I'm tired and I know you ain't worth it: Subjectivity at the intersection of camp taste and queer phenomenology

MISSING IMAGE

Material Information

Title:
I'm tired and I know you ain't worth it: Subjectivity at the intersection of camp taste and queer phenomenology
Physical Description:
Project in lieu of thesis
Language:
English
Creator:
Dees, James Budd
Publisher:
College of Fine Arts; University of Florida
Place of Publication:
Gainesville, Fla
Publication Date:

Notes

Abstract:
“…the!term!‘orientation’!…!is!merely!a!directional!metaphor!drawn!from! magnetism!and!navigation,!which!has!gradually!superseded!the!directional! metaphors!used!prior!to!the!1970s:!inclination,!deviant,!pervert,!invert!…!bent,! drive.”!! –Rictor!Norton! Catherine!Malabou!(2008)!explains!our!brain’s!relationship!to!experience!as!being! literally!shaped!by!its!surroundings,!including!the!social.!But,!too,!the!brain!comes!with!the! power!to!provoke!change,!even!to!‘explode’!given!forms.!(p.!5)!To!echo!and!ground!this! idea!of!shaping,!Sarah!Ahmed!(2006)!points!out!that!“bodies!as!well!as!objects!take!shape! through!being!orientated!toward!each!other”!(p.!54).!I!would!like!to!explore!the!plasticity!of! my!interactions!with!objects!that!are!within!reach,!objects!of!habit,!and!objects!of! expectation.!But!I!want!to!use!these!objects!to!draw!a!link!to!social!and!sexual!difference.!If,! as!Ahmed!points!out,!that!direct!and!straight!experiences!of!objects!are!normal,!then!a! ‘queer!phenomenology’!notes!the!pressures!of!deviating!from!expected!spatial!encounters.! ! 8! Ahmed!uses!these!descriptors!for!a!‘queered’!objecthood:!turning,!slanted,!twisted,!bent,! crooked.!! The!projects!I!will!present!will!visually!interpret!a!‘queer!phenomenology’!by! revisiting!Minimalist!sculpture!with!a!queered!intentionality.!The!Minimalist!cube!made! from!papierjmâché,!retaining!my!handprints,!the!sides!decorated!with!stars,!the!front! holding!a!salvaged!piece!of!metal!implying!that!the!cube!is!an!abstracted!chest!of!drawers,! and!the!back!showing!the!word!‘turtle’!misspelled!a!dozen!times.!These!features,!that! would!be!considered!extraneous!by!a!Minimalist,!are!indexical.!If!the!indexical!can!carry! varying!degrees!of!specificity,!then!this!object!will!run!the!gamut!from!a!generalized!notion! of!queer!history!in!its!incorporation!of!attention!to!surface!décor,!to!a!memory!of!not! knowing!how!to!spell!the!word!‘turtle’!in!second!grade,!to!the!very!moment!of!its!taking! form!in!the!marks!of!my!hands!that!patted!down!the!pulped!paper.! “The!surfaces!of!bodies!are!shaped!by!what!is!reachable.”!(Ahmed,!2006,!p.!55)! Another!section!of!the!work!will!consider!objects!that!are!‘within!reach’!and!how!to!disrupt! their!expected!actions!and!relations!to!my!physical!and!emotional!being.!A!video!of!my! most!prized!possession,!a!lifejsized!poster!of!Whoopi!Goldberg,!is!transformed!from!a! narrative!about!this!acquired!item!to!a!diaristic!retelling!of!waiting!impatiently!for!a!lover.! What!it!is!like!to!be!in!a!relationship,!what!that!intimacy!means!is!the!raw!content!of!the! video.!But!that!intimacy!must!be!shaped,!eroded,!and!encountered!with!our!available! models!of!expression.!! It!is!my!hope!that!this!series!of!work!will!create!a!precarious!representation!of! queer!subjectivity!by!linking!the!sensorial!and!experiential!with!the!social!and!sentimental! body.!!I!hope!to!redefine!the!demands!of!objecthood!as!not!merely!forms!for!truth!or!the! ! 9! objective,!but!forms!that!also!account!for!different!and!new!shapes!which!create!different!“…the term ‘orientation’ … is merely a directional metaphor drawn from magnetism and navigation, which has gradually superseded the directional metaphors used prior to the 1970s: inclination, deviant, pervert, invert … bent, drive.” –Rictor Norton Catherine Malabou (2008) explains our brain’s relationship to experience as being literally shaped by its surroundings, including the social. But, too, the brain comes with the power to provoke change, even to ‘explode’ given forms. (p. 5) To echo and ground this idea of shaping, Sarah Ahmed (2006) points out that “bodies as well as objects take shape through being orientated toward each other” (p. 54). I would like to explore the plasticity of my interactions with objects that are within reach, objects of habit, and objects of expectation. But I want to use these objects to draw a link to social and sexual difference. If, as Ahmed points out, that direct and straight experiences of objects are normal, then a ‘queer phenomenology’ notes the pressures of deviating from expected spatial encounters. Ahmed uses these descriptors for a ‘queered’ objecthood: turning, slanted, twisted, bent, crooked. The projects I will present will visually interpret a ‘queer phenomenology’ by revisiting Minimalist sculpture with a queered intentionality. The Minimalist cube made from papier-mâché, retaining my handprints, the sides decorated with stars, the front holding a salvaged piece of metal implying that the cube is an abstracted chest of drawers, and the back showing the word ‘turtle’ misspelled a dozen times. These features, that would be considered extraneous by a Minimalist, are indexical. If the indexical can carry varying degrees of specificity, then this object will run the gamut from a generalized notion of queer history in its incorporation of attention to surface décor, to a memory of not knowing how to spell the word ‘turtle’ in second grade, to the very moment of its taking form in the marks of my hands that patted down the pulped paper. “The surfaces of bodies are shaped by what is reachable.” (Ahmed, 2006, p. 55) Another section of the work will consider objects that are ‘within reach’ and how to disrupt their expected actions and relations to my physical and emotional being. A video of my most prized possession, a life-sized poster of Whoopi Goldberg, is transformed from a narrative about this acquired item to a diaristic retelling of waiting impatiently for a lover. What it is like to be in a relationship, what that intimacy means is the raw content of the video. But that intimacy must be shaped, eroded, and encountered with our available models of expression. It is my hope that this series of work will create a precarious representation of queer subjectivity by linking the sensorial and experiential with the social and sentimental body. I hope to redefine the demands of objecthood as not merely forms for truth or the objective, but forms that also account for different and new shapes which create different and new encounters with a very specific set of experiences and meanings. and!new!encounters!with!a!very!specific!set!of!experiences!and!meanings.!
General Note:
Art and Technology terminal project

Record Information

Source Institution:
University of Florida Institutional Repository
Holding Location:
University of Florida
Rights Management:
All rights reserved by the source institution and holding location.
System ID:
AA00017789:00001


This item is only available as the following downloads:


Full Text

PAGE 1

! #$%!&#'()!*+)!#!,+-.!/-0!*#+$&!.-'&1!#&2 3045(6#&/ *&!&1(!#+&('3(6&#-+!-8!6*%9!&*3&(!*+)!:0(('!91(+-%(+-;-?@!3ABCCBDE!61*#' 3BDFGH!7BF>E!%(%4(' .BI!,JGCBE!%(%4(' *!9'-5(6&!#+! ;#(0!-8!&1(3#3!9'(3(+&()!&-!&1(!6-;;(<(!-8!8#+(!*'&3 -8!&1(!0+#7('3#&/!-8!8;-'#)*!#+!9*'&#*;!80;8#;;%(+&! -8!&1(!'(:0#'(%(+&3!8-'!&1(!)(<'((!-8! %*3&('!-8!8#+(!*'&3 0+#7('3#&/!-8!8;-'#)* KL"M

PAGE 2

! K ! ! ! N!KL"M!5*%(3!40))!)((3

PAGE 3

! M ! ! &H!.OHHPG!=I &H!.OHHPG!
PAGE 4

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

PAGE 5

! [ &*4;(!-8!6-+&(+&3 *6,+-.;()<(%(+&3 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ \\\\\\\\ YY!U ;#3&!-8!8#<0'(3 \\\\\\\\\ \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\Y![ *43&'*6& \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ YYY ] 61*9&(' *!%-+0%(+&!&-!'#61*')!&0&&;( ^ K :0(('!91(+-%(+-;-
PAGE 6

! ] ;#3&!-8!8#<0'(3 8GFSDB!"2!'G?O>DQ!&SAAJBE! !"#$%&'()*+,-.+% E!"_]` 8GFSDB!K2!5SQ=!6OG?>FHE! !+/+0&.+'123&/+4&#/'56&0'7&/'89: E!"_`L 8GFSDB!M2!8>=B!)SC>T>=!>I!5H>C!6D>TVHDQ!GC! ;-<<2&'=&+#&/* E!"_a" b 8GFSDBI!HV!THD@!GC!9DHZB?A!GC!;GBS!HV!&OBIGI!8HJJHTI!AOB!ABcAd

PAGE 7

! ` 3SXX>D=!HV!9DHZB?A GC!;GBS!HV!&OBIGI 9DBIBCABQ!AH!AOB!6HJJBFB!HV!8GCB!*DAI!HV!AOB!0CGWBDIGA=!HV!8JHDGQ> GC!9>DAG>J!8SJVGJJXBCA!HV!AOB!'BeSGDBXBCAI!VHD!AOB! )BFDBB!HV!%>IABD!HV!8GCB!*DAI 4(+ )E!3;*+&E!;#%9E!8;0&&(' 4= 5>XBI! 4SQQ!)BBI *SFSIA KL"M 6O>GD2!5>?@!3ABCCBD %>ZHD2! *DA f\ AOB!ABDX!gHDGBCA>AGHC$! \! GI!XBDBJ=!>!QGDB?AGHC>J!XBA>POHD!QD>TC!VDHX! X>FCBAGIX!>CQ!C>WGF>AGHCE!TOG?O!O>I!FD>QS>JJ=!ISPBDIBQBQ!AOB!QGDB?AGHC>J! XBA>POHDI!SIBQ!PDGHD! AH!AOB!"_`LI2!GC?JGC>AGHCE!QBWG>CAE!PB DWBDAE!GCWBDA!\! RBCAE! QDGWBYh! i 'G?AHD!+HDAHC 6>AOBDGCB!%>J>RHS bKLLad BcPJ>GCI!HSD!RD>GC$I!DBJ>AGHCIOGP!AH!BcPBDGBC?B!>I! RBGCF! JGABD>JJ=!IO>PBQ!R=!GAI!ISDDHSCQGCFIE!GC?JSQGCF!AOB!IH?G>JY 4SAE!AHHE!AOB!RD>GC! ?HXBI!TGAO AOB! PHTBD!AH!PDHWH@B!?O>CFBE!BWBC!AH!gBcPJHQB$!FGWBC!VHDXIY b PY! [d &H!B?OH!>CQ!FDHSCQ AOGI! GQB>!HV!IO>PGCFE!3>D>O!*OXBQ bKLL]d PHGCAI!HSA!AO>A!fRHQGBI!>I!TBJJ!>I!HRZB?AI!A>@B!IO>PB! AODHSFO!RBGCF!HDGBCA>ABQ!AHT>DQ!B>?O!HAOBDh bPY! [U d Y #!THSJQ!JG@B!AH!BcPJH DB!AOB!PJ>IAG?GA=!HV! X=!GCABD>?AGHCI!TGAO!HRZB?AI!AO>A!>DB!TGAOGC!DB>?OE!HRZB?AI!HV!O>RGAE!>CQ!HRZB?AI!HV! BcPB?A>AGHCY!4SA!#!T>CA!AH!SIB!AOBIB!HRZB?AI!AH!QD>T!>!JGC@!AH!IH?G>J!>CQ!IBcS>J!QGVVBDBC?BY!#VE! >I!*OXBQ!PHGCAI!HSAE!AO>A!QGDB?A!>CQ!IAD>GFOA!BcPBDGB C?BI!HV!HRZB?AI!>DB!CHDX>JE!AOBC!>! geSBBD!POBCHXBCHJHF=$!CHABI!AOB! PDBIISDBI!HV!QBWG>AGCF!VDHX!BcPB?ABQ!IP>AG>J!BC?HSCABDIY!

PAGE 8

! a *OXBQ!SIBI!AOBIB!QBI?DGPAHDI!VHD! >! geSBBDBQ$!HRZB?AOHHQ2!ASDCGCFE!IJ>CABQE!ATGIABQE!RBCAE! ?DHH@BQY! &OB!PDHZB?AI!#!TGJJ!PDBIBCA!TGJJ WGIS>JJ=!GCABDPDBA!>!geSBBD!POBCHXBCHJHF=$!R=! DBWGIGAGCF!%GCGX>JGIA!I?SJPASDB!TGAO!>!eSBBDBQ!GCABCAGHC>JGA=Y!&OB!%GCGX >JGIA!?SRB!X>QB! VDHX!P>PGBD j Xk?Ol E!DBA>GCGCF!X=!O>CQPDGCAIE!AOB IGQB I QB?HD>ABQ!TGAO!IA>DIE!AOB!VDHCA! OHJQGCF! >!I>JW>FBQ!PGB?B!HV!XBA>J!G XPJ=GCF!AO>A!AOB!?SRB!GI!>C!>RIAD>?ABQ!?OBIA!HV!QD>TBDIE! >CQ!AOB!R>?@!IOHTGCF!AOB!THDQ!gASDAJB$ XGIIPBJJBQ!>!QHmBC!AGXBI Y!&OBIB!VB>ASDBI E AO>A! THSJQ!RB!?HCIGQBDBQ!BcAD>CBHSI!R=!>!%GCGX>JGIA E >DB!GCQBcG?>JY!#V!AOB!GCQBcG?>J!?>C!?>DD=! W>D=GCF!QBFDBBI!HV!IPB? GVG?GA=E!AOBC!AOGI!HRZB?A!TGJJ!DSC!AOB!F>XSA!VDHX!>!FBCBD>JGmBQ!CHAGHC! HV!eSBBD!OGIAHD=!GC!GAI!GC?HDPHD>AGHC!HV!>AABCAGHC!AH!ISDV>?B!Ql?HDE!AH!>!XBXHD=!HV!CHA! @CHTGCF!OHT!AH!IPBJJ!AOB!THDQ!gAS DAJB$!GC!IB?HCQ!FD>QB E!AH!AOB!WBD=!XHXBCA!HV!GAI!A>@GCF! VHDX!GC! AOB!X>D@I!HV!X=!O>CQI!AO>A!P>AABQ!QHTC!AOB! PSJPBQ! P> PBD Y f &OB!ISDV>?BI!HV!RHQGBI!>DB!IO>PBQ!R=!TO>A!GI!DB>?O>RJBYh! b*OXBQE!KLL]E!PY! [[ d *CHAOBD!IB?AGHC!HV!AOB!THD@!TG JJ!?HCIGQBD! H RZB?AI!AO>A!>DB!gTGAOGC!DB>?O$!>CQ!OHT!AH!QGIDSPA! AOBGD!BcPB?ABQ!>?AGHCI!>CQ! DBJ>AGHCI!AH X=!PO=IG?>J!>CQ!BXHAGHC>J!RBGCF Y! *!WGQBH!HV!X=! XHIA!PDGmBQ!PHIIBIIGHCE!>!JGVB j IGmBQ!PHIABD!HV!.OHHPG!CIVHDXBQ!VDHX!>! C>D D>AGWB!>RHSA!AOGI!>?eSGDBQ!GABX AH!>!QG>DGIAG?!DBABJJGCF!HV!T>GAGCF!GXP>AGBCAJ=!VHD!>!JHWBDY! .O>A!GA!GI!JG@ B!AH!RB!GC!>!DBJ>AGHCIOGPE!TO>A!AO>A!GCAGX>?=!XB>CI!GI!AOB!D>T!?HCABCA!HV!AOB! WGQBHY!4SA!AO>A!GCAGX>?=!XSIA!RB!IO>PBQE!BDHQBQE!>CQ!BC?HSCABDBQ!TGAO!HSD!>W>GJ>RJB! XHQBJI!HV!BcPDBIIGHCY! #A!GI!X=!OHPB!AO>A!AOGI!IBDGBI!HV!THD@!TGJJ!?DB>AB!>!PDB?>DGHSI!DBPDBIB CA>AGHC!HV! eSBBD!ISRZB?AGWGA=!R=!JGC@GCF!AOB!IBCIHDG>J!>CQ!BcPBDGBCAG>J!TGAO!AOB!IH?G>J!>CQ!IBCAGXBCA>J! RHQ=Y!!#!OHPB!AH!DBQ BVGCB!AOB!QBX>CQI!HV!HRZB?AOHHQ!>I!CHA!XBDBJ=!VHDXI!VHD AD SAO!HD!AOB!

PAGE 9

! HRZB?AGWBE!RSA!VHDXI! AO>A!>JIH!>??HSCA!VHD!QGVVBDBCA!>CQ!CBT!IO >PBI!TOG?O!?DB>AB!QGVVBDBCA! >CQ!CBT!BC?HSCABDI!TGAO!>!WBD=!IPB?GVG?!IBA!HV!BcPBDGBC?BI >CQ!XB>CGCFI Y

PAGE 10

! "L 61*9&('!" *!%-+0%(+&!&-!'#61*')!&0&&;(^ &OB!J>DFB!RJH?@!IA>CQI!>JXHIA!VGWB!VBBA!A>JJ!>CQ!AODBB!VBBA!TGQBY!#A!GI!P>JB!FDBBC!>CQ! ?HWBDBQ!TGAO! O>CQPDGCAI Y &OB!RDH>Q!IGQB!AO>A!HCB!>PPDH>?OBI!GI!RJ>C@n!AOBDB!GI!>!RDH@BC j HVV! O>CQJB!VDHX!>!?OBIA!HV!QD>TBDI!HC!AOB!HPPHIGAB!IGQBY!3A>DI!JGCB!AOB!AHP!>CQ!>!C>DDHT!IGQBn! AOB!HPPHIGAB!C>DDHT!IGQB!O>I!AOB!THDQ!gASDAJB$!XGIIPBJJBQ!ABC!AGXBIY!&OBDB!GI!>!TOGAB! GCQBCA>AGHC HC!HCB!HV!AOB!AHP!?HDCBDI!HV!AOB!RHcY! >"#*%&'?-@ GCADHQS?BI!AOB!WGBTBD!AH!AOB! DBIA!HV!X=!IOHTY! -CB!HV!X=!PDHVBIIHDI!>I@BQ!GV!AOGI!T>I!>!XHCSXBCA!AH!'G?O>DQ!&SAAJBE!XGIA>@GCF!AOB! GCABCQBQ!THDQ!>I!g&SAAJB$!D>AOBD!A O>C!gASDAJB$Y!3H!#!TGJJ!SIB!&SAAJB!>I!>!V GFSDB!HV!GCIPGD>AGHC! VHD >"#*%&'?-@ E!>I!>!T>=!AH!RBFGC!AH!A>J@!>RHSA!AOGI!PGB?B!>CQ!AOB!DBIA!HV!X=!THD@Y! 8HD!>!ISXX>AGHC!HV!AOB!FBCBD>J!ADBCQI!AO>A!&SAAJB!>DHIB!VDHXE!5>XBI!%B=BD!bKLLLd! CHABI!AOB!VHJJHTGCF E!IS??GC?AJ= 2 f9DGX>DGJ=!I?SJPASDBE!%GCGX>J!>DA!A BCQI!AH!?HCIGIA!HV!IGCFJB!HD!DBPB>ABQ! FBHXBADG?!VHDXIY!#CQSIADG>JJ=!PDHQS?BQ!HD!RSGJA!R=!I@GJJBQ!THD@BDI!VHJJHTGCF! AOB!>DAGIA$I!GCIADS?AGHCIE!GA!DBXHWBI!>C=!AD>?B!HV!BXHAGHC!HD!GCASGAGWB!QB?GIGHC j X>@GCFE!GC!IA>D@!?HCAD>IA!AH!AOB!*RIAD>?A!(cPDBIIGHCGIA!P>GC AGCF!>CQ!I?SJPASDB! AO>A!PDB?BQBQ!GA!QSDGCF!AOB!"_ULI!>CQ!"_[LIY!%GCGX>J!THD@!QHBI!CHA!>JJSQB! AH!>C=AOGCF!RB=HCQ!GAI!JGABD>J!PDBIBC?BE!HD!GAI!BcGIABC?B!GC!AOB!PO=IG?>J!THDJQY! %>ABDG>JI!>PPB>D!>I!X>ABDG>JIn!?HJHSD!bGV!SIBQ!>A >JJd!GI!CHC j DBVBDBCAG>JY!b PY "[d

PAGE 11

! "" &SAAJBE!TOGJB!IAGJJ!SIGCF! FBHXBADG?!VHDXIE!O>I! >JDB>Q=!QHCB!>T>=!TGAO! X>C=!HV!AOB!ABCQBC?GBI! HV!%GCGX>JGIXY!%S?O! JG@B!&SAAJB$I!SIB!HV!Q=BQ! V>RDG? E!>CQ!BWBCAS>JJ=! P>PBDE!VHD!OGI! H?A>FHCIE! X=!PGB?B!GI!X>QB!HV! ?OB>P!>CQ!B>IGJ=!>?eSGDBQ! X>ABDG>JIE!IA=DHVH>X >CQ!P>PBDY!&OB!THD@!QHBI!CHA!DBJ=!HC!>C=!P>DAG?SJ>D!BcPBDAGIB!>CQ!CH! J>RHD!GI!HSAIHSD?BQY!&OB!I?SJPASDB$I!RHc!IO>PBE!TOGJB!P>=GCF!AOB!I>XB!OHX>FB!AH! %GCGX>JGIX!>I!&SAAJB$I!H?A>FHCIE!PDBVBDI!GQGHI=C?D>I=!AH!V>?AHD=!V>RDG?>AGHCY!#C!DBVBDBC?B!AH! &SAAJB$I!P>P BD!H?A>FHCIE!'HRBDA!9GC?SI j .GAABC b "_``d DB?>JJIE!f&OB!J>ABD!H?A>FHCI!TBDB! XHDB!B??BCADG?E!BXPJH=GCF!FDB>ABD!CSXRBDI!HV!W>DGBF>ABQ!JBCFAOI!AH!AOB!IGQBI!>CQ!XHDB! SC>CAG?GP>ABQ!GCABDGHD!>CFJBIY!g&OB!J>AB D!HCBI!>DB!RBAABDE$!I>GQ!&SAAJB h bPY]adY #C!AOB!I>XB! GC ABDWGBTE &SAAJB!BWBC!PDBQG?AI!OGI!HTC!V>GJSDBI2!f#$Q!JG@B!AH!X>@B!>JJ!IGc!H?A>FHCI!A OB!I>XBY! 4SA!#$JJ!CBWBD!QH!AO>A hb9GC?SI j .GAABC E!"_``E PY! ]ad Y &OB!PBDIHC>J!X>D@I!HV!AOB!>DAGIA!A>@B! PDGHDGA=!HWBD!OGI!?HXPJBAB!DBXHW>J!VDHX!AOB!THD@Y!%HIA!GXPHDA>CAJ=!AH!XB GI!AO>A!&SAAJB! O>I!DBASDCBQ!OGI!O>CQ!AH!A OB!THD@!HV!AOB!XGCGX>J!HRZB?AY! &OHSFO!BWBC!TGAOGC!%GCG X>JGIX! Bc?BPAGHCI!?>C!RB!VHSCQ2! *FCBI!%>DAGC$I!FDGQI!>CQ!AOBGD!fBWBD j IH j IJGFOAJ=!HVV!>JGFCXBCA! 8GFSDB!"!'G?O>DQ!&SAAJBE! !"#$%&'()*+,-.+% E!"_]`

PAGE 12

! "K ISFFBIAI!>C!>DRGAD>DGCBII!>CQ!O>CQX>QBCBII!GC!?HXPJBAB!HPPHIGAGHC AH!JGABD>JGIA!XBAOHQh! b%B=BD E!5YE!KLLLE!PY KUdY >"#*%&'?-@ T>I!?HCIADS?ABQ!TGAO!PSJPBQ!P>PBD!>CQ!FJSB!P>AABQ!QHTC!R=!O>CQn! AOBDBVHDBE!GA!IAGJJ!JGABD>JJ=!OHJQI!GXPDGCAI!HV!X=!O>CQIY!&OB!GXPDB?GIGHC!HV!AOB!I A>DIE!ABcAE! PJ>?BXBCA!HV!AOB DSIABQ!O>CQJBE!?HCAH SDI!HV!AOB!GCQBCA>AGHCE!B>?O!DBVSIB!AOB!CHAGHC!HV!>C! HRZB?A!PBDVB?ABQ!R=!V>?AHD=!AHHJI!HD!I@GJJBQ!J>RHDY!&OB!GXPJG?>AGHC!HV!AOGI!GI!AO>A!AOB!THD@! X>@BI!DBVBDBC?B!AH!AOB!>DAGIAE!AOB!>DAGIA$I!RHQ=E!AOB!T>=!AO>A!AOB!>DAGIA$I!RHQ=!GCABD>?AI!TGAO! AOB!THDJQE!>CQ BWBC!AOB!?OHG?B!HV!AOB!>DAGIAY!*JJ!HV!AOBIB!>DB!GQGHI=C?D>AG?!>CQ!>JJ!HV!AOBIB!>DB! BcPDBIIBQ!R=!AOB!PGB?B!GC!WBD=!PO=IG?>J!ABDXIY! .OGJB!X>C=!>IPB?AI!HV! X=!I?SJPASD>J!THD@!QBI?BCQ! VDHX!&SAAJBE!AOBDB!>DB!>!VBT! GXPHDA>CA!QGIAGC?AGHCIY!&SAAJB! WGBTI!OGI!FH >J!>I!>!CBT!A=PB!HV! PSDGVG?>AGHCE!fgAOB!@GCQ!HV!PSDGA=! AO>A!?HXBI!HSA!HV!AOB!?HXPJBAB! BJB?ADG?>J!VSC?AGHCGCF!HV!AOB! TOHJB!OSX>C!RBGCF jj AO>A$I!AOB! @GCQ!HV!PSDGA=!#!>IPGDB!AHY!&H!RB! VDBB!HV!IBCIBI!>CQ!AOB!GCABJJB?AY! #!THSJQ!DB>JJ=!JG@B!AH!RB! GFCHD>CAY$!&OB! oBC!HWBDAHCBI!GC!AOBIB!IBCAGXBCAI!>DB!CHA!GC?GQBCA>JYh!b9GC?SI j .GAABC E!"_``E! PY ]_d!'G?O>DQ!&SAAJB!T>CAI!AH!?HCCB?A!OGI!THD@!AH!IGXPJG?GA=!GC!>!T>=!AO>A!GXPJGBI! 8GFSDB!K2!5SQ=!6OG?>FHE! !+/+0&.+'123&/+4&#/'6&0'7&/'89 E!"_`L

PAGE 13

! "M AD>CI?BCQBC?BE!>I!9GC?SI j .GAABC!CHABI!GC!AOB!J>IA!IBCABC?BY!*CQ!AOGI!XHWBI!&SAAJB!>!RGA! VSDAOBD >T>=!VDHX!X=!WGBT!HV!>!DBIPHCIGRJB!T>=!AH!DBASDC!ISRZB?AGWGA=!AH!AOB!>DA!HRZB?AY!*C! >PPDH>?O!TOG?O!?HCIGQBDI!BAOG?I!XHDB!?JHIBJ=!THSJQ!RB!AOB!PHJGAG?>JJ=!?O>DFBQ! QBWBJHPXBCA!HV!5SQ=!6OG?>FH$I!PD>?AG?BE!TOG?O!fDBVJB?AI!>!J>DFBD!ABCQBC?=!HV!B>DJ=!VBXGCGIA! P D>?AG?B!AH!GCVSIB!AOB!%GCGX>J!>CQ!PHIA j %GCGX>J!GQGHXI!TGAO!X>D@I!HV!VBX>JB!ISRZB?AGWGA=! QSDGCF!AOB!"_`LIh!b%B=BD E!5YE!KLLLE!PY M]dY!-DE!RBAABD!IAGJJE!AOB!%GCGX>JGIX!HV!*CCB!&DSGAAE! TOG?O!>RIAD>?AI!HRZB?AI!HV!CHIA>JFG>!>CQ!DBJ>AB!QGDB?AJ=!AH!PBDIHC>J!XBXHD= Y! *QQGAGHC>JJ=E!&SAAJB$I!THD@!RJSDI!AOB!QGIAGC?AGHC!RBATBBC!P>GCAGCF!>CQ!I?SJPASDB!GC!>! CHCDBPDBIBCA>AGHC>J!T>=E!fAOB!@GCQ!HV!PG?AHDG>JGmGCF!I?SJPASDB!TOG?O!DBISJAI!TOBC!AOB! QBPG?ABQ!?HCAHSD!>CQ!AOB!DB>J!?H CAHSD!HV!>C!GX>FB!>DB!?HCFDSBCA h b9GC?SI j .GAABCE "_``E!PY! ]]dY &SAAJB$I!THD@!RB?HXBI!AHA>JJ=!OBDXBAG?!GC!GAI!DBVSI>J!HV!GJJSIGHC!>CQ!GAI!GCIGIABC?B!HC! R>DB j RHCBI!IGXPJG?GA=Y! >"#*%&'?-@ E!OHTBWBDE!?DB>ABI!>!PG?AHDG>J!ISDV>?B!VDHX!B>?O!IGQB!HV!AOB! RHcE!?DB>AGCF!QGFDBIIGHCI!HV!X>C=!QGVVBDBCA!HDQBDIY!&OB!IAD S?ASDB!GI!WBD=!XS?O!?HC?BDCBQ! TGAO!ISDV>?BY!&OB!HRZB?A!GI!CHA!TO>A!GA!GIY!#A!OGQBI!>!IA=DHVH>X!VD>XBY!#A!QGIFSGIBI!?BDA>GC! X>ABDG>J!>AADGRSABIE!IS?O!>I!TBGFOA!>CQ!QBCIGA=Y!#A!ADB>AI!B>?O!ISDV>?B!>I!>!IGAB!VHD! DBPDBIBCA>AGHC!bVSDAOBD!QGIAD>?AGHCI!VDHX!HRZB? AGWB!>CQ!X>ABDG>J!V>?AdY! &OB!HRZB?A!GI!CHA!?HC?BDCBQ!TGAO!>!IB>XJBII!?D>VA!HD!>!gVGCGIO!VBAGIO$Y!#A!?HCIA>CAJ=! DBVBDBC?BI!GAI!HTC!?HCIADS?AGHC!TGAO!AOB!GCABFD>AGHC!HV!X=!O>CQPDGCAIY &OB!FDBBC!?HJHD!HV! AOB!RHc!DBVBDBC?BI!AOB!?HJHD!HV!>!ASDAJBE!?J>DGVGBQ!R= AOB!AGAJB! >"#*%&'?-@ Y &OB!OHJB!>A!AOB!AHP! ?HDCBD!HV!AOB!RHc!T>I!?DB>ABQ!R=!X=!?>AE!ZSXPGCF!HCAH!>CQ!QBIADH=GCF!>!P>DA!HV!AOB! IA=DHVH>X!R>IB!RBVHDB!AOB!P>PGBD!X>?OB!T>I!>QQBQY!&OB!ABcA!QHTC!HCB!IGQB!DBVBDI!AH!>! XBXHD=!HV!O>WGCF!AH!IPBJJ!AOB!THDQ!gASDAJB$!G C!VDHCA!HV!X=!IB?HCQ!FD>QB!?J>IIY &OB!XBA>J!HC! AOB!R>?@!HV!AOB!RHc!GI!>!I>JW>FBQ!O>CQJB!VDHX!>!QDBIIBDY!&OGI!GXPJGBI!AOB!FBCBDG?!DBJ>AGHCI!HV!

PAGE 14

! "U gOHXB$E!gQHXBIAG?$E!>CQ!XHDB!IPB?GVG?>JJ=!DBJ>ABI!AOB!IO>PB!HV!AOB!RHc!AH!>!PGB?B!HV!VSDCGASDBY &OB!IA>DI!>JHCF!AO B!AHP!>CQ!IB?HCQ!IGQB!HV!AOB!PGB?B!BcGIA!>I!QB?HD>AGHCY!&OB!>?A!HV! QB?HD>AGCF!DB>?OBI!AHT>DQI!AOB!GQB>!HV!g6>XPGCF$!%GCGX>JGIXE!?HJHDGCF!AOB!IBcS>JGA=!HV! IS?O!>C!HRZB?A!>I!eSBBD!>CQ!QBX>CQGCF!>!eSBBDBQ!>PPDH>?OY &OGI!I?SJPASDB!IGAI!RBVHDB!AOB!DBIA!HV!X=!P GB?BI!RB?>SIB!GA!>AABXPAI!AH!BcPJHQB!AOB! RHc!GCAH!X>C=!W>D=GCF!QGDB?AGHCIE!QGVVBDBCA!ABCQBC?GBI!TOG?O!VGCQ!DBIHC>C?BI!TGAO!AOB! HAOBD!PGB?BIY!0JAGX>ABJ=!AOB!PGB?B!>AABXPAI!AH!?HWBD!>!%GCGX>JGIA!ABCQBC?=!TGAO!AOB! J>CFS>FB!HV!6>XP E!>CQ!AOBC!JGC@!6>XP!AH!eSBB D!OGIAHDGBI!>CQ!>!eSBBD!?HCIGQBD>AGHC!HV! POBCHXBCHJHF=Y!#A!GI!X=!OHPB!AO>A!AOB!GCABDIB?AGHC!HV!AOBIB!AOBXBI!HPBCI!>RIAD>?AGHC!AH! CBT!PHIIGRGJGAGBI!TOG?O!?>C!RB!IGXSJA>CBHSIJ=!IH?GHPHJGAG?>JE!?SJASD>JE!>CQ!OGIAHDG?>JJ=! >T>DBE!RSA!>JIH!QG>DGIAG?>JJ=!GCAGX>AB Y! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! &OGI!GI!CHA!AH!I>=!AO>A!?>XP!GI!AOB!HCJ=!eSBBD!OGIAHD=!HD!BWBC!AOB!JGCB>FB!TOG?O! QBIBDWBI! AOB!XHIA!>AABCAGHCY!#AI!J>CFS>FB!HV!>??BIIGRGJGA=!>CQ!BCZH=XBCA!HV!PHPSJ>D!?SJASDB!>AAD>?AI! X=!>DA!PD>?AG?BY!4SA!AH!?HCVJ>AB!eSBBD!OGIAHD=!TGAO!?>XP!THSJQ!RB!AH!GFCHDB!XBQG?>J!>CQ! PI=?OHJHFG?>J!OGIAHDGBIE!AOB!AD>ZB?AHD=!HV!>?AGWGIX!>CQ!PHJGAG?I!GC AOB!C>DDHTBIA!IBCIBE!HD!AOB! C>DD>AGWB!HV!OHXHPOHRG>Y!+HD!>DB!AOBIB!OGIAHDGBI!XSAS>JJ=!Bc?JSIGWBY!&OB!ADG>J!HV!-I?>D! .GJQBE!VHD!Bc>XPJBE!THSJQ!RB!DBJBW>CA!AH!>!VBT!HV!AOBIB!ISRIAD>ABIE!GC?JSQGCF!?>XPY K &OGI!GI!CHA!AH!I>=!AO>A!>JJ!eSBBD!RHQGBI!JHH@!>JG@BY! +HD!GI!GA!AH!I>=!AO>A!>JJ!eSBBD!RHQGBI!IBJV j

PAGE 15

! "[ 61*9&('!K :0(('!91(+-%(+-;-C!HRJHCF!DHSCQ!TOG?O!?SDJI!GCAH!GAIBJV!ZSIA!BCHSFO!VHD!AOB!BCQI!AH!HWBDJ>P! TGAOHSA!?JHIGCF!AOB!IO>PBY!&OB!RSJ@GCBII!HV AOB!IO>PB!DBISJAI!VDHX!AOB!I>XB!X>ABDG>J! ADB>AXB CA!HV! >"#*%&'?-@ Y!b#A!GI!P>PGBD j Xk?Ol Y!#A!GI!?JSXI=!>CQ!>!IO>PB!TOG?O!J>?@I!BJBF>C?BY! #A!OHJQI!O>CQ!PDGCAIE!?HCA>GCI!DBJG?I!HV!X=!>?AGHCIE!GI!I@GCCBQ!GC!AOB!PBDVHDX>C?B!HV!GAI!HTC! X>@GCFYd!.OGAB!IPB? @ I!>A!D> CQHX!GCABDW>JI!QHA!AOB!IO>PB$I!V>?BY!#AI!RHQ= AD>CIGAGHCI!VDHX! PSDPJB!AH! RJSBY! A.,#-".0&0GGG GXPBDIHC>ABI!>!CGFOA!I@=!bHD!>I!HCB!XGFOA!>IIH?G>AB!VDHX! HAOBD!PGB?BI!GC!AOB!IOHTE!GXPBDIHC>ABI!AOB!IGXSJ>AGHC!HV!AOB!CGFOA!I@=!GC!?HXPSABD!I?DBBC! R>?@FDHSCQIdY! *! ABcA GI ISPBDGXPHIBQ!HWBD!AOGI!DHSCQBQ!IA>DD=!I@=2!f1B!JBVA!OGI!?>IIBDHJB! QGIO!pp!OB$I!Q>AGCF!IHXBHCB!CBT!pp!7*3&!(%9&#+(33hY!&OB!AD>ZB?AHD=!HV!AOB!VHDX>AGHC!HV! AOGI!PGB?BE!AOB!T>=!GA!GI!J>=BDBQE!VDHX!VHDX!AH!ISDV>?B!AH!DBPDBIBCA>AGHC!AH!ISPBDGXPHIBQ! ABcAE JB>QI!AH!>C!GXPHDA>CA!SCQBDIA>CQGCF!HV!AOB!T>=!AOGI!RHQ=!HV!TH D@!O>I!QBWBJHPBQ! ?HC?BPAS>JJ= jj A OB!THD@!HV!>RIAD>?AGHC!?HDDSPABQ!R=!IBJB?ABQ!6>XP!WH?>RSJ>D=!AH!HPBC!>! IP>?B!VHD!GCAGX>AB!?HCVBIIGHCY! &OB!I?SJPASDBI!GC!AOGI!IOHT!>AABXPA!>! IPB?GVG? SCQBDIA>CQ GCF!HV!IP>?BY!#C!OBD!RHH@! H"&&#'!F&.-<&.-%-,I E!3>D>O!*OXBQ!JGC@I!HSD!>T>DBCBII!HV!IP>?B!>CQ!C>WGF>AGHC!HV!GA!TGAO! IBcS>JGA=Y!3OB!CHABIE!VDHX! %>SDG?B! %BDJB>S j 9HCA=E!AO>A!POBCHXBCHJHF=!GI!CHA!f>!XHQBJ!HV! IP>?B!>I!QBABDXGCBQ!R=!HRZB?AGWB!?HHDQGC>ABI!bIS?O!AO> A!gSP$!>CQ!gQHTC$!BcGIA! GCQBPBCQBCAJ=!HV!HCB$I!RHQGJ=!HDGBCA>AGHCdE!RSA!>I!RBGCF!IO>PBQ!R=!AOB!PSDPHIBVSJCBII!HV! AOB!RHQ=n!AOB!RHQ=!QHBI!AOGCFIE!>CQ!IP>?B!AOSI!A> @BI!IO>PB!>I!>!VGBJQ!HV!>?AGHCh b*OXBQ E! KLL]E!PY ][d Y *!IBcS>J!RHQ=!IOHTI! AOB!HDGBCA>AGHC!HV!> RHQ=!AO>A!GI!fIBCIGAGWB!AH!>JJ!AOB!DBIAh!

PAGE 16

! "] >CQ!>!RHQ=$I!fPDHZB?ABQ!X> CCBD!HV!RBGCF!AHT>DQ!AOB!THDJQh b*OXBQ E!KLL]E!PY ]`d Y 3H!>! geSBBD$!RHQ=! THSJQ!C>WGF>AB!>!OBABDHCHDX>AGWB!THDJQ!GC!QGIAGC?A!T>=IY!3S?O!>!RHQ=!XGFOA! >IIGXGJ>AB!AOBGD!JGVBIA=JB!GCAH!X>GCIADB> X!?SJASDBE!>AABXPA!AH!P>II!>I!CHA!IAD>GFOAE!?>XP!SP! AOBGD!QGIPHIGAGHCY K +HA! HCJ=!>DB!AOBIB!QBIGDBI!CHA!X>GCIADB>X E!>CQ!AOBDBVHDB!CBBQ!>C!SC?HCWBCAGHC>J! XHQ>JGA=E!RSA!AOB=!XSIA!VGFOA!>JDB>Q=!BcGIAGCF!JGCBIY!;GCBI!HV!>?AGHC!>DB!VHDXBQ!R=! DBPBAGAGHCE!RSA!AOB IB!JGCBIE!HC?B!VHDXBQE!>JIH!GCVJSBC?B!RHQGBI!QGDB?AGHC>JJ=Y!&OBIB!VHDXBQ! JGCBI!ABJJ!SI!TO>A!GI!PHIIGRJB!>CQ!TO>A!GI!CHA!PHIIGRJBE!HD!RBAABDE!TO>A!GI!XHDB!PHIIGRJB!HD! JBII!PHIIGRJBY!b*OXBQ E!KLL]E!PY "]d!8>XGJ=!JGCB>FB!GI!IS?O!>!AD>ZB?AHD=E!TOG?O!PDHXPAI!AOB BcPB?A>AGHC!HV!DBPDHQS?AGHC!HV!AOB!V>XGJ=!JBF>?=Y!8HD!XBCE!AOB!JGVB!HV!AOB!V>XGJ=!C>XB!GI!>JIH! >A!IA>@BY!1HXHIBcS>J!QBIGDB!GI!gHSA!HV!JGCB$!TGAO!AOGI!P>AOY!&H!?HCAGCSB!AOB!P>AO!GC!IPGAB!HV! HCB$I!QBIGDB!THSJQ!RB!AH!gIAD>GFOABC$!AOB!>?AGHCI!HV!AOB!GCQGWGQS> J!AH!AOB!BcPB?A>AGHCI!HV! IH?GBA=Y!1HTBWBDE!>!eSBBD!POBCHXBCHJHF=!THSJQ!eSBIAGHC!CHA!OHXHIBcS>J!QBIGDB!>CQ!GA$I! GCABFD>AGHC!TGAOGC!AOGI!I=IABXE!RSA!AOB!I=IABX!TOG?O!QHBI!CHA!BC?HSD>FB!CBT!P>AOI!AH!RB! VHDFBQY! f&OB!ISDV>?BI!HV!RHQGBI!>DB!IO>PBQ!R=!TO>A!GI!D B>?O>RJBY!#CQBBQE!AOB!OGIAHD=!HV! RHQGBI!?>C!RB!DBTDGAABC! >I!AOB!OGIAHD=!HV!AOB!DB>?O>RJB h!b*OXBQ E!KLL]E!PY [[d Y 3H!CHA!HCJ=! QHBI!?HCIBCISIE!PDHAH?HJE!>CQ!O>RGA!QBI?DGRB!TO>A!RHQGBI!?>C!>CQ!IOHSJQ!QHE!RSA!AOB=!>JIH! ABJJ!RHQGBI!TO>A!AH!JHH@!JG@B!>CQ!OHT!AH!B cGIAY!4HQGBI!GCABDC>JGmB!AOBIB!PHABCAG>JGAGBI!>CQ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! K &OGI!GI!CHA!AH!I>=!AO>A!>JJ!eSBBD!RHQGBI!JHH@!>JG@BY! +HD!GI!GA!AH!I>=!AO>A!>JJ!eSBBD!RHQGBI!IBJV j GQBCAGV=!PDGX>DGJ=!>I!eSBBD!HD!>JJ!O>WB!AOB!I>XB!?HC?BDCIY!&H!>WHGQ!>C!BeS>J!DBQS?AGHCE!AOGI! WGBT!HV!POBCHXBCHJHF=!>JIH!QHBI!CHA!>IISXB!AO>A!>JJ!IAD>GFOA!PBHPJB!>DB!AOB!I>XBY!+HD! QHBI!GA!XB>C!AO>A!OBABDHIBcS>JI!> JJ!VGA!PBDVB?AJ=!GCAH!OBABDHCHDX>AGWB!IA>CQ>DQIY!+HD!QHBI!GA! QGI?HSCA!AOB!V>?A!AO>A!PBHPJB!HSAIGQB!HV!geSBBD$!>CQ!gIAD>GFOA$!BcGIAY!:SBBD!POBCHXBCHJHF=!GI! >!AHHJ!VHD!SCQBDIA>CQGCF!>!XSJAGASQB!HV!PHABCAG>JGAGBI!>CQ!QHBI!IH!VHD!>!XSJAGASQB!HV! GQBCAGAGBIY!

PAGE 17

! "` BcOGRGA!AOBGD!DBJ>AGHCIOGP!AH!AOBIB!PHABCAG>JGAGBI!HC!AOBGD!ISDV>?BIE!GC!AOBGD!IO>PBIE!>CQ!GC!AOB! T>=!AO>A!AOB=!PBDVHDXY!(cPB?A>AGHC!>CQ!RHQGBI!?DB>AB!B>?O!HAOBD!XSAS>JJ=!>CQ! ?HCAGCSHSIJ=E!>I!BIA>RJGIOBQ!JG CBI!CBBQ!AH!RB!PDHP>F>ABQ!R=!RHQGBI!>CQ!RHQGBI!CBBQ!AH!RB! IO>PBQ!R=!PHABCAG>J!VGBJQI!HV!>?AGHCY! 3BcS>J!HDGBCA>AGHC!GI!>JT>=I!JGC@BQ!AH!QGDB?AGHCY!*I!*OXBQ bKLL]d CHABI!R=!eSHAGCF! 'G?AHD!+HDAHCE f4B?>SIB!AOB!ABDX!gHDGBCA>AGHC$!GI!CHT!?HXXHC!GC!JBF>J!>CQ!P I=?OG>ADG?! QGI?HSDIBIE!TB!AOGC@!HV!GA!>I!>!I?GBCAGVG?!THDQY!4SA!HV!?HSDIB!GA!GI!XBDBJ=!>! QGDB?AGHC>J!XBA>POHD!QD>TC!VDHX!X>FCBAGIX!>CQ!C>WGF>AGHCE!TOG?O!O>I! FD>QS>JJ=!ISPBDIBQBQ!AOB!QGDB?AGHC>J!XBA>POHDI!SIBQ!PDGHD!AH!AOB!"_`LI2! GC?JGC>AGHCE!QBWG>CAE!PBDWB DAE!GCWBDAE!A>IABE!ABCQBC?=E!RBCAE!QDGWBY!3BcS>J!JHWB!GI! HVABC!BcPDBIIBQ!GC!ABDXI!HV!QGDB?AGHC>J!XBA>POHDIYh!b PY! ]_d &OGI!QBI?DGPAGHC!?JSBI!SI!GC!AH!OHT!TB!XGFOA!SCQBDIA>CQ!IBcS>J!GXPSJIBI!GC!ABDXI!AO>A!?>C! RB!>PPJGBQ!PO=IG?>JJ=E!>CQ!BWBC!I?SJPASD>JJ=Y!*QQ GAGHC>JJ=E!eSBBD!RHQGBI!>DB!QGDB?AJ=!?HQBQ! TGAO!>!OGIAHD=!HV!JBF>JE!PI=?OHJHFG?>JE!>CQ!?SJASD>J!IGFCGVGBDI!AO>A!ABJJ!SI!Bc>?AJ=!TO>A!X>@BI! OHXHIBcS>J!QBIGDB!>PP>DBCAY! fq.rO>A!X>@BI!IPB?GVG?!IBcS>JGAGBI!QBI?DGR>RJB!>I!eSBBD!GC!AOB!VGDIA!PJ>?B2!AO>A! GIE!AOB =!>DB!IBBC!>I!HQQE!RBCAE!ATGIABQY!#C!>!T>=!GV!TB!DBASDC!AH!AOB!DHHA!HV!AOB! THDQ!geSBBD$!bVDHX!AOB!QWBDIBd!TB!?>C!IBB!AO>A!AOB! THDQ!GAIBJV!gATGIAIE$!TGAO!>!ATGIA!AO>A!>JJHTI!SI!AH!XHWB!RBATBBC!IBcS>J!>CQ! IH?G>J!DBFGIABDIE!TGAOHSA! VJ>AABCGCF!AOBX!HD!DBQS?GCF!AOBX!AH!>!IGCFJB!JGCBYh! b*OXBQ E!KLL]E!PY "]"d

PAGE 18

! "a 3H!AOBIB!geSBBD!QBI?DGPAHDI$!>DB!SIBVSJ!VHD!XB!I?SJPASD>JJ=!GC!AO>A!AOB=!?>C!QBI?DGRB!X>C=! IGABI!HV!QGIHDGBCA>AGHC!IGXSJA>CBHSIJ=E!>JJHTGCF!XB!AH!DBJ>AB! A.,#-".0&0GGG AH!>!F>=!RHQ=!G C! PO=IG?>J!ABDXIE!GC!IH?G>J!>CQ!PHJGAG?>J!ABDXIE!>CQ!GC!ABDXI!HV!PI=?OHIBcS>J!QBIGDBY! A.,#-".0&0B'C+"/&-"/B'2*'D"#*/'+'%-*B'+.0'&*')&*&#+B'+.0'E+#'-.'2.*-'*F&'C2,F* ?>C!RB! AOHSFOA!HV!>I!gHRJGeSB$!HD!gIJ>CABQ$!GC!AO>A!GA!JB>CI!>F>GCIA!>!T>JJ!D>AOBD!AO>C!I A>CQI!SPD GFOAY! &OB!X>ABDG>JGA=!HV!P>PGBD j Xk?Ol BJSQBI!AOB!IHVA!I?SJPASDB!HD!O>DQ! I?SJPASDB!QGWGQB!TOG?O! ?DGAG?I >CQ!>DAGIAI!O>WB!SIBQ!>I!>!DBPDBIBCA>AGHC!HV!X>I?SJGCGA=!>CQ!VBXGCGCGA=Y!4SA!AOGI! X>ABDG>J!GI!RDGAAJBY!#A!GI!IHXBAGXBI!IADHCF!>CQ!IHXBAGXBI!B>IG J=!RDH@BCY!#A!XHJQIY!#C!HAOBD! THDQIE!AOB!X>ABDG>J!CBBQI!>!CBT!?HCIGQBD>AGHC!TOG?O!QHBI!CHA!VHJJHT!AOHIB!JGCBI!HV!O>DQ!HD! IHVA!I?SJPASDBY )GIHDGBCA>AGHCE!AHHE!PJ>=I!>!OSFB!P>DA!HV!OHT!AOBIB!I?SJPASDBI!SIB!>!eSBBD! POBCHXBCHJHFG?>J!PBDIPB?AGWB!AH!>IIBDA!AOBX IBJWBIY!&OB!AGAJB!HV!AOB!PGB?B!>I@I!SI!AH! ?HCIGQBD!RBGCF!SCFDHSCQBQ!>CQ!C>SIBHSIE!IBCI>AGHCI!TOG?O!BXBDFB!VDHX!QGIHDGBCA>AGHCY! f)GIHDGBCA>AGHC!?HSJQ!RB!QBI?DGRBQ!OBDB!>I!AOB!gRB?HXGCF!HRJGeSB$!HV!AOB! THDJQE!>!RB?HXGCF!AO>A!GI!>A!HC?B!GCABDGHD!>CQ!BcABDGHD E!>I!AO>A!TOG?O!GI!FGWBCE! HD!>I!AO>A!TOG?O!FGWBI!TO>A!GI!FGWBC!GAI!CBT!>CFJBY!.OBAOBD!AOB!IAD>CFBCBII!GI! GC!AOB!HRZB?A!HD!GC!AOB!RHQ=!AO>A!GI!CB>D!AOB!HRZB?A!DBX>GCI!>!?DS?G>J!eSBIAGHCYYY! &OB!+>SIB>!GIC$A!GCIGQB!XB2!#!?>C!VBBJ!GA!HWBD!AOBDB!HC!AOB!T>JJE!HC AOB! RD>?BIYYYh!b*OXBQ E!KLL]E!PY "]Kd #V!HCB!?>C!VHD!>!XHXBCA!ADSIA!GC!AOB!I?SJPASDB!>I!>!DBPDBIBCA>AGHC!HV!AOB!CGFOA!I@=E!AOBC!GA! XSIA!RB!HCB!HV!AOB!CGFOA!I@=!TOGDJGCF!>RHSAE!QD>FFBQ!R=!>!QGIAHDABQ!WGIGHC!HV!AOGI!>JJ j BC?HXP>IIGCF!WGBT!GCAH!JGAAJB!XHDB!AO> C!>!?HGJ!TGAO!>C!BXPA=!?BCABDY!&OB!ABcA!PJ>?BQ!HWBD!

PAGE 19

! "_ AOGI!QGIAHDABQ!I@=!GI!>JIH!HCB!HV!>!QGIHDGBCA>AGHCE!R=!VHJJHTGCF!AOB!IO>PB!>DHSCQE!AOB!ABcA! ?HCIA>CAJ=!?O>CFBI!GAI!HDGBCA>AGHCY! )GIHDGBCA>AGHC!>JIH!O>I!>CHAOBD!SIB!VHD!*OXBQ bKLL]d E!GA!fGCWHJWBI!V>GJBQ! HDGBCA>AGHCI2!RHQGBI!GCO>RGA!IP>?BI!AO>A!QH!CHA!BcABCQ!AOBGD!IO>PBE!HD!SIB!HRZB?AI!AO>A!QH! CHA!BcABCQ!AOBGD!DB>?Oh!b PY! "]LdY!#C!>!T>=E!QGIHDGBCA>AGHC!GI!>RHSA!>!RHQ=$I!J>?@!HV!>RGJGA=!AH! VGA!>CQ!>QBPAJ=!THD@!TGAO!GAI!ISDDHSCQGCFIY!&OB!J>m=!?JSC@GCBII!HV!AO GI!I?SJPASDBE!TOG?O! XSIA!PD>?AG?>JJ=!?HJJ>PIB!>F>GCIA!AOB!T>JJ!bCHA!RBGCF!>RJB!AH!DGIB!AH!AOB!?O>JJBCFB!HV! WBDAG?>JGA=dE!GI!>C!HRZB?A!TOG?O!IAG?@I!HSA!>I!GCBPAE!B?OHGCF!AOHIB!GCBPA!RHQGBIY!&OB!IJHPP=! ?D>VAE!TOG?O!GC!AOB!?HCABcA!HV!9HIA%GCGX>JGIX!GI!B??BCAD G?!GQGHI=C?D>I=E!XGXG?I!AOB!CHAGHC! HV!>!J>?@!HV!IS??BII!HV!>!RHQ=Y! A.,#-".0&0GGG GI!eSBBDBQ!PDB?GIBJ=!RB?>SIB!GA!GI!CHA! IADB>XJGCBQE!FD>?BVSJE!HD!PBDVB?AJ=!DHHABQY! &OGI!SCQBDIA>CQGCF!HV!QGIHDGBCA>AGHC!?>C!>JIH!QBI?DGRB!AOB!?HCVSIGHC!TGAOGC! J((= K CLJD>M'>& @*';&//+,&'E2,F*'N2*F'O KKK Y!&OB!THD@!GI!HC!Q>D@!RJSB!PHIABD!RH>DQ!TGAO!TOGAB! P>PBD!IPGD>JGCF!HSA!JG@B!ZBAAGIHCBQ!IXH@B!FJSBQ!AH!GAY!8DHX!AOGI!GI!?SA!AOB!THDQ!gFHHQCGFOA$ Y! &OB!HAOBD!BJBXBCAI!>DB!P>PGBD j Xk?Ol 2!>!PSDPJB!VD>XBE!fGC!Bc?BII!HV!X=IBJVEh!f#!QDB>X! HV! XSDQBD! jj IJBBP!>CQ!T>@BEh!fIPHHC!X=!HTC!TDBA?OBQCBIIEh!f5SC!"`E!KL"K!"K2K]!*%Yh!&OB! TOGAB!IPGD>J!GCABDDSPAI!AOB!ABcAE!TOG?O!GI!>JDB>Q=!IH!ABDIB!>I!AH!RB!R>DBJ=!SCQBDIAHHQY! *QQGAGHC>JJ=!AOB!Q>AB!>CQ!AGXB!QGWGQB!AOB!GC?HXPJBAB!AOHSFOAI!>CQ!BWBC!IBP>D>AB! f<--)h! >CQ!f+#<1&hY!&OB!?HCVSIGCF!ABcA!>CQ!AOB!IPGCCGCF!GX>FBD=!?HCWB=!AO>A!AOB!PGB?B$I!IBAAGCF!GI! CGFOAE!>!WBD=!IPB?GVG?!CGFOAE!>CQ!AOB!XHHQ!GI!QGIHDGBCABQ!P>AOHIY #C!V>?A!RHAO!HV!AOBIB!PGB?BI!>DB!>RHSA!>!IPB?G>J!@GCQ!HV!QGIHDGBCA>AGHCE!AOB!@GCQ!GC! TOG?O JHWBDI!CH!JHCFBD!VGA!AHFBAOBD!>CQ!IBP>D>ABY!&OBIB!PGB?BI!H??SD!>VABD!AOB!IPJGA!>A! XHXBCAI!HV!JHCBJGCBII!bTOG?OE!HV!?HSDIBE!>DB!>JT>=I!>A!CGFOAdY!#CQBBQ!#!THCQBD!GVE!VHD!XBE!

PAGE 20

! KL AOB!XHIA!QGIHDGBCAGCF!XHXBCAI!O>WB!RBBC!AOB!XHXBCAI!HV!DB>JGm>AGHC!AO>A!>!DHX>CAG? DBJ>AGHCIOGP!TGJJ!CHA!?HCAGCSBE!AOB!QGIHDGBCA>AGHC!HV!ATH!PBHPJB!CHA!RBGCF!TGAOGC!B>?O! HAOBD$I!DB>?OY!&OBIB!PGB?BI!AD=!AH!>DAG?SJ>AB!>!D>CFB!HV!?HCVJG?AGCF!BXHAGHCI!QSDGCF!AOHIB! XHIA!GC>DAG?SJ>AB!CGFOAIY

PAGE 21

! K" 61*9&('!M 3;#6(3!-8!6*%9 %S?O!JG@B!AOB!PDBWGHSI! ATH!PGB?BIE! LP<'C-*'*F&'1-4&'-3'Q-"#'123& BXRD>?BI!AOB! ?JG?Ol HV!AOB!CGFOA!I@=E!HV!IOHSAGCF!AOB!X>SQJGC!AH!AOB!OB>WBCIY!&OB!WGQBH!GI!>!DB?HDQGCF!HV!X=! QBI@AHP!R>?@FDHSCQE!>CQ!X=!XHSIB!PBDVHDXGCF!>!?OHDBHFD>PO=!AH!+GC>!3GXHCBsI!f/HSsWB! DChE!HCB!HV OBD!XHDB!QD>X>AG?>JJ=!P>AOBAG?!O=XCIY!&OB!BXHAGHC>J!?HCABCA!HV!AOB! IHCF!PJ>=GCF!>F>GCIA!>!CGFOA!I@=!XGFOA!X>@B!XHDB!HRWGHSI!IBCIBE!RSA!AHA>JJ=!VJ>AABCGCF!AOB! PBDVHDX>C?B!>F>GCIA!>!?HXPSABD!I?DBBC!>I@I!IHXBAOGCF!HV!GA!AO>A!AOB!Q>C?B!?HSJQ!CBWBD! QBJGWBDY!&O B!WGQBH!>AABXPAI!>!QGVVG?SJA!R>J>C?B!HV!IGC?BDGA=!>CQ!IBJV j P>DHQ=Y!4=!W>JHDGmGCF! HWBDTDHSFOA!BXHAGHCE! ?JG?Ol XBA>POHDIE!>CQ!BWBC!IOHDA j ?GD?SGAGCF!AOB!DB>J!BcPBDGBC?B!HV! AO>A! ?JG?OlQ CGFOA!I@=E!HCB!XGFOA!I>=!AO>A!GA!FGWBI!AOB!X>DFGC>J!tXHDB!AO>C!AOB!X>DFGC> J! QBIBDWBIt!b4HHAO E!"_aME!PY U`dY!#C!HAOBD!THDQIE!AOBDB!GI!IHXBAOGCF!QGIAGC?AJ=!6>XP=!>RHSA! AOGI!THD@E!>CQ!XS?O!HV!AOB!THD@!GC!AOGI!IOHTY! #!>IIH?G>AB!XS?O!HV!TO>A!?>C!RB!?>JJBQ!seSBBD!OGIAHD=s!TGAO!AOB!OGIAHD=!HV!6>XPY!3H! VHD!XB!AH!AOGC@!HV!AOBIB!PGB?BI! >I!6>XP!GI!>C!>AABXPA!AH!>??BII!AOGI!OGIAHD=!GC!?OHG?BI!HV! ?HJHDE!X>ABDG>JE!WGIS>J!DBVBDBC?BE!>CQ!DBWBJ>AGHC!HV!BXHAGHC!TGAOHSA!DBAG?BC?BY!3H!AOB! ?HCABcAS>JGmGCF!HV!AOBIB!WGQBHI!>I!eSBBD!>?AGHCI!HD!I?SJPASDBI!>I!eSBBD!RHQGBI!DB?BGWBI! IHXB!OBJP!AODHSFO!X=!S CQBDIA>CQGCF!HV!TO>A!6>XP!JHH@I!JG@B!>CQ!OHT!6>XP!HPBD>ABIY! 3SI>C!3HCA>F$I! bKLL"d! IBXGC>J!f+HABI!HC!6>XPh!BIA>RJGIOBI!>!VBT!XHDB!QGI?J>GXBDI2! f-V!?HSDIBE!AH!I>=!>JJ!AOBIB!AOGCFI!>DB!6>XP!GI!CHA!AH!>DFSB!AOB=!>DB!IGXPJ=!AO>AY!*!VSJJ! >C>J=IGI!HV!*DA!+HSWB> SE!VHD!GCIA>C?BE!THSJQ!I?>D?BJ=!BeS>AB!GA!TGAO!6>XPY!4SA!IS?O!>C! >C>J=IGI!?>CCHA!GFCHDB!TO>A!GC!*DA!+HSWB>S!>JJHT!GA!AH!RB!BcPBDGBC?BQ!>I!6>XPh!b PY! Ka"dY! 3H!AH!RBFGCE!GA!GI!PHIIGRJB!VHD!IHXBAOGCF!AH!RB!?>XP=!GC!IHXB!T>=I!>CQ!CHA!GC!HAOBDIY!6>JJGCF! LP<'C-*' *F&'1-4&'-3'Q-"#'123& >!6>XP=!THD@!QHBI!CHA!XB>C!AO>A!AOB!PGB?B!GI!BCAGDBJ=!6>XP=E!

PAGE 22

! KK HD!BWBC!AO>A!>C=!HAOBD!PGB?B!?>C!HCJ=!RBE!HD!BWBC!RBIA!RBE!QBI?DGRBQ!>I!6>XPY!#!IGXPJ=!XB>C! AH!I>=!AO>A!AOGI!HD!AOGI!>RHSA!AOB!PGB?B!GI!?HCFDSHSI!TGAO!>!?HCABXPHD>D=!>CQ!AOB HDBAG?>J! SCQBDIA>CQGCF!HV!6>XPE!>CQ!AOB!ISXX>AGHC!HV!AOBIB!XHXBCAI!HV!HWBDJ>P!GI!BCHSFO!DB>IHC! AH!>AABXPA!AH!>??BII!X=!THD@!VDHX!AOGI!>CFJBY -CB!XGFOA!I>=!AO>A!AH!?>JJ!>!THD@!6>XP=!GI!AH!>??SIB!GA!HV!RBGCF!IO>JJHT!>CQ!TGAOHSA! QBPAOE!HD!AH!RB!HWBDJ=!?HC?BD CBQ!TGAO!ISDV>?BY!.GAOHSA!>!QHSRA!AOGI!WGQBH!PGB?B!GI!HCB!HV! VJ>ACBIIY!#A!BcOGRGAI!CH!QBPAOE!HCJ=!AOB!IGXSJ>AGHC!HV!AOB!CGFOA!I@=Y!&OB!I>XB!HV!?HSDIB!?>C! RB!I>GQ!HV! L.42*+*2-.R'L'=-.S*'D+4&'(.& E!TOG?O!VH?SIBI!>JXHIA!BCAGDBJ=!HC!>!PHIABD!HV!.OHHPG! !O>CQ!IPB?@JBQ!TGAO!PSDPJB!QHAIY! 3SDV>?B!eS>JGA=!>I!BcABCQBQ!AH!AOB!PBDIHC!>DGIBI!GC!AOB!VHDX!HV!QGIFSGIBY! 'G?O>DQ! )=BD!AOBHDGmBI!AOB!HDGFGCI!HV!6>XP2!t\!TB!bOHXHIBcS>JId!O>Q!AH!X>IABD!AOB!V>?>QB!HV! TO>ABWBD!IH?G>J!IBA j SP TB!VHSCQ!HSDIBJWBI!GC!\!IH!TB!O>WB!QBWBJHPBQ!>C!B=B!>CQ!>C!B>D!VHD! ISDV>?BIE!>PPB>D>C?BIE!VHDXI jj IA=JBY!3X>JJ!THCQBD!AO>A!TOBC!TB!QBWBJHPBQ!HSD!HTC! ?SJASDBE!AOB!O>RGA!HV!IA=JB!IOHSJQ!O>WB!DBX>GCBQ!IH!QHXGC>CA!GC!GAt!b3OSF>DA E!KLLaE PY! KUdY! 6>XP!IBBI!AOB! PDBIBCA>AGHC!HV!AOB!IBJV!>I!>!PJ>=VSJ!>?AY!4SA!#!THSJQ!JG@B!AH!QGIAGCFSGIO!AOB! QGIFSGIB!CHABQ!R=!)=BDE!TOG?O!IPB>@I!HV!OGQGCF!>C!GQBCAGA=!AO>A!X>=!BcGIA!>I!BIIBCAG>J!AH!>! PBDIHCE!WBDISI!AOB!CHAGHC!HV!?HCIADS?ABQ!GQBCAGA=Y!*I! 8>RGH! 6JBAH!CHABIE!t?>XP!BXBDFB I\!>I! >C!BcBD?GIB!G C!P>IIGCFE!HDGBCABQ!AH!AOB!XGIB j BC j I?BCB!HV!>!PBDVHDX>AGWB!>CQ!AD>CIGBCA! GQBCAGA=E!GCWBIAGCF!XBCQ>?GHSICBII!CHA!IH!XS?O!AODHSFOHSA!AOB!sIS??BIIVSJ!JGBs!HV!P>IIGCF! VHD!IAD>GFOAE!RSA!D>AOBD!>I!GAI!WBD=!?HCQGAGHCE!>I!AOB!?HCIAGASAGWB!PDGC ?G PJB!HV!>JJ!GQBCAGA=t! b3OSF>DAE!KLLaE!PY! KUdY!#XPHDA>CAJ=E!GV!6>XPsI!QGIFSGIBI!QBWBJHPBQ!>I!>!DBIPHCIB!AH!VHD?BQ! >IIGXGJ>AGHCE!AOBC!AOB=!GCVHDXBQ!GAI!PBD?BPAGHC!HV!GQBCAGA=Y!6>XP!SCQBDIA>CQI!t4BGCF j >I j

PAGE 23

! KM 9J>=GCF j > j 'HJBt!b3HCA>F E!KLL"E!PY KaLd!>CQ!A>@BI!AO>A!>I PBDXGIIGHC!AH!?O>JJBCFB!>JJ!CHAGHCI! HV!VGcBQ!GQBCAGA=!HD!AOB!s>SAOBCAG?!IBJVsY &OBDB!GI!>!X>IeSBD>QB!>A!PJ>=!GC!AOB!WGQBHI!>I!TBJJY!&OB!GJJSIGHCE!>JRBGA!J>m=E!HV!AOB! CGFOA!I@=!>AABXPAI!>!V>JIB!BC>?AXBCA!HV!>C!BXHAGHC>J!ADHPBY!&OB!PDBABCIB!HV! L.42*+*2-. GGG RBGCF!>RHSA!X=!JHWB!VHD!.OHHPG!?AS>JJ=!QGIFSGIBI!AOB!RBCA!C>DD>AGWB!bTOG?O!QGPI! GCAH!GIISBI!HV!>!DHX>CAG?!DBJ>AGHCIOGPdY!#C!>!IBCIBE!AHHE!AOBIB!ATH!WGQBHI!>AABXPA!AH!P>II!>I! IHXBAOGCF!VDHX!AOB!OGIAHD=!HV!WGQBH!>DA!bAO>A!AOB=!>DB!IGCFJB!A>@BIE AO>A!HCB!GI!IOHA!GC!>C!>DA! IASQGHE!AO>A!AOB=!>DB!RHAO!PBDVHDXBQ!VHD!AOB!?>XBD>dE!RSA!AOB!V>GJSDB!HV!AOBIB!WGQBHI!AH!P>II! GI!GXXBQG>ABY!&OB!VJ>AE!QGFGA>J!DBPDBIBCA>AGHC!HV!IA>DIE!TOG?O!T>I!CHA!BWBC!IOHA!TGAO!>! ?>XBD>E!GC! LS<'C-*'*F&' 1-4&'-3'Q-"#'123& HTBI! JGAAJB!AH!WGQBH!>DA! AD>QGAGHCY!&OB!PHHDJ=! PJ>CCBQ!?>XBD>! XHWBXBCA!>CQ!DBJG>C?B! HC!>!J>PAHP!AH!DBPJ>=!>! I?BCB!VDHX!5SXP GC$!5>?@! 8J>IO!QBIADH=!>C=! P>II> RGJGA=!VHD! L.42*+*2-. GGG 4SA!AOBIB!XHXBCAI!HV! CHC j P>II> RGJGA=!RB?HXB! XHXBCAI!HV!GCCHW>AGHC! VHD!AOB!WGQBHIY &OBIB!XHXBCAI!HV!V>GJSDB!AH!P>IIE!HD!V>GJSDB!HV!AOB!BXHAGHC>J!TBGFOA!HV!AOB! 8GFSDB!M2!8>=B!)SC>T>=!>I!5H>C!6D>TVHDQ!GC! ;-<
PAGE 24

! KU PGB?B!AH!J>CQE!>DB!GXPHDA>CA!VHD!AOGC@GCF!HV!AOBIB!PGB?BI!>I!6>XP=E!ZSIA!>I!QGIHDGBCA>AGHC!GI! GXPHDA>CA!AH!AOGC@GCF!HV!AOB!I?SJPASDBI!>I!eSBBDBQ!IP>AG>JGm>AGHCIY! 6>XP!W>JHDGmBI! AOB!V>GJSDB!HV!AOB!>AABXPAY!&OB!?>XP=!PBDIHC!XSIA!VGCQ!GCQSJFBC?B!GC! AOB!AOGCF!AO>A!GI!DGQG?SJHSI!>CQ!QGI>PPHGCAGCFJ=!>CQ!SAABDJ=!>WBD>FBE!>CQ!FGWB!AO>A!>WBD>FB! ?DB>AGHC!W>JSB!AO>A!GA!QHBI!CHA!O>WB!HC!GAI!HTC!XBDGAIY!.O>A!?SJASDB!>A!J>DFB!QBBXI!>!V>GJSDB! H D!IGJJ=!IBJV j GCQSJFBC?BE!6>XP!PDHAB?AI!R=!FGWGCF!AOB!THD@!QGVVBDBCA!FH>JI!>CQ!>!QGVVBDBCA! I=IABX!HV!BW>JS>AGHCY! ;-<=!CHA!RB!>!FDB>A!VGJX!R=!IH?G>J!IA>CQ>DQIY!#A!V>GJI!GC! X>C=!T>=I jj XHIA!GXPHDA>CAJ=!GI!8>=B!)SC>T>=$I!HWBD>?AGCFY!&OB!PDHVBIIGHC >J!HRIBDWBD! QGIJG@BI!AOB!XHWGB!VHD!GAI!V>GJSDB!>CQ!AOB!SCIHPOGIAG?>ABQ!HRIBDWBD!JG@BI!GA!RB?>SIB!OB!QHBI! CHA!CHAG?B!AOB!V>GJSDBY!&OB!6>XP!PBDIHC!IBBI!RHAOE!>CQ!BCZH=I!AOBX!RHAOY!&OB!6>XP!PBDIHC! GI!>C!HSAIGQBDE!QBIAGCBQ!AH!DBX>GC!>C!HSAIGQBDE!>CQ!?>C!AOBDBV HDB!SIB!AOB!V>GJSDB!HV!?SJASDB! >I!>!T>=!AH!?DGAGeSB!AO>A!?SJASDBE!RSA!>JIH!>I!>!T>=!AH!GQBCAGV=!OGI!HTC!V>GJSDBI!AH!VGA!AOB! ?SJASDB!AO>A!O>I!BcPBJJBQ!OGXY!.O>A!?>C!RB!XHDB!?HXPBJJGCF!AO>C!>C!>?ADBII!FGWGCF!OBD!>JJ! AH!PHDAD>=!>!DHJB!>CQ!SAABDJ=!BXR>DD>IIGCF OBDIBJV!>CQ!OBD!?D>VA!GC!AOB!PDH?BII^! 3H!HC!HCB!O>CQE!AOB!DB?HFCGAGHC!HV!AOB!VHDFBD=!GI!BIIBCAG>J!AH!AOB!6>XP!JBCIn!VDHX! AOGI!?HXBI!>JJ!HV!6>XPsI!OSXHDY!4SA!>A!AOB!I>XB!AGXBE!6>XP!XSIA!GQBCAGV=!TGAO!AOB!VHDFBD=E! >I!AOB!P>ADHC!HV!6>XP!OGXIBJV!O>I!>JDB>Q= DB?HFCGmBQ!OGI!HTC!VHDFBD=Y!6>XP!GI!>!QBJG?>AB! R>J>C?B!RBATBBC!IBJV j JHWB!>CQ!IBJV j O>ABE!Bc?JSIGWGA=!>CQ!>??BIIGRGJGA=E!?>CQGQCBII!>CQ!IBJV j XH?@BD=Y!!4SA!D>AOBD!AO>C!XHQGV=GCF!B>?O!HAOBDE!AOBIB!eS>JGAGBI!DBX>GC!VDHmBC!GC!SCB>I=! HPPHIGAGHC!>CQ!TGAOHSA!AOB!Q BIGDB!VHD!DBIHJSAGHCY! &OGI!QSPJG?GAHSI!GCABCAGHC>JGA=!IGFC>JI!AOB!AHCB!VHD!RHAO!WGQBH!THD@IY! LS<'C-*'*F&' 1-4&'-3'Q-"#'123& IBAI!SP!>!P>IIGHC>AB!PJB>!AH!AOB!CGFOA!I@=E!RSA!AOBC!SCQBDXGCBI!GAI! >SAOBCAG?GA=!R=!Q>C?GCF!AH!>!IGXSJ>ABQ!I@=Y!&OB!RHQGJ=!PBDVHDX> C?B!G I!>?AS>JJ=!HCJ=!HCB!HV!

PAGE 25

! K[ AOB!O>CQ TOGI@GCF HWBD!>!XHSIBP>QY!*CQ!AOB!BcPBDGBC?BE!R=!RBGCF!XBQG>ABQ!GC!IS?O!>! X>CCBD!>CQ!AH!IS?O!>!QBFDBBE!VBBJI!?OB>PBCBQY!4SA!AOB!?OB>PBCBQ!DBABJJGCF!GI!>A!JB>IA!HCB! AO>A!GI!OHCBIAY!&OB!FGVA!HV!GCABCAGHC>J!6>XP!GI!AO>A!GA ?HXRGCBI!Bc?BIIGWB!BXHAGHC!TGAO!>! TGIBE!JBII!C>GWB!SCQBDRBJJ=Y! L.42*+*2-.GGG BCQI!TGAO!AOB!>?A!HV!T>GAGCF!VHD!IHXBHCBE!>CQ! DB?BGWGCF!ABcA!XBII>FBI!TOG?O!RHAO!BXPO>IGmBI!AO>A!PBDIHC$I!>RIBC?B!>CQ!>CAG?GP>ABI!AOBGD! >DDGW>JY!4SA!AOB!Bc?GABXBCA!HV!>!PHP!IHCF! PHJGIOBI!AOGI!JGIAJBII!GXP>AGBC?B!GCAH!IHXBAOGCF! FDB>ABDE!AO>A!?>C!RB!>CAOHJHFGmBQ!HD!X=AOG?>JY!&OB!THD@!GI!RHAO!R>C>J!>CcGBA=!>CQ!AOB! =B>DCGCF!HV!>C!GXP>IIGHCBQ!JHWBDY!4HAO!HV!AOBIB!PHIGAGHCI!?>C!RB!ADSB!GC!AOB!DB>JX!HV!6>XPY! 6>XP!WGBTI!GAI!WG?AGXI!TGAO >QSJ>AGHCE!JHWBE!>CQ!ABCQBDCBIIY!8HD!AOGI!DB>IHCE!AH! ?HCVJ>AB!6>XP!TGAO!HWBDA!?DGAG?>JGA=!THSJQ!RB!AH!XGII!AOB!J>DFBD!PHGCAY!6>XPsI!WGBT!HV! V>GJSDB!>CQ!>T@T>DQ!Bc>FFBD>AGHC!GI!CHA!HCB!HV!ZSQFXBCA!b3HCA>F E!KLL"E!PY K_"dY!'>AOBD! 6>XP!BCZH=I!AOBIB!GCIA>C?BIE AOBIB!XHXBCAI!TOBC!AOB!GC?HCIGIABC?GBI!>DB!BcPHIBQY!&OB! 6>XP!B=B!?D>WBI!BCZH=XBCA!XHDB!AO>C!ZSQFXBCAY!*CQ!GA!GI!XHDB!ABCQBD!AO>C!I>D?>IAG?Y!3H! +GC>!3GXHCB$I!WHG?B!?HSPJBQ!TGAO!>!?HXPSABD!I?DBBC$I!DBPDBIBCA>AGHC!HV!AOB!SCGWBDIB!GI!CHA! ZScA>PHIGAGHCE!CHD!GI GA!O>DXHC= Y

PAGE 26

! K] 61*9&('!U #+7#3#4;(!.-', #!O>WB!?OHIBC!AH!VD>XB!AOB!I?SJPASDBI!>CQ!WGQBHI!>I!>!eSBBDGCF!HV!AOB!T>=!RHQGBI! BcPBDGBC?B!IP>?BE!TOG?O!#!AOBC!>DFSB!GI!P>DAG>JJ=!?HQBQ!>I!eSBBD!R=!AOB!6>XP=!ABCQBC?GBI! HV!AOB!GX>FBD=E!X>ABDG>JGA=E!>CQ!IBCAGXBCA>JGA =Y!&OB!DBJ>AGHCIOGP!AH!>!eSBBD!POBCHXBCHJHF=! GI!QGVVBDBCA!TGAO!AOB!gGCWGIGRJB$!PGB?BIY!&OBDB!GI!IHXBAOGCF!AHH!IBDGHSI!VHD!AOBX!AH!AHA>JJ=! ?HCCB?A!TGAO!>!eSBBD!?HCWBDI>AGHCE!SCJBII!#!IADG?AJ=!>QOBDB!AH!%HB!%B=BD$I!QBVGCGAGHC!HV! 6>XPE!AO>A!GA!GI!IGXPJ=!fAOB! AHA>J!RHQ=!HV!PBDVHDX>AGWB!PD>?AG?BI!>CQ!IAD>ABFGBI!SIBQ!AH! BC>?A!>!F>=!GQBCAGA=E!TGAO!BC>?AXBCA!SCQBDIAHHQ!>I!AOB!PDHQS?AGHC!HV!IH?G>J!WGIGRGJGA=h!bULdY!! &TH!JSXPI!HV!FJ>II!DBIA!HC!C>GJI!VDHX!AOB!T>JJY!&OB!JSXPI!>DB!IH!B??BCADG?>JJ=! IO>PBQE!AO>A!AOB=!>A VGDIA!>PPB>D!>RIAD>?An!BWBCAS>JJ=E!AOB=!DBWB>J!AOB!VD>?AGHC!HCB!HWBD! AOGDA= j HCBY!&OB!AGAJBE! D2,F&/*'T/*2<+*&0'62/U'-3'O-.*#+)*2.,'DLV'3#-<'6&)&$*24&'W.+%'7&@' W))-#02.,'*-'L.*&#.&*'7-"#)&/'2.'X"%I'YZ[Y E!?HS?OBI!AOB!ATH!FJ>II!VD>?AGHCIE!FGWBI!AOBX!>! ?HCABcA E!X>@BI!AOBX!SIBVSJY!&OB!AGAJB!FGWBI!AOBX!>C!GXPJGBQ!BcPBDGBC?BE!AOB!GXPJG?>AGHC!HV! IADBIIBQ!DBIB>D?OE!>CQ!>C!GXPJGBQ!ISRZB?AGWGA=!AO>A!>!CSXRBD!IOHSJQ!CHA!RB!>RJB!AH!?HCWB=Y! &OGI!PGB?B!GI!AOB!>?A!HV!A>@GCF!PHTBD!HWBD!AOB!IA>AGIAG?E!CHA!HCJ=!ASDCGCF!GA!GCA H!FJ>II!>CQ! ?>JJGCF!GA!>C!>DA!PGB?BE!RSA!X>@GCF!ISDB!AO>A!AOB!THD@!T>I!PBDIHCGVGBQY!&OBDB!>DB!ATH!FJ>II! RHQGBIE!QBX>CQGCF!AOB!?HCIGQBD>AGHC!HV!>!?HSPJB!HD!JHWBDI!HD!>A!JB>IA!AO>A!AH!?HCAD>?A!1#7! ATH!PBHPJB!XSIA!RB!GCWHJWBQY!&OBIB!PGB?BI!>DB!X>QB!R=!XBJAGCF FJ>II!GCAH!>!XHJQY!4SA!AOBDB! >DB!P>DAG?SJ>DGAGBI!>RHSA!AOB!PDH?BII!TOG?O!GCABDBIA!XBY!8GDIAE!AOB!FJ>II!GI!BcADBXBJ=! IBCIGAGWBn!R=!AOGI!#!XB>C!AO>A!AOB!VGC>J!PDHQS?A!X>GCA>GCI!>C=!GXPBDVB?AGHCI!HV!AOB!XHJQY! *CQ!IB?HCQE!AH!BcAD>?A!AOB!?HHJBQ!FJ>IIE!AOB!XHJQ XSIA!RB!RDH@BC!>P>DAY!#C!HAOBD!THDQIE!GA!GI! >!XHJQ j X>@GCF!PDH?BII!TOG?O!HCJ=!X>@BI!HCB!PDHQS?AY!3H!AOBIB!FJ>II!PGB?BI!?HXB!VDHX! AOBGD!HTC!GCQGWGQS>J!XHJQIE!TOG?O!?>C!CBWBD!RB!Bc>?AJ=!DBPJG?>ABQY!*QQGAGHC>JJ=E!AOB!XHJQE!

PAGE 27

! K` >CQ!>I!>!DBISJA!AOB!VGC>J!FJ>II!PGB? BIE!TBDB!IO>PBQ!R=E!>CQ!IAGJJ!BcOGRGAE!X=!VGCFBDPDGCAI!HC! AOBGD!ISDV>?BIY D2,F&/*'T/*2<+*&0'62/UGGG PBDVHDXI!>!eSBBD!>FBC?=!HC!RHAO!AOB!IA>AGIAG?!GA!DBVBDBC?BI! >CQ!AOB!PDH?BII!VDHX!TOG?O!GA!BXBDFBIY!.OGJB!XHJQ j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cS>J!BcPBDGBC?BI!TGAO!> P>DACBDE!RB!?HCVDHCABQ! TGAO!AOGI!OHDDGRJB!AOHSFOA2!fHCB!HWBD!AOGDA= j HCBh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fAOB!PGB?B!CBBQ!CHA!RB!RSGJAh! b .GBCBDE!"__]E!PY aM_dY!4SA!#!>JIH!T>CABQ!AH!X>@B!THD@!>RHSA!AOB!D BVSI>JIE!AOB!V>GJSDB!HV!X=!

PAGE 28

! Ka >DA!AH!X>@B!IBCIB!AH!AOB!PBHPJB!GC!X=!JGVBE!AH!VDBBmB!AOBIB!XHXBCAI!HV!QGI?HCCB?A!VHD! Bc>XGC>AGHCY! #!T>CABQ!AOB!?HC ?DBAB!P>A?O!AH!RDGQFB!X=!P>PGBD j Xk?Ol I?SJPASDBIE!TOG?O!IAGJJ! IBBXBQ!IH!>RIAD>?AE!AH!IHXBAOGCF!FDHSCQBQY!&OGI!PG B?B!THSJQ!RB!>!FGVAE!>!XHXBCA!HV! FBCSGCB!Bc?O>CFBE!>!XBCQGCF!HV!>DA$I!>DDHF>C?B!TGAO!>!PDHZB?A!TOG?O!T>I!?HC?BPAS>J!>CQ! X>CS>J!J>RHDY!%=!XHAOBD!I>GQ!CH!AH!AOB!PDHZB?A!RB?>SIB!IOB!QGQ!CHA!ADSIA!AO>A!#!?HSJQ! ?HCWGC?GCFJ=!P>A?O!OBD!QDGWBT>=!>CQ!IHXBAOGCF!>RHS A!AOB!?HJHD!HV!AOB!P>A?O!X>QB!OBD! SC?HXVHDA>RJBY!#C!HAOBD!THDQIE!IOB!QGQ!CHA!ADSIA!AOB!X>IeSBD>QB!HV!>C!>DAGIA!>I! RJSB j ?HJJ>D THD@BDY!+HD!QGQ!IOB!T>CA!AOB!HQQGA=!HV!>!QGI?HCAGCSHSI!IB?AGHC!HV!PGC@!?HC?DBAB!GC!AOB! QDGWBT>=Y!3H!AOB!WGIS>J!WH?>RSJ>D=!AO>A!#!T >I!>AABXPAGCF!AH!DHHA!DBX>GCBQ!SCFDHSCQBQY! 8HD!AOB!IB?HCQ!PDHPHI>J!#!T>CABQ!AH!OHJQ!AOB!O>CQ!HV!AOB!FS=!#!T>I!Q>AGCF!>CQ!RBFGC! AOB!PDH?BII!HV!?DB>AGCF!>!QBIGDB!P>AO!VDHX!X=!>P>DAXBCA!AH!AOB!FDH?BD=!IAHDBY!*!QBIGDB!P>AO! GI!>!P>AO!VHDXBQ!R=!?HCAGCSHSI!SIB! AO>A!T>I!CHA!PJ>CCBQ!R=!>C!GCIAGASAGHCY!&OBIB!P>AOI! SIS>JJ=!VHDX!RB?>SIB!AOB=!>DB!AOB!XHIA!BVVG?GBCA!DHSAB I E!RSA!#!T>CABQ!HSD!QBIGDB!P>AO!AH!RB! HCB!HV!>VVB?AGHCY!.B!THSJQ!?DB>AB!>!QBIGDB!P>AO!T>J@GCF!IGQB j R= j IGQB!OHJQGCF!O>CQIY!4SA!AOGI! FS=!#!T>I!Q>AGCF!T> I!>JT>=I!T>D=!HV!PSRJG?!>VVB?AGHCE!IH!#!CBWBD!THD@BQ!SP!AOB!CBDWB!AH!>I@! OGXY!+HD!QGQ!#!BWBD!FBA!>!?O>C?B!AH!GCWGAB!OGX!GCAH!X=!>DAY!#!QGQ!CHA!BcPJ>GC!AH!OGX!AO>A!X=! I?SJPASDBI!TBDB!>RHSA!VGCQGCF!>!T>=!AH!A>J@!>RHSA!X=!RHQ=!>CQ!AH!JBA!X=!JGWBQ!BcPBDGBC?B! R B!BWGQBC?BQ!HV!AOBGD!ISDV>?BIY!+HD!QGQ!#!ABJJ!OGX!AO>A!#!T>CABQ!AH!DBSCGAB!AOBIB!AOHSFOAI! TGAO!X=!HTC!RHQ=E!>CQ!AO>A!#$Q!JG@B!AH!GC?JSQB!OGI!>I!TBJJY! *A!AOGI!PHGCA!AOB!AHCB!HV!AOB!PGB?B!?O>CFBI!QD>IAG?>JJ=Y!#!QBI?DGRB!AOB!CGFOA!AO>A!#! DB>JGmBQ!X=!VHDXBD! JHWBD!T>I!GCAGX>AB!TGAO!IHXBHCB!CBTY!&OBC!AOB!C>DD>AGWB!AD>CIGAGHCI! GCAH!>!?HCABXPHD>D=!'u4!IHCFE!f(CHSFOh!R=!&TBBAY!(>DJGBD!#!?O>D>?ABDGmBQ!AOB!C>DD>AGWB!

PAGE 29

! K_ IOGVA!VDHX!A>J@GCF!>RHSA!X=!JHWB!VHD!.OHHPG!AGBC?B!TGAO!>!JHWBD!>I! fRBCAhY!&OB!IO> PB!HV!AOGI!C>DD>AGWB!O>I!>!IGXGJ>D!fRBCQhY!#!J>=!AOB!ABJJGCF!HV!AOB!ATH!SCX>QB! PGB?BIE!AOB!BcPBDGBC?B!HV!ZB>JHSI=!>CQ!OSDA!VDHX!CBTI!HV!>C!HJQ!JHWBDE!>CQ!>!JSFSRDGHSI!>CQ! ?>AO>DAG?!IHCFE!>JJ!IGQB j R= j IGQB!>CQ!HV!BeS>J!GXPHDA>C?BY!&OBDB!GI!IHXBAOGCF!HV!AOB! I GXSJA>CBHSI!P>IIGHC>AB!>CQ!QGI>VVB?ABQ!C>ASDB!HV!6>XP!GC!RBGCF!>RJB!AH!IGC?BDBJ=!GCWBIA! X=IBJV!GC!B>?O!HV!AOBIB!AODBB!IB?AGHCI!HCJ=!AH!eSG?@J=!XHWB!VDHX!HCB!AH!AOB!CBcAY!&OGI! IBCIGRGJGA=!RB?HXBI!XHIA!PDHCHSC?BQ!GC!AOB!IBBXGCFJ=!C>vWB!BCZH=XBCA!HV!>CQ! GQBCA GVG?>AGHC!TGAO!AOB!GCIBDAGHC!HV!PHPSJ>D!?SJASDB!>I!IA>CQ j GC!VHD!JGWBQ!BcPBDGBC?BY!&OB! GXPJG?>AGHC!HV!IS?O!>!fRBCAh!QGFDBIIGHC!GI!AO>A!>!PGB?B!?>C!ABJJ!XSJAGPJB!IAHDGBI!HV!XSJAGPJB! HDQBDIY!3H!AOBDB!GI!XHDB!AO>C!HCB!JGCB!AH!VHJJHTE!TOG?O!GI!CHA!>RHSA!BVVG?GB C?=!HD!JGCB>FBY! &OB!IAHDGBI!XB>CQBDY!%=!>VVB?AGHC!VHD!.OHHPG!HCJ=!ABCSHSIJ=!?HCCB?AI!TGAO!T>GAGCF!VHD!>! Q>ABY!&OB!?HCCB?AGHC!GI!HCJ=!HV!?O>DXGCF!O>PPBC IA>C?BE!HD!>!6>XP=!?HCWBDI>AGHC b XB>CGCF! HCB!HV!eSGPI!AO>A!?JBWBDJ=!OHP!VDHX!HCB!AHPG?!AH!AOB!CBcA d Y!

PAGE 30

! ML 61* 9&('![ 8*#;0'(!*3!*!9-3#&#-+!-8!6'#&#:0( &OBIB!XHXBCAI!HV!VD>?ASDB!>DB!GXPHDA>CA!VHD!RHAO!>!eSBBD!SCQBDIA>CQGCF!HV! POBCHXBCHJHF=!>CQ!6>XPY!8HD!6>XPE!AOB!IB>XI!HV!AOB!X>IeSBD>QBE!AOB!V>GJSDB!HV!AOB! X>DFGC>J!GCIPGDBI!>!I=XP>AOBAG?!GQBCAGVG?>AGHCY!*CQ!AOGI! XGFOA!OBJP!F>=!PBHPJB!AH!VHDX!>! QBVBCIB!>F>GCIA!AOB!IA>ASI!eSHY!#C!"_aME!4HHAO!CHABQ!AO>A!fA=PBI!HV!X>DFGC>J!>DB!AOB!ADGWG>JE! AOB!AD>IO=E!AOB!@GAI?O!>CQ!AOB!CHA j ABDDGRJ= j FHHQY!&OSIE!GC!AOB!?SJASD>J!IPOBDBE!AH!RB!?>XP!GI! AH!RB!PBDWBDIBJ=!?HXXGAABQ!AH!AOB!AD >IO!>BIAOBAG?!HD!AH!>!IHDA!HV!g?SJASD>J!IJSXXGCFE$!TOG?OE! RBGCF!GC!AOBHD=!GC?HXPDBOBCIGRJB!AH!CHC j ?>XP!PBHPJBE!RB?HXBI!V>IOGHC>RJ=!Bc?JSIGWBh!b PY! "_d!6HCABXPHD>D=!AOHSFOA!HC!6>XP!A>@BI!AOGI!BcPJ>C>AGHC!>!IABP!VSDAOBDY!6>XP!GI!CHA!ZSIA! >!VJ>F!AH!D>JJ=!>DHSC Q!HD!>!?HXXSC>J!QBVBCIB!VHD!AOB!A>IABI!HV!PBHPJB!Bc?JSQBQ!VDHX!AOB! X>GCIADB>XY!%B=BD bKL"Ld >DFSBI!AO>A!fYYYTO>A!BXBDFBI!GI!>!ISPPDBIIBQ!>CQ!QBCGBQ! HPPHIGAGHC>J!?DGAGeSB!BXRHQGBQ!GC!AOB!IGFCGV=GCF!PD>?AG?BI!AO>A!PDH?BIIS>JJ=!?HCIAGASAB!F>=! GQBCAGAGBIY!6BCA D>J!AH!AOGI!DB>PPD>GI>J!GI!AOB!SCQBDIA>CQGCF!AO>A2!6>XP!GI!PHJGAG?>Jn!6>XP!GI! IHJBJ=!>!F>=!QGI?HSDIBn!>CQ!AO>A!6>XP!BXRHQGBI!>!IPB?GVG?>JJ=!F>= ?SJASD>J!?DGAGeSBYh!b%B=BDE! %YE!PY! M_d! W\/*#+)*2-.'2.'!2.U GI!>!QGPA=?OY!&OB!JBVA!P>CBJ!GI!>!?HJJ>FB!HV!GDDBFS J>D!P>PBD!IO>PBIY! &OBGD!BQFBI!O>WB!RGm>DDBJ=!DBFSJ>D!P>AABDCI!RB?>SIB!AOB=!TBDB!?SA!TGAO!AOB!IA=JGmBQ!RJ>QBI! HV!I?D>PRHH@GCF!I?GIIHDIY!&OB=!>DB!P>GCABQ!>!P>JB!PGC@!>CQ!FJSBQ!QHTC!GC!>!O>PO>m>DQ! >DD>CFBXBCAY!*I!>C!>RIAD>?A!?HXPHIGAGHCE!AOGI!FDHSPGCF!GI!BCAG DBJ=!SCGCABDBIAGCFY!#A!AHA>JJ=! V>GJI!GV!BW>JS>ABQ!GC!AOB!AD>QGAGHC>J!ABDXI!HV!VHDX>J!?DGAG?GIXY!& H!VGCQ!IHXB!>VVB?AGHC!HWBD! ZSQF XBCA!VHD!X=!PHHDJ=!?HCIADS?ABQ!>RIAD>?AGHC!GI!AOB!FBCBDHIGA=!HV!4HHAO$I!WBDIGHC!HV! 6>XPY!&H!SIB!AOGI!>VVB?AGHC!>I!>!T>=!AH!?DGAG ?GmB!>!FBCBD>J!?HCIBCISIE!BWBC!>!OBFBXHC=E!HV! FHHQ!A>IAB!GI!AOB!THD@!QHCB!R=!%B=BD$I!WBDIGHC!HV!6>XPY!

PAGE 31

! M" &OB!DGFOA!P>CBJ!GI!>!P>FB!AHDC!VDHX!X=!ZHSDC>J!>RHSA!X=!VDSIAD>AGHC!TGAO!AOB! >RIAD>?AGHC!HC!AOB!JBVAY!-CB! T>=!HV!IBBGCF!AOB!V>GJSDB!HV!AOGI!PGB?B THSJQ! RB!AH!I>=!AO>A!X=! ?HC?BDC!TGAO!>C!BcPDBIIGWBCBII! AO>A!HPBCI!GAIBJV!AH!AOB!PHIIGRGJGAGBI!HV X=!JGWBQ!BcPBDGBC?B >I!?HCABCA ?>CCHA!RB!IBBC!GC!AOGI!>RIAD>?A!?HJJ>FBY!*CQ!PBDO>PI!AOGI!PDBH??SP>AGHC!O>I! PDBWBCABQ!XB!VDHX!?DB>AGCF!IHXBAOGCF!TOG?O!>!VHDX>JGIA!BW> JS>AGHC!THSJQ!QBBX!>!IS??BIIY! 4SA!>!eSBBDBQ!DB>QGCF!HV!AOGI!THSJQ!DBWBDIB!AOGI!HDQBDY!.OG?O!GI!AH!I>=!AO>A!>RIAD>?AGHC! ?>CCHA!>QBeS>ABJ=!>JJHT! VHD!AOGI!A=PB!HV GCAGX>AB!BcPDBIIGHC Y!#A!PDB?JSQBI!AOB!?JSBI!HV! ?HCVBIIGHC Y!#C!V>?AE!AOB!V>GJSDB!HV!AOB!JBVA!P>CB J!GI!AOB!HCJ=!DB>IHC!AO>A!AOB!DGFOA!BcGIAIY! 8>GJSDB!HC!VHDX>JGIA!ABDXI!HPBCBQ!AOB!PHIIGRGJGA=!VHD!XB!AH!A>J@!>RHSA!X=!VDSIAD>AGHC!TGAO! >RIAD>?AGHCE!AH!eSBIAGHC!TO>A!GA!XB>CI!AH!RB!GC!>!DHX>CAG?!HD!IBcS>J!DBJ>AGHCIOGPE!HD!AH!AOGC@! >RHSA!AOB!VB>D!HV!T>GAGCF! VHD!AOB!DBISJAI!HV!>C!1#7!ABIAY!*OXBQ!CHABI!AOB!PHIIGRGJGAGBI!HV! BcPJHGAGCF!AOGI!A=PB!HV!eSBBD!V>GJSDBE! fTB!THSJQ!CHA!>GX!AH!HWBD?HXB!AOB!QGIHDGBCA>AGHC!HV!AOB!eSBBD!XHXBCAE!RSA! GCIAB>Q!GCO>RGA!AOB!GCABCIGA=!HV!GAI!XHXBCAY!/BIE!TB!>DB!O>GJBQn!TB!>DB! IAD>G FOABCBQ!>I!TB!QGDB?A!HSD!QBIGDBI!>I!THXBC!AHT>DQ!THXBCY!8HD!>!JBIRG>C! eSBBD!PHJGAG?IE!AOB!OHPB!GI!AH!DBGCO>RGA!AOB!XHXBCA!>VABD!IS?O!O>GJGCF2!IS?O!>! PHJGAG?I!THSJQ!CHA!HWBD?HXB!AOB!VHD?B!HV!AOB!WBDAG?>JE!HD!>I@!SI!AH!JGWB!HSD! JGWBI!>I!GV!IS?O!JGCBI!QH!CHA! HPBC!>CQ!?JHIB!IP>?BI!VHD!>?AGHCY!#CIAB>QE!TB!OB>D! AOB!O>GJE!>CQ!BWBC!VBBJ!GAI!VHD?B!HC!AOB!ISDV>?B!HV!AOB!I@GCE!RSA!TB!QH!CHA!ASDC! >DHSCQE!BWBC!TOBC!AOHIB!THDQI!>DB!QGDB?ABQ!AHT>DQ!SIY!1>WGCF!CHA!ASDCBQ! >DHSCQE!TOH!@CHTI!TOBDB!TB!XGFOA!ASDCY!+HA!ASDCGCF!> JIH!>VVB?AI!TO>A!TB! ?>C!QHY!&OB!?HCAGCFBC?=!HV!JBIRG>C!QBIGDB!X>@BI!AOGCFI!O>PPBCYh!b*OXBQ E! KLL]E!PY "L`d

PAGE 32

! MK 3H!CHA!VGAAGCFE!CHA!R BGCF!DHHABQ!HD!FDHSCQBQE!CHA!RBGCF!FHHQ!HC!VHDX>JGIA!ABDXIE!JB>QI!AH!>! QGVVBDBCA!?HCIGQBD>AGHC!HV!TO>A!>DA!XSIA!QHY!&OGI!GI!>A!JB >IA!AOB!?>IB!TOBC!AOGC@GCF!HV!TO>A! >!eSBBD!>DA!PD>?AG?B!XSIA!A>@B!>I!GAI!FH>JY!3S?O!>!PD>?AG?BE!?HXGCF!VDHX!>!PHIGAGHC!HV!V>GJSDB! >CQ!Bc?JSIGHCE!XSIA!THD@!AHT>DQI!AOB! QB?BCAD>JGm>AGHC!HV!A>IAB!>CQ!PHIIGRGJGA=Y!f.O>A!TB! >DB!J>?@GCF!GI!JGVBE!TOG?O!GI!AH!I>=2 DBIGIA>C?Bh!b%>J>RHS E!KLLaE!PY ]adY!*CQ!DBIGIA>C?B!VHD!>! eSBBD! >DA IGFC>JI!>!J>?@!HV!P>DAG?GP>AGHC!GC!IA>RJB!DBJ>AGHCI!>CQ!>!QBQG?>AGHC!AH!AOB! PDB?>DGHSI!>CQ!QGIHDGBCABQY!

PAGE 33

! MM ;#3&!-8!'(8('(+6(3 *OXBQE!3>D>Y! H"&&#'!F&.-<&.-%-,I Y!)SDO>X!>CQ!;HCQHC2!)S@B!0CGWB DIGA=!9DBIIE!KLL]Y 4HHAOE!%>D@Y! O+<$ Y!+BT!/HD@2!:S>DABA!4HH@IE!"_aMY %>J>RHSE!6>AOBDGCBY! ]F+*'7F-"%0']&'=-'N2*F'("#'?#+2./R +BT!/HD@2!8HDQO>X!0CGWBDIGA=! 9DBIIE!KLLaY %B=BDE!5>XBIY! ;2.2<+%2/< Y!;HCQHC2!9O>GQHCE!KLLLY %B=BDE!%HBY! W.'W#)F+&-%-,I'-3'!-/2.,M'T// +I/'-.'O+<$B'=#+,B'+.0'7&@"+%2*I Y!%>QGIHCE! .GI?HCIGC2!%>?>ABD!9DBIIE!KL"LY 9GC?SI j .GAABCE!'HRBDAY! !-/*<2.2<+%2/< Y!+BT!/HD@2!-SA!HV!;HCQHC!9DBIIE!"_``Y PY!]M j ]_Y 3OSF>DAE!1BJBCB!*YE!>CQ!6>AOBDGCB!(FJB=!.>FFHCBDY! ;+U2.,'O+<$M'6F&*-#2)/'-3' >#+./,#&//2-.'2.'AG 7G'!-$"%+#'O"%*"#& Y!&SI?>JHHI>2!0CGW BDIGA=!HV!*J>R>X>E!KLLaY 3HCA>FE!3SI>CY! W,+2./*'L.*&#$#&*+*2-. Y! ;HCQHC2!7GCA>FBE!KLL"Y!PY!K`[ j _KY .BGCBDE!;>TDBC?BY!f0CAGAJBQ!3A>ABXBCAYh! >F&-#2&/'+.0'=-)"<&.*/'-3'O-.*&<$-#+#I'W#* Y!(QY! ,DGIAGCB!3AGJBI!>CQ!9BABD!3BJmY!;H I!*CFBJBI2!0CGWBDIGA=!HV!6>JGVHDCG>!9DBIIE!"__]Y

PAGE 34

! MU 4#-<'*91#6*;!3,(&61 5>XBI!4SQQ!)BBI!B>DCBQ!OGI!48*!GC!)GFGA>J!%BQG>!GC!KLLa!VDHX!AOB!0CGWBDIGA=!HV! !>CQ!OGI!%8*!GC!*DA! w!&B?OCHJHF=!GC!KL"M!VDHX!AOB!0CGWBDIGA= HV!8JHDGQ>Y *A!AOBIB! GCIAGASAGHCI OB!QBWBJHPBQ!>!?HC?BPAS>J!PD>?AG?B! VH?SIGCF!HC eSBBD!PHJGAG?IE!PBDIHC>J!>FBC?=E! >CQ!VJ>AVHHABQ!OSXHDY!1B!O>I!IOHTC!THD@!HWBD!AOB!?HCAGCBCA>J!03!>CQ!T>I!GC?JSQBQ!GC!AOB! KL""!#CABDC>AGHC>J!9DGCAX>@BDI!6HCVBDBC?BY!1B!T>I!>T>DQBQ!>!QS>AB!8BJJHTIOGP!VDHX! 08 E!AOB!OGFOBIA!>T>DQ!HVVBDBQ!R=!AOB!SCGWBDIGA=E!>CQ!TGCCBD!HV!AOB! KL"K j KL"M! 3ASQBCA! *DAG IA!GC!'BIGQBC?B!9DHFD>X AH!?HJJ>RHD>AB!TGAO!RGHJHFG?>J!BCFGCBBDI!THD@GCF!TGAO! QGIHDGBCABQ!VBDC!IPHDBI GC!XG?DHFD>WGA= Y!*A!AOB!BCQ!HV!AOB!ISXXBD!OB!TGJJ!O>WB!OGI!VGDIA! G C ABDC>AGHC>J!BcOGRGAGHC!>A!1HXBR >IB!GC!4BDJGCE!C=!AH!?SJXGC>AB!>!AODBB j XHCAO!JHCF! DBIGQBC?=Y! 4SQQ!JHWBI!?>AIE!QGIADSIAI!BcPBDAIE!>CQ!?>C!IJ>X!AOB!QHHD!JG@B!4BAAB!)>WGIY

PAGE 36

!"!#$%&'"()$*+,-.%/0/"'*+"12+0/312+03%1#-3%$+!#$($

PAGE 37

!"!#$%&'"()$*+,-.%/0/"'*+"12+0/312+03%1#-3%$+!#$($

PAGE 38

!"!#$%&'"()$*+,-.%/0/"'*+"12+0/312+03%1#-3%$+!#$($

PAGE 39

!"!#$%&'"()$*+,-.%/0/"'*+"12+0/312+03%1#-3%$+!#$($

PAGE 40

!"!#$%&'"()$*+,-.%/0/"'*+1#%$*+!2",-$%*+"34+0/534+05%3#-5%$+!#$($

PAGE 41

!"!#$%&'"()$*+,-.%/0/"'*+1#%$*+"23+!4",-$%

PAGE 42

!"!#$%&'"()$*+,-.%/0/"'*+1#%$*+"23+!4",-$%

PAGE 43

!"!#$%&'"()$*+,-.%/0/"'*+1#%$*+"23+!4",-$%

PAGE 44

!"!#$%&'"()$*+,-.%/0/"'*+"12+0/312+03%1#-3%$+!#$($

PAGE 45

!"#$%&'()*##&%+,"-&.

PAGE 46

!"#$%&'()*##&%+,"-&.

PAGE 47

!"#$$

PAGE 48

!"#$$

PAGE 49

!"#$$

PAGE 50

!"#$%

PAGE 51

!"#$%&"$'&#$(&)$&!"!*+

PAGE 52

!"#$%&"$'&#$(&)$&!"!*+

PAGE 53

!"#$%&"$'&#$(&)$&!"!*+

PAGE 54

!"#$%&'()**&