace Od Yavo Shalom Aleynu, which means soon peace will come. Finally, the students from the Jewish Academy taught about the upcoming holiday of Chanu kah, which ended in a lively and spirited game of Dreidel! The students learned that ultimately, despite our differ ent beliefs, customs and tradi tions, we all share the values of peace, love and mutual re spect and we share a common desire to have peace in our world. At the Jewish Academy of Orlando, we believe that this is an important program to help promote peace, unity, love and understanding in our very complicated and fragmented world. For more information about the Jewish Academy of Orlando or to arrange a visit to the school, please contact Amy Polacek, Admissions Coordinator, at apolacek@ or 407-647-0713. Students from the Jewish Academy of Orlando, Leadership Preparatory School and Geneva School met at the Jewish Academy for the first Multi-Faith Education Program of the year. Multi-Faith Program at the Jewish Academy of Orlando Andrew Tobin Hovav Landoy shopping at the Mahane Yehuda market in Jerusalem, Dec. 6, 2017. By Andrew Tobin JERUSALEM (JTA)Presi dent Donald Trumps official recognition of Jerusalem as Israels capital may have sent shock waves across the Middle East. But here, in the epicen ter of a city where fewer than a million people work, eat, pray and shop, the first days reaction was muted. The municipality projected images of the Israeli and American flags side by side on the Old City walls. But in Mahane Yehuda, the bustling produce and everything-else market a few miles into the citys western side, it was another working day. Jews generally welcomed the development, while Arabs expressed anger. But nobody thought the U.S. president would fundamentally change the situation in Israelfor bet ter or worse. A number of others had not even heard about it. Shay, 40, a black kippahwearing nut seller and long time Jerusalem resident, said Trump had shown that he understood Israelis national and religious ties to the city. After all these years, we finally have somebody who feels what the Israelis feel, he said. Trump has a warm heart for Israel and he does what he says he is going to do. Here in Israel, we love him more than we love Bibi Netanyahu, he added, using Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahus nickname, and we love Bibi a lot. But Shay said the signifi cance of Trumps announce ment was mostly symbolic. Although some had warned of Palestinian violence, he said he was not worried because Arabs respect power. They know only one thing, he said. When you are strong, they dont do anything. When youre a sissy, they are coming. Asked why he did not want to use his last name, Shay explained, I have many Arab customers. Better not to make them mad. Bassam Hoshiah, a 36-yearold Arab Israeli who lives in a village near Jerusalem, was selling nuts, too, from a stall directly across from Shays. While he agreed that Trump was siding with Israel on Jeru salem, he felt much differently about the significance. Arguing that Jerusalem is for everyone, Hoshiah predicted there would be a spike in terrorism in response to Trumps speech. There will be a balagan in the Old City and the West Bank, he said, using Hebrew slang for a chaotic mess. But Hoshiah said he did not think the violence would spread across Jerusalem, let alone the country. As he loaded a large bag of nuts into an elderly Jewish womans pushcart, he said he planned to show up for work the next day as usual. There was not much support in the market for Netanyahus interpretation of the U.S. poli cy shift as a step toward peace. But nor did anyone seem to think it would derail Trumps international diplomacy on behalf of the ultimate deal, as he has called it, between the Israelis and Palestinians. The prevailing attitude was resignation to the status quo. Uzi Sharabi, a 40-year-old baker from the West Bank settlement of Maale Adumim, said he was happy to have the big man on Israels side, but that peace was not in the cards. He said Israel would be able to deal with any flare up in terrorism. It wasnt going to happen before Trump recognized Jerusalem as our capital, and its not going to happen afterward, Sharabi said. We just have to stay strong. A recent survey by Israels Maariv newspaper found that nearly 80 percent of Israelis believe peace is not possible, despite Trumps efforts. A young soldier from Jeru salem, who asked to remain anonymous because the army forbids enlistees from discuss ing politics, said he of course agrees with Trump that Jeru salem is the capital of Israel. But he questioned whether it was the right time to make the declaration. The soldier wor ried that the announcement would result in a Palestinian uprising that would put him At a Jerusalem market, shrugs greet an announcement from President Trump Andrew Tobin Uzi Sharabi selling baked goods at the Mahane Yehuda market in Jerusalem, Dec. 6, 2017. Andrew Tobin Bassam Hoshiah selling nuts at the Mahane Yehuda market in Jerusalem, Dec. 6, 2017. and his comrades at risk without any tangible reward. Its a fact that it will cause violence. Everything here causes violence, especially in Jerusalem, he said. We already know this is our capital. So isnt peace more important? Hoshni Barazan, a 38-yearold fruit vendor who lives in the Mount of Olives neigh borhood in mostly Palestin ian eastern Jerusalem, said Trump could not give away what did not belong to him, and that Israel would pay the price in bloodshed. You can give this to who ever you want? he said, holding up a strawberry. No. Because its mine, not yours. Its the same with AlAqsa, he continued, referring to the mosque on the Temple Mount, which has long been a flashpoint in the IsraeliPalestinian conflict. When reminded that the city has a Jewish major ity, Barazan said the whole country rightfully belonged to the Palestinians. But his heart did not seem to be in the conversation anymore. How are the strawberries selling today? he shouted affectionately in Hebrew at a Jewish fellow vendor who was walking by. Better than yours, the man retorted, grinning.


HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 PAGE 3A An IDF soldier standing guard at a military base in Israels northern Golan Heights region. The ambassador explained that as Iran continues to ag gressively expand its military presence near Israels border, the Jewish state is forced to enforce its red lines, which risks an escalation in tension. The more they push, we have to enforce our red lines, and you always have the pros pects of an escalation, even when parties dont want an escalation, because we will not allow Iran to establish that presence and establish another terror front against Israel in Syria, said Dermer. So in taking action to de fend ourselves, you dont know what could happen, he said. In line with Dermers com ments, the Israeli Air Force al legedly conducted an airstrike Monday night on a military scientific research center on the outskirts of Damascus. The purported strike fol lowed an alleged Israeli air strike last Friday on an Iranian military base in Syria. War on Israels northern border possibly weeks away ( A war along Is raels northern border could be just weeks away, accord ing to Israeli Ambassador to the U.S. Ron Dermer. Dermer made the com ments in a wide-ranging in terview published by Politico on Monday, stating that the probability of direct conflict with the Iranian terror proxy Hezbollah is higher than people think because of Irans continued push through the region. If Iran is not rolled back in Syria, then the chances of military confrontation are growing. I dont want to tell you by the year or by the month. Id say even by the week, Dermer said. Abed Rahim Khatib/Flash90 Palestinians protest Trumps announcement on Jerusalem. By: World Israel News Staff The Hamas terror organi zation said President Donald Trumps historic recognition of Jerusalem as Israels capi tal opens the gates of hell and has called for another violent uprising against the Jewish state. Trumps decision on Je rusalem will not succeed in changing the fact that Jerusalem is Arab Muslim land, a Hamas spokesman said Wednesday following Trumps announcement at the White House. Hamas called for Palestin ians to take to the streets in a Day of Rage on Friday and respond with all means available. Hamas leader Ismail Hani yeh stated Thursday that the US intention to relocate the Hamas: Trumps recognition of Jerusalem has opened the gates of hell He further called the deci sion a blatant aggression against the Palestinians, the Islamic nation and free people of the world, threatening that the reac tion of the Islamic people will shock the US admin istration. He further threatened that this decision will spark the beginning of grave hostilities, not only at the Palestinian level, but also at the regional level. The Palestinian people will strongly confront this decision and they will not surrender until this Ameri can attempt is foiled, he vowed, saying that the Palestinians can ignite one Intifada [violent uprising] after the other. Haniyeh stated that he phoned Palestinian Author ity (PA) Mahmoud Abbas and they agreed to mobilize the Palestinian masses to pro test against the American decision. He also called upon the Arab and Islamic nations to put aside their differences and to mobilize to support their main battle: the Pal estinian cause. The IDF, anticipating a possible violent Palestinian outburst, said it has de ployed additional troops to possible flashpoints ahead of Friday. The IDF statement on Thursday said it has de ployed several battalions while other units have been put on alert to address pos sible developments. Palestinians went on strike on Thursday and pro tests and sporadic violence at various points were re ported throughout the day. US embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem will not change the history and geography of Jerusalem, and Jerusalem will always remain the capital of Palestine. He called Trumps decision a gamble and an uncalculated risk. JERUSALEM (JTA)Is rael said it expects other countries to follow Americas example and recognize Jeru salem as its capital, even as much of the world decried the U.S. decision to move toward relocating its embassy to the city. Speaking at a diplomatic conference Thursday, a day after the historic shift in U.S. policy, which he welcomed, Prime Minister Benjamin Ne tanyahu said he was in contact with countries interested in such actions. We are holding contacts with other countries who will also recognize Jerusalem as Israels capital. I have no doubt than when the U.S. Embassy will move there, and even before that, many embassies will relocate to Jerusalem, he said at the Foreign Ministry in Jerusalem. Its about time. Israeli officials who spoke anonymously on Thursday downplayed the threat of a diplomatic backlash to the American move. On Wednes day, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas declared that the United States can no longer act as a mediator be tween Israel and the Palestin ians. World leaders expressed concern and Arab and Muslim leaders warned of disaster. On Thursday, Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh called for Palestinians to launch a new intifada, and the Israeli army braced for violence by redeploying troops to the West Bank and putting more soldiers on standby. The Israeli officials said they expect Czech President Milos Zeman to recognize Jerusalem as Israels capital later in the day. They said both the Czech Republic and the Phillipines were eager to move their embassies to Jerusalem from Tel Aviv. The Czech Republics For eign Ministry said Wednes day it considers Jerusalem to be in fact the capital of Israel in the borders of the demarcation line from 1967, meaning only the citys west ern part. But the ministry said it would not move the embassy prior to a negoti ated Israeli-Palestinian deal. Although the Czech parlia ment already recognized Jerusalem as Israels capital earlier this year, the coun trys embassy has remained in the Tel Aviv area. Also Wednesday, Philip pines President Rodrigo Duterte sent a message to Israel that he wanted to move his countrys embassy to Je rusalem, Israels Kan public broadcaster reported. Jerusalem reportedly an ticipates that Hungary may move its embassy to Jeru salem as well. According to The Times of Israel, citing unnamed European sources, Budapest blocked a joint European Union statement that would have opposed the historic change in the U.S. position. U.S. President Donald Trump signed a proclamation at the White House Wednes day saying the United States sees Jerusalem as Israels capital and directing the State Department to start planning an embassy in the city. Trump said the decision should not impinge on his administra tions efforts to bring about a peace agreement between Israelis and Palestinians. He said the proclamation does not presume the outcome of Jerusalems status in negotia tions and he urged continued Muslim administration of the Temple Mount, a site holy to both Jews and Muslims and a flashpoint in the IsraeliPalestinian conflict. Amid global outcry over US recognition of Jerusalem, Israel sees other countries coming around ( The Israeli Air Force allegedly conducted an airstrike Monday night on a military scientific research center in the Jamraya area on the outskirts of Damascus, media affiliated with the Syr ian regime reported. Our air defenses are con fronting an Israeli missile at tack on one of our sites in the Damascus suburbs and three of the targets were downed, reported the Syrian state news agency SANA. The Hezbollah-affiliated media outlet Al Mayadeen stated that the Israeli military launched six missiles at the site, and that three of the missiles were intercepted by Syrian air defense systems. The Syrian Observatory for Human Rights reported that violent explosions were caused by Israeli jets that shook Damascus and the surrounding area. No casualties were reported as a result of the alleged strike. The Jamraya area is the site of numerous Syrian military facilities, includ ing a potential chemical weapons production fac tory and storage unit. The facility was previously at tacked in 2013 in what was believed to be an Israeli airstrike. Reports of the airstrike near Damascus follow an alleged Israeli strike last Friday night on an Iranian military base in Syria. Israel conducts second strike within days in Syria favorite varieties delicious oranges fresh from Florida204 Handpicked fresh from the grove!4 unique varieties. 20 delicious oranges!Call 1-877-599-9729 to order item 453X or Visit Item #453X, mention Code 8SH-D915 for your $15 savings. Only $19.99* (reg. $34.99), plus $5.99 shipping & handling. Satisfaction completely guaranteed. is gift ships in December at the peak of freshness. Order by Dec. 16, 2017 for GUARANTEED Christmas delivery.Call now andSAVE 43%!*Plus $5.99 handling to the 48 contiguous states. Limited time o er, good while supplies last. Not valid with any other o er. Limit 5 boxes per customer. rfntfbHandpicked and hand packed, our fresh, juicy oranges are delivered to your door fresh o the tree! Twenty plump, delicious oranges in 4 favorite varieties. 5 Navel Oranges Juicy, sweet and seedless, theyre everyones favorite! 5 Petite Red Navels Spicy sweet avor with a bright red esh. 5 Tangerines Rich Honey-Sweet avor with easy-to-peel skin. 5 Petite Navel Oranges Snack-sized sweet treat.WOW! WOW! Navel Oranges Tangerines Petite Navel Oranges Petite Red Navels SAVE $15!Reg. Price $34.99 ONLY$1999*Special limited time offer! Orange Spectacular!


PAGE 4A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 THE VIEWS EXPRESSED ON THIS PAGE ARE NOT NECESSARILY THE VIEWS OF HERITAGE MANAGEMENT. CENTRAL FLORIDAS INDEPENDENT JEWISH VOICE ISSN 0199-0721 Winner of 46 Press Awards HERITAGE Florida Jewish News (ISN 0199-0721) is published weekly for $37.95 per year to Florida ad dresses ($46.95 for the rest of the U.S.) by HERITAGE Central Florida Jewish News, Inc., 207 OBrien Road, Suite 101, Fern Park, FL 32730. Periodicals postage paid at Fern Park and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes and other correspondence to: HERITAGE, P.O. Box 300742, Fern Park, FL 32730. PHONE NUMBER (407) 834-8787 FAX (407) 831-0507 MAILING ADDRESS P.O. Box 300742 Fern Park, FL 32730 email: Editor/Publisher Jeffrey Gaeser Editor Emeritus Associate Editor News Editor Gene Starn Kim Fischer Christine DeSouza Account Executives Kim Fischer Marci Gaeser Contributing Columnists Jim Shipley Ira Sharkansky David Bornstein Ed Ziegler Production Department David Lehman Gil Dombrosky Joyce Gore Society Editor Gloria Yousha Office Manager Paulette Alfonso By Chaya Kravetz This is nothing more and nothing less than recognition of reality. It is also the right thing to do. Announced President Trump in his monumental statement today, recognizing Jerusalem as Israels capital established in ancient times. Jerusalem has been the eternal capital of the Jewish people since Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob worshipped on the Temple Mount. Jerusalem continued to be the eternal capital of the Jew ish nation since King David brought the Holy Ark to rest on the Temple Mount. This was further affirmed by King Solomon when he built the Temple on the Temple Mount. Rabbi Steven Burg, CEO of Aish Global proclaimed, I am proud that the Aish HaTo rah Dan Family World Center stands directly across the Temple Mount (rising 7 stories high and encompassing 40 percent of the length of the Western Wall Plaza). Every Jew in the world knows that our heart and soul belongs to Jerusalem and we are thankful to President Trump for his brave statement today. We are eternally grateful to the United States of America for its tremendous support of world Jewry and Israel in particular. Since the creation of the world, Jerusalem has been and will always be the center of the universe for all Jews. May the Almighty bless all of us with peace and happiness in a unified and strong Jerusalem. Aish HaTorah is a global platform empower ing Jews to discover their unlimited potential through Torah wisdom in an inspirational, meaningful and welcoming way, encouraging every Jew to fulfil his or her destiny. Founded by the late Rabbi Noah Weinberg, OBM, in 1974, today Aish HaTorah is a worldwide movement with 35 branches, engaging over 150,000 people per year and reaching over a million people online. Chaya Kravetz is the director of Communi cations Aish Global, One Western Wall Plaza, Old City, Jerusalem, Israel. Eternal we stand By Stephen M. Flatow The Taylor Force Act started out as a power ful and long-overdue tool for pressuring the Palestinian Authority to stop paying terrorists. But the legislation has been diluted, weakened and compromised in so many ways that it is now a pale shadow of its former self. The Taylor Force Act has been gutted. Known in the Senate as S. 1697, the Taylor Force Act is named after a young Vanderbilt University studentand U.S. Army veteran who was murdered by a Palestinian Arab knife-wielding terrorist in Jaffa in 2016. The lead Senate sponsor is Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) and Rep. Doug Lamborn (R-Colo.) initiated the House of Representatives ver sion, H.R. 1164. The idea behind the bill was to reduce U.S. aid to the Palestinians in proportion to the amount that the PA pays to terrorists. Thanks to the good work of Israeli Brig. Gen. (res.) Yossi Kuperwasser and the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, we know that the PA has a precise and sophisticated system of providing financial incentives to murderers of Jews. An Arab who is imprisoned for attacking (but not killing) Jews receives a monthly sal ary of $400 from the PA. The amount goes up according to the length of the terrorists prison sentence. An Arab who succeeds in killing a Jew receives a monthly salary of $3,400. The financial rewards dont stop there. After he completes his sentence, a terrorist receives a minimum additional grant of $1,500. The size of the grant increases according to the length of his sentence. A murderer receives $25,000. Their families are rewarded, too. The family of an unmarried terrorist who is killed receives $100 monthly. The widow of a terrorist receives $250 each month, for life. Stopping such payments is obviously a ne cessity. And the U.S. has the leverage to stop themthe hundreds of millions of dollars that America provides to the Palestinians each year. The original Taylor Force Act would have linked the two. But as the bill began working its way through the legislative process in recent months, the appeasers jumped in. There are officials in the State Department and certain congressional offices who are deeply pro-Palestinian. They started push ing for all sorts of exceptions and loopholes. Unfortunately, some congressional staffers and Jewish leaders who support the bill got weak in the knees. They decided they had to accept compromises in order to get more votes for the bill. So they added language saying that U.S. funding for various Palestinian health and sanitation programs would not be affected. Sen. Bob Corker (R-Tenn.), chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, warned that such exemptions would basi cally gut the bill and render the legislation useless because it would leave too few areas of funding for the U.S. to exercise leverage. He was right. And it got worse. Next they added a one-year delay before the provisions of the bill go into effect. That gives the PA a year in which to come up with a phony new arrangement by which the payments are given to terrorists from some private group instead of the PA itself. Then they stipulated that the money which is withheld must be put into a Palestinian Authority Accountability Fund, which can then be given to the Palestinians if the State Department certifies that the PA is taking steps against terrorism. We all know that for the past 24 years, the State Department has repeatedly certified that the PA was keeping its obligations in the Oslo Accordseven though that certification was a total lie. No matter how blatantly the PA violated the accords, the State Department always found some excuse to declare it to be in compliance, so that U.S. money would keep flowing. There is every reason to believe that the State Department will do so again. Sometimes, in politics, you have to compro mise. I get that and have done it myself when advancing other terror victim legislation. Sometimes a flawed bill is better than no bill at all. But not always. Sometimes a bill is so deeply flawed that it is actually worse than no billbecause it will prevent any other action from being taken on the issue. This is one such bill. If the Taylor Force Act passes in its current form, there will be no further congressional action on the issue for the foreseeable future. And we will be stuck with legislation that pre tends to address the issue of paying terrorists, but really does nothing of the sort. That would deal a grievous blow to the memory of Taylor Force and the many other American victims of Palestinian terrorism. Stephen M. Flatow, a vice president of the Religious Zionists of America, is an attorney in New Jersey. He is the father of Alisa Flatow, who was murdered in an Iranian-sponsored Palestinian terrorist attack in 1995. He may be contacted at The gutting of the Taylor Force Act By Ron Kampeas WASHINGTON (JTA)Michael Flynn, President Donald Trumps former national security adviser, pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI twiceboth times about policy maneuvering with Sergey Kislyak, the Rus sian ambassador to the United States, during the transition. That last word is key: Flynn twice talked to Kislyak in December 2016 when Trump was president-elect, not president. That was still Barack Obamas job. One of the things Flynn and Kislyak talked about was Israel. Flynn says that was at the behest of Trumps son-in-law and adviser Jared Kushner, who has longstanding ties with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. What does that mean for special prosecutor Robert Muellers investigation of ties between the Trump campaign and transition team and Russia? What are the implications for Kushner and for Israel? Why does the timing matter? The 1799 Logan Act calls for the pros ecution of any U.S. person who directly or indirectly commences or carries on any cor respondence or intercourse with any foreign government or any officer or agent thereof, in relation to any disputes or controversies with the United States, or to defeat the measures of the United States. Neither Flynn nor Trump were yet in government. What did Flynn do? According to court papers released Friday, Flynn on Dec. 29 asked Kislyak for assurances that Russia would not retaliate against the United States for sanctions Obama had just imposed for Russias alleged interference in the 2016 U.S. election. On Dec. 22 he asked Kislyak to keep a U.N. Security Council resolution condemning Israels settlement policy from advancing. He lied about those conversations in a Jan. 24 interview with FBI agents. The Obama administration was signaling that it would allow through the Security Council resolutiona move that would en rage Israel and its American supporters. It did and Russia did not intervene, in fact voting for the resolution. (Russia did heed the Trump teams request not to impose sanctions, however.) Flynns actions could suggest that he carried on intercourse... in relation to an other countrys controversies with the United States, as its defined in the Logan Act. In the case of the Obama administrations decision to allow the U.N. Security Council resolution to advance, his action, had it been successful, would have defeated a U.S. measure. So this is about the Logan Act? Maybe not. There has not been a successful prosecution under the act since 1799; there seems to have been only two indictments. One concern is the laws First Amendment implications. The Logan Act, were it ever to be applied broadly, would inhibit political speech. And a president-elect launching his foreign policy during a transition is not unprecedented. President-elect Dwight Eisen hower visited South Korea in November 1952 to lay the ground for his plan to end the war. During the 1968 transition Richard Nixon, through a top adviser, Henry Kissinger, se cretly reached out to North Vietnam in a bid to restart peace talks. So if its not about the Logan Act, what is it about? Maybe it is about the Logan Act. Although the act seems unprosecutable, the threat of its invocation almost since its inception has been a potent political cudgel. Even absent a prosecution, the notion that a political rival is actively undermining U.S. policy, and particularly with an adversary of the United States, can damage a reputation. Flynn may have lied to the FBI on Jan. 24 not because he feared prosecution, but because he feared for the credibility of the 4-day-old presidency he was serving. Vice President Dick Cheney intimated that Nancy Pelosi, then the speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, was in violation of the act in 2007 when she met with Syrian President Bashar Assad. Pelosi vigorously denied Cheneys charges that she was under cutting the Bush administrations isolation of Syria. She said the meeting was at Israels behest, a bid by then-Prime Minister Ehud Olmert to tamp down tensions. Carter administration officials have said Ronald Reagans campaign persuaded Iran to delay the release of Iranian hostages until after the 1980 election to wound incumbent President Jimmy Cartera charge that Reagans aides hotly denied. Reagan in 1984 accused then presidential candidate Jesse Jackson of violating the Logan Act when he visited Syria and returned with an American airman who had been captured. Lyndon Johnson considered invoking the Logan Act just before the 1968 election when he learned that Nixon was secretly working with the South Vietnamese to scuttle peace talks in order not to give the Democratic candidate, Johnsons vice president, Hubert Humphrey, a pre-election boost. (Saigon wanted Nixon to win.) Johnson in the end kept Nixons secret. So its the cover-up, not the crime? Perhaps. If Mueller establishes that the Trump transition team was intent on un dercutting steps Obama had taken to protect American interests, the lying would become more consequential, even if the underlying act is not illegal. So isnt it a wrap? Muellers got Flynns guilty plea, right? Mueller has other game in mind, and Flynn apparently is cooperating. In his plea, Flynn said a very senior member of the presidential transition team directed Flynn to contact of ficials from foreign governments, including Russia, to learn where each government stood on the [U.N Security Council] resolution and to influence those governments to delay the vote and defeat the resolution. That very senior member, Bloomberg News reported over the weekendand other media have confirmedis Kushner. (Flynns subsequent What Michael Flynns plea could mean for Jared Kushner and Israel appeal to Russia not to retaliate for Obamas sanctions was reportedly at the behest of another transition official, K.T. McFarland.) So thats Kushners role. What about Israel? On the same day that Flynn was asking Kislyak to stop the resolution, Dec. 22, 2016, Trump put out a statement saying the Secu rity Council resolution should be defeated. Israeli officials at the time said they had asked Trump to make the statement. We did reach out to the president-elect and are deeply appreciative that he weighed in, which was not a simple thing to do, one told CNN. All of this was aboveboardTrumps tran sition team at the time said it had notified the Obama White House that Trump would make the statement, and the Israeli official told CNN it had warned the Obama team that it was turning to Trump for help. Mueller will want to know if Kushner, who pressed Flynn to make the call to the Russians, was taking directions from Israel. But all this is taking place in the open. Why did Flynn lie about it a month later? A statement from Trump is a wish and not much more. If Flynn, in his conversation with Kislyak, offered a quid pro quo, and with Kushners blessing, it could be seen as a dealan active effort to undermine Obama administration policy. Flynn on page 15A


HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 PAGE 5A Letters To The Editor We are a diverse community and we welcome your letters and viewpoints. The views and opinions expressed in the opinion pieces and letters published in The Heri tage are the views of the authors, and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of The Heritage Florida Jewish News or its staff. The Heritage reserves the right to edit letters for clarity, content, and accuracy. And respectful of lashon hara, we will not print derogatory statements against any individual. Please limit letters to 250 words. Send letters to P.O. Box 300742, Fern Park, FL 32730. Or e-mail to news@ Solidarity on page 15A Dear Editor: The Zionistas thank Presi dent Trump for boldly rec ognizing Jerusalem as the capital of Israel, thus begin ning the process of moving our embassy there. Since 1995, when Congress passed the Jerusalem Em bassy Act for the purpose of initiating the relocation of the U.S. Embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, Presidents Clin ton, Bush and Obama have consistently waived enacting this law, citing national secu Thank you, Mr. President! rity interests. But President Trump made the decision to do the right thing and kept his campaign promise, tak ing steps to move the U.S. embassy to Jerusalem. We know that many have and continue to criticize his decision, and thats why we are taking this moment to express our thanks and appreciation for his faithfulness and courage. We also would like to thank Christians United for Israel and the many Chris tian and Jewish organiza tions who have supported the president. The Zionistas urge Heritage readers to send their own and/ or their organizations letter of thanks the President. The Zionistas BoardSan di Solomon, Eva Ritt, David and Harriet Moldau and Judy Shujman. By Charles Jacobs and Ilya Feoktistov On July 25, 2017, in what appeared to be an unprec edented event in American Jewish history, a group that came into existence as a front for a terrorist organization that murders Jews was in vited to solicit donations at a synagogue. On that date, Rabbi Howard Jaffe of Temple Isaiah in Lex ington, Mass., hosted three Muslim leaders, whom he pre sented to his congregation as wonderful people and friends of the Jewish community. The event was seductively titled Out of Many, One, and was billed as an important inter faith bridge-building affair. Yet video footage of the event (which has now been removed from YouTube) and printed materials handed out to attendees reveal that what the rabbi presided over was something quite different. It was a political rally where Islamist extremists pretend ing to be moderates sought to enlist Jews in their campaign to undermine U.S. govern ment counter-terrorism ef forts, while raising funds for a Hamas-connected groupall in the name of social justice and interfaith harmony. The rabbis Muslim guests were Nadeem Mazen, New England director of the Coun cil on American-Islamic Relations; Stephanie Mar zouk, founder of the Muslim Justice League; and Samer Naseredden, director of youth programming at the Islamic Society of Boston Cultural Center, which is New Eng lands largest mosque. According to the AntiDefamation League and the FBI, CAIR and its founders were part of a group set up by the Muslim Brotherhood to support Hamas, an or ganization whose charter calls for the murder of every Jew on the planet including, presumably, all of Rabbi Jaffes gathered flock. In 2009, a fed eral district judge ruled that prosecutors have established at least a prima facie case as to CAIRs involvement in a con spiracy to support Hamas. Since then, CAIR has put itself forward to the public as a civil rights group. But even in that guise it has sought to persuade American Muslims to op pose the U.S. governments counter-terrorism efforts, and the ISBCC and MJL have recently joined its cause. The rabbi presented his guests as people who are allied with the progressive values of his congregation. The Islamist speakers tried to act the part. The ISBCCs Naseredden, for example, claimed that hes as Ameri can as apple pie. In fact, the mosques youth training cur riculum is used to radicalize the historically moderate Boston Muslim community. It is therefore not a complete surprise that the ISBCC and its sister mosque in Cam bridge, Mass., where Nadeem Mazen is a prominent mem ber, have been home to at least 13 convicted, killed or fugi tive terrorists, including the Boston Marathon bombers. Many of these terrorists are still considered heroes by a significant fraction of the ISBCCs membership. A few years ago, the ISBCC held a pep rally in support of almost two-dozen convicted terrorists from around the country. During the rally, an ISBCC imam called America the land of the coward, the home of the slave and threat ened that this nation, by God, will be brought to its knees. After the Boston Marathon bombing, President Barack Obamas Justice Department initiated a program called Countering Violent Extrem ism to deal with Americanbased terrorism. New Eng lands ADL office became an integral part of this effort. Its executive director, Robert Trestan, insists that CVE is vital to Jewish safety, tell ing the Boston-area Jewish Journal, Islamic extremists are trying to recruit people for violence, particularly violence against Jews. We cant afford to waste time discussing any longer. We need to take action to prevent them from recruit ing vulnerable people in our community. But Rabbi Jaffes second guest, Marzouk, told the con gregation that she founded the Muslim Justice League to fight against the very CVE effort that ADL considers vital to the safety of New Englandsincluding Rabbi JaffesJews. Marzouk argued that Amer ican Muslims should refuse to give aid to law enforce ment officials investigating Islamist terror plots against their fellow Americans. She handed out flyers that al leged, without evidence, a widespread conspiracy of tar geting Muslims through U.S. government policy that has occurred for many decades. Her fliers cited the case of Tarek Mehanna, an ISBCC member and hero among the Massachusetts Islamist com munity, whom she portrayed as unfairly prosecuted and stripped of his liberties by an Obama administration antiMuslim witch hunt. What Marzouks fliers didnt mention was that Mehanna had pledged his loy alty to Al-Qaeda in Iraq, the forerunner of Islamic State, and that he had plotted a ma chine gun massacre at a Mas sachusetts shopping mall. Ac cording to the Department of Justice, Mehanna and his coconspirators, who shared videos of the deaths of Ameri can servicemen, seemed to delight in the most horrific atrocities. (The videos in cluded American soldiers having their rib cages ripped open and set on fire with gasoline. [N]ice juicy BBQ, Mehanna gloated. Texas BBQ is the way to go...I want more BBQ sauce videos.) None of this was presented to the congregation, but Rabbi Jaffe cannot claim he didnt know about it because we had previ ously shared the information with him. Another of the rabbis guests, CAIRs Mazen, com plained to the gathered Jews that New York cops embed ded informants within MITs Muslim Students Association when he was its president. But Mazen did not disclose any of the obvious reasons for them to do so. During the time Mazen attended MIT, for Solidarity with terror and its enablers isnt social justice By Jonathan S. Tobin In the end, perhaps only a president so completely divorced from diplomatic reality and utterly indifferent to international opinion could do it. Despite the difficulties and the manifest dangers in volved with keeping Americas promiseenshrined in U.S. law passed by Congressto move the U.S. Embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusa lem, President Donald Trump may actually do it sometime in the next week. The Wall Street Journal reported that the State De partment had informed U.S. embassies around the world about a plan to make the move and to begin planning for how to deal with the protests that would inevitably follow. For U.S. diplomats living abroadespecially those in the Middle East or working in any Muslim-majority coun trythis is no joke. If Trump makes good on the pledge, the response from the Arab street will likely be nasty and might rival or even exceed the destruction, violence and even murder that resulted when a Danish newspaper published a few satirical cartoons about the Prophet Mohammed. Egged on by Iran and other radical Islamists, protests will be massive and will carry a hefty price tag. This is why most observers, including those sympathetic to Israel, have been skeptical about talk of an embassy move. Few thought even a president as unconventional as Trump would do some thing that virtually everyone in the foreign policy estab lishment as well as moderate Arab nations thinks would not only create a crisis, but also preclude any progress toward a two-state solution or peace. Why then is Trump con templating something the smart people are convinced is foolish? The answer from his criticswhose numbers increase every time he lets loose with an ill-considered tweet or statementis that he is an ignorant fool. Yet, as with those obnoxious tweets, which distract his foes from policy issues and amuse his fans, there may be a method to the madness. Its entirely possible that Trump is either being guided to or is stum bling along a path that could be saner than the supposedly safer course steered by his predecessors on Jerusalem. According to The Wall Street Journal, what Trump might do is to recognize Jerusalem as Israels capital and announce plans for the embassy move, but make it clear that wont happen for several years. In the interim, the U.S. ambassador could work in Jerusalem and peace talks could resume. The method to Trumps madness on Jerusalem may make sense This would merely recog nize reality. Jerusalem has been Israels capital since 1949. The map put forward by the 1947 U.N. Partition Plan resolution that set aside the holy city as an international zone, apart from proposed Jewish and Arab states, has been a dead letter for 70 years. Moreover, even if a two-state solution were pos sible, calling the city Israels capital wouldnt preclude a compromise that might cede its Arab neighborhoods to be the capital of a Palestinian state. But what Trumps potential move would do is put the Palestinians on notice that their decades of denial of the legitimacy of a Jewish state and its historic ties to Jerusalem will no longer be tolerated. It would be a symbolic gesture aimed at reminding them that their century-long war on Zionism that is still inextricably tied to Palestinian national identity must end. The conflict will only really cease when the Palestinians get the mes sage from an international community that has enabled their rejectionism that it is no longer willing to keep playing the same game. If they really want an independent state and peacesomething the propaganda still emanat ing from both Palestinian Authority leader Mahmoud Abbass Fatah and his Hamas rivals continues to make im possiblethey will have to do it with an Israel whose capital happens to be in Jerusalem. If this is Trumps gambit, it may well come back to bite him if Muslim riots exact a high cost. It will be easy for some to lump this decision in with his often-irresponsible statements that have under mined the credibility of his administration. In the end, Trump may be persuaded by the adults in his administration to not do it. But peace will never come except by jolt ing the Palestinians into accepting reality. Thats something more judicious presidents have failed to do. It may be that only a president who doesnt care about flouting the normal rules of conduct and policy would even contemplate something so radical, yet so important. In this case, a potential switch of U.S. policy on Jerusalem might constitute one of the best arguments that can be made for Trump not being as bad a president as his Twitter account might lead us to believe. Jonathan S. Tobin is edi tor-in-chief of and a contributor to National Re view. Follow him on Twitter at: @jonathans_tobin. example, his spiritual leader, MIT Muslim chaplain Suheil Laher, happened to run AlQaedas main fundraising base in the U.S. and was linked by the FBI to the 1993 World Trade Center bombing. The MIT Muslim chaplain openly called for jihad against nonMuslims on his MIT website, and under his influence, an other MIT graduate became Al-Qaedas most notorious female leader, at one point being the most wanted and dangerous woman in the world. Bostons Islamist lead ers consider her Lady AlQaeda, a hero. The three honored guests seemed to count on the igno rance of Temple Isaiahs Jews. Mazen unleashed a string of howlers. Of course, 0 percent of Muslims are doing violence in the Greater Boston area, he insisted. I would argue that 0 percent Muslims are doing violence in America at large. According to Mazen, It turns out that CAIR isnt Muslim Brotherhood. I mean the Muslim broth erhood doesnt really exist in this country, Mazen told the congregation. Theres no political Islam, he said. The falsity of such claims has been made clear by federal


PAGE 6A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 LIGHT SHABBAT CANDLES AT A COMPREHENSIVE COMMUNITY CALENDAR Whats Happening For inclusion in the Whats Happening Calendar, copy must be sent on sepa rate sheet and clearly marked for Calendar. Submit copy via: e-mail (news@; mail (P.O. Box 300742, Fern Park, FL 32730-0742); fax (407-831-0507); or drop it by the office (207 OBrien Rd., Ste. 101, Fern Park) Deadline is Wednesday noon, 10 days prior to publication. DEC. 15 5:12 p.m. DEC. 22 5:16 p.m. MAIL SUBSCRIPTION TO: Name ___________________________________________________ Address _________________________________________________ City/State/Zip _____________________________________________ Phone _________________________________ # ____________________________________________ expiration date __________________________________ Name _______________________________ Address _____________________________ ________________________ Phone _______________________________ YES! I want to be informed. Start my subscription at once. Please: enter extend my subscription for: 1 year at $37.95 52 issues 2 years at $69.95 104 issues 1 year out-of-state at $46.95 or 2 years out-of-state at $87.95 P.O. Box 300742 (407) 834-8787 Its inexcusable! My week is not complete without it! Im lost without it! I cant live without it! How in the world am I supposed to know whats going on? What are you missing out on?... Subscribe today! These are some of the comments we receive from readers when they miss an issue of Heritage Florida Jewish News Quote of the Week In the Jewish tradition, there is at the same time Jerusalem in the heavens and Jerusalem on the ground. Jerusalem is a living city, but also the heart, the soul of the Jewish people and the state of Israel. Yitzhak Rabin 1. Spritz 2. Gadots Wonder Woman wears one 3. Jeff Gordon or Alon Day, e.g. 4. New Eng. school 5. Rachels is believed to be by Bethlehem 6. Sushi fruit 7. Like Marzipan rugelach out of the oven 8. Tefillin hrs. 9. Divisions 10. Menzel with a great set of pipes 11. DeLuise in History of the World Part I 12. Poets palindromic prepo sition 13. Like a soup made in Genesis 18. The Great Dictator Oscar nominee Jack 22. Word before Brith or Yisrael 24. Unearth, in the City of David 26. Locale of a film Night mare: Abbr. 27. Golden age of Hollywood designer Lilly 28. Stare at 29. Rush rocker Geddy 31. Ziploc preservation prod uct 34. Adrien ___ skin care products 35. Hebrew leader 36. Mosby played by Josh Radnor in a sitcom 37. Its ___ country! 38. Kiplings Rikki-Tikki 41. Virus researched at He brew U 42. Yafeh 43. Warms 48. Ross of song 49. Emulate a jester 50. Violinist Yuval or sports writer Weitzman 52. Google competitor 53. Like the Three Stooges, perhaps 54. Called, at a bris 57. Tailors line 59. Levis Stadium sound 60. Hellenistic or Elizabethan 61. ___ love to spend the night in Zion (Rush) 62. Something to chew, to be kosher 63. ___mo (replay feature) See answers on page 14. Across 1. Move like Jagger 6. James Francos degree from Columbia U. 9. Hot or hard drink 14. Joels instrument 15. Koufaxs gift 16. Make like Jacob to Joseph 17. Mercy, Jewishly 19. Used a stopwatch 20. Unclean though we ___... (Numbers 9:7) 21. Freebies from Seasons or Winn Dixie 22. Funny Stiller 23. Place for a sukkah, for some 25. Job for Pinchas or Eli 30. Start of a famous Tevye song 32. Indochinese language 33. Isaacs final one was 180 34. With 41-Across, what the ends of 17, 25, 47, and 62-Across translate to 38. Those who remain ___ to G-d... Daniel 12:12 39. Executive Moonves 40. Words that follow How Will I Know (Whitney Hous ton) 41. See 34-Across 44. Elvis Presleys ___ Lost You 45. (Code of) Kiryas Joels is 10950 46. Ashdod to Hebron dir. 47. Real wild one, in Yiddish 51. ___ Hara 55. Simeon was full of it in the Bible 56. They may say Shalom 58. Gasteyer of Mean Girls 59. Amy Winehouse hit 62. What some mistakenly think Noah does at the end of Genesis chapter 9 64. Gladiator setting 65. Troop grp. The Marx Brothers performed for 66. Like Elijah when he wan dered the desert 67. ___ Nahash 68. Where Daniel prevailed 69. Bellowed, as a bovine Down Medium puzzle I Had a Little Dreidel by Yoni Glatt MORNING AND EVENING MINYANS (Call synagogue to confirm time.) Chabad of South OrlandoMonday Friday, 8 a.m. and 10 minutes before sunset; Saturday, 9:30 a.m.; Sunday, 8:15 a.m., 407-354-3660. Congregation Ahavas YisraelMonday Friday, 7:30 a.m.; Saturday, 9:30 a.m.; Sunday, 9 a.m., 407-644-2500. Congregation Chabad Lubavitch of Greater DaytonaMonday, 8 a.m.; Thursday, 8 a.m., 904672-9300. Congregation Ohev ShalomSunday, 9 a.m., 407-298-4650. GOBOR Community Minyan at Jewish Academy of OrlandoMondayFriday, 7:45 a.m.8:30 a.m. Temple IsraelSunday, 9 a.m., 407-647-3055. FRIDAY, DECEMBER 15 Fourth night of Chanukah Light fourth candle Ahavas YisraelKabbalat, 30 minutes before sundown. SUNDAY, DECEMBER 17 Sixth night of Chanukah Light the sixth candle Kehillah: A History of Jewish Life in Greater OrlandoOngoing exhibit at the Orange County Regional History Center, 65 E. Central Blvd., Orlando, and will continue through Feb. 20, 2018. Chanukah Community Festival and Menorah LightingHeld at Chabad of South Orlando, 7347 W. Sand Lake Rd., 4 p.m., activities and food, 5:30 p.m. World famous Wallendas perform on the high wire; 6 p.m. Grand menorah lighting; 6:15 p.m., live music and concert. Admission is free. Info, 407-354-3660 or visit Chanukah on the ParkJoin Orlando Chabad at Central Park, 251 S. Park Ave., Winter Park, from 46 p.m. Grand menorah lighting at 5:30 p.m. Open to the public, admission is free. Info: 407-644-2500 or visit JCC39ersCinema Sunday, 2 p.m. The movie The Accountant will be shown. Refreshments available. MONDAY, DECEMBER 18 Seventh night of Chanukah Light the seventh candle Israeli Folk Dancing 7:30-8:15 p.m. instruction, 8:15-10 p.m., requests. Cost: Free for JCC members, $5 nonmembers. Info: 407-645-5933. JCC 39ersMeet & Mingle Mondays, Chanukah party, 1 p.m. Refreshments. TUESDAY, DECEMBER 19 Eighth night of Chanukah Car Menorah ParadeChabad of South Orlando hosts starting at 6 p.m. at 7347 W. Sand Lake Rd., Finishes with Menorah lighting celebration at 5135 International Drive. RSVP www. Chanukah on IceChabad Centers of Metro Orlando host ice skating at the RDV Sportsplex Ice Den, 8701 Maitland Summit Blvd. 5:45-7 p.m. WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 20 Temple IsraelLunch & Learn with Rabbi Neely, noon1 p.m. A parashat discussion class. Open to the public, no RSVP needed. Info: 407-647-3055. A Nosh of YiddishClasses in Yiddish the third Wednesday of each month led by Joan Pohl and sponsored by the Jewish Pavilion, held at Oakmonte Village, Royal Gardens Cir., Lake Mary (Valencia Building), 1 p.m. Info: 407-678-9363. Coffee and refreshments served. The Roth Family JCCLunch and Learn, 12:30 -1:30 p.m. RSVP requested to register@ Cost: $5, free for JCC members. THURSDAY DECEMBER 21 A Nosh of YiddishClasses in Yiddish the third Thursday of each month led by Elliot Davis and sponsored by the Jewish Pavilion, held at Brookdale Island Lake, 160 Islander Circle in Longwood 10:30 a.m. Info: 407-678-9363. Coffee and refreshments served. FRIDAY, DECEMBER 22 Ahavas YisraelKabbalat, 30 minutes before sundown. Correction In the From the Editors Desk column of Dec. 8, while clarifying the truth about Haym Solomon, the topic of Murray Toborowskys talk on Feb. 25, 2018 was incor rect (see last paragraph). Toborowsky will be talking on What affect the Hebrew Bible had on the early Puritans and our founding fathers, and how did Hebrew come to Yale and Harvard.


HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 PAGE 7A rf rntbn rrrn rfrntbr r By Marilyn Shapiro Larry and I have many pets in our home. A but terfly rests outside our front door, and two larger ones fly on our lanai wall. A two-foot bear clutching his Bear Feet Only sign greets visitors on the front porch. Pedro the Parrot hangs on a curtain rod. And various bulldogsstuffed, ceramic, and metal, are stationed around the house in honor of the nickname my boss gave me when I moved from the classroom to an administra tive office. However, I would have to say my favorite animals in our menagerie are three turtles and a pelican. These metal copper sculptures are the creative work of a talented Albuquerque, New Mexico, artist who made last years Chanukah very special. In July 2015, Larry and I were spending the summer in Frisco, Colorado, with our daughter Julie, her husband Sam, and their newborn daughter, Sylvie Rose. We had arrived in the Rocky Mountains less than a month after we had moved into our new home in Florida. We had brought several pieces of art for our walls, but many other spaces were empty by choice. We knew that much of the art work that was on the walls from our Upstate New York homereflective of the Adirondack Mountains fall scenes, Early American ac centswould not work in Florida. One area that was tricky for us to decorate was a shadow box effect in the liv ing room. We needed to find something to fill a recessed space in a hallway that would reflect our now Southern address. In August, we were at an art show in downtown Frisco when we noticed some colorful, unique pieces in copper. Many of the ob jects were reflective of the Southwest: lizards, snakes, kokopellli. We introduced ourselves to Greg Gowen, the artist manning the outdoor booth. Greg, a native of Texas, was born in 1968 and began welding at age eight under the guidance of his father and mother, Mike and Mar tha Gowen, both well known artists and gallery owners. My daddy showed me how to sculpt, he wrote on his webpage, and my mother taught me to make it beau tiful. At the age of 18 Greg turned to the art world for his career. He began partici pating in art shows around the Southwest. Galleries quickly became aware of his talent and began exhib iting and selling his work. Today, Gregs sculptures are displayed in private collec tions, galleries, and muse ums throughout the United States and abroad. We were lucky to happen upon his beautiful copper sculptures. We were especially attracted to his turtle design. After we emailed the di Connecting through the gift of generousity Peter the Pelican who grac es the Shapiros bathroom. The family of turtles in the Shapiros shadow box. read, Honestly now. Whats Your Hurry? Youre here! The second was a colorful road sign showing the mile age to Boston, New York City, and San Francisco. What was missing was a piece for our guest bath room. I was the butterfly lover and bulldog-moniker nickname bearer of the fam ily, but Larry loved pelicans. I knew from his website that Greg had not done pelicans before. In May 2016, I con tacted Greg via email to see if he could work his magic in creating a version of Larrys favorite bird to hang over the toilet. Greg responded a couple of days later with his answer. Yes, he would love to create the figure. As I had already missed the deadline for Larrys May birthday, he promised to have completed by Chanukah. Greg and I were in touch over the summer. In late October, however, I realized I hadnt heard from him, nor had any pelicans flown our way via UPS. When he failed to respond to an email, I sent him one more. If he couldnt get it to us in time for Chanukah, I understood. Id give it to Larry for his May birthday. On Dec. 24, Greg emailed me his apologies. He wanted to surprise Larry and me with the pelican in time for Christmas but mailed it to the wrong address. He felt terrible as it wont be under our Christmas tree. I wrote him back imme diately with the good news that we were Jewish. Dec. 24 was not only Christmas Eve, but also the first night of Chanukah. Getting it on the third or fourth day of our holiday would be fine. True to his word, the pelican arrived on the fol lowing Tuesday. Peter the Pelican fits perfectly in our bathroom, I wrote. Larry and I are very happy with the newest member of our menagerie. How much do I owe you? Nothing, Greg wrote back. I was late in getting it to you. It is my gift for the aggravation I caused. Larry and I were grateful for Gregs generous offer, but we couldnt accept. I wrote him a note thanking him but telling him we were very aware of the time he had taken to design and craft our pelican and ship Peter to his new home. I enclosed a check for $180. The number 18 has special significance in Judaism, I told Greg. It signifies life. Use the money to do something special for you or your grandchildren. A couple of months later, Greg emailed me to tell me that he had used our money to treat himself, his wife Debbie, and Martha and Del Pettigrew, two fellow artists, to dinner at a lovely restaurant in Scottsdale, Arizona. The four of them raised their wine glasses in a toast to the Shapiros. I love creating metal works for patrons like you! wrote Greg in his thank you. May God richly bless you. mensions of the shadowbox when we returned home, Greg suggested we purchase three turtles, a mother and two babies, to fill the space. The family of turtles ar rived as ordered within the next few weeks. The colors, the size, the way they fit into the space were perfect. We named them Mother Turtle Tessie and her two children Tommy and Tillie, and posted a picture on Facebook an nouncing their arrival. The three turtles were a conver sation piece when we showed people our new home. It was time to fill more walls. We found a photo of a beach scene mounted on wood that fit over our couch. We added a palm tree clock to the laundry room and a fish clock onto the lanai. In Key West, we found two signs for our guest bedroom: One I was happy to learn that our gift to him had created wonderful memories with his friendsmemories that were more poignant when Del passed away a few months later. That special dinner was the last time they saw their dear friend. What a profound effect your generosity has had, Greg wrote recently. I will never forget! Greg continues to sculpt, drawing inspira tion from all over. He carries around a sketchpad in case something sparks an idea. My favorite part of my art is when I see a customer connect with a piece, he wrote on an other art gallery website. And through his turtles, his pelican, and mutual generosity, we have con nected with Greg.


PAGE 8A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 Nancy Ludin with Pearl Schiffer. The people we assist through our organization are not. We are The Jewish Pavilion of Central Florida. The Jewish Pavilion is, perhaps, one of the least known of the Jewish orga nizations in the area, but our services are among the most valuable. We are very often the lifeline to the world of their Jewish heritage and culture for those in skilled nursing facilities, independent and as sisted living facilities. For our elders, we are the heartbeat of the Jewish Community of Central Florida. Serving over 70 of the areas senior care facilities, we bring Yiddishkite to their Jewish residents through our Out reach efforts including our one-on-one companionship program, Shabbat and holiday festivities, Yiddish classes, pet visits, memorial services and grief support. The Jewish Pavilion has a dedicated staff and group of volunteers who share the care. Care. We visit residents so that they know they have not been abandoned by the Jewish community. When it is difficult for family or friends to visit, or when there is no family at all, a visit from one of our volunteers can bring comfort and companionship; a caring hand and someone to talk to who understands their heritage. Nancy Ludin Executive Director, Jewish Pavilion of Central Florida We are invisible... By Penny Schwartz BOSTON (JTA)Move over, potato latkes. Make room for dosas. The savory fried Indian lentil and rice pancakes take center stage in Queen of the Dosas, a gem of a new Chanukah book by the award-winning childrens writer Pamela Ehrenberg. Its among eight new Chanukah books for kids one for each night of the holidaysure to kindle the flames of imagination in young readers. The bounty of this seasons books travel the globe, from city life to wooded forests, with engagingand many humorousstories and dazzling illustrations that reflect the diversity in how Jewish families celebrate the popular holiday. Old World traditions mix it up with new rituals taking root in todays modern American Jewish families. These new reads showcase the many ways Jewish fami lies from all walks of life cel ebrate the Festival of Lights, which this year begins on the evening of Dec. 12. Way Too Many Latkes: A Chanukah in Chelm Linda Glaser; illustrated by Aleksandar Zolotic Kar-Ben; ages 3-8 Oy vey! Its the first night of Chanukah and Faigel, the best latke maker in the village of Chelm, forgot the recipe for her mouthwatering, sizzling potato pancakes, the traditional fried food eaten during the holidays celebrations. Her husband, Shmuel, races over to the village rabbi for advice. But what does the rabbi know about making latkes? This ticklishly fun adven ture, set in the fictional Old World town of Chelm, the source of enduring Jewish storytelling, will have kids laughing as they wonder how Faigel and Shmuel solve their problem. Aleksandar Zolotics large format, ani mation-style illustrations are perfectly paired for the lively story, which echoes the clas sic Strega Nona stories by Tomie dePaola about magical pots of pasta. Little Red Ruthie: A Chanukah Tale Gloria Koster; illustrated by Sue Eastland Albert Whitman; ages 4-8 This uplifting spin on Lit tle Red Riding Hood features a spirited young girl named Ruthie setting off on the eve of Chanukah to visit her bub be, Yiddish for grandmother, so they can cook up potato latkes for the holiday. In the snow-packed forest Ruthie, bundled up in a bright red hooded parka, meets a not overly menacing-looking wolf. Ruthie summons her courage and smarts as she recalls the brave Maccabee heroes of Chanukah who fought for religious freedom for the Jews in ancient Israel. But will Ruthies clever schemes outsmart the hun gry but foolish wolf, who has fun dressing up in bubbes Here are eight new childrens books for Chanukah and playful animation-like il lustrations match the storys spirited humor. Books for toddlers: The Itsy Bitsy Dreidel Jeffrey Burton and Chani Tornow; illustrated by Sanja Rescek Simon and Schuster; ages 2-4 A delightful read-aloud board book for the young est kids who will enjoy the playful rhymes as the lively little dreidel celebrates Cha nukah. This is the latest in the upbeat Itsy Bitsy board book series that includes the Itsy Bitsy Pilgrim, the Itsy Bitsy Snowman, and others. Grovers Eight Nights of Light Jodie Shepherd; illustrated by Joe Mathieu Random House for Young Readers; ages 2-5 Young fans of Sesame Street enjoy a Chanukah party at Grovers house along with their favorite Sesame Street characters. The book features lighting the menorah, eating latkes and playing dreidel. Stickers, Chanukah cards and a poster with a Chanukah party game are included. And a book for teens: Spies & Scholars Yehudis Litvak Jewish Childrens Book Club; grades 7-8 Spies and Scholars is the latest entry in the Chanukah -themed seriesthe first was Swords and Scrolls. The historical fiction adventure is set during the reign of the Greek King Antiochus in an cient Israel where the Macca bees are fighting the Greeks. The 200-page teen read is geared to Orthodox Jewish teen readers and published by Jewish Childrens Book Club in conjunction with Torah Umesorah-National Society for Hebrew Day Schools. double-page spread that is like a puzzle; kids can follow clues to find where the gimels have been hidden. Chanukah Harvie vs. Santa Claus: The Christmukkah Kerfuffle David Michael Slater; il lustrated by Michelle Simp son Library Tales Publishing; ages 5-8 On the first night of Cha nukah, Chanukah Harvie oils up his steam punk-like machinery to produce all the gifts he needs and climbs aboard his flying Hanukkop ter to deliver eight nights of presents to children. Placing one familys presents next to their Chanukah menorah, Harvie bumps into a redsuited jolly Santa Claus piling gifts under their Christmas tree. Harvey and Santa go on to discover some other homes with both menorahs and Christmas trees and get into a rollicking presentgiving competition, out to prove that their holiday is the best. A young girl who spies them in action puts the quarreling pair to shame, and lets them in on the joy of celebrating the two holi days happening at about the same time each yearthus the Christmukkah mashup. Michelle Simpsons colorful colorful clothing? This is a perfect read-aloud for Chanukah nights, and Sue Eastlands bright and humor ous illustrations bring the warmhearted story to life. Queen of the Chanukah Dosas Pamela Ehrenberg; illus trated by Anjar Sarkar Far rar Straus Giroux; ages 4-7 In this humor-filled tale, an endearing school-age boy in a multicultural IndianJewish family can hardly con tain his enthusiasm for his familys special Chanukah celebration of making dosas, Indian fried pancakes made with lentils, called dal, and rice. But his younger sister, Sadie, who cant resist her urge to climb on everything, may spoil the fun. Anjar Sarkars colorful, cartoon-like illustrations add giggles and put readers in on the action. The end pages are embellished with illustra tions of Indian groceries, chutneys and spices that will tempt the family food ies. Recipes for Dosas and Sambar, a vegetable-based filling or dip for the dosas, are included. The Missing Letters: A Dreidel Story Renee Londner; illustrated by Iryna Bodnaruk Kar-Ben; ages 4-9 Wooden dreidels come to life in this heartwarming page-turner. On the eve of Chanukah, in a dreidel makers shop, there are some bad feelings among the He brew letters painted on the four-sided spinning toy. The nun, hey and shin are jealous of the gimel, considered the favorite letter in the game of chance, and decide to hide all of them. But later they overhear the dreidel maker explain that all the letters play a special role in celebrat ing Chanukah, a holiday of religious freedom. Among Iryna Bodnaruks animated illustrations is a Before It Gets Cold! Call For Preventative Maintenance On Your Heating System Today Service All Major Brands Also Free Estimate On New Energy Saving Heat Pumps and Airconditioning Systems 407-331-4375 At Westchester of Winter Park, a premier Assisted Living Community providing customized care and services in a palatial environment in Winter Park, Florida. Licensed nursing staff is in the building 24 hours each day. Multiple room options at affordable room rates and care level fees. Many services are included in the room rate. The Community entrance fee is $500. Join us for Shabbat every Friday and stay for a tour of our community. Please contact our Community Liaison for further information.


HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 PAGE 9A can be purchased at the following locations: Scene Around Scene Around By Gloria YoushaCall 407-657-9405 or ORANGE COUNTY JCC 851 N. Maitland Ave., Maitland JCC South 11184 South Apopka-Vineland Rd., Orlando Kinneret 515 South Delaney Ave., Orlando SOJC 11200 S. Apopka Vineland Rd., Orlando Browns New York Deli 156 Lake Ave., Maitland Most Publix Supermarkets All Winn Dixie Supermarkets SEMINOLE COUNTY Heritage News 207 OBrien Rd., Fern Park Barnes and Noble Booksellers 451 E. Altamonte Dr. Suite 2317, Altamonte Springs & 1260 Oviedo Marketplace Blvd., Oviedo Bagel King 1472 Semoran Blvd., Casselberry Kosher Kats 744 W. S.R. 434, Longwood Central Florida Hillel 4250 Alafaya Trail, Ste. 212-363, Oviedo Most Publix Supermarkets All Winn Dixie Supermarkets VOLUSIA COUNTY Federation of Volusia/Flagler 470 Andalusia Ave., Ormond Beach Most Publix Supermarkets All Winn Dixie Supermar kets Barnes & Noble 1900 W. International Speedway Blvd., Daytona Beach Perrys Ocean Edge Resort 2209 South Atlantic Ave. Daytona Beach Debary City Hall Debary Library Vienna Coffee House 275 Charles Richard Beall Bl Starbucks 2575 Enterprise Rd Orange City City Hall Orange City Library Dunkin Donuts 1296 S Woodland Stetson University Carlton Union Deland Chamber of Commerce Sterling House 1210 Stone St Temple Israel 1001 E New York Ave Beth Shalom 1310 Maximillan St Deltona City Hall Deltona Library Temple Shalom 1785 Elkam Dr. Temple Israel 1001 E New York Ave, Deland College Arms Apt 101 Amelia Ave, Deland Boston Gourmet Coffee House 109 E. New York Ave, Deland Stetson University Carlton Union 421 N Woodland Ave, Deland Family Bookstore 1301 N Woodland Ave, Deland Deland Chamber of Commerce 336 Woodland Ave, Deland Deland City Hall 120 S Florida Ave, Deland Beth Shalom 206 S. Sprng Garden Ave, Deland Orange City Library 148 Albertus Way, Orange City Boston Gourmet Coffee House 1105 Saxon Blvd, Deltona Deltona Library 2150 Eustace Ave, Deltona Temple Shalom 1785 Elkam Dr., Deltona Deltona Community Center, 980 Lakeshore Dr, Deltona Debary City Hall 16 Colomba Rd, Debary Debary Library 200 Florence K. Little, Debary OSCEOLA COUNTY Cindy M. Rothfield, P.A. 822 W. Bryan St., Kissimmee Most Publix Supermarkets Verandah Place Realty 504 Celebration Ave., Celebration All Winn Dixie Supermarkets St. Cloud City Hall 1300 9th St, St. Cloud St. Cloud Library 810 13th St, St. Cloud Southern Oaks 3865 Old Canoe Creek Rd, St. Cloud Plantation Bay 4641 Old Canoe Creek Rd, St. Cloud Osceola Chamber of Commerce 1425 Hwy 192, St. Cloud Valencia College 1800 Denn John Ln, Kissimmee Kissimmee City Hall 101 Church St, Kissimmee Kissimmee Library 211 E. Dakin, Kissimmee Robinsons Coffee Shop 114 Broadway, Kissimmee Osceola County Courthouse 2 Courthouse Sq, Kissimmee Barnies 3236 John Young Pwy, Kissimmee Reilys Gourmet Coffee 3831 Vine St, Kissimmee Shalom Aleichem 3501 Oak Pointe Blvd, Kissimmee Books-A-Million 2605 W. Osceola Pwy (522), Kissimmee Lower East Side Deli 8548 Palm Parkway, Lake Buena Sudoku (see page 14 for solution) Israel does it again... When it comes to science and technology, Israel is leading the field! I read this recently in the World Jewish Congress digest and pass it along: As highlighted in NoCamels, (the leading news website covering the startup nation, with a focus on Israel innovation in technology, science, design, medicine and cyber) more than 23 million people worldwide suffer from diastolic heart failure, a condition in which the heart fails to pump sufficient oxygen ated blood to meet the bodys needs. Scientists have long been looking for an effective treatment for this condition. A unique device developed by Israeli company CorAssist offers new hope. CORolla, an elastic device that is implanted inside the left ventricle of the heart by a minimally invasive procedure on a beating heart, can improve cardiac diastolic function by applying direct expansion force on the ventricle wall to help the heart fill with blood. Heart failure symptoms include shortness of breath, tired ness, swollen legs and limited ability to exercise or perform simple physical tasks. The prognosis of heart failure is poor; more than 40 percent of heart failure patients die within five years of diagnosis. Approximately half of heart failure patients suffer from diastolic heart failure. The incidence of diastolic heart failure increases with age, and is common among women with hypertension, obesity and diabetes. (Oy vay! I have diabetes!!) We lost a fabulous musi cian... We also lost a fabulous, kind human being. Im referring to Syl LaFata, the very best clari net player I have ever worked with. He was on a par with the great Benny Goodman. (Some even said that Syl resembled Benny.) The last time Syl performed with me was on Oct. 4, 2015, along with MICHAEL and BEN KRAMER and EDDIE VAZZ at Congregation Ohev Shalom. He will be sorely missed. On the subject of fabu lous musicians... I just came from a C.O.S. Seniors meeting at the syna gogue. The entertainment was supplied by SCOTT BERRY on keyboard and vocals. He performed the music of George Gershwin and others. (Gershwin... it just doesnt get better than that!) Everyone who attended loved Scotts performance. I could hear them kvelling as they were leaving. Hopefully Scott will return soon. (I especially love my cookies that are part of the refresh ments at Ohev after the show. Thanks to DAVID MOLDAU, I always get my favorites! David gets to them before they are gone and whats more, THEY DONT HAVE ANY CALORIES!) 39ers Cinema Sundays... On Sunday, Dec. 17th, the movie in the senior lounge will be The Accountant starring BEN AFFLECK. Refreshments are available. Syl LaFata Ben Affleck And more 39ers... On Meet & Mingle Monday, Dec. 18th, a Chanukah party will take place at the Maitland JCC. Come! Smile! Rejoice! Shout Out... Have you ever shopped at Aldi? I have many times, especially because the prices are right. But most of all, because of an absolute sweetheart who works there. Her name is JAHLIL BEYMUHAMMED. She is kind, patient and truly a doll! And she is a great worker!! One for the road... Moishe was sitting at the breakfast table one Sunday morn ing reading the News of the World. He had just read an article about a beautiful film star who had announced that she was going to marry a football player who was famous not only for his aggression on and off the field, but also for his lack of IQ and common sense. In fact he was thick as two planks. Like many men, Moishe loved hearing his own voice and liked to report aloud stories he read from the paper. So he turned to his wife Sadie and said, Ill never understand why the biggest schmucks get the most attractive wives. Sadie replied, Why thank you, darling! By Ben Sales NEW YORK (JTA)When Chris Doeblin agreed to buy 100 copies of a childrens book to help an author friend, he didnt expect to become enmeshed in a controversy over international relations and free speech. But thats what happened after Doeblin, the co-owner of Book Culture, a chain of independent bookstores in New York City, purchased and held a reading of P is for Palestine, which came out last month. Written by Golbarg Bashi, an Iranianborn author who has held Persian-language readings of childrens books at Book Culture for three years, it is subtitled A Palestine ABC Book. The bookstore chain also donated $650 to a crowd funding campaign for P is for Palestine. But that angered another partner of Book Cultures: the Stephen Wise Free Syna gogue. This week, Book Cul ture is set to provide books and toys for a book fair at the large Reform congregation in Man hattan. But after discovering the bookstores work with Bashi, the synagogue threat ened to pull out, charging that the book especially a page on intifadaglorifies violence against Israelis. In the end, the synagogue withdrew the threat, but not before putting an indepen dent bookstore chain in the unusual position of having to make a string of statements on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict -including support ing Israels right to exist and opposing the boycott move ment against it. So many people were incensed and took offense and were hurt by this books publication, Doeblin told JTA. I can honestly say Im sorry. As we try and reach out to people, we have to do it with enough respect so that we dont hurt and cause these violent reactions. This is just the latest ripple effect of controversy that has surrounded P is for Pales tine since it was published on Nov. 11. The picture book dedicates pages to each letter of the alphabet, along with a corresponding wordA is for Arabic, for example. The main reason for the conflict wasnt the books title or conceptrather it was the two-page spread featuring the letter I, which states I is for Intifada, Intifada is Arabic for How a kids book on Palestine ensnared Manhattan store in a political crossfire rising up for what is right, if you are a kid or a grownup! The accompanying illustra tion shows a father and child waving peace signs next to barbed wire. The synagogue, along with plenty of other critics, charged that the book ob scured the violent nature of the two Palestinian intifadas, or uprisings, which occurred over a span of years in the late 1980s and again in the early 2000s. More than 1,000 Israe lis died in attacks perpetrated by Palestinian terror groups that targeted civilians. Thou sands of Palestinians died in clashes with Israeli security forces. Of particular concern to me is the glorification of the Palestinian intifadaa cruel, murderous and terroristic campaign that purposely Book on page 15A


PAGE 10A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 The sfinj hails from North Africa. and coated in sugar, usually of the powdered variety. Israelis of North African descent prepare sfinjim for holidays and special occa sions. Dan Illouz grew up in Montreal, where his family ate the doughnuts during the eight nights of Chanu kah. When he immigrated to Israel eight years ago, he was dismayed that he could only find sufganiyot, so he began making sfinjim in his kitchen to celebrate the holiday. During Chanukah in 2010, Illouz, 31, who lives and does public relations in Jerusalem, invited a handful of friends over to enjoy the doughnuts with him. Word spread quickly: Last year, about 400 people showed up at his three-bedroom apart ment for what has become an annual sfinge party (as he spells it) Illouz expects at least as large a crowd for the third night of this Cha nukah, Dec. 14. To feed the masses that show up throughout the night and spill into the street, Illouz begins pre paring at around 7 a.m., 12 hours ahead of time. He estimated that he fries up about 150 of the doughnuts. Its first come, first serve. Illouz puts on Moroccan music, and when the sun sets, he and his guests light the menorah candles. While sfinj are of course at the cen ter of the celebration, Illouz also serves sweet couscous and store-bought Moroc can cookies and beverages. Needless to say, sufganiyot, plural for sufganiyah, are not on the menu. Im not ideologically opposed to sufganiyot, he explained, but I do prefer sfinjim. Theyre just simpler, and theyre not quite as unhealthy. Illouz said his sfinj party is an expression of both Moroccan and Israeli pride, a duality that has become easier to reconcile in recent years. While Mizrahi Jews, or those with roots in North Africa and the Middle East, were long a socioeconomic underclass that faced sys temic discrimination in Is rael, their culture has lately experienced something of a renaissance. Illouz said the new hipness of Moroccan traditions is probably part of what draws so many people to his sfinj parties. Theres definitely an ele ment of that in the fact that people get excited about the party. People want to have a taste of this culture, he said. What I think is really beautiful is that all Israelis are able to enjoy it. About half of Israelis are now of Mizrahi descent, though the numbers are becoming blurred by mar riage with Asheknazi, or European Jews, and others. Mizrahi music dominates the Israeli airwaves, with some musicians even singing in Arabic. Mizrahi cuisine is not only popular street food, but is also celebrated at high-end restaurants and on popular cooking TV shows. And Mizrahi celebrations, like the post-Passover Mi mouna feast and the henna pre-wedding bridal shower, have been embraced by the mainstream. Of course, Mizrahi Jews have been contributing to Israeli culture for decades, whether or not it was always appreciated. Some credit them with bringing the tra dition of Chanukah dough nuts to the Jews of Palestine in the first place. According to this theory, sfinjim were then largely superseded by deep-fried Eastern European jelly doughnuts similar to todays sufganiyot. (The oil is a nod to the Chanukah legend in which the ancient Temples menorah stayed lit for eight days on a oneday supply of lamp oil.) The Arabic word sfinj, mean ing sponge, was replaced by sufganiyah, a Hebrew word sharing the same root. Some Ashkenazi Jews have also started making sfinjim at home, often inspired by Mizrahi friends and family. Uri Scheft, a co-owner and chef at the high-end bakery chain Lehamim, learned to make the doughnuts from his wife, whose mother immigrated to Israel from Sufganiyot get all the hypebut this humble Moroccan doughnut is Israels Chanukah staple Morocco. He included a sfinj recipe in his 2016 cookbook Breaking Breads: A New World of Israeli Baking, which celebrates the cuisines produced by the melting pot of Israeli society. Scheft said he has planned for many years to serve sfin jim at his bakeries. But he would first want to set up a prep area so he could serve them fresh to customers. The character and the structure of sfinjim is very light, which make them very tasty, but only if they are eaten right away, he said. I think this is why bakeries shy away from serving them. While it is hard to find a hot sfinj for sale in Israel, it is not impossible. Keren Kadosh, a pastry chef with a Moroccan back ground, occasionally serves them at her bustling down town Jerusalem bakery, Caf Kadoshoften in response to requests. At the same time, her lifetime of eating the doughnuts has shaped the way her bakery prepares sufganiyot, which it serves at a rate of a 1,000 a day during Chanukah. When the sufganiyot come out of the fryer, we role it in sugar, and we get that exact same crunch, sweetness and texture, she explained. So in a way, were participating in the Moroc can culture of blessing each other, which has also become Israeli culture. By Andrew Tobin TEL AVIV (JTA)The sufganiyah is the plump, shining star of Chanukah in Israel. During the holiday season, the famed jelly doughnut poses in the windows of ca fs and bakeries across the country. It sparkles with oil and sugar, and shows just enough filling to keep fans interested. Every year, top chefs compete to give the suf ganiyah an edgy new twist, whether its cheesecake fill ing, mascarpone topping or a chocolate-filled squeeze tube accessory. Israeli TV channels, newspapers and social media are filled with close-up shots and reviews of the most enticing inno vations. Meanwhile, in homes across the country, Israelis quietly fry up a humbler doughnut called the sfinj. The confection hails from North Africa, and is a favor ite of Jews whose families came to Israel from the region. But even European Jews have adopted the sfinj and helped push it toward the limelight. Part of the appeal of sfin jim, the plural for sfinj, is that they are easy to make. Simply take a dollop of dough, poke a hole in the middle and deep fry in veg etable oil. The doughnuts can then be dipped in honey Beth Shalom Memorial ChapelProudly Serving Our Community For Over 35 YearsLdor vdor ... From Generation to Generation Traditional Jewish Funerals Non-Traditional Services Interstate Shipping Pre-Arranged Funerals Shalom Assurance Plan Headstones, Grave Markers407-599-1180 W.E. Manny Adams, LFD Samuel P. (Sammy) Goldstein, Exec. Food and monetary donations will be collected for the Jerry Doliner food bank.


HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 PAGE 11A OBITUARIES Orlando Weekday Morning Minyan (Conservative/Egalitarian ), services MondayFriday 7:45 a.m. (9 a.m.national holidays); 2nd floor ChapelJewish Academy of Orlando; 851 N. Maitland Ave., Maitland. For information call 407-298-4650. Celebration Jewish Congregation (R) services and holiday schedules shown at www. ; 407-566-9792. Chabad Lubavitch of North Orlando (O) 1701 Markham Woods Road, Longwood, 407-636-5994,; services: Friday 7:00 p.m.; Saturday at 9:30 a.m. Chabad of Altamonte Springs (O) 414 Spring Valley Lane, Altamonte Springs, 407280-0535; Chabad of South Orlando (O) 7347 Sand Lake Road, Orlando, 407-354-3660; www. ; Shabbat services: Monday-Friday, 8 a.m. and 10 minutes before sunset; Saturday, 9:30 a.m.; Sunday, 8:15 a.m. Chabad of the Space & Treasure Coasts (O) 1190 Highway A1A, Satellite Beach, 321-777-2770. Congregation Ahavas Yisrael/Chabad (O) 708 Lake Howell Rd., Maitland, 407-6442500; ; services: Sunday, 9 a.m.; Monday-Friday, 7:30 a.m.; Shabbat services: Friday, 6:30 p.m.; Saturday, 9:30 a.m.; Family service, 4th Friday of the month. Congregation Bet Chaim (R) 301 West State Road 434, Unit 319, Winter Springs, 407-830-7211; ; Shabbat services: Friday, 8 p.m. Congregation Beth Am (C) 3899 Sand Lake Road, Longwood, 407-862-3505; www. ; Shabbat services: Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, 9:30 a.m. Congregation Beth El (C) 2185 Meadowlane Ave., West Melbourne, 321-779-0740; Shabbat services, 1st & 3rd Friday, 8 p.m.; 2nd & 4th Saturdays, 9:30 a.m. Congregation Beth Emeth (R) 2205 Blue Sapphire Circle, Orlando, 407-222-6393; Shabbat service: monthly, 8 p.m. Congregation Beth Israel (Rec) Collins Resource Center, Suite 303, 9401 S.R. 200, Ocala, 352-237-8277;; Shabbat service, second Friday of the month, 8 p.m. Congregation Beth Sholom (R-C) 315 North 13th St., Leesburg, 352-326-3692; www. ; schedule of services on website. Congregation Beth Shalom (Progressive Conservative) Orange City congregation holds services at 1308 E. Normandy Blvd., Deltona; 386-804-8283; www.mybethshalom. com ; Shabbat services: Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, 10 a.m. Congregation Bnai Torah (C) 403 N. Nova Rd., Ormond Beach, 32174, 386-672-1174; ; Shabbat services: Friday, 8 p.m.; Saturday, 10 a.m. Congregation Chabad Lubavitch of Greater Daytona (O) 1079 W. Granada Blvd., Ormond Beach, 386-672-9300; Shabbat services Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, 10 a.m. Congregation of Reform Judaism (R) 928 Malone Dr., Orlando, 407-645-0444; : Shabbat services, 7 p.m. 1st, 2nd and 3rd Fridays; 6 p.m., 4th and 5th Fridays; Saturday: 10 a.m. Congregation Mateh Chaim (R) P.O. Box 060847, Palm Bay, 32906, 321-768-6722. Congregation Ohev Shalom (C) 613 Concourse Parkway South, Maitland, 407-2984650; ; Shabbat service, Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, 9:30 a.m. Congregation Or Chayim (Rec) Leesburg, 352-326-8745;; services 2nd and 4th Fridays of each month at Providence Independence of Wildwood. Congregation Shalom Aleichem (R) 3501 Oak Pointe Blvd., Kissimmee, 407-9350064; ; Shabbat service, 1st and 3rd Fridays of the month, 8 p.m. Congregation Shomer Ysrael (C) 5382 Hoffner Ave., Orlando, 407-227-1258, call for services and holiday schedules. Congregation Sinai (C/R) 303A N. S.R. 27, Minneola; 352-243-5353;; services: every Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Shabbat Service evert Saturday, 10 a.m. Orlando Torah Center (O) 8591 Banyan Blvd., Orlando; 347-456-6485; ShacharisShabbos 9 a.m.; Mon.Thurs. 6:45 a.m.; Sun. and Legal Holidays 8 a.m.; Mincha/Maariv Please call for times. Southwest Orlando Jewish Congregation/Ohalei Rivka (C) 11200 S. ApopkaVineland Rd., Orlando, 407-239-5444; Shabbat service, Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, 9:30 a.m. Temple Beth El (R) 579 N. Nova Rd., Ormond Beach, 386-677-2484. Temple Beth Shalom (R), P.O. Box 031233, Winter Haven, 813-324-2882. Temple Beth Shalom (C) 40 Wellington Drive, Palm Coast, 386-445-3006; Shabbat service, Friday, 8 p.m.; Saturday, 9 a.m. Temple Beth Sholom (C) 5995 N. Wickham Rd. Melbourne, 321-254-6333; www. ; Shabbat services: Friday, 7 p.m.; Saturday: 9:30 a.m. Minyan, Tuesday, 7:30 p.m.; Thursday, 10:00 a.m. Temple Beth Shalom (R) 1109 N.E. 8th Ave., Ocala, 352-629-3587; Shabbat services: Friday, 8 p.m.; Torah study: Saturday, 10:00 a.m. Temple Bnai Darom (R), 49 Banyan Course, Ocala, 352-624-0380; Friday Services 8 p.m. Temple Israel (C) 50 S. Moss Rd., Winter Springs, 407-647-3055; ; Shabbat services: Friday, 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, 9:30 a.m.; Sunday 9:00 a.m. Temple Israel (R), 7350 Lake Andrew Drive, Melbourne, 321-631-9494. Temple Israel (C) 579 N. Nova Road, Ormond Beach, 386-252-3097; Shabbat service, Friday, 7 p.m.; Saturday: 10:30 a.m. Temple Israel of DeLand (R) 1001 E. New York Ave., DeLand, 386-736-1646; www.; Friday Shabbat service, 7 p.m.; Saturday, 10:00 a.m. followed by Torah study. Temple Shalom (formerly New Jewish Congregation) (R) 13563 Country Road 101, Oxford, 352-748-1800; ; Shabbat services: Friday, 7 p.m.; last Saturday of the month, 9:30 a.m. Temple Shalom of Deltona (R/C) 1785 Elkcam Blvd., Deltona, 386-789-2202; www.; Shabbat service; Saturday: 10 a.m. Temple Shir Shalom (R) Services held at Temple Israel, 50 S. Moss Rd., Winter Springs, 407-366-3556, ; Shabbat services: three Fridays each month, 7:30 p.m. Traditional Congregation of Mount Dora (T) Mount Dora, 352-735-4774; www.; Shabbat services: Saturday, 9:30 a.m. sharp. (R) Reform (C) Conservative (O) Orthodox (Rec) Reconstructionist (T) Mehitsa Washington, N.Y. She is also survived by her grandchil dren, Hunter, Juliette, Ben, Brian and Jessica; and her brother, Kenneth (Charlotte) of Naples, Fla. A funeral service was held at Beth Shalom Memorial Chapel with Rabbi David Kay of Congregation Ohev Shalom officiating. Interment took place at Beth David Cemetery in Elmont, N.Y. In memory of Maxine L. Hayt, the family requests contributions to the New Museum, 235 Bowery, New York, N.Y. 10002 or the North Shore Animal League America, 25 Davis Avenue, Port Washington, N.Y. 11050. Arrangements entrusted to Beth Shalom Memorial Cha pel, 640 Lee Road, Orlando, 32810. 407-599-1180. ALAN BRUCE MOGUL Alan B. Mogul, age 62, of Maitland, passed away on Sat urday, Dec. 2, 2017, at Winter Park Memorial Hospital. He was born on Sept. 13, 1955, in Boston, Mass., to Max and Ruth Mogul. In 1959, the family relo cated to the Orlando area and joined Congregation Ohev Shalom. Alan attended school in Orlando and received his bachelors degree from UCF. He worked in the banking industry. Alan is survived by his par ents, Max and Ruth Mogul of Maitland; his daughter, Alexis; and his sisters, Janet (Tracy) King of Orlando and Lynda Mogul of Winter Park. He is also survived by his nephews, Miles and Jason. A memorial service was held at Beth Shalom Memorial Chapel with Rabbi David Kay of Congregation Ohev Shalom officiating. In memory of Alan Bruce Mogul, the family re quests contributions to Con gregation Ohev Shalom, 613 Concourse Parkway South, Maitland 32751. Arrangements entrusted to Beth Shalom Memorial Cha pel, 640 Lee Road, Orlando, 32810. 407-599-1180. BERNARD RUBIN Bernard Rubin, Baruch ben Yosef, age 95, of Longwood, passed away on Tuesday, Dec. 5, 2017, at Hospice of the Com forter in Altamonte Springs. He was born in New York on July 15, 1922, to the late Joseph and Sarah Goldblatt Rubin. He was a high school graduate and enlisted in the armed forces serving in the US Army and Navy during World War II. He was the husband of the late Kate Rubin who passed away in 1994. During his career, Mr. Rubin worked in retail doing window displays. They relocated to the Orlando area in 1985 to be closer to their daughter and were af filiated with Congregation Ohev Shalom. Mr. Rubin is survived by his sons, Dr. Martin (Ellen) Rubin of Maryland and Robert Rubin of New York; and his daugh ter, Rita (Jon) Rose of Winter Park. He is also survived by his grandchildrenLaura, Brett (Emily), Jed and Chad; and his great-granddaughter, Maya Kate. A graveside service, with military honors, was held at Ohev Shalom Cemetery with Rabbi Arnold Siegel officiat ing. In memory of Bernard Rubin, the family requests contributions to Congre gation Ohev Shalom, 613 Concourse Parkway South, Maitland 32751. Arrangements entrusted to Beth Shalom Memorial Cha pel, 640 Lee Road, Orlando, 32810. 407-599-1180. 47 out of 54 countries benefit from ties with Israel Israels Foreign Ministry recently carried out a com prehensive survey of the citizens of 54 countries about their countrys relations with Israel. The main finding is that in a vast majority of those countries, 47 of 54 of them, most of the people surveyed believe that their country would benefit from links with Israel. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu referred to these finding on Sunday as a gi gantic change. What is also interesting is that half of the public in the countries in the Middle East that were reviewed, the assets and strength of Israel are appreciated and they believe that their country could benefit by links with Israel, Netanyahu said during the weekly Cabinet meeting. When I say again and again that Israel is a rising global powerI know what I am talking about. Today Israel is a sought-after country, Netanyahu underscored. He pointed to his 12 hour visit in Kenya last week, during which he met presidents of Tanzania, Uganda, Zambia, Rwanda, Togo, Botswana and Namibia, as well as the Ethiopian prime minister and other leaders. Over the past year, Netan yahu has visited Kazakhstan, Singapore, Australia, Azerbai jan and several countries in Latin America. For the first three countries, it was the first visit by an Israeli premier. He also hosted Indias Prime Minister Narendra Modi in an historic visit. In August, Senegal and Guinea, two Muslim-majority West African nations, sent their first-ever full-time am bassadors to Israel. Israel is a sought-after, developed and strong coun try that even the citizens of countries with which we do not have official relations understand the benefit of relations with Israel. We are going from strength to strength and developing even more links, the Israeli premier stated, The major diplomatic blossoming of the State of Israel is basedamong other thingson a dynamic economy, initiatives, and the development of businesses and technology. This is at the root of our strength, he declared. NATHALIE TOLEDANO Owned And Operated By NRT LLC (407) 488-2763 CELL (407) 647-1211 EXT 3685 BUSINESS (407) 628-1210 FAX REALTOR RESIDENTIAL REAL ESTATE 400 Park Avenue South, Suite 210 Winter Park, FL 32789 JULIUS A. HABERMAN Julius A. Haberman, Ye hudah Aharon ben Itzhak vKayla, age 92, of Summer field, Fla., passed away on Thursday, Nov. 30, 2017, at his residence. A native of Milton, Massachusetts, he was born on April 22, 1925, to the late Irving and Kate Schoolman Haberman. He was a college graduate and served in the United States Army during World War II. Mr. Haberman was a suc cessful shoe importer and salesman. He was a past president of Congregation Ohev Shalom and active in Bnai Brith and the Jewish War Veterans. In 1999, he and his wife, Barbara, who survives him, relocated to Summerfield. In addition to his wife, he is survived by his son, Robb; and daughters Sherri, Lisa and Stacy; and four grand children. A graveside service was held at Ohev Shalom Cemetery with Rabbi Arnold Siegel officiating. Arrangements entrusted to Beth Shalom Memorial Cha pel, 640 Lee Road, Orlando, 32810. 407-599-1180. MAXINE LESLIE HAYT Maxine Hayt, age 80, of Lake Mary, passed away on Wednesday, Dec. 6, 2017, at Florida Health-South Semi nole Hospital in Longwood. A Brooklyn native, she was born on Jan. 3, 1937, to the late Ju lius and Alice Tamres Tarr. She received her Bachelor in Fine Arts and her Master in Fine Arts degrees from Columbia University. Maxine was a highly re garded artist creating large highly detailed works of New York Citys downtrodden and elderly. Her works were shown in numerous single and mixed shows and she was represented by several New York Galleries. She and her husband, David, who survives her, lived in New York before relocating to the Orlando area three years ago. In addition to her hus band, she is survived by her daughter, Elizabeth (Robert) Atkins of New York; and her sons, Dr. Michael (Nancy) Hayt of Longwood and Paul (Jacque) Hayt of Port


PAGE 12A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 Drew Angerer/Getty Images Haim Saban (r) interviewing Jared Kushner at a forum on Israeli affairs he hosts each year in Washington, D.C., Dec. 3, 2017. off the table: Greenblatt, in encouraging the Palestinian Authority to ease out Hamas, which controls the Gaza Strip, has said that any Palestinian government must abide by previous agreements. Those include the 2003 Road Map brokered by the George W. Bush administration, which explicitly envisions a twostate solution. Ori Nir, the spokesman for Americans for Peace Now, a pro-Israel group that favors the two-state solution, praised Kushners team for staying mum, but said it didnt make sense not to be explicit that two states was the outcome. There has to be a political horizon and, at the moment, there isnt one, he said. Are the Palestinians in the loop? The leaks to The Times, from Palestinian sources, suggest that the Palestinians are scrambling to figure out what happens next. In August, Husam Zomlot, the Palestine Liberation Organization en voy to Washington, said, We need them to tell us where the hell they are going. The Palestinians have been knocked for a loop by reports that Trump plans to recognize Jerusalem as Israels capital as early as this week; the Trump administration will back a congressional bill, the Taylor Force Act, to cut funding to the Palestinians as long as the Palestinian Authority contin ues to subsidize the families of Palestinians who have killed Israelis; and by new strictures on the PLO office. Shoshana Bryen, a Middle East specialist at the conser vative Jewish Policy Center, said the Palestinians were posturing. She said the Trump administration was likely relaying a message to the Palestinians that they had to give in order to get. The Taylor Force Act, the PLO mission, the Jerusalem embassy, if it happens, she said. The thread running through these is you have to pay something. That something, she said, would be full-fledged recogni tion of Israel as a permanent part of the regionremoving any ambiguity suggesting that Palestinians believe Israel will one day disappear. If Israel gets that, every thing else is negotiable, she said. Are the Israelis in the loop? If Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is con cerned about Kushners plan, he isnt showing it. Kushner and his family have been close to Netanyahu for years, and Netanyahu has been effusive about his closeness to Trump. On Monday, Politico ran an extensive and rare interview with Ron Dermer, Israels am bassador to the United States and one of Netanyahus most trusted advisers. He sounded confident of his governments closeness to the Trump ad ministration, a sharp contrast with the fraught relations Netanyahu had with Trumps predecessor, Barack Obama. I think the way this ad ministration has gone about this, very quietly. I think its a sign of great seriousness, Dermer said. Miller said Netanyahu may have good reason to be pleased. I have to assume that due to Mr. Netanyahus relaxed reaction, he is aware of whats in this thing, he said. Nonetheless, the only news Kushner made at the fo rum is that he is hewing to time-honored conventions of Middle East peacemak ing: solve Israel-Palestinians first, and everything will fall into place; score the big overarching peace deal, and the troublesome issues that have shattered peace talks in the past will take care of themselves. If were going to try and create more stability in the region as a whole, you have to solve [the Israeli-Palestinian] issue, he said. Israelis are not fans of either of those formulas. Netanyahu clashed repeat edly with Obama over what he saw as Obamas attempts to link Israeli-Palestinian peace to broader regional policies. Additionally, Israelis have long rejected the premise that Israeli-Palestinian peace would necessarily ameliorate any of the other problems af flicting the region. That to me was jarring, Bryen said. Jerusalem? Wednesday. Or not. There has been a slew of reports that on Wednesday, Trump will in some capacity recognize Jerusalem as Is raels capital. How that will be expressed is not clear: Trump failed to meet a deadline of Dec. 1 to waive the 1995 law that mandates moving the U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem from Tel Aviv. Trump can still waive the lawa Republican Congress is unlikely to challenge him for being late by a few days. But will he recognize all of Jerusalem as the capital? Or just its western sector? Will he move the embassy? Will there be a quid pro quo for the Palestinians? Or will anything at all hap pen on Wednesday? Trump is famousor notoriousfor changing his mind at the last moment. He pledged during the campaign to move the embassy; he reneged in his first weeks as president, say ing he was still considering the matter. On Monday, all a White House official would say was The president has always said it is a matter of when, not if. The president is still considering options and we have nothing to announce. Jared Kushner talks about his peace plan, and leaves everyone guessing By Ron Kampeas WASHINGTON (JTA)The peace deal between Israel and the Palestinians will be comprehensive and pave the way for stability in the region. Thats about all we know concerning Jared Kushners plan, and hes happy to keep it that way, President Donald Trumps son-in-law and se nior policy adviser said this weekend at a gathering of scholars and policy mavens who deal with the U.S.-Israel relationship. The best thing about the team is that theres a lot of trust within the team, Kush ner said at the Saban Forum, speaking with Haim Saban, the Israeli American enter tainment mogul who is the main benefactor of an event organized by the Brookings Institution. The fact that were so close theres been no leaks on the process to date has enabled a lot of the sides we work with to be able to work with us in a more open format than they would. Veteran peace negotia tors are giving the Kushner teamthe others are Jason Greenblatt, Trumps top ne gotiator; David Friedman, the ambassador to Israel; and Dina Powell, a senior adviser on the National Se curity Councilhigh marks for keeping the plan close to their vests. Im stunned by the degree with which this administra tion has managed to pose a degree of discipline on this process, said Aaron David Miller, a veteran of peacemak ing under Republican and Democratic presidents who is now vice president of the Wilson Center foreign policy think tank. Either theres nothing there or theres something worth protecting, Miller said. So which is it? The teams discipline notwithstanding, its possible to glean some information from the recent events. A one-state solution? The New York Times re ported Monday that the Saudi crown prince, Mohammed bin Sultan, had summoned Palestinian Authority Presi dent Mahmoud Abbas two weeks ago and presented him with the outline of a final status solution that included a Palestinian state with limited sovereignty, patches of non-contiguous territory in the West Bank, no stake in Jerusalem and most Israeli settlements remaining in place. Thats not a solution the Palestinians will abide, said Miller. Its more like a script from a Marx Brothers movie rather than a serious proposal, he said. The Times said the Pales tinians were deeply unhappy with the proposal, and accept ing the plan would mean the likely ruination of the Pales tinian Authority. Miller said a proposal seen as killing off the idea of a viable Palestinian state would make the United States look really bad. How the United States looks internationally, however, has been perhaps the least of the concerns of Trump, who thumbs his nose at allies on a daily basis. Trump said at the outset of his presidency that he is not married to the idea of two states. Kushner did not mention two states in his re marks on Sunday, and Israeli and Palestinian officials who have interacted with Kushner and his team have said that two states never comes up in private conversations. That doesnt mean its Attila Kisbenedek/AFP/Getty Images Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban speaking in Budapest, Nov. 12, 2017. By Cnaan Liphshiz BUDAPEST (JTA)At a conference about antiSemitism in Europe, senior Hungarian officials said the absence of violence against Jews in their country owed to its refusal to admit Muslim immigrants. The assertion, which at least one Jewish expert on antiSemitism disputed, came amid criticism of Prime Minister Viktor Orbans right-wing gov ernment by other European leaders of his immigration policy, and a dispute between the Hungarian leader and some Jewish community leaders who accuse Orban of encouraging or tolerating anti-Semitic rhetoric. Whereas other European countries have seen jihadist terrorist attacks against Jews and others in recent years, Hungary has been consis tently able to protect its citi zens and residents, its borders and its fundamental elements of statehood from mass immi gration and international ter rorism, Minister of State for Security Policy Istvn Mikola said Wednesday at an event in Budapest titled Are Europes Jews Safe? and organized by the Hungarian Jewrys watchdog on anti-Semitism, the Action and Protection Foundation. Csaba Latorkai, deputy state secretary for priority social affairs, noted the 2015 killing of a Jewish security guard in Denmark by an Islamist along with other attacks, including the murder of 137 people in Paris by other Islamists later that year. Taking security and admin istrative measures to prevent such acts, the Hungarian government acted, and so in the autumn of 2015 it de cided to set up a border fence, introduced a legal closing of borders, Latorkai said in his speech, adding it was in order to protect citizens and make Hungary one of the most secure places in world. No one should be afraid that there may be attacks on our streets. The arrival of at least 2 million immigrants in Europe since 2015 from Iraq, Syria and other parts of the Middle East has pitted Western European governments that resolved to absorb the newcomers against eastern EU member states that shut down their borders, including Hungary. Rabbi Andrew Baker, direc tor of international Jewish affairs at the American Jewish Committee, told JTA at the event that the link made by Mikola owed to how Hungary, which will have a general elec tion next year, wants to say that this [its immigration policy] is yet another aspect of taking care of its Jewish community, even if its prob ably a bit of a stretch to see it as a threat to the Jewish community. Jewish community leaders across Europe are divided on the arrival of Middle East im migrants, with some citing Jewish values in urging gen erosity toward the newcomers and others warning that the in flux of Muslims from countries where anti-Semitism is a social norm will exacerbate Europes anti-Semitism problem. The large number of refu gees who entered Europe have obviously raised special concerns, Baker said, but he urged listeners of his address to resist the temptation of pointing the finger at that population in identifying the causes of anti-Semitism. Focusing on Muslim im migration is an easy thing for people here in Hungary and the Hungarian government, he told JTA, unlike other issues connected to anti-Semitism including the government-led campaign this year against George Soros, the liberal Jewish-American billionaire, that some observers consider anti-Semitic. The Mazsihisz umbrella of Jewish communities in Hungary has accused Orban since 2013 of whitewashing Hungarys role in the mur der of Jews in the Holocaust and mounting the campaign against Soros, a Holocaust survivor who was born in Hungary. The sad thing is, it works, Baker said. Under the cur rent government, there are efforts at kind of rewriting Hungarys clear narrative on the Holocaust. He noted the famous or infamous memorial statue in Budapest for the Nazi oc cupation, which the Jewish community in 2014 said white washes Hungarys complicity in the Holocaust, and speak ing in positive ways about Miklos Horthy, Hungarys wartime quisling. Orban earlier this year called Horthy, who helped the Nazis kill many thousands of Jews, an exceptional statesman. The chairman of the Action and Protection Foundation, Daniel Bodnar, said at the con ference that while ant-Semitic violence remains extremely rare in Hungary, the country has seen anti-Semitic rhetoric proliferating over the past decade, notably through the far-right Jobbik party and its affiliated media. In 2016 and 2015, his foun dation recorded 23 and 53 Hungary says it keeps Jews safe by keeping out Muslim immigrants incidents in Hungary, which has approximately 100,000 Jews, with no physical assaults of individuals. It has initiated dozens of criminal cases since its establishment in 2012. Hundreds of incidents, with many assaults, were recorded in those years in Britain and France.


HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 PAGE 13A Weekly roundup of world briefs from JTA Roy Moores wife on anti-Semitism charge: One of our attorneys is a Jew WASHINGTON (JTA)Roy Moores wife said she and her husband, the controversial Senate candidate in Alabama, could not be anti-Semitic because they employ a Jew ish lawyer. Fake news will tell you that we dont care for Jews, Kayla Moore, her husband, Roy, standing behind her, said Monday night at Moores final campaign rally in Midland City, Alabama. I tell you all this because Ive seen it all, so I just want to set the record straight while theyre here, she said, waving at the media and grinning. One of our attorneys is a Jew. Kayla Moore, wife of Ala bama Senate candidate Roy Moore, accuses media of painting couple as antiSemitic. Vcczj6pNPv NBC News (@NBCNews) December 12, 2017 Kayla Moore did not name the attorney. We have very close friends that are Jewish and are rabbis and we also fellowship with them, she said. Fellowship used as a verb generally refers to Christians joining together. Its not clear what Kayla Moore, who is a Baptist, meant in applying the term to encounters with Jews. Kayla Moore also did not make clear what she was referring to when she said the media portrayed her and her husband as not caring for Jews, but the candidate came under fire last week for attacking the liberal bil lionaire philanthropist and hedge fund manager George Soros, suggesting that he was headed for hell because he did not accept Gods salvation. Soros is Jewish. Moore, the Republican candidate in the Alabama Senate race who is favored by President Donald Trump, is in an unexpectedly tight race with Doug Jones, a former prosecutor and the Democratic candidate, in the special election Tuesday. A former Alabama chief justice twice removed from the bench for defying federal rulings that countered his re ligious beliefs, Moore has been beset during this campaign by allegations that he wooed teenage girls when he was in his 30s. Two of his accusers have alleged that he sexually assaulted them, one of them describing an encounter she said took place when she was 14. Moores candidacy is backed by Steve Bannon, a former top adviser to Trump who helms the Breitbart News website. Bannon, who remains close to Trump, spoke at the Moore rally Monday night and ap peared to take a shot at Trumps daughter Ivanka, who said re cently that she does not doubt Moores accusers, adding that theres a special place in hell for child predators. Theres a special place in hell for Republicans who should know better, said Bannon, who feuded during his White House tenure with Ivanka Trump and her hus band, Jared Kushner, who are both top aides to the president. NY Port Authority sus pect charged with sup porting terrorism (JTA)The suspect in a pipe bomb attack on the Port Authority Bus Terminal in New York City has been charged with supporting an act of terrorism and making terrorist threats. Akayed Ullah, 27, of Brook lyn, also was charged with criminal possession of a weapon, the New York Police Department said Tuesday morning. Federal terrorism charges are expected next week, according to reports. Ullah, who is said to be of Bangladeshi origin and reportedly worked as a cab driver, spoke with authori ties at Bellevue Hospital after suffering injuries when the homemade pipe bomb strapped to his body deto nated early during Mondays morning rush hour. The bomb exploded in a tunnel connect ing the Times Square subway station with the Midtown Manhattan transit hub. CNN cited an unnamed law enforcement source who said Ullah said he was upset with an unspecified incursion into Gaza. The New York Times reported that he told investigators that he set off the bomb in retaliation for U.S. airstrikes on ISIS targets in Syria and elsewhere, while NBC cited law enforcement officials as saying he did it in the name of ISIS to avenge the deaths of Muslims around the world. The Washington Post re ported that a pro-Islamic State media group, Maqdisi Media, publicized that the attack was carried out in response to President Donald Trumps announcement last week that the United States recognizes Jerusalem as Israels capital, citing the SITE Intelligence Group, which monitors ex tremist activity. Ullah has lived in the United States for seven years after entering as part of a visa program available to those with relatives who are U.S. citizens. He reportedly has never appeared on a terror watchlist in Bangladesh. Police on Monday raided the family home and questioned Ullahs wife, Jannatul Ferdous Piya, 25, and her father. In vestigators believe he acted alone, however. At a news conference Mon day, New York Mayor Bill de Blasio called the attack on the subway system incredibly upsetting. And lets also be clear, he said, this was an attempt ed terrorist attack. Thank God the perpetrator did not achieve his ultimate goals. Trump delivers Chanu kah wishes to Jewish brothers and sisters WASHINGTON (JTA) President Donald Trump said he was proud to stand with the Jewish people on Chanukah. Melania and I wish all of our Jewish brothers and sisters celebrating this mean ingful holiday a happy and healthy eight nights in the company of those they love, Trump said in a message Tues day evening, the first night of the eight-day holiday, and naming the first lady. On this holiday, we are proud to stand with the Jew ish people who shine as a light to all nations. We also stand with the people of Israel, the Jewish State, which has itself a miraculous history of over coming the tallest of odds, the statement said. Trumps director of the Na tional Economic Council, Gary Cohn, lit the national meno rah on the National Mall, an event organized by American Friends of Lubavitch. He noted that Trump last week recognized Jerusalem as Is raels capital, breaking with predecessors who held back from full recognition. President Trump delivered on a promise to recognize Jerusalem as the capital of Is rael, said Cohn, who clashed with Trump this summer over Trumps equivocal remarks after white supremacists and anti-Semites marched in Charlottesville, Virginia. The president made the right decision and it makes these years celebration of Chanukah particularly mean ingful, he said. There were strong winds in Washington, and Cohns kippah flew off his head at least once. Trumps re-election cam paign also sent out Chanukah greetings, as did the chair woman of the Republican National Committee, Ronna Romney McDaniel. So did Tom Perez, the chairman of the Democratic National Committee. Trump continued the tradi tion established by President George W. Bush and car ried on by President Barack Obama, and had a Chanukah party at the White House last week, where he noted his recognition of Jerusalem as Israels capital. Later this week, Jewish members of Congress will host a Chanukah party at the Library of Congress. In previ ous years, the congressional party has been hosted only by Democrats, led by Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz, D-Fla. This year for the first time, Wasserman Schultz is co-hosting the party with a Jewish Republican, Rep. Lee Zeldin, R-N.Y. The Conservative move ment supported Trumps Jerusalem recognition. Hundreds of its members disagree. (JTA)Hundreds of Con servative Jews have signed an open letter opposing their movements support for U.S. recognition of Jerusalem as Israels capital. The letter, first published Sunday night, has garnered some 250 signatures in its first 36 hours online. All of the signatories are affiliates or alumni of the Jewish Theo logical Seminary, the move ments leading educational institution, or the United Synagogue of Conservative Judaism, the movements um brella organization. Dozens of the signatories are rabbis. After President Donald Trump formally recognized Jerusalem as Israels capital last week, the Conserva tive movements institutions released at least three state ments, all of which supported the move. The JTS statement said it was heartened by the recognition A movement-wide statement, signed by those institutions and 11 more, said the movement was pleased with the decision. The status of Jerusalem is a matter to be settled in direct negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians, the movement-wide statement said. But in recognizing Jerusalem as Israels capital and planning to move the American embassy to a lo cation under uncontested Israeli sovereignty, the U.S. government acknowledges the age-old connection that Israel and the Jewish people maintain with the holy city. The only note of criticism appeared in the USCJs state ment. While saying Israel, like all nations, must be free to determine its capital, it added, we question the pur pose of the recognition at this time. All three Conservative statements make extended reference to the need for a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Whats to be gained by doing it now at this mo ment? USCJ CEO Rabbi Steve Wernick told JTA on Tuesday, adding that recognizing Je rusalem was always viewed as something the U.S. could do to leverage the parties to move toward peace. Thats the context thats missing. But, he continued, how can we as a people who un derstand that Jerusalem has been the capital of the Jewish people for 3,000 years, and of the State of Israel for 70 years, not welcome the decision? The letter from dissenters opposes U.S. recognition of Jerusalem as Israels capital, which was signed Dec. 6, on the grounds that it will inflame tensions in the city, risking lives, and will reduce prospects for peace. We believe that support for President Trumps an nouncement is both politi cally shortsighted and morally unsound, the letter reads. It has already cost the lives of several Palestinians and will surely cost more. As institu tions committed to Kevod HaBriyot, human dignity for all peoples, JTS and USCJ should neither be heartened by nor applaud a decision that will lead to violence, further entrench the occupation, and damage prospects for peace. The Reform movement called the decision ill-timed and said it could not support the decision absent a com prehensive plan for a peace process, while Orthodox or ganizations enthusiastically supported it. Senate unanimously passes bill to help Holo caust survivors obtain restitution, seized assets (JTA)The Senate unani mously passed a bill to help Holocaust survivors and the families of victims obtain restitution or the return of Holocaust-era assets. The Justice for Uncom pensated Survivors Today, or JUST Act, which was intro duced in February by Sens. Tammy Baldwin, D-Wisc., and Marco Rubio, R-Fla., received unanimous approval on Tuesday. The measure requires the State Department to report on the progress of certain European countries toward the return of or restitution for wrongfully confiscated or transferred Holocaust-era assets, including property, art and other movable property. It also requires a report spe cifically on progress on the resolution of claims for U.S. citizen Holocaust survivors and family members. The World Jewish Restitu tion Organization praised the bills passage, urging that it be signed into law this year. Through this legislation, the United States will help survivors achieve a small mea sure of justice for the wrongful seizure of their property dur ing the Holocaust, the orga nizations chair of operations, Gideon Taylor, said Tuesday in a statement. Now is the timewhile the remaining survivors are alivefor coun tries to provide restitution. The JUST Act is designed to build on the international Terezin Declaration on Holo caust Era Assets and Related Issues of 2009, which affirms the protection of property rights and recognizes the importance of restituting or compensating Holocaustrelated confiscations. Several nations that en dorsed the Terezin Declara tion have not fully addressed the restitution of Jewish communal, private and heir less property, co-sponsors Baldwin and Rubio have said. A companion bill was in troduced in the U.S. House of Representatives in February by Reps. Joseph Crowley, DN.Y., and Christopher Smith, R-N.J. House passes bill to protect religious institu tions sparked by wave of JCC threats (JTA)The U.S. House of Representatives passed a bipartisan bill that increases the federal penalties for bomb threats and other credible threats of violence against religious institutions. The bill, sponsored by Reps. David Kustoff, R-Tenn., and Derek Kilmer, D-Wash., passed Monday by a vote of 402 to 2. It was co-sponsored by more than 40 other law makers. The Protecting Religiously Affiliated Institutions Act was sparked by a wave of threats against JCCs and other Jewish institutions earlier this year. It would prosecute threats of violence against religious institutions as hate crimes and increase the penalty for destruction of the institu tions property caused by fire or explosives from one year to three years. It amends the Church Arson Prevention Act to include community reli gious centers such as Jewish community centers. In 2017, more than 160 bomb threats and other threats of violence have been made against Jewish commu nity centers across the United States. Most of them came from a young Israeli man. The dramatic rise in threats against religious institutions is deeply dis turbing and makes it clear that existing federal laws do not suitably deter these acts of hate, Kustoff said in a statement. We must stand united against acts of hate and protect the rights of all Americans to worship freely and without fear. The Muslim-Jewish Ad visory Council praised the Houses passage of the bill. Crimes against religious institutions are intended to create an atmosphere of fear that deters community mem bers from attending worship services and social involve ment, Stanley Bergman, the councils co-chair, said in a statement. These hate crimes pose a danger to the religious freedom and security of all Americans. Sens. Orrin Hatch, RUtah, and Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., have sponsored an identical bill being considered in the Senate. Federation of Argentine Jewish centers elects its first female president BUENOS AIRES, Argentina (JTA)The Jewish Argentine federation for sports and so cial community centers, or FACCMA, for the first time has elected a female president. Monica Sucari of Hacoaj, a sports and cultural club with 7,800 members north of Buenos Aires, was elected Monday to lead FACCMA, a Spanish acronym that stands for Argentine Federation of Maccabiah Community Centers. She is vice president of the umbrella group for Argentine-style Jewish com munity centers, one of the main umbrella organizations in the country. FACCMA, the largest mem ber of the Latin American branch of the Maccabi World Union, has 55 affiliates and a network of 50,000 members. It was a huge honor that my institution, Hacoaj, nomi nated me as the candidate for the presidency, Sucari told JTA just after the assembly. I hope that more women will be increasingly encouraged to participate in major roles such as this one. Sucari, who has 10 years of experience with FACCMA, will serve until 2019 while reinforcing the role of Hacoaj at the Global JCC network to raise other women to leader ship positions. Hacoaj has 7,800 members. Last month, the female presence in JCC leadership positions was discussed at the JCC Global World Conference in Tarrytown, New York. Although the objective of each of the JCCs was to meet other JCCs and associate in projects of social impact, each and every one of them was surprisingly interested in the topic of female leadership in the organizations of the Jewish community Patricia Manusovich, who attended the global event representing Hacoaj, told JTA. Manusovich is a member of a network of JCCs worldwide that will begin to raise the issue of female leadership in Jewish organizations. The issue of female leader ship is under debate with no women on the shortlist to replace the chairman of the Jewish Agency for Israel. In an age in which the #metoo campaign is radi cally changing old concepts of male-female power relations, how could the American heads of the agency and its associated institutions fail to include at least one female among the six candidates they deem worthy to succeed [Natan] Sharansky, asked an editorial appearing in The Jerusalem Post on Nov 28. NY Jewish Museum suspends projects with senior curator in wake of sexual harassment allegations (JTA)New Yorks Jewish Museum has suspended all current projects with senior JTA on page 15A


PAGE 14A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 where the Western Wall Heri tage Foundation, the haredi Orthodox organization that runs the site, forbids men and women from praying together. The foundation characterized the clashes as a provocation by the Reform delegation. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has yet to make a statement on the incident. Recruitment for a biannual Detroit teen summer trip to Israel is also getting harder. Last year, Lader and her col leagues changed the itinerary to include a talk by Anat Hoff man, who chairs Women of the Wall, a feminist Western Wall prayer group that has pushed for reforms at the site. Its really challenging working with millennials and young people who see these things in the news and then hear this is your home, this is where you belong, she said. Theyre hearing two differ ent messages from us at the same time. The same problem exists among young professionals, said Rabbi Jen Gubitz, who works with that cohort at Temple Israel in Boston. Gubitz has not planned any programming around Israel yet because no one has asked for it, and because its become such a fraught topic. She said young people are upset both about Israeli policy in the West Bankthe Reform movement regularly urges curbs on settlement growthand the countrys Orthodox monopoly on religious affairs. The way that millennials approach Israel and approach talking about the land and the people and the occupation is a really big tapestry with lots of threads, and I havent yet moved forward with that avenue because Im not totally sure how, she said. I always ask people what do you want, and thats not one of the things that comes up. The movement has grown more outspoken recently in its criticism of the Israeli govern ment. After Deputy Foreign Minister Tzipi Hotovely said last week that American Jews are growing distant from Is rael because they dont send their children to the military and lead quite convenient lives, Jacobs called for her dismissal, a perhaps unprec edented move. The Deputy Foreign Min ister has a right to her illinformed and insulting views, Jacobs said in a statement. But such views disqualify her hold ing such an important role in Israels diplomatic corps. Her comments serve to underscore how the Israeli government disdains the majority of North American Jews. Hotovely later apolo gized for her comments, and Netanyahu condemned her remarks publicly. Some Reform rabbis still feel an obligation to act as traditional Israel advocates despite these differences. Jeffrey Salkin, senior rabbi of Temple Solel in Hollywood, Florida, disagrees with some of the Israeli governments actions, but says blame lies on both sides. Liberal Jews in America, he said, have been distancing themselves from Israel for a while. My job is to make the best possible case for Israel that I can and to interpret Israel as broadly and generously as I can, said Salkin, who is also a columnist for the Religion News Service. The danger is that the encounter with this significant religious flaw in Israels system can and does serve to alienate Jews from Israel more than they already are. Reform leaders are also opt ing for positive engagement with Reform and progressive Israeli organizations. Earlier this year, in response to the cancellation of the Western Wall deal, several Reform donors upped their commit ments to the Reform move ment in Israel, where only 3 percent of Jews identify with the movement, compared to 35 percent in the United States. Reform leaders noted that Jacobs was roughed up while celebrating the ordina tion of the 100th Reform rabbi in Israela positive sign. At Congregation Beth Or in suburban Philadelphia, Hebrew school kids spend time studying the history of the Israeli Reform movement and Women of the Wall. Other rabbis say the best way to foster a complex and authentic connection to the country is to visit and view its pros and cons firsthand. While youre there, you can experience the wonderful successes of Israel, the cre ativity, the energy, and also be honest about the social justice issues, said Rabbi Steve Fox, CEO of the Central Confer ence of American Rabbis, the movements rabbinical asso ciation. The association leads a trip to Israel that teaches congregational rabbis how to lead their own trips and navigate difficult questions. Reform clergy may be outspoken in their criticism of Israels religious policies because its easier to en gage on those than on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, said Rabbi Judy Schindler, co-chair of the Association of Reform Zionists of Americas clergy council. Western Wall policy is more of an internal Jewish issue, she said, while opposing Israels control of the West Bank could fuel the flames of anti-Semitism. Like other Reform rabbis who spoke to JTA, Schindler opposed ending or with holding support of Israel -through philanthropy, travel, activism or otherwise. But she feels frustrated. We work very hard to be strong partners with Israel, and it is disappointing and even devastating when inci dents happen such as what happened at the Western Wall, Schindler said. We would expect that the Israeli government would be in an authentic relationship with us. It seems to be a one-sided relationship. Noam Rivkin Fenton/Flash90 Members of the Reform movement and Hebrew Union College reading from the Torah at the public square in front of the Western Wall in Jerusalem, Nov. 16, 2017. Reform rabbis are finding it tough to love Israel By Ben Sales (JTA)When Israeli se curity guards roughed up the head rabbi of the Reform movement at the Western Wall, ripping his suit jacket and shoving a can of mace in his face, Rabbi Jen Lader had a dilemma: How could she talk about the violence without being boring? Lader, a spiritual leader at Temple Israel in suburban Detroit, had already preached about the Israeli governments apparent disdain for Reform Jews. She had spoken about how Reform Jews cannot marry or perform conversions as they choose in Israel. She had decried the governments abandonment of the Western Wall deal, an agreement to provide space at the holy site for non-Orthodox prayer. Wasnt this latest incident at the Western Wall just more of the same? I gave this sermon a year ago, and two years ago, and three years ago, said Lader, who runs youth program ming at the 3,400-family Reform congregation, one of the countrys largest. Its not shocking anymore. Its not surprising anymore. That fact is part of the reason its so difficult for me to talk about it all the time. Laders problems stretch across Reform Jewry, the largest Jewish denomination in the United States. The lib eral movement self-defines as staunchly pro-Israel but has found itself at odds with many of its governments policies, from West Bank settlement expansion to the preserva tion of Orthodox hegemony in the state. Thats why, leading up to the movements bien nial conference next week in Boston, Reform rabbis and leaders sounded upset but unsurprised by the clashes on Nov. 16 at the Western Wall. For years they have found themselves distinguishing between loving Israel as a country while criticizing its government. I think theres some dif ference between supporting the project and supporting the government, said Peter Knobel, rabbi emeritus of Congregation Beth Emet in suburban Chicago. I will always stay involved in the Zionist project. I believe its important for the Jewish people. Im not prepared to give up and to draw a red line and say if Israel does X, Im out of there. Lader also feels invested in Israel education. She pointed out that her synagogue was founded specifically as a Zionist breakaway from a non-Zionist congregation. But connecting young Reform Jews to Israel isnt easy, she said, when Israeli guards are manhandling Reform rabbis. In the episode nearly two weeks ago, guards and haredi Orthodox onlookers tussled with Jacobs and other Reform officials as they tried to enter the main entrance to the Western Wall plaza carrying Torah scrolls. The guards said it was illegal to bring the scrolls into the main plaza, S1T2R3U4T5 M6F7A8 C9I10D11E12R13P14I A N O A15R M A16D O R E R17A C H M O18N E S T19I M E D A20R E B21A G S B22E N Y23A R D24 K25O H E26N G A D27O28L29 I30F31I L32A O A33G E A34G R E A35T36M I R A37C L E T38R U E L39E S I40F H E H41A P P E N42E D T H43E R E I44V E Z45I P E46S E V47I L D48E C H A49Y50A E51Y52I53N54 I55R E M56A T S57 A58N A R59E60H61A B C62U R S E S63H A M A64R E N A U65S O A66L O N E H67A D A G D68E N M69O O E D rf r fntb


HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 PAGE 15A Book From page 9A targeted innocent Israelis, including children, in res taurants, buses, hospitals, schools and shopping malls, Ammiel Hirsch, the Stephen Wise Free Synagogues senior rabbi, said in a statement. The intifada was not a ris ing up for what is right. It was a mass descent into im morality. Bashi, however, says inti fada encompasses a broader and largely nonviolent Pal estinian cultural resistance. P is for Palestine has sold out its initial print run of 2,000 copies. And the contro versies have continued: Last month, a 28,000-member Facebook group for mothers on the Upper East Side of Flynn From page 4A Is Kushner in trouble? What that deal would in volve would deeply interest Mueller, partly if it involves benefits that would not merely accrue to Trumps presidency, but to Kushners personal fortune. Writing for Bloomberg Solidarity From page 5A trial evidence and academic research on radical Islam in this country. Mazen then blasted Israel and the U.S. He suggested that the congregation should engage in difficult conversa tions about the supposed maleficence of both Israel and the U.S., whose govern Winners From page 1A Jerusalem From page 1A there is no more fitting or beautiful gift, as we approach 70 years of the State of Israels independence. After the 50th anniversary of the reunification of the city the time has come to bring tranquility to Jerusalem, and to see hope blossom in the this is an extremely signifi cant symbolic loss. The announcement will also make it more difficult for Sunni Arab states to be seen as publicly backing a Trump peace initiative, as Jerusalem Manhattan was wracked by vitriolic debate over the book. The dust-up between the synagogue and Book Culture began on Nov. 21, when Hirsch put out a statement demand ing Book Culture publicly rescind their support of P Is for Palestine, a book by Golbarg Bashi that glorifies the Palestinian intifadaor Stephen Wise will cancel its upcoming book fair featuring Book Culture. Since then, the synagogue and bookstore have come to an agreement: Book Cultures owners have publicly repudi ated Bashis views but will keep selling her book. Hirsch told JTA that the synagogue is happy to partner with Book Culture as long as the bookstore chain makes clear that it does not oppose Israel. The book fair will proceed as planned. The sides collectively is sued a statement Wednesday in which the Book Cultures owners regretted that they did not fully appreciate the political or communal rami fications of the childrens book. They also stated their support for Israels right to exist and their opposition to terrorism and to the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement, or BDS, against Israel. The synagogue did not de mand that the store pull the book from its shelves. We are fierce believers in the right of free expression, a statement signed by the synagogue clergy said. Book stores have a critical role to play in free societies, and in particular, in our increasingly polarized country. If Book Culture wants to carry and promote Dr. Bashis book, it is for them to decide. This is also not about Palestinian national culture or rights. We support a twostate solution, the statement continued. We believe that it is important for American Jews to hear the views of Palestinians. Hirsch, the former execu tive director of the Association of Reform Zionists of America, told JTA: We do not want to host people who have antiIsrael, anti-Zionist views. I dont know what the current or future relationship of the store is to the book. We didnt want to get into the business of telling the bookstore what books to carry. Bashi, however, who lives in New York, feels the synagogue inappropriately pressured the bookstore to take a position, and that the incident could have a chilling effect on other bookstores, which could be come scared to carry the book. She called the synagogues opposition to the book, and its initial criticism of Book Culture, mob-like behavior. By doing so, youre basi cally saying dont you dare hold a reading, dont you dare stock this book, she said. Im an Upper West Side mother myself, and I find it dismaying that a religious institution can force businesses in that manner. For her part, Bashi rejects the idea that the word inti fada refers primarily to terror attacks. She told JTA that she sees intifada as referring to a broader cultural and nonvio lent Palestinian resistance to Israels occupation. Western media, she said, tend to em phasize Palestinian violence while not covering peaceful protest Of course, absolutely, violence is wrong, the author told JTA, emphasizing her opposition to terrorism. I think that when youre talk ing about an occupied people and you have an alphabeti cal book about that people, intifada is part of Palestinian life, to resist occupation. That resistance is overwhelmingly peaceful. ments often subvert the will of the people and the natural democracy that it is owed. As the program came to a close, the Islamists asked the Lexington Jews for money. My project this year is I have to raise a million dollars, Mazen announced. Dont send clothes, send money. Im not afraid to say it anymore. Go out and donate to any Muslim organization, ISBCC, CAIR, Jetpac, Muslim Justice League, come on, donate to us, urged Marzouk. Lexingtons citizens have the right to support any cause they like, but the notion that Jewish institutions should be used to promote fundraising for groups such as these is appalling. Organizations that are either linked to terror ism or that seek to impede law enforcement efforts to prevent slaughter should not be confused with those that advance social justice. Nor should sympathy with Muslims that are wrongly associated with support for terror lead well-meaning Jews to aid groups that pose as defenders of civil rights, but are on the wrong side of the argument about prevent ing radical Islamist violence and hate. Yet it appears that Bostons Islamists are planning more Out of Many, One events at other synagoguesTemple Beth Zion in Brookline, Mass., is next. We can only hope that con gregants there and through out the U.S. wake up and understand what is at stake when groups that spew ha tred against Israel (not just settlements), and rationalize terror rather than confront ing it, are given a misguided seal of approval from Jewish communities. Dr. Charles Jacobs is presi dent and Ilya Feoktistov is a board member of Americans for Peace and Tolerance. News, Timothy OBrien, a Trump biographer, said Kushners interests with Rus sia and Israel may extend well beyond his father-in-laws foreign policy considerations. Kushners family is in debt because of its ownership of a Manhattan office tower, and Mueller is intrigued about a meeting Kushner took with a banker during the transi tion. (Kushner has said he met with the banker because of his close ties to Russian President Vladimir Putin, and for no other reason.) In his real estate dealings, Kushner has also partnered with one of Israels wealthiest families. Theres more: Kushner re portedly pressed his father-inlaw to sack then-FBI Director James Comey in May. Comey was investigating the very events that have entangled Flynnand, we now know, Kushner. Kushner also has spoken to congressional committees and with Muel lers investigators. Whether Flynns revelations of the con versations with Kislyak came upand whether Kushner was truthful about what he knewwe dont know. So were back to the Logan Act. Have the Democrats noticed? You bet. This shows a Trump as sociate negotiating with the Russians against U.S. policy and interests before Donald Trump took office, and after it was announced that Russia had interfered in our elec tion, Bloomberg quoted Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., as saying. Thats a stunning revelation and could be a violation of the Logan Act, which forbids unauthorized U.S. citizens from negotiat ing with a foreign power. remains one of the most sensitive issues among Arab publics. Serving as boosters for the Trump peace plan or being seen as heading toward normalization with Israel fol lowing this announcement will put Arab governments in a political bind, and despite the presidents prediction that this move will make a peace agreement easier, the opposite is likely to be the case. Public opinion serves as a heavy brake even in authoritarian states, and while the importance of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has subsided for many Arabs in recent years, any changes in Jerusalems status quo have the ability to reverse that trend given the unique sen sitivity surrounding the city. While the Trump announce ment will change nothing on the ground itself, as Israels capital was Jerusalem even before Trump acknowledged it and moving the embassy will take years, the symbolism should not be understated. In declaring Jerusalem as Israels capital without making a clear statement that the U.S. does not recognize unhindered Israeli sovereignty in eastern Jerusalem, Trump may end up killing his own peace initiative in the cradle for the sake of an announcement whose timing was unnecessary now. Michael J. Koplow is the policy director of the Israel Policy Forum. capital of Israel, the place where pilgrims come from around the world, Rivlin stated. The recognition of Je rusalem as the capital of Israel, and the relocation of all embassies to the city, is a landmark in the recognition of the right of the Jewish people to our land, and a milestone on our road to peacepeace for all the residents of Jerusalem, and the whole region, he said Israels Ambassador to the United Nations (UN) Danny Danon welcomed Trumps announcement, calling it courageous and similar to the one made by President Harry Truman in 1948 when he became the first world leader to recognize the State of Israel Today President Trump righted an historic wrong by recognizing Jerusalem as our capital, said Danon. He called on all UN mem ber-states to follow the lead of our American friends and recognize our ancient capital of Jerusalem as the capital of the State of Israel. Just hours after President Trumps speech, the Czech Republic issued a statement saying it recognizes the pre1967 west Jerusalem as the capital of Israel, but that it will only consider moving its embassy from Tel Aviv to the city after talks with regional partners. World Jewish Congress (WJC) President Ronald Lauder said Trumps an nouncement is a critical and courageous step. Jerusalem is the indis putable capital of Israel and the historic capital of the Jewish people. We hope that the US clear declaration to this effect, and its reitera tion that this has long been its policy, sends a strong message to the international community of this truth, Lauder stated. In honor of the event, the flags of Israel and the US were projected on the walls of Jerusalems Old City. curator Jens Hoffman follow ing sexual harassment allega tions by several museum staff members. Hoffman was suspended on Dec. 4, less than a week after the staffers came forward, the ARTnews website reported, citing a statement sent to the publication by the museum. The museum said it is review ing the allegations Hoffmann served four years as the Jewish Museums deputy director for exhibitions and pro grams beginning in 2012, and then as director of special ex hibitions and public programs. His suspension comes after the announcement late last month that Hoffmann JTA From page 13A was leaving his position as co-artistic director of Front International: Cleveland Tri ennial for Contemporary Art. Since his suspension from the Jewish Museum, several other institutions also have suspended or fired Hoffmann, including the Honolulu Bien nial, The Museum of Contem porary Art in Detroit, Kadist, an international foundation, and the Indianapolis Museum of Contemporary of Arts upcoming Peoples Biennial. He also was suspended as editor-at-large by the Milanbased Mousse Magazine art publication and from his position as artistic director of Fundacin Arte, a Buenos Aires-based foundation, ART news reported. Meanwhile, three editors of the Exhibitionist, a journal about curatorial practices that Hoffmann founded in 2009, have resigned. Hoffmanns attorney, Lance Gotko, told ARTnews in response to the allega tions, He can firmly say he has never subjected anyone at the museum to sexual harassment. Gotko said he has not heard from the Jewish Museum since the suspension and that he regretted that other institutions also cut ties with Hoffmann. Hes obviously very disap pointed with the actions taken by those institutions, the attorney said. Most Jewish institutions resume operations after Skirball Fire (JTA)Most of the Jewish institutions that had been threatened by the so-called Skirball Fire in Los Angeles have resumed normal opera tions. All evacuation orders, road closures and restrictions due to the fire in the Bel Air area were lifted Sunday afternoon, the Los Angeles Daily News reported. The fire remained at 85 percent containment on Tuesday following the calm ing of the Santa Ana winds beginning Sunday. The Valley Beth Shalom Syn agogue in Encino, California, which took in about 25 Torah scrolls from area synagogues and schools for safekeeping, announced Friday that it would resume normal operations. The same day, the Stephen Wise Temple was cleared to hold Shabbat services and brought its Torah scrolls back from Valley Beth Shalom in time for the services. The Leo Baeck Temple an nounced Monday that while its buildings and grounds were not burned, they suffered significant smoke damage and the temple would not be able to reopen its facilities right away. Many of the Leo Baeck events were moved to Stephen Wise, which also invited the mem bers of the smoke-damaged temple to join it for Shabbat services. The Milken Community Schools reopened Monday for regular classes. The Los Ange les eruv remained undamaged by the fire and was available for Shabbat. The Skirball Cultural Cen ter reopened Friday and held a Chanukah festival two days later that was moved indoors due to air quality concerns. The Skirball Fire broke out on Dec. 6, one of several wildfires blanketing the area. It destroyed six homes and damaged 12 others, and required the evacuation of about 700 homes as well as an apartment building. It damaged 475 acres. On Tuesday, the Los An geles Fire Department said the blaze was caused by an illegal cooking fire at an area encampment.


PAGE 16A HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, DECEMBER 15, 2017 By Sonya Sanford (The Nosher via JTA)The Japanese word okonomiyaki is derived from two words: okonomi how you like it and yaki grill. Okonomiyaki is a customizable Japanese savory veg etable pancake. Like a latke, it gets cooked in oil in a fritter formation. Unlike a latke, its usually made into a large platesized pancake comprising mainly cabbage. Food historians have linked the rise in popularity of okonomi yaki in Japan to World War II, when rice was more scarce and this recipe offered a filling meal or snack with a wheat-based starch. Throughout Japan there are regional differences and countless variations of okonomiyaki, but the most common form of the dish involves a batter made of flour, a variety of mountain yam, eggs, shredded cabbage, green onion, dashi and often the addition of pork belly. It gets topped with its own tangy sweet sauce, Japanese mayonnaise and bonito flakes (katsuobushi). I first fell in love with okonomiyaki on a trip to Japan. You can find it there in restaurants that specialize in the dish, but its also something that is prepared in home kitchens. The cabbage gets slightly crisp, tender and sweet when seared in oil on a flattop or skillet, and then it gets generously slathered with an umami-rich sauce, along with a welcome drizzle of creamy mayo. The richness, sweetness and tanginess of these components all work perfectly together. A few months after I returned from Japan, I ended up eating at Brooklyns Japanese Jewish restaurant, Shalom Japan. I didnt hesitate to order its Jewish-influenced spin on okonomiyaki. Shalom Japan is known to top the dish with pastrami, or even corned lamb tongue and sauerkraut. It became clear there that okonomiyaki, with its base of humble cabbage and onion, is a perfect fit on a Jewish table. The fried pancake part of it all called out Chanukah. I am a fan of all pancakes and fritters, and I set out to modify the classic Japanese version for a recipe that didnt require ac cess to a specialty food store and could be made with kosher ingredients. Full disclosure: My version lacks authenticity. If youre going for the real deal, youll need a batter made with an okonomiyaki flour mix or nagaimo yam. This special kind of yam is added in powdered form to the flour mix or is grated fresh into the batter. The toppings should include bonito flakes, and the batter should be made with dashi. These ingredients can be found at most Japanese markets. Instead of nagaimo yam, my version uses a batter of flour and potato starch, and instead of dashi I use water. Japanese-Style Latkes for Chanukah For the okonomiyaki sauce: 1/2 cup ketchup 1/4 cup Worcestershire sauce 2 tablespoons soy sauce 2 tablespoons honey or agave syrup, or to taste Directions: 1. Start by making the batter. Whisk together the flour, starch, baking powder and salt in a large bowl. 2. In a separate bowl beat the eggs. Add the eggs and 1/2 cup of water to the flour mixture. Whisk until smooth. You want a fairly thin, crepe batter-like consistency. If you find it too thick, add another 1/4 cup of water. Try not to over-mix; you do not want to overdevelop the gluten. Allow the batter to rest in the fridge for 30 minutes to an hour. 3. While the batter is resting, prepare the vegetables. Remove the thick core from the cabbage half, then cut the halved cab bage in two. Thinly slice or shred the cabbage. Thinly slice the green onions. Grate the carrot and daikon if using. 4. Make the okonomiyaki sauce: Combine the ketchup, Worcestershire, soy sauce and honey/agave in a bowl. Taste and adjust to your liking. The sauce should be tangy, savory and a little sweet. 5. Combine the batter with the vegetable mixture. 6. Heat a cast-iron skillet or a nonstick skillet with about 3 tablespoons of oil over high heat. Once the oil is glisten ing and hot, lower the heat to medium low and add some of the cabbage mixture to the pan, gently nudging it into a circle shape. I like to make each pancake with about 2 cups of the mixture. For me, that makes an ideal-sized pancake that isnt too hard to flip and one that will hold together. Cover the skillet with a lid for 3-4 minutes. Carefully flip over the pancake, and cover it with a lid for an additional 3-4 minutes, or until browned on both sides and cooked through. Make sure not to cook on too high of a heat or the pancake might burn on the outside while remaining raw in the center. 7. Serve hot topped with a generous spread of the okonomiyaki sauce, mayo if desired, sliced green onions and sesame seeds. 8. Slice and serve! Sonya Sanford is a chef, food stylist and writer based out of Los Angeles who specializes in modern Jewish cooking. Follow Sanford at or on Instagram @sonyamichellesanford. The Nosher food blog offers a dazzling array of new and classic Jewish recipes and food news, from Europe to Yemen, from challah to shakshuka and beyond. Check it out at ww Ive also included a recipe for homemade traditional oko nomiyaki sauce that can be made simply with easy-to-find ingredients, but you can also buy a pre-made bottled sauce. You can make these pancakes large-sized and cut into wedges like the Japanese do, or slightly smaller a la a large latke. I wouldnt go too small, as the vegetables tend to hold together better en masse. This recipe doesnt need to be too exact, and it works as a blank canvas for additional vegetables like kale, mushrooms and/or daikon. In the spirit of Chanukah, these okonomiyaki get cooked in oil, but they are not heavily fried. The oil used to fry the okonomiyaki gives a loving nod to the miracle of the oil glowing in the Temple for eight days instead of one, but the heap of vegetables and addictive sauce make this a nutritious and satisfying addition to any Chanukah meal. Ingredients: For the pancakes: 3/4 cup all-purpose flour or gluten free all-purpose mix 1/4 cup potato starch or cornstarch 1 teaspoon baking powder 1 teaspoon kosher salt 2 large eggs 1/2 to 3/4 cup water 1/2 shredded green cabbage, about 4 1/2 packed cups 3 green onions, sliced thin, plus more for garnish if desired 1 carrot, peeled and shredded 4-5 inches daikon, peeled and shredded (optional) Oil as needed (i.e. sunflower, canola or peanut) Sesame seeds, for topping (optional) Mayonnaise, for topping (optional) interfaith families. Celebrate Christmas and Chanukah togetherChrismukkah, as its become knownwith this sparkling Star of David on top of your tree. Your trees lights will make the Chanukah tree topper shine even more. Night 3: Glow Sticks Kids love these on the 4th of July and New Years Eve, so why not on Chanukah? Get a bunch of these and distribute them to your family. Turn off the lights and have them wave these as you light your candles for an extra-glowing pizzazz. Night 4: Night Light For kids who dont like the dark, a night light is a must. Make it a fun gift by picking a light with a cute design, such as the GummyLamp Gummy Bear Nightlight. Not only is the light fun and friendly, but kids will be reassured that they wont have to fear the dark after the Chanukah lights go out. For a more adult-appropriate, decorative gift that is also Chanukahthemed, consider something like this Chanukah Glass Block Night Light on Etsy. com. Night 5: Flashlight or Headlamp For the gadget or camping enthusiast, a wearable head lamp will make a cool gift. surveyed the best headlamps of 2015 here. A favorite of mine, which I purchased as a gift, is the Petzl Tikka headlamp. It is available at a number of sporting stores or on Night 6: Donate, Be So cial, Be Creative Use Chanukah as an oc casion to help your local Jewish community. For in stance, host a menorah or candle-donation drive, and use the items to light up the holiday for those in need. Alternatively, contribute to a drive already being run by your local synagogue. As part of this, you can even get your community in the creative mood by organizing an event to make your own Chanukah candles, which can then be donated. Here are candlemaking instructions from Night 7: Unique Menorah If youre choosing to gift someone a menorah, pick something quirky and fun. The International Business Times compiled some ex amples in 2014. Additional Eight de-light-ful gifts for eight Chanukah nights Phil Shirley via Flickr Glow sticks. The GummyLamp Gummy Bear Nightlight. Alina Dain Sharon Alina Dain Sharons unique Chanukah menorah. A sapphire and diamond necklace. Internet research will surely yield a multitude of options. Pictured is one that I received as a gift some time ago. Night 8: Diamonds What special someone doesnt like diamonds? Whether or not you have an additional reason to splurge, or just because, a shining piece of jewelry will surely make her smile this Chanu kah. While you can gift this on any night, waiting until the eighth night of Chanukah could make this gift extra spe cial. And if she wears the piece next to the menorah candles, she will sparkle with light like the beautiful lady she is. Honorary mentions: The Glow in the Dark Dreidel Glasses or the LED Light-Up Chanukah Menorah Neck laces for some extra humor and fun! By Alina Dain Sharon Chanukah is known as the Festival of Lights. On each night we light one more candle to remember the vic tory of the Maccabees over the Greeks and the rededication of the Second Temple. But there are more ways to create light than using Chanukah menorah candles. offers a list of eight gifts, one for each night of the holiday, that are guaranteed to light up your friend or loved-ones Chanukah. Night 1: Lantern Lanterns can make won derful gifts. Consider buying a unique, decorative lantern like this example from Etsy. com, or if youre on a budget or feeling crafty, make it yourself. A gift can be much more meaningful when you try to make it more personal. Check out the instructions for these 11 DIY lanterns from Country Living that you can customize for in-door use during Chanukah. Night 2: Chanukah Tree Topper This Christmas tree top per, which gained publicity with an appearance on the Shark Tank reality TV show, might just be the thing for 205 North Street Longwood, FL 32750 Bring in this ad and receive 18% DiscountInvitations & AnnouncementsBrochures & Booklets Forms & Letterheads Business Cards C ustom Pri nting Direct Mail Services Envelopes 407-767-7110