Up-cycle-ing toward a critical pedagogy of visual culture

MISSING IMAGE

Material Information

Title:
Up-cycle-ing toward a critical pedagogy of visual culture
Physical Description:
Project in lieu of thesis
Creator:
Stover, Jeff
Publisher:
College of Fine Arts, University of Florida
Place of Publication:
Gainesville, Fla.
Publication Date:

Notes

Abstract:
Through this research project I combined critical pedagogy and visual culture as a methodology to broaden student awareness of the ways in which familiar popular media art forms can be a medium for personal expression, as well as a way to critically analyze society. This enabled students to begin to critically analyze the structures that define art. This project was conducted with a specific group of fifth graders who have been diagnosed with emotional and behavior disorders and who are at‐risk of not graduating high school. For one‐month I worked with and documented a group of eighteen 5th grade students who developed and painted custom bicycle designs that reflect their interests and values. I video interviewed participating student asking their opinions on popular culture, visual culture, and fine art. In addition I used my daily journal entries and a final exhibition to document and analyze the impact of critical pedagogy and visual culture as a strategy to build student awareness that their interests, meanings, and opinions have socially relevant value.
General Note:
Art Education terminal project

Record Information

Source Institution:
University of Florida Institutional Repository
Holding Location:
University of Florida
Rights Management:
All rights reserved by the source institution and holding location.
System ID:
AA00009604:00001


This item is only available as the following downloads:


Full Text

PAGE 1

! !" # $%&'( # )*+,-./012,0,$1)3)&0',4(20+.+%,.5,6)780',$8'381( !"##$%&'(") $ $ *'++,&&"" $ *-.,)/$0,1-"22"$3,22.45") $ 0"+6")/$*).,7$8'2.45/$9::,:&.4&$;)'#"::') $ <=&:,5"$0"+6")/$;.=2.$0>$945"):'4 $ $ $ ?4,("):,&@$'#$A2'),5. $ B"1"+6") $CDEE $ $ 9$;8
PAGE 2

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

PAGE 3

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
PAGE 4

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b"N-+;6/KG"#QQTXI D"1'96','"*45*"5-*"45B"*4'"(9'F61696*%"5;<"C+E'-"(+-"C'-B+;59"'FC-'BB6+;"5;<"*+" 'FC-'BB"*4'";''
PAGE 5

_ [6A49%"5;F6+@B"/469<-';"c 5"1'45,6+-"+("/469<-';"E6*4"? Z $. d eB''"*5BKB"5B" *4-'5*';6;A"E4'*4'-"C-'B';*'<"5B"*'B*B"+-"C95%"WCI"#!#XI"D;"5"B*@<%"+(" 60C+,'-6B4'<"/469<-';e*4'%"45<"96**9'"'FC'-6';/' "E6*4"<+6;A"5;%*46;A"E6*4" *4'6-"45;$%&=5"4& $R,&-$-,:$6,1@12"$P)'O"1&> $

PAGE 6

M "] @C/%/9'B ^ "5; ) 6*'0"*45*"6B"/+;B6<'-'<"-'(@B'"6;"+@-"B+/6'*%I"85;%"+("*4'B'"B*@<';*B" <+";+*"45,'"5"16/%/9'G"5;<"E'-'"'F/6*'<"51+@*"+E;6;A"5"];'E^"16/%/9'I":4'" B* @<';*B" 5CC-+C-65*'<"5;<"*-5;B(+-0'< *4'0" 6;*+" C'-B+;59" E+-K B "+("5-* G"E46/4"*4'%"/+@9<" *5K'"4+0'"5;<"-6<'"6;"*4'6-"/+00@;6*%I" :4'"B*@<';*B"45<"*4'"+CC+-*@;6*%"*+"9'5-;" 4+E"*+ "@B'"05*'-659B" B@/4"5B"B5;(*'-"5"('E"E''KB"6;*+"*4'" C-+='/*G"*4'"/95BB"45<"5**56;'<"5"/590"/+;(6<';/'"*45*"C-+,6<'<" 5"C'5/'(@9"B+/659" ';,6-+;0';*"E4'-'"E'" /+@9<"E+-K"5;<"6;*'-5/*" *+A'*4'-I" :4'"16/%/9'B" E'-' <6BC95%'<"5B"C5-*"+("*4'" B/4+ +9"5-*"B4+E" W)''"(6AI"2X" <@-6;A"*4'"%'5J ';<" A-5<@5*6+;"/'-'0+;%G" E4'-'"05;%"C5-';*BG" A@5 -<65;B"5;<"(5/@9*%"E'-'" C-'B';*" ) ) E303(F(*3,.5,3G(,41.H'(F ) D"45,'"-'B'5-/4'<"5;<"E+-K'<"*4'"95B*"*4-''"B'0'B*'-B"E6*4"5"<'<6/5*'<"5;<" 'FC'-6';/'<"5-*"*'5/4'-"5*"5" 9+/59"N J #2"B/4++9"(+-"B*@<';*B"<65A;+B'<"E6*4"?Z$. I" ?Z$."6B"6;"C5-*"5 "-'B@9*"+(" 5; "';,6-+;0';*" +("6B+95*6+;G";'A9'/*"5;<"51@B'"*45*"*4'" B*@<';*B "45,'"1'';"'FC+B'<"*+"'5-9%"6;"96('b"*4@B"5";5--+EG"<'(6;6*6,'"5;59%B6B"6B" <6((6/@9*"1'/5@B'"+("*4'"05;%",5-6519 'B"E6*46;"5;"6;<6,6<@59SB"B+/6+ J '/+;+06/"B*5*@BI" D;"4'-"1++KG" .%#)!&*)/'0!1'"'#2 G "U'F9'"W 2!!Q X <-5EB"@C+;"5"/+;B';B@B"+("+C6;6+;"6;" <'B/-616;A"?Z$.G :4'-'"5-'G"4+E','-G"B','-59"1'45,6+-B"*45*"'<@/5*+-B"5A-''"/45-5/*'-6H'"*46B" 951'9I">"('E"5-'7"@;0+*6,5*'< G"E6*4<-5E;"+-"+,'-E-+@A4*G"<6B-@C*6,'G" A,7=)">$C$%&=5"4&S:$6,1@12":$.&$&-"$.)&$:-'R> $

PAGE 7

R <6B-'BC'/*(@9G"5AA-'BB6,'G"5;<",6+9';*I"f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f+-*4'-;"/';*-59" L9+-6<5I":4'%"45,'"1'';"-'9+/5*'<"(-+0" *4'6-"9+/59"B/4++9B"1'/5@B'"+("1'45,6+-" C-+19'0BG"5;<"*4-+@A4"5"9';A*4%"C-+/'BB" 45,'"1'';"<65A;+B'<"E6*4"?Z$." W?0+*6+;59"$'45,6+-".6B+-<'-BXG"5;<";+E" 5**';<" 5"/';*-59"(5/696*%"*45*"BC'/6(6/599%" 5**';I"g@6;;"&+;'B" W>g&X")/4++9I"85;%G"6(";+*"599"+("*4'B'" B*@<';*B"/+0'"(-+0"@;B*519'"4+0'" B'**6;AB"E4'-'"6B+95*6+;G"51@B'"5;<";'A9'/*"5-'"/+;*-61@*6;A"(5/*+-B"*+"*4'"B*@<';*SB" 1'45,6+-59"C-+19' 0BI"D"45,'"BC';*"*4'"95B*"*E+"B'0'B*'-B"E+-K6;A"E6*4"*46B"A-+@CG" 5;<"45,'"(+@;<"C5-599'9B"E6*4"0%" +E;" /469<4++$ %&=5"4&:$R ')U,47$'=&:,5" > $

PAGE 8

T 6B"5"B*-+;A"/+;B';B@B"50+;A"*4'B'"*4'+-6B*B"*45*"59*'-;5*6,'B"*+"B*5;<5-<"'<@/5*6+;" 0@B*"1'" *-6'< G"<@'"*+"*4'"46A4"<-+C"+@*"5;<"(569@-'"-5*'B"+(">0'-6/5;"B*@<';*B"E6*46;" *4'"/@ --';*"'<@/5*6+;59"B%B*'0B "WU 'F9'-G"2!!Qb"N-+;6/KG"#QQTX I .@'"*+"*4'"B+/6+ J '/+;+06/"B*5*@B"*45*"C95/'B"*4'0"6;"*4'"]5* J -6BK^"/5*'A+-%G" ?Z$."B*@<';*B"E699"96K'9%";+*"A-5<@5*'G"5"B+/659"C-+19'0"+("/+;B6<'-519'"60C+-*5;/'" /+;B6<'-6;A"*45*"R!h"+("C-6B+;"6;05*'B"5-'"46A4"B/4++9"<-+C+@*B"W) /45-A'9G"2!!TXI "" .-I"U'6BBG"*4'"C-6;/6C59"+(">g&G"6;(+-0'<"0'"*45*" TMh"+("*4'"B*@<';*B"5*">g&"5-'" >(-6/5; J >0'-6/5;G"%'* "D"(+@;<"*45* RQ h"+("*4'"/+@;*%"C+C@95*6+;"6;"E46/4"*4'%"96,'" 6B"E46*' "W)'CG"2!##7"iI)I"3';B@B"$@-'5@XI D"+1B'-,'< "*45*"05;%"+("*4'B'"B*@ <';*B" E'-'"5;A-%"51+@*"*4'6-"96('"B6*@5*6+; B G"E46/4"6B"@;<'-B*5;<519'"<@'"*+"*4'6-" <6((6/@9*6'B"5;<"C++"V@596*%"+("96('I "j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g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

PAGE 9

k D"+1B'-,'<"*45*"0+-'"*45;"5"/+@C9'"+("*4'"B*@<';*B"D"E+-K'<"E6*4"45<" 0@9*6C9'"B%0C*+0B"+(">.[.I" [';9'% +(('-B 46B /95BB6/"<'B/-6C*6+;"+("5"/469<"E6*4" >.[.G" i;V@'B*6+;519%"16A4*"5;<"A6(*'.[."45,'"96**9'"C5*6';/'"E6*4"*4'"A6,'"5;<"*5K'"+("B+ /659"6;*'-5/*6+;I" f5--+EG"/+0C@9B6,'"6;*'-'B*B"*%C6/599%"51B+-1"*4'B'"/469<-'; I "3469<-';"E6*4">.[." ;''<"5"/+0C'996;A"-'5B+;"*+"B'9( J -'A@95*'I"$'45,6+-"0+<6(6/5*6+;" B@/4"5B" -'E5-)?8)0-@)6-A)A'"")#6$)4%-4-0$*)4%-5$,#)1$)$88$,#'($)'&) 1%'&7'&7)!1-+#),%'#',!")!&!"20'0)-8)#6$)0-,'$#2)!&*),-BB+&'#2) A6$%$) #6$0$)9.# : ;'0<=) '*$&#'8'$*)0#+*$�)"'($>)C!&)?)$&!1"$)0#+*$�)#-),-&0'*$%)#6$'%)-A&)!%#) !0)!&) $B4-A$%$*)(-',$)'&)#6$'%)-A&),-BB+&'#'$0>) ) U6*4"*46B"C-+='/*"D"E5;*'<"*+"4'9C"5"A-+@C"+("B*@<';*B"951'9'<"?Z$."(6;<"5" ,+6/'"*+"'FC-'BB"*4'6-"+E;",59@'B"5;<"6;*'-'B*B "W)''"(6AI"_X G"5;<"*4';"1'A6;"*+" /+;*'0C95*'"*4'6-"-'95*6+;"*+"*4'",59@'B"+("*4'"95A'-"B+/6'*%I"D"E5;*'<"*+"5CC9%"

PAGE 10

Q :5,6;SB"W2!!\X"0'*4+B"0%" -'B'5-/4"/+;*6;@'(*'-"'F*';B6,'"-'B'5-/4" E+-K6;A"E6*4"5"961-5-65;G"D"(+@;<";+"B*@<6'B"+;"*4'"6;*'A-5*6+;"+-"'(('/*6,';'BB"+(" A,7=)"$V>$ %&=5"4&:$:.45,47$.45$P.,4&,47$&-",)$6,U":> $

PAGE 11

#! ,6B@59"/@9*@-'"/@--6/@9@0"E6*4"?$."B*@<';*BI":4'-'"E5B",'-%"96**9'"6;(+-05*6+;"+;" E+-K6;A"E6*4"? Z $."B *@<';*B"6;"5-*"'<@/5*6+;"5B"5"E4+9'G"1@*"*4'"'F6B*6;A"-'B'5-/4" E5B"A';'-599%"C+B6*6,' I ;F.3).*0'MN(G0L).10',C)7.12(1 D;"4'-"1++KG" .%#)!&*)/'0!1'"'#2 G "U'F9'-"<6B/@BB'B"*4'"<6((6/@9*6'B"6;"<'B/-616;A" ?Z$.I":4'"<6B+-<'-"6B"5"-'B@9*"+("*4'"';,6-+;0';*"*45*"* 4'"B*@<';*BS"45,'"1'';" 'FC+B'<"*+"'5-9%"6;"96('b"*4@B"5";5--+EG"<'(6;6*6,'"5;59%B6B"6B"<6((6/@9*"1'/5@B'"+("*4'" 05;%",5-6519'B"E6*46;"5;"6;<6,6<@59SB"B+/6+ J '/+;+06/"B*5*@BI"U'F9'-" W2!!QX" B*5*'BG"" :4'-'"5-'G"4+E','-G"B','-59"1'45,6+-B"*45*"'<@/5*+-B"5A-''" /45-5/*'-6H'"*46B" 951'9I">"('E"5-'7"@;0+*6,5*'
PAGE 12

## A3 # 1)7O,7382(*37 )/45-A'9G":45/K'-G"5;<"$'99" W2!!TX" 45,'"/+0C69'<"5"A@6<'1++K"*45*" C-+,6<'B"5;" +,'-,6'E"+("(6(*%" 46A4"06;+-6*%G"46A4"C+,'-*%" B/4++9B I ":4'%"B*5*'G"]>9*4+@A4"B','-59" <'(6;6*6+;B"+(" !# : %'0< "'F6B*G"+;'"E6<'9%"5//'C*'<"5CC-+5/4"<'B/-61'B" !# : %'0< "B*@<';*B" 5B"*4+B'"E4+"5-'"6;"<5;A' -"+(";+*"/+0C9'*6;A"46A4" B/4++9I"WCI#MX":4'% "A+"+;"*+"B*5*'" *45*"*4'";5*6+;59" <-+C+@*"-5*'"6B"5-+@;<"##hI" >"0+-'"6;"<'C*4"<'B/-6C*6+;"+(" !# : %'0< "B*@<';*B "1%"N-+;6/K"W #QQTG"CI "MXG"-'('-B" *+"m+-<+;"5;<"n+E'99SB"/+;/9@B6+;"*45*7 >* J -6BK"B*5*@B"6B"5"(@;/*6+;"+("*4'"6;5CC-+C-65*';'BB"+("<','9+C0';*59" ';,6-+;0';*B"*+"0''*"*4'";''0'-6/5G"1@*"45B"1'';"5<+C*'<"4'-'"C-'<+06;5;*9%"6;"@-15;"5-'5BI" 8' 5;E469'G"C95/' J 15B'<"'<@/5*6+;"45B"(+/@B'<"+;"'/+9+A6/59G"-@-59"6BB@'BI":4'" 5@*4+-"B*5*'BG"]Y95/' J 15B'<"C'<5A+A6'B"5-'";''<'<"B+"*45*"*4'"'<@/5*6+;"+("/6*6H';B"

PAGE 13

#2 06A4*"45,'"B+0'"<6-'/*"1'5-6;A"+;"*4'"E'99 J 1'6;A"+("*4'"B+/659"5;<"'/+9+A6/59"C95/'B" C'+C9'"5/*@ 599%"6;4516*^ WCI"_X I"D"/4+B'"*4'"16/%/9'"(+-"*46B"-'B'5-/4"C-+='/*"1'/5@B'"6*" 599+E'<"*4'"5-*6B*Z-6<'-B"*+"6;4516*"*4'6-"';,6-+;0';*"E469'"-6<6;A"+-"<6BC95%6;A" *4'6-"5-*E+-Kb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g@'B*6+;B"+("

PAGE 14

#\ '9606;5*6;A"'6*4'-"*-5<6*6+; 59"5-*"+-",6B@59"/@9*@-'"5-'"59B+"C+6;*'<"+@*G"1@*"*4'" 5@*4+-"B@AA'B*B"*45*"*4'%"B4+@9<"/+ J 'F6B*I")4'"1'96','B"*4'"6;*'A-5*6+;"+(",6B@59" /@9*@-'"5;<"/-6*6/59"5-*"C'<5A+A%"E699"C-+,6<'"B*@<';*B"E6*4"*4'";'/'BB5-%"BK699B"(+-" 96,6;A"6;"5"<'0+/-5/%I":4-+@A4"*4 '"@B'"+("/-6*6/59"C'<5A+A%G"*'5/4'-B"';/+@-5A'" -'(9'/*6,'"B'9( J 'F506;5*6+;"+("5**6*@<'BG",59@'BG"5;<"1'96'(B"E6*46;"46B*+-6/59"5;<" /@9*@-59"/+;*'F*B"@B6;A"*4'"C+E'-"+("605A'B"*+"/+;,'%"0'5;6;A"Wm6-+@FG"#Qk2G#Qk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o"Y'*'-B+;7 >99"+("@B"5-'"6;*605*'9%"/+ ;;'/*'-*"'<@/5*+-B"45,'"9+;A"5-A@'<"(+-"*4'"60 C+-*5;/'"+("5;"'<@/5*6+;"*45*"';/+@-5A'B" 5;<"B@CC+-*B"V@596*5*6,'"B'9( J 'FC-'BB6+;"5;<"-'596H5*6+;"W?(95;
PAGE 15

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
PAGE 16

#M B*@<';*BS"C'-B+;59"96,'BG"5;< "D"45,'"K'C*"*46B"6;"06;<"E469'"C95;;6;A"*4'"5/*6,6*6'B"+(" 0%"C-+='/*I D"(+@;<"C5-599'9B"1'*E'';".'"3465-5 SB"W#QQ_X"C-+='/*"5;<"0%"+E;I":4'" -'/+00';<'<"@B'"+("5"B*-@/*@-';<"=@B*"5B"*4'"B*@<';*"'<@/5*+-B"(+@;<" 6;"*4'6-"B*@<%G"D"45,'"59B+"(+@;<"*45*"0%"06BA6,6;AB"51+@*"0 %"51696*6'B"*+"E+-K"E6*4" *4'B'"B*@<';*B"45,'"<6B5CC'5-'-+;+E6*H G "5;<"m6-+@F"W#QQ#XI" [+E','-G" D" (+@;<" *4'"/+016;5*6+;"+( *4'B'" *E+" <@/5*6+; 59 "0'*4+<+9+A6'B J /-6*6/59"C'<5A+A%" 5;<",6B@59"/@9*@-'"'<@/5*6+; J "'FC+@;<'<"+;9%"1%"5"('E"'<@/5*+-B"B@/4"5B":5,6;" W2!!\X"5;<"['6B'"W2!!_XI" ['6B'"1'96','B"*4'"6;*'A-5*6+ ;"+("O3"5;<"3Y"E699"C-+,6<'" B*@<';*B"E6*4"*4'";'/'BB5-%"BK699B"(+-"96,6;A"6;"5"<'0+/-5/% I":4'B'"0'*4+<+9+A6'B" 5-'"B*699"1'6;A"-'B'5-/4'<"5;<"'FC9+-'* J a 6BK"/5*'A+-6H5*6+;BG"6B"5"/+016;5*6+;"D"<6<";+*"/+0'" 5/-+BB"6;"0%"-'B'5-/4I":46B"95/K"+("<5*5" 0+*6,5*'B "0'"*+"K''C"'FC9+-6;A"5;<"E+-K6;A" 6;"*4'"<6-'/*6+;"+("5"0+-'"'A596*5-65;G"<'0+/-5*6/G"5;<"B+/6599%"';/+0C5BB6; A" '<@/5*6+;I" C(5)*)3).*,.5,3(1F7, A3 # 1)7O % ":4'-'"5-'"B','-59"<'(6;6*6+;Bb"+;'"E6<'9%"5//'C*'<"5CC-+5/4"<'B/-61'B"5* J -6BK"B*@<';*B"5B"*4+B'"E4+"5-'"6;"<5;A'-"+(";+*"/+0C9'*6;A"46A4"B/4++9G"<@'"*+"5" E6<'"-5;A'"+("C-+19'0BI"W)/45-A'9G":45/K'-G"o"$'99G"2!!T G"CI#MX $1)3)&0',"(20+.+% # ">//+-<6;A"*+"P'6B*%;5"5;<"U++<-@0G"]3-6*6/59"C'<5A+A%"6B" C-605-69%"/+;/'-;'<"E6*4"/4599';A6;A"6;<6,6<@59B"*+"6;,'B*6A5*'G"@;<'-B*5;
PAGE 17

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http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Upcycling 6)780',$8 '381(, # :4'-'"5-'"05;%",5-6'<"+C6;6+;B"+;"*4'"B/+C'"+("*46B"*'-0b"(+-"*46B" B*@<%"D"50"-'('--6;A"*+"*4'"605A'B"*45*"5-'"@B'<"A9+1599%"5;<"9+/599%"*+"';*'-*56;G" 05-K'*"C-+<@/*BG"5;<"BC-'5<"6<'5BI"W:5,6;G"2!!\X

PAGE 18

#T 4013 ,RK,S(3G.2.'.+% ) B(7(01&G,.HT(&3)L(7 3'"") !%#)$*+,!#'-&)4%-5$,#0)#6!#)'&,-%4-%!#$)('0+!"),+"#+%$)!&*),%'#',!") 4$*!7-72) 1$&$8'# )9.# : ;'0<=)0#+*$�>)?8)0-@)6-A)A'"")#6$)4%-4-0$*)4%-5$,#)1$)$88$,#'($)'&) 1%'&7'&7)!1-+#),%'#',!")!&!"20'0)-8)#6$)0-,'$#2)!&*),-BB+&'#2) A6$%$) #6$0$)9.# : ;'0<=) '*$&#'8'$*)0#+ *$�)"'($>)C!&)?)$&!1"$)0#+*$�)#-),-&0'*$%)#6$'%)-A&)!%#)!0)!&) $B4-A$%$*)(-',$)'&)#6$'%)-A&),-BB+&'#'$0>) ) :4'"C-605-%"+1='/*6,'" +("*46B"C-+='/* J 6; J 96'@"+("*4'B6B"E5B"*+"-'B'5-/4"*4'" '(('/*6,';'BB"+(" 5CC-+C-65*6;A 16/%/9'B"5B"5",6B@59"/@9*@-'"5-*"+1='/*Z 5-*6(5/* E6*4"*4'" 6;*';*6+;"+("';5196;A"B*@<';*B"*+"/-6*6/599%"5;59%H'"*4'"46'-5-/46'B"+(" *4'" ,6B@59"5-*B 5;IgI"&+;'B")/4++9G"6;" m56;'B,699'G"L9+-6<5I":46B"B/4++9"BC'/6(6/599%" 5;<"'F/9@B6,'9%"B'-,'B"B*@<';*B" <65A;+B'<"E6*4"?Z$."(-+0"*4'"';*6-'"/+@;*%"B/4++9"B%B*'0I":4'"-'B'5-/4"A-+@C" /+;B6B*'<"+("*E+"(6(*4"A-5<'"/95BB'BG"+;'"E6*4"M"B*@<';*BG"5;<"*4'"+*4'-"E6*4"QI":4'B'" *E+"/95BB'B"E'-'"B'9'/*'<"1%"8BI"Y5@95">;<'-B+;"W*4'"B/4++9" 5-*"*'5/4'-X"15B'<"+;" *4'6-"-'95*6,'"05*@-6*%"5;<"5-*6B*6/"(9'F61696*%I" :46B"-'B'5-/4"-'/'6,'<"5CC-+,59"(+-0" *4'"i;6,'-B6*%"+("L9+-6<5"D;B*6*@*6+;59"a',6'E"$+5-<"*+"C-+*'/*"*4'"6<';*6*%"+("599" C5-*6/6C5;*B"WB''">CC';<6FXI" ?,';"*4+@A4"*46B"E5B"5"B0599"A-+@C G";+"+;'"E5B" 'F/9@<'<"+-"5<<'BB';*"(+-0B"E'-'"<6B*-61@*'<"5;<"/+99'/*'<"1%"0'I" j;9%"*E+"+("*4'"B*@<';*BS" C5-';*B"<6<";+*"5CC-+,'"(+-"*4'6-"/469<-';"*+"C5-*6/6C5*'G"B+"5"05=+-6*%"+("*4'" B*@<'; *B"5/*6,'9%"C5-*6/6C5*'
PAGE 19

#k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j;"*4'"(6-B*"<5%"*4'%"E-+*'"5;<"BK'*/4'<"5;BE'-B"(+-"*4'"(6-B*"V@'B*6+;"( -+0" *4'"96B*"1'9+EI" D",6<'+"6;*'-,6'E'<"*4'"B*@<';*B"6;<6,6<@599%" <@-6;A"*4'"C-+='/* 5;<" 5BK'< "*4'0"V@'B*6+;B"*E+G"*4-''G"5;<"(+@-"E469'"*4'%"E'-'"E+-K6;A"+;"*4'"16/%/9'BI" D"5BK'<"*4'0"+;'"V@'B*6+;"C'-"6;*'-,6'EG"E46/4"*%C6/599%"95B*'<"51+@*"_ J M"06;@*'BI" #I f50'"\"+("%+@-"(5,+-6*'",6<'+"A50'BG":O"B4+EBG"0+,6'BG"+-"0@B6/65;B"*45*" %+@"96K'"*+"C95%G"E5*/4G"+-"96B*';"*+I 2I U45*"<+"%+@"96K'"51+@*"*4'0` \I >-'"%+@"6;/9@<6;A"*4'B'"6<'5B"6;"%+@-"<'B6A;` _I U45*"05K'B"%+@-"16/%/9'"C56;*6;A"5-*` D"-'/+-<'<"0%"60C-'BB6+;B"6;" 5"=+@-;59"5(*'-"'5/4"/95BB"B'BB6+;I"D"@B'<"*4'" (+99+E6;A"V@'B*6+;B"5B"5"A@6<'96;'7" #I U45*"V@'B*6+;B"E'-'"5BK'<"6;"/95BB"*+<5%` 2I .6<"*4'"B*@<';*B"9'5-;"5;%*46;A"*+<5%`"[+E"<+"D"K;+E` \I U45*"<6<"D"9'5-;"*+<5%`

PAGE 20

#Q >B"5"(+99+E"@CG"*4'"B*@<';*B" E'-' "519'"*+" -6<'"*4'6 -"5-* J 16K'B"+;"/50C@B"E4';" *4'%"E'-'"<+;'" 5B"5"E5%"+("<6BC95%6;A"*4'6-"E+-K"(+-"*4'"-'B*"+("*4'"B/4++9I":4'-'" E5B "59B+"5"B*@<';*"5-*"B4+E"6;"*4'"6;"E46/4"*4'B'"E+-KB"5;<"+*4'-B"1%"*4'"B*@<';*B" E'-' "<6BC95%'<"(+-"*4'"(5/@9*%G"C5-';*BG"5;<"+*4'-"6;,'B*'<"C5*6'BI ?H7(1L03).*7, :4'"/95BB'B"0'*"*E6/'"5"E''K"(+-"(+@-"E''KBI" :4'-'"E'-'"*E+"0'*4+g&"(5/@9*%I D"/+ 0C5-'
PAGE 21

2! *-5<6*6+;59"5-*"*45*"6B" 5" C5-*"+(" ,6B@59"/ @9*@-'I".@'"*+"*4'"(5/*"*45*"*46B"6B"5;"6B+95*'<" B*@<%"E6*4"5"B0599"W51+@*"#_X"BC'/6(6/"A-+@CG"*4'"-'B@9*B"5;<"/+;/9@B 6+;B"-'5/4'<" 0 5%";+*"1'"5CC96/519'"*+"599">* J a 6BK"Z"?$."B*@<';*B"+-"';,6-+;0';*BI"[+E','-G"*4'" B$#6-*0 "@B'<"6;"*46B"C-+='/*"5-'"5 CC96/519'"*+"5;%"B*@<';*"A-+@Cb",6B@59"/@9*@-'"6B A9+159"/@9*@-'I =1'!: >/1)8 ?*8/92(*8 @4214*-' D;*-+<@/'"C-+='/* m';'-5*' "6;*'-'B*" 5;<"'F/6*'0';*"6;" C-+='/* >BB6A;"5"16/%/9'"*+" '5/4"B*@<';*I L506965-6H'" B*@<';*B"E6*4" 05*'-659B"5;<"5-*" *++9B" Y+E'-Y+6;*" C-'B';*5*6+;"+(" O6B@59"3@9*@-'" 605A'B"E6*4"95C*+C" 5;<"C-+='/*+" $6K'BG"C56;*C';BG" BC-5%C56;*G" 05BK6;A"*5CG" /5-<1+5-<"*@1'BG" C56;*C';BG" BC-5%C56;*G" 05BK6;A"*5C' )50C9'"<'B6A;B"+;" /5-<1+5-<"*@1'B )50C9'"$6K'B"*45*" 59-'5<%"45,'" <'B6A;B"C56;*'/1)8 ?*8/92(*8 @4214*-' .6B/@BB"<'B6A;" C-+/'BB )*5-*"<' B6A;" C-+/'BB )*@<';*"0@B*"45,'" \"<'B6A;B"1'(+-'" B*5-*6;A"+;"5/*@59" 16K' )*5-*"6;<6,6<@59" 6;*'-,6'EB"E6*4" B*@<';*B"*+"A56;" *4'6-"+C6;6+;B" 51+@*",6B@59" $6K'BG"C56;*C';BG" BC-5%C56;*G" 05BK6;A"*5CG" 35-<1+5-<"*@1'BG" C56;*C';BG" BC-5%C56;*G" 05BK6;A"*5C' )50C9'"<'B6A;B" g@'B*6+;"p#G",6<'+"/50'-5" .'0+;B*-5*'"4+E" *+"<','9+C"<'B6A;B .6B/@BB"5;<" <'0+;B*-5*'" 0'*4+
PAGE 22

2# /@9*@-'"5;<"46A4" 5-*I <'B6A;"C-+/'BB j;' J +; J +;'" <6B/@BB6+;"+(" -'95*6+;B46C" 1'*E'';"B*@<';*" 5-*E+-K"5;<",6B@59" /@9*@-'I" =1'!B >/1)8 ?*8/92(*8 @4214*-' U+-K"+;"<'B6A;B L506965-6H'" B*@<';*B"E6*4" <6B5BB'019%"+(" 16K'BI )*@<';*B"C-5/*6/'" @B'"+(";'E"*++9B" E6*4"45;/1)8 ?*8/92(*8 @4214*-' )*@<';*B"/+;*6;@'" E6*4"<'B6A;" C-+/'BB )*@<';*B"/+;*6;@'" E6*4"<6B5BB'019%" 5;<"C-'C5-5*6+;"+(" 16K'B )*@<';*B"E4+"45,'" (6;6B4'<"<'B6A;" C45B'"B*5-*" C56;*6;A"16K'I .6BC95%"(6;6B4'<" <'B6A;B 35-<1+5-<"*@1'BG" C56;*C';BG" BC-5%C56;*G" 05BK6;A"*5C' $6K'BG"B5;
PAGE 23

22 3+;*6;@' "B*@<';*" 6;*'-,6'EB" 1'*E'';"B*@<';*" 5-*E+-K"5;<",6B@59" /@9*@-'I" =1'!D >/1)8 ?*8/92(*8 @4214*-' 3+;*6;@'"C56;*6;A" 16K'BI D;BC6-'"B*@<';*B" *+" <','9+C"*4'6-" <'B6A;B"<@-6;A" C56;*6;A"C-+/'BB 3+;*6;@'"B*@<';*" 6;*'-,6'EB $6K'BG"C56;*C';BG" BC-5%C56;*G" 05BK6;A"*5C'I g@'B*6+;"p_G",6<'+" /50'-5I [5,'"B*@<';*B" <6BC95%"5;<"<6B/@BB" E6*4"/95BB"E45*" *4'%"5-'"<'B6A;6;A j;' J +; J +;'" 5BB6B*5;/'"5;<" A-+@C"-' J <'0 +B"*+" -'6;(+-/'"5;<" 6;BC6-'"B*@<';*B"*+" *-%";'E"0'*4+/1)8 ?*8/92(*8 @4214*-' 3+;*6;@'"C56;*6;A" 16K'BI D;BC6-'"B*@<';*B"*+" <','9+C"*4'6-" <'B6A;B"<@-6;A" C56;*6;A "C-+/'BB 3+;*6;@'"B*@<';*" 6;*'-,6'EB $6K'BG"C56;*C';BG" BC-5%C56;*G" 05BK6;A"*5C'I g@'B*6+;"p#G",6<'+" /50'-5I j;' J +; J +;'" 5BB6B*5;/'"5;<" A-+@C"-' J <'0+B"*+" -'6;(+-/'"0'*4+/1)8 ?*8/92(*8 @4214*-' 3+;*6;@'"C56;*6;A" 16K'BI L6;6B4"C56;*6;A" 16K'BI )*5-*"5BB'019%"+(" 16K'BI 3+;*6;@'"B*@<';*" 6;*'-,6'EBI $6K'BG"C56;*C';BG" BC-5%C56;*G" 05BK6;A"*5C'I $6K'BG"C56;*C';BG" BC-5%C56;*G" 05BK6;A"*5C'I $6K'B"5;<" 0'/45;6/"*++9BI j;' J +; J +;'" 5BB6B*5;/'"5;<" A-+@C"-' J <'0+B"*+" -'6;(+-/'"0'*4+
PAGE 24

2\ g@'B*6 +;"p\G",6<'+" /50'-5I )*@<';*B"/+;*6;@'" *+"9'5-;"@B'"+(";'E" *++9B"E6*4"45;/1)8 ?*8/92(*8 @4214*-' L6;6B4"5BB'019%"+(" 16K'BI L6;6B4"B*@<';*" 6;*'-,6'EB )*@<';*B"<','9+C" BK699B"(@-*4'-"E6*4" @B'"+(";'E"*++9B" E6*4"45;
PAGE 25

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
PAGE 26

2M #!!h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

PAGE 27

2R 45<"E45*G" 5;<"E45*"E5B"(56-b "',';"B''06;A9%"6;;+/@+@B"B6*@5*6+;B"E'-'"59E5 %B" 6<';*6(6'<"5;<"<'/95-'<"E6*4"5;A'-"+-"5;"6;*';B'"*+;'"+("6;=@B*6/'I" U469'"*4'-'"E5B"6;6*659"5;<"/+;*6;@59"'F/6*'0';*"51+@*"*4'"16/%/9'"C-+='/*G" *4'"B*@<';*B" +(*'; "1'/50'"5;F6+@B"5;<"05<'"B*5*'0';*B"B@/4"5BG"]$@*"D"<+;S*"K;+E" 4+Eq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b"*4'% "<6<;S*"B''0"*+"K;+EI"D"-'596H'<"*45*"*4'%"E+@9<" ;''<"*60'"*+"1@69< "*4'6-"/+;(6<';/'"E6*4"*4'"05*'-659B"5;<"/+;/'C*BG"B+"D"599+E'<"

PAGE 28

2T *4'0"*60'"*+"'FC9+-'"5;<"'FC'-60';*I">(*'-"*4'"6;6*659"_"E''KB"+("E+-K6;A"+;"*4'" C-+='/*G"*4'"B*@ <';*B"1'/50'"/+0(+-*519'"E6*4"*4'6-"6<'5B"5;<" 51696*6'B"5;<"E+@9<" -'C56;*"+-"-'<'B6A;"5B";'/'BB5-%I" D*"E5B"+;9%"5*"*46B"C+6;*"*45*"*4'%"/+@9<"/+;(6<';*9%" /-'5*'"5"<'B6A;"*45*"*4'%"E'-'"C5BB6+;5*'"51+@*G"5;<"D";+"9+;A'-"45<"*+"-'06;<"*4'0" *+"*5K'"*4'6-"*60' "+-"-'056;"(+/@B'-*"?<@/5*6+;"W .I$I>I? X G "5;<"*4'"/-'5*6,'G"'FC-'BB6,'G" 5;<" 'FC9+-5*+-%"5-*"*'5/46;A"0'*4+
PAGE 29

2k !* # 50)1*(77 D"(+@;<"*45*"*4'"B*@<';*B"45<"5"4%C'-B';B6*6,6*%"*+"*4'6-"C'-/'C*6+;"+(" +& J (56-;'BB"<@-6;A"5;%"*%C'"+("'F/45;A'"+-"5/*6+;I ":4'"B*@<';*B"E'-'" 'F*-'0'9%" B';B6*6,'"*+"*4'"C'-/'C*6+;"*45*"B+0'+; '"'9B'"06A4*"-'/'6,'"0+-'"+("5;%*46;A r 5**';*6+;G"*60'G"+-"05*'-659B r *45; "460B'9("+-"4'-B'9(I "D("*4'%"C'-/'6,'<"*45*"*4'%" E'-'"1'6;A"*-'5*'<"@;(56-9%G"*4'%"E+@9<"C-+*'B*"9+@<9%G"*4';"*%C6/599%"<6,'-*"*4'" ';*6-'"';<'5,+-"1%"5",'-159ZC4%B6/59"<6B*-5/*6+;I -G (,:0W%,N.%7 D"(+@;<";@0'-+@B"-'('-';/'B"<@-6;A"0%"-'B'5-/4"*+"*4'"/+;/'C*"+("] f+; J /+0C965;/'"5B"5"(+-0"+(" -'B6B*5;/'G^"6;"E46/4"B*@<';*B"-'(@B'"*+"C5-*6/6C5*'"5B"5" (+-0"+("-'B6B*5;/'"*+"5"B%B*'0"*4'%"(''9"<6B';(-5;/46B'<" 1%I ":4'% "E699"','; "C5BB"1%"5" -'E5-< 5B"5"E5%" *+";'A5*'" *4'"-'E5-)?8)0-@)6-A)A'"")#6$)4%-4-0$*)4%-5$,#)1$) $88$,#'($)'&)1%'&7'&7)!1-+#),%'#',!")!&!"20'0)-8)#6$)0-,'$#2)!&*),-BB+&'#2)A6$%$) #6$0$)9.# : ;'0<=)'*$&#'8'$*)0#+*$�)"'($>)C!&)?)$&!1"$)0#+*$�)#-),-&0'*$%)#6$'%) -A&)!%#)!0)!&)$B4-A$%$*)(-',$)'&)#6$'%)A&),-BB+&'#'$0>) )

PAGE 30

2Q :4'B'"B*@<';*B"E'-'";+*"5B"6;,+9,'<"E6*4",6B@59"/@9*@-'"5B"D"45<"'FC'/*'< r E46/4"E5B"<@'"*+"0%"+E;"6;'FC'-6';/'"E6*4"*46B"C+C@95*6+;I "Y-6+-"*+"*46B"C-+='/*"D" 45<"1'';",6'E6;A" ,6B@59"/@9*@-' "(-+0"5"06<<9'"/95BB",6'EC+6;*G"E4'-'"B*@<';*B"45,' 0+-'"5//'BB"*+"0'<65"5;<"'V@6C0';*I"f+;'*4'9'BBG"*4'B'"B*@<';*B "E4+"96,'"5*"*4'" C+,'-*%"9','9"E '-'"(506965-"E6*4"*4'"<'*569B"+("*4'"0+B*"C+C@95-"A50'BG"',';"6("*4'%" <6<";+*"+E;"*4'0I D"45<",'-%"9606*'<"-'BC+;B'"6;"*4'",6<'+"6;*'-,6'EB"(-+0"*4'"B*@<';*Bb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b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q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
PAGE 31

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
PAGE 32

\# ?*6*2*,(*8 >-+;+E6*H G")I"o"[I"m6-+@FG"W#QQ#XI" K-0#B-*$%&)V*+,!#'-&E)H$L#+!")!+#6-%'#2@),+"#+%$@) &*)#6$)4-"'#',0)-8)"'#$%!,2E "86;;'5C+96BG"8f 7"i;6,'-B6*%"+("86;;'B+*5"Y-'BB E $6A'9+EG"$I"o"Y'*'-B+;G"$IG"W2!!2XI" ;$#6'&<'&7)7"-1!"'W!#'-&J)H$!,6'&7)8-%)5+0#',$)'&)!&) +&5+0#)A-%"*E) "869E5@K''G"UD7"a'*46;K6;A")/4++9BG"P*IG"W#QkQXI" \'0#-%2)-8)!%#)$*+,!#'-&J) ?&#$""$,#+!")!&*)0-,'!"),+%%$�)'&)#$!,6'&7) #6$)('0+!")!%#0E "f'E"n+-KG"fn7":'5/4'-B"3+99'A'"Y-'BBI L-''<05; G"NI"W2!!\XI":4'"60C+-*5;/'"+("B*@<';*"5-*6B*6/"C-+<@/*6+;"*+"*'5/46;A" ,6B@59"/@9*@-'I" .%#)V*+,!#'-& G" ]^ W2XG"\k J _\I L-6'-'G"YIG"W#QQkXI" H$!,6$%0)! 0),+"#+%!")A-%<$%0J)G$##$%0)#-)#6-0$)A6-)*!%$)#$!,6)K!+"-) D%'$%$E "$+@9<'-G"3+9+-5<+G"U'B*,6'E"Y-'BBI m-@';'E59"/-6*6/59"C'<5A+A%"+("C95/'I" V*+,!#'-&!");$0$!%,6$% G" YF W_XG"\ J #2I ['6B' G".I"W2!!_XI"DB",6B@59"/@9*@-'"1' /+06;A"+@-"/5;+;"+("5-*`" .%#)V*+,!#'-& G" ]_ WMXG" _# J _RI" N5@(05;;G"&I"W#QQ\XI" C6!%!,#$%'0#',0)-8)$B-#'-&!")!&*)1$6!('-%!")*'0-%*$%0)-8),6'"*%$&) !&*)2-+#6 I"8'--699G"fn7"Y-';*6/'"[599 I

PAGE 33

\2 N6;/4'9+'G"&IG"W#QQ\XI" H-A!%*)!),%'#',!")4-"'#',0)-8)#$!,6$%)#6'&<'&7E ""U 'B*C+-*G"3:7" $'-A6;"o"m5-,'% I N-+;6/KG"aIG"W#QQTXI" .# : %'0<)2-+#6J)H6$-%2@)4%!,#',$@)%$8-%BE "f'E"n+-K"5;<"P+;<+;7" m5-95;<"Y@196B46;AI P'6B*%;5G"YI"o"U++<-@0G">IG"W#QQQXI"3+;*'F*"5;<"/@9*@-'7"U45*"6B"/-6*6/59"C'<5A+A%I" D;"YI"P'6B*%;5G">I"U++<-@0G"o")I")4'19+0"W?7"[5-,5-<" ?<@/5*6+;59"a',6'EI Y@;/4 G"NIG"W#QQkXI" ?&#%-*+,#'-&)#-)0-,'!")%$0$!%,6J)`+!&#'#!#'($)!&*) M +!"'#!#'($) !44%-!,6$0E "P+;<+;7")5A'"Y@196/5*6+;BI Scharg el, F., Thacker, T., Bell, J., (2007). From at risk to academic excellence: What successful leaders do Larchmont, NY: Eye on Education )*+,'-G"&IG"W2!#!XI"a' J /%/9' J 6;A"*+E5-<"5"/-6*6/59"C'<5A+A%"+(",6B@59"/@9*@-'I" i;C@196B4'<"C69+*"B*@<%I"i;6,'-B6 *%"+("L 9+-6<5G"m56;'B,699'G"LPI :5,6; G"NI"W2!!\XI"U-'B*96;A"E6*4"5;A'9BG"B'5-/46;A"(+-"A4+B*B7":+E5-<"5"/-6*6/59" C'<5A+A%"+(",6B@59"/@9*@-'G" X#+*'$0)'&).%#)V*+,!#'-& G" QQ W\X"CCI"#QT J 2#\I i;6*'<")*5*'B"3';B@B"$@-'5@I"W2!##X I X#!#$)!&*)C-+)`+',,569519' "(-+0" 4**C7ZZV@6/K(5/*BI/';B@BIA+,ZV(IG"W2!!QXI" .%#)!&*)*'0!1'"'#2J)H6$)0-,'!")!&*)4-"'#',!")0#%+77"$0)8!,'&7) $*+,!#'&E "f'E"n+-KG"fn7"Y59A-5,'"85/06995;I

PAGE 34

\\ H55IJ=
PAGE 35

\_

PAGE 36

\M

PAGE 37

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