New Art City: Identifying and linking opportunities in the urban environment that support and grow creative communities

MISSING IMAGE

Material Information

Title:
New Art City: Identifying and linking opportunities in the urban environment that support and grow creative communities
Physical Description:
Project in lieu of thesis
Language:
English
Creator:
Shaw, Amanda
Publisher:
School of Landscape Architecture and Planning, College of Design, Construction and Planning, University of Florida
Place of Publication:
Gainesville, Fla
Publication Date:
Copyright Date:
2013

Notes

Abstract:
The goal of this study was to identify ways that cities might be able to strengthen their arts communities utilizing urban landscape design and planning strategies employed in the practice of Landscape Architecture. The first step was to locate cities with thriving arts communities, referred to in this paper as “art cities”. The cities selected were Austin, New Orleans, Savannah, and Winston-Salem. Interpretation and survey were employed, through personal observation and interviews, to identify traits of these cities that helped attract and support members of the arts community. Once a list of traits was compiled, and correlations were identified, the traits were used as a lens by which to analyze the potential of Gainesville, Florida, to become an art city. The presence and strength of these traits, in relation to Gainesville, were analyzed. Suggestions were given as to how the city might build upon these traits to elevate its status as an art city. The conclusion reached was that there are common identifiable traits that help to attract and support a city’s arts community. Furthermore, the traits that were identified could be utilized by a city to decipher opportunities by which to strengthen and build upon their arts communities.
General Note:
Landscape Architecture terminal project

Record Information

Source Institution:
University of Florida Institutional Repository
Holding Location:
University of Florida
Rights Management:
All rights reserved by the source institution and holding location.
System ID:
AA00016550:00001


This item is only available as the following downloads:


Full Text

PAGE 1

New Art City: Identifying and linking opportunities in the urban environment that support and grow creative communities By : Amanda Shaw A Terminal Project presented to The Department o f Landscape Architecture of The University o f Fl orida in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Masters of Landscape Architecture Committee Chair: Tina Gurucharri Member: Mary Padua University o f Florida 2013

PAGE 2

ii 2013 Amanda E. Shaw

PAGE 3

iii To my Father who always encouraged me to follow my passion and to trust in where it would lead me

PAGE 4

iv Acknowledgements First I would like to thank my wonderful famil y and friends for supporting me through this challenging proc ess, most especially my husband Nick Without his lovingly prepared meals I would surely have succumb to scurvy. I would also like to thank my committee Tina Gurucharri and Mary Padua for thei r patience, guidance, and creativity in helping me to c omplete this project. They are part of a fantastic team of professors at the University of Florida 's Landscape Architecture program who inspired me daily and whom I will greatly miss. Lastly I would l ike to thank the people of our great cities. I was overwhelmed by their generosity in sharing their time and thoughts in the creation of the project. My faith in humanity has been restored.

PAGE 5

v Table of Contents Acknowledgements ................................ ................................ ............................ iv Table of Contents ................................ ................................ ................................ v Abstract ................................ ................................ ................................ .............. vii Chapter 1: Introduction ................................ ................................ ....................... 1 Research Questions ................................ ................................ ........................... 2 Art City Defined ................................ ................................ ................................ .. 3 21 st Century and the Art City ................................ ................................ .............. 3 Chapter 2: Literature Review ................................ ................................ .............. 6 Creative Class ................................ ................................ ................................ .... 6 The Arts Community ................................ ................................ .......................... 8 New Art Cities ................................ ................................ ................................ ... 12 Chapter 3: Research Methods ................................ ................................ .......... 15 Research Design and M ethods ................................ ................................ ........ 15 Choosing Case S tudy Cities ................................ ................................ ............ 16 Interviews ................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 18 Observation ................................ ................................ ................................ ...... 19 Chapter 4: Fieldwork: Case Study Cities ................................ ......................... 20 Austin: Western meets "Weird" ................................ ................................ ........ 21 New Orleans: History, Culture, and Recovery ................................ ................. 32 Savannah : The Arts College Town ................................ ................................ .. 39 Wi nston Salem: Desire & Potential; Can an Art City be Willed? ...................... 52 Chapt er 5: Findings ................................ ................................ ........................... 60 The Artist and the City ................................ ................................ ...................... 60 Richards' Creative Class Characteristics ................................ ......................... 61 Arts City Traits Identified ................................ ................................ .................. 62 Breakdown by Cas e Study City ................................ ................................ ....... 69 Synthesis ................................ ................................ ................................ .......... 99 Chapter 6: Bringing it Home: Gainesville as Art City ................................ ... 106 Gainesville ................................ ................................ ................................ ...... 107 Synthesis ................................ ................................ ................................ ........ 146 Design Suggestions ................................ ................................ ....................... 148 Conclusions ................................ ................................ ................................ ..... 158 City Traits: Which are a "must have" ................................ .............................. 158 Planning & Design Factors ................................ ................................ ............. 161 Questions for Fu ture Exploration ................................ ................................ ... 162

PAGE 6

vi List of Tables & Figures ................................ ................................ .................. 164 References ................................ ................................ ................................ ....... 168 Books ................................ ................................ ................................ ............. 168 Articles, Journals, and Internet Resources ................................ .................... 168 Interviews ................................ ................................ ................................ ....... 170 Appendix ................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 173 Interview Question Samples ................................ ................................ .......... 173

PAGE 7

vii Abstract The goal of this study was to identify ways that cities might be able to strengthen their arts communities utilizin g urban landscape design and planning strategies employed in the practice of Landscape Architecture The first step was to locate cities with thriving arts communities referred to in this paper as "art cities" The cities selected were Austin, New Orlea ns, Savannah, and Winston Salem. Interpretation and survey were employed through personal observation and interviews to identify traits of these cities that helped attract and support members of the arts community. Onc e a list of traits was compiled, a nd correlations were identified, the traits were used as a lens by which to analyze the potential of Gainesville, Florida, to become an art city. The presence and strength of these traits in relation to Gainesville were analyzed S uggestions were given a s to how the city might build upon these traits to elevate its status as an art city. The conclusion reached was that there are common identifiable traits that help to attract and support a city's arts community. Furthermore, the traits that were identif ied could be utilized by a city to decipher opportunities by which to strengthen and build upon their arts communities.

PAGE 8

1 Chapter 1 Introduction Richard Florida ha s studied what he deemed the "creative class" and their rise in society today. He defines a member of this class as someone who would "use your creativity as a key factor in your work", a group that he says makes up more than 30 percent of the US work forc e (Florida, Rise of the Creative Class" ix). He reports that members of this class are mobile and because of this they choose where they will live bas ed on the lifestyle they desire James Richards a Landscape Architect and Urban Sketch artist, took a look at the physical attributes shared by three cities that are hubs for Florida's creative class; Austin, Seattle, and Washington D.C. Using these cities as case studies, he produced a list of the common qualities of plac e that he identified among them : 1. A green framework 2. A compact urban grid 3. Distinct, self contained neighborhoods 4. An urban village at the center of the neighborhood 5. A range of viable transportation choices 6. A vital public realm 7. A wealth of "third places" 8. Preserved vintage landmarks, buildings & districts 9. A range of cultural opportunities 10. A stimulus rich environment Florida's definition of the "cr eative class" is focused on economics and innovation, and includes those working in a great number of fields w h ere creativity is exercised including engineering, business, and law My interest for this project is in taking a clos er look at a sect of this creative class: the artists,

PAGE 9

2 writers, and performers that Florida refer s to as "bohemians" (Florida, 2002 46) I came to study Landscape Architecture from a studio arts background and have watched as my peers in the arts dissemin ated throughout the country. I have been fascinated with all of our reasoning in the choosing of where we would move after college as well as in following everyone's progress in these places that they chose Early on in my Landscape Architecture studies I gravitated toward projects that utilized and supported the arts commu nity. They were projects that would help create the kind of cities that my colleagues within the arts and I would want to move to. When I attended a presentation by James Richards of his work at an ASLA Conference, I realized that his was the type of research I had already been conducting on my own and that it was the direction I wanted to take in designing my graduate terminal project. The focus group for this project will expand beyond those who are employed fulltime in the arts identified by Florida as "bohemians ", to include what will be referred to in this project as the arts community Members of this community do not have to work in the arts, but inste ad art and culture must be a driving force in their lives, dictating where and how they live. These communities include working artists, arts facility owners and opera tors, and students of the arts, as well as artists with day jobs and passionate arts patr ons. Research Questions Thanks to the work of Florida, we have identified a creative class and the cities they are currently attracted to. Richards showed us what physical qualities are common among these cities and gave suggestions as to how to encourage these qualities. Several of the qualities that Richards identified have direct links to the arts community, while others are potentially linked to it. This project questions whether, in addition to the direct benefits to a city provided by the arts commun ity, this community might also provide the foundation for some of the other urban qualities identified by Richards as common to these creative cities. If

PAGE 10

3 this were true, then a major factor for a city in physically attracting the creative class would be th e presence of a strong arts community. In order to suggest how a city might utilize the arts community as a basis for future design and planning, this research asks, 1) What are the observable physical qualities of an art city? 2) What are the qualities and physical characteristics of an art city that arts community members identify as key to attracting and retaining them? Art Cit y Defined T his project seeks to identify what will be refer red to as "art cities". This is not a term that can be defined via any dictionary, but is an expression of the quality and content of certain cities as perceived by that ci ty's inhabitants as well as those who reside elsewhere. An art city will be characterized as a city that possesses a strong arts community, known to by residents of the city that are outside the arts community and to non residents who are interested in th e arts. Those who were interviewed during the fieldwork portion of this project were familiar and comfortable with the term. For the most part, when case study city interviewees were asked if they would define their city as an art city, they responded with a positive. 21 st Century and the Art City Members of the arts community have certain criteria for the places that they live including amenities, quality of life and an active and nurturing arts community." (Markusen, The Artistic Dividend" 3) These q ualities are important in fueling creativity and the community necessary for the exchange of ideas. This research seeks to identify the qualities of the built environment wit hin both the public and private realm, that are present in existing art cities. It's these criteria that lead many of these people to move to a handful of cities in

PAGE 11

4 the US including New York, San Francisco, Seattle, and Austin (Florida) This centralizatio n of arts communities into only a few places is economically, socially, and environmentally unsustainable. Many artists end up fa r from their homes which leads to an increased financial and fossil fuel expenditure as they travel back and forth They a re faced with ever increasing rents due to the constant influx of young artists who also feel that their only choice is to move there, into cities who's pioneering opportunities have been exhausted (Steinhauer) Many arrive only to have to work long hours at uninspiring jobs to pay their rents leaving little time for the creative endeavors that they c ome to these cities to nourish. Robert Thayer proposes in his article, "The World Shrin ks, The World Expands" that as we move in to the future our worlds will become more limited physically due to the shrinking supply of fossil fuels (11) At the same time, thanks to computer technology, we will have increasing opportunities for the exchange of ideas over great distances (14). Through video conferencing and the easy transfer of large files, we can work on projects with a team made up of people from many different geographic locations. If Thayer is correct, then this shift in lifestyle will m ake moving across the country less plausible as well as appealing for members of the creative community. If going home for the holidays requires a huge financial commitment and a multi day train ride, those trips will become several years between. On the o ther hand, communication tools through the Internet make it easy to share ideas with others. For example, two art school grad uates live in separate cities, one in Seattle and the other in Gainesville. B oth belong to an artist co op in Atlanta, which shows their work in Brooklyn. They are able to view the progress of others over the web and give feedback at all hours of the day. There is already a measurable trend towards smaller, more localized art cities (Markusen, "The Artistic Dividend" 4 ) If this tre nd continues, it will have many benefits including keeping these creative forces in our communities and having

PAGE 12

5 citizens that are more vested in the cities where they live. Members of the creative community are often urban pioneers, moving into run down or abandoned areas of the city because of the cheap rents they offer. Through their skills and creativity t hese pione ers transform the neighborhoods, which then attract more shops, restaurants, and potential residents, decreasing crime and raising property va lues ( Roney ) With the large numbers of artists currently confined to a small number of cities, this process leads to skyrocketing real estate prices that drive artists "out of the very neighborhoods they helped to pioneer." (Steinhauer) But if applied on a more local scale urban pioneers can provide economic and social benefits to the greater community This research aims to work towards the goal of fostering smaller, localized art cities by identifying common traits amongst existing art cities with the i ntention of applying the se findings to potential future art cities.

PAGE 13

6 Chapter 2 Literature Review Creative Class Richard Florida who calls himself an urban theorist, is the Direct or of the Martin Prosperity Institute at the University of Toronto and Global Research Professor at New York University. His 2002 book Rise of the Creative Class a best seller, introduced his concept of an emerging class which he coined the "creative class This classification is economically based and is defined as anyone who uses their creativity as a basis for the work they do. Florida claims that this class makes up more than 30 percent of the workforce and that because of their size, and their values, they are shaping the way we as a society live and work (Florida, Rise, iv ). Through extensive observation and interviews with members of this identified class, Florida has come up with a profile of these individuals that includes their values, habits, and their influence on their environment. These class members occupy a great variety of fields from art to law music to business but Florida believes that they share a "common creative ethos that values creativity, individu ality, difference, and merit" (Florida, Rise, 8). He states that because these class members identify themselves as creative, they demand a lifestyle full of the experience of creativity (Florida, Rise, 13). Florida states that today's, and even more so the future's, industry success depends on the acquisition of creative talent. Where as traditionally companies would locate themselves somewhere and then the workers would follow, he says that today's technology based companies are now locating themselves in cities where they will more easily be able to attract creative class members. He has identified this as the reason for Austin and San Francisco's success as tech industries hubs (Florida, Rise) In the introduction to his first book Florida reco gnizes that his "Bohemian Index a measure of the density of artists, writers, and performers in a region" had a very strong correlation to his measures

PAGE 14

7 for high tech growth. "My conclusion was that rather than being driven exclusively by companies, economic gro wth was occurring in places that were tolerant, diverse and open to creativity because these were places where creative people of all types wanted to live." (Florida, Rise, x) In A Theory of Scenes Daniel Silver, Terry Nichols Clark, and Lawrence Rothf ield attempt to identify what makes a scene. They identify three ways in which people approach potential places to live. The first two are the more traditional. One is as a resident who looks to satisfy practical needs such as grocery shopping or parking. The second is as a producer, or worker, who looks at a place in terms of opportunities to make money. They suggest that the creative class, who "shop" for their cities, relate to a place as consumers. The basis of this groups social bonds are their ideals, their goals are based on experiences. Because of this they choose where they will live based on the amenities provided for them to consume. "From this standpoint, the relevant social question is not focused on who you live or work with, but whether you c an find others with whom to share your dreams and ideals, others with whom you can enjoy the amenities of life: is there a good jazz scene here, can I find martial arts clubs in the style I prefer, are there civil war reenactment societies? To view the c ity block, its institutions, and its people in this way is to view all of them as things to be consumed, enjoyed, and appreciated. When viewing a city block from this perspective the consumer's you are approaching it not as a neighborhood or industria l sector but as a scene a distinct territory devoted to offering not just spaces to live and work but for amenities and pleasures, where social ties are defined by wishes, desires, and dreams, and healthy social ties by the energy with which those ideals are lived out. Scenes, that is, structure social consumption." (Silver, Clark, Rothfield 8) James Richards, FASLA, has worked in the field of landscape architecture for over 30 years. He is co founder and principal of TOWNSCAPE Inc., a Dallas/Ft. Worth based architecture, landscape architecture, and planning firm. I n his 2005 thesis entitled Places to Flourish: Placemaking that nourishes ideas, creativity, and commerce Richards pr esents us with planning and design strategies for creating cities that wil l attract Florida's creative class. These strategies were based on findings from interviews and personal observation of common physical

PAGE 15

8 characteristics in three creative class hubs: Seattle, Washington D.C., and Austin. The strategies he suggests are: 1. Create a green framework 2. Embrace the traditional, compact urban grid 3. Foster distinctive, self contained neighborhoods 4. Create an urban village at the center of the neighborhood 5. Provide a range of viable transportation c hoices 6. Create a vital public realm 7. Encourage a wealth of "third places" 8. Preserve vintage landmarks, buildings and districts 9. Provide a range of cultural opportunities 10. Create a stimulus rich environment The ninth strategy, "Provide a range of cultural opport unities" is directly tied to the arts community Richards elaborates on this suggestion by saying, "A choice of diverse and varied cultural outlets and opportunities, both formal (concerts, live theatre, galleries, and museums) and informal (clubs, street performers) is cited as critically important for leisure time activity, socializing and recharging creative batteries (84). What part might the arts community play in applying the other strategies that Richards suggests? Once the art city case study resea rch has been completed, findings will be compared with this list to identify what relationships might exist. The Arts Communit y Anne Markusen is an economist and professor at the University of Minnesota's Humphrey Institute of Public Affairs Markusen 's main research and publishing topic is the effects of artists on local economies. In her work, Markusen argues that artists provide benefits to their hosting cities' economies beyond what is commonly measured through data such as ticket sales. We show, on the contrary, that artistic activity is a major and varied contributor to economic vitality. We suggest that the productivity of and earnings in a regional economy rise as the incidence of artists within its

PAGE 16

9 boundaries increases, because artists' creativity and specialized skills enhance the design, production and market ing of products and services in other sectors. They also help firms recruit top rate employees and generate income through direct exports of artistic work out of the region" (Marku sen The Artistic Dividend, 4 ) Figure 2 0. Creative Cluster A chart illustrating the downstream effects of the arts on other creative, production based industries. From the paper "Economic Contributions of Singapore's Creative Industries." A group of economists, working along with the Economics Division Ministry of Trade and Industry in Singapore presented a paper in 2003 entitled Economic Contributions of Singapore's Creative Industries This paper sought to chart the downstream effects of the arts on the other creative and distribution based industries along with the scope of these industries. They then compared Singapore's creative industry against several nations known to be leaders in the this sector, all with t he intention of making po licy suggestions to strengthen Singapore's creative industry Figure 2 0 illustrates the downstream effects of the arts community on output from Richard's creative class and beyond to the larger economy The "Cultural Industries" are made up of the artist s, performers, etc. that form the arts community that this project aims to identify and support. The "Creative Industries" are those populated by Richard's creative class and include areas such as advertising, software services, graphic design, and archite cture. The category of "Copyright Industries" includes goods and services that are utilized by the

PAGE 17

10 creative industries such as printing services for advertising There is also an inverse relationship represented by those industries that rely on the service s of the creative industries, exemplified by the building industries reliance on architectural services. The autho rs compare Singapore's potential for strengthening it's creative class economy with Australia, Hong Kong, the UK, and the US and ultimately p ropose public investment in arts, media, and culture as part of a plan to grow it's creative economy Figure 2 1 shows the importance of the creative industries in the US economy with 35% of the workforce being classified as members of the creative class a nd 20% of total exports being products of the copyright industry. It also shows that the US invests the least amount of public funds out of the case study cities in media, arts, and culture. (Heng, Ch oo, Ho, 2003) The Singapore study helps to clarify why R ichard Florida's class is such an important resource. It goes beyond the city scale, to the national one, highlighting the competitive advantage of supporting the creative class. These researchers theorize that the work of artists or those involved in the "creative industries ", make up the foundation for the creative class industry. Ann Markusen's work also places the presence of artists as an important factor in healthy economies. If these researchers are correct, then identifying what attracts and suppor ts artists to a city is a n important tool in securing the success of a city now and in the future. Building on what James Richards identified about creative class cities, this project will seek to identify how the built environment might be shaped to facil itate the creative interactions identified by these researchers

PAGE 18

11 Figure 2 1. From the paper "Economic Contributions of Singapore's Creative Industries."

PAGE 19

12 New Art Cities Most literature identifies large cities as the centers for the arts in the US. New Yo rk City ranks first on this list, often referred to as the cultural capital of this country, and sometimes the world. Other cities commonly found on this list include San Francis co, Los Angeles, Washington DC, and in the more recent times, the medium sized cities of Seattle, Portland, and Austin (Markusen) Numerous articles have been written about which cities are best for artists currently and in the near future One such article is Maya Roney's "Bohemian Today, High Rent Tomorrow published in Business Week in 2007. This article was written with the intention of recommending cities to young artists but despite addressing the issue of high living costs they report ed that at th at time artists we re still likely to sacrifice in order to be near a l arge concentration of other artists and institutions. The recommendations put forth are based on five factors: art establishments per 100,000 people, percentage of population age 25 34, an Arts & Culture Index, a Diversity Index, and a Cost of Living Index Of the ten cities recommended, LA, San Francisco, and NYC made the list despite ranking high on the cost of living index. Some of the other cities had i mpressive scores though, including Nashville, which ranked well in all the categories and had by far t he lowest cost of living. Articles have also been written addressing the issues of increasing real estate prices faced by artists in the most well established art cities today as well as tracking the trends of artists in response to this issue Jennifer St einhauer, in her 2005 article New York, Once a Lure, is Slowly Losing the Creative Set reports that New York City artists have run out of affordable places to live and work and are leaving for cities like Seattle or even being courted by cities such as Ph iladelphia and Minneapolis (Markusen's home base) who wish to capitalize on a strong arts scene.

PAGE 20

13 Robert L. Thayer FASLA, is a n Emeritus Professor of Landscape Architecture and founder of the Landscape Architecture program at University of California, Da vis. He's published two books, including Grey World, Green Heart and over 100 essays. In his 2008 essay entitled The World S hrinks, the W orld E xpands : Information, Energy, and Relocalization Thayer highlights the effects of peak oil and advanced telecomm unication on our experience and perception of the world. He forecasts what the future will look l ike as a result of these forces With a landscape architecture based audience in mind, he places his focus on the changes that would occur in terms of transpor tation, tourism, and land development patterns. "In sum, the implications of the coming oil supply peak and steeply increasing transport fuel prices are considerable for the "grain" of the landscape, for the economy, for food, energy, and water supply chai ns, for travel and tourism. Part of the "re expanding" physical world we will encounter will feature a significant relocalization of provision of physical needs." (13) He predicts that travel by car and air will decrease significantly while increasing sig nificantly by rail, a more energy efficient but slower means of transit. Because of this, he argues, people will choose to travel shorter distances to conserve monetary and energy resources, but also the resource of personal time. In reference to the impac t of a diminishing fossil fuel supply on tourism, he states: "Nearby nature" will become even more critical than it is today, and the entire landscape or tourism will most certainly be transformed. Tourist destinations that are capable of replacing remote international visitors with local and regional visitors will thrive" T hayer then points out that these limitations on travel will "expand" our perception of what has been an ever shrinking world We will physically feel the impact of great distances when we can no longer visit them or must spend days or weeks to get there. But, he argues, technology will continue to expand our communication options over these distances, creating an opposing experience of a world that continues to "shrink". A key notion in Thayer's future is that of global

PAGE 21

14 ideas live d out locally, a future where localized arts communities could be crucial for both the survival of the artists as well as the happiness of the greater community. The research and vision of these writers shows us that c reating and supporting strong arts communities outside of a few major cities provides benefits well worth the effort. Their presence helps to support the local economies as they are today and will perhaps play an even more important role in the futu re as our way of life shifts. So what can a city do to build upon this important resource? This project seeks to provide guidance to cities asking this question.

PAGE 22

15 Chapter 3 Research Methods Research D esign and M ethods This project utilized the research strategies of interpretation and survey and correlation. The nature of this research was qualitative in its search for commonalities and patterns The following research methods wer e applied : Case Studies : based on interviews and articles, four case study cities, of varying scale, were selected. These cities were selected based on a variety of indicators relating to the presence of established arts communities and with the intention of representing four very different types of "art cities". Interviews : in each of the case study cities, interviews were conducted with members of the creative communities as well as city, university, and private workers in the areas of urban planning, l andscape architecture, and urban design Topics include d motivation for coming to their city, features that are important to the arts community, what makes this place special and what may be missing. Interv iews lasted from 45 minutes to 2 hours and went i nto great detail about the physical and social relationships between place and the arts community. All interviews were recorded for later reference. Observation : based on insight gained from earlier research and interviews, personal observations of physic al features that provide evidence of the presence of the arts community or have been reported as important to the creative community were identified and recorded Features that were common to all case study cities were recorded as well as those that were u nique to only one or some of them.

PAGE 23

16 Choosing Case Study Cities The approach to this project was qualitative, not quantitative, so cities were chosen based on how they were perceived in terms of the arts rather than, for instance, how many arts facilities p er capita they had. A list of possible case study cities was create d first by scouring the Internet for arts based blogs, and collecting magazine and journal lists of top art cities At the same time, informal conversations were conducted with many individ uals posing the question of which cities they considered to be art cities. A rtists that had moved to reported art cities were contacted and asked for their impressions. Questions about one art city would lead to mention of another. There was a certain amou nt of variety in the reported cities, but some city names came up repeatedly. From this process a list of possible cities, small, medium sized, and large in scale was formed The scope of the case study cities for this project was contained with in the so uthern region of the US This was done for reasons of e conomic feasibility of this project as well as regional cultural connections to the design implementation city of Gainesville, FL. Many of the interviews conducted in search of case study cities were d one in the southern region, providing the benefit of gaining an understanding of which cities artists within this region considered to be models for arts communities. Cities were broken up into three size categories; small cities being those with a metro p opulation between 100,000 and 750,000, medium sized cities being those with a metro population between 750,000 and 2,000,000, and big cities being those with a metro population of 2,000,000 or more. The chosen case study cities did not include any of the c ountries largest cities, but instead focus ed on two medium sized cities and two small cities. During research of established art cities, the same big cities came up agai n and again like New York City Washington DC, and San Francisco. Cities of this size a re complex systems with many resources available in large quantities. Also, as stated above, there is already a trend toward artists locating to smaller cities (Markusen, "The Artistic Dividend" 4). As the purpose of this study is to find ways

PAGE 24

17 in which to strengthen the arts community in more localized places, it was assumed that the larger cities had a weaker connection to the cities these findings would eventually be applied to. Four case study cities were eventually selected, two within the medium sized city category and two within the small city category. This particular group of cities was selected partly because each represented a different manifestation of an art city. The cities are of varying size and are distributed throughout the southern region. Some details of why each city was chosen: Austin : Austin is a growing medium sized city. Other medium sized cities considered for this study included Nashville and the Research Triangl e (Raleigh/Durham/Chapel Hill), but Austin was eventually chosen for several reasons. Since the publication of Florida's first book, which highlighted Austin as the prime example of a creative class city, many other articles have called out the city for its strength in attracting and supporting the creat ive class. It is also well known for having an internationally recognized music scene as well as for the cit y' s steady growth in spite of the economic downturn. During the case study selection interview process, Austin was one of only sever al cities outside of the major hubs that were reported as popular destinations for artists to locate today. New Orleans : The only other city in the southern region to be reported as a destination for today's artists was New Orleans. The city has long been known for its rich culture and arts scene, especially its music. It didn't rank highly, but made Florida's 2002 list based on his bohemian (artist based) index. Since Hurricane Katrina though, the city has experienced a surge in its arts as well as its cr eative class community (Thompson). In 2008 Prospect.1 New Orleans began the largest biennial of contemporary art ever organized in the US. The fourth incarnation is scheduled for Fall 2014.

PAGE 25

18 Savannah : Savannah is a small sized city known for it's large pre served historic downtown. It also has more galleries per capita th a n New York City (Baker) and is home to the Savann ah College of Art and Design, a large private arts college with a decentralized campus. Florida and others have written about the important role of colleges and universities in strengthening creative cities and in a 2006 interview Florida said the city "defines the frontier" of building creative class cities due to a variety of resources and efforts that will be highlighted later in this pape r. Winston Salem : Winston Salem is another small sized city. It was first considered as a case study city by suggestion from a new resident of the city studying film at one of the universities, and then seconded by a resident by birth. It did not appear o n any of the published arts city lists. Research into the city revealed numerous mentions, by the city mostly, to the arts community. The arts council had a strong presence and the city had branded itself as "the City of Arts and Innovation". Based on thes e findings, Winston Salem was selected as a case study city to represent a city that was putting a lot of energy into being an art city. The unique question going into the analysis of this city was, Can a city will a strong arts community into existence? Interviews In each city at least one person from each category below was selected to be interview ed : An artist: visual artist, musician, filmmaker, or dance/ theater member Someone from the local c ollege or u niversity: an administrator if it was an art school, or either an arts or landscape architecture/ urban design professor or both from all other schools Planning Agency: someone from either the arts council or, if they didn't have one, another city planning agency Arts Facilities Operators: often arti sts themselves, people who owned or helped to run galleries, theatres, and music venues

PAGE 26

19 Observation Before visiti ng each case study city, extensive research was conducted to identify the general layout of the city including where the city center was, the size and location of colleges and universities existence of arts facilities and organizations, and what the alternative transportation options were. When the author arrived at each case study city she would travel the streets via car, foot, and/or publi c transit depending on what the city and neighborhood were suited for. She looked for signs of an arts community. Without a pre conceived notion of what those signs would be, she noted any observations that seemed related to the arts community Next inte rviews were conducted Based on what was learned from the interviewees, the author would head back out into the city, this time paying attention to and seeking out features that had been discussed during the interviews

PAGE 27

20 Chapter 4 Fieldwork: Case Study Cities Figure 4 0. Map of the USA highlighting the region of The South The four case study cities for this project are marked within this context.

PAGE 28

21 Austi n: Western meets "Weird" Population: City = 790,390 Metro = 1,716,2 89 (2010 US census) Slogan: The Live Music Capitol of the World Unofficial Slogan: Keep Austin Weird Figure 4 1. Regional map for Austin showing its place along a triangle formed by Tex as' 3 largest cities : Houston, Dallas, and San Antonio Image Source: maps.google.com Austin is a growing medium sized c ity that was chosen as a case study city for several reasons. The city appeared at the top of Richard Florida's list of Creative Clas s cities and has been referenced in countless articles and books focusing on the city's ability to attract and support the creative class, it's internationally recognized music scene, and the city' s steady growth in spite of the economic downturn The once popular phrase "Keep Austin Weird" seems outdated, as the city has gone from an anomaly in the center of conservative oil and cow country, to being a technology industry hub and well established art city, appearing on both the national and interna tional radar. Austin is known to be a creative city,

PAGE 29

22 but what does the art scene look like there and how do those living in and out of the arts community s ee their city ? Figure 4 2 Google Maps image of downtown Austin Image Source: maps.google.com Au stin is the capital of Texas and is located towards the center of the state in an area known as Texas hill country". It's positioned in between Dallas/Ft. Worth and San Antonio and sits along one side of a triangle formed by the two cities, along with Hou ston (Figure 4 1) The city is also home to the University of Texas at Austin, a 350 acre campus with over 50,000 students (utexas.edu) The campus is located just north of the capital, and is bordered to the east by I 35 and to the west by Guadalupe Stree t (Figure 4 2) Guadalupe, commonly referred to as "the drag", is a long strip of college student oriented restaurants, shops, and bars. The character is a mix of quirky independent businesses and typical chains. UT Austin has programs covering the full r ange of the arts and the

PAGE 30

23 main campus includes generous facilities to house them like the Blanton Museum of Art, which boasts "the largest and most comprehensive collection of art in central Texas." (blantonmuseum.org) Figure 4 3 UT Austin's Public Art Master Plan Prepared for the Landmarks program in 2008 by Peter Walker and Partners. Image Source: landmarks.utexas.edu. The university runs a unique public art program called Landmarks. This program brings sculptures from the Metropolitan Museum of Ar t to campus on long term loan. The program is funded through the University's Art in Public Places program, which reserves 1 2% of the budget of new buildings for public art, as well as philanthropic donations. The sculptures are placed based on a design b y landscape architects at Peter Walker and Partners (Griffin) The Program runs a comprehensive website with maps for printing and podcast tours that can be accessed by cellphone. The campus' closed layout, with restrictive parking, limits the use of this resource, as well as other campus resources, by the greater public. Leah Griffin, the External Affairs Director for the 8

PAGE 31

24 Landmarks program, sp o ke about the challenges of accessibility for off campus community members, They do have to navigate in to the ce nte r of campus which is! a challenge. I think for any person trying to get to campus for any event it's a challenge if they re not living here on a daily basis. It's even challenging if you work here to park ." (Griffin) A sked if the situation were any be tter at night, Griffin said yes, but that you still have to pay and it's still confusing to find your way around. The parking garage ch arges $3 per hour for parking, 24 hours a day (utexas.edu). When Griffin was asked why she came to Austin wh ich she di d a few years earlier, she spoke about her choice not to go to New York City or San Francisco. She said that she really loves both those cities but knew that if she moved there, she wouldn't be able to afford to live in the actual city. She knew she was go ing to have to struggle and she might not be able to make it and might have to leave. Austin offered the quality of life that she desired, having an arts scene but also being very livable and very affordable. Also, because of the large university, she felt there would be job opportunities for her (Griffin). A Savannah resident and graduate of the Savannah College of Art and Design (SCAD) reiterated the draw of Austin as an alternative to the biggest art cities, "I know a lot of people who have graduated fro m SCAD who moved to Austin. It's kind of like the New York of the S outh! we don't want to move to New York!" (Hopkinson)

PAGE 32

25 Figure 4 4 The Trailer Park Eateries a culinary destination located on a gravel lot along S. Congress Avenue in "SoCo". The Colora do River runs through the heart of the city, dividing it into north and south. The river is damned towards the outskirts of town creating a reservoir known as Lady Bird Lake. The C apitol building sits on the north side of the river, in the center of town and at it s entryway begins Congress Avenue. The avenue stretches south through the downtown and continues across the river where it becomes South Congress, or SoCo. This popular pedestrian gathering area is made up of a long strip of stylish restaurants an d bars, boutique hotels, and vintage shops. A block along the east side of the street features a gravel lot packed with food trucks and picnic benches, known collectively as the Trailer Park Eateries (Fig. 4 4 ). Lights strung from poles around the eclec tic mix of food trucks collected there create a scene reminiscent of communal trailer park villages seen in movies The resident ial neighborhoods that surround the SoCo strip are filled with a mix of historic and bold modern style homes These homes featur e well established landscaping that incorporate s both traditional southern and desert plant palettes

PAGE 33

26 In the heart of d owntown, back on the north side of the river, runs the infamous 6 th Street. The street is divided east/ west at Congress Ave and it is east 6 th from Congress to I 35 that makes up the 6 th Street entertainment district. This strip of bars and clubs that serve as live music venues is closed off from traffic on weekend evenings. It's a popular destination for both college students and touris ts that on your average week end feels a lot like Bourbon Street, but once a year it is taken over by members of the weeklong international music festival South by Southwest or SXSW Figure 4 5 A Google map image of central Austin with overlays of th e cities established districts. Austin is well known as a music destination and the city has realistically branded itself as The Live Music Capitol of the World While 6 th street has a high concentration of music venues, Austinites repo rt that this distr ict provides only a

PAGE 34

27 small portion of the music and culture that the city is famous for The city hosts many music venues distributed all over town in little pockets. Figure 4 5 shows a breakdown of Austin by music district. One well known venue is an old dance hall called the Broken Spoke It's located in the South Austin district, in an area defined mostly by car repair shops. It's off a 5 lane road, with no bike paths or cross walks a nd a side walk on only one side of the street. The building look s li ke a feed & seed type shop with little indication of what is inside other than the proliferation of pick up trucks in the parking lot an d the mix of local cowboys and mainstream 20 somethings making their way in Figure 4 6 Toy Joy, novelty toyshop and cafŽ, located on Guadalupe, UT's main drag. Many interviewees mentioned Austin's unique businesses as a major factor in their attraction to the city. The "Toy Joy" shop (Fig. 4 6 ), located near campus on the Guadalupe St. "drag" was a recommended example of this. The shop p resents as a children's toyshop but once inside t he inter ior reveals a few surprises. It is a toy shop for all ages, full of novelty items ranging from Japanese figurines to roas t beef flavored gumballs. It is also a coffee and i ce cream shop

PAGE 35

28 Isaac Oster who is both a visual artist and a video game designer stated that this shop was a good representation of what he believes really makes Austin an art city. It's not necessarily the art that they have there, or even the music; i t's the places. The businesses have such character and imagination, that you find inspiration in your daily routine (Oster) Figure 4 7 Sixth St. Cool Store. A convenience store in the East Austin district, the neighborhood where young artists are c urrently congregating that still offers affordable housing and plenty of "funky" places. With the influx of people, and money, Austin has been experiencing a lot of new development in the downtown. This urban infill can be viewed as positive in contrast t o the urban sprawl that is chipping away at the area's distinctive hill country, but it lacks the character that Austin is known for. High rise apartment buildings with balconies overlooking the water are popping up all along the river's north side. Urban pioneers have done their job in this area, establishing the brunch spots and music venues that have attract ed these new residents. They've now moved to East Austin, the current pioneering neighborhood in Austin where interviewees consistently reported the art s community to now be centered The

PAGE 36

29 neighborhood is centered along two main strips of development. One is East Cesar Chavez Street. The other is East 6 th street, which is a continuation of the music district mentioned previously that is separated by I 3 5. This side of the interstate is now a mix of Latino community and arts community members whose styles meet in the proliferation of murals that characterize many of the buildings (Figure 4 7 ) Here, interviewees said, one can be close to downtown and sti ll afford a live work space. Figure 4 8 Zilker Park Map. Outdoor recreation is popular in Austin with the waterways and many parks filled on temperate weekend days. Zilker Park (Figure 4 8 ) a resource c ited by many of those interviewed, i s a 350 acre (coincidentally the same size as UT's campus) park that contains the Barton Springs Pool (Figure 4 9 ) as well as botanical gardens, a sculpture garden, a hillside theatre, and biking and hiking trails. It also includes all the traditional par k features like shelters and children's play structures as well as programmed sporting areas to include disc golf. The park is located in the heart of the city and is bordered by Lady Bird Lake to the northeast and Barton Creek, a tributary to the river, o n the southeast.

PAGE 37

30 (www.austintexas.gov) Zilker hosts events throughout the year such as the family friendly Zilker Park Kite Festival and the Austin City Limits Music Festival, a festival so popular that its attendance is capped at 75,000 people per day. Figure 4 9 Barton Springs, featured in 2011's film "Tree of Life", is a city run spring fed swim park within Zilker Park. Austin residents from all different backgrounds come to swim & sunbath on warm days (of which there are many). While the city doe s well to provide large scale green space for residents, what it lacks are intimate public spaces. Bikers can be spotted riding along with traffic throughout downtown, but it is apparent that transit in Austin is dominated by cars. Interviewees consistentl y reported that cars were the main mode of transit and listed traffic as one of their biggest, and sometimes only, i ssues with the city Austin is scaled for the car leaving little room for the intimate shared social spaces that are common in more finely s caled walkable cities. A possible reaction to this is the proliferation of p orches found throughout the city and beyond to the suburbs (Figure 4 10 ). The porch culture places groups together in

PAGE 38

31 common places where they've all come to celebrate favorable w eather and the city's food a frequently cited source of pride and entertainment Not only do several bars contain the word "porch" in their name, but porches are featured in some fashion at most, if not all, eating establishments in the city center. Do th e porches provide the fe stival like social atmosphere that one experiences on the streets in downtown New Orleans? Figure 4 10 Porch culture, downtown Austin.

PAGE 39

32 New Orleans: History, Culture, and Recovery Population: City = 343,829 Metro = 1, 1 89 866 (US Census Bureau, 2010) Slogan: Follow Your Nola (before 2013, You're Different Here) Figure 4 1 1 Regional map of New Orleans. Image source: maps.google.com For a city its size, New Orleans is widely known in this country, as well as around the world. The city is a popular tourist destination for it's music, unique culture, and festivals such as Mardi Gras and J azzfest. It stands as a model of the concept that our country is a cultural melting pot. The city was chosen as a case study of a cit y that has historically been viewed as an art city and one whose arts community is currently evolving after one of the worst natural disasters our country has seen. Gene Meneray, Arts Business Program Director at the Arts Council of New Orleans spoke about what makes his art city unique "The interesting thing culturally about the city of New Orleans is that there's this fantastic depth of stuff that's created here. And its not an original thought. A lot of people have said the same thing, but what makes Ne w Orleans a fun, creative city is that there's just so much stuff and its being created by everybody. It's being created by a lot of people who have other jobs, who aren't considering themselves as full time artists. A lot of the jazz musicians in town, hi storically, have been tradesman. The Mardi Gras Indians don't get paid for what they do; they have jobs. They present their art on the streets of N ew O rleans for free to the community and there are thousands of these people and there are thousands of visua l artists as well. And what makes it an interesting place I think, is that

PAGE 40

33 when people come down here they really get enveloped in the culture, it's everywhere. Every city has good artists! but what I think we bring is this just shocking depth." (Meneray) Meneray speaks to several different characte ristics of the arts community in this statement. One is the presence of art performed for free on the streets, making it accessible to everyone and turning the streets into a public gathering space. This practice was noted by interviewees in New Orleans, as well as outside, as what made the city a great destination for arts and culture. Meneray also names two of the traditionally w ell known artist groups in New Orleans: the jazz musicians and the Mardi Gras India ns, who perform in meticulously crafted costumes during the parades. He then speaks about the visual artists who outs iders may not realize make up a significant part of the city's arts community. New Orleans has always b een a destination for music and for the theatrical pageantry associated with its festivals and theatres Dawn Dedeaux, a successful visual artist who was born and raised in New Orleans and continues to work there, discusses how she sees the relationship between the various art forms in the c ity, "Music is a dominant art form. It's the one most recognized internationally; it put New Orleans on the cultural map. I would say though that it s linked to the visual arts and the performing arts in the tableaux. T he reality not from a PR point of vi ew or from a public perception point of view! is that we are a ta bleaux, a cross discipline city. W e have been all along. The music, I would offer, is very seldom static. It's usually while walking and there is music in the parades ...If you look at the hist ory of the visual arts, more often than not, it has served the parade. It has also moved So I think where musical and visual arts meet is in the performance arena of the tableaux! But music is by far what has put New Orleans on the map. No doubt about it, its what brings people here." (Dedeaux)

PAGE 41

34 Figure 4 1 2 Map of central New Orleans. Image Source: maps.google.com The city of New Orleans is situated along the east and west banks of the Mississippi River. It is bordered on the north and east by lakes and on the south by marshland and swamps (Figure 4 1 1 ). It is referred to as the "Crescent C ity" due to the shape of the downtown area formed by curvature in the Mississippi (Figure 4 1 2 ). The downtown neighborhoods run adjacent to each other along the r iver (Figure 4 1 3 ). The streets developed in sectioned grids that follow the path of the river, with St. Charles Ave set back from th e water. A streetcar line runs down the center St. Charles which is lined with historic mansions and oversized oak trees.

PAGE 42

35 Figure 4 1 3 Streetcar map of New Orleans showing the four interconnecting lines. This map also shows the ferry that connects the section of the city across the river and some of the downtown neighbor hoods including the Garden District, the Central Business District, and the French Quarter. Image Source: norta.com The St. Charles streetcar line starts at the Uptown neighborhood that forms the western edge of central New Orleans. I t then runs through t he Garden D istrict, a historic residential neighborhood that is famous for its mansions. Next the streetcar passes under I 10 which forms the dividing line between the Garden District and the Warehouse Arts District The streetcar travels around Lee Circl e, a large traffic circle that holds a monument to Confed erate General Robert E. Lee. This neighborhood is characterized by converted warehouse spaces and houses a number of museums as well as the city' s gallery district. This transitions into the Central Business District (CBD) which is made up of a mix of historic and modern taller buildings. The line ends at Canal Street, which runs perpendicular to the river and starts a shift in the grid. This shift signals a neighborhood change as Canal forms the ent ry point to the historic French Quarter. This popular tourist destination is commonly travelled on foot. The

PAGE 43

36 walkable streets are lined with bars, restaurants, and shops. Bourbon Street, known for its walk through bars and strip clubs, is cut of to traffic for much of its length and serves as an active public gathering space. The Project for Public Spaces calls it perhaps the most sociable and pedestrian oriented street in the country" (pps.org) The neighborhood has a number of galleries, mostly catering to tourists, and many of the bars offer live music. The bars open their doors so that the music fills the street in an attempt to lure in passing pedestrians. Thirteen blocks later, at Esplanade Avenue, the grid shifts again signaling the end of the Frenc h Quarter and the beginning of the Marigny neighborhood. This is where the local arts community members reported that they went as an alternative to the tourist heavy French Quarter. The other neighbo rhood the locals said they visited to see music shows wa s the Uptown neighborhood that houses a lot of the areas college students. Figure 4 1 4 St. Charles line streetcar passing Loyola University.

PAGE 44

37 R ather than having one dominating university as in Austin, New Orleans has a large collection of smaller col leges The largest is Tulane University with a current population of 13,486 (tulane.edu) The remaining schools have less than 10,000 students. The city hosts several historical ly African American schools as well as two seminary colleges. Tulane's campus r uns north south from St. Charles Ave. to Claiborne Ave. in the Uptown neighborhood of central New Orleans. The smaller Loyola University is located adjacent to it on St. Charles and together the two sit prominently along the streetcar line ( Figure 4 1 4 ). Hurricane Katrina, which devastated the city with massive flooding in 2005, was still very much in the forefront for those who live in the city. Scarcely a subject was discussed without the context of Katrina's effects on it. The flood, while devastating seems to have united the arts community here and undoubtedly put them in the national and international spotlight (Meneray). As people work to rebuild the city, many are using the arts as an anchor to build community upon. A lthough the city was still st ruggling to fix things such as street signs, overall when compared with conditions pre Katrina, it looked and felt much the same as it had before the event On e marked difference was in the influx of people in the arts who had taken up residence there, at least part time. There were young filmmakers from afar in town looking to find inspiration for their next movie like Benh Zeitlin writer and director of Beasts of the Southern Wild a magical realism film about a homeless community living outside the lev ees when a storm hit s. The film was nominated for a 2012 Best Picture Oscar. Gallerists from New York City opened up shop and organized the United States' first art biennial in the city of New Orleans, calling it Prospect 1 Dedeaux spoke of the art scene post Katrina, "T here were so many satellite activities. Young people from around the country came in, everybody wanted to be here. Not just for the art but there were lots of young people co ming in to rebuild the city. It presented new opportunites and edu cation in architecture, urban planning, in al most any field you can think of.

PAGE 45

38 T he slate was wiped clean. Okay what can we do new and better? So it brought in lots of new creative energy, including young artists! The locals, the old timers such as myself, w hen we came back to the city we had a different kind of a can do spirit. I think we were left to dangle and I think we pulled ourselves up and it gave us a different sense of resiliency and self reliance! let's rebuild, let's remake. So I think the combinat ion of a new kind of emotional structure on the part of longtime residents combined with all the new energ y and innovative ideas such as P rospect 1 has really fostered an extraordinary thing. This is one of the happening places to be right now in the arts. (Dedeaux) Meneray agrees that the arts community has really strengthened in the past few years, but he doesn't give all the credit to Katrina, "I think there's a lot more interesting things going on here than there were when I first came here (in 2001). Some of that is storm related, but not all of it. New Orleans was getting ready to blow up arts wise before the storm anyway, its just that we had this huge gash that took a long time to repair, which still hasn't fully been done of course! there were more interesting artists that were coming to town and then the storm did add, oddly enough, an element to that. We definitely become known much more nationally and worldwide! then when things started to rebuild decently well, in their own weird way, there were a lot of, especially young people, that wanted to be a part of that, especially in arts and culture." (Meneray) Dedeaux, who has spent months to years working on projects in well established art cities like New York and San Francisco had this to say about a recent stint away from her home "Vancouver was gorgeous, but in the end a little too clean for me. In the end, you look for the funk a little bit. You want a little asymmetry, a little something off beat, a bit of imperfection." (Dedeaux)

PAGE 46

39 S avannah : The Arts College Town Population: City = 136,286 ; Metro = 347 611 (US Census Bureau, 2010) Slogan: Savannah Est. 1733 (savannahnow.com) Figure 4 1 5 Regional map of Savannah. The city is separated from the Atlantic Ocean by marshland and barrie r islands. Image Source: maps.google.com Savannah is known in the US and beyond to be a tourist destination for it's designated historic district It contains the l argest registered hi storic district in the country (Baker). The city also hosts 60 gallerie s, more than three times as many per capita as New York City (Creative Coast). It is home to the Savannah Colle ge of Art and Design, or SCAD, a large and well known university that is dedicated to the arts. Savannah does not appear in Florida's origina l c reative class index ( Rise 2002) but the city has changed since then. Here's what Florida had to say in an interview about the city in 2006,

PAGE 47

40 "Savannah virtually defines the frontier of this field. You are on the absolute cutting edge. I'm so pleased to see things like the Creative Coast effort down there. You're certainly a city with enormous geographic assets, your fantastic historic buildings. Another great thing you've got going on is having the university and college community that you do both with th e Georgia Tech installation that you have and SCAD, with its unique ability not only to revitalize its own buildings but to revitalize the community as well. That kind of seamless blending of environments is very important in attracting the creative class. ( Morekis 2006 ) Savannah is nestled within marshland along the south edge of the Savannah River. It lies on the edge of the Georgia border with South Carolina just north over the river. Mar s hes and barrier islands separate the city from the Atlantic Ocea n, which is a 15 20 minute drive away. The city, established in 1733, developed along the river and grew south from it in a grid pattern. The historic grid goes well beyond the designated historic area, referred to by locals as downtown. Figure 4 1 6 A Saturday in Forsyth Park, Savannah's central urban park located in the Victorian District. Residents enjoy activities ranging from sports, music, and farmer's market shopping, to just strolling the promenade or relaxing on the grassy fields.

PAGE 48

41 Withi n the designated historic area is a feature that makes Savannah unique and plays a large role in the city's popularity with tourists. A series of squares, preserved from the city's original design, remain a part of the urban fabric today. Each of the twent y two squares i s a unique public space and all are connected by attractive walkable streets. The grid of green spaces terminates to the south with a sizeable central park called Forsyth Park (Figure 4 1 6 ) The park is simple and keeps with the style of th e squares A formal fountain stands at the north entrance and a pedestrian promenade travels long ways through the center. Fields on each side provide space for concerts, farmer's markets, and other community events. SCAD holds their Sidewalk Arts Festival there, "The 32nd annual Sidewalk Arts Festival! features the imaginative chalk art creations of SCAD students and alumni. This ever popular event creates an open air gallery in the enchanting environs of Forsyth Park for the public to enjoy." (scad.edu)

PAGE 49

42 Figure 4 1 7 Map of SCAD 's campus This map shows the city's downtown area and highlights the SCAD's buildings as well as the city's series of squares and parks. Image Source: scad.edu

PAGE 50

43 The Savannah College of Art and Design is a private university that o ffers bachelors and graduate degrees in the fields of art and design. The school claims to offer more degree programs and specializations than any other art and design university" (scad.edu) It currently enrolls just under 9,000 students (usnews.com) in p rograms covering the range of traditional art and design offerings as well as programs such as historic preservation, illustration, and game design. SCAD contributes to the arts community by bringing in large numbers of faculty and students who practice the arts, but it is their open campus that brings this resource to the larger arts community (Singiesen) Figure 4 1 7 shows a map of SCAD's campus. The school's buildings are shown in brown and contrasted with the city's historic squares and parks, which are shown in purple. The buildings are distributed throughout the designated historic downtown and further south, past Forsyth Pa rk, where begins the Victorian D istrict that interviewees reported housed many students and arts community members

PAGE 51

44 Figure 4 1 8 Broughton Street, a main street in historic downtown Savannah. The school's impact on the urban landscape can be seen in F igure 4 1 8 The image shows Broughton Street a main street in historic downtown Savannah that has wide, shaded, pedestrian or iented sidewalks that are lined with shops and galleries. The Trustees theatre seen on the street with a SCAD marquee originally operated from 1936 1980. SCAD acquired the property, which they re opened in 1998. It now houses theatrical and musical perfo rmances as well as the annual Savannah Film Festival (scad.edu). Debra Zums tein, Arts Program Coordinator at the Savannah Department of Cultural Affairs, says t he film festival is an example of how the school and the city work tog ether to bring arts to the city, The film festival is a SCAD thing, but we fund that. It's a symbiotic relationship."

PAGE 52

45 The school's influence is one that some interviewees indicated both strengthens and stifles the local arts community. The open campus means that art is in the i mage and consciousness of the whole city, an asset to the community. But the school's seeming monopoly on all things innovative in art was indicated as an oppressive force by some local arts community members. Field observation and interviews revealed th at there were many artists living in and around the city The artists were there because the y attended SCAD, or they work ed at SCAD, or because they thought of Savannah as an art city due to it's history as such and the presence of a such a large art schoo l y ou have a lot of (current) stu dents, a lot of students who end ed up staying here and local artists who have moved here because there's a lot of resources for them here because of the college. (Gossett) But the art that was being publicly displayed for the most part, was either tourist oriented or brought in by SCAD as a resource for the students (Hopkinson) The presence of SCAD galleries displaying work by national and international artists is a great resource but the city currently suffers from a lack of young, emerging, and innovative artwork that is accessible to the public (Morgan) The visual art s cene, however, sounds as though it is strengthening to a point where people are starting to find alternative ways to show their artwork such as t he once monthly Studio H op. The hop works because a number of artists have their studios in the same area allowing for a map driven walking tour. Myrriah Gossett, Executive Director at the Desotorow Gallery, had this to say in response to the question of w hether she considered Savannah to be an art city, "Oh definitely. A lot of times when you talk to people who've never been here and you say something about Savannah, they think of Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil and that whole southern drama! I thi nk once people are here they can feel more of the artist community." (Gossett)

PAGE 53

46 Figure 4 1 9 Map of central Savannah. The series of squares can still be seen in the historic district. The grid pattern continues past the historic district to the south an d east. Image Source: maps.google.com Figure 4 20 An art ist interviewee's house and studio in the Victorian District one of several neighbor ho ods south and east of the designated historic district that offer affordable historic home s and retail sp aces for urban pioneering.

PAGE 54

47 Two a rtists interviewees reported that they had bought historic homes, which they renovated to be used as live work spaces (Figure 4 20 ). A drive around the city revealed many more vacant homes available to fix up (Figure 4 2 1 ) Older buildings are also utilized for music and theatre productions (Baker). "its very very cheap to live here in comparison to other cities that have large art communit i es. If you move to N ew Y ork, you're cutting off an arm and a leg to live there. Wh ere as here you can still hold down a part time job and afford to pay all of your bills, even if you're a working artist. I think part of the draw is the fact that there is a younger crowd here because of the college but there's more people staying because its affordable to live here. (T he arts community) continues to grow because of the graduates who have decided to stay." (Gossett) Figure 4 2 1 A boarded up house in the Eastside neighborhood, another neighborhood on the outskirts of the historic distr ict with historic homes available to be renovated. Artist Johanna Hopkinson said this i n reference to the Eastside neighborhood where she once lived, "There's a lot of artists that have bought houses there because it was kind of a very bad area, like yo u didn't go over there. It's the state streets. They're all named after states. The one that I lived on was Louisiana. Pennsylvania's a big one! and that's pretty much where the Studio Hop was, not show spaces, but people's studios." (Hopkinson)

PAGE 55

48 Figure 4 2 2 Desoto Ave in the newly developing Starland D istrict The Starland District was reported by art community members to be a developing arts area. Desoto Avenue, shown in Figure 4 2 2 is where the Desotorow Gallery is located, along with several other local shops and cafes catering to community members The area is located in the Metropolitan neighborhood, just south of the Victorian neighborhood (Figure 4 18 ).

PAGE 56

49 Figure 4 2 3 The McQueen's Island Historic Trail is a multi purpose trail that run s 6 miles along the Savannah River. It's located along US 80, travelling through the marshlands between Savannah and Tybee Island. Artists stated that they found inspiration in the unique landscape surrounding the city. The marshland and island culture's influence is obvious in the many paintings around town that depict them. The same is true of the historic streets and squares that are also popularly depicted. But they are also sited as important to the abstract painter and the musicians for the beauty an d inspiration that they add to their lives. Savannah's historic district, like the entire city of New Orleans, allows pedestrians to consume alcohol on the streets if they follow certain rules such as avoiding glass containers. The se city's "wet laws ar e aimed at tourists, but also contribute to a street culture that is popular with artists. Socializing is not confined to clubs or house parties, but can be a strolling, anywhere and everywhere event. It gets people out of the bars and into the streets, ut ilizing and

PAGE 57

50 strengthen ing these public spaces b y activating them. It encourages development that is pedestrian friendly and is conducive to events such as art walks, which often include street performers and vendors. It also makes going out more affordabl e as there is no charge for walking the streets, whether one brings a beverage or not. The city also passed ordinances that restricte d alcohol consumption in ways that Gossett says has affected the arts community, "The music scene is also on the rise! the city wants to try and embrace savannah being this up and coming young bustling art scene but they pass all these ordinances that totally restrict that." Gossett says that when she first moved to Savannah, at age nineteen, she couldn't go to any music sho ws. The city had just passed a law that after 10pm, if you weren't twenty one years old you couldn't go in to a bar/music venue. So half of the crowd couldn't support the bands they want ed to see. A new ordinance has affected the gallery she helps run, "Ga lleries now, we get fined if we have wine at our gallery openings. I t's a gallery opening, when is there not wine and beer ?.. It's very restricting SCAD can still have wine at their openings because they have their own catering company with its own liquor license, so they are not affected by the ordinance. (Gossett) Another artist mentioned the lack of wine as part of why the art hop felt "stuffy" and she was not inclined to participate in it. She also cited the amount of time it took to get to all the pa rticipating galleries as an issue. (Hopkinson) As Richard Florida obs erved back in 2006, Savannah does seem to be on the "cutting edge" of becoming a well known destination for creative class as well as arts community members, "My painting professor came here because he thinks it's an emerging art scene, he's brought other people here T here's the SCAD art scene and then there's this other art scene which is much more diverse and happening." (Hopkinson)

PAGE 58

51 "There's more and more things going on if you plan on staying and living here as a youn g artist or just as an artist. There's a lot of opportunites for you to show your work or just to be involved in that community. I mean, even this coffeeshop runs as a gallery too. This is all work from Savannah State U niversity, their seniors." (Gossett)

PAGE 59

52 Winston Salem: Desire & Potential ; Can an Art City be Willed? Population: City = 229,617 ; Metro = 640,595 (US Census Bureau, 2010) Slogan: Your Southern Wake Up Call (before 2013, The City of Arts and Innovation) Figure 4 2 4 Map of greater Winston Salem. Image Source: maps.google.com Winston Sa lem came about as a case study city by suggestion from a new resident of the city and then was seconded by a resident by birth It did not appea r on any of the published arts city lists Research into the city proved intriguing revealing numerous mentions, by the city mostly, to the arts scene. The arts council had a strong presence and t he city had branded itself as The City of Arts and Innovatio n Based on these findings, Winston Salem was selected as a case study city to represent a city that was putting a lot of energy into being an art city. The unique questions for this city, going into the interview and landscape analysis phase were, "Are t hey pulling it off? Can a community will an art scene into existence?"

PAGE 60

53 Winston Salem is located in the foothills of North Carolina It was built on the t obacco and textile industries, and came about when the neighboring cities of Winston the county seat and Salem an old Moravian settlement, were joined In the early through the mid 1900's the Reynolds Tobacco Company and the Hanes textile factory were the major employers of the town. The names of these families can still be fo und attached to things lik e parks, museums, and theatres. Since tobacco has decreased in populari ty and textiles have moved over seas, Winston Salem, like many other cities, is looking for a new industry (Bright) As their slogan before 201 3 The City of Arts and Innovation t old us, the city was looking to the tech industry and arts tourism as the new face and economic drivers for the city. But interviewees reported that the slogan was branding and nothing more and that the city at this time did not live up to it. The n ew slog an Your Southern Wake Up Call" which so far has not been taken up by the arts organizations, is perhaps a signal that city leaders have given up on trying to remake the traditional southern town.

PAGE 61

54 Figure 4 2 5 Map of downtown and north central Winston Salem. Wake Forest campus can be seen in the northwest corner of the map. Image Source: maps.google.com The city hosts several colleges. The two largest are Wake Forest, a private u niversity of just under 5,000 students whose st rength s are their business and medical school s, and Winston Salem State, a public and historically African American university with enrollment of over 5,600. There are a number of other schools, most notably the UNC School of the arts, a member of the North Carolina public univers ity system that has high school through graduate students majoring i n all areas of the arts, and Salem College a small (1,200 student) l iberal arts all girls' school located in the historic old Salem area of t own. Each of the schools is located some dis tance from the downtown area (Figure 4 2 5 especially Wake Forest University which is a 4 .5 mile drive from city center (Figure 4 2 4 ) In some cities, these distances would not be far, but because of the rural or suburban quality of much of the city, t hese campuses seemed quite disconnected. A professor at NC School of the Arts reported that his students

PAGE 62

55 rarely travelled into downtown Winston Salem and that it seemed as though it were in a different town. Instead, they mostly stayed on campus, where the y are all required to live, or visited the shops and restaurants located across the street (Shelnutt). One of the interesting comments received from those who had visited the city was regarding the apparent segregation of the city into a n African American and an Anglo Saxon side of town. Two people separately suggested this observation as a possib le factor in stifling the development of arts and culture within the city. C onnection s were not obvious at first, but interviewees were asked about the issue during investigation. A driving tour revealed that while the city may not be universally split, it is clear why the observation had been made before Several interviewees identified US 52 as the dividing line Interview questions regarding this returned interesting answers along with some history and thoughts on why it had not changed. The city has a compact downtown with a mix of historic buildings and modern skyscrapers. The main strips of activity downtown are 4 th S treet and Trade Street. Each houses bars and restaurants ranging from college oriented to upscale. Trade Street has been labeled by the city as the "Avenue of the A rts" and there a re signs at each intersection alerting visitors to this fact. A visit to the "Avenue of the A rts" revealed a street that contained a few so called galleries. B ut upon closer inspection they were mo stly gift and home dŽcor shops There were no apparent music venues either.

PAGE 63

56 Figure 4 2 6 A "gallery" along the Avenue of the Arts sells imported pieces for home dŽcor. Trade Street has its version of galleries while 4 th street features UNCSA's histor ic Steven Center for performing arts along with an independent film theatre and several more shops calling themselves galleries The arts council has an office on 4 th St. and their new Milton Rhodes Center for the A rts is just around the corner. The M ilton Rhodes Center incorporates a redeveloped city block and includes, two new galleries, meeting and event spaces, a cafŽ and terrace, the new Hanesbrands Theatre and Sawtooth School for Visual Art." (rhodesartcenter.org) Like the Departmen t of Cultural Affairs headquarters in Savannah, the center houses art classes, a gallery, and a flexible multi use black box theatre in one space. The newly reno vated space in Winston Salem was more polished than the Savannah arts space and appeared to be of a larger scale.

PAGE 64

57 Figure 4 2 7 Winston Square Park. A walking tour of the downtown revealed only one obvious public gathering space Between 4 th street and the arts center site is Winston Square Park, a city park, more of a plaza really, that contai ns a water feature and an open air amphitheater On a pleasant Sunday the park was em pty save for a pair of homeless looking people.

PAGE 65

58 Figure 4 2 8 "Avenue of the Arts". The red sign at each intersection alerts visitors that they are in the arts area. The streets are empty on an acclimate weekend day. A striking feature of downtown Winston Salem overall was how empty it appeared On a weekday or weekend, even during pleasant weather, the streets were mostly populated by individuals who appea red to be homeless and radiat ing from the bus depot located downtown. During weekday lunch and on weekend nights the popular restaurants and bars along the main strips attract a lot of people, but at any other time the scene on the streets is in stark cont rast to the tall buildings and sizable population It i s difficult to envision a city population of nearly 230,000 and, in fact, students who were asked were often surprised to hear the figure. The downtown scene in terms of people sited and businesses th at serve residents, is indicative of a population well under 100,000.

PAGE 66

59 Figure 4 29 "To Build a Commu nity," Brad Spencer, 2006, Winston Salem, NC. The sculpture in figure 4 29 tucked a way in a back corner of the Super Walm art parking lot highligh ts a missed opportunity by the city. A 1% for the arts program was implemented so that new big box retailers might offset their negative aesthetic impact by supporting public art (Davis) Unfortunately, this sculpture, along with another at the other end o f the parking lot was allocated to the property of the large retailers with no control over where they were placed The meaning and impact of these pieces is lost in the odd context Could these pieces have been used to activate the downtown areas where p edestrians would encounter them? When taken to see the pieces, a local student and interviewee was surprised that he had never noticed them before (Corrao). The Winston Salem art s community suffer s from a f ail ure to connect the arts community from school of the arts and the other colleges with the desired downtown arts community The city's attempts at creating this community seem stifled by a lack of authenticity that arts community members consistently reported being repelled by.

PAGE 67

60 Chapter 5 Findings The Artist and the City An artist requires some essentials to both survive and create. Arts community members identified the following list of requireme nts as universal needs that their cities must provide : inspiration, income, workspace, and community. Inspiration Artists interpret the world as they see it for their art. They require some source of inspiration to fuel their creativity. The sources are as individual as the work, but common external sources of inspiration included nature, culture, and the art of others. "The good thing is that there is food here to nourish creativity. The circumstances are perfect right now." (Dedeaux in reference to Ne w Orleans ) An artist needs to eat literally They need some source of income to pay the bills. Ideally this income comes from the selling of their work, but more often it is in the form of residencies, grants, or working a day job. The most ideal jobs ar e those that support their art, namely teaching jobs, community arts work, or working in the facilities where the art takes place. ( Markusen, Dividend, 19) In order to produce and share their work, an artist needs a workspace Musicians, dancers, and thos e in theatre need rehearsal and performance spaces. Visual artists need studios and show spaces. Filmmakers need locations and studios to shoot in and workspaces in which to edit. First and foremost, these spaces need to be affordable, but just as importan t is the quality of place. "One of the rea sons I chose to stay here over New Y ork was economy. Its so much cheaper to live and work here. Its getting more expensive though." (Dedeaux who's workspace is in a historic New Orleans home complete with a full kitchen and firnished bedroom for when she works late )

PAGE 68

61 Lastly, few artists can survive without community Solo artists need colleagues to bounce ideas off of and share resources with. Many artists, especially those in the field of music, theatre, film, o r integrated arts, work consistently with other artists. Just as important are the patrons. The artist creates their work to share with others and this experience of sharing is what helps to fuel their work. Richards' Creative Class Characteristics In the process of this research, relationships were identified between the arts community and the strategies James Richards suggested for attracting the creative class In some cases, the arts community directly provided the resources needed, in other cases the arts community demanded the same characteristics. 1. Create a green framework : a ccess to nature was universally reported as important to members of the arts community. 2. Embrace the traditional, compact urban grid : urban pioneers from the arts communities gravi tate towards the areas within their cities that contain a compact urban grid Foot traffic is important to galleries and music venues, so the walk able scale of these areas attracts them. The relationship works both ways here as a compact urban grid attrac ts the arts community and they also, in turn, preserve and revitalize these areas by settling there. 3. Foster distinctive, self contained neighborhoods : the arts communities tend to congregate, creating a vibrant arts district. These districts make for disti nct and desirable neighborhoods. 4. Create an urban village at the center of the neighborhood : it was observed that, a side from large theaters, most arts venues are at the scale of the urban village. They cluster alongside cafes and shops toward the centers o f neighborhoods creating arts nodes in various neighborhoods throughout a city. 5. Provide a range of viable transportation choices : the availability of transit options was a common characteristic of the case study art cities

PAGE 69

62 and was named by arts community m embers as an important criterion when choosing their city 6. Create a vital public realm : the arts community contributes to a vital public realm through activities such as arts and film festivals, monthly art walks, fresh air markets downtown concerts and o utdoor movies screenings They require centralized and pedestrian friendly streets and public spaces in which to conduct these events. 7. Encourage a wealth of "third places" : live music demands venues and enlivens coffee shops and bars. Many visual artists s how their work on the walls of these places. Galleries and museums are themselves third places. 8. Preserve vintage landmarks, buildings and districts : artists serve as urban pioneers, doing the work to preserve historic buildings and open spaces. 9. Provide a r ange of cultural opportunities : the arts make up the bulk of cultural opportunities a city provides. These include the activities listed that enliven the public realm, as well as theatrical and musical performances, film screenings, and visits to galleries and museums. Besides providing cultural opportunities, artists also require this resource as it provides inspiration for their work. 10. Create a stimulus rich environment : The unique storefronts, signage, and outdoor spaces created by arts venues work toward s creating a stimulus rich urban environment, as do street artists and public art. Arts City Traits Identified Through literary review, observation of the case study cities and personal interview s with residents in the arts and design communities in eac h, fourteen traits were identified that were common to some or all of these cities. These traits each play a role in the presence of the arts in a city be it as a source for artistic inspiration, a tool for sharing the arts, or as a sig nal of the strength of the arts

PAGE 70

63 community. Below, t he traits are first listed with a brief explanation after which they will be discussed in relation to each case study city with examples to help clarify the concept. Nature Local James Richards identif ied a "green framework" as one of the physical characteristics of a creative c lass city. He advises cities wishing to attract the creative set to "Preserve the best and most distinctive natural features and extend and link them to create a generous, interc onnected network of green space, framing urban growth and buffering incompatible uses while providing a wide range of landscape experiences." ( Placemaking, 48) Markusen identified as important the pull of the "area's unique lake, river and recreational en vironment" (Dividend, 21) in her research on artists and the arts community in the Twin Cities. This category refers to the natural resources available within the city. This refers to not just the quantity of these resources, but also the quality. Importan t questions are: What is the accessibility to nature within the core of the city? Can these resources be accessed via public transit? Are there bike and pedestrian greenways? This category includes greenways as well as accessible areas such as wooded parks and preserves, waterways, and gardens. City as nature some cities have a sense of nature that is integrated with the urban fabric. Observed and reported e lements that contribute d to this sense include d tree cover formed by large shade trees of organic form, overgrown landscape shrubs and groundcover or established plantings that are meant to mimic nature, and older weathered hardscape or hardscape that responds to the existing plantings.

PAGE 71

64 Figure 5 0. "Savannah Marsh" by Carolyn Molder. Nature Regio nal Regional nature is accessible outside the city at a distance of up to an hour and a half by car. Interviewees in each case study city identified regional natural resources as important in their choice to be in these cities, but this message was especia lly strong in Austin and Savannah, two cities with a variety of unique natural areas within a short distance from city center The importance of these places as a resource for artists is reflected in their frequent depiction in art pieces displayed through out the city. Figure 5 0 shows a painting by a Savannah artist. The image was found on her website along with the quote Savannah is a painters paradise. The marsh just draws this artist! ( Art Expressions by Carolyn, 2012 )

PAGE 72

65 Local Cultural Identity The successful art cities that were studied each had their own local and cultural identity. This culture formed organically and its presence was evidenced through the music venues, food establishments, shops, and public celebrations. Because the onl y "native" culture to the US is Native American, all these unique local cultures were either formed by the various groups that through the years made these cities their homes or by cultures that were formed in the cities themselves. University Richard Fl orida identified universities as an important part of the creative class city, In my view, the presence of a major research university is a basic infrastructure component of the Creative Economy! (Rise, 291) He breaks down the universi ty's influence into three roles. Technology : university's being on the cutting edge of research in technological fields ; Talent: university's bring in those who are talented in their fields for teaching and for graduate study, and graduates create spinoff companies lo cated nearby ; Tolerance: "Universities also help to create a progressive, open and tolerant people climate that helps attract and retain members of the Creative Class." (Rise, 292) The pres ence of a college or University also plays an important role in a rt cities. (Markusen, Dividend, 16) If the school has arts programming, as most do, it does so by bringing artists and art historians to the city to teach and by creating fluctuating but ever present student arts communities. These schools provide performa nce and gallery spaces for students to share their work with the university population as well as the community, often at very reasonable prices. They also bring in artists to showcase for the students and larger community. Schools differ in their contri bution to the city's art scene depending on factors of accessibility (venue size, parking, signage) and publicity of arts events and resources. Internet mapping and social networking has increased the value of this resource as community members can now sub scribe to schools' arts

PAGE 73

66 departments and venues for notification and can more easily look up directions and instructions. Urban Environmental Cues These cues are the visible evidence to the public of an active arts community. This would not include a publ ic art piece commissioned by the city, but instead the more organic, everyday displays of a city influenced by the arts. The murals of Austin are an example of this Pedestrian Promenade Qualities of a pedestrian promenade include either entirely carless streets or large sidewalks, filled with parading people, and often characterized by unique shops, cafes, and galleries. Sometimes these promenades are more nature focused, occurring along the water or through a tree lined allŽe. Centralized Public Gatheri ng Space These gathering spaces, in the center of the city, serve as venues for the cities' many festivals and celebrations. They are the destination for people from all different backgrounds, bringing them together in great numbers on beautiful spring Sat urdays and serving as shared backyards and neighborhood streets for weekday evening strolls. These spaces include central parks and pedestrian only or dominated streets and quarters Transit Options "A range of viable transportation choices" was lis ted as one of James Richards ten Creative City Characteristics. (Placemaking, 63) Florida too found transit options to be important to the creative class, "The availability of subway and rail transportation was a key factor cited by creative people in the interview s and focus groups for the Rise of the Creative Class! (Flight, 201) In his book My Kind of Transit: Rethinking Public Transportation in America", Darrin Nordahl looks at public transportation not for its economic or

PAGE 74

67 environmental benefits, but for its potential as a destination in itself. He argues that when thoughtfully and creatively designed, public transit can attract users and itself become a sought after public gathering space. Most of the successful art cities, and many great cities in g eneral, offer attractive transportation options besides a personal vehicle. In the art city, these options are not only offered, but they have character, enriching the experience of the traveller as well as adding visual interest to the city's urban f abric. These options include novelty public transit, attractive walk able streets, and pedestrian and bike friendly streets and greenways. Arts Nodes An arts node will be defined in this paper as a grouping of arts venues and may include arts supportive b usinesses and public open space. These nodes form organically as each of the venues and businesses serve each other in a reciprocal way. These nodes often begin in an area with excess empty commercial space that offers low rents and little restrictions on what businesses can do with the spaces. "So it doesn't get officially designated like "we're gonna make this a gallery district." It sort of organically happens to where there's a leased building that suddenly becomes vacant, so an artist will move in and then another artist will move in. Then it becomes that gallery designation of a cultural district, rather than the district being defined and then the shops." (Baker) City & Community Arts Infrastructure The four cities studied for t his project each have strong city and community arts infrastructure. This includes city arts councils and various community run arts organizations. These groups function to offer support to artists in the area as well as make the arts more accessible to the community. Each of the case study cities had at least one, and often several, physical spaces that housed these organizations. These spaces typically included offices for the staff with information and advice available to local artists as well a s performance, studio,

PAGE 75

68 and/or exhibition space. Many used the venues to offer classes for adults and children within the community. Connectivity Connectivity in this context refers to the adjacency of desirable traits such as affordable housing, arts node s, nature, university, and public gathering space. Also, what the transit options available to connect these areas are. Affordable Real Estate with Character Interviewees consistently referred to neighborhoods offering older/historic areas that were still affordable as an important resource for artists. These neighborhoods were important in terms of both residential and business real estate. They offer opportunities for urban pioneering, the process by which individuals or groups move into a neglected area and fix it up. The presence of the pioneers attracts other businesses, then more residents. Real estate values go up and then eventually the original pioneer populations gets priced out and moves on to another area to start the whole process over again. A rtists make for obvious pioneers due to their need for cheap workspace and their skills for fixing places up. Arts nodes, which may now be upscale, were often formerly settled through this urban pioneering process. Public Functions I n th e case study cities visited it was discovered that there were a lot of public, outdoor based functions happening. Some were free of charge and others were ticketed events, but all were open to anyone who wished to attend. Some of these functions include d: art walks, farmer's markets, parades, and festivals. Festival themes included art, music, theatre and film, as well as non arts themes like the kite festival in Austin or a beer festival in Winston Salem.

PAGE 76

69 Public Art The presence of public art sends t he message to residents as well as visitors that art is something that the city values. Public art did not have a large presence in all the cities studied but in the ones where it did, it was well distributed throughout the city. Surprising was the find ing that most of the public art in these cities was tucked away off park paths or on neighborhood streets, rather than being large and flashy and located on major streets where they would get the most exposure. This created a real sense of discovery and allowed for a more intimate experience with the art pieces. Breakdown by Case Study City The chart in Figure 5.1 is a visual comparison of how the identified art city traits manifest differently in each of t he case study cities. A section is marked with an "X" when a trait was either absent from a city or when no visual example of the trait was identified. Following, each city is revisited through the prism of the identified traits, exploring further how they may attract and support the arts community through these elements of the built environment.

PAGE 77

70

PAGE 78

71 Figures 5 1 Art City Traits: this matri x compares the different manifestations of the identified art city traits in each of the case study cit ies.

PAGE 79

72 Austin Figure 5 2 Nature within the city. Clockwise f rom top left: "Festival B each" community garden ; dog park along the river, dinosaur sculpture at Zilker Botanical Gardens; Barton Springs at Zilker Park ; Kite Festival at Zilker Park; gre enway along the river during a rowing event Nature Local Austin has a strong showing of nature at a local level. Interviewees referred to several local resources and conveyed a high level of satisfaction with the access to nature that the city provided High on the list of nature destinations was Barton Springs Pool, a large spring fed pool constructed within a creek (Figure 4 6). The pool is located within Zilker Park, which contains a variety of other natural areas with access via bike and hike trails canoes and kayaks. The city is divided by the Colorado River, which was damned at the east end of the city and created Lady Bird Lake. Bridges over the water, bike and hike trails along it, and access points along the shore provide opportunities for the community to enjoy this resource (Figure 5 2 )

PAGE 80

73 Figure 5 3 City as Nature: an outside bar and music venue on busy South Congress Street. Figure 5 4 Regional Nature. Clockwise from top left: Hamilton Pool Natur e Preserve located 30 miles from Austin city center ; spring at Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center; winery in Texas Hill Country, irrigation structure at Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center; and The Salt Lick barbeque restaurant in Driftwood.

PAGE 81

74 Parts of Aus tin provide the experience of city as nature. Along some of the city's urban pedestrian oriented streets are pockets like the one pictured in Figure 5 3 that look like a wooded park. Nature Regional Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, a renowned n ative plant botanical garden and research center, lies on the southwest outskirts of town. The region of the country in which Austin lies, referred to as "Texas Hill Country", offers a unique landscape experience and is dotted with beautiful natural form ations like Hamilton Pool (Figure 5 4 ). Figure 5 5. Local Cultural Identity: F ood t rucks found throughout the city. Local Cultural Identity Austin is home to real cowboy culture, a culture that manifests in country music shows, honky tonk dance club s, boot shops, and restaurants visible throughout the city. The influence of the city's Latino population is evidenced by the many Mexican themed restaurants, but the population is not really integrated into the city as a whole. East Austin offers an opportunity to experience this culture

PAGE 82

75 through the businesses still owned and patronized by Latin Americans. The influence of Latino culture can also be seen throughout the city wi th the proliferation of food trucks. Food trucks are now an integrated part of Austin 's culture, showing up solo or in groups, in parking areas or empty lots throughout the city, serving every kind of food imaginable (Figure 5 5) University The University of Texas at Austin is a large university that offers a lot of cultural resources to the city of Austin. It is located just north of the city center and houses numerous arts venues. The school s Landmarks public art program brings outdoor sculptures by well established artists to the campus as well as visitin g artists and indoor pieces in other mediums While the school has a lot to offer the arts community, its closed campus design and limited parking can make it difficult for off campus community members to access these resources. The city is also home to a number of other small public and private colleges including an offshoot of the Art Institute of Houston. Figure 5 6 Urban Environmental Cues: Signage.

PAGE 83

76 Figure 5 7 Urban Environmental Cues: Murals. Urban Environmental Cues Quirky businesses with imaginative and highly visible signage (Figure 5 6) give the city character and signal a creative culture. Murals throughout the city (Figure 5 7) pay homage to this traditional art form of the c ity's Latin American population while also reflecting the city's support for unregulated urban art. The prevalence of both food trucks and porch culture show the penetration of creativity in all aspects of public life, including dining out. Each food tru ck is as unique as is their placement, sometimes clustering together to create their own small villages where people sit family style at picnic tables. If a restaurant has space surrounding the building, then they usually have a porch, many of which are fu ll of character.

PAGE 84

77 Figure 5 8 South Congress Pedestrian Promenade. Pedestrian Promenade A number o f pedestrian oriented streets form the backbones of the arts neighborhoods. South Congress, starting just south of the river, is popular with locals as w ell as tourists for it's galleries, funky shops, and unique eateries (Figure 5 8) Historic east Sixth Street, located downtown, is lined with bars and clubs serving as music venues. The street is closed off to cars on most weekend evenings and for special events (Figure 5 9)

PAGE 85

78 Figure 5 9 Pedestrians and bikes take over for the South by Southwest Music Festival on East 6 th Street. Centralized Public Gathering Space Zilker Park is Austin's large, programmed, and heavily used central park. It is used da ily by city residents and is also the venue for special events and festivals such as the Austin City Limits Music Festival. The Colorado River runs through the heart of the city and is utilized by businesses for views and citizens for activities ranging fr om water sports to sunset bat viewing on the bridge. East Sixth Street, when closed off from traffic on weekend evenings and for special events like the SXSW music festival (Figure 5 9) serves as public gathering space

PAGE 86

79 Figure 5 10 Rickshaws provid e relief to pedestrians on their way to and from the Kite Festival at Zilker Park. Transit Options While Austin has implemented transit alternatives such as a limited rail line, cars still appear to rule the streets there and terrible traffic was the one complaint that most all interviewees had. A certain constituency seems determined to bike despite the apparent dangers of riding along and amongst thick car traffic. One interesting transit option is the popularity of rickshaws or pedicabs in areas where there are crowds. Arts Nodes Austin's numerous music venues are clustered in large numbers in areas such as East Sixth Street and South Congress The city has many others though, and rather than being limited to an Arts District, arts venues are distributed in pockets throughout the city.

PAGE 87

80 City & Community Arts Infrastructure Austin h osts a number of arts organizations, with coinciding venues, covering all areas of the arts. The university plays a key role in the cities perfo rming arts programming (van Ryzin, Austin arts groups feel strains of growth") Affordable real estate with character East Austin currently provides an opportunity for cheap housing and pioneering opportunities, but as Austin has grown quickly, the pionee rs have exhausted much of the historic affordable housing that the city had. Connectivity Arts nodes, the university, public gathering space, and nature are all adjacent to each other, but the city's scale and lack of transit options make it so that many activities involve a car ride. Most interviewees indicated that they travelled miles apart for various activities and relied on their cars to get from one place to another. There are neighborhoods in the downtown area that provide numerous resources at a bike able distance, but it appears that the only one that also offers affordable housing is East Austin. Public Functions : Austin has an active festival schedule of music, film, and arts festivals as well as novelty festivals like the Kit e Festival. The city hosts two well known music festivals. One of these, SXSW, brings in artists and fans from around the world. Tickets are expensive, but off shoots from the event turn the entire downtown into a weeklong arts festival. There are numer ous farmers' markets spread out all over the city.

PAGE 88

81 Figure 5 1 1 Rayo de Esperanza A Beacon of Hope: Sculpture, Community Kiosk, Benches" by artists Connie Arismendi and Laura Garanzuay at the entrance to the East Austin neighborhood. Public Art : Austin has a strong public arts presence. The city's Art in Public Places program allocates 2% of capital improvement project budgets for the acquisition of public art. The website for the program, which catalogs all the pieces and tells where you can fin d them, lists 168 pieces of public art work ("Art in Public Places"). Austin is also rich with murals, which help to characterize the city.

PAGE 89

82 New Orleans Figure 5 12 "City as Nature" Nature Local The Mississippi River forms the southern ed ge of the downtown. Audubon Park is a large natural park in city center that also houses a zoo. Much of the city has a "city as nature" quality with large oak trees forming allŽes along major avenues. Nature Regional The city rests between a lake and a river. Just beyond the city is the Gulf of Mexico and the bayou stretches out to the east and west of the city providing a variety of unique ecosystems. Local Cultural Identity New Orleans serves as a microcosm of "the melting pot" phenomenon that defines American culture. The cities name is unanimous with culture and interviewees from this city, as well as from others, referenced the city's rich culture as inspirational. There appears to be a certain level of cultural mixing throughout the city center, at least when compared with the other case study cities. New Orleans history brought with it a unique style, amongst American

PAGE 90

83 cities anyways, that is reflected in the endless blocks of beautiful historic streets and squares. University The city hosts severa l colleges and universities with arts programs. Tulane and Loyola sit adjacent to each other on St. Charles, along the streetcar line. The location and visibility of the schools make their arts offerings more accessible to the larger community. Figure 5 13. Urban Environmental Cues. Urban Environmental Cues "Funky" spaces abound in this city with p lenty of "grit", even in the gentrified areas The house in Figure 5 13 shows evidence of Mardi Gras, many months after the festival has ended.

PAGE 91

84 Pedestri an Promenade Bourbon Street is the street in New Orleans most famous to those outside the city It is cut off from traffic and hosts an endless stream of parading tourists, but the locals indicated that they do their best to stay away from this node of deb auchery. Neighborhoods beyond the French quarter provide alternative pedestrian promenades, such as Magazine Street, that are where the locals spend their free time. Centralized Public Gathering Space New Orleans has a very large, programmed park called C ity Park that sits at the north end of the city. Audubon Park is a natural park that is on the south side. These parks are used for events and as a place to gather and enjoy the outdoors. It is the streets and squares though, that really serve as New Orl eans' centralized public gathering spaces. Figure 5 1 4 View from the streetcar.

PAGE 92

85 Transit Options Driving in New Orleans is relaxed due to wide slowly travelled streets and a surprising lack of traffic in the city center. Perhaps that is because the ci ty offers an inviting and enlivening public transit system of streetcars (Figure 5 1 4 ) and ferries as well as a pedestrian oriented city center. Two of the main attractions for visitors to the city are riding the streetcar and walking the streets of the Fr ench Quarter. Arts Nodes New Orleans has several identifiable arts nodes. The Julia street arts district presents a strong visual arts node. The French Quarter and Adjacent Marigny neighborhood are filled with music venues. City & Community Arts Infrast ructure New Orleans now has a strong city & community arts infrastructure thanks to numerous city and community run arts organizations. The tourists who come to the city for its arts and culture help to support the city's artists and give rise to these org anizations. Interviews revealed that since Katrina the national attention and interest in helping to rebuild after Katrina ha ve led to the organization of arts events, such as Prospect New Orleans This event, for instance, strives to function a s the United State s premiere biennial arts event.

PAGE 93

86 Figure 5 15. Freret Street Center in the pioneering Freret Street neighborhood. Affordable real estate with character Due to the large stock of historic buildings, the city still has plenty of older neig hborhoods that provide cheap housing and pioneering opportunities. Freret Street (Figure 5 15) is just one example of this. Connectivity New Orleans' downtown neighborhoods, Universities, and large naturalistic park are all connected via streetcar and wal k able streets. Another streetcar travels north ending near the very large City Park. Ferries connect the downtown to neighborhoods across the Mississippi River.

PAGE 94

87 Public Functions Festivals are a key part of New Orleans culture. The city hosts some s ort of festival every week and many of these festivals offer opportunities for local artists to participate and make money (Meneray) They have festivals themed around every area of the arts, the most famous being the New Orleans Jazz and Heritage Festi vals held at City Park. The biggest festival of all though is Mardi Gras, held in the streets of the city, which officially runs for twelve days and brings together all areas of the arts into a parad ing arts and culture experience Public Art : Public art in New Orleans is a mix of more classic styled pieces that blend in with historic parks and squares and colorful modern pieces distributed throughout. The works are organized by the Arts Council of New Orleans and funded by a program called Percent for Ar t that collects 1% of eligible municipal capit a l bonds (Meneray )

PAGE 95

88 Savannah Figure 5 1 6 Savannah squares and the walkable streets that connect them. Nature Local The city of Savannah is located along the Savannah River and the city is de fined on two more side s by marshland. The historic city center is built around a grid of park like squares each with large shady oak trees. The squares are connected by tree lined walk able streets (Figure 5 16) and terminate at Forsyth Park. Nature Regional Marshland extends from the border of the city to the ocean, a 15 minute drive away. Amongst the marshlands are wooded preserves. Tybee Island, along the ocean, offers sandy beaches. A Savannah visual artist, when asked to map the city of Savannah highlighting what places were important to her, had this to say : "The most important places for me are the islands because even just driving out to Tybee you see all that marsh. Just seeing the horizon I think is, it's good for

PAGE 96

89 people. It sets my mind at ease to see the horizon. You look at it, so peaceful. It's great, especially if it's warm enough to get in the water." (Hopkinson) Local Cultural Identity Savannah has a large, beautiful historic district at the city center. It is, in fact the largest National Historic Landmark District (Baker) and is a popular tourist destination because of this resource. The city has a rich African American history that dates back to the slave trade and reaches forward through the civil rights movement. The cit y' s historic tours offer several oriented toward s the African American community. University Savannah has a remarkable number of colleges and universities for its size. The Savannah College of Art and Design is a large, private, arts centered un iversity. This school has the biggest impact on the arts community in Savannah due to its focus as well as its open distributed campus, which integrates the school with the greater arts community. Florida shared this observation in an interview, "SCAD, wit h its unique ability not only to revitalize its own buildings but to revitalize the community as well. That kind of seamless blending of environments is very important in attracting the creative class." (Morekis 2006) Personal Interviews suggested that SC AD had a powerful relationship with the city because of its size and investment in downtown real estate. Since the school has no campus, as it grows it acts as urban pioneer fixing up marginal historic buildings and transforming the areas they are containe d within. "That's another thing people don't realize. There's SCAD, but we have the second largest student population per square mile, second only to Boston. There's SCAD which in the downtown, then there's Savannah State which is out toward Skidaway and more towards the islands. They have an art program as well. Almost all of the interns at my gallery have come from Savannah State. A lot of our volunteers are from SCAD, but almost all of our interns are from Savannah State A lot of people forget about th e other colleges because SCAD is so well known and its downtown. Because we don't have a centralized campus! every other block you're seeing a SCAD building, so you just assume

PAGE 97

90 that it's the only college here. But its not, there's a lot of them and they al l contribute to the different programs." (Gossett) Figure 5 1 7 A SCAD building offers the juxtaposition of "retro" bikes with canon clad historical architecture. Urban Environmental Cues One cue of the creative community is the juxtaposition of his toric architecture with artifacts of the mo dern arts culture and venues (Figure 5 17) Pedestrian Promenade River Street, along the water, is a promenade lined with bars, restaurants, and shops that is popular with tourists and college studen ts. The city's infamous series of squares connected by pedestrian oriented oak tree shaded streets serves as a pedestrian promenade along with the central path of the park that's at the terminus of the grid. Open container laws through out the designated hi storic district bring patrons to the streets where they stroll and take in the views rather then being limited to the indoors while imbibing

PAGE 98

91 Figure 5 1 8 Forsyth Park. Centralized Public Gathering Space The historic city is built on a series of squares connected by pedestrian oriented streets. These squares culminate at a small (30 acre), but active, central park (Figure 5 1 8 ) Transit Options Savannah has pedestrian oriented streets throughout the city center. A charming ferry, wate rfront streetcar, and downtown shuttle connect many of the cities cultural and civic destinations, all for free. The biking infrastructure is limited, but enough residents choose to bike so as to create a critical mass. The critical mass makes for a steady presence so that cars become accustomed to looking out for bikes. Like New Orleans, there is an ease to driving the streets of Savannah's city center thanks to wide streets, a number without lane dividers, and slow driving speeds. Arts Nodes

PAGE 99

92 Arts venues, including those at SCAD, are distributed throughout downtown. The Starland District, south of the historic district is a burgeoning arts district. Several galleries and creative independent businesses have moved in to vacant retail space there and the arts community is active in trying to grow it City & Community Arts Infrastructure The city has a long history of arts based tourism (Baker). Because they still do, the cit y invests in its arts community. The city's Department of Cultural Affairs puts on festivals and productions and offers art classes to the community. It's housed in a building in the South of Forsyth Park ( SOFO ) neighborhood where the monthly Art Bash take s place and includes studios, a gallery, and a black box theatre. Figure 5 1 9 Affordable historic real estate available for pioneering Affordable real estate Older neighborhoods like the Victorian District, that surround the designated histor ic district still provide a generous stock of affordable historic housing and pioneering opportunities (Figure 5 19)

PAGE 100

93 Connectivity Connectivity in the downtown is pretty good. Walk able streets and squares lead from the waterfront to the central park. A variety of public transit options connect areas to and around downtown. The scale and pace of the city and clustering of resources in the city center make walking and/or biking a viable way of life. Public Functions The city hosts a number of music and t ech nology related festivals in the vein of Austin. The First Friday Art March covers venues in the area called SOFO (south of Forsyth Park). The area is south of the historic district and contains the Starland District arts node. Every Saturday there is a farmer's market at Forsyth Park. Public Art The city has a lot of historic statues and fountains (public art was very big here in the 1800's) that add to the historic experience, but is quite limited when it comes to modern public art. (Zumstein) "The o ne thing we've all been talking about that the city lacks is public artworks." That's something we've been working on at the gallery. We'd really like to start a public art program. "a lot of it is, because its a historical town, you can't actually do them The historic district has very strict quidelines even on what color you can paint your house." But there are other areas where public art could be integrated such as the Victorian District where many of artists live because it's cheaper. (Gossett) Zums tein, from the Department of cultural affairs also spoke to a lack of public art in the city, saying, "It has a lot of monuments. As far as modern public art, no. (The city has) a lot of historic public art."

PAGE 101

94 Winston Salem Figure 5 20. Reynolda Garde ns, originally owned by the Reynolds Tobacco family now belongs to Wake Forest University It in contained on campus and is free accessible, and open to the public. Nature: Local Winston Salem has city parks and historic gardens (Figure 5 20) distribute d around the suburban residential areas that make up most of the city. Rural areas between different sections of the city offer the experience of nature while driving (Corrao). Nature: Regional The city is in the Piedmont region of North Carolina with sm all but picturesque mountains a short drive away. For example, Pilot Mountain S tate P ark is a 25 minute drive away and Hanging R ock S tate P ark is a 45 min ute drive

PAGE 102

95 Local Cultural Identity Old Salem a National Historic Landmark that sh owcases the historic Moravian settlement through a staffed interpretive village, and other history based parks provide for cultural tourism. The city's focus on historical ways of life and the appearance of racial segregation in the urban landscape make f or a sense of experiencing the culture of the old south for better or worse University The city has several universities, including Wake Forest and Winston Salem State, each with standard arts program offerings. As with the rest of the city, the campuse s of these schools are separated from the city center by rural areas. The North Carolina School of the Arts is a state run magnet arts boarding high school that offers undergraduate and graduate degree programs in the arts as well. The campus is within the city limits but is distanced from the city center and students rarely engage in activities off campus (Shelnutt). Figure 5 21 Avenue of the Arts. Clockwise from top left: The avenue on a Saturday afternoon A red sign near the traffic light reads "A venue of the Arts"; an interesting building off of the avenue with graffiti reading "What is art?"; a lamppost along the avenue with a banner that reads Downtown Arts District : Where art lives. ; the avenue is cut off from traffic at night for the once mo nthly artwalk.

PAGE 103

96 Urban Environmental Cues Downtown has a designated "arts district" which is heavily advertised through signage and publications but which contains little true art. The area is very polished, lacking the gritty quality of other art cities (F igure 5 21) Pedestrian Promenade A few people can be seen walking to shops and restaurants along the pedestrian oriented streets of the city center. Students can also be seen parading down the pedestrian friendly sidewalks, lined with bars, on weeke nd nights. For the most part though, the city has no true pedestrian promenade. Centralized Public Gathering Space Most of the time, the downtown feels empty. Considering the population size the city feels surprisingly empty as well (Corrao). However, s treets in the historic downtown center are closed off to traffic for special events (Figure 5 21, last image) creating a much needed centralized public gathering space Transit Options The Winston Salem transit authority offers a fairly comprehensive bus service. Routes radiate from the city center, connecting residential areas with the downtown, without any links between. The bus appears to be mostly utilized by those who cannot afford a car with interviewees reporting that they do all their travel in th e city by car. Arts Nodes The arts organizations have been a major shaping force in the downtown center and have clustered their venues there accordingly (Hanes).

PAGE 104

97 Figure 5 22 Arts Facilities. The images to the left show the Hanesbrands Theatre (top) and Sawtooth School for Visual Art (bottom), both part of the new Milton Rhodes Center for the Arts; the image to the right shows the Stevens Center, a historic theater operated by the UNC School of the Arts that is located downtown City & Communit y Arts Infrastructure The city has a number of active city arts planning groups that are ready and waiting to support the arts activity that the city has to offer. Mr. Hanes (a Hanes underwear heir in his 80s) himself, as well as other interviewe es familiar with the history of the cities arts community, credited Hanes as helping to build both the city and community arts infrastructure. Affordable real estate Recognizing the trend towards downtown revitalization, the city has paired investors with most of the unique historic structures downtown. Residential areas mostly appeared either well kept or impoverished with no signs of urban pioneering. Connectivity The city does not work as a whole, instead like several small towns in proximity to each o ther. Each of the schools sits as an outlier and the students have little, if any, contact with the rest of the community. Arts facilities entertainment venues,

PAGE 105

98 and shops are clustered downtown, but the lack of affordable housing makes this resource only available to wealthier city residents few of whom are likely to be working artists. Public Functions The city hosts a number of arts themed festivals including a weeklong arts festival, a film festival, and an African American theatre festival. The "Dow ntown Art District" hosts a monthly Gallery Hop with closed off streets and street performances as well as an "Arts on Sunday" series that runs through the month of May in the same area. Figure 5 2 3 Public Art. The mosaic wall on the left is an older piece, located in the downtown area. The piece on the top left is located in a Wal Mart parking lot. Below it is an aerial view of the parking lot the sculpture 's placement indicated by a green star. Public Art The city passed an ordinance requiring la rge scale retail developments to either be designed to create some kind of v isual interest, which can be satisfied by landscaping, or to include some kind of public art. The success of this ordinance is questionable (Titus). Figure 5 2 3 shows an example of a public art piece tucked away in a Wal Mart parking lot.

PAGE 106

99 Community arts organizations have contributed permanent public art pieces as well as organizing temporary installations like the Winston Salem Light Project, now in its fifth year (Hanes). Sy nthesis The chart below (Figure 5 24 ) s ummarizes the presence and strength of art city traits in each of the case study cities. Below each synopsis is a ranking, ranging from 1 to 5 The ranki ngs were given based on observation and indication during interv iew s of the strength of these qualities in each city. The numerical value represents that the strength of the trait is: 5: very strong 4: strong 3: average 2: weak 1: very weak

PAGE 107

100

PAGE 108

101

PAGE 109

102

PAGE 110

103 Figure 5 24 City Trait Summary. The ranking were then added up and di vided by the number of traits (14) creating an average that could be used to compare how the cities ranked over all. These are the totals from highest ranking to lowest : New Orleans: total 65, average 4.64 (strong to very strong) Austin : total 58, av erage 4.14 (strong to very strong) Savannah: total 57, average 4.07 (strong to very strong) Winston Salem: total 38, average 2.71 (weak to average)

PAGE 111

104 Figure 5 2 5 City Trait Ranking Chart. In Figure 5 2 5 the rankings were charted to give a visual understanding of how they ranked through the categories. In comparing these different charting methods, varying patterns were observed. For instance, Austin ranked near the top in most categories, but its average was brought down by weakness in the two categories of transit and real estate. Despite these factors though, Austin is viewed as a successful and desirable art city, highlighting that a city needn't have strength in every one of the identified traits to be a success. Also, Savannah

PAGE 112

105 ranked ve ry closely to Austin, though it is a much lesser known art city due to its scale. The city was only "very strong" in four of the categories, but it also never dipped below an "average" ranking indicating no serious areas of weakness. This would seem to in dicate that Savannah is a good example of a regionally scaled art city, providing the same traits as bigger art cities, but on a smaller scale. It also indicates that the city traits can be used to analyze smaller cities that wish to identify the potentia l to grow their arts communities How might a city's rankings in the different categories change as it develops as an art city? Savannah, for example, may rise in its rankings of the three categories it did worst in: urban environmental cues, arts nodes, and public art. Like Austin though, it s rankings may drop in the category of affordable real estate with character as pioneered neighborhoods move into the next phase of gentrification. Winston Salem ranked fairly low overall for an art city. Its low est rankings included (but were not limited to) the following areas: pedestrian promenade centralized public gathering space, transit options, and connectivity. These are areas within the design and planning powers of the city which with the right vision c ould help to shape the art city they seem to desire so much.

PAGE 113

106 Chapter 6 Bringing it Home: Gainesville as Art City Figure 6 0. Map of the USA highlighting the region of The South. The city of Gainesville is marked along with the previous case study cities for context.

PAGE 114

107 Gainesville Population: City = 124,354 ; Metro = 264,275 (US Census Bureau, 2010) Slogan: Every Path Starts with Passion Figure 6 1 Reg ional map of Gainesville showing vicinity to other cities and natural resources. With a population of almost 125,000, Gainesville is alternately thought of as a small city or a large town. From an outsider's perspective, it is dominated by its role as hom e to the University of Florida. The university is one of the largest in the nation that is well known for many things including research and a top ranking football team. The city also hosts Santa Fe Colle ge and it's population of over 23 ,000 students. A well respected community college, the school is in the process of expanding its program offerings as it takes on its new role as a four year college

PAGE 115

108 The residents of Gainesville know that there is more to the city than it's University. The city is known regionally, and beyond by those who know of it, as culturally rich and the region is heralded for it's natural beauty and resources. The large student popula tion and hip long time residents support the arts and local businesses that contribute funkiness to the town. Gainesville has a lot in common with the art cities profiled for this project, but you won't find it on any art city lists out there, at least not yet. Figure 6 2. Local Nature: Paynes Prairie Preserve.

PAGE 116

109 Figure 6 3. Loca l Nature. Clockwise from top left: bat houses on UF campus, the City's historic Evergreen Cemetery, bridge at Kanapaha Botanical Gardens, a butterfly rests at UF's Butterfly Rainforest. Figure 6 4. City as Nature. Street, houses, and a parking lot in th e area surrounding IHub Square.

PAGE 117

110 Figure 6 5. City as Nature. The live oak canopied SW 2 nd avenue, adjacent to UF's law school. Nature Local Gainesville residents often boast about their "tree city" and generally report that they are happy with the cit y's natural resources. Gainesville has a well developed neighborhood park system distributed throughout the city, with larger spaces concentrated on the outskirts. Throughout the city are small nature parks with trails and many of the programmed parks have large shade trees and overgrown shrubs that give a feeling of being in "nature." Just outside the city limits to the north and east of town are access points to Paynes Prairie (Figure 6 2), a unique ecosystem that houses a great variety of indigenous plan ts and animals. The preserve contains numerous walking trails and is most noted for frequent sightings of birds and alligators and the occasional glimpse of introduced buffalo and wild horses. Just west of the city there is Kanapaha Botanical Gardens, a private park which houses a variety of garden styles from around the world. UF campus, near the

PAGE 118

111 center of town, contains several publically accessible preserved areas including a lake. Large bat houses and a Butterfly Rainforest provide opportunities to se e these ephemeral animals close up (Figure 6 3). These resources are limited in their availability as Kanapaha charges an entrance fee and is a challenge to get to without a car and parking is heavily restricted on campus. Much of the city of Gainesville, especially the older areas east of 34 th street, qualifies for the concept referred to in this project as "city as nature." Several people interviewed referred to feeling as though they were in nature when they visited older neighborhoods and areas of the downtown. Large trees abound and much of the landscape has grown out to a natural form throughout the years. Figure 6 4 shows examples of this in the College Park/University Heights area located between UF campus and downtown. Figure 6 6. Regional Nature. Clockwise from top left: the Santa Fe River, a pelican flies over a dock at Cedar Key, Itchetucknee Head Springs, Marjorie Kinnan Rawlings Historic State Park.

PAGE 119

112 Nature Regional The region surrounding Gainesville offers a great variety of natural resources. Large preserves like Paynes Prairie and San Felasco sit just outside the city limits. Spanning from a half to one hour's drive north are a series of springs that feed into a system of rivers. Itchetucknee Head Springs (Figure 6 6) is the beginning of the Itchetucknee River, a crystal clear river that is popular for tubing and canoeing. An hour and a half in either direction are the Atlantic and Gulf coasts. Florida's Eden is an organization that works to combine art, nature, and econom y in North Florida in order to preserve lands, educate the public, and connect locals and tourists to the resources the area provides (McMurry). Figure 6 7. Local Culture: Gator Fans & Ethnic Diversity. Gator football culture unites people from all wal ks of life, as long as they wear the right colors. Reggae Shack CafŽ Jamaican restaurant and Caribbean Queen cafŽ offer taste s of Caribbean culture.

PAGE 120

113 Figure 6 8. Porters & Hippies. Clockwise from top left: a house in the Porters neighborhood; The Jam mu sic venue where patrons are encouraged to bring their own instruments and jam out together; another house in Porters; hippies playing banjo and juggling oranges at the Downtown Farmer's Market. Figure 6 9. Springhill Neighborhood. Clockwise from top left : historic Perryman's Grocery; the historic Cotton Club; presumed sign for the historic Cotton Club; an example of residences in the neighborhood. Center: Springhill Neighborhood sign displayed outside the historic Cotton Club, which is still being redevel oped in the eastside of Gainesville.

PAGE 121

114 Local Cultural Identity The Gainesville community doesn't contain any singular culture that is unique, but is made up of a diverse population that is rich in culture and that blends together to create an overall unique "Gainesville culture". Some examples of this include the Gator football culture that takes over the streets from downtown to the university on seven Saturdays each fall (Figure 6 7) and the Hare Krishnas who have a large presence on campus and can be seen chanting and parading down the streets. The Porters Community (Figure 6 8), a historically African American residential neighborhood located just west of downtown is named after the train porters who originally settled the area. The Springhill Neighborh ood (Figure 6 9) of Southeast Gainesville, another African American neighborhood, houses two culturally significant historic buildings the former Cotton Club and the historic Perryman's Grocery The city's Community Redevelopment Agency is in the process of renovating the building with plans to utilize the whole site as a community resource. The former grocery store will have a commercial kitchen and shop and the site will host a cultural farmer's market. ( "Project: Cotton Club/Perryman's Grocery Revitaliz ation & Farmer's Market ") Thanks to the University the city hosts students, professors, and their families from all over the world. Opportunities to share in these cultures are presented by the restaurants, ethnic grocery stores, clubs, and festivals tha t are a part of the urban fabric (Figure 6 7). The University and Santa Fe College, along with the city's abundance of nature, create an atmosphere that attracts another of the city's cultural populations. Gainesville is known to many as a "hippy" town bec ause of the liberal minded and colorfully clothed people who flocked to the town in the 60's, and never left, contributing creatively designed cafŽs and shops and helping to support the arts community. The city would do well to support the visual presence of these communities who often inhabit "funky" older buildings

PAGE 122

115 that offer lower rents and are vulnerable to being pushed out of the way for shiny new (or redeveloped) developments in the city's core. Figure 6 10. College & University Arts Facilities. Cl ockwise from top left: UF's University Auditorium; a performance outside Santa Fe State College's Gallery; UF's 4most Gallery located between campus and downtown; UF's Phillip's Center for Performing Arts, part of UF's Cultural Plaza.

PAGE 123

116 Figure 6 11. Publi c Art on UF campus. Clockwise from top left: "Blue Trees" by artist Konstantin Dimopoulus; "Whispering Close" by artist Seward Johnson; "Squares on Square" by artist Charles Fager. University Gainesville is home to both a college and a university: The Un iversity of Florida, the 2 nd largest state university in Florida with nearly 50,000 students (A.Ps, Enrollment at Florida universities is up 2.6 percent") and Santa Fe State College which has a student population of nearly 24,000 ("About Us" Santa Fe Col lege .). Both schools have programs that cover the range of the arts and each contributes to the presence of the arts within the greater community. For example, Santa Fe College puts on the annual Spring Arts Festival held in the streets of downtown. Figur e 6 10 shows some of the arts venues at the two schools. While the University hosts a generous variety of arts events, interviews revealed that events on the east side of campus were often unknown and perceived as inaccessible to some of those from the Gainesville community. M any of those interviewed who did not currently attend the University said that they rarely hear d

PAGE 124

117 about events happening on campus, but that even if they did, they wouldn't know where to park or how to na vigate the campus. The university is spread out and boxed in by the large streets that border it on all four sides. Parking is extremely limited on campus and prohibite d in the areas surrounding it for blocks. By contrast, evening events at the west campus venues contained within UF's Cultural Plaza, including The Harn Museum of Art, The Phillips Center for the Performing Arts, and The Museum of Natural History, were mor e well known to the general public who indicated in interviews that they were familiar with the location and felt confident that they could find parking there. The university is responsible for doing a better job publicizing it's events, and social network ing is helping, but how can UF and the city work together to "open the doors" of the university to the rest of the community by providing better access to art and cultural events on campus? How can they help those who are unfamiliar with campus to navigate it once they are there? The University of Florida has several public art pieces located either on the exterior of buildings or in the landscape (Figure 6 11). "Squares on Square" is one that is tucked away and can only be seen when approaching the build ing who's wall contains it, but it offers a great surprise when it is discovered. Like many of the art pieces on campus, it was funded through UF's Art in State Buildings program, a subsidiary of the state of Florida's program by the same name. The program was established in 1979 and works by reserving up to .05% (capped at $100,000) of state funds for new buildings to purchase public art ("About" Art in State Buildings at the University of Florida.). "Blue Trees" is a temporary on campus installation in wh ich high profile trees were painted with an environmentally safe pigment. The project highlights Florida Friendly tree varieties and is meant to bring awareness to deforestation. The UF Foundation funded the project in celebration of the 150 anniversary of the Land Grant Act, which created the university and also in celebration of National Arts and Humanities Month (Crabbe, Attention getting art project aims to save forests").

PAGE 125

118 A collaboration between the University of Florida and the Gainesville Communit y Redevelopment Agency brought outdoor sculptures to both the UF campus and the city's downtown area. "Whispering Close" is the only statue that remains from the large collection of sculptural figures included in the exhibition entitled "Crossing Paths" (C rabbe, "Statues to bring real life, artistic replicas to Gainesville"). These lively public art pieces caught the attention of many residents and students and served as a great example of how the university and city can work together to elevate the arts ex perience for both populations. Figure 6 12. Urban Environmental Cues: Businesses use buildings as canvases. Clockwise from top left: FLA Gallery; The Top restaurant and bar ; The Original Pizza Palace restaurant ; Best Jewelry & Loan pawn shop

PAGE 126

119 Figur e 6 13. Urban Environmental Cues: Unique and visually striking businesses. The Repurpose Project on South Main Street and The Zen Hostel in the SE downtown area. Figure 6 14: Urban Environmental Cues: Restaurant theme parks. Lightnin Salvage Enterprises which encompasses Satchel's Pizza, Junk Museum, Five & Dime, and Lounge on the far NE side of Gainesville.

PAGE 127

120 Figure 6 15. Urban Environmental Cues: In your face sustainability. Tempo Bistro To Go cafŽ on NW 13 th Street.

PAGE 128

121 Figure 6 16. Urban Environmental Cues: Porch culture. Clockwise from top left: Common Grounds music club; The Lunchbox cafŽ on the downtown plaza ; The Lunchbox cafŽ with live music during Artwalk ; The Top restaurant & ba r. Urban Environmental Cues It is not unu sual to see businesses in downtown Gainesville use their buildings as canvases (Figure 6 12). Murals are a cue that there are artists active in the area and that the city supports the arts by allowing this form of public art. Locally owned businesses are popping up all over downtown Gainesville. These newer business are incorporating originality to differentiate themselves and to fill unique niches (Figure 6 13). The Repurpose Project on South Main Street is both a unique and visually striking business. Th e business is a non profit and works by collecting excess materials from the public that would otherwise be thrown away. They then offer workshops for a minimal fee where they demonstrate how to re use the materials in creative ways. They also have a galle ry that showcases recycled art and they participate in Artwalk by running workshops. The Zen Hostel in the SE downtown area offers unique accommodations. In the spirit of Zen, the hostel only suggests a donation of $20 40 and asks that visitors do ten

PAGE 129

122 minutes of chores. The compound, adjacent to the Sun Center, is worth just walking by. Satchel's Pizza is now a Gainesville institution. The restaurant/museum/five & dime was a true urban pioneer when it opened in 2003 near the far NE Industrial Park (Fig ure 6 14). Since its popularity, several other restaurants have given the area a try but most have closed or relocated. The restaurant succeeds because it is a destination in its own, worth travelling across town or even to town for (their Facebook page co ntains comments from fans who drive from towns like Jacksonville, an hour and a half away, just to eat there). Outdoor seating options include lush landscaped gardens and a Volkswagen Bus. There is almost always a wait for a table, but that's no problem be cause it gives guests the time to explore the theme park that is Satchel's. Local businesses in Gainesville are working together to elevate sustainable practices and create a tighter knit community. Tempo Bistro To Go is an example of a local cafŽ that u tilizes "in your face" sustainability projects to attract and inspire its customers (Figure 6 15). Their backyard patio showcases rain barrels and repurposed vertical gardens. The compost advertises a relationship with a local compost company that manages their compost in exchange for collecting it and selling it to the community. Another sign advertises the local source for their heirloom vegetable garden. When the whether is nice and the setting is too, people flock to restaurants and bars with porches ( Figure 6 16). Porch culture is growing in Gainesville as more businesses are making the effort to create charming outdoor spaces that have open views to public streets and squares. Seeing people enjoying the social outdoor scene of a porch is great adverti sing and a healthy porch culture is a sign to visitors that the community knows how to enjoy themselves.

PAGE 130

123 Figure 6 17. University Avenue looking west from West 8 th Street. Pedestrian Promenade Gainesville, as it stands today, lacks a dense urban core. T o some this is a good thing as it leaves the downtown more relaxed and more easily accessible via car. Most all art cities though, or "cities" in general, have a part of town where the scale of the buildings shifts to become larger and more dense. Sid ewalks widen to accommodate greater pedestrian traffic. When entering a new city, one needs only look for the skyline to point them towards the restaurants, bars, shops, and galleries. Gainesville has a downtown much of it lovely and historic, but it is fairly spread out making navigating from one venue to another by foot challenging. The once monthly art walk exemplifies this. Arts venues have began to congregate in the downtown, but they are still too far apart to visit them all without getting in the c ar a few times, having to deal with the challenges of parking each time. Future plans for Innovation Square offer some promise for providing urban density but that will take time and some versions of the plans seem aimed at more of a corporate park than a diverse and stimulating town center.

PAGE 131

124 The closest the city currently comes to a pedestrian promenade would be University Avenue which holds pockets of shops t hat are almost close enough to warrant parading along (Figure 6 17). I nfill on this street seems likely in the future and linking these pockets with interesting retail and venues would make it a destination. The sidewalks, however, are tight. Even at four lanes, the traffic can be congested. What if this street where to be c losed off from traffic? Replaced with wide sidewalks, bike lanes, and a streetcar or trolley? Due to the fact that the avenue is a state road, this possibility seems highly unlikely. One idea that has been discussed is to use SW 2 nd in this way. This idea will be further discussed below in the "Transit Options" section. Figure 6 18. Existing downtown public space. Clockwise from left: The Sun Center plaza; Bo Diddley Community Plaza ; brick streets of the historic downtown temporarily closed off to traffic during an annual arts festival ; Easter Sunday photo shoot at the Thomas Center gardens

PAGE 132

125 Figure 6 19. Open Space Study. The study shows that West Gainesville is less dense with many large scale natural and recreational parks. Downtown and East Gainesville have denser populations with many small parks, some only a frac tion of an acre, but few if any large scale or natural parks. Figure 6 20. Future Public Space. An artist's rendition of the future Depot Park slated to open in 2015 in the SE downtown area. Image Source: gainesvillecra.com Centralized Public Gathering Space Gainesville offers a small, pedestrian oriented, historic city center. Beyond the Downtown Plaza, it offers limited public areas for gatherings and events. The city does well with the small Downtown Plaza for small concerts and School Conservation Area or Nature Park Community Park Neighborhood or Mini park Roper Park: 1. 5 acres Cofrin Park: 27 acres Depot Park Tech Square Downtown Westside Tumblin Creek Park

PAGE 133

126 the farmer's market. They shut down the charming historic streets surrounding it for special events such as the biannual arts festivals (Figure 6 18). The successful art cities that this study looked at, as well as other well known cities, have a large central park type sp ace where the public gathers on evenings and weekends creating opportunities for collaboration and community building at all times and bringing a diversity of people together who would not otherwise meet in the course of their own daily routines. One of Ga inesville's strengths is its cultural diversity, but small neighborhood parks tend to only serve the segregated communities that they are contained within (Figure 6 19). Plans are in the works for a large downtown park on the SE edge of town that will be n amed Depot Park (Figure 6 20). While not currently central, the park is close to the downtown center and offers the potential to expand the downtown development to the south and east. How can this park be programmed to become an attraction for the community at large, a true "central park"? How can it reach out and connect with the rest of the city so that people will want to make the trek there?

PAGE 134

127 Figure 6 21. Transit Options. Clockwise from left: Entrance to the Hawthorne Trail from Depot Avenue; n ew pedestrian and bike friendly street in SE downtown; the new and expanded bus station ready to integrate BRT if and when the city starts it up; a city bus on SW 2 nd avenue. Transit Options Gainesville has a well developed public transit system, based s olely on buses. The system is ever expanding and is currently the fourth largest in the state. It is supported by fees and grants from the University of Florida and Santa Fe College and is offered to University of Florida students free of charge. Although the system is actually very reliable, and most buses can be tracked in real time using GPS, residents often reported the bus to be very unreliable. Most of those who had the option of driving expressed that they only take the bus when forced due to pa rking restrictions on campus. The buses are very mundane which may contribute to lack of interest many residents feel in exploring them as an option They are all painted the same, unless covered by advertisements, and offer no stimulation once inside eith er.

PAGE 135

128 Figure 6 22 Innovation Square. An image created by Perkins & Will showing what SW 2 nd Avenue could look like in the future. Image Source: perkinswill.com/work/innovation square The city is slowly growing its bike infrastructure. They are working to expand rails to trails and are proposing other rail and pedestrian friendly routes throughout the city. SW 2 nd avenue which runs from downtown to campus, is a good example of a multimodal route. Buses, cars, bikes and pedestrians share the roadway wi th equal status (Figure 6 21). This avenue is part of the streetcar route in the city's BRT (Bus Rapid Transit) proposal A successful mult i modal transit corridor, yes, but does this avenue have the potential to become a pedestrian promenade as discussed in the earlier section? This will hinge on how the area is developed Currently the avenue contains large sections of historic residential homes set back from the road as well as blocks free from any development There isn't really anything to visit along the route, and walking is the least common mode of transit observed by those using it today The future development of the area known as Innovation Square ", which takes up several blocks roughly half way between downtown and campus, could turn the avenue into a pedestrian destination. Some versions of the plans for the future include pedestrian friendly sidewalks pedestrian scaled infill, and pedestrian destinations such as shops and sidewalk cafes (Figure 6 22 )

PAGE 136

129 Figure 6 2 3 Downtown Arts Node. Cl ockwise from top left: The Bull bar which hosts art shows and live music just off of South Main Street; the courtyard at the center of a burgeoning arts node on South Main Street; The Top restaurant on North Main street has created its own node by opening a music venue across the street and bringing in a gallery next door.

PAGE 137

130 Figure 6 2 4 The Downtown Arts Node. from left to right : the pillars of the Hippodrome Theatre and gallery with Gallery 21 next door; the Artisan's Guild Gallery and Persona in the Union Street Station; Maude's local coffee shop in the historic Sun Center that wraps around the Hippodrome; across the street, the rival Starbucks coffee in Union Street Station.

PAGE 138

131 Figure 6 2 5 The South Main Arts node. Clockwise fr om top left: the main building on Main Street that houses the Display Gallery, Civic Media Center, and the Co op Grocery store; Across a small avenue and adjacent to the shared parking lot is The Church of Holy Colors, an artist's cooperative started by re cent UF grads; the courtyard with seating and a stage and access to the businesses housed there ; the courtyard entrance to the Sequential Artists Workshop, an art school for the graphic arts. Arts Nodes The downtown is home to a number of galleries, theaters, and music venues branching east and west off of North and South Main Street. The Sun Center, in the Southeast quadrant of downtown, is a historic complex of galleries, shops, and restaurants that wrap around the historic Hippodrome Th eater with a plaza in between. The Hippodrome is the architectural showpiece of downtown and houses the city's largest theater as well as an independent film venue and a gallery. Across the street is the fairly new Union Street Station, a development with retail on the bottom floor and upscale condos on several floors above. The complex did an excellent job of blending in with the Sun Center and fits comfortably in its place in the center of downtown. Two longtime artsy Gainesville businesses have relocated there: the Artisan's Guild, a co op retail space for local artists, and Persona, a shop for eccentric used costumes and dŽcor.

PAGE 139

132 Outside Persona is a public art piece that looks like a beast in recline (Figure 6 2 4 ). This piece is part of a public art proj ect that the owner of the shop, who is also a painter, has just started. Further south on Main Street is an area that has been slowly pioneered and has recently organized together around a central courtyard to form an arts node that calls themselves the S outh Main Arts & Community Center (Figure 6 2 5 ). The node is made up of a gallery, an artist's cooperative, a co op grocery, a graphic arts school, and the Civic Media Center, an alternative library that hosts educational and arts events. The courtyard is the center of the action during the monthly Artwalk with live music on the painted stage, food trucks, and other vendors. This is a very exciting area, showcasing the kind of urban arts pioneering that anchors the hip neighborhoods in established art citi es. It is currently under threat, and possibly already doomed, by the city and private developers who wish to take over the transitioning area. It would be a loss to Gainesville's development as an art city if this node where dismantled too soon. Figure 6 2 6 The Doris Bardon Community Cultural Center on North Main Street.

PAGE 140

133 Figure 6 2 7 The Actors' Warehouse, a non professional community theater, is home to the Star Center Children's Theatre and the Spirit of Soul Repertory Company. The black box the ater opened in 2011 in small strip development on North Main Street. Figure 6 2 8 Across Main Street and in between The Doris and The Actors' Warehouse a sign announces the arrival of a new business. Vine is a local bakery and pasta maker that got its s tart at the Farmer's Market. A sign of a developing arts node on North Main Street?

PAGE 141

134 City & Community Arts Infrastructure The city's community arts organizations finally have a face. The Doris opened recently in an interesting historic building on North M ain Street (Figure 6 2 6 ) It features a gallery and artists' studios as well as ceramic and printmaking studio access for the public. The artists in residence teach art classes in the studios. The Artisan's Guild Gallery (Figure 6 23) offers local artists an opportunity to sell their work in a retail setting in exchange for working in the shop several hours a week. This also offers the artists and community members a chance to interact and connect. There are numerous groups that are active in bringing in outside, and showcasing local, arts in Gainesville and the surrounding areas. The city has good community support for independent businesses making it more viable for people to take the risk of starting up the kinds of businesses that support a strong arts community (Figure 6 2 8 ).

PAGE 142

135 Figure 6 2 9 Affordable historic business real estate. Clockwise from top left: former home of Louis Lunch burger joint which closed after 82 years in business; a very unique building on North Main Street ; the old Rice Hardware building just off South Main Street ; a vacant building on University Avenue near Main Street Figure 6 30 Housing stock. Clockwise from top left: two houses from the SE area near the futur e Depot Park; a cottage integrated into a local Bed & Breakfast complex; a student rental along SW 4 th avenue near campus.

PAGE 143

136 Figure 6 3 1 The Power District. The relocation of the city's utility company opens up 16 acres of land in the SE near the future Depot Park. Figure 6 3 2 The Catalyst Building on the outskirts of The Power District which now houses Prioria Robotics.

PAGE 144

137 Affordable real estate with character Downtown Gainesville, while far along in the revitalization process, still offers affordabl e and unique retail spaces (Figure 6 2 9 ). Historic houses are available at all levels of renovation and offer opportunities for artists looking for affordable housing near the downtown with pioneering potential (Figure 6 30 ). Southeast Gainesville is a n important resource for the arts community because of art city traits addressed in other categories that precede and follow this one, like "Arts Nodes" for example. These features include affordable historic buildings and neighborhoods, the future Depot P ark, the bus and future BRT depot, and the burgeoning South Main arts node. The relocation of the city's utility company opens up 16 acres of land in southeast Gainesville adjacent to the bus depot and the future Depot Park. The city has branded the land a nd the neighborhood surrounding it as the Power District (Figure 6 31 ). A peak inside reveals Gainesville's only factory building with potential to become lofts. The old smoke stacks and cylindrical tanks make for a visually rich environment. How could t his area evolve if it were taken over by artists as a live work space? It could grow to be a unique and exciting destination for locals as well as cultural tourists from all over. Figure 6 3 2 shows the Catalyst Building, the first building to be renov ated and occupied within the Power District. While this building serves as the first step towards redevelopment of the district, the project seems to have missed the mark. The building now looks new standing in contrast to the historic residential neighbor hood and weathered industrial district behind it. The city seems enthusiastic that the company, which creates drones for the military, will encourages other tech companies to settle in the area (Curry, Prioria Robotics moves into former GRU warehouse"). T he Innovation Square site (Figure 6 33) located midway between downtown and the university, has also been designated as a tech hub. The University of Florida's Innovation Hub, the only building on the

PAGE 145

138 otherwise cleared site, is a tech company incubator th at is similar in design and feel to the Catalyst Building. Does Gainesville need two downtown tech hubs? The Innovation Square site, with it's lack of existing buildings of interest and location near the university as well as downtown, seems like a better fit for a tech hub. The Power District, full of character and located adjacent to the South Main Arts node and other pioneering opportunities, has great potential to serve as the arts district that would attract tech companies to house their headquarters a t the Innovation Square site. If Austin is the model because of its booming tech industry that has completely transformed the downtown with shiny new skyscrapers, it's important to remember that Austin had many gritty neighborhoods surrounding the downtown available for pioneering. It is these neighborhoods that now attract the creative class and the tourists to the city. Figure 6 33. Basic design plans for Innovation Square, a technology centered redevelopment area located between the University and downtown. Image Source: innovationsquare.ufl.edu

PAGE 146

139 Connectivity Gainesville currently suffers from a disconnect between the University 's large enclosed campus and the downtown area where much of the art s and cultural activities are centered. Santa Fe College 's main campus is located beyond the city limits on the other end of town from downtown. The large park that is in the process of being developed is positioned to the south of downtown and south and e ast of most residents. The bus service is impressively comprehensive, and growing, but still serves mostly those who have no other option. Bike and pedestrian options are being expanded that aim to connect these resources. The closing of an old hospital h as created an opportunity to reshape the heart of Gainesville. An area several blocks wide in both directions has been wiped clean for development. It has been branded as Innovation Square (Figure 6 33) in hopes that it will be the anchor for tech nology ba sed development. What happens in this area has an opportunity to link the University of Florida campus and downtown as it sits halfway between the two locations and is convenient to both of them Santa Fe College has a downtown campus located along University Avenue and NW 6 th Street, just north of downtown The campus offers a selection of classes to those living on the eastside because the main c ampus is beyond the city limits to the northwest. This prime real estate is under utilized with outdated one story buildings and large open parking lots. Could Santa Fe move some of their arts facilities including a gallery, to this location? This would put them in the vicinity of the downtown arts nodes, where they could participate in the Artwalk. They would also be located halfway between the downtown arts and the campus arts, serving as a potential link.

PAGE 147

140 Figure 6 3 4 Festivals. Clockwise fro m top left: belly dancers at the Tioga Arts Festival in Town of Tioga, a TND planned community in a suburb north of town; waiting for the next band at a Farm to Family music festival in rural Alachua ; live painting at the Tioga Arts Festival ; local painter Peter Carolyn's display at the Downtown Arts Festival; University Avenue, closed off from traffic, for the Dow ntown Arts Festiva l. Figure 6 3 5 The Downtown Farmer's Market held every Wednesday afternoon at the Bo Diddley Community Plaza downtown.

PAGE 148

141 Figure 6 3 6 Artwalk Gainesville, held on the last Friday of each month, presents gallery openings and music ians on the street. Clockwise from left: Humble Pie food cart at the South Main Arts & Community Center; interior plaza of the South Main Arts & Community Center; a band plays outside the Artisan's Guild Gallery; patrons walking from Union Street Station a nd the Hippodrome galleries to the next venue; Gallery 21 in The Sun Center. Public Functions Gainesville hosts a number of yearly arts themed festivals. During the two largest of the festivals, the Spring Arts Festival and the Downtown Arts Festival in t he fall, the city closes off several blocks downtown to traffic. These blocks are adjacent to the Downtown Plaza and together they form a public gathering space large enough to accommodate the events. The charming cobblestone streets of downtown make for a great street festival setting. Other smaller festivals are held in areas further from the city center such as Tioga Arts Festival held in Town of Tioga, a TND planned community in a suburb north of town. Farm to Family is a three day music festival held o ut in the country several times a year (Figure 6 3 4 )

PAGE 149

142 One of Gainesville's great attractors is the Downtown Farmer's Market held every Wednesday afternoon (Figure 6 3 5 ). Each week the Downtown Plaza is transformed into a true festival atmosphere with c rowded booths selling produce as well as prepared foods and wares, people picnicking, hoola hoopers, and children running around on the lawn. Often there are people playing music on the stage. This event activates the whole downtown area as porches in the surrounding businesses fill up for farmer's market specials. Thanks to a grant and a team of university interns, the town's Artwalk has really started to come together in the last few years (McMurry). During the event, held on the last Friday of every mon th, galleries stay open late and bands play at cafes and along the paths that connect these venues (Figure 6 3 6 ). The galleries stretch from The Doris on North Main Street, to the South Main Arts node. They dip down into the Downtown Arts node near the H ippodrome. There are a few outliers like the University of Florida's 4most Gallery near SW 6 th Street. The nodes are too far in distance to walk in the time allotted and parking has to be found several different times if the route is tak en by car Nonetheless, this event really helps to highlight and make a connection between the existing art nodes and could help encourage greater connection and infill in the future.

PAGE 150

143 Figure 6 3 7 The Intersection of Art & Nature. "Gainesville Solar Wa lk" by artist Elizabeth Indianos. The ten 14 ft sculptures stretch along NW 8 th Avenue from 34 th Street to 22 nd Street and intersect with the Hogtown Creek Greenway, which cuts across NW 8 th Avenue to connect wooded paths on either side.

PAGE 151

144 Figure 6 3 8 M urals depicting the civil rights struggle by artist Alan T. Pearsall at the Rosa Parks downtown bus depot. The Art in Public Places Trust funded the project Figure 6 39 The 34 th Street Wall mural r uns along the east side of SW 34 th Street starting at 2 nd Avenue and ending 5 blocks south.

PAGE 152

145 Public Art Driving, biking, or walking along NW 8 th Avenue between 34 th Street and 22 nd Street, travellers get a sense of the scale of the universe thanks to a publ ic art project entitled "Gainesville Solar Walk" (Figure 6 3 7 ). The installation includes ten 14 ft sculptures that represent the sun and nine planets (Pluto is included because it was installed in 2002) and are placed at distances that correlate to thei r true positions in our solar system at a scale of 4 billion to 1. The piece intersects with the Hogtown Creek Greenway that cuts across NW 8 th Avenue to connect wooded paths on either side. Additions have been to made to the installation to include benche s, signage and two comets. The project was paid for through a collaboration between Gainesville's Art in Public Places Trust and the Alachua Astronomy club. This art is highly visible along a major avenue. The subject is very accessible to all ages, but th e concept and vehicle are creative and original. A new addition to the city's public art stock are the murals depicting the civil rights struggle by artist Alan T. Pearsall at the Rosa Parks downtown bus depot (Figure 6 3 8 ). The murals are painted on th e columns and are highly visible to those waiting at the depot as well as those walking or driving by. The project is a permanent installation funded by the Art in Public Places Trust. The 34 th street wall is a five block long ever evolving mural wall (Fi gure 6 39 ). Students and citizens are frequently spotted, day or night, adding a new painting. While every painting isn't always what most would consider "art", the wall brightens up an otherwise mundane 6 lane road and gives a sense of ownership to the public in relation to the public art presence in town.

PAGE 153

146 Synthesis Figure 6 40 E xisting arts facilities and greenspace between UF campus and downtown. Gainesville has strengths in a number of the city trait categories including nature, both loc al and regional, culture, university, and arts facilities and nodes. It has some weaknesses in realizing these resources though due to issues of c onnectivity and accessibility. However, t his shows potential that the foundation for an art city is there. T he resources just need to be identified and strategies for better access need to be explored Figure 6 40 s hows a section of Gainesvil le stretching from the eastside of UF campus past the downtown area. Open green space and water resources are identified along with important roads and the placement of Santa Fe College's downtown campus. Pastel colored dots represent known arts facilities broken down into visual arts, theater, and music venues. The venue dots show the arts nodes identified earlier in the center of downtown and along South Main Street

PAGE 154

147 They also highlight the arts resources available on the east side of campus and give an idea of the challenges of accessibility to these venues, as well as their connectivity with the downtown nodes As discussed earlier, the A rtwalk in Gainesville has gained a lot of momentum, but venues outside the central downtown cluster are difficult to make it to on foot. Having to get in and out of the car several times defeats the purpose of an art "walk" and still leaves campus venues out of reach for most people. Art walks are a tool utilized by many art cities to familiarize residents with the arts v enues in their town The event create s a festival like atmosphere where people feel comfortable walking in to arts venues just to check out what they have to offer

PAGE 155

148 Design Suggestion s Figure 6 41 Design suggestions for Gainesville city center. Figure 6 41 shows the resources mapped previously in the synthesis with future design suggestions incorporated. The suggestions aim to increase connectivity by linking and expanding open greenspace as well as bike and pedestrian route option s. It also addresses two redevelopment areas and how they might be utilized to this end. Features of the design include: Expan sion and linking of existing greens paces to create a central park that run s into the heart of the city. Expansions are shown in li ghter green and link the current and future depot park with a gre en square located within Innovation Square. Plans for the new development already include park space that would link it with the current Depot Park.

PAGE 156

149 Utilization of Tumblin Creek as an amenity by daylighting (exposing to the surface) it's spring source The creek is currently channeled underground from it's source in the center of Innovation Square to the south side of South 4 th Avenue. Daylighting of Sweetwater creek within the Power District redevelopment area The creek area north of the Power District is buffered by park. This design proposes expanding that linear park through the redevelopment area and exposing the segment of the creek that now lies underground. Increased connection between greenspace and bike and pedestrian routes. Creation of artist work live space within the west end of the Power District. This is the portion that contains factory loft type buildings that are attractive to working artists. Daylighting of water bodies and returning them to a natural system offers the benefits of greater cleansing to the water, exposure to citizens of how their water system works, and the creation of a natural amenity. The three most successful case study cities all had water as a defini ng element of the downtown. Though Gainesville is not located along a river, as those cities all are, creeks and ponds in the downtown area offer opportunities and flexibility in shaping the city's future blue infrastructure. The yellow paths that run eas t west and north south represent existing, planned, and sugg ested routes. The existing rail trai l that runs from south of the future Depot Park up north along 6 th Street is currently planned to be disconnected from greenspace until it reaches the existing Depot Park. Th is proposal for expanded park space, besides creating a large centralized gathering space, would make for an extended greenway experience. South 2 nd Avenue currently acc omo dates bike and pedestrian traffic while the linear park that it termin ates at is underutilized. This design suggests connecting to the path system in the existing

PAGE 157

150 linear park as well as continuing it into the expanded linear park that would run through the Power District The creation of an artist work live area within the industrial portion of the Power District would elevate the city 's status as an art city and help to a ttract the creative class tech industry that the city wishes to capitalize on. Artists would use their skills to transform the rundown industrial area into a unique arts destination. The area is adjacent to existi ng arts venues as well as the futur e park and would help to link the two areas as pedestrian destination s This space, like no other left available in the city center, offers the skeletal structure of what could become a dynamic and unique arts district that would put Gainesville on the map. Arts Bus Route In a second design suggestion, the Art walk w ould be used as the impetus to create greater connection between and accessibility to the arts ve nues identified on the synthesis map Currently the Artwalk includes venues that are too far apart to travel by foot, taking away from the essence of the event as a walking experience Also, although there are arts events that occur on the eastside of camp us during Artwalk, due to distance and parking issues these campus venues cannot logistically be included. What if the city created a bus route that connect ed the downtown and U niversity arts destinations ? Downtown to campus is already a popular rou te, and no new stops would need to be added to connect the venues that have been mapped

PAGE 158

151 Figure 6 42 Proposed Art Bus route connecting arts destinations from campus to downtown. Figure 6 42 shows the proposed art bus route in relation to the resources identified in the synthesis It passes directly, in most cases, or within a block or two of all destinations currently participating in Gainesville 's Artwalk. At the north end is the Doris Bardon Community Cultural Center in an area with potential to form into another arts node, especially if it were better connected. It travels south along M ain Street where it passes the city's largest clusters of arts venues until it reaches the site of the Cade Museum. Then it travels west and north, intersecting with the U niversity 's student run 4most Gallery at S. 4 th Avenue and 6 th Street It then heads west again along the south edge of Innovation Square the re development area that seeks to connect with both downtown and campus and to collaborate with the creative forces of each. The route hits campus at the site of several galleries and then takes riders into campus to reach the remaining east campus music and theater venues. It returns east along South 2 nd Avenue, passing the northern edge of Innovation S quare un til it reaches Bo Diddley

PAGE 159

152 Downtown P laza, home to many outdoor performances and events The route back north is along East 1 st Street, the tree and historic home lined street that hosts the Spring Arts Festival each year. The route would also connect to g reenspaces in the area, highlighting the connection between nature and the arts These spaces include the future Depot Park, the current Depot Park, Lynch Park, the Downtown Plaza, the Thomas Center Gardens, and green open spaces on campus such as the Plaz a of the Americas. Gainesville has a very comprehensive bus system, with plans to continue to expand, but the system lacks any of the charm observed in public transit options in case study cities like New Orleans and Savannah. Additionally, in a city with a lot of warm and rainy days, there is a shortage of bus shelters. Shelters are a resource that, when available, makes riding public transit much more comfortable. The arts focused destinations would only be one p iece of the art bus experience. Artist de signed and painted buses would be mobile art pieces in themselves and artist designed bus shelters would mark the route These buses would act as travelling advertisement for the arts community and would serve as an engaging public gathering space. The she lters would provide a needed public function and increase public interest in riding the bus. At the same time the bus shelters as a group would create a striking public art piece that would signal the presence of a strong arts community and the city's inve stment in the arts and public transit.

PAGE 160

153 Figure 6 43 A Mexico City art piece consisting of a Japanese bus that was "Yarnbombed by American artist Magda Sayeg Image Source: telegraph. co.uk The bus line could start as a shuttle (Figures 6 43 and 6 44 ) that runs on the last Friday of every month during Artwalk. Or it could run on Friday and Saturday evenings when the greatest number of events and performances occur. This would create the desired buzz while testing out the popularity of the route. Then, if the route were succe ssful, a n artist designed city bus (Figures 6 45 and 6 46 ) and fulltime bus line could take over

PAGE 161

154 Figure 6 44 A "matatu", the most common form of public transit in Kenya and neighboring countries complete with disco lights and stereo system. Image Sour ce: markiliffe.wordpress.com Ideas for the art bus : Music playing by local musicians Film/video art pieces and video tours of arts venues and events Pamphlets about local arts and cultural venues and events Rotating shows insi de with prints under plastic cover, the way adv ertising is currently displayed Offer the bus f ree of charge during Artwalk E xamples of art buses in other cities : Figure 6 45 shows a bus from the Sun Metro Bus fleet in El Paso, Texas. The bus was paint ed by community members and ran as part of the cities bus system for six months. ( main tain.com/sun metro art bus)

PAGE 162

155 Figure 6 4 5 A bus from the Sun Metro Bus fleet in El Paso, Texas. Image source: main tain.com/sun metro art bus Figure 6 4 6 shows a bus from the Metro Arts in Transit program, based in St. Louis, Missouri. The program paints approximately five buses a year using an artist's design and help from members of the community. The program also commissions public art in bus and light rail st ations, at bus shelters, and in bus interiors. (artsintransit.org)

PAGE 163

156 Figure 6 4 6 A bus from the Metro Arts in Transit progra m, based in St. Louis, Missouri. Image source: nextstopstl.org Examples of art bus shelters Figure 6 4 7 Sea themed bus shel ter in Seattle Image source: blog.arldesign.com ; Stained glass bus shelter in Seattle. Image source: cityofart.net; "School bus shelter in Athens, Ga. Image Source: chicagonow.com ; Watermelon bus shelter in Japan. Image source: chicagonow.com

PAGE 164

157 Figure 6 47 shows examples of artist designed bus shelters in Seattle, Athens ( Georgia) and Japan. Seattle 's relationship with water and the ocean is reflected in the artist's use of mermaids and waveforms. Gainesville 's bus stops could too create a sense of place if local artists were commissioned to design them Instructions could in clude that the pieces be site responsive or that they express how the artist sees or feels about his or her city. This design pro posal has the potential to bring the face of the arts out in to the public realm, signaling to current and potential residents that the city has a strong arts community. It would bring more people to the existing arts venues, giving greater support to the arts community, and would encourage businesses to fill in along the route. The city has just approved a study to look at the potential for a future trolley or streetcar route that would connect the downtown and campus (Curry 2013) The art bus could be utilized as a piece of the study looking at the arts comm unity 's use and impact on public transit in this area.

PAGE 165

1 58 Conclusion s City Traits: Which are a "must have" Following is a dvice for city planners designers and arts community builders based on the case study and test city findings. Each category is addressed based on its importance across all four case study cities, as well as the test city. Nature : at both the local and regional scale. Each of the successful case study cities was rich in unique and varied natural resources at both the local and regional scale. Artists in each city indicated that the natural resources of their city were an important factor in their choice to stay in the city. The y also indicated that the unique natural resources of their particular city contributed to th eir connection with th e city that they have come to identify with. Local Cultural Identity : local cultural identity was strong in all three successful art cities, strongest in the two most established. Community members identified with this culture and as with the nature distinctive to their city, found it important in their connection with the city. Artists reported that they found inspiration from the local cult ure. This would indicate that this trait is very helpful in building a strong arts community. Since a city can't create local culture, the way to strengthen this trait would be to identify and nurture whatever local culture there may already be. Universi ty : all the case study cities had multiple colleges and universities, but the schools' importance in the larger arts community varied. New Orleans and Winston Salem had the weakest connection with the campus arts due to school size in relation to the city, in the case of New Orleans, and physical disconnection in Winston Salem. Savannah had the strongest correlation because of the schools scale, focus on the arts, and open campus design. So it is less a question of is there a college than how is th is potential resource utilized

PAGE 166

159 Urban Environmental Cues : once again, Austin and New Orleans, the most successful of the arts cities, both scored high in this category. T hese cues are impor tant in attracting artists to a city as well as cultural tourists who can help support the arts. They send the message to the whole population that art and creativity are valued by the city and the communities who are the source of these cues. Winston Sale m s attempt to replace organic cues with branding and signage only draw s more attention to what's missing. Pedestrian Promenade : this trait was strong in the top three case study cities Promenades get people out on the street where they can experience mu sic and visit shops and galleries. This trait may not be essential, but it would be a good idea to foster this resource if there is an opportunity. Centralized Public Gathering Space : this trait was strong in all three top art cities and was very weak in Winston Salem. This seems to indicate that thi s trait is an important piece of the art city equation. These spaces are used as venues for all mediums of art and create an opportunity for community building and encounters with community members from differ ent cultures and scenes. Transit Options : Austin ranked low in terms of transit options, but all interviewees complained about the traffic issues. The city has a lot of other things going for it, so people are willing to tolerate this inconvenience. Tran sit options may not be essential, but they offer an opportunity to implement something, like the art buses, that will make a city standout. Arts Nodes : these nodes were present though not dominant, in both Austin and New Orleans. They were less present in the other two case study cities. Arts nodes tend to develop organically, and since they do not seem to be essential, it may be better to let them develop on their own rather then to put a lot of energy into creating them.

PAGE 167

160 City and Community Arts Infra structure : arts infrastructure was strong in all of the case study cities. Each had an arts council, by some name, which housed a supportive staff. Some offered venues for performance, show space, and studio space and some offered classes to the community. These spaces create a physical representation of the city and community's commitment to the arts Affordable Real Estate with Character : When an art city is getting established, affordable real estat e with character is an essential resource to att ract artists into settling in your city and to allow for the urban pioneering that will shape the organic growth of the art city. Artists in each of the case study cities, as well as in Gainesville, reported this as being an important factor in where they chose to live. Each of the three successful art cities that had this, and the two most well established cities, Austin and New Orleans, had been built upon this. Connectivity : connectivity was high in both New Orleans and Savannah. Austin ranked lower due to its scale verses transit options. Winston Salem ranked very low on this trait. This trait may not be essential, but increased connectivity elevates the strength of t he other art city traits. Public Functions : this trait was observed in all four case study cities. These functions can be organized by the city, the university, or arts community gr oups. Themes can range from art to food, to culture, to the novel but mos t include music, food, and celebration. A city can encourage public functions by providing the right venue, making it affordable, and creating regulations that will support successful public functions in relation to issues such as open container. Publi c Art : an abundance of art in public places is a definite sign of a city that cultivates the arts. Both Austin and New Orleans have program s dedicated to public art. The quantity of these commissioned pieces, along with the flexibility that the cit ies allow citizens in creating their own public art, makes for an overall culture of art for and by the people.

PAGE 168

161 Planning & Design Factors Exploration : One of the most important qualities of art is the way it communic ates and idea or emotion without just simply stating it. The artist spends time with a theme and then creates an original expression of that theme. People who are interested in art are interested in experiencing place in the same way. They want to explore. In vibrant art cities art, music and theatre ar e happening in alternative and secret spaces that are off the beaten path. In Savannah, for instance, it has lon g been popular to house theatre companies in old Victorian homes downtown. The patron has to see k this type of venue out. An interviewee from Austin reported that what she loved about the arts scene in that city is that t here isn't just one strip downtown where you go to get your arts fix, and then its over. There's lots going on in different places and the variety and the spontaneity is part of what makes it interesting (Griffin) You have no chance of that when you go in to a an area that's labeled Arts District where you then see a sign pointing you to the Arts Avenue This practice leaves little opportunity to just explore and discover and it makes for the same experience in every city. Social Media : social networking, i nternet mapping, and podcasting all now play an important role in strengthening arts communities by linking art and place These tools make the exploration described above possible and viable to the larger community The Landmarks program at the University of T exas in Austin use s all three of these tools to maximize the exposure and access to the public art resources they 've obtained. The programs website, which provides a mobile version as well, displays online maps showing the location of all art pieces on campus. A podcast on the site, that can either be downloaded ahead of time of accessed by phone, takes viewers on a walking tour through the campus landscape where information enhances exploration of the pieces Social media like Facebook is used to promote events, such as live art performances, and share images and videos of these events for those that can't make it.

PAGE 169

162 Evolution : art cities can't be built overnight They must grow from what already exists by taking the right steps to create opportunities for future evolution by the community to occur. Some suggestions on how to encourage evolution: Take stock of th ings Pass regulations that support the arts. Don't pass those that can harm growth of the arts community like single use zoning or unreasonable alcohol use restrictions (as in Savannah) Find ways to link things through green sp ace interesting walkable streets or novelty transit Organize art walks & festivals Questions for Future Exploration The discoveries made during this project raised many questions and opened up areas for future exploration. Questions of history and evolution include, How did these cities come to be art cities? Some, like New Orleans and Savannah had long histories as arts destinations, but Austin's appearance as an art city was rather sudden. How long did the arts community take to de velop? There are also questions about city form and development and whether that had an impact on the city 's potential as an art city. W hat was the city's pattern of development? When it came to becoming an art city, d id every city do it the same way? Other questions look to the future. If someone were to monitor Winston S alem will they be successful in creating an arts city ? The city is attempting to do so from a top down approach, rather than the more organic, bottom up evolution that seems to have created the other case study art cities. In the future, w ill the successful art cities studied be able to sustain their arts identity? The issue of sustainability is an important one. Th is research grew in part as a way to look for alternatives to the long established art cities like New York that may have been pioneered past its capacity so that no affordable artist space

PAGE 170

163 remained. Is an art city sustainable in the long term? Or is it tr ue that once a city is on the map, artists will flock to it, grabbing up all the affordable real estate and beginning the gentrification process that will eventually displace them? Perhaps creating more localized art cities is the solution to this process though and their absence has been the cause of this dilemma all along.

PAGE 171

164 List of Tables & Figures Item Figure 2 0. The downs tream effects of the arts Figure 2 1. "Economic Contributions of Singapore's Creative Industries." Figure 4 0. Map of the USA highlighting the region of The South Figure 4 1. Regional map for Austin Figure 4 2. Google Maps image of downtown Austin Figure 4 3 UT Austin's Public Art Master Plan Figure 4 4 The Trailer Park Eateries Figure 4 5 A Google map image of central Austin F igure 4 6 Toy Joy, novelty toyshop and cafŽ F igure 4 7 Sixth St. Cool Store Figure 4 8 Zilker Park Map Figure 4 9 Barton Springs Figure 4 10 Porch culture Figure 4 11 Regional map of New Orleans Figure 4 12 Map of central New Orleans Figure 4 13 St reetcar map of New Orleans Figure 4 14 St. Charles line streetcar Figure 4 15 Regional map of Savannah Figure 4 1 6 A Saturday in Forsyth Park Figure 4 1 7 Map of SCAD's campus Figure 4 1 8 Broughton Street Figure 4 1 9 Map of central Savannah Figure 4 2 0 An artist interviewee's house and studio Figure 4 21 A boarded up house in the Eastside neighborhood Figure 4 22 Desoto Ave Figure 4 23 The McQueen's Island Historic Trail

PAGE 172

165 Figure 4 24 Map of greater Winston Salem Figure 4 2 5 Map of downtown and nor th central Winston Salem Figure 4 26 A "gallery" along the Avenue of the Arts F igure 4 27 Winston Square Park Figure 4 28 "Avenue of the Arts" Figure 4 29 "To Build a Community," Brad Spencer Figure 5 0. "Savannah Marsh" by Carolyn Molder Figures 5 1. Art City Traits Figure 5 2. Nature within the city Figure 5 3. City as Nature Figure 5 4. Regional Nature Figure 5 5. Local Cultural Identity Figure 5 6. Urban Environmental Cues: Signage Figure 5 7. Urban Environmental Cues: Murals Figure 5 8. Sout h Congr ess Pedestrian Promenade Figure 5 9. Pedestrians and bikes Figure 5 10. Rickshaws Figure 5 11. Rayo de Esperanza A Beacon of Hope Figure 5 12. "City as Nature" Figure 5 13. Urban Environmental Cues Figure 5 1 4 View from the streetcar Figure 5 15. Frere t Street Center Figure 5 1 6 Savannah squares and the walkable streets Figure 5 1 7 A SCAD building Figure 5 1 8 Forsyth Park Figure 5 1 9 Affordable historic real estate Figure 5 20. Reynolda Gardens Figure 5 21 "Avenue of the Arts." Figure 5 22 Arts Fa cilities Figure 5 23 Public Art Figure 5 24 City Trait Summary

PAGE 173

166 Figure 5 25 City Trait Ranking Chart Figure 6 0. Map of the USA highlighting the region of The South Figure 6 1. Regional map of Gainesville Figu re 6 2. Paynes Prairie Preserve Figure 6 3. L ocal Nature Figure 6 4. City as Nature Figure 6 5. City as Nature Figure 6 6. Regional Nature Figure 6 7. Local Culture Figure 6 8. Porters & Hippies Figure 6 9. Springhill Neighborhood Figure 6 10. College & University Arts Facilities Figure 6 11. Public Art on UF campus Figure 6 12. Urban Environmental Cues Figure 6 13. Urban Environmental Cues Figure 6 14: Urban Environmental Cues Figure 6 15. Urban Environmental Cues Figure 6 16. Urban Environmental Cues Figure 6 17. University Avenue Figure 6 18. Exist ing downtown public space Figure 6 19. Open Space Study Figure 6 20. Future Public Space Figure 6 21. Transit Options Figure 6 22. Innovation Square Figure 6 23. Downtown Arts Node Figure 6 24. The Downtown Arts Node Figure 6 25. The South Main Arts node F igure 6 26. The Doris Bardon Community Cultural Center Figure 6 27. The Actors' Warehouse Figure 6 28. Across Main Street Figure 6 29. Affordable historic business real estate

PAGE 174

167 Figure 6 30. Housing stock Figure 6 31. The Power District Figure 6 32. The Cata lyst Building Figure 6 33. Designs for Innovation Square Figure 6 34. Festivals Figure 6 35. The Downtown Farmer's Market Figure 6 36. Artwalk Gainesville Figure 6 37. The Intersection of Art & Nature Figure 6 38. Murals Figure 6 39. 34 th Street Wall Figur e 6 40. Existing arts facilities and greenspace Figure 6 41. Design suggestions for city center Figure 6 42. Proposed Art Bus route Figure 6 43 "Yarnbombed" bus in Mexico City Figure 6 44 A "matatu" shuttle bus in Kenya Figure 6 45 A bus from the Sun Me tro Bus fleet Figure 6 46 A bus from the Metro Arts in Transit F igure 6 47 Art bus shelters

PAGE 175

168 References Books 1. Currid, Elizabeth (2007). The Warhol Economy Princeton: Princeton University Press. 2. Florida, Richard (2002). The Rise of the Creative Class: and how it's transformi ng work, leisure, community and everyday life. New York: Basic Books. 3. Florida, Richard (2005). The Flight of the Creative Class: the New Global Competition for Talent New York: Harper Business 4. Florida, Richard (2008). Who's your city? : How the creativ e economy is making where to live the most important decision of your life. New York: Basic Books. 5. Lynch, Kevin (1960). The Image of the City Cambridge: The Technology Press & Harvard University Press. 6. Nordahl, Darrin (2008). My Kind of Transit. Chicago : University of Chicago Press Articles, Journals, and Internet Resources 1. "Art in Public Places" austintexas.gov City of Austin, n.d. Web. 26 March 2013. 2. "Art Expressions by Carolyn" Blogspot.com Blogger, 30 March 2012. Web. 10 April 2013. 3. Barber, Keith. "Plugging in to the Arts." Yes Weekly.com 11 August 2010. Web. 22 August 2010. 4. Creative Class: The Source on How We Live, Work, and Play 2010. Web. 28 February 2010. 5. Curry, Christopher. "City Moves Ahead with $100K Streetcar Study" Gainesville.co m 18 April 2013. Web. 4 June 2013. 6. Eakin, Emily. The Cities And Their New Elite" New York Times.com 1

PAGE 176

169 June 2002. Web. 4 April 2010 7. El Nasser, Haya. "Mid sized cities get hip to attract young professionals." USAToday.com 10 October 2003. Web. 3 August 2 010. 8. Florida, Richard and Currid, Elizabeth. "Bohemian Rhapsody" New York Times.com 31 July 2005. Web. 4 April 2010 9. Markusen, Ann "Cultural Planning and the Creative City." American Collegiate Schools of Planning meetings, Ft. Worth, Texas 2006. Ed. Conference Editor(s). 10. Markusen, Ann, and David King. The artistic dividend: The arts' hidden contributions to regional development Project on Regional and Industrial Economics, Humphrey Institute of Public Affairs, University of Minnesota 2003. 11. Markusen, Ann, and Amanda Johnson. "Artists' centers: Evolution and impact on careers, neighborhoods and economies." (2006). 12. Morekis, Jim. "Interview: Richard Florida." connectsavannah.com 6 Dec 2006. Web. 13 March 2013. 13. Muschamp, Herbert. The Way We Live Now: 5 18 03; Who Gets It?" New York Times.com 18 May 2003. Web. 10 April 2010 14. Richards, James (2007) Placemaking for the Creative Class Landscape Architecture February, 2007: 32 38 15. Richards, James (2005) Places to flourish: Placemaking that nu rtures ideas, creativity and commerce M.L.A. dissertation, The University of Texas at Arlington, Texas. Retrieved August 17, 2010 16. Richards, James (2009) Places to Flourish: Principles of Placemaking for a New Economy Townscape, Inc. Town Planning and Ur ban Design. Retrieved January 17, 2010] 17. Roney, Maya. "Bohemian Today, High Rent Tomorrow" Business Week.com 26 February 2007. Web. 28 February 2010 18. Silver, Nichols and Clark, Rothfield. "A Theory of Scenes." The University of Chicago: Working Group on S cenes 30 April 2007. Web. 5 February 2011.

PAGE 177

170 19. Steinhsuer, Jennifer. "New York, Once a Lure, Is Slowly Losing the Creative Set." New York Times.com 18 December 2005. Web. 10 April 2010 20. Thayer, Robert L., Jr. (2008) The World Shrinks, the World Expands: Info rmation, Energy, and Relocalization Landscape Journal 27: 1 08 21. van Ryzin, Jeanne Claire. Austin arts groups feel strains of growth ." statesman.com. Cox Media Group, 23 July 2011. Web. 25 March 2013. Interviews 1. Baker, Eileen Personal Interview. 22 Octo ber. 2010. Director of the City of Savannah Department of Cultural Affairs. 2. Bright, Paul. Personal Interview. 12 November. 2010. Visual Artist and Assistant Director of Hanes Gallery at Wake Forest University in Winston Salem. 3. Brott, Andy. Personal Intervi ew. 11 December. 2010. Glass artist based in New Orleans 4. Browning, Michael. Personal Interview. 1 February. 2011. Landscape Architect who works in Savannah (lives in Atlanta?) 5. Corrao, Nick. Personal Interview. 11 November 2010. Formerly a graduate student in Documentary Film at University of Florida, currently a graduate student in Documentary Film at Wake Forest University in Winston Salem. 6. Dalton, Mary. Personal Interview. 13 November. 2010. Personal Interview. Professor of Documentary Film at Wake Fores t University in Winston Salem. 7. Davis, Bill. Personal Interview. 13 November. 2010. Landscape Architect at Stimmel and Associates in Winston Salem. 8. DeCristo, Jim. Personal Interview. 4 March. 2011. Director of External Affairs at the University of North Car olina School of the Arts in Winston Salem 9. Dedeaux, Dawn. Personal Interview. 10 December. 2010. Multi media artist born, raised, and based in New Orleans. 10. Garcia, Carl John. Personal Interview. 11 February. 2011. Tattoo artist living in Austin since early high school. 11. Gossett, Myrriah. Personal Interview. 31 January. 2011. Undergraduate student in Art History at Savannah College of Art and Design and Executive Director at Desotorow Gallery in Savannah.

PAGE 178

171 12. Grengs, Kellie. Personal Interview. 11 December. 2010. Professor of Theatre at Loyola University in New Orleans. Founder of The New Freret organization. 13. Griffin, Leah. Personal Interview. 10 February. 2011. External Affairs Coordinator for the Landmarks Program at the University of Texas, Austin. 14. Hanes, Phill ip. Personal Interview. 12 November 2010. Eldest surviving member of the Hanes (Underwear) Family. Has spent his life building arts councils throughout the US and elevating the arts presence in his hometown of Winston Salem. 15. Hopkinson, Johanna. Personal In terview. 23 October. 2010. A visual artist and graduate of Savannah College of Art and Design living in Savannah. 16. Lyons, Anthony. Personal Interview. 13 January. 2011. Director of the Community Redevelopment Agency of Gainesville, Florida. 17. McMurry, Ken. Pe rsonal Interview. 13 of February. 2012. Director of Artwalk in Gainesville, Florida. 18. Meneray, Gene. Personal Interview. 10 December. 2010. Arts Business Program Director at the Arts Council of New Orleans. 19. Nowlin, Lesley. Personal Interview. 12 February. 2 011. Owner and Director of Nowlin Gallery in Austin. 20. Oster, Isaac. Personal Interview. 13 February. 2011. Visual Artist, Musician, and Video Game Designer in Austin. 21. Richards, James. Personal Interview. 11 Sept. 2010. Landscape Architect and author of the 2005 MLA thesis Places to flourish: Placemaking that nurtures ideas, creativity and commerce. 22. Sakakeeny, Matt. Personal Interview. 9 December. 2010. Professor of Ethnomusicology at Tulane University in New Orleans. 23. Santander Morgan Personal Interview. 30 January. 2011. Visual artist and Professor at S avannah C ollege of A rt and D esign in Savannah. 24. Shelnutt, Greg. Personal Interview. 4 March. 2011. Director of Visual Arts and Professor of Sculpture at the University of North Carolina School of the Arts in W inston Salem 25. Singeisen, Scott Personal Interview. 31 January. 2011. Chair of Urban Design at SCAD. 26. Titu s Harry Personal Interview. 12 November 2010. Art History and Landscape Architecture Professor at Wake Forest University in Winston Salem

PAGE 179

172 27. Veltheim, Zachary Personal Interview. 11 of February. 2012. Longtime resident graduate student in Landscape Architecture at the University of Florida and former owner of a non profit indie film rental shop in Gainesville, Florida. 28. Zumstein, Debra Personal Interv iew. 22 October. 2010. Arts Program Coordinator at the City of Savannah Department of Cultural Affairs.

PAGE 180

173 Appendix Interview Question Samples Below are examples of templates used to create interview questions for this project. Fo r each interviewee, questions were tweaked to their exact position and some more specific questions were added in regards to each city. In each interview though, these basic questions began a conversation that spanned from 45 minutes to over two hours. Pl anners How long have you lived here? o If more than 5 years, do you consider it home? Why, or Why not? How long have you been in this position? o In any planning position in this city? How would you describe this city? o What is the image? o Are there plans to cha nge the image? If so, what tools does the city plan to use? Does this city wish to brand itself as an art city? o If so, what policies and programs has the city initiated to work towards this? o If not, what place does do the arts hold in the city's agenda? Is the arts scene here long established? In your time here, has the arts scene grown, maintained, or changed in any other way? Does the city have what you would consider to be an Arts District? What is/are the colleges' relationship like with the community a rts scene? o Are there specific areas/venues where the students and the community come together in support of the arts?

PAGE 181

174 Does tourism play a big role in the cities economy? o If so, are the arts an important part of the tourism industry here? College Faculty: Urban Design How long have you lived here? o If more than 5 years, do you consider it home? Why, or Why not? How long have you taught here? How would you describe your city? o What is the image? o Are there plans to change the image? If so, what tools does the c ity plan to use? Does the city have what you would consider to be an Arts District? How are the College's a rts facilities (galleries, performance spaces) situated in terms of accessibility and attraction to the greater community? Since you've been here, in what ways has the city developed in relation to the arts community? College Faculty: Arts How long have you lived here? o If more than 5 years, do you consider it home? Why, or Why not? How long have you taught here? How would you describe your city? o What is the image? o Do you know of any plans to change the image? Is the arts scene here long established? In your time here, has the arts scene grown, maintained, or changed in any other way? Does the city have what you would consider to be an Arts District? Wh at is the "School of the arts" relationship like with the community arts scene?

PAGE 182

175 o Does the school have arts facilities or events (galleries, performance spaces, readings) off campus and within the city? If so, what part of town are they located in? What kind s of spaces are used (for instance, are readings held at a local coffee shop, are studios housed in an old industrial building, are performances done in a park or at a street festival)? When you visit an arts event or venue, is it typically an isolated eve nt or are there multiple stops in the same area (such as dinner and a film, or gallery openings and then a band, or farmer's market and children's theatre in the park) Arts Community Members How long have you lived here? o If more than 5 years, do you cons ider it home? Why, or Why not? Were you involved in the arts before you came here? How would you describe your city? o What is the image? o Do you know of any plans to change the image? What brought/attracted you to this city? What elements (resources) of the city keep you here? Is the arts scene here long established? In your time here, has the arts scene grown, maintained, or changed in any other way? Does the city have what you would consider to be an Arts District? Since you've been here, in what ways has t he city developed in relation to the arts community? When you visit an arts event or venue, is it typically an isolated event or are there multiple stops in the same area (such as dinner and a film, or

PAGE 183

176 gallery openings and then a band, or farmer's market a nd children's theatre in the park) Landscape Architects How long have you lived here? o If more than 5 years, do you consider it home? Why, or Why not? How would you describe your city? o What is the image? o Are there plans to change the image? Is the arts sc ene here long established? In your time here, has the arts scene grown, maintained, or changed in any other way? Does the city have what you would consider to be an Arts District? Since you've been here, in what ways has the city developed in relation to t he arts community? In your experience has the city worked to brand itself as an art city? o If so, what policies, programs, or developments has the city initiated to work towards this? If not, what place do the arts hold in the city's agenda? For more details on the interviews conducted for this project, as well as other questions regarding this body of work, the author can be contacted via email at: amandes@gmail.com