r-fjfirjiff Ir--, r -i L
Di Lba e f
L 'TA LAE
--1 ,1 4K
- .r' .. -. 7.
'- I <*
.4.rawn-v .rarK x *
Amudced Sm FindS mUn
. f iaeha.r Pe&
S L0 2 !Lit= ii hSLtna5 llS ii Ite
- SitE rE iL^ a
C L -
Windward Islands' opinion.
Pubishel Philipsburg, Netherlands Antilles
Edit or F-iYat I Journal, magazine Periodical English
S I a ~ 1nv o gihe UNIV OF FLtORIDAi
Nefto rm.uReauestilidit Checik for Electronirc ResAources NMot iUeBleuest tin LUial EMitLLfAlE
CFinadLUesJajatfnsiyL tla EJfllalulsSlilU OaLcoElitSaE$tlclh
Enter your location: 32611
lspayng tiane, 1-1 w I
University of Florida
GAINESVILLE, FL 32611 United States
HoMe Search *
0orBo- Mlan a c-t
I I < 1 mile
> i M -ana ne f Ne ee -r
WIKIPEDIA Search results
1 Fic Eatlce F tomVs impeha. te fr.ee encyclopedia
Feat ean intent
Don tcr 1n pet i
At,, uW ea
A ,,r w ,,,,,
"windwerd islands opuron" Q
r'widward islands opmnon* S.--d
Conlent pgel Mlrkmerra Hep a Prrject pag Es o Nryi q A~-r i
There were no results matching the query
Fwcsy pwoxy Abc.At isretu Cistwrrns
* ." .* ^. *,.
iS ^ ..-. <-,% -'
,,3 e* P" ,, -,', ,
Vftt.or trrr |POwTs r Mi If.Ui*IfJLi. T1
/0CC tf,,.. 0- -7 .L- k. _
<.lr Ute 1 fi. % -, .
. ... l........k. .. ... -
ti l k I 9 i k,+ I
i> ,:.- L -,* uikii .'W :-1.a.- J.:H- .=
. 4.. ..... .. ... L...
'.. ,9..-..+ "-.. .9 '-'.
..~ >prru. ;-. .-. .. _. _, .. r. .
S. N lL S.
A '- 7!..-. *.. .,I-.9, .
P" ."""* f -* ..1..4i
** r .1 di~n-. -^.J j.jk o M r
I '-.rvhri. I. -9 ii-U 99 r ...*
A.-- J k *^- f &.9 k..
tj-.pj n f~k*> ~ln-j.9..-.,.
.4C. 9.- 4. -ki A. U BL p r."Il-.*
OM DE LA NATION.
... .. .. ...... ,rf j..n ,i-. :
,i. I i m II + "kl ....n I&^r
. ,. ... k ,,-l. ,:..
IA. .. ..9. A A .-- l .- .
6.d .. k i + '.1 n I- '4 -
.... ...a a. 49.. -
-ll+ n. + 49 1.9 .4... .-
,.. ,i A94. l .i F-n ,*ri. .
L^," .4' ..9B4.49.*A9IA.4.
I.,. *~-*.9 '9 i r&j^ --*
-rK'^Vt --. 4.. A. .- "A .
1A.A-.l1.9....9 l *A
.4... -* 4 I- i'- -x
1 U f9. --.-,. *' *-'*- l3t.99
IT b- '. A ','.;.. ..I "
-,:.i :h ...M .- I -.., .-
-. e ...,t .i ... F ....
A r. .
4A B. 9 4 ..lbl5 A.A9.~-^.. 4
_.9.-;.9. -.2 -& Z.. 7 _
" m (1 .K^ Hb f .h- .. .... -
,.9A.9+ ....9... .
11 99niw fl'. r rn* '. -.
L9f.ti.-. J.18.104.22.168.99.-4.9 *
. -r- .. -, r..-. -.
9 L9 4 L 9 9 .. J. L n n. a 1 l ~ r U
9" n. IX
.9 r .A. rir1> *b--
ACAkTA Er VERBAL\
L, nUI6 gld eaIW,- loui 1tiM
ML B. a ItmaVi -- r i a-i l 9
I. A.L.1S-5- LA.-L"1I
uGw o". .09T Lo... 80y7.Viu
I aorus .l FOu sGa r P T s 0
F. PICiHON, SUCCESSEUR, tD
L .oraf do .nd tti.,il n a scM do lalO
U4, Rag looTLor, U
Brols d repodutooteiltss
.' AFFAIRES EMiLE RIGAUD
ET PIECES JUDICIAIRLS
' F. S'r. IM. R~e. d. 1nPor"I
IMPRIMERIE DE L'ETAT
tu m 7 7
Caribbean Disaster Information Network (CARDIN),
Digital Library of the Caribbean (dLOC),
1 ACURIL 2011 DRAFT PRESENTATION NOTES/PAPER The Digital Library of the Caribbean (dLOC) and t he Role of Digital Libraries in Disas ter Preparedness and Mitigation By: Laurie N. Taylor and Brooke Wooldridge Introduction The role of digital libraries in disaster preparedness and mitigation is multi faceted. In order to properly address the topic we are using the term digital library the term to refer the structures that support digital access and preservation: digital archives, digital repositories, and related technologies and tool s for digital preservation. Preservation is similarly defined in an inclusive manner, with a consideration of the overall digital supports for preservation and with preservation understood as the assurance that materials will continue to exist in something close to its original form. With this broad view of the technologies supporting preservation and preservation itself we approach preservation from a long term perspective where preservation is a process within the ongoing lifecycle of information and art ifacts, and not as an endpoint. In order to address the role of digital libraries in disaster preparedness and mitigation, we also want to emphasize that the role is both technical and social or communal. Digital libraries, like their non digital counterpa rts, utilize technology for specific purposes. The underlying library purpose s for using the technology define digital l ibraries, and not the technologies alone For digital libraries, technology serves to support access and preservation as well as the co mmunities for the digital libraries. In this paper, we review
2 how access to library collections informs digital library technical operations. We then turn to focus on the communities surrounding digital libraries which serve as the most critical supports f or disaster preparedness and mitigation. This critical support is explained in context with several examples: digital library communities working to provide reference resources to assist first responders after a disaster; digital library communities utiliz ing other library communities to restore materials lost in disasters; new digital library communities developing in response to a disaster for disaster mitigation; and, new communities emerging in relation to their work on particular materials, that then s eek out and connect to digital libraries in support of shared goals for disaster preparedness and mitigation. These examples illustrate the many roles and importance of digital library communities in disaster preparedness and mitigation. Technical Conside rations As the Final Report of the Blue Ribbon Task Force on Sustainable Digital Preservation and Access also true for digital libraries: without access, there is no preservation. The Comm ittee For Film Preservation and Public Access before The National Film Preservation Board of the
3 For digital libraries, preservation co ncerns must also be access concerns because of the scale of the work involved in digital preservation. T he scale of this work creates many demands that can only be supported through supporting access. Clay Shirkey, in the Library of Congress Archive Inge st and Handling Test (AIHT) Final Report explains : Scale is a mysterious phenomenon processes that work fine at one scale can fail at 10 times that size, and processes that successfully handle a 10 times scale can ering tools and systems for digital preservation should be careful to explain the scale(s) at which their systems have been tested, and institutions implementing such systems should ideally test them at scales far above their intended daily operation t o have a sense of when scali ng issues are likely to appear. ( Page 26) Owens ; Page 28 ). D igital preservation work demands access to files as a necessary part of that testing and vali dation for scale. Access is thus an ever present workflow requirement Access is required to support digital preservation as an ongoing process for the lifecycle of digital information and materials Even for a relatively small set of materials, the work to support digital preser vation is a perpetual process within the information lifecycle. The scale of the work is measured by the quantity of materials with an infinite timeline for digital preservation processing. Because of the ongoing timeline, the scale of the work continues t o grow beyond the simple quantity of materials. The unending timeline for digital preservation work must be able to adapt to technological changes. For specific technologies as they relate to the overall preservation processes for the lifecycle, see Mark V Sullivan (ACURIL 2011). In it, he similarly stresses that specific technical concerns are secondary and defined in support of digital tiered, about ensuring
4 Digital libraries thus perform ongoing and changing work in order to support digital preservation. Because digital libraries must continually adapt to new technolo gies and conduct ongoing work to support digital preservation process es digital libraries face challenges that require a community for support. Digital Library Communities D igital library communities s upport disaster preparedness, immediate response, a nd mitigation. The simplest and most obvious supports are the digitization of materials as part of disaster preparedness and the restoration of preserved materials after a disaster as part of disaster mitigation. Digital library communities follow other li brary communities in their support of disaster preparedness and mitigation by sharing copies of mater ials for preservation and access Before digital libraries shared digital copies libraries performed this work with print copies, microfilm, and other ana log formats. Digital library communities provide many less obvious supports for disaster preparedness and mitigation through their communities. Digital libraries follow and extend traditional library supports for disasters in the manner that they : provide reference services and resources to assist first responders after a disaster; utilize library communities to restore materials lost in disasters; support the development of new communities to respond to disasters for disaster mitigation; and,
5 support new communities that emerge based on new needs in relation to their work on particular materials and that require library collaboration to support shared goals for disaster preparedness and mitigation. In addition to ongoing preparatory work, through sharing, disseminating, and preserving copies of materials, the digital library community provides support for the full spectrum of needs related to preparedness and mitigation. This includes support immediately f ollowing disasters serving as a resource for the c ommunity as a whole. Digital Library Communities and Disaster Preparedness, Response and Mitigation Immediately after the January 2010 earthquake in Haiti, the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) contacted the University of Florida (UF) George A. Smathers Libraries to request copies of topographical maps of Haiti not held elsewhere. FEMA needed access to the maps for their first responders to use in Haiti. The UF Libraries immediately provided the maps and offered to provide any possible additional assistance. The UF Libraries these maps in the physical and digital collections because the UF Libraries have traditionally been a preservation partner for institutions throughout the Caribbean. This role in the community emerged in pa rt location affords a degree of protection from hurricanes and storms which are of greater concern when closer to the coast. The UF Libraries embraced the preservation role, preserving materials through local holdings in print, microfilm, and digital.
6 The highly engaged and collaborative community to which the UF Libraries belong created the Digital Library of the Caribbean (dLOC) to meet shared preservation and access needs. In dLOC, the UF Libraries serve as the technical partner supporting the computer servers, software applications, and technical needs for digital preservation to support the community In a ddition to the UF Libraries, the Florida International Univ ersity (FIU) Libraries serve as the administ rative host, and dLOC has over 25 enhanced electronic access t o cultural, historical, legal, governmental, and research materials dLOC Fact Sheet ). In addition to serving first responders and immediate needs following a disaster, digital library communities can provide mitigation for prior disasters. For instance, the Windward I is a culturally and historically significant publication from St. Maarten. The archives of the were preserved in paper in the archives in St. Maarten. The print copies of the were lost to a fire in in St. Maarten. Fortunately, the existing library communities had ensured the was preserved through microfilm The microfilming was conducted by the UF Libraries, with copies of the film held b y both St. Maarten and the UF Libraries. While preserved, microfilm is a poor medium for local access and a very problematic medium for general access because of the need to physically use the film and because of the need to use a microfilm reader, which i s specialized and not casually available equipment. Because of the historical significance of the it was selected for digitization through By digitizing this title, the digital
7 library community is mitigating the loss of the print materials and supporting the overall needs for preservation and access through free and open access online. N ow digitized, the i s available online for anyone from anywhe re using a computer with internet access. T his free and easy access is necessary to provide full support for the materials. T he materials themselves are preserved already on microfilm, but the difficulties with microfilm inhibit both preservation as an ong oing process and access Further, the limited access hinders the UF Libraries as the only holding institution for the (WorldCat) Using a gen eral web search for the generates insufficient results in terms of quantity and quality of information given the significance of this title. The digital library community is currently digitizing this title to mitigate the prior di saster with the loss of the printed materials. The community is simultaneously working to mitigate the future disaster that would take place if the information and materials providing historical context for the title were to be lost. This loss could occur simply from the lack of recognition of their importance, which could occur as a result of a lack of access to the primary materials. P artners in dLOC have already noted that Wikipedia currently lacks a listing for the and the comm unity is making plans to create a Wikipedia entry once the materials are digitized to provide the prerequisite primary documentation After the 2010 earthquake in Haiti, t he Law Library Microform Consortium (LLMC) called on its existing community to work together to provide disaster mitigation and generate new resources for future disaster preparedness. LLMC is a non profit
8 cooperative of libraries that is dedicated to two core goals. The first is p reserving legal titles and government documents, and the second is making the co ntent accessib le and searchable LLMC began its work using microform and has since add ed digital technologies. In 2010 LLMC responded to the earthquake in Haiti by bringing together many partners to establish the LLMC Haiti Legal Pa trimony Project The LLMC Haiti Legal Patrimony Project combines the strengths of collections and resources in many law libraries around the world, locating, digitizing, and providing central access to these resources. All materials for the LLMC Haiti Lega l Patrimony Project are available through LLMC (for subscribers with paid access) and all resources are also freely available through dLOC. Previously, LLMC had undertaken many projects to digitize legal documents. In all of the prior projects, access was only availabl e for paid subscribers to LLMC With the LLMC Haiti Legal Patrimony Project LLMC sought to go beyond their existing model to ensure free and full access for all in Haiti and working with Haiti following the disaster. This meant worldwide, fre e access was needed. As an institution, LLMC also had to support the costs for this project. In working with their community, participating libraries provided access to physical content for digitization, digitized files, and financial support. LLMC thus in itiated a new project model which responded to a disaster not only to mitigate loss but to actually improve overall access to and preserva tion of materials. In doing so LLMC provided mitigation for the present concerns, furthered preparedness for the futur e, and expanded the possible models to support the overall lifecycle as a whole. With stated on the LLMC website:
9 The real potential behind the Haiti Legal Patrimony Project is the opportunity to combine the scattered resources of law libraries around the world. To get that process going, over 13 libraries have agreed to sponsor the project by canvassing their collections to see if they ha ve unique titles to contribute. ( LLMC) In w orking on the LLMC project, partners learned more about their own collections and were thought to be wanted for the project As the project continued, new entries w ere added to the master list each month because new materials critical to the project goals but that were previously unknown, were discovered. Many of the i tems being added to the list had already been digitized. The project itself thus : digitized materia ls to preserve and provide access increased access and findability for al ready digitized materials by locating them within a central collection and enhanced the available contextual information about the materials which enhances the overall usability and support for understanding the materials. As with the the LLMC project shows the importance of curatorial work for providing the level of access necessary for immediate disaster mitigation and future preparedness. This curatorial work requires a great deal of research and effort. In fact, the curatorial work itself is recognized as a highly important and rigorous form of academic scholarship within the digital humanities. Finding materials, creating context, locating the materials together, and locating the materials within the proper context is necessary for disaster preparedness and mitigation. D igital library comm unities are called upon to respond and must do so as full communities in order to meet the demands for curatorial wor k given its complexity and sheer quantity In order to support disaster mitigation and preparedness, LLMC expanded their library community and project models. The Association for Cultural Equity (ACE)
10 similarly did so for a project with the Alan Lomax rec ordings. Unlike LLMC, ACE began by preserving and then digitizing primary materials not held by libraries and without the initial involvement of library communities. The ACE project for the Alan Lomax recordings is an example of how digital libraries supp ort new communities that are initially outside of the digital library communities and that eventually become part of the digital library communities because of the need for collaboration with libraries to support shared goals for disaster preparedness and mitigation. The Alan Lomax recordings led to the emergence of ACE, which was created to support the preservation and access needs of the recordings. As the immediate needs for the materials were satisfied, new needs emerged. These new needs included the re patriation, distribution, and promotion of the materials as well as preservation and access support for secondary materials. In this case, the secondary materials are thousands of photographs taken by Alan Lomax when he was also creating the audio recordin gs. Alan Lomax made his recordings in the Caribbean beginning in 1935 when Lomax sailed to the Bahamas. Lomax was supported by a budget of $198 from the Library of Congress, garnered thanks to support from Zora Neale Hurston. He traveled to Nassau, Cat Is land and Andros Island There, he recorded sailors, sponge fishermen, farmers and dockworkers. His recordings capture African and New World styles and traditions intertwined in boat pulling songs, shanties, anthems, and old story songs The old story song s are a cross between Jack tales and African Anancy tales of trick ster lads outwitting the devil One of the songs in this collection, t he "John B. Sail" was a popular hit, sung by many artists including Pete Seeger, The Beach Boys, and Johnny Cash. In
11 193 6 19 37, the Library of Congress sponsor ed Lomax for an extensive recorded survey of Haitian music. For this collection, Lomax made fifty hours of recordings documenting legenda ry composer Ludovic Lamothe (1882 1953). The audio recordings for this collection are accompanied by archival materials: a diary correspondence chronicling the trip, diagrams, drawings, and film footage. These rich resources were unavailable and in dange r for 70 years before ACE reformatted and restored the recordings. In 1962, the Rockefeller Foundation provided funding and the University of the West Indies provided sponsorship for Lomax to record the music of the Lesser Antilles. During this six month project Lomax made 1,859 field recordings and 1,093 documentary photographs This collection features recordings and photographs from twelve islands, including : Anguilla, Dominica, Carriacou, Grenada, Guadeloupe, Martinique, St. Bart helemy, St. Kitts and Nevis St. Lucia, and Trinidad and Tobago Later in the decade, Lomax made recordings in St. Eustatius and the Dominican Republic. preservation and access. ACE provided the nec essary support for this work. With the materials reformatted for preservation, providing access was the next step. Because the Lomax recordings and photographs were made as field research, the people captured for posterity did not grant permissions for the ir work or likeness to be used in any sort of wide manner. Further complicating the situation is that these recordings capture not only the work of individual artists, but also the work and heritage of different cultures with the folk tales and traditional music. In order to provide general access, ACE first had to
12 provide access to the countries of origin and patrimony. ACE identified collaborative partners to facilitate repatriation across the Caribbean. In the case of Haiti, ACE worked with the Green Fa mily Foundation to repatriate copies of recordings to the country of origin and to promote the recordings as resources locally. In April 2010, members of the Green Family Foundation and ACE traveled to Haiti to initiate repatriation of Lomax Haiti recordi ngs and widespread outreach that so far has reached over 250,000 people The Green Family Foundation is also supporting a dLOC project for an online and Foundation served as a co llaborative bridge to connect ACE and dLOC. While some of the Lomax recordings have been repatriated, more re main and are in process. ACE also needed to find a method for supporting online access to the photographs because their site was designed to suppo rt the recordings as the primary goal, with the photographs as a future concern. While the Lomax recordings did not begin with a digital library community, ACE joined the dLOC community and the two are collaborating to share the Lomax photographs openly on line, promote the Lomax recordings, and conduct outreach to artists and their heirs to further share the recordings that are rich examples of cultural heritage and individual artistic work. The evolution of the Lomax project shows how digital library comm unities can aid in disaster preparedness and mitigation for existing projects that originate outside of library communities. Conclusion In digital libraries, technology is always in service of the overall goals which include preservation and access. Becau se of the scale of digital library work and the
13 evolving technologies in use, digital libraries are best defined by the shared goals of their communities as they work together. For disaster response, digital libraries have continued and expanded upon tradi tional library roles. Digital libraries have developed new project models and new collaborations. Further, digital libraries continue to develop new methods and means to support preservation and access as part of the ongoing support for the lifecycle of in formation. In doing so, digital library communities are active participants in all aspects of disaster preparedness, mitigation, and the development of new ideas to better support the entire process. Many digital library communities also provide informatio n resources on the role of libraries in disaster preparedness and mitigation, as with Caribbean Disaster Information Network (CARDIN) and dLOC. Existing needs include supporting both the preservation and access. The needs related to access are not yet ful ly defined. For instance, the Lomax project is particularly striking because its materials were in danger of being lost through the disaster of being unknown. Digital library communities serve a pivotal role in disaster preparedness and mitigation for both commonly considered disasters and the unexpected disasters that will occur from neglect and a lack of remembering. The Lomax recordings could have been lost, despite their status as cultural treasures, from a lack of knowledge about the recordings. The ro le of digital library communities in curatorial work will continue to expand. For materials in need of preservation, all too often their histories need to be found and documented. This contextual information provides the necessary means for understanding a nd using the primary documents. Without the historical context and supports, the materials can be rendered inaccessible from the lack of connection, even if the primary materials are openly and freely available online. Digital library communities
14 provide t he libraries in their communities with needed connections and supports so, too, must digital libraries provide connections and supports for the primary materials they contain. Works Cited Association for Cultural Equity Digital Collection. Digital Library of the Caribbean (dLOC) http://www.dloc.com/ iace Blue Ribbon Task Force on Sustainable Digital Preservation and Acc ess. Sustainable Economics for a Digital Planet Ensuring Long Term Access to Digital Information: Final Report of the Blue Ribbon Task Force on Sustainable Digital Preservation and Access. Feb. 2010. Washington, DC. 1 May 2011 < http://brtf.sdsc.edu/publications.html >. Caribbean Disaster Infor mation Network (CARDIN). University of the West Indies. Mona, Jamaica. 1 May 2011 < http://www.mona.uwi.edu/cardin / >. Committee f Film Preservation and Public Access before The National Film Preservation 12 Feb. 19 93. Los Angeles, California. 1 May 2011 < http://www.cinemaweb.com/access/pre_stmt.htm >. Digital Library of the Caribbean. Digital Library of the Caribbean ( dLOC ) Fact Sheet. Miami, FL. 1 May 20 11
15 Law Library Microform Consortium (LLMC) Haiti Legal Patrimony Digital Collection Digital Library of the Caribbean (dLOC ) http://www.dloc.c om /illmc Owens, Eva n ; Cheruku Vinay ; Meyer, John; and Morrissey, Sheila Digital Content Management at Scale: A Case Study from Portico Digital Library Federation Spring Forum 28 30 April 2008. Minneapolis, MN. 1 May 2011 < http://www.diglib.org/forums/spring2008/presentations/Owens.pdf >. Shirkey, Clay. Library of Congress Archive Ingest and Handling Test (AIHT) Final Report Library of Congress. June 2005. Washington, DC. 1 May 2011 < http ://www.digitalpreservation.gov/library/pdf/ndiipp_aiht_final_report.p df> Association of Caribbean University, Research and Institutional Libraries (ACURIL) 2011 Conference: The Role of Libraries and Archive s in Disaster Preparedness, Response, and Research. Association of Caribbean University, Research and Institutional Libraries (ACURIL ) 1 3 June 2011. Tampa, FL. 3 June 2011 < http://dloc.com/ IR00000449 / >. Digital Library of the Caribbean (dLOC). < http://www.dloc.com/ AA00000504/00002/allvolumes2 >. WorldCat OCLC Online Computer Library Center. Dublin, Ohio. 1 May 2011 < http://www.wor ldcat.org/title/windward island s opinion/oclc/1746332 >.
The Role of Digital Libraries in Disaster Preparedness and MitigationLaurie Taylor Interim Director, UF Digital Library Center email@example.com Brooke Wooldridge Project Coordinator, Digital Library of the Caribbean firstname.lastname@example.org ACURIL, University of South Florida
Preservation and AccessWithout preservation, there is no access Final Report, Blue RibbonTask Force on Sustainable Digital Preservation and Access Preservation without access is pointless The Committee For Film Preservation and Public Access before The National Film Preservation Board of the Library of Congress Scale changes everything Evan Owens, Chief Technology Officer, Portico
Digital Libraries for Disaster Preparedness & MitigationCommunity / Network Collaboration Communication
Communities / NetworksFEMA Request forHaitimaps after earthquake
Windward Islands Opinion
Image from the St. Martin News Network Jos Lake, Sr. (4thfrom L) (Saltwater Collection/Photo by W. Roumou). Windward Islands Opinion
Law Library Microform Consortium (LLMC)x
x Law Library Microform Consortium (LLMC)
Recordings by Alan Lomax Digital images of Alan Lomax photographs Lopinot, Trinidad ( www.dloc.com ) Alan Lomax recording in Dominica, 1962 Photo by Antoinette Marchand. (www.culturalequity.org)
ResourcesCaribbean Disaster Information Network (CARDIN), http://www.mona.uwi.edu/cardin/ Digital Library of the Caribbean (dLOC), www.dloc.com